Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Tobacco Duty In HK To Rise By 50pc

BUDGET 2009 – Regina Leung – 1:52pm, Feb 25, 2009 – SCMP

Financial Secretary John Tsang Chun-wah on Wednesday announced an increase in Hong Kong tobacco duty by 50 per cent “with immediate effect” – saying it was needed for public health reasons.

Mr Tsang was unveiling new fiscal measures in his second budget address in the Legislative Council.

“The duty on cigarettes will increase from around HK$0.8 to about HK$1.2 per stick. We will also continue to step up our efforts on smoking cessation, as well as on publicity and enforcement in tobacco control,” he said.

There had been calls from health experts for the government to consider raising tobacco taxes in an effort to curb smoking-related diseases such as lung cancer.

According to customs statistics, a tobacco tax of 80 cents per cigarette levied in Hong Kong – unchanged since 2001 – makes Hong Kong cigarettes among the cheapest in the developed economies. It is estimated that over 6,000 people die in Hong Kong annually of smoking-related illnesses. Health experts are also concerned about the dangers posed by passive-smoking.

Mr Tsang said although the government’s fiscal position this year was likely to be weak, spending on healthcare would be boosted.

“The government will honour its pledge to increase healthcare expenditure to 17 per cent of recurrent expenditure by 2012,” he said.

“When the financing arrangements are finalised after the consultation on its implementation, we will draw an amount of HK$50 billion from the fiscal reserves to implement the reform” he told the legislators.

Mr Tsang said the government would increase Hospital Authority funding by about HK$870 million a year over the next three financial years.

“The annual subvention for the Hospital Authority by 2011-12 will be approximately HK$2.6 billion higher than now.

“I have also earmarked some HK$840 million for the next three financial years to implement various complementary measures to strengthen primary care services and the support to chronic patients, promote public-private partnership and develop a territory-wide electronic health record system,” he said.

He said the government would provide additional funding of about HK$19 million to enhance the care for people with disabilities.

Mr Tsang said that because of the growing ageing population, healthcare posed the greatest challenge to the public finances.

He said the Food and Health Bureau would continue with the second stage of a public consultation on healthcare reform.

Mr Tsang said more measures to support the development of food testing services were also planned.

“This will help Hong Kong to develop into a food testing hub in the region,” he added.

Prevent Officials Accepting Cigarette Bribes

Lawmakers draft rules to prevent officials accepting cigarette ‘bribes’

Shi Jiangtao in Beijing – Updated on Feb 25, 2009

Mainland legislators are drafting bills to ban government officials from buying cigarettes using public funds or accepting them as gifts.

The legislators said tobacco consumption had led to an increase in rampant corruption, state media reported.

They were also likely to propose an increase in tobacco tax and a separation of the State Tobacco Monopoly Administration and large tobacco companies, Xinhua quoted mainland health activists as saying.

Analysts said if the bills were passed, it would be the first time on the mainland that accepting cigarettes would amount to taking bribes.

As part of the anti-smoking campaign which has gathered pace in recent months, the Ministry of Health’s National Tobacco Control Office and several non-governmental organisations have worked with deputies to the National People’s Congress and the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, who gather for their annual meetings next week.

Although Beijing signed the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, a World Health Organisation treaty, in 2003, activists said it had made little effort to implement it or provide adequate support for tobacco controls.

This is not the first time that health activists and legislators have joined forces in pushing for tougher tobacco controls. A similar bill was proposed by an NPC deputy in 2007 calling for government attention to the health hazards of smoking and for a ban on using public funds to refund cigarette costs.

But Wu Yiqun, executive vice-director of the Research Centre for Health Development, said the bills proposed this year had made the most specific reference yet to the links between cigarette smoking and combating corruption.

“We have to make repeated efforts to push forward the difficult campaign which very much depends on the government policy,” Professor Wu said. “No one expects big breakthroughs through one single bill, but the bills this year have a better opportunity because of enormous public support for a healthy environment and anti-corruption attempts.”

The monopoly of the tobacco industry, and expensive cigarettes, were sources of huge waste and graft, the agency and campaigners said.

Zhou Jiugeng, a district housing chief in Nanjing, was sacked and placed under investigation last year after being found wearing a watch worth about 100,000 yuan (HK$113,580) and smoking cigarettes selling for 1,500 yuan a carton.

Anti-smoking activists say government funds for cigarettes in Jianli and Honghu counties in Hubei stand at as much as 10 million yuan a year.

The proposed bills would cover all government agencies, state-owned enterprises and the military. Officials who accepted cigarettes as gifts would be charged with taking bribes, and subject to criminal punishment.

Tobacco office director Yang Gonghuan told Xinhua there were over 300 million cigarette smokers in the country, with 1 million dying of tobacco-related illnesses such as lung and throat cancer and heart disease each year.

“It’s high time for NPC and CPPCC delegates to appeal to the government and the public to get involved in tobacco controls,” Dr Yang said.

Nonsmokers Exposed To Tobacco Smoke Face Higher Risk Of Dementia, UK, US

Judy Siegel-Itzkovich , THE JERUSALEM POST – Feb. 15, 2009

If you are a nonsmoker exposed to sidestream tobacco smoke, you’re at a significantly higher risk of developing dementia and other forms of cognitive impairment, according to new research in the UK and the US.

On Friday, the British Medical Journal published the research conducted at the University of Cambridge, Peninsula Medical School and University of Michigan on 5,000 non-smoking adults over the age of 50.

It is already known that an active smoker is at a significantly higher risk of dementia and that passive smoking can lead to poor cognitive performance in children and adolescents, as well as coronary heart disease, lung cancer, premature death, airway diseases such as asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and impaired lung function in adults.

But this new study, by Dr. David Llewellyn of the University of Cambridge and colleagues, is the first major one to conclude that second-hand smoke exposure could lead to irreversible dementia and other neurological problems.

They used data from the Health Survey for England in 1998, 1999 and 2001 and the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing. Saliva samples were tested for cotinine – a product of nicotine that can be found for about 25 hours after exposure to second-hand smoke.

Cotinine levels are an objective, short-term biomarker of second-hand smoke. Participants also provided a detailed smoking history.

The researchers used established neuropsychological tests to assess brain function and cognitive impairment – focusing on memory function, aptitude for numbers and verbal fluency (for example, naming as many animals as
they could within a minute).

The tests’ results were added together to provide a global cognitive function score. Participants whose scores were in the lowest 10 percent were defined as suffering from some level of cognitive impairment.

The link between second-hand smoke and cognitive impairment could be explained by the fact that heart disease increases the risk of developing dementia and second-hand smoke exposure is known to cause heart disease.

Dr. Mark Eisner from the University of California writes in an accompanying editorial that while the serious negative health effects of second-hand smoke like cancer and premature death have been established beyond doubt, there is still a lot to learn about the scale of illness caused by second-hand smoke.

“Emerging evidence suggests that parental smoking may impair childhood cognitive development. Later in life, second-hand smoke may cause cardiovascular disease and stroke, which are themselves linked to cognitive decline. Until now, however, the suspicion that passive smoking is bad for the adult brain had not been scientifically confirmed,” he wrote.

Eisner concludes by hoping that greater public awareness about the dangers of second-hand smoke, especially awareness about a much feared disease like Alzheimer’s disease and other dementias, “would eventually translate
into political action aimed at passing smoke-free legislation in regions of the world where public smoking is still permitted.”

Scientific proof of health damage from passive smoking has persuaded legislators to ban smoking in public places and workplaces around Israel, and to increase fines and other means of deterrence.

Eisner noted in his editorial that “dementia has terrible consequences for quality of life, is greatly feared and is not easy to prevent. Consequently, publicizing the link between second-hand smoke and dementia may resonate powerfully with the public and increase awareness of the harms of passive smoking.

“Greater public awareness would eventually translate into political action aimed at passing smoke-free legislation in regions of the world where public smoking is still permitted.”

Breaking The Habit

Mark O’Neill, SCMP – Updated on Jan 01, 2009

Beijing has committed itself to the WHO convention on tobacco control, but the powerful influence of the industry means efforts to enforce it are half-hearted

From today, cigarette packets on the mainland are supposed to change radically – with a warning of a specific disease and a picture that leaves the smoker in no doubt about the possible consequence of his choice.

The change is a result of Beijing having signed up to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), which came into force on January 1, 2006 and mandated that packaging regulations be implemented after three years.

Mainland China is the world’s largest tobacco producer consumer, with 350 million smokers, one-third of the global total. One million people die each year from smoking-related diseases, while 540 million suffer the effects of others’ smoking, with 100,000 dying annually from illnesses caused by passive smoking, according to Ministry of Health figures.

Article 11 of the FCTC sets out the rules for the packaging of cigarettes. It provides that packaging must ensure that “the truth of the effects of tobacco use be properly reflected in the packaging and labelling of tobacco products, including the use of picture warnings that even the least literate members of society can readily understand”.

It prescribes that 30 per cent to 50 per cent of the main display area be covered with a warning, including a picture.

But, when mainland smokers buy their cigarettes today, they will find no disturbing picture or image and just this anodyne wording, in Chinese and English: “Smoking damages health and to quit smoking can reduce the risk to health.”

There is no reference to lung cancer or any specific disease.

The packaging was designed by the State Tobacco Monopoly (STM), the official government regulator which also happens to be the world’s biggest producer of cigarettes.

Mainland public health campaigners say the new packaging contravenes the FCTC regulations and should be changed.

“It is absurd to put the STM in charge of the packaging,” said Yang Gonghuan, deputy director of the Chinese Disease Prevention Centre at the Ministry of Health.

“This should be decided by the Ministry of Health, as it is in other countries. The warning should specify which disease the smoker may contract.

“It is like asking the arsonists to put out a fire.”

Dr Yang pointed out that packets of cigarettes for export carried the requisite photograph and specific warning. “There is a different rule for Chinese and foreigners,” she said. “The STM cares for the lives of foreigners but not those of Chinese.”

The row over the packaging is the latest battle in a long-running war between supporters and opponents of the tobacco industry within the central government and the wider society.

On one side is the STM, the mainland’s single biggest taxpayer – in 2007, it contributed 388 billion yuan (HK$441 billion) to state coffers, 9 per cent of national revenue – and the 10 million farmers, processors, workers and distributors who work for the industry. China is one of only two countries – the other is North Korea – to have a monopoly producer of tobacco that is also the industry regulator.

Production is increasing. Output in 2007 was 2.14 trillion cigarettes, an increase of 14 per cent from three years earlier.

And the prestige enjoyed by the STM is far higher than that of cigarette producers in any other major country, where it is often a case of overcoming serious image problems.

Last month, the Ministry of Civil Affairs awarded the STM the “China Charity Award” for being the country’s most generous firm. Four other cigarette producers were among the 140 domestic and foreign firms cited.

The award gave the tobacco firms some welcome exposure at a time when they are banned from direct advertising. Fighting the influence of the STM are doctors, health workers and civic groups who argue that the tax revenue it provides is less than the cost of treating those with smoking-related illnesses and their lost productivity, not to mention the distress caused to their families.

It was only after years of lobbying that the central government ratified the FCTC in 2005.

Dr Yang’s office has just eight full-time staff and an annual budget of less than 10 million yuan.

Studies show that a majority of mainlanders have a limited understanding of the health risks associated with smoking, because the STM has been successful in limiting discussion in the mass media.

These stark contradictions were in public view at an international conference on smoking held in Durban, South Africa, at the end of November.

The Conference of the Parties to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control was attended by 600 delegates from more than 100 countries. The convention has 168 signatory countries in total, a record for a UN treaty.

Beijing sent a delegation of 17, including two from the STM, as well as officials of the foreign, finance and health ministries.

The STM delegates expressed their opposition to clauses of the treaty, saying that it was unsuitable to conditions on the mainland. They, along with the Japanese delegation, opposed Article 11, the provision dealing with health warnings on packets.

The delegates pointed out that Chinese packaging showed famous geographic and cultural sites and to put ugly pictures over them “would insult and be disrespectful to the public”, in the words of one delegate.

The STM response to domestic and international pressure is to argue that the anti-smoking movements of the west were inappropriate for the mainland.

“We have 350 million smokers and the number is likely to increase over the next 30 years,” said Zhu Zunquan, a member of the China Academy of Engineering, who is working with the STM.

“A total ban is not suitable to conditions in China. While the government is implementing the FCTC, it is fully utilising the developments of science.

“With the principle of man as the base, this is good for the nation and the people.”

He said that, while mainland gross domestic product had been rising rapidly each year, the percentage of tobacco tax as a share of national tax revenue remained about 9 per cent.

“We must also take into account the 10 million workers and farmers who make their livelihood in the industry,” Mr Zhu said. “To protect the health of the hundreds of millions of people who do not want to stop smoking and the national interest, the only option for the stable development of the tobacco industry is less-harmful cigarettes.”

Mr Zhu is involved in a research project, in which the STM is investing hundreds of millions of yuan, to produce a “China-style cigarette” that causes little or no harm to the smoker.

He said that the tar content of a mainland cigarette had fallen from 40 milligrams in the 1960s to 30 in the 1970s and 13.2 now. It would drop to 12 by 2010, he added.

The research is being carried out by scientists and laboratories, to which the government has awarded five patents.

Two well-known brands have already produced 77,384 cases of these low-tar cigarettes, known to many as “the responsible cigarette”, and they have been well received by the market.

Another important provision of the FCTC that was discussed in Durban is Article 13, which mandates a ban on advertising, promotion and sponsorship of tobacco products nationally and across borders.

In light of this clause, it was wrong of the central government to give STM a charity award, campaigners said.

“While tobacco is not classified as a poison, smoking harms the health and life of those who use it and is very similar to a poison,” Li Dun, a member of the China Academy of Social Sciences, wrote in China News Weekly.

“Worse than that, it threatens the health and life of other people, the passive smokers.

“The large profits and donations made by the tobacco companies come from this base.

“What basis did the ministry use for its decision?” he asked.

According to government figures, the STM ranked second in 2006 to Altria – the parent company of Philip Morris – in sales revenue among global cigarette producers, while its US$76.59 billion in assets is more than double that of Altria.

Documents Offer Look At Big Tobacco’s Asia Tactics

Associated Press By MICHAEL CASEY – Dec 23, 2008

BANGKOK, Thailand (AP) — Two of the world’s largest tobacco companies, seeking to expand sales into Asia, worked to undermine anti-smoking policies in Thailand and China by infiltrating one research institute and funding another, researchers said Tuesday.

The allegations — highlighted in two separate studies — come as tobacco companies are aggressively marketing cigarettes in the developing world as lawsuits and anti-smoking laws hit revenues in the West.

“As the high income countries put more and more obstacles in the path of the cigarette companies, they have to look for new markets,” said Edouard Tursan d’Espaignet, epidemiologist with the WHO’s Tobacco Free Initiative.

Critics said tobacco companies are trying to drum up sales by minimizing the dangers of smoking.

In Thailand, Philip Morris, the world largest cigarette maker, planted a scientist in Chulabhorn Research Institute in Bangkok in a bid to get researchers to shift their attention away from secondhand smoking and toward other forms of air pollution, according to one study. Public health researchers from the University of Sydney and the University of Edinburgh produced the study by analyzing internal industry documents made public following litigation in the United States.

A separate study alleges that British American Tobacco, the world’s second-largest firm, provided funding in China for the Beijing Liver Foundation in a campaign to shift focus away from links between smoking and ailments such as liver disease.

Both companies denied the charges presented online in the Public Library of Science Medicine journal. The two studies were partly funded by the National Cancer Institute in the U.S.

However, longtime anti-smoking advocate Stanton Glanz said the tactics are “part of long-running and continuing tactics by the tobacco industry all over the world,” and he called on the two Asian institutions to end their ties with the industry.

Anti-smoking groups say big tobacco for years has sought to covertly influence western government’s smoking policies and squash scientific findings highlighting hazards of smoking.

Now, some charge, the tobacco countries are taking these time-tested tactics to the Asia, Africa and Latin America where the WHO estimates 80 percent of the 8 million tobacco-related deaths will occur by 2030.

The University of Sydney’s Ross MacKenzie, who co-authored the Thai study, said that in Asia, tobacco companies have fought successfully to prevent the publication of ingredients used in their products in Thailand and worked in Cambodia to undermine advertising bans.

“They have shown they are willing to take advantage of economic situations and lax legislation in many Southeast Asian countries to aggressively market their products,” MacKenzie said, citing previously released company documents.

In the Thai study, MacKenzie and University of Edinburgh’s Jeff Collin allege that Philip Morris scientist Roger Walk lectured and organized conferences at the government-funded Chulabhorn from the early 1990s through 2006.

The researchers say this allowed Philip Morris to develop relationships with key officials and scientists in efforts to discount the threat of secondhand smoke.

Spokeswoman Marija Sepic of Switzerland-based Philip Morris International — which was spun off by the Altria Group in the United States earlier this year — dismissed the documents as outdated and said the company never hid its affiliation with Walk.

Walk, who now works for Altria’s Philip Morris USA unit, could not be reached for comment.

Chulabhorn Associate Vice President Jutamaad Satayavivad said the institute was not aware Walk worked for Philip Morris until about a decade into his tenure. After seeing the study, institute officials plan to bar him because he was “not straightforward in sharing with us,” she said.

The other study alleges that London-based British American Tobacco used the Beijing Liver Foundation to lobby China’s Health Ministry in a campaign to forestall smoke-free legislation.

The company also provided training for industry, public officials and the media to spread its message that secondhand smoke was an insignificant source of pollution, it said.

“Despite the tobacco industry’s public efforts to appear socially responsible … there is a fundamental conflict between the interests of tobacco companies and public health,” said the Mayo Clinic’s Monique E. Muggli, who conducted the study with four other researchers.

China’s Health Ministry did not immediately respond to a faxed request for comment.

British American Tobacco spokeswoman Catherine Armstrong said it was illogical to suggest that any link the company has to a medical charity “was an attempt to divert attention away from smoking related disease.”

However, Glanz, a University of California San Fransico professor who has led research into secondhand smoke, said he’s not surprised to hear the studies’ results.

Asia is particularly attractive to tobacco companies because “understanding of the effects of smoking and passive smoking is low,” Glanz said

Government Tipped To Ban Tobacco Displays In Shops

The Age, Nick Miller – December 22, 2008

THE State Government is expected to ban cigarette retail displays in its Tobacco Control Strategy, due for release today.

A discussion paper released in August revealed the Government was wondering whether to completely ban tobacco retail displays, or restrict them to one square metre.

Under a total ban, no cigarette packets would be allowed to be visible inside or from outside a shop.

They would have to be covered or moved under the counter, though retailers would be allowed to display a price board.

Tobacco signage may go. Photo: Jon Reid

Health insiders yesterday predicted the Government would choose this option, following a similar law enacted last month in NSW. However, a Government spokesman declined to comment yesterday.

Cigarettes are sold at about 11,000 retail outlets in Victoria, which would be given time to redesign their point-of-sale displays before the law came into force.

In NSW, big outlets were to be allowed six months, and smaller shops a year.

Specialist tobacconists were likely to be exempt from the rules.

The strategy also includes extra money for programs to tackle Victoria’s alarmingly high indigenous smoking rates, as reported by The Age two weeks ago.

It is expected to ban smoking in government school grounds and in cars carrying children, and may extend the ban to smoking in a car containing anyone under the age of 18.

Temporary tobacco stands at major events such as the Big Day Out will also be outlawed.

The strategy is part of the Government’s Cancer Action Plan, released last week.

The plan said the tobacco strategy would include “anti-smoking social marketing and new smoking cessation services”, including support for pregnant smokers who wanted to quit.

Should The Smoking Ban Be Extended Further?

SCMP – Dec 20, 2008

Although the law prohibiting smoking in indoor public places, including restaurants, is in force, non-smokers are still affected by people lighting up.

You can still smell stale smoke when you are walking around Hong Kong. People are still allowed to smoke outside on the city’s streets. As a pedestrian, you often have to walk past groups of smokers. Given that problems still exist, it is clear that the smoking ban must be extended, because this problem is still adversely affecting the majority of Hong Kong citizens who do not smoke.

I think it would be reasonable to extend a smoking ban to all public areas.

Kaza Chu, Lai Chi Kok

Setback For Cigarette Firms

SCMP – 17 December 2008

WASHINGTON – The US Supreme Court has handed a surprising defeat to tobacco companies, ruling that smokers may use state consumer protection laws to sue cigarette makers for the way they promote “low tar” brands. The decision was at odds with recent anti-consumer rulings that limited state regulation. AP

Anti-smoking Legislation To Come Into Effect – Taiwan

15 Dec 2008.

A smoking ban in indoor and public areas will come into effect from 11 January 2009.

The new Tobacco Hazard Prevention Act will also ban smoking in indoor working areas with over three people. Smokers who smoke on stairs, kitchens, or restrooms will be fined. A smoking room with separate air conditioning can be installed by hotels, restaurants and malls. Smoking will also be prohibited in outdoor areas of gyms, college campuses, as well as cultural and social organisations. Violators can be fined TWD 2,000 (EUR 45) to TWD 10,000.

Chao Kun-yu, deputy director-general of the bureau of health promotion of the ministry of health, said that the bureau would place promotional leaflets on the smoking ban in four major convenience store chains beginning 1 December.

Chao said that the definition of outdoor areas would be left to local governing authorities. He also reminded that a non-smoking sign should be put up at the entrance of every smoke free place and ashtrays should not be provided. Owners who do not put up signs will be fined. (pi)

Those Smokers Spoil a Good Meal

Stacey Niermann – Published on ShanghaiDaily.com

I am an American who has lived in Asia for 11 years, but in Shanghai only four months.

The few times I have managed to get off my “compound” in Pudong and made it out to dinner, or even recently to a hair salon, I have been absolutely assaulted by the smokers. (“How dare they light up under no-smoking signs” ? Shanghai Daily December 8 )

Honestly, it makes dining out not worth it for me because I have real difficulty enjoying my meal (or even breathing for that matter!).

I love your suggestion to help enforce smoking bans and I thank you sincerely for your efforts to help protect the non-smokers, our children, our air quality, and employees who should not be forced to breathe such air in order to earn a living.

I lived many years in Hong Kong and as Hong Kong moved towards enforcement of this ban, there was, of course, resistance, but once the tide started to turn and it was obvious that non-smoking areas was the wave of the future, the whole issue just sort of “went away” and the smokers stopped fighting it.

To my knowledge, no restaurant suffered an extended loss of business. And there are people such as myself who now limit their dining out or bar visiting because of the smoke, so this is an economic factor also.