Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

August, 2016:

Missouri has the lowest cigarette tax in the country. Why does a tobacco company want to raise it?

http://www.pitch.com/news/feature-story/article/20831514/missouri-has-the-lowest-cigarette-tax-in-the-country-why-does-a-tobacco-company-want-to-raise-it

Stanton Glantz, director of the Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education at the University of California–San Francisco, is a veteran anti-smoking researcher and activist.

In 1994, the Brown & Williamson tobacco company sued the California Board of Regents in an effort to keep Glantz from making public the sensitive company documents he had received from a whistleblower. The university prevailed, and Glantz and his colleagues wrote an influential Journal of the American Medical Association paper based on the documents, which showed that the tobacco industry knew nicotine was addictive and that smoking caused cancer.

Yet even he marvels at the ballot initiative that Missouri voters will consider this fall to raise the tax on major cigarette brands by 60 cents a pack.

The most unusual aspect of the proposal is that it’s being financed largely by a cigarette manufacturer. RAI Services Company has given more than $2.6 million to Raise Your Hand for Kids, the campaign committee leading the push for the new tax. “RAI” stands for Reynolds American Inc., the parent of the R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., maker of Newport, Camel and Pall Mall.

“I’ve never seen an instance where a cigarette company went to the ballot with a tax before,” Glantz tells The Pitch.

The tactic caught people off-guard. In February, The St. Louis Post-Dispatch’s editorial board described the tobacco tax initiative as a “sound proposal” and made no mention of R.J. Reynolds’ involvement. Two months later, the paper rescinded its endorsement. But in a sign of how strange this story is, the paper made its about-face for reasons other than the cigarette company’s influence.
________________________________________
Tobacco exemplifies the occasionally baroque nature of Missouri politics. The state’s current tax on cigarettes — 17 cents a pack — is the lowest in the country, even though Missouri is not a major tobacco-growing state.

Jefferson City is famous for its hospitality to the tobacco industry. When lawmakers passed a 4-cents-a-pack increase in 1993, the last time they touched the tax, they restricted local governments from enacting their own taxes on cigarettes. In 1995, the state Senate designated a lobbyist for the Tobacco Institute an official smoking area wherever he roamed within the Capitol. That it may have been a joke seems beside the point.

From 2000 to 2009, 46 states and the District of Columbia increased cigarette taxes, raising the average state cigarette tax by 92 cents a pack, according to the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, a nonprofit group. Many of these tax hikes were passed via ballot initiative. But voters in Missouri rejected new taxes on cigarettes in 2002, 2006 and 2012.

The tobacco industry fought the 2006 ballot initiative, which would have raised the tax by 80 cents a pack. The major manufacturers stayed out of the 2012 campaign because the proposed initiative addressed a facet of the settlement agreement that companies had reached with 46 states in 1998.

Some background: In return for billions of dollars, the states agreed to drop the lawsuits they had filed against the major manufacturers to recover the costs of providing medical care to people suffering from smoking-related illnesses. Missouri receives about $130 million each year under the agreement.

States required cigarette manufacturers that were not part of the settlement to make escrow payments as security for possible future lawsuits against them. These “non-participating manufacturers,” as they’re known, sell mostly discount brands (Echo, Decade, etc.). In addition to setting aside funds for future judgments, the escrow laws protect the big manufacturers from being steeply undercut on price by companies not subject to the settlement agreement.

A loophole in the law allows small manufacturers to claim refunds from the escrow accounts by concentrating their sales in a few states. Most states fixed the loophole.

Missouri — alone among the 46 states party to the settlement agreement — never has.

When he was attorney general, Gov. Jay Nixon pleaded with the Legislature to close Missouri’s loophole. His successor, Chris Koster, has continued to make the appeal. In a letter to lawmakers earlier this year, Koster said the state refunds $80 million each year to the small manufacturers.

The 2012 ballot initiative proposed raising the tax on cigarettes by 73 cents a pack. It also contained language addressing the small-manufacturer loophole. Alas, the measure failed by fewer than 41,000 votes.

R.J. Reynolds was one of the big four (now big two) tobacco companies that settled with the states in 1998. So it’s not a coincidence that the constitutional amendment it’s now bankrolling speaks to that agreement. Among other things, the amendment promoted by Raise Your Hand for Kids imposes an “equity assessment fee” of 67 cents on each pack of cigarettes sold by non-participating manufacturers.
________________________________________
Raise Your Hand for Kids incorporated in late 2014. U.S. Engineering Co., one of the oldest and largest private companies in Kansas City, was an early contributor to the campaign. Tyler Nottberg, the chairman of U.S. Engineering, is a founder of the Alliance for Childhood Education, a group that promotes workforce readiness in Kansas and Missouri.

Most of the money raised by the tax — estimated at about $300 million annually — will go into a fund for early childhood health and education programs. Stressing the Raise Your Hand for Kids campaign’s honest origins, Nottberg says he and others were working to muster support for the initiative for more than a year before the “partnership” with Reynolds American. “The overall concept of a tobacco tax was self-funded by private citizens,” he tells The Pitch.

Not everyone was on board. The executive director of the Missouri Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association, which opposed past efforts to raise the cigarette tax, called the proposed amendment “outrageous and unfair.”

Recognizing that increasing the cigarette tax for the first time in more than 20 years may not look outrageous to many Missourians, the convenience-store owners and discount-cigarette makers later came forward with a competing proposal to raise the tax by 23 cents. That money would be spent on state transportation projects.

The 23-cent tax hike was cast as a cynical effort to, as the Post-Dispatch put it in an editorial, “head off a more serious proposal at the pass.” A fuller picture of the more serious proposal emerged later, when Raise Your Hand for Kids began to smell of cigarette smoke. RAI Services Co. gave $1 million to the campaign in late 2015 and has continued to give in the months running up to the election.

The dynamic changed when R.J. Reynolds’ involvement came to light. In March, health groups in Missouri that had supported previous proposals to raise the cigarette tax spoke out against both the R.J. Reynolds–backed amendment and the proposition that convenience stores were working to put on the ballot. The American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, the Health Care Foundation of Greater Kansas City and other groups issued a statement calling the proposals “alarming and deceitful.”

In the same statement, the health groups suggested that both tax proposals had been designed to minimize their impact on tobacco sales. Each proposal raises the tax gradually, lessening the financial shock known to be effective in convincing smokers to try to quit. The American Cancer Society Action Network recommends increasing cigarette taxes by a minimum of $1 per pack to make smokers feel the jolt.

The Raise Your Hand for Kids initiative would raise the tax on discount brands by $1.27. Defending the 60-cent tax on major brands, campaign officials say past ballot initiatives suggest that Missouri voters are cautious about raising the cigarette tax. “The past three attempts that have been made to raise it have in aggregate raised the tobacco tax exactly zero dollars and zero cents,” Nottberg says.
________________________________________
The size and speed of the tax increases are not the only objections to the Raise Your Hand for Kids initiative. The amendment contains several sentences restricting the money from being spent on abortion services, though public funding for abortions is already prohibited in Missouri. The amendment also states that the money can’t be used for embryonic stem-cell research.

The insertion of the stem-cell language dismayed groups promoting scientific research in Missouri. “We were shocked,” says Dena Ladd, the executive director of the Missouri Cures Education Foundation, which worked to pass the 2006 amendment to the state constitution that protects any stem-cell research and therapy in Missouri that is legal under federal law.

Missouri Cures and other scientific groups worry that the proposed amendment could chip away at the protections they’ve secured. Ladd tells The Pitch that her group met with the organizers of Raise Your Hand for Kids and asked them to remove the language about stem cells. They refused.

In March, Missouri Cures announced its opposition the Raise Your Hand for Kids initiative, calling it “North Carolina–based Big Tobacco’s proposed amendment to change Missouri’s Constitution.” Missouri Cures faulted the campaign for allowing “anti-research activists,” which is to say anti-abortion rights groups, to insert the language about stem cells.

The language about abortion and stem cells is what led the Post-Dispatch editorial board to rescind its support of the amendment. Raise Your Hand Kids campaign officials say the language was added to make it clear that that the tax revenue would be spent on children. (The amendment states that between 5 and 10 percent of the money will be spent on smoking cessation and prevention programs.) “It’s not a research initiative,” says James Harris, a campaign spokesman. “It is to help kids birth to [age] 5.”

It was not the first time abortion had become intertwined with tobacco. Missouri Right to Life provided late opposition to the cigarette-tax ballot initiatives in 2002 and 2006, claiming that the money could be used to pay abortion providers. The group has declared its neutrality on the Raise Your Hand for Kids initiative.

Both the 60-cent and the 23-cent tax initiatives will appear on November’s ballot, putting in competition groups whose interests are normally aligned. Glantz, the University of California–San Francisco researcher, says he cannot recall an instance when a tobacco company has squared off against convenience-store and gas-station owners. “The fact that you now have open warfare between these two groups is interesting,” he says.

Both ballot initiatives suggest a realization that Missouri’s cigarette tax was not going to stay at 17 cents much longer. The question that cigarette makers and convenience stores seemed to have asked themselves is: How do we manage the increase? Glantz notes that R.J. Reynolds’ e-cigarette unit supported a tax on the product now in place in North Carolina, the company’s home state. That tax, it should be noted, is small.

“Tobacco companies always play the long game,” Glantz says. “They’re very unusual for American corporations. The standard complaint about big American corporations is they’re always obsessed with this quarter’s bottom line and they don’t really think about the future. The tobacco companies are quite different. They’re very strategic.

They are willing to accept minor compromises and setbacks in the short run in order to protect their long-run interests.”

Iraqi mission staff fined over cigarette smuggling

http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/society/up-in-smoke_copy-of-iraqi-mission-staff-fined-over-cigarette-smuggling/42392164

Two officials working at the Iraqi diplomatic mission in Geneva have received stiff fines for a huge cigarette smuggling scam. Some 600,000 packets of cigarettes were sold on the black market in northwest France.

The two Iraqi permanent mission staff members were fined CHF170,000 ($177,000) and CHF120,000 for the cigarette smuggling ring, which owed CHF2.4 million in unpaid tax.

The Federal Customs Administration on Monday confirmed a SonntagsZeitung report which stated that they had abused privileges normally reserved for diplomats and illegally resold duty-free cigarettes in France over a three-year period.

As smuggling has a seven-year statute of limitations, almost a third of the volume could not be sanctioned. The federal authorities also rejected a request from the Iraqi mission to reduce the fine of one of the employees, who has since been fired.

According to the customs office, the smugglers ordered the cigarettes from a firm in northern Germany which specialises in duty-free deliveries for diplomats, embassies and international organisations. They were then sent to a delivery firm in French-speaking Switzerland.

The goods were subsequently transported to a rented warehouse in Ferney-Voltaire in France, not far from Geneva Airport. From there the cigarettes were sent to the city of Rennes in northwest France, where they were resold on the streets.

The smugglers ordered cigarettes not only on behalf of the Iraqi mission, but also on behalf of the permanent missions of Hong Kong, Bahrein, Saudi Arabia and Oman.

Swiss police were tipped off when the Hong Kong Chamber of Commerce complained to the Swiss authorities that unknown individuals had ordered cigarettes on their behalf.

Protecting plain tobacco packaging against industry influence

Summary: Canada’s public consultation on plain packaging for tobacco requires strict guidelines to protect against interference by the tobacco industry, and media must also be wary, according to a new report.

Canada’s public consultation on plain packaging for tobacco requires strict guidelines to protect against interference by the tobacco industry, and media must also be wary, according to a commentary in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal).

The Canadian government’s public consultation on plain packaging of tobacco products, as a public health measure, will close Aug. 31, 2016. In the past, the tobacco industry has tried to thwart plain packaging initiatives using threats of legal action and by influencing public opinion through biased research — for example, in Australia in 2011, when its government introduced this type of packaging. Troubling tactics are now being deployed in Canada, with individuals and organizations linked to the tobacco industry speaking against plain packaging in the media.

Plain packaging requires the removal of all branding (colours, imagery, corporate logos and trademarks) on tobacco products, so that all packaging is standardized.

Manufacturers may only include the brand name in a mandated size, font and location on the package. According to the Australian government, which was the first to implement plain packaging, this move has contributed to a decrease in smoking.

The authors of the commentary call for vigilance by several sectors.

“The Canadian media should remember their important role in challenging industry-affiliated sources regarding their conflicts of interest, and should guard against simply becoming vehicles for industry misinformation,” write Drs. Julia Smith and Kelley Lee, Faculty of Health Sciences, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British Columbia.

“The [Canadian] government must require any individual or organization making a submission to the federal consultation to declare potential conflicts of interests, including funding sources, and must require that any claims made in submissions be substantiated by peer-reviewed evidence, with transparent methodologies, non-industry-linked data sources and clear funding declarations.”

Protecting plain tobacco packaging against industry influence

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/08/160822140526.htm

Source:
Canadian Medical Association Journal

Summary:

Canada’s public consultation on plain packaging for tobacco requires strict guidelines to protect against interference by the tobacco industry, and media must also be wary, according to a new report.

Canada’s public consultation on plain packaging for tobacco requires strict guidelines to protect against interference by the tobacco industry, and media must also be wary, according to a commentary in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal).

The Canadian government’s public consultation on plain packaging of tobacco products, as a public health measure, will close Aug. 31, 2016. In the past, the tobacco industry has tried to thwart plain packaging initiatives using threats of legal action and by influencing public opinion through biased research — for example, in Australia in 2011, when its government introduced this type of packaging. Troubling tactics are now being deployed in Canada, with individuals and organizations linked to the tobacco industry speaking against plain packaging in the media.

Plain packaging requires the removal of all branding (colours, imagery, corporate logos and trademarks) on tobacco products, so that all packaging is standardized.

Manufacturers may only include the brand name in a mandated size, font and location on the package. According to the Australian government, which was the first to implement plain packaging, this move has contributed to a decrease in smoking.

The authors of the commentary call for vigilance by several sectors.

“The Canadian media should remember their important role in challenging industry-affiliated sources regarding their conflicts of interest, and should guard against simply becoming vehicles for industry misinformation,” write Drs. Julia Smith and Kelley Lee, Faculty of Health Sciences, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British Columbia.

“The [Canadian] government must require any individual or organization making a submission to the federal consultation to declare potential conflicts of interests, including funding sources, and must require that any claims made in submissions be substantiated by peer-reviewed evidence, with transparent methodologies, non-industry-linked data sources and clear funding declarations.”

Ombudsman Raises Concern Over Plan to Increase Tobacco Excise

http://en.tempo.co/read/news/2016/08/22/056797790/Ombudsman-Raises-Concern-Over-Plan-to-Increase-Tobacco-Excise

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – The Indonesia Ombudsman delivered several notions related to the planned tobacco excise increase. The increase is predicted to boost cigarette prices to Rp 50,000. Some of the notions include the Ombudsman’s concern that higher excise rate would not be effective to suppress cigarette consumption.

Although the total amount of tobacco excise in 2015 had reached Rp 139.5 trillion, the Ombudsman was not certain that it goes in line with cigarette consumption rate. “If demands are elastic, it is predicted that excise will reduce revenue, but at the same time suppress cigarette consumption rate,” according to Ombudsman Commissioner Alamsyah Saragih in a press release on Sunday, August 21, 2016.

However, if tobacco excise is to be increased and state revenue increases, Alamsyah said that it means cigarette consumption is not declining. “And household financial pressure will increase,” Alamsyah said.

The Ombudsman also questioned the production sharing fund for tobacco producer region, which is considered to be ineffective. According to Alamsyah, the Tobacco Farmers Association argued that there are regions who still use the fund to purchase operational vehicles.

In addition to the lack of direct benefits, the Ombudsman argued that the percentage of production sharing for tobacco producer region, which is currently set at two percent, is too small. Alamsyah added that the government had only planned to issue a supervision guideline for tobacco production sharing fund in 2016. “As a result to bad management, local tobacco prices are sold cheaper compared to imported tobacco,” Alamsyah said.

The Ombudsman also highlighted the government’s strategy in spending revenues gained from tobacco excise. Alamsyah said that if the government is planning to shift from producing tobacco to other commodities, trillions of funds originated from tobacco excise should be used for research and development activities to discover new high productivity commodity.

The arguments against making cigarettes Rp 50k are ridiculous, but the gov’t will probably listen to them anyways

http://jakarta.coconuts.co/2016/08/22/arguments-against-making-cigarettes-rp-50k-are-ridiculous-govt-will-probably-listen-them

If you follow the Indonesian media whatsoever, you’ll know that they are totally freaking out right now about the possibility that the government could raise the taxes on cigarettes to make them cost Rp 50,000 per pack (even as netizens are making memes claiming they will are not panicking about it).

The notion that the price of cigarettes in Indonesia will more than double didn’t start with the government actually saying they would do so, or that it was even a possibility. Rather, it began with a survey of 1,000 Indonesian smokers, conducted by Universitas Indonesia’s Public Health Faculty. Among the more incredible results of the survey were that 72% said they’d quit smoking if a pack of cigarettes costs Rp 50,000 or more and that 76% agree that a tobacco tax hike and overall increase in the price of cigarettes would be a good thing.

However, there are still no actual signs the government is doing anything other than considering it as an idea that has been “communicated,” as Customs and Excise Director General Heru Prambudi put it. A few government officials have also expressed some tentative support for a tax hike, but there is certainly no concrete evidence that the government is studying it as a real possibility.

That has not stopped some pro-tobacco industry advocates from denouncing the unlikely Rp 50k cigarette scenario, with the Chairman of the Indonesian Cigarette Manufacturers Association (GAPPRI) Ismanu Soemiran even going so far as to call the rumor a deliberate hoax “made to cause commotion and economic chaos”.

While Ismanu thinks the idea would cause chaos, advocates of the tax hike say it would bring plenty of huge benefits to the country. Besides the most obvious one of getting a large percentage of smokers to quit the incredibly addictive and health hazardous habit (which is estimated to kill 217,400 Indonesians per year), the Indonesian Consumers Foundation (YLKI) notes that the steep price increase would put cigarettes out of the reach of Indonesia’s poorest, not to mention young children.

However, opponents to the idea have already issued several dire warning about the disastrous effects such a cigarette tax hike would have on Indonesia, most of them having to do with the economy. These are their arguments (and why they’re ridiculous):

It will cause a decrease in tax money overall

Opponents of the tax hike argue Indonesia is highly dependent on the huge amount of taxes they collect from cigarettes currently – in 2015, the government collected about Rp 144.6 trillion in excise taxes, of which tobacco taxation made up about 96 percent. They say that even with the increase in the tax, the resulting drop in demand will lead to a huge overall drop in tax revenue, at a time when the government desperately needs money to cover budgetary shortfalls.

If they were talking about almost any other product they might be right, but because of its addictive properties, the demand for tobacco would likely not drop proportionately with the increase in price. And because it would be such a large increase in the tax rate specifically, even if demand was decreased by about ⅔ as suggested by the survey results, tax revenue would remain about the same.

Also, consider for a moment how much money the government currently spends on healthcare for tobacco related illnesses. One study estimated that amount to be around Rp 2.9 trillion per year just for smokers, without calculating the costs of healthcare for people affected by secondhand smoke. There’s also the enormous loss in national productivity caused by smoking related diseases. It may be a longer term investment, but reducing smoking rates always ends up saving countries more money eventually.

Lastly, if you agree with the logic that the government should allow people easy access to an extremely dangerous and addictive substance because it helps them make money, congratulations, you’ve just justified the legalization and taxation of all sorts of drugs.

It will hurt poor tobacco farmersThis is the argument used not just against the the Rp 50k price but also any tobacco control measure proposed in Indonesia. It’s easily the tobacco industry’s most effective argument since it frames the issue as one of employment – a recent Tempo article mentions that 30-35 million people are employed by the tobacco industry in Indonesia (although that number comes from the National Commission to Save Kretek (KNPK) so it might not be totally accurate).

As YLKI head Tulus Abadi argued, increasing tobacco regulations have not led to corresponding layoffs in other countries. Also, if Indonesia is ever going to get serious about fighting cigarette addiction, it is going to have to start transitioning tobacco farmers into cultivating other types of crops.

In truth it may not be easy for some of those poor tobacco farmers. But let’s not forget, that many of the richest people in Indonesia are tobacco tycoons. Perhaps they can use parts of their enormous fortunes to help the farmers they rely on to find new trades.

It will increase the number of illegal cigarettes

This is probably true, but that’s a matter that government law enforcement should have to deal with, just as they deal with the spread of illegally produced alcohol. And unlike illegal alcohol, which is often toxic and lethal, illegal cigarettes probably wouldn’t contain the harmful additives that are used by large manufacturers to make their products more addictive.

At any rate, the chance of seeing such a steep excise tax increase is probably next to nil (we hope to be pleasantly surprised). However, the government is currently studying how much the next increase in cigarette taxes will be, and we hope that all of the talk currently taking place in the media makes them consider at least pushing it at least a bit farther than they would have previously.

FDA Says Nicotine-Free E-Liquids Are Tobacco Products in ‘Certain Circumstances’

Manufacturers will have to guess which circumstances those are, because the FDA won’t say.

http://reason.com/blog/2016/08/19/fda-will-regulate-nicotine-free-e-liquid

Smoke NVThis week, responding to one of the lawsuits challenging its e-cigarette regulations, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) further muddied the question of whether those regulations apply to products that do not contain tobacco-derived nicotine. The lawsuit, which was brought by Nicopure, a manufacturer of e-liquids and vaping systems, argues that such a result would be unfair, illogical, and illegal. In response, the FDA says Nicopure has failed to show that any of its nicotine-free liquids are actually covered by the regulations and therefore has no standing to challenge that aspect of the rules. At the same time, the FDA concedes that “e-liquids marketed as ‘nicotine-free’ may properly be considered tobacco products—or components or parts thereof—under certain circumstances.”

What circumstances are those? “Some e-liquids ‘claiming to be nicotine-free actually contain[] high levels of nicotine,” the FDA says, quoting its regulations. “Others are tobacco flavored, and are thus ‘made or derived from tobacco’ regardless of their nicotine content.”

Does that mean e-liquids are not subject to the FDA’s burdensome, prohibitively expensive regulations as long as they do not contain nicotine or any other tobacco derivative? No, because the FDA’s definition of “tobacco product” does not require nicotine or any other tobacco derivative.

The Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, the statute that gave the FDA authority over tobacco products, defines them as products “made or derived from tobacco that [are] intended for human consumption, including any component, part, or accessory of a tobacco product.” In deeming e-cigarettes to be tobacco products, the FDA defined “component or part” as “any software or assembly of materials intended or reasonably expected…to alter or affect the tobacco product’s performance, composition, constituents, or characteristics” or “to be used with or for the human consumption of a tobacco product.” Hence vaping equipment, whether a closed, disposable e-cigarette or an open system with a refillable tank and parts that can be switched out, is a “component or part” of a tobacco product, which means it is also a tobacco product.

Does that mean a nicotine-free e-liquid is a “component or part” of a tobacco product—i.e., the vaporizer? The FDA can’t or won’t give a straight answer to that question.

“The only nicotine-free e-liquids that the rule brings under the FDA’s regulatory authority are those that are made or derived from tobacco (such as tobacco-flavored varieties) or that otherwise meet the definition of a ‘component’ or ‘part,'” it says. “Thus, nicotine-free e-liquids not made or derived from tobacco are subject to the deeming rule only where they meet the definition of a ‘component or part.’…Whether nicotine-free e-liquids meet this definition ‘will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.'”

That means a company like Nicopure cannot know ahead of time which of its products are covered by the regulations. It can only find out by asking the FDA about each one, a process that will carry its own costs, even if they do not rise to the hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars that each “premarket tobacco product application” is expected to cost. The FDA’s position is that Nicopure can’t challenge the potential regulation of its nicotine-free e-liquids because it does not know whether they will actually be regulated. Never mind that it doesn’t know because the FDA won’t say.

Dirty secrets of your KiwiSaver

Find out how much your KiwiSaver has invested in cluster bombs, landmines and tobacco.

http://insights.nzherald.co.nz/article/kiwisaver-investments

The country’s largest KiwiSaver provider today announced it was reviewing client investment policies as the Herald revealed New Zealanders had unwittingly invested $152m in controversial arms manufacturers and big tobacco companies.

The launch of the Herald series looking at the Dirty Secrets of KiwiSaver also saw the Minister of Commerce concede in Parliament there were “some indications” a number of providers had broken strict laws banning investments in cluster-bomb-makers.

The investigation analysed more than 100,000 individual assets held in nearly 500 individual KiwiSaver funds looking for 169 companies blacklisted by the New Zealand Superannuation Fund. The analysis found half of KiwiSaver providers – mostly smaller boutique outfits – had avoided blacklisted investments, but more than 2 million people were unwitting investors in big tobacco companies and makers of banned weapons.

Many fund providers today defended their schemes, claiming individual investments in controversial companies – such as British American Tobacco and nuclear bomb component maker Honeywell International – were made only as part of indiscriminate investments in entire stock indices.

In total, New Zealanders were found to have $102m invested in tobacco companies, with more than half of this stake made by one fund provider – ANZ, and its OneAnswer funds. The Herald analysis ranked the ANZ pair as having invested the highest proportion of client funds into blacklisted assets

Today ANZ, the country’s largest provider managing $8.3b on behalf of 830,000 New Zealanders, announced it was reviewing its investment policies.

“ANZ Group is currently conducting a review of the governance and selection criteria of its underlying investments,” a spokesperson for the bank said.

The spokesperson said ANZ was transparent about where funds were invested, offered a specific ethical investment fund as an option, and clients were free to change funds any time they wished. The investigation also found three KiwiSaver providers had made investments worth a total of $2.3m in a trio of United States companies – Textron, General Dynamics and Northrop Grumman – blacklisted by the NZSF due to their production of cluster bombs.

New Zealand signed an international treaty banning such weapons, and in 2009 passed enabling legislation specifically forbidding investments in such companies.

Funds managed by Westpac, AMP and Aon hold shares in three companies. Aon did not respond to questions.

A spokesperson for Westpac said the bank was “not aware of any non-compliance with any legislation”.

A spokesperson for AMP said its holdings were only indirect, via unit trusts, and it was “moving to remove exposure from cluster munitions in accordance with its legal obligations”.

Minister for Commerce Paul Goldsmith told Parliament he had today requested advice on the matter and had been told by officials there were “some indications” the cluster bomb laws had been broken.

“I’ve asked for advice on that and there is some indication that the law may apply but that’s for the appropriate enforcement authority to decide whether there’s been a breach of the law,” Goldsmith said.

Goldsmith drew a contrast between issues of ethics and laws. “We expect KiwiSaver providers to follow the law, but we believe individual investors are best placed to make moral judgments,” he said.

The questions to Goldsmith came as Opposition MPs urged the Government to act on the issue.

Labour’s Grant Robertson said: “Most New Zealanders would be appalled that their KiwiSaver funds are being invested into cluster bombs and land mines.”

The Green Party’s Julie Anne Genter said default funds – which half-a-million people had enrolled in and not moved from – should be cleaned up.

“The Government should be showing strong leadership by clarifying the legality of investing in cluster munitions and landmines,” she said.

Prime Minster John Key said the Government was unlikely to further regulate the KiwiSaver sector, and the choice of fund – and where to draw lines on what was an acceptable investment – was up to individuals.

“So in the end every KiwiSaver investor, I guess, needs to look at the investments they are making and make a decision about whether that’s an ethical investment,” he said.

The Herald series will next week crunch more KiwiSaver data, particularly over performance and fees charged, to find the sector’s best performers and worst performers.

72% of Indonesians would quit smoking if a pack of cigarettes costs Rp 50K: Survey

http://jakarta.coconuts.co/2016/08/18/72-indonesians-would-quit-smoking-if-pack-cigarettes-costs-rp-50k-survey

Indonesia’s alarmingly high smoking rates can be attributed to many factors, chief among them the government’s hesitance to reduce and regulate cigarrette consumption, which has led to their ubiquitous availability and incredibly cheap prices.

One notably shocking statistic is that 67.4% of Indonesian males over 15 smoke, but a new survey shows that that number could be significantly curtailed if the government slapped a heavy tax on tobacco production, which would in turn raise cigarette prices.

Universitas Indonesia’s Public Health Faculty recently conducted a survey of 1,000 Indonesian smokers to gauge the relationship between smoking prevalence and cigarette prices. Unsurprisingly, the majority of respondents said they’d give up smoking if cigarettes were more expensive.

“As many as 72% said they’d quit smoking if a pack of cigarettes costs Rp 50,000 or more,” said lead researcher Hasbullah Thabrany, as quoted by Kompas.

Currently, a pack of cigarettes generally cost around Rp 20,000 in Indonesia.

Surprisingly, 76% of the respondents – all of whom are smokers, mind you – said they’ agree to a tobacco tax hike and overall increase in the price of cigarettes.

The government is well aware of the results of the survey.

“Making a pack of cigarettes cost Rp 50,000 is something that’s being communicated,” said Customs and Excise Director General Heru Prambudi, as quoted by Liputan6 yesterday.

However, Heru added that the government would have to look into the issue not just from a public health perspective, but from an economic perspective as well.

“We have to communicate this to all stakeholders, be it the pro-health or pro-industry, because [tobacco] farmers have a say in this too. If we only listen to one party, we can go bankrupt,” he said.

“If the price of cigarettes go beyond the optimum curve, there will be negative effects such as the death [of the tobacco industry] or the rise of illegal cigarettes.”

The survey estimated that the state would stand to earn around Rp 70 trillion annually from tax on tobacco if a pack of cigarettes were to cost Rp 50,000. Last year, the state earned Rp 139.5 trillion from tobacco taxes.

Do you think that the importance of public health should outweigh the potential economic shortfalls should cigarette prices be raised? Let us know your opinion on our Facebook page.

Plain cigarette packs to hit shelves Saturday

A regulation requiring cigarettes to be sold in uniform plain packaging comes into effect this Saturday. However, brands already on the market will receive a temporary exemption, online daily hvg.hu reported.

http://bbj.hu/economy/plain-cigarette-packs-to-hit-shelves-saturday_120777

In harmony with European Union regulations, Hungary is introducing measures under which menthol cigarettes will be banned and tobacco products can be sold only in uniform packaging in the country. The Hungarian government was first said to be planning such changes in June 2015. Professionals working in the tobacco industry have criticized the measures, claiming they will not reduce the consumption of tobacco products.

Under the EU’s Tobacco Products Directive (TPD), as of May 20, 2017, cigarette packets on sale should meet strict criteria. The TPD regulates that both the largest surfaces of tobacco product packets must contain warnings amounting to 65% of the surface area, while similar warnings must also appear on the top of packets. Hungary is also introducing uniform packaging – void of brand logos, with the product brand and all other type printed in a uniform font – and the banning of flavored cigarettes.

Already existing brands can be purchased by retailers in their current packaging until the end of the year, and can be sold until May 20, 2017, as part of a temporary exemption. By May 20, 2019, at the latest, all retailers need to conform with the regulations. By May 20, 2020, flavored cigarettes must disappear from shelves.