Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Plain packaging does not violate Big Tobacco’s intellectual property rights

http://theconversation.com/plain-packaging-does-not-violate-big-tobaccos-intellectual-property-rights-38802

The argument that plain packaging encroaches on trademark rights is unconvincing – here’s why.

The House of Commons has voted in favour of compulsory, standardised and logo-free packaging for cigarettes. If also approved by the House of Lords, the new law will enter into force in England in 2016. This will mean trademarks, graphics and logos will be removed from packs, except for the brand name, which will be displayed in a standard font identical for all brands in the market. Large graphic health-warning images will also dominate on the front. A dark colour such as olive green will permeate the pack.

The aim of the measure – already in force in Australia since December 2012 and approved by Ireland – is to make cigarette boxes unappealing, especially for adolescents, so reducing the prevalence and uptake of smoking in the overriding interest that is public health.

Obviously Big Tobacco strongly opposes this measure. Seen from their perspective, such a legislative move is capable of confusing consumers and is an unacceptable de facto expropriation of their (intellectual) properties, namely their powerful brands, for which they have invested, and are still investing, so much money. In particular, they have claimed that this measure infringes their trademark rights, as it would end up in banning the use of all logos and graphic, fancy and design elements, which are protected by trademark registrations, for which tobacco companies have paid and will keep on paying filing and renewal fees.

Alongside this, the industry has argued that standardised packaging will not be effective in reducing the uptake of smoking, and may even have a “boomerang” effect of increasing smoking uptake – without the possibility of adorning their packs, it is argued, tobacco companies would compete only on prices making tobacco cheaper and more affordable.

Trademark argument unconvincing

Big Tobacco’s arguments are not convincing, and when it comes to trademarks standardised packaging doesn’t encroach on these rights.

First, tobacco manufacturers will still be able to distinguish their products from those of competitors as the measure allows them to display on their packs the brand name, although in a standard font.

Second, trademark registrations do not offer their owners a positive right to actually use the protected sign, but just the negative right to prevent counterfeiters from copying it. Indeed, enterprises and businessmen are able to use brands regardless of trademark registrations: the simple fact of starting a business allows them to use signs and logos in the course of trade. And the fact that trademark registrations do not offer their owners a positive right to use the trademark allows governments to introduce measures, such as standardised packaging, that prohibit or restrict such use on public interest grounds.

image004

That trademark registrations do not offer a right to use the sign also lends weight to the conclusion that plain packaging does not constitute a de facto expropriation of tobacco brands and does not expose the countries which adopt this measure (such as England, Australia and Ireland) to the risk of having to pay damages in compensation to tobacco producers under the European Convention on Human Rights and the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (which protect, among other fundamental rights, the right to property). Basically, standardised packaging does not amount to any expropriation of any property.

As the Australian High Court eventually held in a domestic litigation concerning plain packaging, a government that introduces this measure is not “acquiring” tobacco brands – it just prohibits their promotional use on packaging on public health grounds.

A parallel could be drawn between cigarettes and cannabis. If countries want to legalise the consumption of cannabis (and there are several governments which have already done so, or are currently discussing this legislative option), they may also want to protect consumers’ health and thus prevent marijuana and hashish manufacturers and distributors from using colourful and eye-catching brands to promote their consumption.

Should we allow cannabis growers and distributors to stop these countries pursuing this legitimate public interest by permitting them to claim a positive right to use trademarks and protect their investments in cannabis-related brands? My answer is no.

The measure seems effective

Finally, contrary to what Big Tobacco claims, standardised packaging seems also effective. Australia, for example, has justified this measure by relying on convincing scientific evidence. Recent figures released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics indeed show that total consumption of tobacco and cigarettes in the first quarter of 2014 in Australia is the lowest ever recorded. The number of young people taking up smoking also appears to have fallen.

In addition, the introduction of this measure has triggered a significant spike in Australian callers to Quitline, the telephone helpline offering treatment for addiction and behaviour change, while the allegations about unintended boomerang effects of standardised packaging seem rather speculative and unsubstantiated.

The conclusion that this measure is lawful and effective is further reinforced by a multilateral treaty adopted under the auspices of the World Health Organisation and introduced in 2005, under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC). This treaty aims to protect “present and future generations from the devastating health, social, environmental and economic consequences of tobacco consumption and exposure to tobacco smoke”. In particular, the Guidelines to the FCTC recommend that states adopt plain packaging to increase the noticeability and effectiveness of health warnings and messages and so eliminate the effects of advertising and promotion on tobacco packs.

Whatever the tobacco companies may argue, it is the public’s health that should come first and foremost.

Plain packaging does not violate Big Tobacco’s intellectual property rights

http://theconversation.com/plain-packaging-does-not-violate-big-tobaccos-intellectual-property-rights-38802

The House of Commons has voted in favour of compulsory, standardised and logo-free packaging for cigarettes. If also approved by the House of Lords, the new law will enter into force in England in 2016. This will mean trademarks, graphics and logos will be removed from packs, except for the brand name, which will be displayed in a standard font identical for all brands in the market. Large graphic health-warning images will also dominate on the front. A dark colour such as olive green will permeate the pack.

The aim of the measure – already in force in Australia since December 2012 and approved by Ireland – is to make cigarette boxes unappealing, especially for adolescents, so reducing the prevalence and uptake of smoking in the overriding interest that is public health.

Obviously Big Tobacco strongly opposes this measure. Seen from their perspective, such a legislative move is capable of confusing consumers and is an unacceptable de facto expropriation of their (intellectual) properties, namely their powerful brands, for which they have invested, and are still investing, so much money. In particular, they have claimed that this measure infringes their trademark rights, as it would end up in banning the use of all logos and graphic, fancy and design elements, which are protected by trademark registrations, for which tobacco companies have paid and will keep on paying filing and renewal fees.

Alongside this, the industry has argued that standardised packaging will not be effective in reducing the uptake of smoking, and may even have a “boomerang” effect of increasing smoking uptake – without the possibility of adorning their packs, it is argued, tobacco companies would compete only on prices making tobacco cheaper and more affordable.

Trademark argument unconvincing

Big Tobacco’s arguments are not convincing, and when it comes to trademarks standardised packaging doesn’t encroach on these rights.

First, tobacco manufacturers will still be able to distinguish their products from those of competitors as the measure allows them to display on their packs the brand name, although in a standard font.

Second, trademark registrations do not offer their owners a positive right to actually use the protected sign, but just the negative right to prevent counterfeiters from copying it. Indeed, enterprises and businessmen are able to use brands regardless of trademark registrations: the simple fact of starting a business allows them to use signs and logos in the course of trade. And the fact that trademark registrations do not offer their owners a positive right to use the trademark allows governments to introduce measures, such as standardised packaging, that prohibit or restrict such use on public interest grounds.

That trademark registrations do not offer a right to use the sign also lends weight to the conclusion that plain packaging does not constitute a de facto expropriation of tobacco brands and does not expose the countries which adopt this measure (such as England, Australia and Ireland) to the risk of having to pay damages in compensation to tobacco producers under the European Convention on Human Rights and the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (which protect, among other fundamental rights, the right to property). Basically, standardised packaging does not amount to any expropriation of any property.

As the Australian High Court eventually held in a domestic litigation concerning plain packaging, a government that introduces this measure is not “acquiring” tobacco brands – it just prohibits their promotional use on packaging on public health grounds.

A parallel could be drawn between cigarettes and cannabis. If countries want to legalise the consumption of cannabis (and there are several governments which have already done so, or are currently discussing this legislative option), they may also want to protect consumers’ health and thus prevent marijuana and hashish manufacturers and distributors from using colourful and eye-catching brands to promote their consumption.

Should we allow cannabis growers and distributors to stop these countries pursuing this legitimate public interest by permitting them to claim a positive right to use trademarks and protect their investments in cannabis-related brands? My answer is no.

The measure seems effective

Finally, contrary to what Big Tobacco claims, standardised packaging seems also effective. Australia, for example, has justified this measure by relying on convincing scientific evidence. Recent figures released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics indeed show that total consumption of tobacco and cigarettes in the first quarter of 2014 in Australia is the lowest ever recorded. The number of young people taking up smoking also appears to have fallen.

In addition, the introduction of this measure has triggered a significant spike in Australian callers to Quitline, the telephone helpline offering treatment for addiction and behaviour change, while the allegations about unintended boomerang effects of standardised packaging seem rather speculative and unsubstantiated.

The conclusion that this measure is lawful and effective is further reinforced by a multilateral treaty adopted under the auspices of the World Health Organisation and introduced in 2005, under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC). This treaty aims to protect “present and future generations from the devastating health, social, environmental and economic consequences of tobacco consumption and exposure to tobacco smoke”. In particular, the Guidelines to the FCTC recommend that states adopt plain packaging to increase the noticeability and effectiveness of health warnings and messages and so eliminate the effects of advertising and promotion on tobacco packs.

Whatever the tobacco companies may argue, it is the public’s health that should come first and foremost

Plain packaging to thank for Australia’s decline in smoking, says Labor

http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/mar/12/plain-packaging-to-thank-for-australias-decline-in-smoking-says-labor

Tobacco consumption fell 2.9% in quarter and 12.2% over the year, two years after plain-packaging legislation came into effect

Australia’s plain packaging: the British House of Commons has just voted to adopt similar legislation. Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP

Australia’s plain packaging: the British House of Commons has just voted to adopt similar legislation. Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP

Australians are ditching cigarettes at record levels, with the latest quarterly figures from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) showing a fall of nearly 3% in tobacco consumption.

The seasonally-adjusted figures for the December quarter show a 2.9% fall in consumption, contributing to a 12.2% yearly fall from December 2013 to December 2014.

Labor attributes the decline in smoking to its plain packaging legislation, which saw all branding removed from cigarette packs from December 2012.

“That takes the total fall in tobacco consumption to a staggering 12.8% in the two years since Labor’s plain packaging laws came into effect,” the opposition health spokeswoman Catherine King said.

“The minister welcomes any decrease in smoking rates and believes several factors have likely contributed, including education campaigns, excise increases and plain packaging,” a spokesman for the assistant health minister, Fiona Nash, told Guardian Australia.

A spokesman for British American Tobacco Australia, Scott McIntyre, told said plain packaging had little to do with the reduction.

He said successive governments’ decision to hike up prices has meant more smokers are buying cigarettes from the black market or opting for cheaper brands.

“Just because people are spending less money on tobacco doesn’t mean they’re reducing the amount the smoke, in fact many are smoking more for less,” McIntyre said.

“Instead of quitting, smokers are looking for cheaper options. Australia’s three million smokers are speaking with their wallets and literally walking into their local retailers and asking for the cheapest pack on the shelves.”

Overnight, the British House of Commons voted to adopt similar legislation by 367 votes to 113.

image002

The Australian Council on Smoking and Health said Australia has been a pioneer in the area of plain packaging.

“The British decision is especially important, as many countries still look to the UK as an exemplar. Several other countries are now planning to introduce plain packaging, following Australia – legislation last week in Ireland, and now the UK,” its president, Mike Daube, said.

“The British decision to introduce plain packaging is a massive victory for public health and a tremendous vindication for Australia’s world-leading legislation.”

Branding will be banned from cigarette packets in the UK from May 2016.

“As feared by tobacco companies, Australia’s lead is now creating an unstoppable momentum, with France set to follow and the entire European Union now likely to soon move to plain packaging. Labor’s example in staring down the ferocious legal attacks from big tobacco are now inspiring the rest of the world to follow this major advance in public health,” King said.

“It is understandable why the tobacco industry thinks plain packaging is a bad thing. But the evidence, and the momentum, is clear and Labor now looks forward to other nations joining the UK and Ireland in following Australia’s lead.”

President signs plain packaging into law

http://www.tobaccojournal.com/President_signs_plain_packaging_into_law.52891.0.html

President Michael Higgins signed the Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill into law which says manufacturers have until May, 2016, to retool and start producing plain packs for the Irish market, RTE News said.

Plain packaging applies to cigarettes and roll-your-own products. The law mandates a matt finish and uniform colour for portions of the pack not devoted to graphic health warnings. Under EU rules, those warnings must cover two thirds of the front and back. Manufacturers must begin producing the plain packs from May, 2016, and only plain packs may be sold from May, 2017.

Commons votes plain packs with big majority

http://www.tobaccojournal.com/Commons_votes_plain_packs_with_big_majority.52892.0.html

The House of Commons in a 367-113 bipartisan vote opted to introduce uniform packaging for cigarettes and hand-rolled tobaccos, setting the stage for final parliamentary approval on 16 March, the Guardian reported.

Plain packaging would mandate a standard green/brown colour and limit branding on packs that mostly would display graphic health warnings. Approval in the House of Lords for a bill that currently applies only to England is expected, the newspaper said on its website. Regional authorities in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland also are expected to adopt the plain packaging provisions.

Major tobacco companies have said they will contest standardised packaging in the courts, both in the UK and in Ireland, which earlier this week became the second country after Australia to approve plain packs. Two court challenges are pending against the Australian law. The UK version would take effect in May, 2016. In Ireland full implementation is planned one year later.

“This legislation is a case of the UK government taking property from a UK business without paying for it. That is illegal under both UK and European law”, said Jerome Abelman, corporate and regulatory affairs director at British American Tobacco. “Legal action is not something we want to undertake, nor is it something we enter into lightly – but the UK Government has left us with no other choice.”

MPs back standardised cigarette packaging

http://www.bbc.com/news/health-31839859

How the standardised packets may look

How the standardised packets may look

MPs have voted in favour of introducing standardised packaging for cigarettes in the UK.

It means from 2016 every packet will look the same except for the make and brand name, with graphic photos accompanying health warnings if the House of Lords also approves the move. The Irish Republic passed a similar law earlier this month and Australia has had plain packaging since 2012. Health campaigners said they were “delighted” with the move. Some 367 MPs voted in favour of standardised packaging with 113 against it in a free vote.

Long battle

It comes after a long battle to get to this point. The government announced in 2011 it would be considering standardised packaging and ran a consultation in 2012. But ministers then appeared to go cool on the plan, prompting accusations it had been influenced by the tobacco industry, before another review of the public health benefits was ordered. That review was carried out by paediatrician Sir Cyril Chantler and concluded last year it was very likely the change would lead to a modest but important reduction in the uptake and prevalence of smoking. More than 600 children aged 11 to 15 start to smoke every day – more than 200,000 a year. The review said if that number could be cut even by 2%, 4,000 fewer would take up the habit.

image002 (2)

Research has shown standardised packaging makes the packets less appealing and helps reinforce health messages. Darker colours – olive green is proposed – are favoured ahead of white, as they are perceived to signify more harm. British Lung Foundation chief executive Dr Penny Woods said she was “delighted” with the result. “We now look to the House of Lords to give this legislation the final parliamentary stamp of approval. The moment tobacco companies are finally denied the right to use glitzy packaging to recruit new smokers will be a moment of celebration for those who care about public health.”

Meanwhile, the campaign group, Action on Smoking and Health, called it the “most important public health reform of this Parliament”.

A history of smoking legislation in the UK

1965: Government bans cigarette advertising on television
1971: Ministers announce health warnings to be carried on all cigarette packets
1984: Smoking banned on London underground trains
2002: Legislation passed banning tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship
2005: Smoking banned on all trains
2006: A ban on smoking in public places, including bars and restaurants, comes into effect in Scotland
2007: England, Wales and Northern Ireland introduce their own bans on smoking in public places
2008: Picture health warnings introduced on cigarette packets
2012: Large shops are banned from displaying cigarettes. Smaller shops to follow suit in 2015
2015: MPs vote in favour of banning smoking in cars where children are present

But the Tobacco Manufacturer’s Association has argued there is a “complete lack of evidence that the policy will work”. Simon Clark, of the smokers lobby group Forest, said: “Consumers are fed up being patronised by politicians of all parties. Smokers know there are health risks associated with tobacco. Plain packaging won’t make any difference. “What next? Standardised packaging for alcohol and sugary drinks?”

Paper ballot

While the vote in favour had been widely expected, concerns were raised about how the process had been handled. Powers for standardising packaging were in the Children and Families Act 2014 and were agreed by a committee earlier this week. But as it is not primary legislation, there was no need for a debate and so the vote was done via a paper ballot. Conservative MP Nick De Bois said: “I certainly would never have expected to see this measure before this House this late in the parliament, announced in an adjournment debate without the benefit of a full debate.” While the vote was on the introduction of the regulations in England, the other parts of the UK had already committed to introducing standardised packaging if MPs passed it.

UK charity backs tobacco packaging law

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/breaking-news/uk-charity-backs-tobacco-packaging-law/story-fni0xqlk-1227254809886

CLAIMS that the tobacco industry will be able to sue the British government if it passes a law on Australian-style plain packaging are “ludicrous and unjustified”, an anti-smoking charity says.

ACTION on Smoking and Health says the legislation, which will be debated by MPs on Monday, is entirely compatible with European law and compensation would therefore not be due.

Finland and France have also indicated they will follow the lead set by Australia, which introduced plain packaging in 2012.

Professor Alberto Alemanno, an expert in EU law, said there was such strong evidence to support the new law that any challenge from the tobacco industry would be unlikely to succeed.

“Our analysis demonstrates that, under current EU law, the UK Government is entitled to regulate the packaging of tobacco products well beyond what the EU prescribes,” Prof Alemanno, of HEC Paris, said.

“The UK Government therefore enjoys considerable freedom of action in regulating the presentation of tobacco products, particularly given the overwhelming evidence of the harm that tobacco consumption causes.”

He said the proposals are also admissible under EU law relating to both trademarks and the issue of fundamental rights, which do not prevent member states from introducing legislation to protect public health.

“The legal opinion we are publishing today blows out of the water the ludicrous and unjustified claims by the tobacco industry that it would be due billions of pounds in compensation if the UK proceeds with standardised packaging,” Ash chief executive Deborah Arnott said.

Earlier this week, Ireland became the first country in Europe to ban branded cigarette packets, but is already facing a legal challenge over claims it infringes trademarks and the free movement of goods across the EU.

Government urged to bring plain packs to a vote

http://www.tobaccojournal.com/Government_urged_to_bring_plain_packs_to_a_vote.52888.0.html

Plain-pack supporters including the Maori Party urged the government to rethink its go-slow approach to standardising packaging for tobacco products and send legislation back to Parliament, the New Zealand Herald reported.

A survey in Australia showing a decline in the smoking rate to 12.8 per cent in 2013, the first year of plain packaging, from 15.1 per cent in 2010 was cited as grounds for quick action to protect public health, the newspaper said on its website. The New Zealand measure was put on hold after the government said it would await the outcome of complaints against the Australian law filed with the World Trade Organisation and Permanent Court of Arbitration.

Associate Health Minister Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga was cited in the article saying the government continues to support plain packaging, but has not changed its position on awaiting the outcome of legal challenges.

Australia remains the only country with a plain-pack law. The Irish parliament this week approved a plain packaging bill and the UK government has promised a parliamentary vote on its proposal in March.

Up in smoke: our researchers debunk Big Tobacco’s arguments against standardised packaging

http://www.bath.ac.uk/research/case-studies/standardised-tobacco-packaging-myths

Tobacco manufacturers argue that plain packaging would have unintended negative consequences in the UK. Our research exposes their misinformation.

A crime wave fuelled by smuggling and a death sentence for small businesses — these are just some of the claims made by tobacco manufacturers in their campaign to keep standardised cigarette packaging out of the UK.

Early results from Australia, which introduced the policy in 2012, have linked standardised packaging with a sustained increase in calls to Quitline, a reduction in pack appeal and a reduction in display of cigarette packs by smokers. This hasn’t stopped tobacco companies arguing that plain packs will be nothing but trouble, even when their own numbers don’t add up.

Our Tobacco Control Research Group (TCRG) has repeatedly exposed the misinformation used by tobacco companies, lobbyists and astroturfing organisations. These are three popular arguments from the tobacco industry, and how our researchers debunked them.

Myth #1: “Plain packaging will lead to increased tobacco smuggling”

One of the most common arguments from the industry is that plain packaging will make it easier for smugglers to make counterfeit cigarettes. Tobacco companies claim that this smuggling boom would benefit organised crime and that additional income would finance prostitution, arms trafficking and terrorism. Dramatic videos produced by British American Tobacco showed the introduction of plain packaging leading to car bombs exploding on the high street and gangster shootouts amidst shipping containers.

The reality is very different. The TCRG has exposed how the industry exaggerates the extent of tobacco smuggling by commissioning surveys whose methodology and validity remain uncertain, misquoting government data and planting misleading stories in the media.

The group’s findings are supported by independent data from the Australian Borders and Customs Agency showing that plain packaging has not impacted the illegal trade of cigarettes.

Smuggling cigarettes isn’t just for organised crime — tobacco companies have even been linked to smuggling their own products in order to dodge taxes and regulations. In 2000, tobacco company Philip Morris International (PMI) was sued by the European Commission for smuggling cigarettes into the EU. As part of the $1.25 billion settlement, PMI agreed to produce an annual report called Project Star about illicit tobacco in the European Union.

The 2010 Project Star report concluded that 64.2 billion contraband and counterfeit cigarettes had been trafficked in the EU that year — a rise of 3.1 billion since 2009. Our researchers evaluated the report and found it was misleading, concluding that “its publication serves the interests of PMI over those of the EU and its member states.” They showed how the report overestimated the prevalence of contraband cigarettes and relied too heavily on their own ‘empty pack’ surveys, which weren’t independently verified.

The ‘empty pack’ surveys can identify which cigarettes are domestic and which have come from abroad, but they’re unable to distinguish whether foreign cigarettes have been smuggled into the country or imported legally. The timing and location of the surveys can also skew the results dramatically — surveys in Germany over-represented border regions and locations near American military bases, where foreign cigarettes were significantly more likely to be found.

Myth #2: “Plain packaging would put independent shops out of business”

In their response to the UK’s consultation on plain packaging in 2012, British American Tobacco highlighted fears from the Tobacco Retailers Alliance that plain packaging would endanger small businesses: “For many of you, tobacco sales make up around a third of turnover, sometimes more. … During the busy times, such as the morning rush, there is a real risk that customers who have to wait will go to supermarkets and larger shops, which have more staff and therefore shorter transaction times.”

Similarly, Imperial Tobacco cited a study commissioned by the Alliance of Australian Retailers which concluded that “retailing times would be adversely affected if standardised packaging were introduced by an additional 15 to 45 seconds per transaction and that the effect would be particularly significant for smaller retailers”.

But the Tobacco Retailers Alliance and the Alliance of Australian Retailers were both created and funded by tobacco companies — a fact which the companies failed to mention in their submission.

Our researchers reviewed 74 pieces of evidence on illicit and economic impacts of standardised packaging cited by tobacco companies in their submissions to the 2012 consultation. They found that the companies had failed to cite any independent, peer-reviewed evidence which supported their arguments.

Nearly half the evidence cited was financially linked with at least one tobacco company, but the vast majority of these conflicts of interest were not declared in their submissions to the Department of Health.

Researchers concluded that “any data produced by industry on the illicit tobacco trade, or on those with whom it has a financial relationship, should be treated with extreme caution.”

Myth #3: “There’s no evidence or research that shows plain packaging would reduce smoking”

Despite a wealth of consistent peer-reviewed research and the independent Chantler review, which found that plain packaging is highly likely to reduce the appeal of smoking, tobacco companies keep arguing against this. But the evidence they submitted to the UK’s 2012 consultation on standardised packaging doesn’t stand up.

The TCRG investigated tobacco companies’ critiques of the evidence for plain packaging and found that they misrepresented the evidence base for standardised packaging by misquoting and using a ‘mimicked’ form of scientific critique.

Researchers also analysed 77 items of evidence submitted by four tobacco companies intended to prove that standardised packaging wouldn’t work.

Their analysis found that only 17 out of the 77 items actually addressed the impact of standardised packaging. Of these 17, 14 were industry-funded, and none had been published in peer-reviewed journals. Our researchers submitted these findings to the Chantler review.

In the article, our researchers said: “The transnational tobacco companies have maintained that advertising and promotional material — including packaging — stimulate only brand switching among current smokers. Yet, overwhelming evidence from the tobacco industry’s own marketing documents suggests this claim is highly disingenuous.”

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the industry did not submit its own internal material about the effectiveness of packaging as a marketing tool. But at a Philip Morris conference in 1994, marketer Mark Hulit made its importance clear:

“Our final communication vehicle with our smoker is the pack itself. In the absence of any other marketing messages, our packaging — comprised of the trademark, our design, color and information — is the sole communicator of our brand essence.

“Put another way — when you don’t have anything else — our packaging is our marketing.”

Ireland smokes big tobacco with plain packaging

http://www.ft.com/fastft/286012/ireland-bans-branding-on-tobacco-packaging

Ireland has passed a law banning branding on tobacco packaging, making it the second country in the world after Australia to introduce plain packaging legislation.

The law must now be signed by the country’s President and is expected to take effect in 2017, reports Kadhim Shubber.

The move comes as the UK prepares for a vote on plain packaging regulations this month, with the measures expected to be introduced as early as May 2016.

James Reilly, Ireland’s Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, who spearheaded the legislation, said:

Today is a very good day for the future health of our children. The interests of public health will be served when children decide never to take up smoking in the first place and if smokers are persuaded to quit.

Japan Tobacco International and Imperial Tobacco have threatened legal action against Ireland over the measures.

A furious row has erupted in Ireland over the role of legal firms and consultants that do work for tobacco companies, with Mr Reilly suggesting they should be barred from government contracts.