Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Tobacco Unpacked: Shadowy lobbying against Tobacco Products Directive

from the blog Tobacco Unpacked:

by Andy Rowell, research fellow at the Tobacco Control Research Group, University of Bath, and editor of TobaccoTactics.org

European Parliament MEPs will debate the landmark Tobacco Products Directive, seen by public health advocates as a crucial measure in reducing the harm from tobacco across the EU.

For the last two-and-a-half years, we have been monitoring the activities of the tobacco industry under a ground-breaking academic project at the University of Bath, which has been part funded by Cancer Research UK. Instead of just focusing our output on academic journals we have also developed a wiki, called TobaccoTactics.org, which has more timely access to our research findings.

SOPHISTICATED PR

Tobacco is unique. No other product kills one in two of its long-term users. If someone invented the cigarette today, it would never make it onto a supermarket shelf. It is now over 60 years since the link between cancer and smoking was first discovered, but millions of us remain addicted.

The reason for this, in part, is one of the most sophisticated and well-funded public relations campaigns ever undertaken by an industry. The tobacco companies set out to deny the scientific evidence of the harmfulness of their product and the addictiveness of nicotine. The object is always to try to sow confusion and doubt and delay action.

Such tactics have again been evident in the multi-million-pound lobbying campaign the industry has inflicted in recent months on Brussels. New leaked documents from Philip Morris International (PMI) reveal the extent of this campaign, which targeted the three pillars of Brussels decision-making: the European Parliament, the European Commission and European Council.

PUSH OR DELAY

The documents reveal that by mid-2012, the overall strategic objective of PMI’s lobbying campaign was to either “Push” (i.e. amend) or “Delay” the Directive and “block” the proposals coming from the relevant Directorate on health, DG Sanco, which was in charge of the proposals. To this end, PMI employed a two-fold technical and political strategy to ensure it received as many “negative opinions” from other Commission DGs as possible, as well as to try and ensure a political commitment from other business-friendly Commissioners to oppose what PMI was labelling as excessive legislation. PMI identified key messages to push in its lobbying campaign, especially in relation to the Inter-Service Consultation between the directorates, arguing there was a need to “break” into the “silo” of the European Commission. The main lobbying messages used by the company were that the TPD proposals lacked “legal basis”, “evidence”, “logic” and a “market analysis”.

“TRIGGER NEGATIVE OPINIONS”

Just as PMI had done fighting proposals on Point of Sale and Plain Packaging in the UK, the tobacco giant was keen to highlight the “illicit trade problem”, despite its historical involvement in smuggling. For more information on this see TobaccoTactics.org on smuggling. The company set out to “trigger negative opinions” amongst other Commissioners or their senior advisors, known as their cabinet, and set out to get other “high-level influencers” to directly engage with the Commissioners. The tobacco companies such as PMI have a history of using so-called third party techniques in their lobbying campaign, using other organisations or people to influence the debate on the industry’s behalf.

The reason is simple: the use of third parties removes the message from the interested messenger. Moreover, the tobacco industry is such a discredited voice that it has to look for someone else to be its ventriloquist dummy. The public or a politician may be sympathetic about a corner shop going out of business, but they would have less sympathy towards an industry which kills its long-term customers and whose profits stretch into billions.

LED BY THIRD PARTIES

The documents reveal that PMI’s anti-TPD lobbying campaign, via social and traditional media, would be “led by third parties”. The tobacco giant identified tobacco growers, small and medium-sized businesses, other trade organisations, unions, suppliers, intellectual property organisations, employers’ associations and even consumer associations to front its campaign for it.
And just as the industry used retailers against Point of Sale Display Ban and Plain Packaging in the UK, so they have been central to PMI’s lobbying campaign in Brussels. PMI outlined how the retailers would lobby other parts of the Commission and “promote events to gain visibility” for the campaign. As well as retailers based in Brussels, national retailers associations across the EU were also brought in to help, too.

Another key constituency to front the campaign were tobacco growers and processors. PMI organised meetings between tobacco growers’ unions, such as UNITAB, the European Association of Tobacco Growers and Fetratab, the European Federation of Tobacco Processors, with key officials at the Commission, including a meeting with the Cabinet of the European President Manuel Barroso.

DIRECT LOBBYING

The leaked documents also outline in detail PMI’s strategy in the European Parliament. This time, the tobacco giant undertook direct lobbying as well as indirect. By mid-2012, nearly a third of MEPs had been lobbied by PMI, some 233 MEPs in total. Some MEPs by then had met the tobacco giant four to five times, with meetings happening on a regular basis. Almost half of the European People’s Party and European centre-right groups met with PMI’s lobbyists, the documents show.

At the parliament, the company also focused its lobbying efforts on two influential committees, ENVI and IMCO. The ENVI committee – Environment, Public Health and Food Safety – was tasked with overseeing the TPD through the Parliament. PMI set out to “Break ENVI’s full control on the dossier.” Heads of national delegations were lobbied, as were the “political heavyweights” from each political party. The company sought to “secure political agreement though top level contacts”.

EXCLUDING MENTHOL FLAVOUR

PMI also set out to lobby the Council, in order to create a “blocking majority” against any public health measures it deemed “extreme”. One of these measures is the banning of certain flavours including menthol. PMI’s objective was “exclude” menthol from the TPD. It wanted to get different member states with “significant menthol segments to oppose a menthol ban in TPD at the Council”.

In order to do this it wanted to “neutralise” lead countries in the menthol debate, such as Germany. The use of language such as this is indicative. Here we have a transnational company effectively planning to politically nullify the most powerful EU country. This multi-million-euro lobbying campaign raises all kinds of issues, two of which are deeply important for public health and the political process. The fact that PMI has had such extensive access to the Commission and hundreds of MEPs is clearly a breach of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. Article 5.3 of the Convention requires signatories to protect their health policies “from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry”. This clearly has not happened in this case.

VIOLATION OF TOBACCO CONTROL CONVENTION

Last week, 11 public health and transparency NGOs wrote to President of the European Parliament to argue these meetings constitute “a serious violation” of the Convention.

“We are deeply concerned about the astounding level of access to MEPs by tobacco lobbyists which has been exposed in the leaked Philip Morris International documents,” they wrote.

PMI has also voluntarily signed up to the EU’s Transparency Initiative and is meant to accurately record how many lobbyists and how much money it is spending lobbying in Brussels. The documents reveal that PMI has been using a significant number of lobbyists and consultants. One spread-sheet outlines that 161 employees and consultants were engaged in lobbying concerning the TPD. By mid-2012, the documents also reveal, PMI had spent €1.25 million on consultancy and expenses fighting the proposals.

TPD MAY BE PUT BACK YEARS

In contrast, PMI only declares nine lobbyists in its entry to the EU Transparency Register. For the whole of 2012, the company estimated that its lobbying spend had been €1 million–€1.25 million. Behind the scenes we know the lobbying will continue right up to any vote. Via the documents we only have a small snapshot of how widespread and pervasive PMI’s lobbying campaign has been. PMI’s key aims are to reduce the size of health warnings and ensure menthol cigarettes are not banned. If the industry can delay the vote at the Parliament and also at the council again, the whole Directive may be put back years. So, just as it has done many times before, the industry will have delayed action, whilst the profits keep rolling in.

7 Oct 2013

Indonesia brings fifth WTO challenge to Australia tobacco laws | Reuters

http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/20/ah-wto-australia-tobacco-idUSL
5N0HG2QD20130920

UPDATE 1-Indonesia brings fifth WTO challenge to Australia tobacco laws

Fri Sep 20, 2013 12:38pm EDT

By Tom Miles

(Reuters) – Indonesia launched a complaint against Australia’s stringent
tobacco packaging laws on Friday, becoming the fifth country to raise
the restrictions at the World Trade Organization.

Australia has forced cigarette manufacturers to sell their products in
drab green packets with no colourful logos since late 2012, as part of a
health drive to cut down on the number of smokers.

Tobacco companies say their trademark rights are being infringed by the
restrictions, which are widely seen as a test case for other schemes
around the world.

Australia’s laws broke trade agreements on technical barriers to trade
and intellectual property rights, Indonesia said, according to a
statement from the WTO.

Ukraine, Honduras, Dominican Republic and Cuba have already filed
complaints at the WTO about Australia’s laws.

The earliest WTO ruling on the cases could come around mid-2014, with a
possible final appeal judgment in the second half of the year.

The case could take months longer, however, if the other complainants
decide to wait for Indonesia to catch up, and some WTO disputes have
dragged on for years

Lobbyists puff and blow over new EU tobacco rules

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-23330553

Lobbyists puff and blow over new EU tobacco rules

By Jane Deith File on 4, Brussels

Olivier Hoedeman Olivier Hoedeman criticises the tobacco industry’s lobbying tactics in Brussels

Continue reading the main story

Related Stories

Olivier Hoedeman takes people on unusual tours of Brussels – he opens their eyes to the billions of euros that multinationals, unions and campaign groups spend trying to shape – even rewrite – the European laws made there.

The research and campaign coordinator of Corporate Europe Observatory – which monitors lobbying – pauses outside a smart office block, a few streets away from the European Parliament.

He points to the second floor and the offices of British American Tobacco. It has seven full-time lobbyists here and Mr Hoedeman says the tobacco industry as a whole employs around 100 in Brussels, spending more than 5m euros (£4.3m; $6.6m) a year.

Those numbers have grown as the industry fights proposed new regulation.

The European Commission is beefing up the Tobacco Products Directive, to try to dissuade young people from smoking.

So, for example, there would be a ban on menthol cigarettes and some other flavourings and bigger pictorial health warnings on packets.

Lobbying battlefield

Tobacco firms “directly lobby MEPs, trying to meet with him or her to talk them into tabling amendments, but also [organise] social events, like dinner parties for MEPs’ assistants,” Mr Hoedeman says.

“We have already seen in several of the votes of committees of parliament that the Commission’s proposals are being weakened. It shows they’re gaining ground and achieving that goal.”

Continue reading the main story

“Start Quote

Linda McAvan MEP

Why don’t they just operate like every other company that lobbies the European Parliament? ”

End Quote Linda McAvan MEP

The lobbying appears to be having an impact. Almost 1,500 amendments to the tobacco directive have been tabled.

The EU’s health ministers, for example, voted to drop a ban on slim cigarettes, and reduce the size of the graphic health warnings, from the 75% the European Commission wanted, to 65%.

But last week the parliament’s public health committee voted to keep that ban, as well as a ban on cigarette flavourings, and backed the 75% target. So more hard bargaining lies ahead, and the full parliament will vote on 10 September.

The EU has an online database of lobbyists called the Transparency Register. But it does not tell the whole story: the register is voluntary and hundreds of lobbyists simply choose not to reveal themselves. There is no information about whom they have lobbied.

Special rules are supposed to apply to the tobacco industry. The EU has signed up to a World Health Organization treaty which says politicians should avoid meeting tobacco companies; if they must, the meeting has to be transparent.

But the British MEP piloting the tobacco legislation through parliament, Linda McAvan, says that away from the main lobbying battlefield the tobacco companies have been firing salvoes below the radar.

She accuses one of ringing her constituency office, posing as a representative of small retailers to demand an urgent meeting.

‘Legal company’

EU Commissioner Tonio Borg with cigarette pack, 19 Dec 12Tonio Borg from Malta is now negotiating for the EU Commission on the revised directive

Other tobacco lobbyists, she said, have been handing out anonymous amendments to MEPs, in the hope they will be put forward.

“If they think it’s legitimate, why are doing it like that? Why don’t they just operate like every other company that lobbies the European Parliament and just send it out in a normal email? I think they know that if people know they’re from the tobacco industry, they’ll be suspicious of the arguments they make,” said Ms McAvan.

Ronan Barry describes himself as a corporate affairs professional for British American Tobacco and heads their Brussels lobbying operation, which cost nearly 1m euros to run last year.

He says his company is always open and honest, and he does not recognise the tactics described by the MEP.

He believes tobacco companies have as much right to meet MEPs as any other business and says the scale of the tobacco lobby is often exaggerated.

“We sell a legal product and are a legal company and therefore have a role to play in communicating our point of view to people who make decisions that impact upon us.

There are certainly at least as many lobbyists arguing against our positions as there are arguing for them, so it’s not true to say there are armies of us here lobbying,” said Mr Barry.

A British Conservative MEP, Martin Callanan, echoed that view. “This idea they put across that it’s a sort of David and Goliath – these industrial giants with thousands of well-paid, suited lobbyists and only one or two little NGOs representing the oppressed common man is very, very far from the truth – it’s the other way round if anything.”

On average, non-governmental organisations (NGOs) in Brussels get 43% of their funding from EU institutions.

‘Billions of euros’

In the past year the lobbying debate on both sides has been overshadowed by a scandal involving the former commissioner who was supposed to be driving the tobacco directive, John Dalli.

At the centre of so-called “Dalligate” is an allegation that a friend of Mr Dalli asked for 60m euros to overturn a ban on snus – a moist chewing tobacco which you put under your lip.

Mr Dalli and his friend both strenuously deny the allegation.

An investigation by Europe’s anti-fraud office Olaf says that although it has circumstantial evidence linking Mr Dalli to the bribe request, that evidence is not conclusive.

Speaking from his home in Malta, Mr Dalli claims he is the victim of a conspiracy: “I was considered as a person who was very hard on the tobacco industry and they didn’t want that during their campaign.

“I’m already hearing about a lot of dilution that is being made to the directive because of the tobacco lobbies that have been very active.

“I’m afraid that what’s going to go through, if it goes through, is not as effective as one would like and what is the gain? The gain is billions of euros.”

Tobacco debate ‘hotting up’ as Council details leaked to industry

Published: 15 May 2013

The content of European Council working party meetings on the EU’s tobacco policy review is being leaked to the industry, said an EU source who added that the debate is “hotting up”.

Background

The first tobacco control legislation in the EU was introduced in the 1980s. Since then, EU legislation and policy has been further developed in the areas of product regulation, advertising and protecting people from second-hand smoke, as well as prevention.

Health Commissioner Tonio Borg is set to widen the scope of cigarette-trading rules to cover potentially harmful electronic cigarettes, flavourings and marketing strategies – potentially including plain packaging – as part of a revision of the 2001 Tobacco Products Directive.

The tobacco industry receives notes and documents from ministerial meetings on the revision of the Tobacco Products Directive and prepares lobbying materials targeting specific policymakers, and the tobacco lobby has sent out the campaign letters using the information as soon as one day after they took place.

“There is an issue that reports of working party meetings are obviously going to tobacco industry,” said the source. “Somewhere in the chain there’s a leakage of reports. Then industry goes to certain capitals and complains about the positions taken up by some member states.

“That shouldn’t really be happening. They shouldn’t be engaging with the tobacco industry on issues of public health policy. It’s hotting up at the moment. It’s getting more real,” he said.

The European Council holds working party meetings with national representatives and members of the Commission. Decisions taken at the meetings are sent back to national experts who mull over the legislative amendments. Representatives then reconvene to discuss the proposals of the national experts.

The Council has held so far nine meetings on the revision of the tobacco directive, with another five scheduled for before June when ministers are expected to take up an official position.

The next meeting on the tobacco directive is due on Thursday (16 May), but it may be delayed due to recent strikes at the Council, an unexpected boon for the tobacco industry.

‘Bombarded’

The tobacco industry, which employs over 100 full-time lobbyists in Brussels, is also waging an intense campaign in the European Parliament. MEPs complain of receiving dozens of e-mails, letters and brochures

“MEPs will tell you they’re being bombarded. It’s often through front organisations acting on their [tobacco’s] behalf,” the source told EurActiv.

The source said that the industry produces reports predicting, for example, a rise in illicit tobacco trade if the Commission’s proposals go through in their current form.

The industry also applies pressure closer to home. “We had a lobbyist from the tobacco industry – BAT [British American Tobacco] if I remember correctly – trying to organise small retailers in my constituency to complain about the draft Commission law,” the British MEP drafting the amendments, Linda McAvan, said in emailed comments.

Economic arguments are particularly prevalent, holding more sway during the economic crisis. Anti-smoking campaigners have accused the British government of stalling on plans for standardised, “plain” packaging because industry claimed it would move its packaging suppliers abroad if the government carried through with the move.

“Since the UK government has u-turned on their plan to introduce plain packaging, we may see an increase as industry turns their attention to Brussels,” said McAvan, a Labour politician.

The aggressive campaign may be working. “The positions of some member states closely resemble the tobacco industry position,” another source said.

Some political groups also may have been influenced by the industry, he said, adding that some UK Independence Party MEPs often present arguments which closely resemble those of the industry.

Other politicians in the Parliament’s Europe of Freedom and Democracy Group, such as members of the eurosceptic Italian Northern League, have also given statements which appear like a pure copy and paste from industry campaign materials. “But sometimes this is broken down on national lines rather than political groups,” the source said.

“MEPs should be careful about meeting with the lobbyists but it depends on the political group how careful they are.”

In general these MEPs are pro-industry and regard EU regulation on smoking as indicative of a supranational “nanny state”.

The Commission and the Irish EU presidency are attempting to push through the amendments to the tobacco directive as soon as possible to avoid the inevitable delays that would be caused by next year’s European elections.

The Commission says that its proposed amendments to EU tobacco rules would see only a 2% drop in consumption over five years, stressing that the measures will not affect regular smokers but are aimed at preventing uptake amongst the youth.

Positions

“There is very intense lobbying at the moment to the influence the outcome. They are trying every trick in the book at national and EU level,” said a Council source.

European Health and Consumer Policy Commissioner Tonio Borg told European lawmakers to be wary of the “economic arguments” for less regulation which were “very persuasive in an economic crisis.”

Florence Bertelli Kemp, director of the Smoke Free Partnership, called the tobacco lobby “Goliath”, saying it sows “myths and lies to create fear”. She called for MEPs to strengthen the regulation and introduce plain packaging.

“It is not surprising that there is a huge amount of lobbying – this is to be expected given the figures – e.g. the tobacco industry has hired about 100 full-time lobbyists to lobby the EU institutions alone,” said British Labour MEP Linda McAvan​.

“Mr Borg kept his word that the release of the revised TPD would be one of his priorities when taking up the Health and Consumer portfolio. This long-delayed revision is a leap towards better health protection of hundreds of millions of people in Europe. I hope this is a watershed moment for the relationship between the Commission and the tobacco industry, and indicates a move towards greater transparency,“ said Monika Kosińska, secretary general of the European Public Health Alliance, on the release of the Commission’s revision of the tobacco directive.

Next Steps

  • 16 May 2013: Scheduled Council working party meeting
  • June 2013: Expected formal Council position

Tobacco display ban in large shops comes into force

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-22332048

28 April 2013 Last updated at 23:01 GMT

Cigarettes displayed in cabinet

Cigarettes can no longer be displayed in Scottish shops

A ban on the display of cigarettes and other tobacco products in large shops in Scotland has come into force.

Public Health Minister Michael Matheson said the move will help prevent young people from taking up smoking.

Under the Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Act 2010, the sale of cigarettes from vending machines is also banned.

Stores that do not comply could be convicted of a criminal offence or receive a fixed penalty fine.

England, Wales and Northern Ireland have already brought in similar bans to prevent large stores from displaying cigarettes and tobacco.

The Scottish government’s Tobacco Control Strategy also supports the introduction of standardised packaging.

‘Right step’

Mr Matheson said: “These bans are the right step to prevent young people in Scotland from taking up smoking.

“It is well known that smoking is associated with a range of illness and is the primary preventable cause of ill health and premature death. Each year, tobacco use is associated with over 13,000 deaths and 56,000 hospital admissions in Scotland.

“That is why it is so important that this government works to improve health by reducing the number of people who choose to smoke and evidence shows that young people exposed to the promotion of tobacco are more likely to try smoking.”

The move has been welcomed by Cancer Research Scotland but the Tobacco Retailers’ Alliance (TRA) – which represents more than 26,000 shopkeepers across the UK – has argued against the legislation.

And the Scottish Grocers’ Federation said it will mean longer transaction times at the till and confusion over pricing.

It also believes the new laws will not make any difference and that smokers will still smoke.

John Drummond, from the federation, told BBC Scotland: “We think it’s unnecessary. We don’t believe that displays of cigarettes behind the counter actually influences anyone to buy cigarettes.

“There is no doubt that smoking can be harmful but it’s a legal practice.

“We stock it, sell it, and will continue to do so.”

Large shops are defined as those with a relevant floor area exceeding 280 square metres.

Smaller retailers have until 6 April 2015 to comply with the display ban.

Smoking in vehicles

Meanwhile, a consultation on proposed legislation to ban smoking in vehicles when children are present is to be launched by Liberal Democrat MSP Jim Hume.

Mr Hume said such a ban has already gained support from a number of charities, including Children in Scotland and the British Heart Foundation.

The South of Scotland MSP will launch the consultation on proposals for his Members Bill next month.

He said banning adults from smoking in cars when children are present is the next step in tobacco control.

“Passive smoking is entirely avoidable and a private vehicle is one of the few places a child can still be legally exposed to tobacco smoke,” he said.

“I stand alongside the British Heart Foundation, British Lung Foundation, Children in Scotland and ASH Scotland, among many others, in seeking a change to the law and hope that people and organisations from across Scotland can take part in this important consultation.

“It doesn’t seem fair that any child should have to be trapped in a car which is filled with smoke. When you consider the real implications this can have for a child’s immediate and future health, it is clear we need to do what we can to protect children and give them the best start in life.”

High Court Rejects Tobacco Marketing Appeal

The Wall Street Journal

http://leadback.advertising.com/adcedge/lb?site=695501&srvc=1&betr=wsj_snippet_cs=1&betq=4544=381370http://leadback.advertising.com/adcedge/lb?site=695501&srvc=1&betr=wsj_snippet_cs=2&betq=4544=381371

Updated April 22, 2013, 3:14 p.m. ET

High Court Rejects Tobacco Marketing Appeal

BY BRENT KENDALL AND JENNIFER CORBETT DOOREN

The Supreme Court on Monday rejected a tobacco industry challenge to a 2009 federal law that requires graphic warning labels on cigarettes and expanded marketing restrictions on tobacco products.

The challengers argued that parts of the law, which gave the Food and Drug Administration the authority to regulate tobacco, violated their constitutional free-speech rights. The companies challenging it include R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. and Lorillard Tobacco Co.

The law mandated that tobacco manufacturers allow half of the space on the front and back of cigarette packages for graphic health warnings. It also barred marketing practices … http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323735604578438594078101904.html#printMode

South Africa: Smokers Take Note – Current and Future Tobacco Regulation

By Wilma Stassen, 18 March 2013

Tobacco legislation in South Africa is constantly changing, and ignorant smokers may find themselves on the wrong side of the law with fines of up to R100 000. Here’s what smokers should know, and new changes thay can expect in future.

Smokers in New Zealand will soon buy their cigarettes in boring brown packaging with graphic pictures of smoking-related disease and the brand name displayed in a small, plain font.

This island country is following the lead of its southwest Pacific neighbour, Australia, who was the first country to introduce plain packaging of tobacco products last December. Australia went ahead with the legislation despite legal threats from the tobacco industry and tobacco-growing countries.

The motivation behind this new legislation is to strip tobacco products of any “glamour” or marketing that might be attached to brand names, a move, experts believe will stop young people from taking up the habit in the first place.

“Plain packaging is not a ‘shot in the dark’, as the tobacco industry would have us believe,” said Patricia Lambert from the US-based Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids.

“Credible international behavioural scientists conducted exhaustive tests to determine the effects of plain packaging as a public health measure on the general public before making recommendations to the Australian government. They have provided scientific evidence that the introduction of plain packaging will deter young people from becoming addicted to tobacco products and may also assist addicted smokers to quit.”

Last year, when congratulating the Australian government on the new legislation, the South African Minister of Health, Dr Aaron Motsoaledi – who has been driving stricter smoking regulation for this country as well – said plain packaging will also be introduced here sometime in the future.

“South Africa and other governments should first implement pictorial warnings that cover 75 percent of the front and back of every packet of tobacco or cigarettes. After that, they will be in a position to move towards plain packaging,” said Lambert.

Although plain packaging in South Africa is still several years away, there are other recent changes, or changes in the pipeline, to the Tobacco Control Act that can land a perpetrator with a fine of up to R100 000 fine.

“This legislation works so well, because people want it to work,” said Peter Ucko from the National Council Against Smoking (NCAS).

The law states that the person in control of a public place is responsible for enforcing the smoking ban. For instance, at a restaurant, the manager or owner should ensure the law is enforced, or at a cricket match, the managers or organisers of the event would have to train security personnel and other staff to ensure people only smoke in designated areas.

If the law is not enforced, any member of the public can lay a complaint by contacting the health department at the local municipality, or open a docket at the nearest police station. Some municipalities, like Cape Town, have a dedicated tobacco complaints line that deals only with these types of complaints.

Once a police docket has been opened, or a complaint has been laid and investigated, the offending party (be it a restaurant owner or events manager) will receive an official warning, and in other instances a fine.

According to Ucko, many fines have been issued to businesses and venues that have failed to enforce the law and admission of guilt fines paid.

Here is what South Africans need to know.

Current legislation

A number of tobacco laws are often misunderstood or plainly ignored.

– No smoking is allowed in a public enclosed or partially enclosed space, unless it is a designated smoking area. Currently no more than 25 percent of any premises may be allocated to the smoking area – up to R50 000 fine.

This law is occasionally ignored by restaurant, pub and night club owners who allow smoking anywhere on their premises or in areas larger than the prescribed 25 percent. This law also applies to partially enclosed areas such as sport stadiums and other event venues, where smoking is only allowed in designated areas – this does not include staircases and walkways.

– Tobacco products may not be sold or supplied to anyone under the age of 18 – up to R100 000 fine.

As with alcohol, no cigarettes or tobacco products may be sold or supplied to anyone under the age of 18. The law includes the sale of flavoured tobacco products used for smoking the hookah pipe, or hubbly bubbly, which is gaining popularity among the youth.

– Children under the age of 18 are not allowed in a designated smoking area – up to R50 000 fine.

Some restaurateurs allow families with young children to sit in the smoking section of a restaurant because adults in the group want to smoke. The restaurant manager is required to ensure that no person under the age of 18 is present.

– No smoking is allowed in a motor vehicle where a child younger than 12 years is present – up to R50 000 fine.

Under no circumstances is smoking allowed in any motor vehicle while there is a child under the age of 12 present. Despite the well-publicised dangers of second-hand smoke, many adults, including parents, still light up with children in the car thinking that opening a window is enough.

– Cigarettes may not be sold individually – up to R100 000 fine.

The law states that tobacco products may not be sold “loose”, and may only be sold in packages as prescribed in the regulations. Whilst the size of the package has not been specified, it must contain information such as the health warning and quit line number. Selling cigarettes individually make it more affordable to children who may not have been able to afford to buy a whole packet.

Regulation in the pipeline

There are several regulations proposed which are in the process of being passed into law. These regulations have been published in the Government Gazette and after receipt of public comment are currently being considered by the Minister of Health. The following regulations are expected to be published and come into force this year:

– Smoking will be not be allowedinside any building, and smoking in certain outdoor areas, for example, beaches , sport stadiums, etc. will be regulated. Smoking will not be permitted at all in outdoor eating or drinking places, covered walkways or parking areas or within five meters of any doorway, entrance to a public place, or window or ventilation inlet.

Under these regulations, smoking will not be allowed in any public building, and smoking rooms, or designated smoking areas will not be permitted inside buildings. Smokers will have to smoke in a designated area outside that is at least five metres away from windows and doorways.

Smoking will also be banned or controlled in certain outdoor areas, for instance parks or beaches.

Smoking will not be allowed in any drinking or eating areas, therefore no more outdoor smoking areas at restaurants, bars or pubs.

– Cigarette displays in shops.

Currently tobacco companies use displays at the point-of-sales to advertise and market their products. These displays are believed to encourage people, especially the youth, to start smoking and make it more difficult for smokers to quit. New legislation is being considered that will limit the size and number of tobacco product displays at retailers.

Regulation currently under discussion

There are also other tobacco regulations that are currently being discussed that will possibly become legislation within the foreseeable future.

– Graphic health warnings on tobacco products.

It is expected that the Minister of Health will order graphic health warnings to be placed on cigarette boxes and other tobacco packaging. In other countries, visual images of, for example, smoker’s lungs, or tobacco-related cancers, have proven more effective than the text warnings that currently appear on South African tobacco packaging.

Tobacco complaint lines:

Cape Town – 021 400 4291

Johannesburg – 011 407 6111

Bloemfontein – 0800 111 3000

News for 07 March 2013

HEADLINES

Tobacco shares fall on possible UK regulation

Tobacco company shares fell in trading on Wednesday following the news that the UK government may follow Australia’s lead and impose plain packaging for cigarettes.

See also:
– Imperial Tobacco Slides on News of U.K. Plain Packaging Law, Bloomberg
– Tobacco stocks suffer on plain packaging fear, City AM

Source: Yahoo!/AP – 06 March 2013
Link: http://yhoo.it/ZfTDZc

Lords gather evidence on the proposed revision of the Tobacco Products Directive

The House of Lords Home Affairs, Health and Education EU Sub-Committee conducted enhanced scrutiny of the EU’s proposed revision of the Tobacco Products Directive on Wednesday 6 March.
Source: GovToday – 06 March 2013
Link: http://bit.ly/ZfUmK4

U.K. still mulling plain cigarette packaging, official says

The U.K. government is still considering proposals to make plain packaging compulsory for tobacco products, Prime Minister David Cameron’s spokesman said after the Guardian reported that the country will follow Australia in introducing such a law as early as May.

“A process of consultation has been going on,” Jean- Christophe Gray told reporters in London today. “No decisions have yet been taken. On the issue around smoking in cars, there are no plans to change policy in that direction.”

See also:
– Plain packaging could be given green light, Convenience Store

Source: Bloomberg – 06 March 2013
Link: http://bloom.bg/ZfYp9h

EU: Ombudsman launches investigation into Dalli departure

The European Ombudsman has launched an investigation into the resignation of John Dalli as European commissioner for health and consumer policy, and asked the European Commission to hand over all files relating to his departure.

The investigation follows a complaint made earlier this year by the transparency campaign group Corporate Europe Observatory, which accused the Commission of selectively releasing documents relating to the case and failing to fulfil its obligations under EU transparency laws.

Source: European Voice – 06 March 2013
Link: http://bit.ly/ZfUDg6

Fight tobacco marketing, boost vaccinations to curb cancer, says report

Fighting the tobacco industry’s tactics in the world’s poorest countries and ensuring the best vaccines get to those most in need are key to cutting the number of cancer deaths worldwide, according to a report by specialists in the disease published by the journal Science Translational Medicine.

See also:
– Leading scientists sign up to global cancer manifesto, The Guardian
– Measures need to be taken to prevent a billion deaths from tobacco by end of century, Medilexicon

Source: Reuters – 06 March 2013
Link: http://reut.rs/ZfVbCu

Tobacco Firms Save $1 Billion With Kitty Litter in Cigars

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-03-01/tobacco-firms-save-1-billion-with-kitty-litter-in-cigars.html

By Anna Edney – Mar 1, 2013 1:01 PM GMT+0800.

A dozen tobacco companies have gained from a legal loophole that helped them avoid as much as $1.1 billion in U.S. taxes.

Their secret: Using fillers such as the clay found in cat litter or stuffing the products with more tobacco to tip the scales in their favor. The heavier weight let the companies sidestep a 2,653 percent increase in a federal excise tax, taking advantage of a 2009 law that spared so-called big cigars.

There were 22 companies producing small cigars in the year before the law created the new tax structure, according to data from the Treasury Department’s Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau. Twelve of those companies, none of which the government would name, either switched to or increased production of large cigars in the year following the law, the bureau found.

“It shows what length the tobacco companies will go to avoid taxes and regulation that were designed to improve public health without regard to their customers,” Danny McGoldrick, vice president of research at the Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids in Washington, said in a telephone interview. “They should equalize the tax to stop the shenanigans.”

The practice has contributed to a doubling in sales of the weightier tobacco products and slowed a decade-long decline in tobacco use. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in an Aug. 2 report blamed sharp increases in adult consumption of pipe tobacco and cigarette-like cigars since 2008 on the 2009 law “that created tax disparities between product types.”

Durbin Legislation

The Government Accountability Office estimated in an April report that “market shifts from roll-your-own to pipe tobacco and from small to large cigars reduced federal revenue by a range of” $615 million to $1.1 billion from April 2009 through September 2011.

U.S. Senator Dick Durbin, an Illinois Democrat, introduced legislation Jan. 31 to close the loophole. The bill would equalize the tax structure so there wouldn’t be an incentive to manipulate products, generating $3.6 billion in new tax revenue over 10 years, Christina Mulka, a spokeswoman, said by e-mail.

The loophole appears to have mainly benefited smaller tobacco companies. Reynolds American Inc. (RAI), the second-biggest U.S. tobacco company, doesn’t operate in that market, David Howard, a spokesman for the Winston Salem, North Carolina-based company, said in an e-mail.

Altria Group Inc. (MO), the largest seller of tobacco in the U.S., said its John Middleton Co. unit had already been selling large cigars with its Black & Mild line before the change in the law. The company didn’t have to make any shifts in how it formulates the cigars, which mostly are wood or plastic tipped and come as singles or in packs of two or five, David Sylvia, a spokesman for Richmond, Virginia-based Altria, said by phone.

Customer Demand

Prime Time International Co., a closely held tobacco company, sells some of its large cigars and flavored cigars in 20-count packs, similar to regular cigarettes. Closely held Cheyenne International LLC, based in Grover, North Carolina, also specializes in smaller-sized cigars that have a similar look and design of cigarettes.

Jack Wertheim, chairman of Phoenix-based Prime Time, said shifts into the “large” cigar market are about responding to customer demands. The company sells large and small cigars to satisfy customers who prioritize taste and quality and appease those who want a lower-priced product, he said.

Prime Time isn’t saving on taxes, and any savings would be passed to the customer, Wertheim said.

Current rules require a rolled tobacco product to weigh at least 3 pounds per 1,000 to be labeled as a “large” or “premium” cigar, a category where taxes increased just 155 percent.

Nothing Illegal

The Treasury Department said tobacco companies aren’t doing anything illegal by making their products heavier.

“If you meet the definition of a large cigar, then you’re a large cigar,” Thomas Hogue, a spokesman for the tobacco bureau, said in a telephone interview. “There’s nothing in the Internal Revenue code that goes after the specifics on how that weight is achieved.”

Hogue wouldn’t provide the names of the tobacco makers switching to heavier products.

Cheyenne was found to make two kinds of cigars that look like cigarettes yet weigh enough to be taxed as big cigars. One of the two has a regular fiber filter; the other has filters made of white fiber cylinders surrounding a granular clay substance.

X-Ray Tests

Jim Pankow, a chemistry professor at Portland State University in Oregon, published the first measurements of how addictive nicotine is when delivered by tobacco smoke. He agreed to conduct X-ray diffraction tests on the weightier Cheyenne product on behalf of Bloomberg News and found the clay filters were made of sepiolite. The weighty mineral is used for absorption in waste treatment, industrial cleaners and pet litters, according to the European Industrial Minerals Association.

“They’re making products that are classified as cigars that are designed almost exactly like cigarettes,” Pankow said in a telephone interview.

The vast majority of Cheyenne’s cigars that are considered large began marketing in 2007, said Marc Scheineson, a partner at Alston & Bird LLP in Washington who is regulatory counsel for the tobacco company. He didn’t say when the company’s heavyweights hit shelves. He said less than 3 percent of the company’s sales come from little cigars and heavyweights.

The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau reviewed Cheyenne’s products to determine which excise class they fit in, he said.

“You can look at this as a loophole or tax planning or a way to perpetuate job growth or small business continuity,” Scheineson said in a telephone interview.

Filter Choice

British American Tobacco Plc (BATS)’s Kent cigarettes used a similar micronite filter at one point. The London-based company said it moved the cigarettes to charcoal filters long ago.

“The decision regarding whether to use charcoal or micronite filters is simply down to taste and currently, charcoal filters are used in Kent cigarettes in the vast majority of international markets where the product is sold,” Will Hill, a spokesman for the company, said in an e-mail.

Filtrona Plc (FLTR), a maker of cigarette and cigar filters, said its sepiolite-based Cavitec Flavour product is one of many specialty filter types. Altogether they represent about 17 percent of the Milton Keynes, U.K.-based company’s total filter sales globally, Melanie Hulbert, a spokeswoman, said in an e- mail. Filtrona wouldn’t reveal its customers’ names, citing confidentiality agreements.

FDA Oversight

In addition to avoiding some taxes, cigars also sidestep a ban on flavored cigarettes. Cheyenne’s heavyweight products come in wild cherry flavor, while their other cigars can be bought in flavors such as grape and vanilla.

The result is that while cigarette smoking — the leading preventable cause of death in the U.S. — continued an 11-year downward trend, large cigar smoking tripled from 2000 to 2011 and loose tobacco pipe smoking has jumped almost sixfold, the CDC said last year in a report.

Sales of large cigars more than doubled to 1 billion units a month in September 2011, from 411 million when the law took effect in January 2009, the GAO said. At the same time, small cigar sales dropped to 60 million from 430 million.

The FDA, which was given the authority by Congress in 2009 to regulate tobacco, primarily cigarettes, is now looking to broaden its rules.

The agency is “moving as expeditiously as possible to release for public comment a proposed rule to regulate additional categories of tobacco products,” Jennifer Haliski, an agency spokeswoman, said in an e-mail.

The FDA is scheduled to release a proposed rule by April, the federal Office of Management and Budget, which oversees all regulation development, said on its website.

To contact the reporter on this story: Anna Edney in Washington at aedney@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Reg Gale at rgale5@bloomberg.net; Jodi Schneider at jschneider50@bloomberg.net

2nd Circuit upholds NYC ordinance on flavored tobacco YET in Hong Kong it is still legal ! it is even manufactured here !

http://newsandinsight.thomsonreuters.com/Legal/News/2013/02_-_February/2nd_Circuit_upholds_NYC_ordinance_on_flavored_tobacco/

Tobacco leaves. File photo. REUTERS Jorge Silva

2nd Circuit upholds NYC ordinance on flavored tobacco

2/26/2013COMMENTS (0)

By Bernard Vaughan

NEW YORK, Feb 26 (Reuters) – The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday affirmed a district judge’s decision that upheld a New York City ordinance limiting the sale of flavored tobacco products, saying the measure did not pre-empt federal law.

The ruling marks a victory for the city, which under Mayor Michael Bloomberg has pushed several health-focused measures, including limits on sales of supersize soft drinks in an effort to fight obesity. The tobacco ordinance, signed into law and approved by the city council in October 2009, prohibits the sale of any flavored tobacco product except in a tobacco bar.

Sharyn Rootenberg of the New York City Law Department handled the case on appeal for the city.

Kenneth Parsigian of Latham & Watkins represented the U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Manufacturing Company LLC, whose moist smokeless tobacco brands include Copenhagen and Skoal, and U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Brands Inc. Both entities are units of Altria Group.

Tuesday’s decision backed a summary judgment ruling in favor of the city granted by U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon in November 2011.

Federal law “expressly preserves localities’ traditional power to adopt any ‘measure relating to or prohibiting the sale’ of tobacco products,” Judge Gerard Lynch wrote for the three-judge panel, which also included Judges Reena Raggi and Jon Newman.

“We are disappointed with the court’s decision and are considering our options,” said Brian May, a spokesman for Altria.

The City Law Department was not immediately available for comment.

The ordinance sought to deter younger smokers often attracted to flavored tobacco products, Bloomberg said before signing it in 2009.

In late 2009, the plaintiffs filed a lawsuit in Manhattan federal district court, seeking to stop enforcement of the measure.

The plaintiffs argued that a statute that Congress passed in 2009, the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, pre-empted the city ordinance. The federal law granted the Food and Drug Administration power to regulate tobacco products.

The city ordinance was a products standard regulation designed to “evade express federal pre-emption … by artful crafting that elevates form over substance,” the appellants wrote in their brief.

But the 2nd Circuit concluded that the ordinance does not require tobacco manufacturers to alter the properties of their products, which would have subjected it to federal pre-emption.

“A local sales regulation that does not clearly infringe on the FDA’s authority to determine what chemicals and processes may be used in making tobacco products does not fall within this description and is therefore not pre-empted,” Lynch wrote.

The 2nd Circuit also disagreed with the plaintiffs’ argument that the ordinance is effectively an outright ban on the sale of flavored tobacco products.

“While the sales restriction imposed by the City’s ordinance is severe, it does not constitute a complete ban, as it permits the limited sale of flavored tobacco products within New York City,” Lynch wrote.

The case is U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Manufacturing Company LLC, U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Brands Inc. v. City of New York, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 11-5167

For U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Manufacturing Company LLC, U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Brands Inc: Kenneth Parsigian of Latham & Watkins.

For the City of New York: Sharyn Rootenberg and Michael Pastor of the New York City Law Department

– See more at: http://newsandinsight.thomsonreuters.com/Legal/News/2013/02_-_February/2nd_Circuit_upholds_NYC_ordinance_on_flavored_tobacco/#sthash.AbmyWg99.dpuf