Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Turkey smoke ban extends to bars

BBC News

Turkey has extended an existing ban on smoking in public places to all bars, cafes and restaurants.

The ban has come into force despite opposition from some bar and cafe owners who fear losing business.

It comes after the government banned smoking from most enclosed public spaces in May last year in an effort to improve the nation’s health.

Turkey has more than 20 million smokers but polls suggest 95% of people support the ban.

“We are working to protect our future, to save our youth,” said Health Minister Recep Akdag.

Anyone caught lighting up in a designated smoke-free area faces a fine of 69 liras ($45:£28) while bar owners who fail to enforce the ban could be fined from 560 liras for a first offence (US$ 366) up to 5,600 liras (US$ 3,660).

Local authorities have hired thousands of extra staff to track down smokers and impose the fines.

Many people in Istanbul said they thought the ban was a good move.

“We were being destroyed in the places where you were allowed to smoke inside,” said Istanbul cafe patron Hanife Demirm.

“I was choosing the non-smoking places automatically, but after the ban is extended I will not need to be selective. I’ll be very comfortable in every place that I go,” he told the AP news agency.

‘Unnecessary stress’

But the BBC’s David O’Byrne in Istanbul says many Turkish people see the ban as an erosion of their democratic rights and have called for bars to be able to apply for a smoking licence.

Some cafe owners have also said they were concerned the ban would drive away customers.

“They will simply leave and never come back, or we would get in trouble for letting them smoke,” said Istanbul cafe owner Selahattin Nar.

“Then both we and they would be filled with unnecessary stresses. In the end they will not be able to relax and we will have to shut down.”

But Mr Akdag said there was no reason for cafe and bar owners to be worried about a drop in trade.

“The public supports a smoke-free environment and the only ones to suffer will be the cigarette producers and sellers,” he said.

A no smoking rule has been in place for the past 15 months in government offices, workplaces, shopping malls, schools and hospitals.

All forms of public transport, including trains, taxis and ferries, are also affected but there are exemptions for special zones in psychiatric hospitals and prisons.

Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/europe/8157747.stm

Published: 2009/07/18 23:42:21 GMT

© BBC MMIX

__________________________

CTA, Jim: we need many more Tobacco Control Inspectors and the onus placed on licensees to enforce the smoking ban here in Hong Kong

the officers could be empowered to issue littering tickets also

Stop trying to please everyone

SCMP

Some pedestrians have apparently complained about Hong Kong’s designated smoking areas. This seems to indicate an increasingly draconian approach to public health. I am not a smoker and few of my friends smoke. The law to ban smoking has tried to appease smokers and the non-smoking members of the community. But the result has been that neither group is happy.

The way the government promoted the ban has led some non-smokers to expect a smoke-free city. Now people converge at public places to light up, locations where there are smokers and non-smokers, such as elevated walkways, outside shopping malls, bus stops, taxi stands and pavements.

Before the law was enacted you would normally see smokers in restaurants, bars and karaokes, where they were not so much of an eyesore. You might see one or two people puffing on cigarettes at outside locations. Now you see groups of up to a dozen. We are not less exposed to second-hand smoke than we were before the ban came into force. There is ill-feeling between the two groups.

The smokers feel cornered and vilified. The non-smokers are annoyed that people are lighting up outside in areas where there should be fresh air. When will the government stop trying to please all parties when it launches campaigns to publicise new policies?

Virginia Yue, Tsuen Wan

No retreat from smoking ban, says health minister

http://www.todayszaman.com/tz-web/

Health Minister Recep Akdağ has reaffirmed that Turkey will not backtrack on its complete ban on the use of tobacco products at indoor establishments, which comes into force on Sunday. Akdağ stressed that no extra time would be given to shop owners to make the necessary adjustments to their business premises. “We are not happy with the idea of allowing extra time to cafes, restaurants or tourism agencies to make the adjustments to their premises that the law requires. Some European Union member countries did allow extra time to businesses before enforcing the full smoking ban, but later had great difficulty in carrying it out,” he stated.

With the amendment made to Law 4207 on the Prevention of the Harmful Effects of Tobacco Products, smoking will not be permitted in indoor sections of cafes, bars, restaurants and the like as of July 19. The operators of such businesses will be responsible for monitoring their clients’ compliance with the law and reporting any violation by telephoning the nearest police station or by calling 184 to reach the Ministry of Health’s Communication Center (SABİM).Any violation on the part of operators and clients will be penalized by fines of TL 560 to 5600 and TL 69, respectively.

Meanwhile, Bahattin Köksal, head of the anti-tobacco organization Healthy Life Association (SAĞLIK-DER), suggested that July 19, when the full ban on tobacco products in public places goes into effect, should be celebrated annually as “Clear Air Day.”

Speaking in Ankara yesterday at a conference on the tobacco ban at the Ankara Mayor’s Office, Köksal said their association aimed to educate people about the dangers of tobacco use.

Toker Ergüder from the World Health Organization (WHO) also attended the conference, stating that Turkey is among the countries with the highest tobacco-consumption rates. “This law will make Turkey one of the few countries that have banned smoking in all closed areas at a national level,” he said, hailing the law as “revolutionary.”

He said the WHO and civil society organizations have been working together well ahead of the ban. “We believe that this cooperation is very important for us to fight the global tobacco problem that threatens the lives of millions of women, men and children across the globe. Cooperation among governments, international organizations and civil society, as has happened in Turkey, is much needed to fight this problem, which is completely preventable.”

Smoking ban may save lives

SCMP

James Griffiths, who laments the extension of the ban on smoking to all Hong Kong’s bars, loses sight of two key points (“Smoking ban in bars will only cut much-needed spending”, July 10).

One is that non-smokers like to go to bars too, and they can be, and very often are, disturbed – indeed poisoned – by the smoke emitted by others.

The challenge, now that smoking inside bars will no longer occur, is to get the smokers away from the open fronts of restaurants and bars, lest they continue to disturb those inside with their toxic exhalations.

The other key point is that smoking eventually makes seriously ill, or kills, nearly half of those who indulge in the unhealthy habit. By forcing smokers to at least desist while inside a bar, these enhanced rules may be saving the life of the smoker.

These vital points far outweigh the inconvenience to smokers of no longer being allowed to smoke inside bars.

Hong Kong has taken the right step here and it is a step already taken by many other jurisdictions around the world.

Paul Surtees, Mid-Levels

Richmond bans smoking in apartments and condos

http://www.mercurynews.com/breakingnews/ci_12822126

The Associated Press

RICHMOND, Calif.—City officials in Richmond are snuffing out smoking in apartments, condominiums and public places, making it the hardest place in the San Francisco Bay area to smoke.

The City Council approved an ordinance this month that will ban lighting up in all multiunit housing by Jan. 1, 2011. Officials say smoking in multiunit housing exposes people to secondhand smoke, which can travel between apartments.

The city has already banned smoking in parks, farmers markets and other public places. Fines start at $100 for violating the bans.

Richmond was given an “F” by the American Lung Association in January, which got city leaders to move quickly to enact tougher restrictions to discourage smoking and reduce secondhand smoke.

———

Information from: Contra Costa Times

Richmond tightens smoking rules

Katherine Tam – West County Times

Richmond will ban smoking in apartments and condominiums in addition to public places, making the city the toughest place in the Bay Area to light up.

City officials will require multiunit housing to go smoke-free by Jan. 1, 2011. That includes individual apartment units and common areas such as lobbies and patios, where experts say secondhand smoke can seep through cracks, vents and wall sockets. Apartment owners can designate a smoking area, but it must be at least 25 feet away from where smoking is prohibited.

Fines for violating the new ban on smoking in multiunit housing start at $100.

The new ordinance, which the City Council approved this month, is on top of additional regulations created in May that bar smoking in public places such as parks, trails and where parades, farmers markets and other public events are held. Smoking is prohibited indoors where people congregate and work — regardless of whether it’s publicly or privately owned — including restaurants, bars and conference rooms.

That’s a big change from more than a decade ago when people hoping to keep secondhand smoke at bay created smoking and nonsmoking sections in restaurants and airplanes.

“We’re on the right side of history,” Councilman Tom Butt said. “This idea that somehow you could bifurcate buildings and make portions of it smoking, portions of it nonsmoking, it just doesn’t work.”

Richmond now has on the books the strictest batch of secondhand smoking laws in the region, said Serena Chen, a regional director at the American Lung Association in California. Other cities have some of the same laws, but not all of them.

Secondhand smoke is listed as a human carcinogen by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

It was an F grade on an American Lung Association report card in January that spurred Richmond officials to toughen their laws. That report card graded cities on how well they discouraged smoking by developing laws that ban smoking outdoors and in multiunit housing and that regulate tobacco sales.

Most cities in the Bay Area got a D or F. No one got an A; five jurisdictions — Contra Costa County, Oakland, Berkeley, Novato and Belmont — got Bs.

Belmont made national headlines in 2007 when it became the first in the country to ban smoking in multiunit housing; that went into effect in January. Dublin followed suit in 2008 with a less-restrictive requirement that half the units in buildings with more than 16 rentals be smoke-free by 2010.

In Richmond, people can continue to smoke at home if it is a single-family house and on sidewalks and streets, but not within 25 feet of a door, window or vent that leads to a place where smoking is prohibited. Tobacco retailers are required to get a permit.

Smoke-free law supporters celebrated with hugs in the back of the City Council chamber this past week after officials passed its latest law. Smokers and apartment representatives, who were fewer in number at the meeting, were less enthused. Theresa Karr, who represents the California Apartment Association, asked the city to cushion the financial blow to apartment owners and tenants by requiring half, instead of all, the units in existing buildings be smoke-free. Evictions could be an unintended consequence, she warned.

“You are not only financially impacting owners and operators of rental properties, you’re probably going to financially impact tenants who maybe have no other bad habit other than they smoke,” Karr said.

THE NEW SMOKING BAN – what it means to Hong Kong and what still needs to happen

hkoutdoorsmoke

Smoking ban working well, tobacco office says

Ng Yuk-hang, SCMP

A week after the smoking ban was extended to bars and clubs, the Tobacco Control Office has issued only three summonses, though it received 59 complaints.

Thirty-six of the complaints involved mahjong parlours, while 12 involved bars, Ronald Lam Man-kin, the head of the office, said yesterday on a morning radio programme.

The ban targeting entertainment establishments, which include massage centres and bathhouses, took effect last week – 2 1/2 years after most indoor places and public areas went smoke-free, and amid strong objections by businesses.
Dr Lam said the ban was working well and that most businesses were co-operating by putting up posters and taking away ashtrays.

His office was recruiting “anti-smoking ambassadors” to the clubs and bars to raise awareness of the dangers of smoking, he said.

It would also step up inspection and prosecution by recruiting 14 more inspectors by next March. Since 2007, the office has conducted more than 31,000 spot inspections and issued more than 13,000 summonses. Those who flout the ban can be fined up to HK$5,000.

The ban might not be bad for business, Dr Lam said. In New York, for example, it created 10,000 jobs and raised tax revenue, he said.

But Bars and Karaoke Rights Advocacy executive secretary Anita To Miu-yu disagreed, saying business dropped by 20 to 30 per cent over the weekend.

“Now that the border is open 24 hours a day, many people choose to have a drink in Shenzhen,” she said.
Chow Chun-yu, chief executive of the Licensed Massage Association, also said business had dropped by 30 to 50 per cent. Besides, customers were still smoking secretly, and staff found it hard to stop them. “We are scared that they may leave, or use foul words to scold us.”

Government statistics show more restaurants and licensed premises opened after the smoking ban was enacted here

letterstatspanelhs

West Vancouver looks to tighten outdoor smoking regulations

By Rebecca Aldous – North Shore Outlook

With the District of West Vancouver’s new bylaw, the North Shore is moving towards more stringent smoking bylaws than those introduced by the provincial government in 2009.


The North Shore may soon be butting out more outdoor smoking.

With West Vancouver leading the charge, the districts and city east of the Lions Gate Bridge, along with the help of the Vancouver Coastal Health Authority, aim to introduce stricter regulations on top of the provincial government’s 2008 outdoor smoking laws.

The new bylaws, which must be approved by the province’s Ministry of Health, would ban smoking on patios, swimming beaches, athletic fields and children’s playgrounds.

They will also further extend B.C.’s three- metre rule for smoking next to building entrances or air ducts to six metres. “I think essentially it will eliminate smoking on outdoor patios at restaurants,” West Vancouver Mayor Pamela Goldsmith-Jones said.“That is the biggest thing that people will notice.”

Sailor Hagar’s Brew Pub owner Brian Riedlinger said his business will be negatively impacted financially by the move.A lot of the pub’s patrons smoke and currently use the outdoor patio. Eliminating that area will force them onto streets and into alleys, which in turn will create more work for his staff, he said.

“We’ll have to start monitoring they don’t take their drinks out there,” Riedlinger said.

Already the provincial regulations mandating smoking three metres from doorways or air ducts are not being complied throughout Greater Vancouver, he said noting the regulation just pushes people further into sideway traffic.

In B.C. less than 20 per cent of the population smokes, reports Perry Kendall, B.C.’s public health officer.

In West Vancouver this number is further reduced to 6 per cent and predicted to diminish as demographic changes occur, stated the district report.

West Vancouver has sent the bylaw to the health minister for approval. Once it returns, the bylaw will be put to a final vote by council, likely in September, said Liz Holitzki, West Vancouver’s manager of permits, inspections and bylaws.

Steve Feenstra, District of North Vancouver assistant chief of fire prevention, said the district is currently working on a new smoking bylaw that could have a far reaching effect.

One major area the bylaw would tackle would be smoking in the district’s parks and forests, he said.

“The fire chief has the ability to enforce a smoking ban any time he sees fit,” Feenstra explained but added the bylaw could outright ban smoking from parks instead.

“We haven’t quite nailed (the ban) down to six months or year round.”

Earlier in June, the DNV Fire Rescue Service reported it had fought 25 wildfires as of June 5. In 2008, district firefighters fought 62 brush or grass fires.

“It’s looking like we’ll be somewhere in the 60 to 80 (brush/grass fire) range,” deputy fire chief Victor Penman told The Outlook in June.

On Monday, City of North Vancouver council asked its staff to look into the possibility of banning smoking in multi-unit dwellings.

The decision followed a presentation by resident Sean Soper, who argued for the ban due to health concerns and fire hazard.

While Soper acknowledged that a smoking ban can be implemented by an individual building, he claimed it is a difficult process particularly if a strata is involved.

“It’s a matter of principal, I don’t think people in the city should be exposed to second-hand smoke,” Soper told The Outlook. “I think the city should try to keep citizens away from known hazards.”

Mayor Darrell Mussatto said staff have been asked to look into whether it would be legal for the city to enact such a bylaw and what options it has.

“Once we know what our legalities are we can have the discussion about what we can do about this,” Mussatto said.