Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Tobacco laws to pass Senate – Evans

http://www.skynews.com.au/national/article.aspx?id=680881&vId

Updated: 22:49, Wednesday November 2, 2011

Tobacco laws to pass Senate - Evans

The federal government plans to force its tobacco plain packaging legislation through the Senate next week.

Labor wants all cigarettes to be sold in drab olive-brown packs from the end of 2012.

Government Senate leader Chris Evans said the upper house would debate and vote on the legislation on Thursday, November 10.

Labor has tabled a motion outlining changes to the upper house’s legislation schedule with the support of the Australian Greens.

The coalition supports the main plain packaging legislation but not an associated trademarks bill.

However, both will pass the Senate with the support of the Greens.

Earlier on Wednesday, Health Minister Nicola Roxon announced the implementation of the world-first move would be delayed from July 1 next year to December 1, 2012.

Ms Roxon said the delay was necessary because it had taken longer than expected for the upper house to pass the legislation after it sailed through the House of Representatives in August.

‘I think that it is important that industry gets a reasonable timeframe to make an orderly transition to plain packaging,’ she said in a statement.


Dining permits cheaper if smoking banned – ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-08-03/outdoor-dining-permit-smoking/2822010

Cheaper Permits for outdoor restaurants with smoking bans

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6CTR7nZA9A

Australia – ban on patio smoking

The Great Lakes Council in New South Wales, Australia bans smoking in outdoor dining areas.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6CTR7nZA9A&feature=player_embedded

Singapore bans smoking in outdoor eateries

Clear the Air says:

Anti smoking legislation is intended to protect the health of workers in their work places – catering workers in outdoor restaurants and patios should be protected as should customers and their children from the highly toxic sidestream passive smoke.  It is disingenuous to have laws covering workplace protection from  indoor smoking only. It is high time Hong Kong banned smoking in ALL areas of restaurants and licensed premises, Outdoor Seating Accommodation and patio areas covered by general restaurant , light refreshment and liquor licensed premises and the areas within 10 meters of the above premises and surrounds. It is high time the outdated law placed the legal onus on the premises’ licensees to enforce the anti smoking laws or lose their licenses to operate. This would in one move, increase the policing  of the Tobacco Control Office by 12,000 enforcers.  60% of our visitors are Mainlanders (where 60% of males smoke)  – but the visitors  follow our laws in no smoking places like Ocean Park – Hong Kong’s example can have a marked effect on smoking in the Mainland when visitors see what can be achieved here and demand changes back home.

http://www.news24.com/World/News/Singapore-bans-outdoor-smoking-20060704

July 2006  Singapore bans smoking in outdoor eateries

Singapore – Richard Tan usually lingers at one of the tables at the Newton Food Centre to puff a cigarette after a bowl of his favourite prawn noodles.

But as of this month, the 65-year-old retiree must leave the premises and light up under the tree-lined surroundings after Singapore banned smoking in outdoor eateries, coffee shops, canteens and cafes.

Cigarette firm violates tobacco law co-branding with F1

http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/formula-1-indian-anti-tobacco-law-godfrey-phillips-india/1/157885.html

MAIL TODAY BUREAU NEW DELHI, OCTOBER 29, 2011 | UPDATED 15:55 IST

Marlboro-Ferrari ad

A Marlboro-Ferrari ad at a shop in New Delhi.

The Formula 1 event in India has come as a great opportunity for brand promotion by various companies. But health activists are not taking kindly to the co-branding of one of the participating teams with a leading cigarette brand. Such association, they say, violates the Indian anti-tobacco law.

Godfrey Phillips India is promoting its cigarette brand ‘Marlboro’ by demonstrating its association with a popular team participating in the event – Scuderia Ferrari.

This violates Section 5 (3) (a) of the anti-tobacco law, which prescribes that ‘no person shall, under a contract or otherwise, promote or agree to promote the use or consumption of cigarettes or any other tobacco product’, voluntary group Hriday pointed out in a complaint filed with the Delhi tobacco control cell.

Under a new campaign called ‘Feel the passion’, the company is inserting messages about Ferrari in cigarette packs. “Such ads and inserts are a violation of the law. The message is basically to promote the brand surreptitiously,” said Monika Arora of Hriday.

ACT bans smoking in car with kids

http://news.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=8363215

Oct. 20, 2011

Smoking inside a vehicle that contains children has been outlawed in the ACT.

The territory’s Legislative Assembly has passed a law that makes it illegal for anyone to smoke inside a car or other vehicle while a child under the age of 16 is in it.

ACT Chief Minister Katy Gallagher said she was pleased the assembly agreed to pass her bill.

“While it is an adult’s right to choose to smoke, vulnerable groups who cannot always speak for themselves have a right to be protected from second-hand smoke, particularly when exposure can increase the risk of asthma, pneumonia, bronchitis and middle-ear infections,” Ms Gallagher said in statement on Thursday.

Similar legislation has already been enacted in most other jurisdictions of Australia.

Big tobacco ‘abusing’ FOI process: govt

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/big-tobacco-abusing-foi-process-govt-20111019-1m7g1.html

The federal health department is considering taking action against big tobacco for lodging “vexatious” Freedom of Information (FOI) claims as part of the industry’s fight against Labor’s plain-packaging push.

Health department secretary Jane Halton says the department is being “swamped” with FOI requests as part of a deliberate campaign by cigarette manufacturers.

“This is a very specific and deliberate attempt to divert resources,” Ms Halton told a Senate estimates hearing on Wednesday.

Advertisement: Story continues below <iframe src=”http://ad-apac.doubleclick.net/adi/onl.smh.news/news/breakingnewsnational;cat1=national;cat=breakingnewsnational;ctype=article;pos=3;sz=300×250;tile=3;ord=9.5171356E7?” width=’300′ height=’250′ scrolling=”no” marginheight=”0″ marginwidth=”0″ allowtransparency=”true” frameborder=”0″> </iframe>

“There will come a point where we will have to consider what to do about that.”

Ms Halton said there was a provision in the FOI legislation relating to vexatious applicants.

“We are intending to take advice on that,” she said.

“It is being discussed.”

The health department has received 63 FOI requests, of which 52 were from big tobacco. Some 35 are still being dealt with.

The Gillard government wants to force all cigarettes to be sold in drab olive-brown packs from mid-2012.

Cigarette manufacturers have threatened to challenge the world-first laws in court after they pass the Senate later this year.

Ms Halton said on Wednesday big tobacco’s FOI requests had cost the department “an awful lot”. Industry is disputing some of the charges.

The department secretary said she supported the principle of openness but “the way the current FOI laws are written there are huge opportunities for people who wish to abuse process to do so”.

The amount the department can charge for processing requests “goes nowhere near meeting our costs”, Ms Halton said.

It can only charge $15 per hour for search and retrieval and $20 an hour for decision-making time. The staff doing the work can earn up to $50 an hour.

“So we are hardly talking reasonable recompense for the amount of time and energy it’s taking,” Ms Halton said.

British American Tobacco Australia (BATA) argues it’s been forced to rely on freedom of information applications because Health Minister Nicola Roxon refuses to consult industry.

BATA has lodged 15 FOI requests with the health department in the past 18 months and is currently waiting on six to be finalised.

“Documents (already obtained) from the government show they have concerns about the need to pay compensation to the tobacco industry for removing our intellectual property, the growth in illegal tobacco once all packs look the same and an increase in smoking rates due to cheaper cigarettes,” BATA spokesman Scott McIntyre told AAP in a statement.

An April 2010 briefing note from the government body which administers Australia’s intellectual property rights system states plain packaging would impinge on trademark rights.

But, IP Australia points out, that might not be a problem if it serves the public interest.

Greens health spokesman Richard Di Natale says big tobacco is using every tactic possible to derail plain packaging.

“They have resorted to trying to clog up the health department with vexatious FOI requests,” he said in a statement on Wednesday.

“The tobacco industry should halt their campaign of mischief and let the health department do its job protecting the public’s health.”

Under Australia’s FOI laws an applicant can be declared “vexatious” by the information commissioner.

© 2011 AAP

CTA letter to CEO Hong Kong

Download PDF : CTAletterCEOHK

Australia may delay controversial anti-tobacco plan

http://uk.reuters.com/article/2011/10/12/uk-australia-smoking-idUKTRE79B0XS20111012

CANBERRA | Wed Oct 12, 2011 6:27am BST

CANBERRA (Reuters) – Australia’s government may have to delay plans for the world’s toughest anti-tobacco laws after conservative opposition lawmakers on Wednesday postponed a final vote on the controversial legislation in parliament.

The new laws, which will force cigarettes to be sold in plain packaging from 2012, are being closely watched by New Zealand, Canada, the European Union and Britain, which are considering similar restrictions.

Health Minister Nicola Roxon said the conservatives, who managed to postpone an upper house Senate vote on the bills during a rancorous day in parliament for the minority Labour government, were playing into the hands of big tobacco firms.

“Given the delays in passing the bill caused by the opposition, the government now has no choice but to reconsider the impact on implementation timeframes,” Roxon said.

Australia says the new laws reflect its obligations under the World Health Organization’s 2005 framework against tobacco, which urges states to consider plain packaging laws. The WHO estimates more than 1 billion around the world are regular smokers, with 80 percent in low and middle income countries.

The laws have angered tobacco producers who have threatened a High Court challenge, while the governments of Nicaragua and Ukraine said the new measures breached international trade rules and would be challenged in the World Trade Organisation.

Prime Minister Julia Gillard’s government is hoping the laws will come into effect on January 1 next year, although the main provisions forcing all cigarettes to be sold in plain packaging only come into operation on July 1, 2012.

The delay in the Senate means the laws will not be voted on before November, forcing the government to reconsider now whether it can meet its deadlines.

Australia’s Cancer Council said the Senate should end the political delays and get on with passing the legislation, with authorities estimating smoking now kills 15,000 Australians each year and costs the health system $32 billion (20 billion pound).

“We know the tobacco industry is vehemently opposed to plain packaging, which is just another indication that plain packaging has great potential to reduce tobacco,” council chief executive Ian Olver said.

Analysts say tobacco companies like Britain’s Imperial Tobacco and Philip Morris are worried that plain packaging could spread to emerging markets like Brazil, Russia and Indonesia, and threaten growth there.

Australia’s tobacco market generated total revenues of around $10 billion in 2009, up from A$8.3 billion in 2008, although smoking generally has been in decline. Around 22 billion cigarettes are sold in the country each year.

British American Tobacco, whose brands include Winfield, Dunhill and Benson & Hedges, has said the government’s plans would infringe international trademark and intellectual property laws, promising a court challenge to the laws.

(Reporting by Rob Taylor; Editing by Sugita Katyal)

Norway’s left-center proposed a string of measures, including an outdoor smoking ban, to tighten existing laws, reports Dagsavisen.

http://www.tobaccojournal.com/Stricter_anti-smoking_measures_proposed.50829.0.html

Current laws have banned or highly restricted smoking indoors for years, but now the government also wants to ban smoking outdoors, for example at the entrances to public buildings and in the outdoor areas of bars, restaurants and cafés. Many were set up to accommodate smokers who no longer were able to smoke inside.

Other proposals include bans on all smoking, indoors or outdoors, at public institutions, schools and day care centers.

The government also seeks a ban on toy cigarettes and sale of cigarettes with just 10 in a pack.

The government’s new proposals will be up for hearings this autumn. (pi)

Tenants’ rights up in smoke

http://wehonews.com/z/wehonews/archive/page.php?articleID=6562

10 Oct. 2011

If you’re a smoker, start packing. Off to Nevada you go.

Last month Governor Brown signed Senate Bill 322, which targets smokers in rental properties throughout the State for eviction.

Introduced in February by State Senator, Alex Padilla, (D-Pacoima), the bill allows landlords to prohibit smoking or use of any tobacco products, apparently including smokeless tobacco, in their buildings.

While I have never been a smoker and I was grateful for the ban on smoking in restaurants, bars and airplanes, it just seems that we have reached a point where smokers have being demonized in a fashion that was previously reserved for homosexuals and pedophiles.

After January 1, landlords will be able to prohibit smoking not only in common areas, but in individual apartments.  Smoking in your own home could result in a just cause eviction after the first of the year.

Constituted as California Civil Code Section 1947.5, the summary set forth by the State Assembly Judiciary Committee, states “the new law permits a residential landlord to prohibit smoking of a cigarette or any other tobacco product on the entirety of a rental property.

The prohibition would include individual dwelling units, all communal buildings, indoor and outdoor public spaces and any other public spaces and any other section of the property as specified by the landlord.”

What I found fascinating was that one of this bill’s leading supporters was Apartment Owners Association of California, a powerful landlord lobbying machine that does not have a history of concern for health issues and is clearly not looking out for the rights of tenants.

The fact that you are a current tenant does not protect your smoking rights.

The landlord can terminate your right to smoke in your unit upon sixty days written notice.

There is not appeal and you are not protected by the West Hollywood Rent Stabilization ordinance.

Apparently the City of West Hollywood was missing in action while this bill was being considered.

Although I recognize that the majority of our City Council members are rabid when it comes to the issue of smoking, thousands of West Hollywood renters who do smoke may soon find themselves exiled from our community.

As tenants in rent controlled buildings are aware, property owners are constantly on the lookout for ways of terminating the tenancies of long term tenants who have enjoyed the benefits of West Hollywood’s strict rent control.

What is egregious about this bill is that is designed to allow a landlord to selectively ban smoking in individual units.  While your landlord can ban smoking in your unit, if you move or are evicted, the same unit can be rented to a smoker, albeit at a substantially increased rent.

As written, the law provides that a landlord can ban smoking in the entire building or any portion of a building, “including any dwelling unit.” The bill does not require a landlord to ban smoking in all units, just the units the property owner selects.

A landlord can evict one smoking tenant but not another.  Thus tenants with low rents would be at a huge risk while new tenants who are paying market rents are not likely to be evicted.

This law incentivizes tenant harassment.  After giving notice, your apartment manager would simply testify that he saw you smoking in your unit and you are out.  SB 332 will wreak havoc in West Hollywood.

The City of West Hollywood has a professional lobbyist on retainer, who constantly alerts the City Council as to any bill that relates to landlord/tenant issues.

Apparently the City of West Hollywood did not take a position on this bill.  Our Assembly member, Mike Feuer chairs the Assembly Judiciary Committee.  According to the staffer I spoke with in his office, the City of West Hollywood never contacted his office regarding this bill.

Had the City of West Hollywood been involved in the legislative process, the bill could have been cleaned up so it not have resulted in a law that seems specifically crafted to assist landlords to selectively evict tenants.

At every election our incumbent Council members religiously recite the “tenants’ rights” catechism.  They sanctimoniously pledge that no one is working harder to protect West Hollywood’s tenants.

We know this is largely a crock, as the Heilman/Land clique have been the biggest cheerleaders and enablers of the demolition of rent controlled housing to make way for luxury condos.

Nonetheless, you would expect that State legislation that may impact thousands of local residents would have warranted some public debate at the City Council level.  By all evidence, it appears that the City simply has betrayed thousands of local residents.

I understand that smokers are not a protected class.  They certainly are not a popular minority group.  But at the risk of being politically incorrect, I would maintain that they are still human beings who need a place to live.

While this community celebrates alcohol and embraces the needs of meth addicts, virtually no sympathy is extended to those hooked on tobacco.

As a society, we demonize second hand smoke.  Indeed in the SB 332’s legislative findings drafted by State Senator Padilla, statistics were quoted blaming second hand smoke for 49,000 deaths of non-smokers in the United States annually, including 3,400 from lung cancer and 46,000 by heart disease.

Now I don’t want to sound like some Republican doubting the science behind global warming, but how do accurately come to a figure of 46,000 deaths by heart disease caused by second hand smoke?  Americans die of heart disease because of all the hormone laden red meat we eat, our junk food diets, the stress of our jobs and our disgraceful lack of exercise.

While I am not saying that second hand smoke is free of health hazards, 3,400 of lung cancer could simply be from breathing the air or by use of charcoal barbeques.

Heck, I live next to the MTA lot at San Vicente.  My neighbors and I must second hand smoke the equivalent of two packs a day.  I am in greater danger from riding my bike to work than I am from second hand smoke coming from my neighbor’s apartment.

As California has become increasing “progressive,” we have become increasing intolerant of the other guy’s faults.

I would ask all of the supporters of SB 332 if they would be willing to stop texting or using their hand held cell phones while driving.  Thousands die because of our unhealthy addiction to our tech toys but no one is serious about penalizing their obvious misuse.

SB 332 does provide a potential escape clause if the City of West Hollywood is willing to act prior to January 1.  The law does allow municipalities to “grandfather” the rights of current smoking tenants that would protect them from eviction under the new law.

At this point I would certainly encourage all of my smoking friends who rent in West Hollywood to kick the habit.

Alternatively, give up tobacco and switch to marijuana.  At least marijuana smoking in your castle is still a protected activity in West Hollywood.