Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

EFTA rules on display ban

http://www.eftacourt.int/images/uploads/16_10_PR_EN.pdf

12 Sep 2011. In the case Philip Morris Norway versus the Norwegian State, the European Free Trade Association (EFTA) today ruled that tobacco display bans are a suitable measure for protecting public health.
In its judgement today, the EFTA Court ruled that the display ban, which “by its nature” would reduce the consumption of tobacco in Norway, clearly reflects health concerns recognised by Article13 EEA. “Accordingly, in the absence of convincing proof to the contrary, a measure of this kind may be considered suitable for the protection of public health,” states EFTA in its ruling.

The EFTA Court did agree with Philip Morris Norway who argued that the display ban in shops entails an unlawful restriction contrary to Article 11 of the Agreement on the European Economic Area as it hinders the free movement of goods.

However, the court said it will be up to the national courts to determine that their objective to protect public health could not be achieved by less extensive prohibitions or restrictions. “The review of proportionality [between Article 11 and 13] and of the effectiveness of the measures taken relies on findings of fact which the referring court is in a better position to make than the EFTA Court”.

Today’s ruling ends one of the first legal challenges brought against a display ban of cigarettes. Although EFTA, which consists of Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland, doesn’t have juridical powers over EU policy, the outcome is expected to indirectly influence the ongoing reform of the EU tobacco products directive.

After a display ban took effect in Norway in January 2010, Philip Morris Norway filed a lawsuit against the Norwegian state (represented by the Ministry of Health and Care Services) before the Oslo District Court, which requested an Advisory Opinion from the EFTA Court in October 2010. (ci)

New Law Lets Landlords Ban Smoking

http://manhattanbeach.patch.com/articles/new-law-lets-landlords-ban-smoking-3

Gov. Jerry Brown signs Senate Bill 332, which allows landlords to prohibit smoking in rental units.

By Meredith Skrzypczak

California renters might soon face new smoking rules after Gov. Jerry Brown Wednesday signed a bill that would allow landlords to ban smoking in apartments and other rental units.

The law goes into effect on Jan. 1, 2012.

“With the Governor’s action today, we will see the availability of smoke-free, multi-family housing grow throughout California,” said state Sen. Alex Padilla, D-Pacoima, who authored the measure, in a statement Wednesday. “While more than 86 percent of Californians do not smoke, there is currently very little smoke-free housing in California. Living in multi-family housing should not compromise the health of renters or their children. This new law will provide tenants with healthier choices.”

While landlords can restrict pets, noise and specific furniture, such as waterbeds, there is nothing in current law that allows a landlord to restrict smoking

Smoke and mirrors: how the tobacco industry hides behind lobbyists

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/smoke-and-mirrors-how-the-tobacco-industry-hides-behind-lobbyists-2348402.html

The tobacco industry is covertly using third-party companies to lobby against smoking restrictions and to gain access to health documents held by public organisations.

Public relations companies and law firms are working on behalf of anonymous multinational tobacco companies without declaring who their clients are, according to an investigation by The Independent.

The third parties have refused to confirm they are working on behalf of tobacco firms when they make freedom of information requests from universities and other public bodies, even though the third parties are demanding more openness from their targets.

The public relations company Bell Pottinger and the London law firm Clifford Chance have both requested information from public organisations without making it clear they are working on behalf of tobacco firms.

The Irish PR company Hume Brophy has also carried out a lobbying campaign against the Government’s ban on cigarette displays in shops on behalf of the National Federation of Retail Newsagents without stating that the campaign was being funded by the tobacco industry.

The Independent has established that Alex Deane, a former chief-of-staff to David Cameron, played a key role in attempts to use the freedom of information law against one public organisation involved in promoting awareness against the health dangers of roll-up tobacco. Mr Deane is a director of Bell Pottinger which earlier this year requested documents from a health-awareness organisation funded by the NHS, the Bristol-based Smoke Free South West, following a campaign it ran against roll-up tobacco, which is popular in that part of the country.

Soon after this informal request, Smoke Free South West received a formal freedom of information request for the same documentation from Big Brother Watch, a right-of-centre libertarian group founded by Mr Deane.

Neither Bell Pottinger nor Big Brother Watch declared to Smoke Free South West that they had held discussions with one another or with Bristol-based Imperial Tobacco, which is listed as one of Bell Pottinger’s clients in the PR firm’s website, and makes Golden Virginia rolling tobacco and Rizla cigarette papers.

Mr Deane was not available for comment yesterday; Bell Pottinger said he was on holiday. David Petrie, the Bell Pottinger executive who sent the email requests to Smoke Free South West, did not return calls. Daniel Hamilton, a director of Big Brother Watch, refused to confirm or deny that his organisation had been in contact with Bell Pottinger or Imperial Tobacco over the FOI request to Smoke Free South West. “We don’t work on behalf of other groups. We only work on behalf of ourselves… We’ve got no formal links with anyone in the tobacco industry,” Mr Hamilton said.

This week, The Independent revealed that tobacco companies had demanded access to confidential university research papers on teenagers’ attitudes to smoking, as well as meetings within the Department of Health between government officials and experts on smoking and health.

Stirling University, which carries out research on behalf of the Health Department and Cancer Research UK, said Philip Morris, the makers of Marlboro cigarettes, was attempting to access thousands of confidential interviews with British teenagers.

The FOI request was initially made in 2009 through the London law firm Clifford Chance, which tried to keep the identify of its client confidential. However, under the Scottish Freedom of Information Act, which is slightly different to the English Act, a third party must name the client it is working for – in this case Philip Morris.

A spokeswoman for Clifford Chance said she could not comment on whether the law firm was carrying out any further freedom of information requests on behalf of tobacco companies. Under the English FOI Act, third parties can work on behalf of anonymous clients.

Hume Brophy, the Irish public relations company, admitted it was a mistake to conduct a parliamentary lobbying campaign against cigarette displays in shops without making it clear it was paid for by the tobacco industry. In a letter to Stephen Williams MP, John Hume, a partner in the company, said that it will not happen again.

Martin Dockrell of the campaign group Action on Smoking and Health said that the tobacco industry’s use of “front” organisations was nothing new.

“Big Tobacco’s dirty little secret is how they get others to do their dirty work,” Mr Dockrell said. “Some front groups are pretty much wholly owned subsidiaries; some appear to be independent but tobacco companies pay the bills and pull the strings.”

Former Cameron crony leading the fight for the smoking lobby

Profile

Alex Deane served as David Cameron’s chief of staff when Cameron was shadow education secretary from 2004-2005. A Tory activist since 1995, Mr Deane is now a director of Bell Pottinger, the public relations firm set up by Lord Bell, the Tory peer. He was a founding director of Big Brother Watch, a right-of-centre libertarian pressure group that opposes state-controlled surveillance and what it sees as intrusions into civil liberties. He has opposed CCTV cameras, DNA databases, council surveillance and data chips in dustbins. Big Brother Watch also stoutly defends the rights of smokers to smoke in public places.

Turkey Working on Cigarette Branding Ban Law, Milliyet Says – Bloomberg

The Domino increases – Black Box packaging
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-09-07/turkey-working-on-cigarette-brandin
g-ban-law-milliyet-says.html

Turkey Working on Cigarette Branding Ban Law, Milliyet Says
By Benjamin Harvey – Sep 7, 2011 4:45 PM GMT+0800 .
Turkey is working on new regulations that would ban brand names, logos and
designs on cigarette packaging and replace them with numbered black boxes,
Milliyet reported, without saying where it got the information.
The regulations would ban any imagery or text other than health warnings and
aims to reduce cigarette usage, the Istanbul-based newspaper said. Smokers
would be required to order cigarettes by number, it said.
Health Minister Recep Akdag has asked officials from the World Health
Organization and Turkey’s Tobacco and Alcohol Markets Regulation Board, or
TAPDK, to coordinate on beginning technical studies toward implementing the
new regulations, Milliyet said.
To contact the reporter on this story: Benjamin Harvey in Istanbul at
bharvey11@bloomberg.net

What the paper said: Smoking ban in Tassie; New bar culture for Perth;

http://www.hospitalitymagazine.com.au/article/What-the-paper-said-Smoking-ban-in-Tassie-New-bar-culture-for-Perth/531158.aspx

TasPorts in firing line over smoking

Tasports should ban smoking in alfresco dining areas in its jurisdiction, a leading public health specialist says. Heart Foundation president Peter Sexton yesterday called on TasPorts to help support efforts to reduce the high rate of tobacco smoking in Tasmania. “TasPorts had an ideal opportunity to use the powers available under section 67B of the Public Health Act 1997, to support the Hobart City Council indesignating alfresco entertainment areas smoke-free,” Dr Sexton said. The Hobart City Council has banned smoking in outdoor dining areas at restaurants, cafes and pubs in Salamanca and pockets of North Hobart and South Hobart. Since the smoking ban came into place on August 1 there has been confusion over how the rules apply, with smoking still allowed in areas of Elizabeth St Pier, Murray St Pier and Victoria and Constitution docks, which come under the jurisdiction of TasPorts. Dr Sexton said smoking rates in Tasmania were significantly higher than in mainland states. About 23 per cent of Tasmanian adults are either daily or occasional smokers, compared with about 19 per cent nationally. Hobart Mercury, August 15.

North Sydney Council bans smoking

http://mosman-daily.whereilive.com.au/news/story/north-sydney-council-bans-smoking/

31 August 2011

NORTH SYDNEY: Smoking will be banned in several public places within the North Sydney Council’s area from October 1 this year. A smoking policy forbidding smoking in outdoor dining areas on public land, covered bus shelters and taxi ranks as well as within 10m of children’s playgrounds and sporting fieldswhen sports are played was approved by North Sydney councillors on Monday.

The council will lobby the state government to introduce a blanket-ban on smoking in public spaces across NSW.

The smoking-ban policy was on public exhibition recently and attracted a 140-signature petition in favour, 30 written submissions in favour and six against, and a video submission via YouTube called Hands Up for a Smoke Free North Sydney.

Of the 583 participants in an online survey, about 92 per cent agreed with the ban.

Cr Veronique Marchandeau’s original motion put up in February this year asked for the council to forbid smoking at all council-controlled lands including public footpaths.

On Monday night, Cr Andrew Robjohns asked the council to consider banning smoking in all parks.

But they opted to look at widening the ban after the policy had been implemented.

Smoking in a prohibited area could attract a $110 fine.

Half of all NSW councils ban smoking in some council-owned or controlled areas.

Laws Banning Smoking in Vehicles Carrying Children – International Overview

Canadian Cancer Society

August 30, 2011

Summary: Laws prohibiting smoking in vehicles carrying children have been adopted in 9 Canadian provinces/territories (British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Ontario, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Labrador, and the Yukon Territory); 8 Canadian municipalities – Wolfville (Nova Scotia), Surrey (British Columbia), White Rock (B.C.), Richmond (B.C.), Okotoks (Alberta), Athabasca (Alberta), Leduc (Alberta), Medicine Hat (Alberta); 6 Australian states – South Australia, Tasmania, New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia; 4 U.S. states – California, Maine, Arkansas, and Louisiana; 10 U.S. municipalities – Bangor (Maine), Keyport (New Jersey), West Long Branch Borough (New Jersey), Rockland County (New York), Monroe County (Indiana), Rohnert Park (California), Martinez (California), Hawaii county (Hawaii), as well as South Africa, Mauritius, Bahrain, and Puerto Rico.  It may be that other jurisdictions have also adopted laws.

Listed below are the jurisdictions, the applicable age, the date of coming into force.  Applicable age refers to under the age, thus “19” (for example) means that smoking is prohibited in a vehicle carrying someone under age 19.


Countries

1. Mauritius (18+ [i], Mar. 1, 2009)

2. South Africa (12, Aug. 21, 2009)

3. Bahrain 2

Canadian provinces/territories (9 of 13)

1. Nova Scotia (19, Apr. 1, 2008)

2. Yukon Territory (18, May 15, 2008)

3. Ontario (16, Jan. 21, 2009)

4. British Columbia (16, Apr. 7, 2009)

5. New Brunswick (16,   Jan. 1, 2010)

6. Prince Edward Island (19, Sept. 15, 2009)

7. Manitoba (16, July 15, 2010)

8. Saskatchewan (16, Oct. 1, 2010)

9. Newfoundland and Labrador (16, July 1, 2011)

Canadian municipalities (8)

1. Wolfville, Nova Scotia (19, June 1, 2008)

2. Surrey, British Columbia (19, July 31, 2008)

3. Okotoks, Alberta (16, Sept. 1, 2008)

4. White Rock, British Columbia (16, Nov. 1, 2008)

5. Richmond, British Columbia           (19, Nov. 30, 2008)

6. Athabasca, Alberta (18, Mar. 22, 2011)

7. Leduc, Alberta (18, July 2, 2011)

8. Medicine Hat, Alberta (16, Sept. 1, 2011)

Australian states and territories (6 of 8)

1. South Australia (16, May 31, 2007)

2. Tasmania (18, Jan. 1, 2008)

3. New South Wales (16, July 1, 2009)

4. Victoria (18, Jan. 1, 2010)

5. Queensland (16, Jan. 1, 2010)

6. Western Australia (17, Sept. 23, 2010)

U.S. states (4 of 50)

1. Arkansas (if car seat required,3 July 21, 2006)

2. Louisiana (13,4 Aug. 15, 2006)

3. California (18, Jan. 1, 2008)

4. Maine (16, Sept. 1, 2008)

U.S. municipalities (9)

1. Bangor, Maine (18, Jan. 18, 2007)

2. Keyport, New Jersey (18, Apr. 26, 2007)

3. Rockland County, N.Y.  (18, June 21, 2007)

4. West Long Branch Borough, NJ (18, June 9, 2007)

5. Loma Linda, CA (18, July 24, 2008)

6. Monroe County, Indiana (13, April 8, 2009)

7. Rohnert Park, CA (18, May 28, 2009)

8. Martinez, CA (18, June 5, 2009)

9. Hawaii County, Hawaii (18, Aug. 8, 2010)

10. Carpenteria, CA (18, May 16, 2011)

Other

1. Puerto Rico (13, Mar. 2, 2007)

(US Commonwealth in Caribbean)

DOWNLOAD PDF : INTERNATIONAL OVERVIEW international overview-2011-08-30-vehicles with kids



Tourists don’t get smoking message

South China Morning Post – 29 August 2011

Of all the statistics that should make us feel good, those showing that Hong Kong’s smoking rate has fallen to the lowest-ever level are the ones most likely to put an extra spring in our step. The Census and Statistics Department’s latest figures reveal that 11.1 per cent of people aged 15 and over and 19.9 per cent of men smoke, among the lowest levels for developed economies. Better still, the rates are for last year and do not take into account trends since an additional 41.5 per cent tax was imposed on tobacco products in February. Progress is clearly being made.

Smoking, despite the serious impact it has on health, is not the easiest habit to kick. Left to our own devices, rates here would in all likelihood be nearer those on the mainland, where six in 10 people smoke. A number of government anti-smoking policies over the years, starting with tax increases, advertising bans, health warnings on packets and expanded to banning smoking in indoor public areas, are largely what it has taken to make smokers quit. Such measures are necessary as smoking and second-hand smoke are bad for health. Our next target has to be a single-digit figure.

Efforts are also needed on the mainland. There are anti-smoking laws there, but they are so poorly followed and enforced that it is near impossible to avoid clouds of second-hand smoke. With 60,000 mainlanders crossing the border each day to visit Hong Kong, what is working so well here is increasingly being strained. As our rules do not apply to outdoor areas, busy shopping districts at street level often are shrouded in cigarette smoke.

That sends the wrong message to our children and is dangerous to health. While our laws will go some way to educating visitors, they are not going to have an immediate impact. The next stage of the government’s campaign will be television advertisements focusing on blunt messages. That is a worthy strategy, but widening it to places frequented by tourists would make it considerably stronger.

ACT to ban smoking in cars with kids

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-08-25/act-car-smoking-ban/2854914 Australia

The ACT Government is moving to ban people from smoking in cars when children are passengers.

It will introduce legislation into the Legislative Assembly today that will allow police to issue a $250 on-the-spot fine to adults caught smoking in cars with children around.

The penalty will be separate to other traffic infringements, so people cannot lose their licence if they fail to pay the fine.

Most other Australian jurisdictions have similar laws.

Chief Minister Katy Gallagher says it will send a clear message that smoking is a danger to children’s health.

“This is about behaviour change, it’s not about wanting to see people get caught under this legislation,” she said.

“We’re also going to delay the commencement of it once it passes the Assembly, for six months, to make sure that we’ve got time to educate drivers about the new offence.

Ms Gallagher says police initially expressed some concerns about enforcing public health laws, but that has been worked through.

“I don’t think it was feasible either to have public health officials out pulling people over in cars because they don’t have the powers to do that either,” she said.

“We’ve reached a healthy compromise and we don’t expect there will be additional cost because we don’t expect that police will pursue people just for smoking.”

Anti-smoking lobby groups have praised the proposed changes.

Quit executive director Fiona Sharkie says tobacco smoke poses an enormous health risk to children.

“The dangers of second hand smoke are well documented and the harms that second hand smoking or smoking near children at all, are really devastating,” she said.

“In a confined area like a car it’s really important people are not smoking around anyone in the car, but particularly young children.

“It’s an enormous health risk particularly in respiratory illnesses and also can be with glue ear. We’re talking about young babies and the high rates of SIDS from smoking households.”

Topics: smoking, states-and-territories, canberra-2600, act

Australia Poised to Ban Tobacco Package Logos – Bloomberg

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-08-24/australia-s-lower-house-passes-plai
n-tobacco-packaging-laws.html

Australia Poised to Ban Tobacco Package Logos
By Gemma Daley and Joe Schneider – Aug 25, 2011 10:54 AM GMT+0800 .
…Australia is poised to become the first nation to require tobacco
products to be sold in plain packages, a move that could see other countries
follow suit and crimp earnings of companies like British American Tobacco
Plc.

The laws, passed by the lower house yesterday and due in the Senate in
September, will ban logos and color variations on cigarette packages.
Packets will have to be olive green and carry health warnings within six
months from Jan 1, 2012.

“Other countries will follow,” said Anne Jackson, chief executive of Ash
Australia, a non-profit lobby group funded by Cancer Council Australia and
the Heart Foundation. “This is a light shining the way for others to do the
same and many countries are already considering it.”

Health Minister Nicola Roxon announced the move last April, along with a 25
percent tobacco tax increase and a A$85 million (A$89 million) advertising
campaign to combat smoking, which the government says kills 15,000
Australians each year. Companies have since introduced their own advertising
campaigns and legal actions against the move.

British American Tobacco Plc (BATS) this week lost an appeal for the release
of Australian government documents the company said would help it fight the
law. The company plans to ask the Australian High Court to review the
ruling.

The company will next take its case to the Parliamentary Legal and
Constitutional Affairs Committee, with a hearing scheduled for Sept. 13,
Scott McIntyre, a spokesman for the tobacco company, said today in a phone
interview. So far the focus has been on the health aspect of the
legislation, he said.

Legal Implications
“There are a lot of issues outside of health that have to be looked at,”
McIntyre said. “There are serious repercussions here. The tobacco company
will pursue the case in courts, seeking billions of dollars in damages, if
the law is enacted.”

Smoking costs Australia about A$31 billion per year in health and workplace
costs, according to the government. With 15.1 percent of the population aged
14 or over smoking daily, it is the country’s top drug and preventable
health issue, the government says.

“There isn’t any safe amount of tobacco you can smoke,” Roxon told Channel
Ten television today. “It will kill you eventually and we obviously want to
make sure the message is loud and clear.”

The tobacco companies say the bill is a breach of the Australian
Constitution, as plain packaging exceeds the Commonwealth’s acquisition
powers. They said they would seek damages for losing the right to use their
trademarks, which they claim the government is seizing, illegally.

Brand Identification Questions
“This would clearly undermine the value of manufacturers’ trademarks and
destroy the goodwill built up over many years in consumer brands,” British
American Tobacco said in a June 6 submission to the government. “Plain
packaging will frustrate brand identification and consumer choice, making
smuggled branded product more acceptable to consumers.”

Australia’s top court has never addressed the question of whether banning
the use of trademarks amounts to an acquisition by the government, George
Williams, a constitutional law professor at the University of New South
Wales in Sydney, said.

“The tobacco companies have a hard road ahead,” Williams said. “They’re
quite likely to lose.”

Philip Morris International Inc. (PM), the world’s biggest publicly traded
tobacco company, said the Australian law also violates a 1994 treaty with
Hong Kong that prohibits the forced removal of trademarks.

Legal Strategies Considered
“It is disappointing that the House of Representatives has approved plain
packaging even though the Government admits there is no evidence that the
policy will be effective at reducing smoking,” Philip Morris said in a
statement today in response to the passage in the lower house.

The tobacco companies plan to argue the law is a breach of the World Trade
Organization’s Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, or
TRIPS.

According to TRIPS, the use of a trade mark in the course of trade “shall
not be unjustifiably encumbered by special requirements.” The tobacco
companies say the Australian law breaches that article.

“As a result of the Government’s actions, Philip Morris has little option
but to pursue our claim for substantial compensation through international
arbitration against Australia and to also consider legal claims under
domestic Australian law,” Philip Morris said.

To contact the reporter on this story: Gemma Daley in Canberra at
gdaley@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Peter Hirschberg at
phirschberg@bloomberg.net