Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Europe

World’s third-largest tobacco producer quits cigarettes

As cigarettes face increasing regulation and a diminished customer base, under Lars Dahlgren’s leadership Swedish Match is looking ahead to a smoke-free tobacco industry

Based in Stockholm, Swedish Match is a company that makes snuff, chewing tobacco, cigars, matches and lighters. However, it is most famous for making snus – a unique Swedish variety of moist snuff, designed to be placed under the upper lip for long periods of time. The company is the third-largest producer of tobacco products in Europe, according to the 2015 Financial Times Global 500 list. The two other largest tobacco firms on the continent, by the same measurement, are British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco. Both of these are UK-based.

While the UK is not exactly known as a hotspot of tobacco use in Europe, historically it played a larger role in the development and growth of the tobacco industry, while Sweden – at least within popular perception – has played a much smaller role. It should be seen as no small feat, then, that this Swedish tobacco company has managed to secure itself so lofty a position. A large part of its success is due to the company’s forward-looking approach when it comes to selling tobacco. The firm itself no longer produces cigarettes, having divested from that particular product 11 years ago. Rather, Swedish Match has steered away from smoke-related tobacco products, focusing instead on the safer snus and chewing tobacco alternatives. This strategy has been followed under the overall direction of one man since 2008: CEO Lars Dahlgren.

Dahlgren and Swedish Match have recognised that smoking tobacco is on the way out. Fewer and fewer people want to enjoy nicotine through the traditional method of burning and inhaling tobacco smoke. However, the consumption and enjoyment of nicotine through other means is far from at a dead end. With the health threats of cigarettes universally known, consumers are looking for safer ways to get their fix – and removing the combustible element massively reduces the potential risks. The recent explosion in popularity of electronic vaporiser cigarettes attests to this. Swedish Match, under the leadership of Dahlgren, has accepted this trend and acted according.

Dahlgren’s strategy as CEO has not been to batten down the hatches and defend smoking from the ever-growing regulation of governments around the world, amid a general decline in use. Rather, he has taken the initiative to push Swedish Match to develop its focus away from conventional cigarettes.

Striking the match

Even before its divestment, Swedish Match was always more than just a cigarette producer. The company is over 100 years old; its origins lie in two firms founded in Sweden in the early 20th century, one producing tobacco products and the other matches and lighters. Svenska Tobaksmonopolet, founded in 1915, started to produce tobacco as a monopoly firm, while Svenska Tändsticks was founded in 1917 and produced matches. The two firms joined together in 1992, under the Procordia Group, before merging into the company that exists today – Swedish Match. As of 1996, Swedish Match has been listed on the Nasdaq Stockholm exchange. In 2015, it had total revenue of €1.5bn, and an operating income of over €425m.

With its nearly 5,000-strong workforce, Swedish Match sells its products worldwide, in more than 100 countries. The firm’s snus products have a majority market share in both Sweden and Norway, and its other products also enjoy market dominance further away from home. Swedish Match’s Redman chewing tobacco has a 40 percent market share in the US, while its cigar products hold almost 25 percent. Its matches and lighters are leaders in a wide range of markets, including the UK, various Scandinavian nations, France, Spain, Australia, Brazil, Russia and France.

Dahlgren himself has worked his way up since joining the company shortly after graduating, as an assistant controller. Now aged 46, Dahlgren climbed to the top through first reaching the position of CFO in Swedish Match’s Philippines office, before working for a few years in the firm’s group finance division. Finally, in 2004, he gained an executive role, serving as the head office’s CFO in Stockholm. Four years later, in 2008, he was appointed CEO. Dahlgren hopes to dispel the myth that tobacco companies are led by out-of-touch traditionalists, clinging to what is left of a declining and increasingly unfashionable market.

“I think many people perceive the tobacco industry as conservative and middle-aged”, he said in an interview with the Swedish Match website. “At Swedish Match, it is the complete opposite; we constantly strive to think in a youthful and innovative manner in everything we do.”

Adapt and improve

As the result of a merger between a firm producing lighters and matches, and another producing tobacco products, Swedish Match has a wider product base than most tobacco companies. At the same time, its production of the uniquely Swedish snus means its tobacco-producing arm is also more varied.

In a world of reduced smoking levels and increased tobacco control – with policies regulating and discouraging smoking from local government councils all the way up to national governments and beyond – Swedish Match’s diverse product base gives it an edge. Rather than fighting the tide of anti-smoking campaigns, it has even embraced it, seeing it as an opportunity to gain market share for its non-smoke tobacco products.

In 1996, when the company first became publically listed, its “smokeless tobacco business consisted of chewing tobacco and moist snuff in the US, and snus in Scandinavia”, said Dahlgren. Now, however, snus products have seen growing sales, particularly in the US. This has been part of a drive to focus on non-cigarette tobacco products. “Today, Swedish Match is truly a different company with a truly different vision.”

According to Dahlgren: “Swedish Match adapts and thrives.” And, in a world of smoking cessation, it is doing both. As he has noted: “In line with our strategic focus and vision, we are working diligently and enthusiastically to facilitate the trend and goal of a world without cigarettes.” And the adaptation seems to be working: snus products now account for more than 50 percent of Swedish Match’s operating profits.

Dahlgren said that now, “in line with our strategic focus and vision, we are working diligently and enthusiastically to facilitate the trend and goal of a world without cigarettes”. The company has taken clear steps towards this, gradually divesting from smoking products. It has already wound up its cigarette operations and, in January 2015, the company took the decision to reduce its shareholding in Scandinavian Tobacco Group, a cigar-producing firm. The company was founded in 2010, and Swedish Match previously owned 49 percent of it, which has now been cut to 31.2 percent.

Snus is, of course, still a tobacco product, meaning it still has some associated health risks. However, it remains much safer than cigarette smoking. In spite of this, many anti-smoking campaigns and local authorities have attempted to clamp down on non-smoking tobacco products. As Dahlgren has noted: “We face challenges through product taxation, regulation, and even the efforts of anti-tobacco organisations.” However, Swedish Match has taken steps to work towards remedying this through the relevant authorities. In the US, for instance, the firm has made an application to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for its snus products to be classified as a Modified Risk Tobacco Product, allowing them to potentially escape certain punitive anti-smoking regulations.

Across the Atlantic

This attempt at a US reclassification is also part of Dahlgren’s forward-looking strategy. The US is seen as a key market for Swedish Match to expand into with its snus products; already a key market for chewing tobacco, Swedish Match has identified it as having a strong potential to become a large destination for snus.

The US is one of the few places in the world where the use of chewing tobacco has gained widespread use and cultural status. However, Americans are increasingly turning away from the product; Swedish Match estimated that in 2014 the company had a 40 percent market share for chewing tobacco in the US, representing an eight percent decline from 2012. Likewise, 2015 saw further a decline in sales volumes. Although Swedish Match owns Red Man, the market-leading premium brand in the US, it recognises use of the product is in decline. For this reason, alongside the decline of smoking, Swedish Match is gearing a lot of its efforts towards expanding its snus market in the US.

Swedish Match’s various snus products saw good growth in the US market last year. “For snus and moist snuff in the US, the General snus brand had good growth in both consumption volumes and market share, and the overall snus market experienced more rapid growth”, said Dahlgren. Dahlgren put the increased popularity of the product down to “its taste, its quality, and its benefits versus smoking”.

While Swedish Match’s application for Modified Risk Tobacco Product status is still awaiting approval, Dahlgren appears confident that it will be achieved. “While we are still awaiting an FDA decision, we were very pleased to see that Swedish Match this past year was the first and so far only tobacco company to have received product approvals under the pre-market approval process of the FDA”, he said. With its pre-existing brand dominance and its acceptance of changing market conditions, Swedish Match is well positioned to grow its snus sales in the US market. It has recognised which tobacco products are on the decline, and has focused its energies accordingly, as well as working with regulators in order to ensure lighter regulation of its products.

New Lawsuit Risks for Philip Morris International Inc. as EU Anti-Smuggling Deal Expires

http://www.nwitimes.com/business/investment/markets-and-stocks/new-lawsuit-risks-for-philip-morris-international-inc-as-eu/article_ee55dad7-8e5f-5d1e-99d6-025b394384f7.html

The litigation risk of Philip Morris International (NYSE: PM) just rose exponentially as its decade-old agreement with the European Union to combat cigarette smuggling expires and the commission has opted to not extend it. With its cloak of legal protection now removed, investors ought to expect anti-smoking activists to launch lawsuits against the tobacco company for its alleged role in the illicit cigarette trade.

It’s been argued that as government taxation of tobacco products approached usurious levels, the tobacco companies sought to minimize the duties they had to pay by conspiring with smugglers who were often connected to organized crime to trade cigarettes on the black market.

Investigations purported to show that executives of Philip Morris, Reynolds-American (NYSE: RAI), British American Tobacco (NYSEMKT: BTI), and others were well aware of the nefarious connections their shady partners had, and with lawsuits piling up against them, they entered into an agreement with the EU to be shielded from liability for smuggling in exchange for making annual payments to the European Commission (EC) that would go to programs to combat cigarette smuggling.

The deal was signed on July 9, 2004 and would run for a period of 12 years. Similar agreements were subsequently signed with British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco (NASDAQOTH: ITYBY), and Japan Tobacco (NASDAQOTH: JAPAF), but lawsuits against Reynolds’ R.J. Reynolds division are still going on.

Philip Morris says the agreements are effective and noted that seizure of its own branded cigarettes has declined by 85% since 2006.

According to an annual survey conducted by accounting giant KPMG for the EC at the behest of the tobacco companies, illegal cigarettes accounted for 9.8% of all cigarettes consumed in the European Union in 2015, or 53 billion cigarettes, representing a loss in tax revenues of 11.3 billion euros. Yet most of the illegal cigarettes, or 88%, come from markets outside of the EU, with Belarus being the biggest source of the illicit trade. That, says the tobacco industry, highlights the effectiveness of the agreement it has had with the member states.

Philip Morris noted, “With or without (the agreement’s) renewal, PMI’s priority remains the measures contained within it. PMI’s ongoing commitment to continued efforts and investments around the world to tackle illicit trade remains intact and stronger than ever.”

Anti-smoking activists would beg to differ, saying the tobacco companies have gotten off cheap, paying almost $2 billion over the life span of the agreements, thus insulating themselves from lawsuits, which, if successful, would undoubtedly be a much larger cost.

Tobacco Company Payments Made Expiration Date
Philip Morris $1.2 billion over 12 years July 9, 2016
Japan Tobacco $400 million over 15 years Dec. 14, 2022
Imperial Tobacco $300 million over 20 years Sept. 27, 2030
British American Tobacco $200 million over 20 years July 15, 2030

Data source: Tobacco Control.

The activists are calling for immediate investigations of the tobacco companies following the expiration of their respective agreements. Because Philip Morris’ agreement is the first to expire, it is the one that will have the anti-smoking lobby’s guns trained on it.

While the member states of the EU were reportedly in favor of extending the agreements, no doubt enjoying the cash that flowed into their coffers from the tobacco companies, the commission said it was no longer necessary as strict new laws enacted this year that require tracing of tobacco sales while banning certain types of cigarettes made the agreements obsolete.

The industry had also angered the commission by suing to prevent the new laws from taking effect. Now Philip Morris, as the biggest and most visible symbol of that opposition, and no longer possessing its cloak of legal protection, could very soon see a wave of lawsuits wash over it.

A secret billion-dollar stock opportunity

The world’s biggest tech company forgot to show you something, but a few Wall Street analysts and the Fool didn’t miss a beat: There’s a small company that’s powering their brand-new gadgets and the coming revolution in technology. And we think its stock price has nearly unlimited room to run for early in-the-know investors! To be one of them, just click here.

Rich Duprey has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

EU ends anti-smuggling deal with tobacco firm PMI

https://euobserver.com/economic/134225

The European Union is ending the anti-smuggling agreement it has with tobacco multinational Philip Morris International (PMI), sources confirmed to EUobserver.

The European Commission has decided not to renew the deal after it expires on Saturday (9 July), effectively choosing to listen to the European Parliament’s wishes.

EU commissioner Kristalina Georgieva, responsible for the file, wrote to PMI and member states on Tuesday night (5 July) that “there is no need for a prolongation of the PMI agreement”.

The commission will not start negotiations with PMI to extend or renew the 12 year-old deal, which laid down rules for cooperation between the tobacco firm and national customs authorities, as well as the EU’s anti-fraud agency Olaf.

The letter to member states, seen by this website, laid out that the deal with PMI “has effectively met its objective of reducing the prevalence of PMI contraband on the illicit EU tobacco market”.

However, Georgieva also wrote that “the reduction of PMI contraband did not lead to an overall reduction of illicit products in the EU”.

“The market and legislative framework has changed significantly since the entry into force of the agreement,” she wrote.

The Bulgarian official added that new EU legislation on tobacco products, and a treaty signed under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control “are the best instruments to fight illicit trade by regulatory means”.

The move was first reported by the Financial Times, and confirmed by multiple sources in Brussels to this website.

The agreement included annual payments into both national and EU coffers, which totalled around €1 billion over the entire agreement period. Member states were in favour of, or did not oppose, a new agreement.

PMI

A spokeswoman for PMI on Wednesday afternoon confirmed the company had received a letter from the Commission.

“In its twelve years of implementation, the anti-illicit trade agreement with the EU has worked to significantly reduce the flow of PMI counterfeit and contraband cigarettes,” she said in an e-mailed comment.

She did not state specifically if PMI was disappointed the agreement would not be renewed.

“The supply chain control measures outlined in the agreement will remain an integral part of how we do business in the EU and around the world,” the PMI spokesperson added.

EU to end anti-smuggling deal with Philip Morris

http://www.politico.eu/article/eu-to-end-anti-smuggling-deal-with-philip-morris/

After months of wavering, the European Commission has decided not to renew its controversial agreement with Philip Morris International on tobacco smuggling and counterfeit products.

According to an EU official, commissioners meeting in Strasbourg Tuesday followed a recommendation from Vice President Kristalina Georgieva that continuing the deal — in place since 2004 — did not make sense. The agreement, under which the company cooperated with EU and national customs officials in fighting the illegal trade in cigarettes, had been heavily criticized by anti-tobacco groups and by members of the European Parliament.

In a letter to national capitals explaining the decision, seen by POLITICO, Georgieva said new international rules on smuggling had made the Commission’s arrangement with PMI unnecessary.

“There is no need for a prolongation of the PMI agreement,” she wrote, citing legal provisions in a World Health Organization convention, as well as the EU’s tobacco products directive adopted in 2014, as helping to fight tobacco smuggling.

Anti-tobacco groups had been pressuring the Commission not to renew the agreement, arguing it gave industry the opportunity to lobby customs officials and hide potential illegal activities.

The PMI deal became a template for similar arrangements between the EU and other tobacco giants like Japan Tobacco International, British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco Limited. Those agreements remain in place until they come up for renewal.

Some critics said the PMI agreement was not well equipped to tackle new tobacco smuggling trends like rolling tobacco or “cheap whites,” which are cigarettes produced on the black market.

Earlier this year, MEPs voted for a resolution calling on the Commission not to renew the PMI agreement, arguing it was outdated and did not respect the latest tobacco smuggling convention of the WHO, the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control.

“There have been major doubts about the effectiveness of the Philip Morris International agreement in reducing the illicit trade in tobacco products,” said Bart Staes, a Green MEP and member of the budgetary control committee.

Commission sources in recent months said the Berlaymont had been in a difficult spot on the issue: Even as MEPs voted to end the agreements, many EU countries were in favor of keeping them.

About €1 billion in public revenue from cigarette taxes has been safeguarded by the agreement with PMI, according to the Commission.

Expiration of tobacco deal is nigh but future still unclear

https://euobserver.com/economic/134159

Nine days before a twelve-year old cooperation agreement on tobacco smuggling between the EU and tobacco giant Philip Morris International (PMI) is due to expire, its future is still unclear.

EU Commission spokesman Alexander Winterstein said on Friday (1 July) he was unable to “give you a very concrete answer here”.

He noted that the president of the commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, decides what is put on the agenda for the weekly meeting of commissioners, the so-called college.

“He puts items there when he thinks it is the right moment. I’m not aware of this being on the agenda,” said Winterstein.

The college of commissioners is meeting on Tuesday 5 July in Strasbourg. It will be their last meeting before the EU-PMI deal expires.

It was signed on 9 July 2004, for a period of twelve years.

The agreement cemented cooperation between PMI on one hand, and national customs authorities and anti-fraud agency Olaf on the other.

It also included annual payments from PMI into EU and national budgets, totalling around €1 billion over the twelve-year period. The two sides agreed that the payments may be used by governments to combat tobacco smuggling, although no earmarking was done.

Member states in general have been supportive of the agreement, and are in favour, or have no strong objections against, a renewal.

But the European Parliament has turned against the deal, which they say is anachronistic. In March, it adopted a non-binding text which called on the commission not to extend or renew the deal.

Reasons included that new legislation covers many of the aspects from the agreement, but also that the EU should not cooperate closely with an industry that has questionable tactics – tobacco firms had challenged the new tobacco products directive in court, but failed.

The parliament said in its resolution that since the deal was concluded in 2004 “the market and regulatory environment have experienced substantial changes” and noted “that the agreement does not address important characteristics of the illicit tobacco trade today”, like brandless cigarettes being smuggled.

In the resolution, the MEPs asked the commission “not to renew, extend or renegotiate it beyond its current date of expiry”.

The commission does not need the parliament’s consent to renegotiate the deal, which it concluded on behalf of national governments. But it is likely that the commission is taking the potential political fallout of going against the wishes of the parliament into consideration.

Although commission spokesman Winterstein was unable on Friday to say whether the deal would be renewed, or even if there would be enough time to renegotiate it before 9 July, he did provide a statement that may slightly bolster the hopes of those opposed to a renewal.

“What I can tell you is that the president has read with great interest the resolution of the European Parliament,” said Winterstein.

Last year, EUobserver published a four-part series of articles about the EU’s agreement with tobacco company PMI

E.U. Survey Finds E-Cigarettes Helped 15 Million Smokers Quit or Cut Back

There was little evidence that vaping leads to smoking.

http://reason.com/blog/2016/06/27/eu-survey-finds-e-cigarettes-helped-mill

A large survey of Europeans indicates that more than 6 million have quit smoking with the help of e-cigarettes, while more than 9 million have cut back, according to a study recently published by the journal Addiction. “These are probably the highest rates of smoking cessation and reduction ever observed in such a large population study,” says the lead researcher, Konstantinos Farsalinos, a cardiologist at the Onassis Cardiac Surgery Center in Athens. “The European Union data show that the use of electronic cigarettes seems to have a positive impact on public health for two main reasons: 1) High smoking cessation and reduction rates are observed, and 2) electronic cigarette use is largely confined to smokers (current and former), with minimal use by nonsmokers.”

The study, based on responses from 27,460 participants in the Eurobarometer survey, found that 48.5 million citizens of E.U. countries have tried e-cigarettes, while 7.5 million are current vapers. Within the latter group, 35 percent reported that e-cigarettes helped them quit smoking, while 32 percent said they were smoking less thanks to e-cigarettes. Such self-reports are not conclusive, since the study did not independently verify smoking status, smokers who try to quit by vaping are probably different from those who don’t, and it’s possible these outcomes could have been achieved without e-cigarettes. But policy makers and regulators should not lightly dismiss the experiences of millions who say e-cigarettes helped them make changes that dramatically reduced the health hazards they face.

Critics of vaping say the risk that it will lead to smoking in people who otherwise never would have used tobacco products must be weighed against the success stories of people who believe they’d still be smoking if it weren’t for e-cigarettes. But this study found very little evidence of such a risk. Just 0.8 percent of respondents who had ever tried tobacco products said they had tried e-cigarettes first (which does not necessarily mean that the latter led to the former). Only 1.3 percent of never-smokers reported using e-cigarettes with nicotine-containing liquids, and only 0.09 percent did so every day. “In nonsmokers we observed some experimentation with electronic cigarettes, but regular use is minimal,” says one of Farsalinos’ collaborators, Jacques Le Houezec, a neuroscientist at the French National Research Institute for Health and Medical Research. “The concern that electronic cigarettes can be a gateway to smoking is largely rejected by our findings.”

Study finds e-cigarettes caused one of the biggest drops in smoking rates

Where the government failed, the private sector succeeded.

http://economiccollapsenews.com/2016/06/27/study-finds-e-cigarettes-caused-one-of-the-biggest-drops-in-smoking-rates/

A new study suggests that e-cigarettes have helped cause one of the biggest drops in smoking rates ever recorded in Europe.

Published in the journal Addiction, more than six million Europeans have quit smoking and an additional nine million have reduced their cigarette consumption thanks to e-cigarettes.

Researchers say 48.5 million Europeans have tried an e-cigarette and 7.5 million are currently using the product. Of the millions using e-cigarettes, more than one-third (35.1 percent) have quit smoking and nearly one-third (32.2 percent) have slashed their smoking intake.

“These are probably the highest rates of smoking cessation and reduction ever observed in such a large population study,” said the study’s lead author, Dr. Konstantinos Farsalinos, in a statement. “The European Union data show that the use of electronic cigarettes seems to have a positive impact on public health for two main reasons: 1. High smoking cessation and reduction rates are observed, and 2. Electronic cigarette use is largely confined to smokers (current and former), with minimal use by non-smokers.”

Despite the positive results, governments everywhere are trying to either regulate it the same as tobacco cigarettes or prohibiting e-cigs from hitting the marketplace.

Big Tobacco suspected of dodging EU antismuggling rules

Tobacco companies have sold their anti-smuggling system to a third party to comply with upcoming EU rules, but critics say the new owner is a front company.

The track-and-trace system, Codentify, helps tobacco firms and customs authorities to find out where a pack of cigarettes was produced and is used to combat smuggling – a multi-billion euro criminal industry in Europe.

It was set up in the wake of cooperation agreements between the EU and the four major tobacco companies, which required the firms to keep track of their products.

Tobacco companies had previously been suspected of smuggling their own goods in an effort to avoid paying taxes.

Codentify was owned by the tobacco industry until last month.

The cooperation agreements, one of which, with Philip Morris International (PMI), is due to expire in less than three weeks, were non-legislative contracts and did not require the track-and-trace system to be separate from the tobacco industry.

However, new EU legislation, as well as upcoming World Health Organisation (WHO) rules, specify that the system should be independently owned.

The WHO has previously expressed criticism of Codentify, which it said lacked transparency “and might have features that only the tobacco industry is aware of”.

Spokespersons for Philip Morris International, and for the joint venture that sold Codentify, told this website via email on Monday that the system now complies with the EU’s new Tobacco Products Directive and the WHO’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC).

The FCTC is an international treaty, also signed by the EU, which aims to curb tobacco smuggling.

“Inexto is fully independent from the tobacco industry,” said PMI spokesman Andrew Cave, referring to the Swiss-registered company that bought Codentify.

Inexto is registered in the Swiss city of Lausanne, at an address that is a fiveminute drive from the offices of Philip Morris International (PMI) and British American Tobacco Switzerland.

Inexto was founded this year and owned is owned by a French group called Impala, which has several daughter companies specialising in industries that range from energy to manufacturing.

The receptionist at Inexto’s mother company, Impala, said she did not know Philippe Chatelain, Inexto’s managing director, but told EUobserver he would be called back.

This has yet to happen.

Chatelain, and two other top officials of Inexto, have worked for PMI for over a decade. They left the firm just last month.

EUobserver was made aware of the sale and make-up of the new company by Oscar Larsson, a student at the Open University of London. He runs a blog, called Why It’s Bad in which he is critical of the Codentify tool.

“This is not an innocent purchasing of a legitimate technology,” Larsson told this website in an email.

“These are not just former employees from PMI, they are the dedicated core of the whole Codentify concept. Their names are on the patents and they are the inventors of this intentionally flawed system, designed by the tobacco industry to serve the tobacco industry and not the European Union”, he said.

Other critics of the tobacco industry also questioned the motives behind the sale.

Anna Gilmore, director of the tobacco control research group at the University of Bath, said Inexto could not be considered sufficiently independent from the tobacco industry.

“Given the tobacco industry’s long history of involvement in the illicit tobacco trade, a genuinely independent system would be a threat to the industry,” she told this website via email.

“It is therefore attempting to have governments implement its Codentify system by setting up intermediaries and front organisations to promote Codentify,” she added.

Luk Joossens, advocacy officer of the Association of European Cancer Leagues, said the sale was “a predictable move”, adding that tobacco companies will now “pretend” that Codentify is no longer part of the tobacco industry.

The FCTC’s secretariat, which has taken aim at Codentify before, repeated its opposition in a response to this website.

“Whether or not the new company will truly be independent of the tobacco industry, or if it will continue to defend the interests of the tobacco industry with just one more degree of separation remains to be seen,” said Vera Luiza da Costa e Silva, head of the secretariat of the FCTC.

She added that even if the track-and-trace (T&T) system was independent, it would still lack transparency.

“If the new company’s purpose is to continue to promote Codentify as a T&T system allegedly in compliance with the protocol, then this independence is irrelevant, since … analyses of Codentify have found it to not be compliant with protocol recommendations on T&T,” said Da Costa e Silva The Digital Coding & Tracking Association (DCTA), which owned Codentify until 1 June 2016, said Inexto “is fully independent from any tobacco company”.

DCTA is a joint venture by British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco Limited, Japan Tobacco International, and Philip Morris International.

“The three individuals you reference are no longer employees of any tobacco manufacturer and their jobs transferred to Inexto as part of the technology sale,” a DCTA spokesperson said by email, without revealing his or her name.

“Their deep knowledge of the technology, combined with their understanding of the complexities involved in the tobacco supply chain, means they offer Inexto unique expertise which will be necessary as the technology continues to evolve as a world-class, open source solution”.

The European Commission did not respond to requests for a comment.

Big Tobacco suspected of dodging EU anti-smuggling rules

Tobacco companies have sold their anti-smuggling system to a third party to comply with upcoming EU rules, but critics say the new owner is a front company.

The track-and-trace system, Codentify, helps tobacco firms and customs authorities to find out where a pack of cigarettes was produced and is used to combat smuggling – a multi-billion euro criminal industry in Europe.

It was set up in the wake of cooperation agreements between the EU and the four major tobacco companies, which required the firms to keep track of their products.

Tobacco companies had previously been suspected of smuggling their own goods in an effort to avoid paying taxes.

Codentify was owned by the tobacco industry until last month.

The cooperation agreements, one of which, with Philip Morris International (PMI), is due to expire in less than three weeks, were non-legislative contracts and did not require the track-and-trace system to be separate from the tobacco industry.

However, new EU legislation, as well as upcoming World Health Organisation (WHO) rules, specify that the system should be independently owned.

The WHO has previously expressed criticism of Codentify, which it said lacked transparency “and might have features that only the tobacco industry is aware of”.

Spokespersons for Philip Morris International, and for the joint venture that sold Codentify, told this website via email on Monday that the system now complies with the EU’s new Tobacco Products Directive and the WHO’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC).

The FCTC is an international treaty, also signed by the EU, which aims to curb tobacco smuggling.

“Inexto is fully independent from the tobacco industry,” said PMI spokesman Andrew Cave, referring to the Swiss-registered company that bought Codentify.

Inexto is registered in the Swiss city of Lausanne, at an address that is a fiveminute drive from the offices of Philip Morris International (PMI) and British American Tobacco Switzerland.

Inexto was founded this year and owned is owned by a French group called Impala, which has several daughter companies specialising in industries that range from energy to manufacturing.

The receptionist at Inexto’s mother company, Impala, said she did not know Philippe Chatelain, Inexto’s managing director, but told EUobserver he would be called back.

This has yet to happen.

Chatelain, and two other top officials of Inexto, have worked for PMI for over a decade. They left the firm just last month.

EUobserver was made aware of the sale and make-up of the new company by Oscar Larsson, a student at the Open University of London. He runs a blog, called Why It’s Bad in which he is critical of the Codentify tool.

“This is not an innocent purchasing of a legitimate technology,” Larsson told this website in an email.

“These are not just former employees from PMI, they are the dedicated core of the whole Codentify concept. Their names are on the patents and they are the inventors of this intentionally flawed system, designed by the tobacco industry to serve the tobacco industry and not the European Union”, he said.

Other critics of the tobacco industry also questioned the motives behind the sale.

Anna Gilmore, director of the tobacco control research group at the University of Bath, said Inexto could not be considered sufficiently independent from the tobacco industry.

“Given the tobacco industry’s long history of involvement in the illicit tobacco trade, a genuinely independent system would be a threat to the industry,” she told this website via email.

“It is therefore attempting to have governments implement its Codentify system by setting up intermediaries and front organisations to promote Codentify,” she added.

Luk Joossens, advocacy officer of the Association of European Cancer Leagues, said the sale was “a predictable move”, adding that tobacco companies will now “pretend” that Codentify is no longer part of the tobacco industry.

The FCTC’s secretariat, which has taken aim at Codentify before, repeated its opposition in a response to this website.

“Whether or not the new company will truly be independent of the tobacco industry, or if it will continue to defend the interests of the tobacco industry with just one more degree of separation remains to be seen,” said Vera Luiza da Costa e Silva, head of the secretariat of the FCTC.

She added that even if the track-and-trace (T&T) system was independent, it would still lack transparency.

“If the new company’s purpose is to continue to promote Codentify as a T&T system allegedly in compliance with the protocol, then this independence is irrelevant, since … analyses of Codentify have found it to not be compliant with protocol recommendations on T&T,” said Da Costa e Silva

The Digital Coding & Tracking Association (DCTA), which owned Codentify until 1 June 2016, said Inexto “is fully independent from any tobacco company”.

DCTA is a joint venture by British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco Limited, Japan Tobacco International, and Philip Morris International.

“The three individuals you reference are no longer employees of any tobacco manufacturer and their jobs transferred to Inexto as part of the technology sale,” a DCTA spokesperson said by email, without revealing his or her name.

“Their deep knowledge of the technology, combined with their understanding of the complexities involved in the tobacco supply chain, means they offer Inexto unique expertise which will be necessary as the technology continues to evolve as a world-class, open source solution”.

The European Commission did not respond to requests for a comment.

Tobacco firms defend value of EU deals

https://euobserver.com/economic/133884

Three weeks are left before an anti-smuggling agreement between the European Union and tobacco firm Phillip Morris International (PMI) expires.

While the EU commission is yet to announce whether it wants to negotiate for a renewal or extension, EUobserver spoke to representatives of two of the other four big tobacco firms. They are quite happy with the cooperation so far.

Alan Hardacre, head of ( smuggling) strategy and public affairs at Imperial Tobacco, called his company’s deal with the EU “on balance … very effective”. Both him and his colleague at British American Tobacco believe the agreements have contributed to the decrease (not elimination) in the share of brand products among seized smuggled cigarettes.

“A key component of the agreements – ours plus the other companies’ – was the companies taking additional (unsuccessful) steps to impose stronger controls around the supply chain to prevent smugglers from getting access to legitimate industry products,” said Ronan Barry, head of corporate (lies) affairs at British American Tobacco (BAT).

“The effectiveness … is demonstrated by the prevalence of industry brands as a component of the total amount of illicit trade, which has dropped by 45 percent from 2010 to 2015,” said Barry.

An EU commission assessment report of the PMI deal published in February, said it “effectively met its objective”, but may not be the appropriate tool for the future.

PMI was the first tobacco multinational to sign a deal with the EU and its member states, back in 2004.

The agreement settled a legal dispute: PMI had been accused of smuggling its own cigarettes, dodging tax and customs payments.

The PMI agreement was taken as a model for the three other deals, with Japan Tobacco International in 2007, and with BAT and Imperial Tobacco in 2010.

The agreements cemented a cooperation between European law enforcers and the firms to tackle cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting, as well as providing a steady flow of, in total, more than €1.4 billion from the tobacco industry into government budgets.

Generally speaking, national governments would favour a renewal or extension, but the European Parliament is against it. MEPs say that the most important provisions of the agreements, all four of which are similar although not identical, are covered by upcoming legislation.

PMI decision as ‘precursor’

Barry, of BAT, said he did not follow the public debate about the PMI deal in great detail.

“Our agreement doesn’t come up for renewal until 2030. We don’t plan that far ahead. That’s almost 15 years away,” he said, adding that his company has not received any signal from the EU commission that it may want to alter the agreement or terminate it prematurely.

Alan Hardacre of Imperial Tobacco, is following the debate more closely.

“If there is a decision not to renew the PMI agreement, then I suspect we would have to prepare ourselves for our agreement to be terminated when it comes to an end as well,” Hardacre told this website in a phone interview in May.

“It’s one of the reasons why we are following what is happening with the PMI agreement. I would imagine it would be a precursor for everybody else’s agreement,” he added.

Cheating ‘is not in our DNA’

Both rejected criticism that public authorities have come to rely too much on the tobacco industry.

Whenever smuggled cigarettes are seized and found to be genuine, the tobacco company under the agreements has to pay a fine. However, the tobacco firms themselves provide the analysis of whether seized cigarettes are genuine or counterfeit.(wow, the fox in charge of the hen house)

A conflict of interest?

“We have a high interest in knowing to what extent our brands are being counterfeited. We need to know. There is no question of us not engaging with law enforcement on a 100 percent truthful and honest basis,” said Ronan Barry, of BAT.

EUobserver asked if BAT’s forensic experts have an incentive to say seized cigarettes are counterfeit, because that would avoid the company from having to pay the fine.

“It’s just not the way companies behave. I can’t imagine a responsible legal industry lying to law enforcement. It’s not in our DNA. … I would say it is impossible in our company”, Barry said.

Imperial Tobacco agreed. It had forensics and compliance manager Alex McDonald call EUobserver after the interview.

McDonald said that law enforcement authorities generally trust his team’s analyses, but that EU and national authorities are always able to scrutinise a decision made by the forensics experts of the tobacco companies.

“Whilst the EU is not constantly breathing down our neck, that opportunity does exist,” he said.

Meanwhile, BAT’s Barry said he didn’t believe the EU agreement would be impacted by a British exit from the EU.

“In terms of the broader Brexit debate, BAT hasn’t taken a clear position, principally because we don’t expect it will have a huge impact on our business in the UK, which is quite small, despite our name,” Barry said.