Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Cigarette plain packaging to cost Big Tobacco USD5bn a year

http://www.sharecast.com/news/cigarette-plain-packaging-to-cost-big-tobacco-usd5bn-a-year-says-goldman-sachs/23709012.html

Cigarette plain packaging to cost Big Tobacco USD5bn a year, says Goldman Sachs

(ShareCast News) – Goldman Sachs warned Big Tobacco it sees a $5bn annual profit hit from the impact of plain packaging on cigarettes, which the UK will impose next March and other countries following Australia’s lead in the next few years.

As a result of the long-term impact, Goldman downgraded British American Tobacco (BAT) to ‘sell’ and removed fellow FTSE 100 cigarette giant Imperial Tobacco from its ‘conviction buy’ list, but maintained its ‘buy’ recommendation.

“Tobacco multinationals have enjoyed above-inflation pricing owing to the favourable tax and regulatory backdrop and its restrictive effect on competition,” the investment bank said in a note.

“However, three years since its introduction, plain packaging regulation, combined with tax increases in Australia, appears to have driven considerable disruption to the industry profit pool.”

Imperial’s profits have a considerable has a 15% EBIT exposure to the UK market and Goldman estimates a 15% downside risk to the company’s UK profit post plain packaging adoption, with “more downside than upside risk” in the UK as the company has a leading position in cigarettes.

But the investment bank still noted that it had performed impressively in Australia since plain packaging was introduced in 2012 and is expected to be a potential beneficiary of plain packaging outside the UK.

On the other hand BAT is forecast by the bank’s analysts to be the most exposed of the Big Tobacco groups to the next wave of potential plain packaging adoption beyond the UK and Ireland.

Goldman estimates the company’s exposure to key markets such as France, Canada and others currently considering plain packaging to be circa 21%, resulting in an estimated 5% downside to group profits in a scenario of these markets adopting the regulation.

Furthermore, group earnings have not grown materially since 2012 and analysts predict forex to continue to hold back growth in 2016.

Imperial’s target price of 3,800% offers around 8% upside, while BAT target of 3,350p a downside of roughly 12%.

Tobacco giants and Government in plain packaging showdown

British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco will line up against the Government

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandconsumer/leisure/12035251/Tobacco-giants-and-Government-in-plain-packaging-showdown.html

The world’s biggest tobacco companies will this week start their High Court battle with the Government over plans to sell cigarettes in plain packets, a controversial law that the manufacturers argue deprives them of their property rights.

FTSE 100 companies British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco, along with Marlboro maker Philip Morris International and Japan Tobacco, will line up against the Government on Thursday, when a six-day hearing will start.

The firms are not claiming compensation or costs, but if they succeed in scrapping the ban they could receive large payouts.

Although the companies originally lodged papers separately, their bids to have plain packaging ruled illegal will be heard as one case. The new law is due to come into force in May next year.

The four cigarette companies are co-operating with each other so that each one will present a different argument against the legislation on standardised packets.

Mr Justice Green will hear the case, with a decision expected by January. Whatever the outcome of the hearing, the side that loses will almost certainly appeal.

MPs voted to ban brands and logos on cigarette packets in March, becoming only the third country in the world to do so after Australia and Ireland.

The Government hopes the measures will make smoking less appealing, particularly to youths.

The tobacco companies, however, argue that the measures are unlawful. They believe plain packaging breaches European Union law on community trademarks and that they have been deprived of their valuable brands without compensation.

The firms will also argue that the introduction of plain packaging in Australia, in December 2012, did not lead to a reduction in smoking, although the Government is expected to counter by saying that it is too early to judge the impact of that ban.

In a separate case in Luxembourg, the manufacturers are also attempting to prove that the plain packaging measure in the UK exceeds the EU Second Tobacco Products Directive.

The advocate general will issue an opinion on the matter in less than three weeks, with a ruling to follow early next year. The outcome of the High Court battle will become irrelevant should the tobacco companies win in the EU, because they will have proven that the UK had no legal right to introduce plain packaging.

It is hoped that, even in the event of an appeal, the matter will have been decided one way or another before plain packaging is introduced in May.

If that looks unlikely, the companies are expected to try to delay the start of the ban.

The slow-burn, devastating impact of tobacco plain packs

http://theconversation.com/the-slow-burn-devastating-impact-of-tobacco-plain-packs-51727

It is three years since Australia fully implemented its historic tobacco plain packaging law. From December 1, 2012, all tobacco products have been required to be sold in the mandated standardised packs, which, with their large disturbing graphic health warnings, are anything but “plain”.

Ever since, there have been frenzied efforts by the tobacco industry and its ideological baggage carriers to discredit the policy as a failure.

The obvious subtext of this effort has been to megaphone a message to other governments that they should not contemplate introducing plain packaging because it has “failed”: smoking, it is claimed, has not fallen any faster in Australia after plain packaging that it was already falling before. All that has occurred, they argue, is that illicit trade has increased.

The supreme irony here is of course that if such criticism was correct, then to paraphrase Hamlet’s mother Gertrude, “The tobacco industry doth protest too much, methinks.” Why would the industry and its astro-turfed bloggers waste so much money and effort denigrating a policy which was having little or no impact?

Why take the Australian government to the High Court (and fail six to one) to try and block the law? Why invest in supporting minnow tobacco-growing states such as the Dominican Republic, Honduras and Cuba in their efforts to have the World Trade Organization rule against plain packaging?

Why not just ignore an ineffective policy instead of making it only too obvious to all by such actions that it is in fact a grave threat to your industry?

Two key assumptions have underscored efforts to discredit the impact of plain packaging. First, critics assume the impacts of the law should have been evident immediately as it was implemented: as one colleague put it recently “within ten seconds of the law passing”.

Second, they assume (but never actually state) that the impact of plain packaging on smoking by children (the principal target) and adults was supposedly going to be greater than anything we have previously observed in the entire history of tobacco control.

In 1999, the late Tony McMichael, professor of epidemiology at the Australian National University, published a classic paper called Prisoners of the Proximate where he wrote about the need to understand the determinants of population health in terms that extend beyond proximate single risk factors and influences.

In tobacco control, both proximal (discrete, recent and quick-acting) and distal (on-going, slow-burn) effects of policies and campaigns can occur. Price rises (and falls through discounting) can have both immediate and lasting effects, jolting smokers into sometimes unplanned quitting and also slowly percolating an unease about the costs of smoking that translate into quitting down the track.

Tobacco advertising bans are a good example of a policy that has such slow-burn effects across many years. Few if any quit smoking in direct response to tobacco advertising bans. They work instead by causing the next generations of kids to grow up in an environment devoid of massive promotional campaigns depicting smoking in positive ways.

I have often heard smokers say “plain packaging won’t make me quit smoking”. This is akin to the myopic self-awareness of those who swear “advertising (for any product) never influences me” while noting that it only influences the more impressionable.

Plain packs were unlikely to act suddenly in the way tax rises do, although the unavoidably huge graphic health warnings may well have acted like straws that broke the Camel’s back of worry about smoking. Their impact was far more likely to be of the slow-burn sort, where the constant reminder that tobacco, unique among all products, is the only consumer good treated this way by the law. It is exceptionally dangerous, with a recent estimate that two in every three long-term smokers will die from tobacco use.

In 1994 I wrote a now highly cited paper in the British Medical Journal which talked about the impossibility of “unravelling gossamer with boxing gloves” when it came to being certain about precisely why smokers quit. I took a day in the life of a smoker who quit, and pointed to the myriad of influences both distal and proximal that coalesce to finally stimulate a smoker to quit.

While a smoker might nominate a particular policy, conversation with a doctor or anti-smoking campaign as being “the reason” they quit, much of what went on before provides the broad shoulders of concern that carry the final attribution. There are synergies between all these factors and the demand to separate them all is like the demand to unscramble an omelette.

So what has happened to smoking in Australia since plain packs?

Data released this month from a national schools survey involving more than 23,000 high school children found smoking rates were the lowest ever recorded since the studies first commenced in 1984 (see graph). This momentum is starving the tobacco industry of new smokers, which is one important reason why all tobacco companies are now busily acquiring e-cigarette brands.

Proportion of 12- to 15-year-olds who smoke, 1984 to 2014

image-20151203-22439-ofg596

Trends in proportion of current (smoked in past seven days) and committed smokers (smoked on three or more of the past seven days) among 12 to 15-year old students, Australia, 1984-2014.

With adults, National Accounts data just released show that for the 11 quarter-year periods since March 2013, consumption of tobacco products in aggregate fell an unprecedented 20.8%, while the previous 11 quarters it fell 15.7% and in the 11 before that, only 2.2%.

The latest available data on adult smoking prevalence we have is from 2013 and show just 12.8% of Australians over 14 smoked on a daily basis. This is the lowest on record and again, the biggest percentage falls experienced since the surveys commenced (see graph).

Reductions in daily smoking among Australians aged over 14, 1991 to 2013

AIHW National Drug Strategy Household Survey 2013: preliminary findings. 2014 Author-sourced.

AIHW National Drug Strategy Household Survey 2013: preliminary findings. 2014 Author-sourced.

Meanwhile, the tobacco industry plods along funding heavily lambasted studies which purport to show none of this is happening.

The argument that plain packaging would cause illicit trade to boom was made with monotonous regularity by Big Tobacco between April 2010 when plain packaging was announced and its December 2012 implementation. When the industry lost its case in the High Court, the argument was quietly dropped.

Today, the industry explains illicit trade entirely by the heinous government tobacco tax rises cloaked in a sanctimonious rhetoric of speaking up for poor smokers and corporate citizen concern about tax avoidance bleeding Treasury. In all this it fails to mention that it has long used tax rises as air cover to quietly raise its own profit margins.

As I wrote recently in The Conversation:

From August 2011 to February 2013, while excise duty rose 24¢ for a pack of 25, the tobacco companies’ portion of the cigarette price (which excludes excise and GST), jumped A$1.75 to A$7.10. While excise had risen 2.8% over the period, the average net price had risen 27%. Philip Morris’ budget brand Choice 25s rose A$1.80 in this period, with only 41¢ of this being from excise and GST.

Ireland, the United Kingdom and France have already passed laws to introduce plain packs. Norway and Canada will soon, and New Zealand, Chile, Turkey, South Africa and Brazil have also made high-level noises about joining in too. The world has a lot to thank Rudd and Gillard governments (and particularly Health Minister Nicola Roxon) for taking this initiative, and the subsequent Coalition government for continuing to support it strongly as it continues to come under attack from those it has and will continue to hurt.

Update: Dec 5: There are now 25 nations which have either passed plain packaging legislation, have it in train, or are planning to introduce it. See https://twitter.com/SimonChapman6/status/672888858871095296

Malawi’s forests going up in smoke as tobacco industry takes heavy toll

Malawi is reliant on tobacco for 60% of foreign earnings, but while demand is falling the cost of environmental damage caused by the industry is rising

This high level of marketing in poorer countries is consistent with the tobacco industry’s targeting of these countries. They are key to the industry’s future. In the west, the tobacco industry’s profits continue to increase despite the decline in smoking rates , but it is unclear how long this pricing power will hold out in the face of growing regulations. The requirement for tobacco to be sold in plain packs, due to come into force in the UK next year, is a particular threat.

Of all the world regions, Africa is probably most critical to the long-term future of the tobacco industry. The tobacco epidemic is at its earliest stage in Africa, meaning the industry still has millions of potential customers to recruit. Marketing will drive this recruitment, and industry marketing deliberately targets children, recognising that today’s teenager is tomorrow’s potential regular customer.

It is depressing that 10 years after the framework convention came into force, tobacco marketing remains ubiquitous. Evidence shows that the FCTC has led to significant progress in other areas of tobacco control but that comprehensive bans on marketing are one of the treaty’s least adopted measures. A concerted effort is needed to implement and enforce marketing restrictions before millions more die needlessly. Holding the tobacco industry to account is an essential first step.

Parliament passes plain-pack law

http://www.tobaccojournal.com/Parliament_passes_plain-pack_law.53323.0.html

Parliament narrowly voted approval of a law to strip branding from cigarette packaging and require manufacturers to adopt a unitary pack design from May 2016, Euronews reported.

Legal action by tobacco companies is possible, the French-based multilingual broadcaster said on its website. Introduced by Health Minister Marisol Touraine, plain-packaging aims to discourage youth from taking up the smoking habit and reduce smoking, the main cause of death in France, Euronews said.

France joins Ireland and the United Kingdom among European Union countries opting for plain packaging in addition to 65 per cent health warnings on packaging that will be introduced throughout the EU next May.

Tobacco Tactics – Plain Packaging Opposition in Ireland

Download (PDF, 103KB)

Plain Packaging – International Overview

Download (PDF, 852KB)

Canada could join UK and go for plain tobacco packs

http://www.packagingnews.co.uk/news/canada-could-join-uk-and-go-for-plain-tobacco-packs-02-11-2015

Canada could be the next country to pass laws imposing plain packaging on tobacco products.

The newly elected Liberal government reportedly set out a plain pack pledge during the country’s election campaign. The Liberal Party swept to power in a landslide result last month.

If Canada were to adopt the law it would follow the UK, Australia and Ireland.

Such a move has been welcomed by anti-tobacco lobbyists including the Canadian Cancer Society, according to a report in The Globe and Mail. However, critics of the plans include Imperial Tobacco Canada.

It’s not the first time plain packaging has been floated in Canada, with the Liberals considering the plan pack in 1994.

BAT moves from packaging to sue TGA on nicotine inhalers

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/health/bat-moves-from-packaging-to-sue-tga-on-nicotine-inhalers/story-fn59nokw-1227590164902

One of the largest tobacco ­companies in the world has sparked another­ legal battle with the Australian government, over its refusal­ to allow its electronic cigarette to be classified as a legal health product.

British and American Tobacco has launched legal action against the Therapeutic Goods Administration claiming that the health authority did not even consider an application to have its Voke nicotine inhaler listed, much like other nicotine products that could help smokers quit the habit.

BAT’s nicotine product arm, Nicovations, has filed a claim in the Federal Court claiming that the TGA erred by not even reviewing­ the application, with Britain’s Medicine and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency recently allowing the product to be licensed like other nicotine-quitting products.

“Nicovations is disappointed that the Therapeutic Goods Administr­ation has refused to evaluate our application for Voke in Australia,’’ BAT said in a statement. “We’ve been forced to seek a review of the TGA’s decision not to assess our application.”

The big tobacco companies took the Australian government all the way to the High Court recent­ly in a failed bid to have laws forcing them to sell cigar­ettes in plain packaging overturned.

In a statement, BAT said the inhaler could prove more effective than other quitting products such as patches or gums, with the inhaler working on a different system to other e-cigarettes and not requiring heating.

“Nicovations would like to see the Australian government take a pragmatic and proportionate approach to regulating next generation nicotine products,’’ the statement said. “It seems unreasonable that adult smokers in Australia currently can’t legally access these types of products.”

Despite e-cigarettes still being illegal for sale in Australia, hundreds­ of thousands of people here are now estimated to use the products, which have been approved­ for use in Britain and in the EU.

While not commenting on the case, the TGA directed The Australian to its current advice on the products, which claims its hard line on e-cigarettes is based on nicotine’s classification as a “dangerous poison”. But it accepted­ it had not conducted an assessment of the products for quality and safety.

“Unlike Nicotine Replacement Therapy products, which have been rigorously assessed for efficacy and safety and, therefore, approved by the Therapeutic Goods Administration for use as aids in withdrawal from smoking, no assessment of electronic cigar­ettes has been undertaken and, therefore, the quality and safety of electronic cigarettes is not known,” the TGA states on its website.

A recent independent paper by the British Health Department evaluating the use of e-cigar­ettes found they were about 95 per cent less harmful than smoking cigarettes, could benefit poorer smokers and release negligible amount of toxins to bystanders.

“On the evidence, we believe e-cigarettes have the potential to make a significant contribution to the endgame for tobacco,’’ it said. “With opportunity comes risk, and a successful approach will be one that retains vigilance and manages these risks, while enabling a flourishing and innov­ative market with a range of safe and effective products that smokers want to use to help them quit.”

WTO panel to hear oral arguments on Australia tobacco plain packaging case

http://www.ash.org.uk/:world-trade-organization-panel-to-hear-oral-arguments-on-australia-tobacco-plain-packaging-case-from-28-to-30-october-2015

Action on Smoking and Health

World Trade Organization panel to hear oral arguments on Australia tobacco plain packaging case from 28 to 30 October 2015

Tuesday 27 October 2015

Tomorrow a World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement panel will begin to hear a second and final round of oral arguments in claims that Australia’s tobacco plain packaging infringes WTO agreements. The hearing will take place at WTO in Geneva from 28-30 October, 2015. An initial oral hearing took place 1-5 June 2015.

The outcome of this case is being watched worldwide by governments, health organizations and tobacco companies alike given the crucial nature of plain packaging as a tobacco control measure. Fiercely opposed by the tobacco industry, plain packaging is recommended by guidelines under the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, the international tobacco control treaty.

Under plain packaging, health warnings would remain as would product names in a standard size and font, but tobacco company colours, logos and graphics on packages would be banned. The brand portion of package have the same colour (e.g. drab brown) for all brands. Tobacco packages would no longer be mini-billboards promoting tobacco.

Plain packaging was implemented in Australia in 2012, has been adopted in Ireland and the United Kingdom for implementation on 20 May 2016, and is under formal consideration in Norway, Sweden, Finland, Hungary, France, Canada, New Zealand, Singapore, Turkey and South Africa. [1]

There are four complainants that have each brought a claim to WTO: Honduras, Indonesia, Cuba and Dominican Republic. (Another initial complainant, Ukraine, has withdrawn its legal claim). At the October 28-30 hearing, it is only the four complainants as well as Australia that will be entitled to present oral argument.

Tobacco companies have admitted to paying legal costs for two of the current complainants: Philip Morris International for the Dominican Republic, British American Tobacco for Honduras as well as for the previous complainant Ukraine. [2] At WTO, only governments can initiate proceedings, which is why the tobacco industry is paying legal costs of certain countries.

There are 36 Third Parties that are participating in the proceeding, more than in any previous WTO case. The Third Parties were entitled to present their perspective at the June 1-5 hearing, but will not be able to do so at the October 28-30 hearing. The Third Parties are: Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, China, Chinese Taipei, Ecuador, Egypt, European Union, Guatemala, India, Japan, Korea (Republic of), Malawi, Malaysia, Moldova, Mexico, New Zealand, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Norway, Oman, Panama, Peru, Philippines, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, South Africa, Thailand, Trinidad and Tobago, Turkey, United States, Uruguay, Zambia, Zimbabwe.

The tobacco industry had previously brought a constitutional challenge in Australia to plain packaging, but this was dismissed by the High Court of Australia on August 15, 2012. [3]
Deborah Arnott, Chief Executive of health charity ASH said:

“The claim that Australia’s tobacco plain packaging infringes WTO agreements is ill founded and has little or no chance of success. The sooner all the legal challenges are settled the better. Then the example set by Australia, and followed by the UK and Ireland, will rapidly spread all round the world.”

ASH has been given permission to intervene in the legal challenge brought by tobacco companies to try to stop the introduction of standardised, plain packaging in the UK. The case is due to be heard from 10-17 December. [4]

The importance of plain packaging was recently emphasized by WHO Director General Dr Margaret Chan at the World Conference on Tobacco or Health [5]: “Despite industry’s best efforts to block plain packaging, the train has already left the station. The evidence base is strong, empirical, and comes from well-qualified, respected, and credible sources. I thank all the researchers who have contributed to this evidence base. We know that plain packaging works.”