Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Is condo developer’s quest for green building certification behind balcony smoking clampdown?

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/health/condo+developer+quest+green+building+certification+behind/6867978/story.html

A ban on smoking near operable windows means residents in a 125-unit building at 200 Lett St. would not be able to light up on their balconies. But resident Scott Sigurdson says the message, posted near the elevators on the parking garage’s first level, is vague enough to make him wonder how many others who live there have caught on.

A ban on smoking near operable windows means residents in a 125-unit building at 200 Lett St. would not be able to light up on their balconies. But resident Scott Sigurdson says the message, posted near the elevators on the parking garage’s first level, is vague enough to make him wonder how many others who live there have caught on.

Photograph by: Pat McGrath , The Ottawa Citizen

OTTAWA — Residents at a LeBreton Flats condominium building should be asking questions about a lone sign that went up sometime in the past couple of weeks in their parking garage.

It says smoking is forbidden “in common areas or within 25 feet of main entrances, exits or operable windows.”

A ban on smoking near operable windows means residents in the 125-unit building at 200 Lett St. would not be able to light up on their balconies. But resident Scott Sigurdson says the message, posted near the elevators on the parking garage’s first level, is vague enough to make him wonder how many others who live there have caught on.

It also isn’t clear who is behind the sign or whether it has any legal bite. Perhaps that might be the reason no one is swinging a heavy hammer to try to enforce the rule. Sigurdson, furious at the idea, figures whoever is behind it may just be waiting to see how residents react before going any further.

Is Claridge Homes, the building’s developer, trying to stop balcony smoking? Can it?

The company transferred ownership of the building to the condominium corporation about two years ago. Claridge refuses to talk, though it is believed the company is seeking a “green” designation for the building in order to bolster its environmentally-friendly portfolio. A smoking ban could help it in its goal.

What about the condo corporation’s board of directors? It asked the board’s safety and security committee last winter to consider a recommendation to disallow balcony smoking, but was rebuffed.

Dave Rushton, board vice president, says he has “second-hand” information that Claridge work crews put up the sign. He also says the board is in the process of coming up with a no-smoking rule for common areas but is not considering one for balconies and patios, at least for now. Ontario law already forbids smoking in common areas of residential buildings, such as foyers, meeting rooms and parking garages — so why bother?

Sigurdson says the building’s superintendent, whose office is beside the elevators, told him he saw Claridge workers install the sign. Yet Claridge vice president Neil Malhotra refuses to comment “as this matter appears to be a dispute among condo owners.”

Sigurdson is not a smoker, but he is mighty miffed, especially as the condo wasn’t advertised as a “non-smoking building” when he bought his unit two years ago. Rushton says the condo board cannot stop smokers from lighting up in their units. But he believes it does have that right for balconies and patios.

Rushton says condo balconies and patios in his building are considered “common areas” and belong to the condominium corporation, which is responsible for maintenance and repairs. However, they are for the “exclusive use” of the owners in the adjoining units. The condo board decides what activities are permitted on them, such as barbecuing and smoking.

Sigurdson, however, is drafting a letter that he plans to “slip under” every door in the building, detailing the negative implications of such a ban.

He says he has plans to sell his condo in a couple of years and believes the value of the unit would drop because a ban would “reduce the pool of potential purchasers.”

He also says the balcony is convenient for friends who smoke. He doesn’t want them puffing away in his unit. But he doesn’t want them to have to “walk across the street” to smoke, either.

What’s the big deal about smoking on a balcony, he asks, as it doesn’t hurt anyone except the smoker?

“The occasional whiff of cigarette smoke that one might get from another balcony might be annoying, but to say it’s a health hazard is a little ridiculous, especially when they allow barbecues on balconies that billow smoke and make adjacent balconies uninhabitable for the duration of the cooking.”

Sigurdson figures “there are a few forces at work here.” But, he says, he’ll take them on, whether it’s Claridge, the board or both.

He says he immediately suspected the board of directors because he was a member of the board’s safety and security committee when it was asked to look into a balcony smoking ban. He says some of the five members on the board still want one.

Said Sigurdson in an email to the board on June 21: “You have no mandate to impose such restrictions on the owners of (200 Lett). I suggest you get one before attempting to impose your values on others. … (T)his would require a referendum of all the owners. I will not respect anything else. Attempt to impose this on me and you’ll have to take me to court.”

Rushton replied on June 24. He explained the sign was posted by Claridge because it is seeking LEED certification for the condo building. LEED stands for Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design and uses its trademark Green Building Rating System, which measures building performance in several areas that affect human and environmental health. Credits are given based on site development, location to surrounding communities, water efficiency, energy efficiency, building materials, durability and indoor environmental quality. The latter is where balcony smoking comes in.

Depending on the number of credits earned, buildings earn a rating of certified, gold, silver or the highest ranking, platinum.

Rushton says the board is trying to determine the scope of the smoking ban posted by Claridge, and whether it is binding.

But, he says, it appears that LEED rules are not explicit enough on smoking bans. So with or without a LEED designation, he says the posted sign may mean nothing, and the decision to ban smoking on balconies would still rest with the board.

“We haven’t made a decision,” says Rushton. “But the discussion has been and the tendency has been that we would probably not say ‘no smoking’ (on patios and balconies.) I say ‘probably’ because it’s not a formal decision yet.”

Is something bothering you? Please contact thepubliccitizen@ottawacitizen.com

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen

Read more: http://www.ottawacitizen.com/health/condo+developer+quest+green+building+certification+behind+balcony+smoking+clampdown/6867978/story.html#ixzz1zMZQIbfy

Smoking ban, five years on: the Inn crowd’s view

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2012/jun/29/smoking-ban-manchester-pub-opinion

Has the ban ruined pubs? And has it helped people to cut down? Regulars at the Union Inn in Levenshulme have their say

Helen Carter

guardian.co.uk, Friday 29 June 2012 22.09 BST

The smoking ban was introduced in July 2007. Photograph: Roy Riley/Alamy

At the Union Inn in Levenshulme, Manchester, the smoking ban was brought in amid a lot of opposition from regulars. Now under new management, the pub, on the main road between Stockport and Manchester, has survived the cull that has seen at least five of its competitors close since the smoking ban was introduced. It was bustling on a muggy Mancunian Friday afternoon.

Graeme Jackson, 57, has been drinking at the pub on and off for 40 years. “There’ll be nothing left for the working classes with the smoking ban. Going to the pub’s an expensive hobby now. People can’t afford it anymore,” he says nursing a pint in one hand and an unlit cigarette the other.

His friend John Cherry, 50, also holding an unlit roll-up and a pint says: “It’s not the smoking ban that’s ruined pubs, it’s the recession. I’m a heavy smoker and I think the smoking ban is the best thing that’s ever happened.

“It makes it more difficult for me to smoke,” he said.

Terry Henry, 72, remembers the days when there were snugs for women drinkers, best rooms and smoking rooms in pubs. “All the men supped together and all the women were in the other room. I can’t see why they can’t have smoking rooms.”

Frank Bamber, 85, a smoker for over 70 years, thinks the smoking ban is a nonsense. “I’ve smoked for 71 years and if it’s going do me any harm, it’s already done,” he says.

“I don’t like that we’ve got to go out there to have a smoke because these people in government say so. They have subsidised prices in the House of Commons bar and need to get their own house in order before taking it out on us.” He nips out of the pub to the back yard. “Sorry, love,” he adds. “I’ve got to go for a smoke.”

Smoking ban’s impact five years on

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-18628811

A smoker lighting up while drinking a pint

It’s been five years since smokers could light up in a pub anywhere in the UK

Continue reading the main story

Related Stories

The sight of employees smoking outdoors in all weathers is now commonplace. Smoking areas in bars, pubs, restaurants and hotels are long gone.

It is five years since England became the last part of the UK to introduce legislation banning smoking in workplaces and enclosed public spaces.

The aim was to reduce passive smoking, or exposure to secondhand smoke, which is known to be harmful.

Scotland was the first country in the UK to introduce a smokefree law in March 2006.

England’s smokefree laws came into force on 1 July 2007, with Northern Ireland on 30 April 2007 and Wales on 2 April 2007.

So what has been the impact of the legislation on our health?

‘Hugely beneficial’

Amanda Sandford, research manager from Action on Smoking and Health (Ash) says it was long overdue.

“When it started people wondered why we’d waited so long to do it. Non-smokers always found it unpleasant breathing in other people’s smoke.

Continue reading the main story

“Start Quote

Thanks to the ban many smokers are smoking and drinking at home – who can blame them when the alternative is standing outside in the wind and rain?”

End Quote Simon Clark Forest

“It is one of the most important public health acts in the last century. There’s no question it’s been hugely beneficial.”

The ban was popular with British adults when it was implemented – and a recent poll of more than 12,000 people found that 78% of adults still support it.

A review of the evidence on the impact of the law in England, was commissioned by the government and carried out by Prof Linda Bauld from the University of Stirling and the UK Centre for Tobacco Control Studies.

Prof Bauld’s report concluded: “The law has had a significant impact.”

“Results show benefits for health, changes in attitudes and behaviour and no clear adverse impact on the hospitality industry.”

A study of barworkers, using saliva, lung function and air quality tests, showed their respiratory health had greatly improved after the laws came in, thanks to the reduction in exposure to secondhand smoke.

Another study looking at children’s exposure to secondhand smoking in England, between 1996 and 2007, found that their exposure levels had declined by nearly 70%.

Home risks

Although this study only covered a few months beyond the introduction of the smokefree laws, Prof Bauld says children’s exposure continues to decline.

Opponents of the legislation feared that it would push adults to smoke more at home, and therefore put children at greater risk of secondhand smoke.

Continue reading the main story

DAMAGE CAUSED BY SMOKING

  • Smokers in their 30s and 40s are five times more likely to have a heart attack than non-smokers
  • Smoking contributes to coronary artery disease which increases the risk of a heart attack or stroke
  • It does huge damage to the lungs and massively increases the risk of lung cancer
  • Smoking also increases the risk of other cancers such as oral, uterine, liver, kidney, bladder, stomach and cervical cancer
  • Exposure to secondhand smoke can reduce lung function, exacerbate respiratory problems, trigger asthma attacks, reduce coronary blood flow, irritate eyes, and cause headaches and nausea
  • Smoking in pregnancy greatly increases the risk of miscarriage and is also associated with lower birth weight

But Scottish evidence suggests the reverse. A Glasgow University study showed a 15% reduction in the number of children with asthma being admitted to hospital in the three years after the ban came into force in Scotland.

Ms Sandford says smokers are now more aware about the dangers of secondhand smoke and are doing more to protect children at home.

Professor John Britton, chairman of the Royal College of Physicians’ tobacco advisory group, says the ban “has had a huge impact on quality of life particularly in people with cardiovascular disease”.

A Department of Health-funded study examining emergency admissions between July 2002 and September 2008 in England found a 2.4% reduction in admissions for heart attacks.

Breathing in secondhand smoke can increase the long-term risk, as well as the immediate risk of a heart attacks and angina, Prof Bauld says.

Research from Scotland reported a much larger 17% decrease in heart attack admissions in the year after its ban.

Another Glasgow study which looked at smoking and birth rates before and after the ban found a 10% drop in the country’s premature birth rate, which researchers linked to the smokefree laws.

Trigger to quit

But there is no evidence as yet that smokers have given up smoking in huge numbers because of the legislation.

While overall levels of smoking among adults in Great Britain remained constant at 21% between 2007 and 2009, the north east of England saw a different trend.

There, the smokefree ban proved to be a trigger for some adults to quit with the largest drop in smoking in England – from 29% in 2005 to 27% in 2007 and down to 21% by 2011.

Smokers’ groups say the ban has been a disaster for many pubs and clubs and the impact on many people’s social lives has been huge.

A total ban on smoking in cars and in public spaces where children are present has been suggested

Simon Clark, director of smokers’ lobby group Forest, said smokers were being forced to take their habit elsewhere.

“Thanks to the ban many smokers are smoking and drinking at home. Who can blame them when the alternative is standing outside in the wind and rain?”

Calling for a comprehensive review of the impact of the smoking ban, he said: “We want the government to amend the legislation to allow separate, well-ventilated smoking rooms in pubs and clubs. Few people would object to that because no-one would be exposed to other people’s smoke against their wishes.”

What next?

But others want to take smokefree laws further.

Graph of prevalence of smoking in Great Britain since the 1970s

The Royal College of Physicians supports a total ban on smoking in cars and would like to see the smokefree ban extended to anywhere where children are present.

“This includes parks, outside areas and cars. We would like to see tobacco imagery taken out of children’s lives altogether,” says Prof Britton.

A private member’s bill to ban smoking in cars when children are present has been debated in the Lords recently.

Ash also supports a ban on smoking in cars but recognises the difficulties of imposing it.

“Cars are not as straightforward as the workplace because they are a private space. It does raise ethical issues, but because they are a confined space the level of smoke is concentrated.”

Prof Bauld said: “In the next 20 years we should be able to halve smoking rates.”

But that would need the introduction of plain cigarette packaging, tougher legislation on sale displays in shops, high taxes on tobacco and a crackdown on illicit tobacco, she said.

“It’s children who start smoking, not adults. We need to prevent people starting in the first place, full stop.”

More on This Story

Related Stories

06 MARCH 2012, HEALTH

14 MARCH 2012, WALES

17 NOVEMBER 2011, HEALTH

25 MARCH 2011, SCOTLAND

09 JUNE 2010, HEALTH

06 MARCH 2012, HEALTH

Law should not punish landlords for illegal smoking in bars

SCMP letter from a part owner of the Railway tavern (smoking bar) in Tai Wai He ‘forgets’ the licensee should be on the premises when open

Jun 27, 2012

Allan Dyer’s suggestion that bar owners should be held responsible for illegal smoking in their premises is too extreme and would be totally unjust (“Smoking bans are not enforced”, June 20).

Provided that a bar licensee and staff have advised customers that it is against the law to smoke inside their premises, they have adequately fulfilled both their legal and social obligations.

Just as Mr Dyer admits in his letter, determined smokers often turn abusive and violent when challenged for ignoring this ban.

Bar workers are neither policemen nor tobacco control officers.

It is unfair to suggest that these lower-paid employees should also take on the role of law enforcers.

Likewise, it is unjust for the licensee to be held accountable for breaches of this law within his premises, provided he has not actively encouraged this misbehaviour.

He cannot be in attendance 24/7. It would be far too extreme to threaten a bar owner with the loss of his investment, probable bankruptcy of his business and the consequential termination of employees’ contracts because some third party has chosen to break the law.

What precisely is Mr Dyer expecting a barman to do when confronted by a customer who purchases a drink and then just lights up, ignoring the signs and advice that smoking in the premises is illegal? Is he supposed to leave the bar service area unattended, ignore his other duties and involve himself in a possible fight with the offender? And why pick only on small-business bar owners Mr Dyer? That’s another injustice in itself.

Why not take your suggestion to its logical conclusion and make the directors of major property companies responsible for the illegal smoking which goes on in the toilets of their malls and office blocks?

Next, Mr Dyer could have the directors of public and private hospitals struck off the Medical Council of Hong Kong’s doctors’ list because patients have been found smoking in fire exit staircases.

This is only a start. I could provide far more potential injustices if he persists.

No, Mr Dyer, illegal smoking is a criminal offence and dealing with it is the duty of policemen and other relevant law enforcement officers in accordance with priorities.

P. A. Crush, Sha Tin

Green light for smoking ban in cars carrying young children

SMOKING in cars carrying children as passengers will be banned under new laws being introduced by the Government.

Health Minister James Reilly is taking up the proposal as part of a wider effort to discourage people from smoking altogether.

However, the plans are at a very early stage and it is not yet known how the new law will be policed. There is no definite timescale for its introduction either.

A government spokesman also said last night he did not expect it would be a penalty points offence to be caught smoking in a car with a child present.

The initial idea came from Independent senator John Crown, who tabled a motion in the Seanad with fellow Independent Jillian van Turnhout and Fianna Fail‘s Mark Daly.

The senators initially planned that the ban would be enforced by gardai through fines that start low but rise for multiple offences, but the final system will be decided by the Government.

At its weekly meeting yesterday, the Cabinet agreed amendments to a private members’ motion on the issue in the Seanad.

Taoiseach Enda Kenny also confirmed in the Dail that the Cabinet had given the green light for the new laws to be drawn up.

Dr Reilly’s spokesman said Prof Crown should be credited for the idea, and said that the minister was more than happy to take it up and bring it into law.

“In its present form, the bill is deficient, so there are amendments that have to be made,” the spokesman said.

“It is not about restricting the rights of smokers, but it is about protecting the rights of children.”

Dr Reilly has also said he was examining banning smoking in parks and on beaches in a bid to discourage children from taking up the habit.

– Fiach Kelly Political Correspondent

Irish Independent

The best anti-smoking ad you’ll ever see – Hong Kong (and the world) should copy the idea using local child actors

As a rule, smokers don’t like to be lectured. So how do you create yet one more anti-smoking campaign that might actually make smokers think?

Use that perfect tool of manipulation: children. A fascinating ad from Ogilvy & Mather Bangkok failed to grab a prize at the Cannes advertising festival last week, though it did end up on the shortlist for the Promo & Activation category, and has caught some viral attention online.  Sadly the Thai Health Promotion Foundation chose an advertising agency that has and continues to earn money from Big Tobacco and the YouTube video was pulled after a brief appearance – but Clear the Air has it on our website. (you will need Real player to view the video]

In the video, cherub-faced kids walk up to smokers on the streets of Thailand holding cigarettes in their tiny fingers and asking for a light. The smokers refuse, explaining to the kids why smoking is bad for them. After listening patiently to each lecture, the child would hand the smoker a folded-up note and walk away.

“You worry about me. But why not about yourself?” the note read. It then gave the number of the Thai Health Promotion Foundation’s hotline to help smokers quit.

An extreme rarity for such street campaigns, most of the adults did not throw away the brochures they were handed.

According to the agency, phone calls from smokers went up 40 per cent in the wake of the campaign.

The vice-chairman of Ogilvy Group, Rory Sutherland, spoke publicly about the way consumers’ brains make decisions. One of the points he likes to make is that a message has a much higher chance of getting through if delivered in the proper context. In an interview last month, he described one of his favourite campaigns from the global network in the past year – and it demonstrated a similar contextual intervention that the Thai anti-smoking campaign does.

“One of the first rules that you learn from brain science is that we make decisions contextually,” Mr. Sutherland said.

Op-Ed The best anti-smoking ad you’ll ever see

Smoking bans are not enforced

SCMP

I refer to the letter by Peter Wong Sze-chai (“Introduce tobacco-free HK in phases”, June 18).

It may have escaped his attention, but we already have piecemeal non-smoking areas, and designated areas for smokers, including a smoking ban in shopping malls, restaurants and bars, some public transport interchanges, and parks.

What is lacking is effective enforcement. Arrogant smokers flout the law and become abusive when asked to stop.

First, the Tobacco Control Office should start frequent, random undercover inspections of no-smoking zones, issuing fines to offenders.

Second, management companies and bar owners should be made responsible for illegal smoking on their premises.

Illegal smokers will soon show greater respect for the law when there is a high probability of being fined.

Allan Dyer, Wong Chuk Hang

Introduce tobacco-free HK in phases

In a world of growing complexities, arguments and counter-arguments, one can debate about a person’s right to smoke in public. There is overwhelming evidence of health hazards – heart attack, stroke, cancer, just to name a few – associated with direct smoking as well as passive, or second-hand, smoking.

Despite these harmful effects, society must also balance the interests of smokers, non-smokers and the tobacco industry. Smokers have the right to smoke as long as this does not impose a health risk to people around them. Tobacco companies have a duty to highlight the harmful effects of their products.

It is possible for the government to implement such a policy, in stages, starting perhaps in the tourist districts, or in piecemeal fashion. Special zones will need to be made available for smokers, with suitable law reinforcement outside these zones to safeguard the rights and health of others. This ban will send a clear message to both smokers and non-smokers about their rights and responsibilities. Having a tobacco-free city will raise Hong Kong’s status internationally about our health values and commitment.

Dr Peter Wong Sze-chai, Kowloon

News

Council fired up for 2013 smoking ban

‎

Illawarra Mercury – 20 hours ago

Wollongong councillors are hoping to start 2013 with a healthy New Year’s resolution – a ban on smoking in alfresco dining areas in Crown St …

Diesel fumes as bad as passive smoking

‎

The Canberra Times – 1 day ago

”It’s on the same order of magnitude as passive smoking,” said Kurt Straif, director of the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), …

Diesel exhaust fumes pose cancer risk just like passive smoking …‎ Rush Lane
Diesel fumes cause cancer: World Health Organization; ‘On the …‎ New York Daily News
Diesel fumes deemed as cancerous as asbestos and passive smoking‎ Scotsman
Business Standard– New Zealand Herald
all 440 news articles »

Councillors butt heads on smoking

‎

Northern Star – 9 hours ago

THE lack of proposed designated smoking areas in Lismore’s city centre is concerning business owners who employ smokers.

Smoke-free CBD policy‎ Northern Rivers Echo
all 2 news articles »

Smoke gets in your eyes

‎

Vancouver Sun – 12 hours ago

If there weren’t already compelling enough reasons for you to quit smoking, think about the risk.

Smoking can cause blindness‎ Sacramento Bee
all 8 news articles »

SUNY trustees seek smoking ban

‎

Newsday – 16 hours ago

State University of New York trustees want tobacco banned on all 64 campuses.

SUNY trustees approve ban on smoking‎ Albany Times Union
SUNY trustees request system-wide campus smoking ban‎WatertownDailyTimes.com
SUNY votes to ban smoking across college system‎ Hornell Evening Tribune
CBS Local– NY1
all 44 news articles »

More than 60% of Israel’s nonsmokers smoke passively, study finds

‎

Haaretz – 12 hours ago

While only about 20 percent of Israel’s adult population smokes cigarettes, passivesmokers are equally exposed to the risks of developing cancer, the study …

Detroit Medical Center will not hire smokers, plans to test applicants …

‎

Detroit Free Press – 16 hours ago

While several states have passed laws banning such hiring policies, Michigan has not, leaving smokers without legal grounds to challenge …

Detroit Medical Center will no longer hire smokers as of July 1‎ The Detroit News

Absurd smoking ban widely ignored

SCMO – Laisee

With the arrival of the hot weather and al fresco drinking and dining, the absurdity of the smoking laws is becoming increasingly obvious.

As we know, smoking is banned inside bars and restaurants, but the outside areas in some of these venues remain contentious.

If the area is covered only by a roof of some sort, typically a canvas canopy, then smoking is not banned. But if it is enclosed, say, at least 50 per cent of the total area on all sides, then smoking is prohibited.

The law is widely flouted. As anyone knows, there is not a great deal of difference between sitting inside or in the middle of an outside area under a canopy in which there can be anywhere from 20 to 50 people.

The law was designed to protect staff working at these establishments, but in its present cockeyed form, it doesn’t have much effect.

The Tobacco Control Office under the Department of Health takes several days to react to a complaint. The process is similar to that with the ineffective engine idling law.

That is why anti-smoking groups would like Hong Kong to make all public areas smoke-free, including outside areas where members of the public are served food and drinks, whether roofed or not.

They also want the landlords of these establishments to be responsible for banning smoking as they are in other parts of the world, such as Japan, Australia, the United States and Britain, among others. If one of them persists in allowing smoking, then he loses his liquor licence.

The present arrangements are akin to having a non-urinating section in a swimming pool