Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

August, 2016:

NZ won’t make smokefree by 2025 target – study

http://www.newshub.co.nz/nznews/nz-wont-make-smokefree-by-2025-target–study-2016080420

A new study shows New Zealand is way off its target to become smokefree by 2025.

The Government has committed to a goal of reducing smoking to 5 percent of the population or less within the next nine years.

But researchers at the University of Otago, in a series of articles published in the New Zealand Medical Journal, say current efforts aren’t enough.

“We want to achieve pretty much nil smoking,” says Prof Richard Edwards.

“Or certainly less than 5 percent, in all groups of the population, and our evidence is that for Māori we’re not going to do that until 2060, rather than 2025.”

For smoker Rachel Beaumont, her story is a familiar one.

“I got addicted at a young age. Plus like both my parents smoke, my whole family smokes,” she says.

“I know it’s not good for me but it’s hard to give up, aye?”

Smoking is the single biggest preventable risk factor for premature death and morbidity in New Zealand – it’s worst among Māori and Pacific people.

Efforts are being made to lower rates – taxes on cigarettes are going up, there are health warnings on packs, and the Government’s looking to bring in plain packaging. Even smoking in public spaces is under threat as councils investigate new bylaws.

But are all these measures working?

While overall rates are slowly declining, now around 15 percent, more than a third of Māori (35.5 percent) and almost a quarter of Pacific people in New Zealand smoke (22.4 percent).

The rates among women are even higher.

“Being brought up like people around us smoked, so I guess we do it too,” says one woman smoker.

She’s trying to cut down because at 27, it’s already affecting her health.

“I’m down from a pack a day to about four cigarettes a day.”

Māori and Pacific people are at a much higher risk of hospitalisation or death from respiratory disease.

Ministry of Health figures show Māori are 3.5 times more likely to be hospitalised for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease than non-Māori, and Māori children are one-and-a-half times more likely to have asthma than non-Māori children.

The Ministry of Health says while smoking rates have halved overall in the past 30 years, it has “priority populations where we need to do better – that includes our Māori and Pacific people, where there’s a high burden of harm caused by tobacco.”

Researchers says more could be done to raise awareness and reduce supply.

“Tobacco is available in every dairy, every supermarket, every gas station,” says Prof Edwards.

“We’re not trying to reduce the supply of tobacco and we’re not doing enough on the mass-media campaigning side.”

But for some, like Ms Beaumont, it will take more than money and health warnings to quit.

“If I got sick, if I got cancer or something, then yep, I’ll give up.”

Protests call for tobacco operating license reversal

‘SELLING POISON’:Allowing a Japanese tobacco plant to operate would encourage domestic smoking and turn Taiwan into an export hub for cigarettes, protesters said

http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2016/08/05/2003652492

The Executive Yuan should revoke the operating license for a massive new Japanese-owned tobacco factory, anti-smoking advocates said yesterday, blasting the government for approving the investment and providing subsidies.

“We do not want Taiwan to become a center for selling poison,” said Taiwan Medical Alliance for the Control of Tobacco founder Wen Chi-pang (溫啟邦), a professor at China Medical University, alongside 20 protesters from the John Tung Foundation and other groups outside the Executive Yuan in Taipei.

The protesters said that the Ministry of Finance should not have issued an operating license to Japan Tobacco International’s new factory in the Tainan Technology Industrial Park.

Japan Tobacco’s NT$9.2 billion (US$290.1 million) investment is reportedly to produce enough cigarettes to cover one-third of local consumption, becoming the nation’s second foreign-owned tobacco factory, following the establishment of an Imperial Tobacco factory in Miaoli County in 2009.

The groups say that the Japan Tobacco factory will encourage domestic smoking, while turning the nation into a base for exporting cigarettes to an export base to Southeast Asia because of favorable government incentives.

“The government says it is bringing in foreign investment, but a lot of the funds are coming out of taxpayers’ pockets,” foundation tobacco control division head Lin Ching-li (林清麗) said, adding that the government should not have granted the factory use of a 7.6-hectare site, as well as utility incentives and property tax exemptions.

Japan Tobacco will be able to use the factory to skirt cigarette tariffs, Lin said.

“Japanese firms plan to turn Taiwan into a huge factory base, but the government was too stupid to foresee this ‘beggar thy neighbor’ behavior,” foundation chief executive officer Yao Shi-yuan (姚思遠) said.

Yao criticized the government for allowing Japanese investment in the tobacco industry using the Arrangement for the Mutual Cooperation on the Liberalization, Promotion and Protection of Investment (投資自由化促進及保護協議) negotiated in 2011.

He said the government could still revoke the company’s license, as long as it provided compensation.

Lin Hsin-ho (林信和), a professor of law at Chinese Culture University, said that allowing the factory to begin operations could oblige the nation to allow similar investment from other nation’s according to the WTO’s most-favored-nation status provisions.

Lin added that the government’s approval breached the spirit of the Statute for Investment by Foreign Nationals (外國人投資條例), which forbids foreign investment in industries that have an adverse effect on public health.

Philip Morris Gets Its Ash Kicked in Uruguay; Where Will It Next Blow Smoke?

http://www.truth-out.org/opinion/item/37106-philip-morris-gets-its-ash-kicked-in-uruguay-where-will-it-next-blow-smoke

Philip Morris International just lost a six-year battle to block Uruguay’s strong cigarette warning labels, which cover 80 percent of the front and back of cigarette packs, including graphic photos of the damages of smoking.

The decision was made by the World Bank’s trade tribunal, the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), the world’s the leading body to settle international investment disputes.

Philip Morris became the first tobacco company to take on a country in an international court, and it took on one of the smallest. The company argued that Uruguay had violated terms of an investment treaty with Switzerland by enforcing anti-smoking laws. The operational headquarters for Philip Morris International is in Lausanne.

Philip Morris, with gross revenues of US $64 billion in 2010, sued Uruguay, with a GDP of US $32 billion that year, under the investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) provisions of international trade deals. The tobacco company claimed Uruguay’s health warnings reduced the value of its investment and trademark rights to sell cigarettes in Uruguay. The ICSID trade tribunal upheld Uruguay’s right to protect its people’s health.

Small Country, Easy Prey

Uruguay, nestled between the southern tip of Brazil and the northern part of Argentina, has a small population — 3.4 million — but a big desire to cut tobacco usage. Its president, Tabaré Vázquez, is an oncologist.

Among other anti-smoking efforts, it bans tobacco advertising and smoking in public places.

Such efforts have paid off. A study published in 2012 in The Lancet praised Uruguay’s “substantial, unprecedented decrease” in adult cigarette smoking. The number of adults who smoke in Uruguay fell from 35 percent in 2005 to 22 percent in 2014.

At one level, Uruguay’s win seems to contradict opponents of trade deals like the proposed Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPP) and Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP). These opponents say the pending trade agreements would give multinational corporations, such as Philip Morris, the ability to directly challenge public health, worker safety and environmental laws through ISDS provisions.

In this case, however, Uruguay was able to resist Philip Morris because of financial help from Michael Bloomberg in faraway New York. Indeed, before international health groups appeared, Uruguay was considering weakening the health warnings to avoid an even longer battle with Philip Morris.

Neither Bloomberg nor Uruguay disclosed the amount of Bloomberg’s financial help. It is safe to say that Uruguay would have not prevailed without this financial and international political support.

A History of Bullying

Philip Morris’ legal bullying of Uruguay is nothing new. It has bullied other countries, states and cities for years. It does this by filing lawsuits that exhaust the resources of governments that enact anti-smoking laws.

Tobacco companies routinely sued US communities in the 1980s and 1990s to deter them from enacting smoke-free laws, despite the companies almost always losing in court. This strategy often succeeded by using the mere threat of litigation to deter localities from adopting similar laws.

Although tobacco companies almost always lost in court, most localities did not go to court for fear of being sued. Few have the money and ability to hire the expensive lawyers — some of whom are paid as much as $1,000 an hour — to stay in a legal battle with tobacco companies. The threat of legal action was powerful to stop localities. More importantly, the threat of incurring expensive legal fees was enough to deter other cities from enacting laws that ban smoking.

Laurent Huber, the executive director for Action on Smoking and Health, the oldest anti-smoking group in the US, hinted at the effectiveness of this strategy in his post-trial comments. Phillip Morris “will no doubt shed some public crocodile tears, but their main goal in launching the suit has been realized, six years and millions of dollars have been spent defending a nondiscriminatory law that was intended purely to protect public health,” Huber said.

Likewise, in the 1990s when Australia and Canada first started thinking about requiring cigarettes to be sold in plain generic packaging, tobacco companies threatened to sue them. Standardized plain packaging, as Simon Chapman notes, removes the emperor’s clothes. The companies claimed that these proposals violated their trademark rights, one of the same claims Philip Morris made against Uruguay.

This was despite their own lawyers privately telling them that international treaties permitted governments to require such packaging. The tactic worked; both countries dropped their efforts for two decades. Canada has resumed its efforts, and Australia implemented plain packaging in 2012.

In response, Philip Morris sued Australia in domestic and international trade courts. After a four-year battle, Australia prevailed. The country still faces an industry-inspired challenge in the World Trade Organization, however.

Uruguay’s and Australia’s victories provide some legal precedent about a country’s sovereign right to implement public health regulations for other countries. Indeed, it is just these kinds of precedents that Philip Morris was trying to block. As then Philip Morris Vice President Hugh Cullman observed in 1985, “a sneeze in one country today causes international pneumonia tomorrow.”

He was right to be worried. UK, Ireland and France recently enacted plain packaging, and New Zealand, Canada, Norway, South Africa, Malaysia, Turkey, India and Chile are moving forward.

US Lagging Behind Other Countries

Uruguay’s and Australia’s wins against Big Tobacco are important reminders of how much the United States is lagging. Despite being required by the 2009 Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Act, we still do not have pictorial health warnings, much less plain packaging, on tobacco products.

The FDA issued a rule requiring pictorial warnings (albeit smaller than Uruguay’s) in 2011. The tobacco industry blocked this rule in court. That was in no small part because the Obama administration grossly underestimated the benefits and overstated the cost of including the pictorial warnings, including the “pleasure” that smokers would lose if they broke their addictions to nicotine or never started.

The FDA still has not issued new graphic health warnings despite the fact that 91 countries have pictorial health warnings on cigarette packages.

The administration is still pushing the TPP and TTIP, both of which will provide new avenues for Big Tobacco and other corporate interests to sue governments over strong public health policies. It also opposed excluding tobacco, also known as a tobacco “carve-out” in the TPP, and was willing to support only mild limits on Big Tobacco’s ability to use ISDS provisions to directly sue governments over their tobacco control policies.

TPP members would still need to “elect to deny” the ability of tobacco companies to sue directly, creating a loophole for them to continue intimidating governments with potential ISDS challenges.

With both the Republican and Democratic presumptive nominees for president opposing the TPP, it is time for the next president to start removing provisions of trade agreements that empower big companies to sue governments over health and environmental protections.

And, in the meantime, the administration should follow Uruguay, Australia and the rest of the world and require 21st-century warning labels on tobacco products.

Disclosure statement: Eric Crosbie receives funding from the National Institute of Health, and Stan Glantz receives funding from the National Institutes of Health and Truth Initiative. He is the president of the University of California Council of Faculty Associations.

Gambia to Embrace Plain Packaging of Tobacco Products

The Minister of Health and Social Welfare, Honourable Omar Sey, has stated that with strong multi-sectoral team and the efforts of the media, The Gambia can effectively implement the promotion of plain packaging of tobacco products.

https://observer.gm/gambia-to-embrace-plain-packaging-of-tobacco-products/

He added that his Ministry is in full support of the plain packaging and therefore counts on the continued support and collaboration from the media and the multisectoral team. He was speaking yesterday during a day-long media briefing on World No Tobacco Day, held at the Ministry in Banjul.

The theme for this year’s celebration advocates for the introduction of “Plain (Standardised) packaging” of tobacco products which was first introduced by Australia in 2012 and recently in the UK and France.

Dr. Omar Sey further said The Gambia will soon join other countries that have already passed laws to implement plain packaging, adding that, it is time to act. As countries seek to embrace the plain packaging of tobacco products, he noted, tobacco companies all over the world are on the fight against the initiative with massive misinformation campaigns.

“Plain packaging of tobacco products restricts or prohibits use of logos, colours, brand images and promotional information. It is part of an integrated approach to tobacco control that helps to reduce attractiveness of tobacco packaging,” he added.

Minister Sey disclosed that The Gambia has recently won two of the five awards for the World No Tobacco Day 2016 throughout the African region.

The Executive Director of RAID, The Gambia, Sambujang Conteh noted that this day is set aside by the World Health Organisation (WHO) to reflect on the past achievements, efforts and bottlenecks and also pave a way forward in protecting the present and future generation from risks associated with tobacco use.

“The Gambia has tremendous achievements in tobacco control but, we have a long way to go as we need a legal framework to pave us the way,” he affirmed.

He added that the stakeholders would soon table a bill before lawmakers for the control of tobacco use in the country. He said tobacco being one of the four risk factors of Non-communicable Diseases (NCSs) kills nearly six million people annually worldwide, noting that The Gambia is not an exception.

Bakary Gassama of the WHO thanked The Gambia Government for the wonderful strive towards the area of tobacco control in the country.

He said health is something that cannot be done by the government alone and thus called for the support of the general public and journalists to continue raising awareness on the dangers of tobacco.

The Programme Manager of NCDs, Omar Badjie, said nowadays there are many youth engaged in smoking cigarette, especially young boys and girls. He, therefore, called on the media to continue sensitising the general public on the dangers of smoking, especially in public places.

by Arfang MS Camara

MMWR- Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report

Disparities in Adult Cigarette Smoking — United States, 2002–2005 and 2010–2013

Proven interventions, including increasing the price of tobacco products, coupled with evidence-based cessation services, comprehensive smoke-free policies, high-impact media campaigns, and promotion of cessation treatment in clinical settings, are effective strategies in reducing the prevalence of tobacco use and tobacco-related disease and death in all racial/ethnic populations. To assess the prevalence of, and changes in, cigarette smoking among persons ages ≥18 years in six racial/ethnic populations and 10 select subgroups in the U.S., CDC analyzed self-reported data collected during 2002–2005 and 2010–2013 from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health and compared differences between the two periods. During 2010–2013, the overall prevalence of cigarette smoking among the racial/ethnic populations and subgroups ranged from 38.9 percent for American Indian/American Nativesto 7.6 percent for Chinese and Asian Indians. Differences might be due, in part, to variations in socioeconomic status, acculturation, targeted advertising, price of tobacco products, and practices related to the acceptability of tobacco use across population groups. These findings highlight the importance of looking at tobacco use estimates by smaller racial/ethnic subgroups and by sex to better understand and address disparities in tobacco use among U.S. adults.

Some racial, ethnic groups continue smoking cigarettes at higher rates

Substantial disparities found among American Indians/Alaska Natives, Korean and Puerto Rican Americans

Despite a significant decline in overall adult cigarette smoking since 1964, disparities in cigarette smoking remain among racial and ethnic population groups, according to a new study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) published in today’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR).

For example, current (past 30-day) cigarette smoking during 2010-2013 was lower among Asians overall (10.9 percent) compared with Whites (24.9 percent). But among Asian sub-groups, the prevalence of current cigarette smoking ranged from 7.6 percent among Chinese and Asian Indians to 20.0 percent among Korean Americans. The American Indian/Alaska Native population had the highest prevalence of cigarette smoking at 38.9 percent. The findings in this study show the importance of identifying higher rates of tobacco use across and within racial/ethnic population groups to better understand and address differences in tobacco use among U.S. adults.

Larger sample size for racial/ethnic subgroups

Estimates of cigarette smoking prevalence are usually presented in aggregate for racial or ethnic populations, such as Asian or Hispanic, because sample sizes are too small to provide estimates among racial/ethnic subgroups within these populations. To get a large enough sample size for this study, researchers aggregated data from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health collected between 2002-2005 and 2010-2013 to assess cigarette-smoking prevalence among 6 racial and ethnic population groups and 10 select subgroups in the United States.

“Even though the overall cigarette-smoking rate is declining, disparities remain among racial and ethnic groups and within subgroups,” said Bridgette Garrett, Ph.D., associate director for health equity in the CDC’s Office on Smoking and Health. “Looking beyond broad racial and ethnic population categories can help better focus the strategies that we know work to reduce tobacco use among sub-groups with higher rates of use.”

Testimony: Tobacco dealer paid $30K to meet Armstrong

Robert Carter, who set up the initial meeting between state Rep. Joe Armstrong and a tobacco wholesaler, testified Wednesday in the legislator’s trial on charges of conspiracy and tax evation in the deal developed after the meeting.

http://knoxblogs.com/humphreyhill/2016/08/03/testimony-tobacco-dealer-paid-30k-meet-armstrong/#content

Carter testified Wednesday that he brokered a meeting between the veteran lawmaker and Knoxville-based tobacco wholesaler Boyd Wyatt that would ultimately lead to a deal that netted Armstrong roughly $321,000 in profit from a 2007 cigarette stamp tax hike Armstrong voted to approve.

Armstrong is standing trial this week in U.S. District Court on charges of conspiring with his accountant, Charles Stivers, to hide that profit from the IRS — and the voting public — as well as charges of tax evasion and filing a false income tax return.

Until this week, Carter’s role had not been revealed. Also kept under wraps until this week’s trial is the fact that Wyatt’s firm, Tru Wholesale, paid Carter $30,000 to set up a meeting with Armstrong.

Carter testified it wasn’t the first time he charged a “fee” for introducing people to Armstrong. The lawmaker, however, was unaware of Carter’s profiteering off his friendship with Armstrong, he said.

“Sure, he would have been mad,” Carter said of the lawmaker’s reaction if he had discovered Carter’s profiteering.

…Carter had been on the board of Tengasco Inc., an oil and natural gas company, for which Armstrong had worked since 1997, served as director in 1998 and was tapped as chairman of the board in 2003, according to an archived news release from the Knoxville-based energy firm. Stivers also had been on the Tengasco board at some point.

It’s how he and Armstrong met and why, according to defense attorney Gregory P. Isaacs, Armstrong trusted Stivers to do his taxes as far back as 1998.

Wyatt and his firm had a problem. As the exclusive wholesaler for a popular discount cigarette brand, Tru Wholesale stood to gain hundreds of thousands of dollars by hoarding tax stamps at the 20-cent rate on the books in early 2007 and then selling them to retailers at the 62-cent rate that went into effect later that year. But the state Department of Revenue, which sells the stamps, had its own problem — wholesalers were beating down the agency’s doors to buy the stamps at the cheaper rate.

So, the agency decided to ration the stamps. That meant Wyatt and his firm couldn’t buy as many as they wanted. Wyatt’s brother publicly complained to the News Sentinel in 2007 about the ration. It didn’t help.

Armstrong, according to Wyatt’s testimony Wednesday, did.

After Carter put Armstrong and Wyatt together, Armstrong arranged a meeting for Tru Wholesale with Department of Revenue officials, Wyatt testified. As a result, the wholesaler was able to buy its full allotment of the stamps and ultimately made $3 million from the tax hike, he said.

Carter dealt a blow Wednesday to Armstrong’s defense, laid out Tuesday by attorney Gregory P. Isaacs, that he believed Stivers paid the taxes Armstrong owed the IRS on his profit but that Stivers instead stole the money and falsely incriminated Armstrong to avoid punishment for his own thievery.

Carter told jurors Armstrong asked to funnel his profit from the tax stamp deal through Carter’s firm, Carter’s Warehouse, in early 2007 — before prosecutors Frank Dale and Charles Atchley Jr. allege Armstrong recruited Stivers to help him hide the money.

“I said no, he could not,” Carter testified. “I wouldn’t do that. If he used my Corp., it would be under my (federal identification number), and I won’t put it in jeopardy.”

Carter’s testimony, if believed by the jury, bolsters the prosecutors’ case Armstrong “willfully” conspired to hide his windfall from the IRS.

Cover: Is tobacco investment going up in smoke?

https://www.fundstrategy.co.uk/cover-tobacco-investment-going-smoke/

Loved by equity income managers and shunned by socially responsible investors, tobacco has long been a divisive sector, albeit one that has managed con-stantly to churn out dividends over the past 20 years. But as the UK government ramps up its campaign to encourage smokers to kick the habit with the introduction of plain packaging, and insurance behemoth Axa remembers its raison d’être and retreats from the sector, are the tables turning for tobacco?

There are currently over a billion smokers in the world, according to the World Health Organisation. The harmful effects of tobacco have been widely reported for decades, with WHO calling it “one of the biggest public health threats the world has ever faced”.

In the developed world, the message is resonating. Since the Office for National Statistics began recording the UK’s smoking habits in 1976, the number of smokers has fallen from 46 per cent of the adult population to 19 per cent in the latest statistics from 2014, although this figure has remained the same since 2013. However, the number of cigarettes smoked per day has fallen to its lowest point in 40 years at 11.4 cigarettes, down from 12.1 in 2013 and 16.8 in 1976. Cancer Research UK asserts the number of smokers is on track to fall to 10 per cent by 2035.

According to British American Tobacco (BAT), the global tobacco industry is valued at around £450-£500bn. But BAT is under no illusion about the declining numbers of smokers in the developed world and has turned its attention to the emerging markets.

“Generally speaking, we think that individual smokers will consume fewer cigarettes each and smaller percentages of populations will smoke,” the firm says in its outlook. “While cigarette sales in developed countries continue to decline year on year, sustained volume growth is widely predicted in emerging markets, driven by population growth and increasing disposable income. As a result, the overall value of the tobacco market continues to increase.”

The UK introduced plain packaging for tobacco products on 20 May this year, following in the footsteps of Australia, which adopted plain packaging in 2012. Colours and logos have been replaced with standardised product names and are adorned with graphic photos showing the dangers of smoking.

“You have to look at sales and packaging rules in the UK to ask ‘how long can this go on for?’”

Not surprisingly, BAT has opposed plain packaging, claiming it is unlawful on the grounds the government is “taking property from businesses without paying for it”. This reaction is not unprecedented; Philip Morris Inter-national (PMI) sued the Australian government over plain packaging, claiming it was in violation of a bilateral trade agreement with Hong Kong. Australia won the legal battle.

Jamie Clark, fund manager in the macro-thematic team at Liontrust, says the new packaging laws will compound the secular decline of smoking and hinder pricing hikes.

He says: “There is now a social stigma to the habit. While the bull case for tobacco is that the contraction in volumes will be offset by the increase in price, if tobacco companies can’t advertise or brand their packaging, it will be difficult for them to increase their pricing.”

Clark says the team has not owned tobacco stocks in their portfolios since 2012 on the grounds that “the investment credentials of tobacco [are] gradually eroding”. He points to research released by Citigroup in 2010 that suggested smoking will die out by 2050. Although he forecasts the decline to be “much stickier than that”, he is bearish on the prospects for tobacco.

“There is also a social stigma in the developing world. China is the key engine of growth for tobacco, but it is introducing a ban on smoking in public places. They are introducing social education programmes and pre-school children in China are taught to tell adults to stop smoking. We are seeing a sea change in the perception of the habit.”

James Horniman, portfolio manager at James Hambro & Partners, does not currently invest in tobacco, saying: “There are cleaner ways of making money for clients than investing in tobacco. It leaves a bad taste in the mouth.”

He adds: “So far the industry has survived in the face of the legal battles against it, but you just have to look at the sales and packaging rules in the UK to ask ‘how long can this go on for?’”

Elsewhere, fund managers are rather more blasé on the impact of plain packaging, with some even suggesting it will make monopolies of the major brands.

Martin Cholwell, equity income manager at Royal London Asset Management, says: “For established players such as Imperial, plain packaging could be a great advantage as it will be virtually impossible for new entrants to come to market. Their relationship with retailers will be even more important.”

WEB_0716_CoverStory_Table

Miton’s David Jane, who has around 10 per cent of the Miton Cautious Monthly Income fund invested in tobacco, points out that the addictive nature of tobacco holds more sway than pictures on a box and says the investment credentials of tobacco remain intact – for now.

“The grotesque packaging may deter new smokers, but the number of existing smokers is shrinking only relatively slowly,” he says. “Yes, it’s a dying product over time, but that doesn’t make it a poor investment.”

According to a review by the Australian Government, plain packaging in combination with graphic health warnings contributed to the decline in smoking by around 0.55 percentage points between December 2012 and September 2015, equivalent to one quarter of the total drop. However, the introduction of plain packaging in Australia has been dismissed as ineffective in some quarters.

Michael Clark, fund manager at Fidelity, says the Australian figures suggest the UK’s law will have little effect.

“We don’t think plain packaging will have a major impact, looking at the experiences in other markets, such as Australia,” he says. “Tobacco is a declining business in all the developed markets. The falls in Australia continued -after the introduction of packaging a couple of years ago.

It hasn’t changed the way the market works in a big way.”

While the Government is seen to be taking an active role in attempting to curb smoking in the UK, should such responsibilities extend to financial services?

In May this year, insurance giant Axa announced it would cease to invest in tobacco in its €552bn general account and would be divesting its holdings – to the tune of €1.8bn – from the industry. The group swiftly began selling its equity holdings in tobacco companies, valued at €0.2bn, and said it would run off its existing tobacco bond holdings, worth just under €1.6bn. The group’s third-party funds are not affected.

The announcement is the latest in a series of socially responsible measures taken by the firm, following its move away from coal mining investments in 2015 and its pledge to triple the green investments in its general account to more than €3bn by 2020.

In a statement issued in May, Axa’s deputy chief executive, Thomas Buberl, said of the tobacco divestment: “This decision has a cost for us, but the case for divestment is clear: the human cost of tobacco is tragic; its economic cost is huge. It makes no sense for us to continue our investments within the tobacco industry.”

The move was applauded by the UK arm of Tobacco Free Portfolios, funded by CRUK. Not-for-profit organisation Tobacco Free Portfolios was launched in Australia by radiation oncologist Bronwyn King in 2010 with the aim of reducing and eventually eliminating tobacco from investment portfolios worldwide through collaborative work with the industry.

WEB_0716_CoverStory_Table2

However Axa’s announcement has been met with mixed feeling in the investment community. David Jane dubbed the move “a marketing decision”, saying “it looks good for an insurance company to put their money where their mouth is”.

Jane doesn’t see tobacco investment as unethical, and suggests that if investors want to “do good” they should reinvest profits they are uncomfortable with in good causes.

He says: “It is up to people if they want to smoke or not. The tobacco companies are definitely not misleading anyone. I don’t see it as unethical.”

Jane argues that managers have a fiduciary duty to invest in tobacco if it constitutes a sound investment.

“If managers are not investing in tobacco, they need to give a rational investment reason. If it is for socially responsible reasons, they need to apply them to every investment they make. As it stands I think tobacco is a good investment. There are plenty of products out there that pose a risk of harm, so where do you draw the line? Even if you are running a socially responsible mandate, you would still struggle to know where the line is.”

Colin McLean, a fund manager at SVM, suggests that far from tobacco divestment gaining traction, we could see a reversal of the trend. He points to the Norwegian sovereign wealth fund, the largest in the world, which removed 17 tobacco companies from its portfolio on ethical grounds in 2010. The move meant the sovereign wealth fund missed out on $1.9bn in profits, the FT reported earlier this year, and McLean says the sovereign wealth fund is now debating whether it should reinvest in tobacco.

“The outperformance of tobacco is causing angst. It wouldn’t be impossible for people to re-enter; it is not a one-way street.”

However, Horniman says he can see other groups following Axa’s stance. “Axa is making a stand,” he says. “Tobacco divestment will be a very common thing.”

He adds: “I just don’t see the need to invest in tobacco. Companies such as Reckitt Benckiser, Unilever and Kerry Group are consumer staples with a good growth profile.”

While the combustibles market continues to decline in the developed world, a potential area of growth is “next generation products”, such as electronic cigarettes and heat-not-burn devices.

According to Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), an estimated 2.8 million adults in Great Britain currently use electronic cigarettes, accounting for 6 per cent of the population, up from 700,000 in 2012. While still significantly smaller than the combustibles market, are such products the future for tobacco companies?

BAT says that although next generation products are gaining traction, combustibles will be “the mainstay of the industry’s profits for some years to come”.

“Yes, it’s a dying product over time, but that doesn’t make it a poor investment.”

Horniman labels the current interest in e-cigarettes “a fad”. He says: “I think tobacco companies will branch out, but whether they will be highly successful, I am not sure.”

Fidelity’s Clark says that while there appear to be health benefits associated with switching from tobacco to electronic cigarettes, it is too early to tell whether that will translate to a profitable business model.

“Vaping has come from nowhere in 2012 to a big market now,” he says. “It will grow as there are definitely health benefits. The Royal College of Physicians has said it is much better for you than smoking – not great, but better. Vaping is growing rapidly and heat-not-burn technology is being developed by PMI and BAT. There is some doubt about it as it contains tobacco, so it hasn’t had a public health endorsement. But things may well change there. The question is, does the new low-harm technology change the tobacco profit model? It is too early to give an answer.”

Jane points out that it will be the large tobacco companies that benefit from the new-generation products in the long run because they have all the power when it comes to distribution.

“The tobacco companies have got the financial wherewithal and the distribution. It’s a distribution game, not a manufacturing game. The people in the vaping market think they are new age, but they will buy the profit of a big company as a big company will squish the new company.”

The question is, does the investment case for holding tobacco still stand? And will the tobacco companies be able to maintain their growing dividends that have made them so popular with income seekers?

Looking purely at the performance of the tobacco stocks, the MSCI Tobacco index has beaten the MSCI World index every year based on annual performance since 2002, except for 2012. In 2015, the MSCI Tobacco index returned 18.6 per cent against the 0.87 per cent decline in the MSCI World index.

Furthermore, data from AJ Bell shows BAT’s dividend yield is expected to rise from 3.5 per cent to 3.7 per cent in 2017, while Imperial’s dividend yield is projected to rise from 3.9 per cent to 4.3 per cent in 2017. The estimated dividend cover for both BAT and Imperial Tobacco is 1.45 times in 2016. Indeed, Imperial has forecast a 10 per cent growth in its dividend policy over the medium term and recently reiterated this target at its investor day, says Martin Cholwell, who holds 3.9 per cent in British American Tobacco and 2 per cent in Imperial. He adds that tobacco remains a cash-generative industry.

WEB_0716_CoverStory_POB

“The industry has a good pricing discipline. Although volumes are in decline, revenue lines are gently increasing; the real prices of cigarettes are up pre-duty. Providing the companies continue with steady dividend growth, they are a great source of dividends.”

Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell, points out that Imperial and BAT are two of the 25 companies in the FTSE that have grown their dividends in the past 10 years.

“I expect they will continue to grow their dividends for some time,” he says. “They have cut costs, are digesting their acquisitions and are seeing growth in emerging markets. I generally like dividend cover to be north of two times, although that is more for cyclical companies. I’m happy with dividend cover of 1.4 times for tobacco companies.”

However, Nick Clay, who has a 13 per cent weighting in tobacco in the Newton Global Income fund, warns tobacco stocks are now looking expensive.

He says: “Where it starts to go wrong is on valuations. When we were buying tobacco stocks, they were cheap, with free cashflow yields of 7.5 per cent; now they are 4.5 per cent. They are certainly getting expensive. We are not adding new money to the sector but we are diversifying away from the US, from companies such as Reynolds and Altria and into BAT and PMI, purely because of valuations.”

While managers may be at odds over the ethical implications of investing in tobacco, it is clear tobacco com-panies have the characteristics income managers are looking for in today’s low-growth environment. And while they may well have a limited life, David Jane is taking a pragmatic view. “Will the tobacco companies be massive in 20 to 30 years? Probably not,” he says. “But they will still be selling cigarettes in 10 years’ time. While the highly-developed economies are pressing down on tobacco companies, the rest of the world likes them because of the tax revenue.

“If you think tobacco won’t exist in six years’ time, it is not a good investment. If you think it will be around for 10 years-plus, it is going to be fine. There is an existing cohort of smokers – plenty of 20-year-olds smoke. No government will ban smoking as they need the revenue stream in these times of fiscal austerity.”

Cover: Is tobacco investment going up in smoke?

Download (PDF, 1.83MB)

Police bust gang which made illegal tobacco-making machines

http://www.shanghaidaily.com/metro/society/Police-bust-gang-which-made-illegal-tobaccomaking-machines/shdaily.shtml

SHANGHAI police have busted a seven-member gang which produced and sold illegal tobacco machines nationwide, Shanghai Television reported yesterday.

In China, tobacco production and sales are strictly under state control.

In May, local police were tipped off about a suspect surnamed Zhai in Jiading District.

Over the next two months, police discovered that Zhai and other gang members had an assembly of tobacco-making machines and sold them to other provinces like Fujian, Liaoning and Guangdong.

Police eventually busted the gang on July 12 in Shanghai and Fujian Province and seized 19 tobacco machines.

According to police, the gang had been running the business since October 2014. They bought the machine parts from other places and hired people to assemble them in Jiading. These machines were sold at prices ranging between 250,000 yuan to 400,000 yuan.

A machine of this kind can produce 2,000 cigarettes a minute. In a year, it can produce cigarettes with a value of 10 million yuan.