Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Quit Smoking

E-cigarette study doesn’t convince Nova Scotia’s top doctor

Dr. Robert Strang says there is evidence e-cigarettes make it easier for people to continue smoking

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/e-cigarettes-vaping-smoking-robert-strang-1.3557764

A new study from Britain’s Royal College of Physicians that pegs e-cigarettes as a much safer alternative to smoking tobacco isn’t enough to fully sway Nova Scotia’s chief public health officer.

The report, released Thursday, cites expert opinion and concludes the hazards to health from inhaling e-cigarette vapours are likely less than the harms from smoking tobacco.

Nova Scotia’s top doctor, Robert Strang, agreed with that finding — to a point.

“If you’re smoking something, is it safer to use an e-cigarette than a regular cigarette?” he asked.

“I think for any individual, the answer would be, everything we know is much likely to be safer, but that doesn’t mean that it may not come with some risks.”

Strang said the real concern is e-cigarettes re-normalizes the smoking habit. (CBC)

Strang said there is evidence that e-cigarettes make it easier for people to continue smoking.

“They can keep using their e-cigarette where they can’t use a cigarette and then keep using cigarettes where they can.”

That wasn’t the case for John Burke. A smoker for 45 years, at his peak he was inhaling a pack and a half a day.

“Once I tried vaping, it’s been two years, I haven’t had a cigarette since,” he said.

“I don’t smoke nearly as much as I would with cigarettes and there’s no ashtrays and the stink in the car and the stink in the house.”

John Burke was a smoker for 45 years before switching to e-cigarettes. (CBC)

But Strang said the real concern is e-cigarettes re-normalizes the smoking habit and will be another route for young people to take up smoking.

“There’s growing evidence, for instance, in some of the research and surveillance in the United States that more and more young people are, who weren’t previous smokers, are using e-cigarettes,” he said.

“The real risk that they develop and addiction to nicotine and switch to regular cigarette products.”

‘Good luck to us all’

Burke said vaping was his gateway to quit regular cigarettes and he hopes the government doesn’t get too involved.

“I’m glad the research has been done and good luck to us all, I just hope it doesn’t come to the point where it’s controlled such as cigarettes and alcohol,” he said.

Strang said he likes the rules the province has put in place that treat e-cigarettes like all other tobacco products, regulating where they can be sold and consumed.

“I think we have found a very good balance in Nova Scotia while we still wait for some federal direction,” he said.

Strang points out e-cigarettes are only one method to help quit smoking and there are other better studied alternatives out there.

Burke said e-cigarettes were the only solution for him and many other smokers.

“It’s saving a lot of people’s lives, it really is,” he said.

Cigarette Smokers Can Now Quit Smoking Effectively By Doing One Thing; Learn More

Cigarette smoking is among the most addictive vices known to mankind. This new study done by scientists at the Oxford University would help smokers to finally quit smoking consistently.

http://www.universityherald.com/articles/29226/20160420/cigarette-smokers-now-quit-smoking-effectively-doing-one-thing-new.htm

There were smokers who attempted quitting, but would eventually go back doing it because the methods they tried were not that effective. This new study that can be found via the journal called Annals of Internal Medicine says that smokers can finally say goodbye to smoking forever as cited by The Inquisitr.

Scientists from Oxford University said, that going “cold turkey” is indeed the best way to quit smoking based on their recent survey. They used 700 smokers based in the United Kingdom who have always wanted to quit smoking cigarettes.

They were asked to participate for two weeks. Half of those smokers were told to go back to smoking after two weeks if they still feel the urge to. The other half was asked to completely stop it.

The researchers then observed the two groups and their behavior towards smoking after a month, which also was followed by another survey after six months. They found out that smokers who quit abruptly were more likely to quit smoking forever than those who did it gradually. But that was just for the first month. The success rate was also similar to that after six months.

One of the researchers of the said project, Nicole Lindson-Hawley, said that going “cold turkey” is the best strategy to quit smoking, but quitting gradually is still not a bad idea because at least the person is making an effort.

Gradually saying goodbye to smoking is still better than not doing anything at all to quit it.

If you are someone who is trying to quit smoking using the “cold turkey” style, then you should know that you’re on your way to a healthy lifestyle. Share this information to your friends and family who you think need to finally quit smoking, but are having a hard time.

Anti -smoking doctor calls for vaping to help hopeful quitters

Vaping experts have slammed the Hong Kong Government for turning a deaf ear to the potential to improve health outcomes. An European doctor-researcher believes vaping can help many to reduce the harm of using cigarettes and even quit.

http://harbourtimes.com/2016/04/20/anti-smoking-doctor-calls-for-vaping-to-help-hopeful-quitters/

Consumers and business owners alike have been consistent in their calls urging the Hong Kong Government to adopt a more open attitude towards vaping products, also known as e-cigarettes. Last week, a European doctor and scientist, Professor Riccardo Polosa, arrived in Hong Kong making the argument that is can be a boon to public health and even reduce smoking rates.

Professor Riccardo Polosa is a doctor turned scientist supporting the liberalisation of vaping products in order to lower the incidence of smoking and help people quit. He is the former president of the Italian Anti Smoking League (from 2003 to 2008) and founded the University of Catania’s Centre for Tobacco Research in 2003, making him an active member contributor to the European debate on vaping regulatory issues.

In his recent visit to Hong Kong, the smoking cessation expert stressed that vaping, given proper monitoring and regulation, can be a “gateway away from the harmful effects of smoking”, citing a widely endorsed report by Public Health England which concluded that e-cigarette is 95% less harmful than combustible cigarettes in terms of harmful constituents produced.

“By definition, smokers are already polluting themselves with more than 7,000 chemicals. What causes disease… is a synergistic action of these many thousands of chemicals. If you look at the component…of what is emitted by electronic cigarettes, it’s not thousands of chemicals, but a few, 95% less chemicals,” Professor Polosa explained.

“Brainwashed”

Commenting on the Hong Kong Government’s cool, if not dismissive, response towards market liberalisation of vaping products, the professor criticised it for being “brainwashed by ideological information.” “It seems to me that [the] Hong Kong [Government]…is trying to mimic what’s happening in Singapore..to follow steps without any scientific reason,” he said, calling it “nonsensical” and “irresponsible” for the Hong Kong Government, or any government, to deprive smokers of a lower risk alternative which can generate a “public health revolution.”

For Professor Polosa, what matters at the end of the day is the smoking prevalence. He draws upon findings of studies conducted by his team in the past three years over switching from smoking to vaping and its impact on tobacco-related diseases (here, here and here). “All people exclusively adopting the vaping lifestyle are improving all objective and subjective outcomes for all diseases under examination. So it’s a great public health gain that we are going to see if we embrace electronic cigarettes,” the professor said. “I would like to caution the Hong Kong Government to follow more beneficial examples, say in England, where e-cigarette [usage] has been very popular for the past five years and they have seen the largest decrease in smoking prevalence.”

“I understand [Hong Kong] has a flat rate for smoking for the last seven or eight years, so it is time for a change…We see in other countries where [vaping] had been liberalised, there were big changes in smoking prevalence and I don’t see why this is not going to happen in Hong Kong too,” the professor added.

Crusade for health

As such data is not yet available in Hong Kong, Professor Polosa urged the Hong Kong Government to build up its own smoking prevalence data, monitor it and formulate vaping policies accordingly. In his short trip to Hong Kong, he met with lawmakers Joseph Lee Kok-long (???), representative of the Health Services functional constituency, and Aron Kwok Wai-keung (???) for the Labour constituency and offered his expertise in designing a monitoring system and designing experimental protocol.

Speaking to HT, Lee was open to Professor Polosa’s ideas. “I think this is a good perspective that would allow Hong Kong smokers to have a better informed choice,” Lee says. “Right now there is no regulation over e-cigarettes in Hong Kong, so the Government should look into the regulatory lines drawn by other countries that have already legalised the product.”

The Federation of Trade Union lawmaker and social worker, meanwhile, is less open. “Whether examples in other places can be applied to Hong Kong remains unclear. It can be due to cultural difference, or difference in the perspectives over what e-cigarette can deliver. Indeed, the Baptist University of Hong Kong was commissioned to conduct a research and found that, used improperly, there are harmful chemicals in e-cigarette that can lead to cancerIf you can’t prove that . the substances in e-cigarette are 100% safe, it is hard for us to be convinced that there are other, positive functions of the product,” Kwok says. “That being said, I have always urged the Government to . Given current findings, I am provide more scientific evidence to support their propositionleaning towards stricter regulations [on e-cigarette], but it is still too early to conclude whether we should ban it completely. The Government should strive to provide a regulatory framework first, but if it insists that they don’t have the resources to provide such a supplement, banning the product may be the only way to go.”

As a general response, Professor Polosa slammed the papers generally embraced by the Hong Kong Government for not reflecting normal use, while noting a general misunderstanding in the general public towards nicotine.

“You stress the product so that it produces a much higher level of toxicants. This does not appear under regular use,” he said. “The dosage of nicotine normally absorbed by smokers is just a transmitter, or a psycho-stimulant. Nicotine doesn’t cause cancer. Nicotine doesn’t cause lung disease. Nicotine doesn’t cause serious cardiovascular problem. What causes these problems is the [chemicals arising from] combustion. So you need to quit combustion, not to quit tobacco nicotine.”

“E-cigarette should not be categorised as a drug, and in principle not as a tobacco product. In essence, it is currently included as a separate chapter under the tobacco category in Europe. Hong Kong may want to follow [Europe],” he says, suggesting an increase in tobacco tax in addition to other regulatory initiatives.

The ‘kids’ card

The two lawmakers also express concerns over teenagers picking up smoking habits if vaping is made available to them. In response, Professor Polosa drew upon a recent study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), a leading national public health institute of the United States, which found that e-cigarette use among middle and high school students in the US is skyrocketing.

“Data in CDC shows clearly that even though there is a high adoption rate in experimentation of e-cigarette, smoking prevalence in the same age group is going down for the first time in ten years,” he said, “In fact, the CDC lied as it released the two sets of data months apart, making people think that the two are unconnected.” In other words, teenagers may be smoking less because they are vaping instead.

“It’s never been shown that this is going to cause an increase in smoking prevalence…30-50% of kids have a risk-seeking profile. That’s normal. But the large picture is not the few kids that are trying e-cigarettes, the large picture is billion of smokers that need a safer alternative,” the professor added. “I find it very irritating to use kids for their campaigns.”

Train the shoppers!

Back in his country, Professor Polosa has launched a collaborative project to provide training for vape shop owners and salespersons on smoking cessation counselling. “I prefer to have professionals in vape shops. Probably in the future we need to regulate vape shop owners and salespersons in the way we regulate pharmacists. They should have a minimal training, because after all they are helping people to quit smoking,” he says. “I don’t see anyone in Hong Kong who is in charge of smoking cessation.” There is much to be done Expect the professor to be in Hong Kong more often as part of his lifelong mission to help people quit smoking.

Snus undermines quit attempts but not abstinence

A randomised clinical trial among US smokers

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2016/04/12/tobaccocontrol-2015-052783.short?g=w_tobaccocontrol_ahead_tab

Abstract

Background

Observational studies and a few clinical trials suggest that use of low nitrosamine smokeless tobacco (snus) can facilitate smoking cessation. To better understand the real-world impact of snus on smoking behaviour, a large-scale, long-term clinical trial of naturalistic snus use among smokers is needed.

Study design

A nationwide clinical trial compared abstinence outcomes among smokers who were randomised to receive free samples of snus versus not. Participants (N=1236) were recruited throughout the US and assessed for 1 year following a 6-week naturalistic sampling period, with high retention throughout. Primary outcomes included self-reported quit attempts, floating abstinence (any 7-day period of non-smoking) and 7-day point-prevalence abstinence at 6 months and 12 months. Secondary outcomes were changes in smoking, motivation and confidence to quit and adverse events. No tobacco industry support was provided.

Results

Within snus group, 82% used at least once, and 16% were using regularly at end of sampling period. Compared to control participants, smokers in the snus group were less likely to make any quit attempt (RR=0.83; 95% CI 0.70 to 1.00), and any 24 h quit attempt (RR=0.77; 95% CI 0.63 to 0.95). There were no group differences on any measure of abstinence.

Conclusions

Provision of snus in a naturalistic context resulted in minimal uptake, and as a whole, undermined quit attempts and did not increase smoking abstinence. Results do not support the unguided, free provision of snus among smokers not motivated to quit as a means to facilitate quit attempts.

Trial registration number NCT01509586, Results.

Reasons for Electronic Nicotine Delivery System use and smoking abstinence at 6 months

A descriptive study of callers to employer and health plan-sponsored quitlines

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2016/04/12/tobaccocontrol-2015-052734.short?g=w_tobaccocontrol_ahead_tab

Abstract

Objective

Describe cigarette smoking abstinence among employer and health plan-sponsored quitline registrants who were not using Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems (ENDS), were using ENDS to quit smoking or were using ENDS for other reasons at the time of quitline registration.

Methods

We examined 6029 quitline callers aged ≥18 years who smoked cigarettes at registration, and completed ≥1 counselling calls, baseline ENDS use questions and a 6-month follow-up survey (response rate: 52.4%). 30-day point prevalence smoking quit rates (PPQRs) were assessed at 6-month follow-up (ENDS-only users were considered quit). Data were weighted for non-response bias. Logistic regression analyses controlled for participant characteristics and programme engagement.

Results

At registration, 13.8% of respondents used ENDS (7.9% to quit smoking, 5.9% for other reasons). 30-day PPQRs were: 55.1% for callers using ENDS to quit, 43.1% for callers using ENDS for other reasons, and 50.8% for callers not using ENDS at registration. Callers using ENDS for other reasons were less likely to quit than other groups (adjusted ORs=0.65–0.77); quit rates did not significantly differ between non-ENDS users and those using ENDS to quit. Among callers using ENDS to quit at baseline, 40% used ENDS regularly at follow-up.

Conclusions

ENDS users not using ENDS to quit smoking were less successful at quitting at 6-month follow-up compared with callers using ENDS to quit smoking and callers who did not use ENDS at programme registration. Incorporating reasons for ENDS use may be important for future studies examining the role of ENDS in tobacco cessation.

How To Quit Smoking? Science Unravels Best Strategy For Smokers

http://www.inquisitr.com/2984633/how-to-quit-smoking-science-unravels-best-strategy-for-smokers/

Many smokers have grappled with one rather perturbing question for years: How to call it quits once and for all? Finally, a new study on smoking habits seems to have addressed the question compellingly. The study published in the journal Annals of Internal Medicine has brought to light some revealing findings in this regard.

Smokers are usually quite happy to contend that gradually cutting down the number of sticks each day over a period of time as opposed to quitting instantly or using the so-called “cold turkey” approach is perhaps the most effective strategy for quitting the habit. New findings from the Oxford University study based on a compelling survey of smokers has suggested that the latter could, in fact, be the best possible way to purge away the habit.

The study observed nearly 700 regular smokers in the UK who had demonstrated the inclination to quit the habit over the subsequent two weeks. Fifty percent of these smokers were encouraged to continue smoking the usual way until the end of the two-week period followed by a period of immediate abstinence. The other 50 percent were asked to gradually curb their number of cigarettes each day over the same period until the quitting day. Subsequently, smoking habits of both the groups were examined a month after quitting followed by another six-month follow-up survey.

The results revealed that the success rates after four weeks for smokers who had refrained from smoking altogether had been up to 25 percent higher than those using a gradual cessation approach. An almost similar success rate was documented between the two groups after the designated six months as well.

According to contributing researcher Nicola Lindson-Hawley, although these findings contradict the long-held common-sense way thought by many smokers as the best strategy to curb the tendency, attempting to quit gradually is still better than making no attempt at all.

“Health care workers should offer abrupt quitting first, but if that is not an option, gradual quitting can be a second-line approach. We understand that people might be dead set against quitting abruptly so if the only way they would consider quitting is gradually then the results of this trial suggest it shouldn’t be ruled out.”

Many smokers experience continuous cycles of recurring abstinence and relapse time and again. For most, quitting smoking can become an excruciatingly lengthy battle owing to the many nicotine withdrawal symptoms that follow within days and sometimes even hours after the last cigarette. However, studies have shown that these symptoms are most agonizing during the first three to five days and are likely to subside and even vanish after two to three weeks.

According to the Centers For Disease Control and Prevention, many smokers are tempted to resort to smoking once again owing to the highly unpleasant nicotine withdrawal symptoms oftentimes leading to stress and weight gain. These symptoms are known to include irritability, anger, anxiety, distraction, and sometimes erratic appetite.

The success rate of smokers who choose to cease the habit abruptly compared to those who prefer the gradual cessation approach may be explained by the first group’s early exposure to and, more importantly, success during the withdrawal phase. Similarly, the reduced success rate documented in the smoking habits of the second group in the study may be attributed to a delay in the onset of the same symptoms.

According to experts, few population-based studies have comprehensively studied relapse among former smokers. Researchers have historically maintained that the quantification of the relationship between the duration of abstinence and the likelihood of continued abstinence is critical for the understanding of ongoing public health interventions and the formulation of smoking-cessation initiatives

Evidence, Policy, and E-Cigarettes — Will England Reframe the Debate?

Tobacco-control advocates have been embroiled in a multiyear controversy over whether electronic cigarettes threaten the goal of further reducing tobacco smoking or offer the possibility of minimizing harm for people who cannot or will not quit smoking conventional cigarettes. England and the United States have now staked out very different positions.

The international landscape was dramatically reshaped in August 2015, when Public Health England (PHE), an agency of England’s Department of Health, released a groundbreaking report, “E-cigarettes: an evidence update.” With its claim that e-cigarettes are 95% less harmful than combustible cigarettes, the report attracted headlines internationally. It recommended that smokers who cannot or will not quit smoking tobacco try e-cigarettes and expressed great concern that the public perceived the two products as posing equal risks. Strikingly, the report underscored e-cigarettes’ potential to address the challenge of health inequalities, a central mission of PHE, stating that these devices “potentially offer a wide reach, low-cost intervention to reduce smoking and improve health in these more deprived groups in society where smoking is elevated.”1

The report — written by tobacco-addiction researcher Ann McNeill of King’s College London — reflected the position on e-cigarettes that had been agreed to by the U.K. public health community. Yet the editors of the Lancet asserted that though PHE claims to protect the nation’s health and well-being, it has failed to do so with this report.

Two public health scholars writing in the BMJ also denounced the report, seizing on the methodologic limitations of one of the many studies on which the evidence review had relied, underlining the potential conflicts of interests acknowledged in the paper, and roundly condemning PHE for failing to meet basic evidentiary standards.

Invoking the precautionary principle, the authors asserted that e-cigarette proponents bore the burden of proving that these products are not harmful. In contrast, 12 prominent U.K. public health organizations, including Cancer Research U.K. and the British Lung Foundation, defended PHE. Their joint press release underscored a public health responsibility to encourage smokers to switch to e-cigarettes, perhaps with the help of local smoking-cessation programs.

As dramatic as the report’s recommendations appear to be, they built on the United Kingdom’s long-standing commitment to harm reduction. In 1926, the Ministry of Health’s Rolleston Committee concluded that drug addiction was an illness that should be treated by physicians, sometimes with a minimal dose of drugs in order to prevent withdrawal symptoms. When AIDS came to the United Kingdom in the 1980s, the first government report on human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection among injection-drug users encouraged safer drug practices. Meanwhile, the United States took a prohibitionist position. Tight narcotic regulation and refusal to provide narcotics to addicts as treatment or maintenance defined the U.S. posture for decades.

Application of harm-reduction principles to tobacco products debuted in England in the 1970s, at the Institute of Psychiatry of the Maudsley Hospital. In 1976, Michael Russell, pioneer of effective nicotine-cessation treatments, famously wrote that “People smoke for nicotine but they die from the tar,”2 suggesting that one could satisfy a nicotine craving without risking the harms caused by smoking. Professional medical bodies in the United Kingdom endorsed a harm-reduction perspective. A 2007 report by the Tobacco Advisory Group of the Royal College of Physicians made the case that strategies to protect smokers were key, since nicotine addiction is difficult to overcome and millions of people fail to quit. That report argued “that nicotine itself is not especially hazardous, and that if nicotine could be provided in a form that is acceptable and effective as a cigarette substitute, millions of lives could be saved.”3

Even before e-cigarettes became widely available, the venerable and influential antitobacco organization Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) embraced the development of nicotine products that could rival the nicotine-delivery power of combustible cigarettes. Fiercely opposed to the tobacco industry, ASH had for decades called for increasingly stringent policies to reduce the prevalence of tobacco smoking by imposing higher taxes, banning advertisements, and setting strict limits on smoking in enclosed settings. In 2014, an ASH review of the evidence concluded that fears of a “gateway effect” were unsubstantiated and that e-cigarettes were being used largely by current or former cigarette smokers. Because it found little evidence that nonsmoking bystanders could be harmed by the vapor from e-cigarettes, ASH opposed inclusion of e-cigarettes in public smoke-free laws. Reinforcing his organization’s commitment to harm reduction and the primary goal of assisting smokers who could not or would not give up cigarettes, ASH’s chairman, John Moxham, said, “It would be a public health tragedy if smokers were discouraged from switching to electronic cigarettes and vapers were encouraged to go back to smoking because they don’t understand that vaping is a lot less harmful than smoking. That really would cost lives.”4 Not surprisingly, ASH applauded the findings of the PHE report.

The dominant policy perspective in the United States serves as a foil to the one embraced in England. The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids — ASH’s U.S. equivalent and a powerful voice in anti-tobacco advocacy — has been unequivocal in its denunciations of e-cigarettes. Similarly, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention hosted a Public Health Grand Rounds on e-cigarettes in which all five speakers focused on the possible health risks associated with e-cigarette use. None acknowledged a potential role for e-cigarettes in reducing the tobacco burden in marginalized populations or reducing health disparities. Given the tight focus on potential risks to children and nonsmokers, e-cigarettes were out of the question. But one powerful voice for enhanced tobacco control in the United States did support the PHE report. In December 2015, the Truth Initiative (formerly the American Legacy Foundation) declared in an organizational position paper, “If prudently regulated, we believe ENDS [electronic nicotine delivery systems] hold promise as one means to move smokers to a less harmful product and reduce the devastating death and disease burden caused by combustible tobacco products.”5

What distinguishes the harm-reduction approach taken in the PHE report from the more absolutist approach adopted by U.S. policymakers today is a matter of focus. In England, where leading medical organizations regard nicotine alone as relatively benign, the pressing need to reduce the risks for current smokers frames the debate. The overwhelming focus in the United States is abstinence. It is in this broader context that the focus on children and nonsmokers must be viewed.

Will England change the international conversation about e-cigarettes? The answer will depend, in part, on what the evolving evidence suggests, and it may take years before the answers are definitive. In the end, the sorts of policies that are implemented will depend on whether whoever dominates the debate views harm reduction as opportunity or anathema.

Disclosure forms provided by the authors are available with the full text of this article at NEJM.org.

Source Information

From the Department of Sociomedical Sciences, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York

Phantom smoking among young adult bar patrons

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2016/04/05/tobaccocontrol-2015-052821.short?g=w_tobaccocontrol_ahead_tab

Abstract

Objective

To explore the prevalence and sociodemographic makeup of smokers who do not self-identify as smokers (ie, phantom smokers) compared with self-identifying smokers in a sample of bar-going young adults aged 18–30 years to more accurately assess young adult prevalence of smoking and inform cessation message targeting.

Methods

Cross-sectional surveys of smokers (n=3089) were conducted in randomly selected bars/nightclubs in seven US cities. Logistic regression models assessed associations between phantom smoking (past 30-day smoking and denial of being a smoker), tobacco and alcohol use behaviours (eg, social smoking, nicotine dependence, smoking while drinking, past 30-day alcohol use) and demographics.

Results

Compared with smokers, phantom smokers were more likely to be college graduates (OR=1.43, 95% CI 1.03 to 1.98) and to identify themselves as social smokers (OR=1.60, 95% CI 1.27 to 2.12). Phantom smokers had lower odds of smoking while drinking (OR=0.28, 95% CI 0.25 to 0.32), being nicotine dependent (OR=0.36, 95% CI 0.22 to 0.76) and having quit for at least 1 day in the last year (OR=0.46, 95% CI 0.36 to 0.69) compared with smokers.

Conclusions

This research extends phantom smoking literature on college students to provide a broader picture of phantom smoking among young adults in high-risk contexts and of varying levels of educational attainment. Phantom smokers may be particularly sensitive to social pressures against smoking, suggesting the importance of identifying smoking as a behaviour (rather than identity) in cessation messaging to ensure that phantom smokers are reached.

Lion Rock Institute’s Andrew Shuen defames Dr Judith Mackay on RTHK3’s 123 Show

Download (PDF, 744KB)

Download (PDF, 505KB)

Download (PDF, 510KB)

We’re unsure if e-cigarettes are harmful, but it still makes sense to restrict them

https://theconversation.com/were-unsure-if-e-cigarettes-are-harmful-but-it-still-makes-sense-to-restrict-them-55777

E-cigarettes have rapidly risen in popularity in recent years and are now the subject of heated debate as to whether they are effective in helping smokers quit tobacco or whether they are actually making smoking attractive to young people. Are they a way for Big Tobacco to protect its profits in markets where smoking is declining and lure people back into nicotine addiction or are they just a fashion that will quickly lose its appeal?

Given that vaping has been around for barely a decade and studies into the long-term effects take time, we cannot answer these questions with certainty yet. The benefits of e-cigarettes’ continue to be debated – and the potential risks to non-smokers and young people remain under-explored.

This makes it difficult to make recommendations, but politicians across the world are nonetheless having to decide what to do. The latest country to confront this question is Scotland, where the parliament has just voted to ban under-18s from using e-cigarettes. One of a raft of restrictions, this imposes the same age limit as for traditional cigarettes, bringing Scotland broadly into line with England and Wales. Was it the right thing to do?

Different countries have taken different approaches to vaping. Canada has technically made sales illegal, though regulation remains largely unenforced. While regulation across the US is mixed, San Francisco has just raised the minimum buying age from 18 to 21 years.

In some European countries, – among them Bulgaria, Ireland and Poland – sales and advertising are unregulated. In May, however, new EU regulations will impose standardised quality control on liquids and vaporisers across the union as well as requiring disclosure of ingredients in vaping liquids and child-proofing and tamper-proofing for liquid packaging. They will also restrict cross-border advertising. Wales meanwhile looks likely to extend its restrictions by introducing a ban on e-cigarettes in public places.

The ayes and the noes

In the run up to the vote on the new Scottish Health Bill, opponents and supporters of e-cigarette regulations fiercely debated which approach was the most sensible. Opponents usually argue that vaping is less harmful than traditional cigarettes and effective in helping smokers to quit. They want minimal restrictions on availability and complete freedom for advertising, promotion and the use of e-cigarettes in public. Restrictions, they argue, might prevent smokers from switching to safer alternatives and reduce the chances of curbing tobacco consumption.

Supporters of regulation say that children and young people need to be protected from using products which imitate smoking and from developing nicotine addiction. They also favour regulation to ensure product safety and quality. They advocate a precautionary approach until there is evidence that e-cigarettes do not undermine our recent successes at controlling tobacco.

As well as banning sales to under-18s, the new Scottish laws require retailers to ask for proof of age when selling to someone that looks under 25 (similar to alcohol). They ban the sale of e-cigarettes from vending machines, make it an offence to buy on behalf of someone under 18, and require retailers to put their names on a product register. Scottish ministers will also have the power to further restrict or prohibit advertising and promotions in future.

Tighter shackles, please

While the evidence about the risks of e-cigarettes is likely to remain unclear for several years, the Scottish parliament can at least say it is doing what the country wants. A large majority of respondents backed regulation in the consultation of 2014, including representatives of health bodies, local authorities, charities, academics and members of the public. As well as supporting a ban on sales to under-18s or adults buying e-cigarettes on their behalf and preventing young people from seeing advertising and promotions, respondents also widely endorsed restricting the use of e-cigarettes in public places.

‘Save me from myself’ Milles Studio

The Scottish public’s desire for these kinds of rules is also reflected in research I co-published that looked at debates about e-cigarettes in the UK media and found that supporters of regulation greatly outnumbered opponents. I have also been involved in a new study, about to be published, which investigates the views of UK adolescents on regulation. We found they have a very sophisticated understanding of the advantages and disadvantages. While aware of the potential benefits of e-cigarettes to smokers – including those teenage smokers who want to quit – young people overwhelmingly support strong e-cigarette regulation. This includes restrictions on sales to minors, marketing and the use of e-cigarettes in public places.

The reality is that, until the jury returns, it makes sense to trust the public to reach a view from the best information on e-cigarettes that is available. Even if current regulations were to end up looking disproportionate in years to come, no one will be able to accuse the Scottish government of ignoring people’s concerns and taking public health issues lightly. In a situation where no one really knows what to do for the best, regulation which restricts access and promotion to young people looks like the best policy.