Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Is enough being done to police the smoking ban?

SCMP

Your correspondents Allan Dyer and Annelise Connell should get realistic about smoking “offenders” inside buildings, lifts and bars (Talkback, August 17). Ms Connell claims that offenders are “criminal” and bar licence-holders should be penalised if they fail to enforce no-smoking rules.

She even suggests they should call the police every time an offender refuses to co-operate and, furthermore, that they should lose their liquor licences (and landlords the use of their premises) if they fail to report these “vice” cases to the police.

Let’s make it quite clear, smokers lighting up in the wrong places are not committing crimes. These offences are only misdemeanours in law and the police have much more important priorities than to welcome smoking complaints and send officers rushing to licensed premises to track down smokers.

If I were the local police commander, whose officers received repeated phone calls from a bar owner about this problem, I would issue a polite warning about wasting police time.

You have to face the reality. All you anti-tobacco lobbyists have been outwitted. You have been handed an utterly useless and almost unenforceable law.

Blasphemy and the use of foul language also continue to be offences, but we hear these on the streets all the time. Why not start a campaign about these “crimes” as well? Your correspondents have to get real.

P. A. Crush, Sha Tin

TVB Pearl 1855 hrs tonight: 2009.08.23 – Discussing the Smoking Ban

http://programme.tvb.com/news/pearlreport/episode/20090823/#page-1

播出日期 2009.08.23(日)

娛樂場所禁煙經已實施,現時只餘下街頭與家裡為合法吸煙場所。但娛樂場所禁煙的實施也困難重重,因為部分娛樂場所負責人表明不會要求客人禁煙 – 而新例亦只懲處違例吸煙者,不包括場所負責人。

今年9月禁煙條例實施定額罰款,繳交罰款期以21日為限。有批評指出,禁煙措施與定額罰款,難以向訪港旅客推行。

The ban on smoking in places of entertainment like bars, clubs and mahjong parlours is meant to have pushed cigarette smoking on to the streets of Hong Kong. Or, into homes.

Enforcing that ban though will be a challenge. Some entertainmnet venue operators have vowed to allow their customers to smoke, in defiance of the ban. And the law permits that – only the smoker is punished.

Anyone hit with a fixed penalty fine for smoking, to be implemented in September, will have 21 days to pay it. Critics ask if that’s the case, how can Hong Kong enforce a smoking ban on visitors?

___________________________________

Click the following link to see the programme:

http://mytv.tvb.com/news/pearlreport/8765#page-1

Is enough being done to police the smoking ban?

SCMP

It is impossible for the government to punish every person who chooses to flout the smoking ban. I do not think there are enough tobacco-control officers to supervise the smokers. It is impractical for the government to ask the public to report smokers. Even if someone sees an individual breaking the law in the street, by the time the officer arrives, the person may have left. I think more of these officers need to be deployed on Hong Kong’s streets.

The government must also broadcast more television adverts and use them to educate people to obey the law.

Agnes Yu, Kwun Tong

Is enough being done to police the smoking ban?

SCMP

I would like to report that the Tobacco Control Office requires a very high standard of evidence before considering taking action against a smoker.

It is not enough for a complainant to have had multiple witnesses, even if some could identify and name the culprit, having seen him with a lit cigarette in a no-smoking area, and building caretakers who recorded the culprit’s name and identity card number – all recorded on closed-circuit television.

This relates to an incident on August 4, when I was leaving my workplace shortly after the typhoon signal No 8 was issued.

I immediately noticed that the lift was smoky and I pointed out a man holding a lit cigarette to the caretakers on the ground floor. I asked them to report the incident to the Tobacco Control Office for prosecution.

On Monday, four tobacco control officers visited my office, not to take my statement, but to explain the situation.

Apparently, this was a “minor offence”, with not enough evidence. If an officer had been present at the time, he could have requested the offender to put out the cigarette, and educated him about statutory no-smoking areas.

The situation will improve in September, when the office will be able to issue a HK$1,500 fixed-penalty fine – but the Tobacco Control Office does not plan to station an officer in the lift 24/7.

A tiny minority of smokers are so anti-social that they uncaringly release poisonous gases in lifts – the most enclosed spaces that we regularly use.

As the Tobacco Control Office will never have enough officers to station one in every lift, we must find other ways to stamp out this practice.

The office could publish explicit guidelines to the public on how to collect enough evidence to enable prosecution.

We could fit smoke detectors in every lift.

Does the office have the determination to seek out innovative ways of achieving its priority?

Allan Dyer, Wong Chuk Hang

In every bar and most restaurants in Hong Kong there is a tobacco control enforcement officer, namely the liquor licence holder.

Not one of them is “powerless” to prevent smoking.

They have the power and a duty, under their liquor licence, to call the police if someone is smoking.

They are required to prevent crimes, such as solicitation for sex, gambling and smoking, in their bar or restaurant.

They are very powerful. It is their deliberate choice to turn their workplaces into “vice establishments”.

Once the building owner is made aware, if the owner does nothing, then the police can shut the place down and the landlord cannot rent it out again for several months.

Annelise Connell, Stanley

Is enough being done to police the smoking ban?

SCMP

Apparently, the enforcement of the ban is too lax as we can still see smokers lighting up in indoor areas. Some smokers have moved to upstairs bars where they can enjoy their cigarettes without worrying about being caught.

Worse still, the owners of some bars actually provide ashtrays to their patrons. Although there are some owners who will try and persuade customers to put out their cigarettes, they are often ignored.

A ban that cannot be enforced is equal to having no law at all.

Those flouting the law will continue to light up and non-smokers will still be exposed to lethal second-hand smoke.

I would like to see Tobacco Control Officers increase the frequency of their patrols in areas such as SoHo and Lan Kwai Fong. I also think raids should be carried out in those upstairs pubs where smokers ignore the law.

I appreciate that pub owners face a dilemma, but they should play a more active role. For example, they should remove all ashtrays and urge customers who wish to smoke to go outside.

Non-smokers also have an important role to play. They can report venues where smokers are defying the ban to the respective government department.

I urge smokers to abide by the ban and show some consideration for non-smokers. Also, they must appreciate that they are breaking the law and if they are caught they will be fined. All they have to do to avoid that is go outside.

Mike Lam, Kwun Tong

Is enough being done to police the smoking ban?

SCMP

I doubt if enough is being done. It astonishes me to see some people continuing to smoke indoors at venues where it is banned, even on the ground floor.

This reveals the inadequacy in the government’s enforcement policy.

The deterrent effect is inadequate, as smokers think that if they flout the law they will not be caught.

A more worrying problem is that the owners of some bars and mahjong parlours are turning a blind eye to smoking inside their establishments.

They will not strictly follow the law, as they do not shoulder any legal responsibilities, even if someone is caught smoking on their premises. They do not want to lose customers, especially during the present economic downturn. Clearly there is a loophole in the law.

Even if some bar owners do try to stop customers lighting up, they have no powers.

Therefore, more manpower should be allocated to enforce the law.

Frederic Lam Hei-wai, Kwun Tong

Is enough being done to police the smoking ban?

SCMP

The government has passed laws to prevent smoking in all workplaces, including establishments that previously had exemptions.

Overseas, where similar bans have been implemented, the onus is on licensees to prevent smoking on their premises or lose their licences. This is not the case here, therefore they choose not to act.

Unlike in overseas jurisdictions, there are no demarcated non-smoking zones outside the entrances of buildings, restaurants and bars.

The Tobacco Control Office is 90 per cent understaffed. It is ludicrous to expect 85 officers, soon to be 99, to cover Hong Kong on three shifts. They need at least 1,000 to patrol entertainment areas, while the Leisure and Cultural Services Department and other government servants will enforce parks, markets and playing fields from September.

Clear the Air has been accompanying a film crew around Hong Kong entertainment areas. Smoking is blatantly continuing in ground-level bars, condoned by licensees. Upstairs bars and mahjong parlours are worse.

Those premises enforcing the ban see crowds of smokers outside their entrances blocking pavements.

Bars and tables are placed illegally on the pavements, and bar staff serve patrons illegally on the pavements while passers-by are forced to walk in the road to get past the toxic smoke, the revellers and cigarette butts.

These laws are intended to protect employees in the workplace. All they have achieved is to move the problem mostly from indoors to outdoors.

Passive smoking kills 111 people per month, and the government deliberately allows the situation to continue with minuscule enforcement. And flawed licensee liability laws mean they are not legally obliged to enforce the ban.

James Middleton, chairman, anti- tobacco committee, Clear the Air

The smoking ban was extended to nightclubs and other entertainment venues last month. However, some people are questioning its effectiveness (“Many feel free to flout smoke ban”, August 1).

It would appear that individuals are continuing to smoke in some venues, such as bars, in contravention of the law.

I suspect that some bar owners, if they cannot get smokers to stop, just decide not to bother trying. If the government does not do something about this, the problem will only get worse and we will witness an increasing number of smokers flouting the law.

I would like to see more smoke detectors installed in nightclubs, which would prevent people from lighting up.

I welcome the new legislation. In spite of the problems, you do see fewer people smoking, so there is less exposure to second-hand smoke.

Ella Chan Ho-chi, Hung Hom

Gary Brand (Talkback, August 5) provides an excellent summary of the reasons why there should be both public and commercial observance of the smoking ban. It will be good for business and for the health of employees and customers.

The threat of civil disobedience was a prominent part of the shroud-waving by opponents of the tobacco control bill.

This was led by the tobacco industry, a relatively small clique in the catering industry and some legislators.

It is time that all lawmakers came out with a clear and unambiguous declaration that there are no grounds for defiance of the law and that rigorous penalties should be applied to those who facilitate defiance of it.

In other countries it is law-breaking that threatens landlords’ livelihoods, not smoke-free policies.

Anthony Hedley, School of Public Health, University of Hong Kong

‘I want to quit one day… but not because of the ban

Amy Nip, Austin Chiu and Dan Kadison – SCMP

Smokers are banned from having a puff inside entertainment venues, but that has not been enough to make them quit the habit.

Smoker Michael Chow said lax implementation of the ban at bars had given him “an excuse” not to stop smoking.

Lighting up a cigarette in a Central bar after midnight, Mr Chow spoke of repeated attempts to quit smoking.

He said he returned to Hong Kong from Canada a few years ago, after that country imposed a smoking ban.

When Hong Kong announced its ban, he said, he felt it was the right time to quit.

“I still want to quit one day … but I would do it for my own benefit, not because of the smoking ban in bars.”

Man Cheung, who was also smoking inside a pub, said he was under the impression that staff at the Tobacco Control Office “did not dare go check pubs located upstairs”.

“I was in a bar in Causeway Bay last month when a few tobacco control officers arrived. But they did not go into the bar to check out whether there were people smoking. They simply handed out anti-smoking leaflets to the owner,” he said.

One patron at Delaney’s Irish pub, Mike Galvin, 46, who works in Shenzhen, said he had just found out about the ban this week and was not happy about it.

“All the ban is doing is putting … people out of work,” he said. “You’re destroying the tourist industry in Hong Kong. And you’re making people obviously unhappy. So what’s the point?”

In Tsim Sha Tsui, a female smoker was standing outside the Pelican Bay Beachside Bar, an Observatory Court watering hole close to Knutsford Terrace.

The 33-year-old insurance consultant, who would only identify herself as Wong, said she found it inconvenient to walk outside a bar to have a cigarette, but still did so.

Tobacco Control Office staff had been visiting establishments since June to promote the smoke-free message, an office spokesman said. They had distributed leaflets and stickers to managers and owners so they could help promote the cause.

“All qualified establishments, whether they are situated upstairs, on street level or in the basement, are visited,” he said.

Is enough being done to police the smoking ban?

SCMP

That the press can so easily find smokers in violation of the law means those who are meant to police the ban have failed (“Many feel free to flout smoking ban”, August 1).

What is more troubling, however, is the degree to which the new law is being speciously blamed for the trouble pubs and massage and mahjong parlours say they are in – that they are on the verge of closing as a result of the smoking ban.

More likely, these businesses were teetering on the edge of profitability to begin with.

Publicans in just about every jurisdiction around the world that has enacted a similar ban, including those with storied drinking cultures such as Ireland and Australia, actually saw business improve once the air was cleared in their venues.

That is because the handful of smokers who stopped going out when they could no longer light up were replaced by many more non-smokers who had been forced to stay away from the toxic air.

I suspect we would have seen a similar transition here, had Hong Kong enacted its anti-smoking laws with a less protracted timetable.

The local economy of 18 months ago was a lot healthier.

Therein lies a valuable lesson to be learned by lawmakers and those who persist in postponing social progress.

Gary Brand, Mid-Levels

Mahjong halls flouting ban

SCMP

Out of the five mahjong parlours that I play at in Sham Shui Po, all but one is still full of smokers ruining my lungs and my clothes with cigarette smoke.

Staff continue to give out free cigarettes and even help players light them. I have complained to the Tobacco Control Office, but the problem is still there, a month after the smoking ban began.

I have personally given up on the office because it does not have enough enforcement officers to effectively implement the law.

Instead, I hope that the Television and Entertainment Licensing Authority (Tela) can help out. The Tela commissioner is empowered under the Gambling Ordinance to cancel any mahjong parlour licence anytime “he considers that the public interest so requires”.

It appears to me that where a mahjong parlour wilfully turns a blind eye or actively assists in behaviour that contravenes a law within its premises, the commissioner is entitled to cancel that establishment’s licence in the public interest.

I hope the commissioner acts on complaints against mahjong parlours that participate in or ignore such activities within their premises.

William Yip, Sham Shui Po