http://www.aph.gov.au/house/info/votes/rvpp062.pdf
17 TOBACCO PLAIN PACKAGING BILL 2011
The order of the day having been read for the resumption of the debate on the question—That the bill be
now read a second time—
Debate resumed.
Question—put and passed—bill read a second time.
Consideration in detail
Bill, by leave, taken as a whole.
Dr Southcott moved the Opposition amendment.
Debate continued.
Question—That the amendment be agreed to—put.
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—
AYES, 67
Mr K. J. Andrews Mr Frydenberg Mr Macfarlane Mr Scott
Mrs K. L. Andrews Ms Gambaro Ms Marino Mr Secker*
Mr Baldwin Mrs Gash Mrs Markus Mr Simpkins
Mr Billson Mrs Griggs Mr Matheson Mr Slipper
Mrs B. K. Bishop Mr Haase Mrs Mirabella Mr A. D. H. Smith
Ms J. I. Bishop Mr Hartsuyker Mr Morrison Mr Somlyay
Mr Briggs Mr A. G. Hawke Mr Neville Dr Southcott
Mr Buchholz Mr Hockey Mr O’Dowd Dr Stone
Mr Chester Mr Hunt Ms O’Dwyer Mr Tehan
Mr Christensen Mr Irons Mrs Prentice Mr Truss
Mr Ciobo Dr Jensen Mr Pyne Mr Tudge
Mr Cobb Mr E. T. Jones Mr Ramsey Mr Turnbull
Mr Coulton* Mr Keenan Mr Randall Mr van Manen
Mr Dutton Mr C. Kelly Mr Robb Mr Vasta
Mr Entsch Mr Laming Mr Robert Dr Washer
Mr Fletcher Ms Ley Mr Wyatt Roy Mr Wyatt
Mr Forrest Mr McCormack Mr Schultz
NOES, 72
Mr Adams Mr Danby Mr S. P. Jones Mr Ripoll
Mr Albanese Mrs D’Ath Ms King Ms Rishworth
Mr Bandt Mr Dreyfus Dr Leigh Ms Rowland
Ms Bird Mrs Elliot Ms Livermore Ms Roxon
Mr Bowen Ms Ellis Mr Lyons Ms Saffin
Mr Bradbury Dr Emerson Mr McClelland Mr Shorten
Ms Brodtmann Mr L. D. T. Ferguson Mr Marles Mr Sidebottom
Ms A. E. Burke Mr M. J. Ferguson Mr Melham Mr S. F. Smith
Mr A. S. Burke Mr Fitzgibbon Mr Mitchell Ms Smyth
Mr Butler Mr Garrett Mr Murphy Mr Snowdon
Mr Byrne Mr Georganas Mr Neumann Mr Swan
Mr Champion Mr Gibbons Mr Oakeshott Mr Symon
Mr Cheeseman Mr Gray Mr O’Connor Mr C. R. Thomson
Mr Clare Ms Grierson Ms O’Neill Mr K. J. Thomson
Ms Collins Mr Griffin Ms Owens Ms Vamvakinou
Mr Combet Ms Hall* Ms Parke Mr Wilkie
Mr Crean Mr Hayes Mr Perrett Mr Windsor
Mr Crook Mr Husic* Ms Plibersek Mr Zappia
Pairs
Ms Gillard Mr Abbott
Mr Rudd Mrs Moylan
Ms Macklin Mr Ruddock
Dr M. J. Kelly Mr Broadbent
And so it was negatived
Bill agreed to.
Consideration in detail concluded.
On the motion of Ms Roxon (Minister for Health and Ageing), by leave, the bill was read a third time.
18 TRADE MARKS AMENDMENT (TOBACCO PLAIN PACKAGING) BILL 2011
The order of the day having been read for the resumption of the debate on the question—That the bill be
now read a second time—
Question—put.
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—
AYES, 72
Mr Adams Mrs D’Ath Dr M. J. Kelly Mr Ripoll
Mr Bandt Mr Dreyfus Ms King Ms Rishworth
Ms Bird Mrs Elliot Dr Leigh Ms Rowland
Mr Bowen Ms Ellis Ms Livermore Ms Roxon
Mr Bradbury Dr Emerson Mr Lyons Ms Saffin
Ms Brodtmann Mr L. D. T. Ferguson Mr McClelland Mr Shorten
Ms A. E. Burke Mr M. J. Ferguson Mr Marles Mr Sidebottom
Mr A. S. Burke Mr Fitzgibbon Mr Melham Mr S. F. Smith
Mr Butler Mr Garrett Mr Mitchell Ms Smyth
Mr Byrne Mr Georganas Mr Murphy Mr Snowdon
Mr Champion Mr Gibbons Mr Neumann Mr Swan
Mr Cheeseman Mr Gray Mr Oakeshott Mr Symon
Mr Clare Ms Grierson Mr O’Connor Mr C. R. Thomson
Ms Collins Mr Griffin Ms O’Neill Mr K. J. Thomson
Mr Combet Ms Hall* Ms Owens Ms Vamvakinou
Mr Crean Mr Hayes Ms Parke Mr Wilkie
Mr Crook Mr Husic* Mr Perrett Mr Windsor
Mr Danby Mr S. P. Jones Ms Plibersek Mr Zappia
NOES, 67
Mr K. J. Andrews Mr Frydenberg Mr Macfarlane Mr Scott
Mrs K. L. Andrews Ms Gambaro Ms Marino Mr Secker*
Mr Baldwin Mrs Gash Mrs Markus Mr Simpkins
Mr Billson Mrs Griggs Mr Matheson Mr Slipper
Mrs B. K. Bishop Mr Haase Mrs Mirabella Mr A. D. H. Smith
Ms J. I. Bishop Mr Hartsuyker Mr Morrison Mr Somlyay
Mr Briggs Mr A. G. Hawke Mr Neville Dr Southcott
Mr Buchholz Mr Hockey Mr O’Dowd Dr Stone
Mr Chester Mr Hunt Ms O’Dwyer Mr Tehan
Mr Christensen Mr Irons Mrs Prentice Mr Truss
Mr Ciobo Dr Jensen Mr Pyne Mr Tudge
Mr Cobb Mr E. T. Jones Mr Ramsey Mr Turnbull
Mr Coulton* Mr Keenan Mr Randall Mr van Manen
Mr Dutton Mr C. Kelly Mr Robb Mr Vasta
Mr Entsch Mr Laming Mr Robert Dr Washer
Mr Fletcher Ms Ley Mr Wyatt Roy Mr Wyatt
Mr Forrest Mr McCormack Mr Schultz
Pairs
Ms Gillard Mr Abbott
Mr Rudd Mrs Moylan
Ms Macklin Mr Ruddock
Mr Albanese Mr Broadbent
And so it was resolved in the affirmative—bill read a second time.
Leave granted for third reading to be moved immediately.
On the motion of Ms Roxon (Minister for Health and Ageing), the bill was read a third time.