Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Protect health laws from big tobacco

SCMP

Shin Young-soo says we must push back against industry attempts to undermine tobacco control and health laws that target smoking

May 31, 2012

Hands off! That’s what we shout when the tobacco industry tries to undermine the laws that protect people from the ravages of tobacco use, and when it misuses the treaties designed to protect trade and investment in an effort to block a novel law requiring that tobacco be sold in plain, unattractive packages.

That’s what we tell an industry that tries to crush the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, the landmark public health treaty that now has 174 parties covering more than 85per cent of the world’s population.

And that’s what we say to a tobacco industry whose so-called “corporate social responsibility” projects are designed to buy influence and make people forget that its products cause addiction, suffering and nearly six million deaths per year.

The tobacco industry needs to keep its hands off all the protections that have been erected since science tied smoking to lung cancer, emphysema, cardiovascular disease and a host of other fatal diseases.

The industry is getting more aggressive and brazen. Tobacco giant Philip Morris recently took the unusual step of suing Australia under the country’s bilateral investment treaty with Hong Kong on the grounds that Australia’s revolutionary plain packaging law infringes on international trademarks.

That’s why the World Health Organisation chose “tobacco industry interference” as the theme of today’s World No Tobacco Day.

On this day and throughout the year, the WHO will educate policymakers and the general public about the tobacco industry’s nefarious and harmful tactics so that they might be better resisted.

Doing so is in keeping with the WHO’s framework convention, the preamble of which recognises “the need to be alert to any efforts by the tobacco industry to undermine or subvert tobacco control efforts and the need to be informed of activities of the tobacco industry that have a negative impact on tobacco control efforts”.

We encourage everyone to join the good fight. Today, and every day, tell the tobacco industry to keep its hands off public health legislation. The industry deserves no seat at the policymaking table, its interests being fundamentally and irreconcilably in conflict with the public interest.

Tell the industry to keep its hands off the framework convention, which obligates parties to ban tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship, to protect people from tobacco smoke, to warn people about the harms of tobacco use and to offer help to people who want to quit. The treaty is our most important tool in the fight to curtail the tobacco epidemic.

Stand by countries such as Australia that have stood up to the industry’s legal intimidation. Every country has a right and a responsibility to protect its people from the enormous health and economic costs of tobacco use. Trade laws should not be abused to prolong or increase exposure to tobacco industry marketing.

Denounce tobacco industry interference with public health laws whenever and wherever you see it.

Our message to the tobacco industry is simple and direct. Hands off!

Dr Shin Young-soo is WHO regional director for the Western Pacific

Unpaid smoking fines put bar licenses in jeopardy

http://www.middletownjournal.com/news/middletown-news/unpaid-smoking-fines-put-bar-licenses-in-jeopardy-1381803.html

Area liquor permits at risk over fines from smoking violations. Ohio’s anti-smoking law gains traction.

HANDOUT

http://www.ohio-share.coxnewsweb.com/multimedia/dynamic/01133/hjn052612a1Smoking_1133510b.jpg

ENLARGE PHOTO

The Froggy Blues Café in Monroe owes $34,000. Staff photo by Gary Stelzer

GARY STELZER/MBR The Froggy Blues Café in Monroe owes $34,000. Staff photo by Gary Stelzer

  • ·

By Beena Raghavendran, Staff Writer 12:56 AM Saturday, May 26, 2012

A number of area drinking establishments are at risk of losing their liquor permits if they don’t pay smoking fines levied against them, health officials said.

Ohio’s Smoke-Free Workplace Act gained more teeth this week when it was ruled constitutional by the Ohio Supreme Court. The court rejected a Columbus tavern owner’s case that said requiring establishments to pay the smoking fine was an illegal taking of property. The law, passed in 2006, makes smoking in most public places illegal. Easy’s in the Village has the most unpaid fines from smoking violations in Butler and Warren counties, according to hundreds of Ohio Health Department records examined by the Middletown Journal.

Owners of Easy’s in the Village did not returns calls for comment. The Hamilton bar owes $245,000 in unpaid smoking fines from the past five years. It’s one of several bars and pubs that still owe thousands of dollars in fines.

Unpaid smoking fines in area businesses add up to $34,000 at Froggy Blues Café in Monroe, $16,600 at Towne Pub in Hamilton and $11,500 at Scotty’s Pub in Fairfield, according to Ohio Department of Health invoices.

A bar’s first violation of the smoking ban is a warning from the Ohio Department of Health and a $100 fine; the second is a $500 fine; the third is a $1,000 fine; and the fourth and each subsequent offense is a $2,500 fine, according to ODH spokeswoman Shannon Libby.

State records show $3 million in fines have been issued in the past five years, but almost $2.3 million remains unpaid.

Ohio health officials say they hope collections improve now that the Supreme Court has declared the law constitutional and removed one of the justifications some businesses have used to withhold payment of fines.

However, budget cuts, a bad economy and the difficulty of collecting fines for offenses that are, legally speaking, the equivalent of parking tickets all play a part in the low collection rate.

“We have had some difficulty collecting,” said Amanda Burkett, chief of the Ohio Department of Health’s indoor environment section. “It’s not like you have a huge stick to get people to pay fines.”

The Butler County Health District has 57 smoking ban violations at or over the fourth offense, the fourth highest in Ohio, state records say. The county has had 1,810 reports and has undergone 862 investigations since the ban was enacted — the 11th highest number in the state.

Five Ohio establishments that have refused to pay could face revocation of their liquor licenses, said Ohio Attorney General spokesman Dan Tierney.

However, several area bars have continued to violate the ban and not pay, Libby said, and those that don’t pay risk not having their licenses renewed.

Jim Coffman, owner of Scotty’s Pub, said because the bar business is slow in the summer, many establishments cannot pay.

“If there’s a bar that says, ‘We’re not going to smoke anymore,’ they’re just going to go to another bar,” Coffman said.

The manager at Froggy Blues Café refused to comment, and the manager at Village and Towne Pub could not be reached.

The Associated Press contributed to this story.

Big Tobacco backs Australian law opposers

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/314c9446-91fb-11e1-867e-00144feab49a.html#axzz1u4LyNInF

Description: tobacco

Two of the world’s biggest tobacco companies are providing legal support to member countries at the World Trade Organisation that are threatening to take Australia to international court over the world’s toughest antismoking laws.

Philip Morris International and British American Tobacco, the two largest publicly listed tobacco companies by volume outside China, told the FT they were advising several countries that had complained that Australia’s plain packaging laws – in which tobacco companies will have to sell their products in identical drab packaging – violate international trade agreements.

In March Ukraine, which has a substantial tobacco industry, began legal proceedings against Australia, accusing it of violating intellectual property and free trade laws. Honduras, a tobacco exporter, launched legal action this month. Since then a dozen more countries have signed up to the legal complaints including Brazil, Canada, the EU and Indonesia.

According to the WTO, third-party countries may often sign up to legal complaints and this does not necessarily indicate their opposition. Under the trade body’s rules Australia has until mid-May to settle the dispute, or else it could go before a WTO court.

PMI said the company was openly supporting governments that challenged Australia on plain packaging.

“We have been in contact with many of these countries, including on the trade and legal issues associated with the [plain packaging] policy,” it said. “It is commonplace for affected industries to support countries in WTO disputes and we are open to supporting governments that challenge Australia on plain packaging.”

BAT said the company was happy to provide legal support to member states, but it was “up to them” to accept it.

However, the news drew a sharp response from anti-tobacco campaigners.

“It is very concerning that tobacco companies are using legal action as a delaying tactic against a government that is trying to protect the health of its citizens,” said Robin Hewings, tobacco control manager for Cancer Research UK.

Deborah Arnott, chief executive of the London-based Action on Smoking and Health, accused the tobacco companies of “getting others to do their dirty work”.

Action at the WTO is part of a multi-pronged fightback by Big Tobacco against the plain packaging law that Australia is due to implement in December. The EU and Britain are also considering plain packaging, which tobacco companies worry could spread to lucrative emerging markets.

Japan Tobacco International and Imperial Tobacco have joined PMI and BAT in launching lawsuits against the Australian government, accusing it of illegally confiscating their brands. They say there is no scientific evidence to show plain packaging will reduce smoking rates.

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2012. You may share using our article tools.
Please don’t cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web

Ban on sale of tobacco in Sharjah welcomed

http://www.khaleejtimes.com/kt-article-display-1.asp?xfile=data/nationhealth/2012/May/nationhealth_May12.xml&section=nationhealth

Lily B Libo-on / 5 May 2012
The draft legislation of the Sharjah government to ban tobacco sale at supermarkets and groceries around residential areas has been received favourably by various sectors of society.
Ramez Sawiris, Regulatory Affairs Director of GSK Consumer Healthcare, told Khaleej Times that the legislation is a positive step in raising awareness on the ills of smoking and minimising its affects on the community. “It is yet to be known how this move will impact consumption, but the decrease on the widespread availability of cigarettes will surely help smokers think more closely about the warning labels on each cigarette pack.”
Similarly, Saul Shiffman, Consultant for GSK Consumer Healthcare (NiQuitin), said that despite constant reminders by the health authorities and warning labels on cigarette packs, smoking remains one of the leading preventable causes of several fatal diseases.
“It has the distinction of being one of the few substances affecting all the systems in the human body, from head to toe. Besides being a leading cause of the obvious cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, smoking is known to be a major contributor to many forms of cancer. Additionally, smoking has many adverse effects that are known causes for infertility, preterm delivery and low birth weight,” he said.
A very specific recommendation from Dr Ghada Fahmy, medical director and in-charge of Smoking Cessation Clinic of Al Etihad Health Centre, Ministry of Health, is that shops which continue to sell tobacco to young children and teenagers be closed down.
She said that there is a proliferation of ‘meduakh’, an Arabic term for some sort of smoking pipe where powdered tobacco or tobacco leaves are put in small holes of these pipe and smoked by children as young as 10. “Many Emirati mums have brought their kids in the age-group of 10 and 11 years for medical counseling. The government has to close down the shops selling such stuff as it is very harmful to them. It is indeed a great step by the Sharjah government to ban the sale of tobacco over the counter,” she added.
Sudheer DH, manager of Abraj Al Nahda, a supermarket in Sharjah, said that the tobacco ban, when it will be finally implemented, will affect supermarkets because sales from tobacco alone accounts for about Dh600 daily. “It will definitely affect us as an estimated 15 to 20 per cent of our daily customers are tobacco buyers.”
Filipino Ronald Villanueva, a non-smoking resident of Sharjah for the past eight years, said that even with the ban, it will be difficult to implement the rule as 70 to 80 per cent of males smoke in this emirate. “Many might protest against it and trade in the blackmarket may rise.”
Lebanese Elizabeth Mekhjian, whose husband died of lung cancer, told Khaleej Times that this is good news for her as she supports anti-smoking. “My husband died of lung cancer at 71 even though he quit smoking 20 years before he died. But, the effect of tobacco had long settled in his system.”
Emirati smokers Ahmed Al Shamsi, 18, and his cousin Jassim Al Shamsi, said they would stop smoking when the ban is implemented. But, they believed that the ban will lead to ‘blackmarket selling’ of tobacco and may not really contribute much in stopping teenagers from smoking.
lily@khaleejtimes.com

Lily B Libo-on / 5 May 2012

The draft legislation of the Sharjah government to ban tobacco sale at supermarkets and groceries around residential areas has been received favourably by various sectors of society.

Ramez Sawiris, Regulatory Affairs Director of GSK Consumer Healthcare, told Khaleej Times that the legislation is a positive step in raising awareness on the ills of smoking and minimising its affects on the community. “It is yet to be known how this move will impact consumption, but the decrease on the widespread availability of cigarettes will surely help smokers think more closely about the warning labels on each cigarette pack.”

Similarly, Saul Shiffman, Consultant for GSK Consumer Healthcare (NiQuitin), said that despite constant reminders by the health authorities and warning labels on cigarette packs, smoking remains one of the leading preventable causes of several fatal diseases.

“It has the distinction of being one of the few substances affecting all the systems in the human body, from head to toe. Besides being a leading cause of the obvious cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, smoking is known to be a major contributor to many forms of cancer. Additionally, smoking has many adverse effects that are known causes for infertility, preterm delivery and low birth weight,” he said.

A very specific recommendation from Dr Ghada Fahmy, medical director and in-charge of Smoking Cessation Clinic of Al Etihad Health Centre, Ministry of Health, is that shops which continue to sell tobacco to young children and teenagers be closed down.

She said that there is a proliferation of ‘meduakh’, an Arabic term for some sort of smoking pipe where powdered tobacco or tobacco leaves are put in small holes of these pipe and smoked by children as young as 10. “Many Emirati mums have brought their kids in the age-group of 10 and 11 years for medical counseling. The government has to close down the shops selling such stuff as it is very harmful to them. It is indeed a great step by the Sharjah government to ban the sale of tobacco over the counter,” she added.

Sudheer DH, manager of Abraj Al Nahda, a supermarket in Sharjah, said that the tobacco ban, when it will be finally implemented, will affect supermarkets because sales from tobacco alone accounts for about Dh600 daily. “It will definitely affect us as an estimated 15 to 20 per cent of our daily customers are tobacco buyers.”

Filipino Ronald Villanueva, a non-smoking resident of Sharjah for the past eight years, said that even with the ban, it will be difficult to implement the rule as 70 to 80 per cent of males smoke in this emirate. “Many might protest against it and trade in the blackmarket may rise.”

Lebanese Elizabeth Mekhjian, whose husband died of lung cancer, told Khaleej Times that this is good news for her as she supports anti-smoking. “My husband died of lung cancer at 71 even though he quit smoking 20 years before he died. But, the effect of tobacco had long settled in his system.”

Emirati smokers Ahmed Al Shamsi, 18, and his cousin Jassim Al Shamsi, said they would stop smoking when the ban is implemented. But, they believed that the ban will lead to ‘blackmarket selling’ of tobacco and may not really contribute much in stopping teenagers from smoking.

lily@khaleejtimes.com

New Tobacco Legislation Catches On

http://allafrica.com/stories/printable/201204161103.html

Namibia: New Tobacco Legislation Catches On
By Desie Heita, 16 April 2012Comment

Windhoek – The legislation that seeks to force tobacco companies to sell
cigarettes in plain packaging is slowly catching on with Britain
considering implementing the law, following in Australia’s footsteps.

This is the same legislation that had the world’s biggest and Namibian
market leader in tobacco products, British American Tobacco (BAT),
threatening Namibian lawmakers with a legal challenge if they promulgated
such amendments into Namibian law.

Minister of Health and Social Services, Dr Richard Kamwi, wants to add
restrictions to a part of the section in the Tobacco Products Control Act
No. 1 of 2010. Once in force, the Act would black out marketing and
promotion of tobacco products in the country and restrict tobacco vending
machines to controlled areas with an 18-year age limit.

The amendments were gazetted in November last year with subsequent public
discussions.

The Act also prohibits sponsorship of any Namibian event, however
charitable, by tobacco companies or distributors of tobacco products.

BAT threatened to take lawmakers to court unless changes were made,
saying the proposed restrictions would allow government to expropriate
its trademark properties while robbing the company of freely
communicating to consumers the nature of the lawful products on offer.

According to the proposed regulations, the display of wordings “mild, low
tar or light” would never appear on cigarette boxes or any other tobacco
products because they create the impression to consumers that such a
specific tobacco product is less harmful than others.

The Ministry of Health and Social Services motivated its stance by saying
there is a notable increase in the number of young smokers, most of whom
are women.

Figures provided by the ministry in mid-2010 singled out Hardap Region as
the region where most women smoke with an average percentage higher than
the estimated global women percentage.

The ministry is scared that the number of young smokers could increase as
tobacco companies capitalise on marketing opportunities that become
available to entice new smokers.

In Hardap, the average is 24 percent, which the health ministry says,
“tops the list of women smokers countrywide”.

Interestingly, that average percentage also exceeds the estimated number
of women smokers worldwide, at 20 percent of the total number of smokers.

In Omaheke, women smokers are estimated at 5 percent. “The number could
increase as the industry sees opportunities for business, especially
among women and the youth,” the Ministry of Health and Social Services
had warned.

In addition, the Act mandates the establishment of a fund from levies on
sales of tobacco and other sources.

The fund would partly use the money to pay for treatment of
tobacco-related illnesses.

A mandatory restriction on packaging methods is also being proposed – and
packaging would include graphic pictures depicting the ill health
associated with smoking.

These range from stained teeth, throat cancer to damaged lungs and breast
cancer with appropriate warnings underneath the picture.

Copyright C 2012 New Era. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica
Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly
for corrections – or for permission to republish or make other authorized
use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 130 African news
organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for
their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify
allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.

Remote control roof on smoking area lands pub in court

Wexfordpeople.ie

A PUB smoking area is not a smoking area for the purposes of complying with the law when it has four walls and a roof. But Gorey District Court was told that it may fit the bill if only 50 per cent of the roof is in place.

The finer points of the legislation were teased out last week during the case taken by the health service against Demmac Inns, the firm which runs the Castle Bar on Enniscorthy’s Castle Hill. The case was brought after the environmental health officer called to the premises on August 15 last, when the smoking area was totally enclosed.

Demmac’s solicitor Julie Breen told Judge Gerard Haughton that her clients had spent €5,000 installing a retractable roof operated by remote control. On the date of the offence, rain was falling and the roof was left fully closed. A fine of €500 (HKD 5,300) was handed down and Demmac was ordered to pay prosecution costs of €800 (HKD 9,600).

http://www.wexfordpeople.ie/news/remote-control-roof-on-smoking-area-lands-pub-in-court-3071402.html?service=Print

Government files High Court tobacco defence

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/government-files-high-court-tobacco-defence/story-fn59niix-1226320028978

General Nicola Roxon is ready for a fight over plain tobacco packaging laws. Source: The Courier-Mail

THE federal government has formally rejected big tobacco’s High Court claims that the commonwealth is actually acquiring the companies’ brands through its new cigarette plain packaging laws.

The government lodged its detailed submissions to the High Court today in response to the legal action launched by four big tobacco companies.

In November last year, the government passed landmark laws forcing all cigarettes to be sold in drab olive-brown packs by December 2012.

British American Tobacco, Phillip Morris, Imperial Tobacco Australia and Japan Tobacco International are now challenging the legislation in the High Court.

They believe the laws breach the Australian Constitution because they seek to acquire property – in the form of brand names – without providing compensation.

But the government insists it is restricting the use of brand names and logos, not taking them over.

Breathing new force into smoke laws

SCMP – 28 March 2012

Beijing is weighing up amendments to regulations that would ban smoking in all indoor public places

Beijing city authorities are considering implementing a complete ban on smoking in indoor public spaces, a move that some see as the precursor to a similar ban nationwide.

The Standing Committee of the Beijing Municipal People’s Congress has released draft amendments to the capital’s anti-smoking regulations for public consultation. They would prohibit smoking in lifts, corridors and underground passages in all public places, as well as at outdoor bus stations and sport venues.

The draft marks out indoor workplaces, public transport waiting rooms and vehicles, and indoor public places as areas that must be free of smoking. Smokers would also face fines of between 50 and 200 yuan for smoking in places such restaurants, museums and hospitals, where smoking has been banned since 2008. The current fine is 10 yuan.

Managers of public spaces may also be fined between 10,000 and 30,000 yuan if they fail to persuade smokers to put out their cigarettes.

Another amendment would require tobacco retailers to halt sales on World No Tobacco Day, which falls on May 31 each year.

Progress on tobacco control has been slow in Beijing, even though the city introduced its first ban on smoking in public places in 1995 and another in 2008 ahead of the Olympics.

On May 1 last year, the mainland introduced a ban on smoking in indoor public places. However, workplaces were not included and the ban, initiated by the Ministry of Health, has proved difficult to enforce. A survey in November found that just one in five restaurants in Beijing was obeying the rules.

“China has hundreds of millions of smokers and many tobacco producers are state-run. I don’t think the ban can work effectively,” said Ginessa Huang, who works as a clerk in Shenzhen, said. “I’m a second-hand smoker every day in the office.”

Shanghai introduced a smoking ban covering most public places in 2010, but it is not well enforced. Harbin , the capital of Heilongjiang province , banned smoking in all public indoor areas, including workplaces, in May last year.

huifeng.he@scmp.com

Government of Canada Legislation

Clear the Air says: the cost of treatment for tobacco related diseases in Hong Kong in 1998 was calculated as HKD 5.3 billion per year (University of HK Dept of Community Medicine report). Now in 2012 that cost will be far higher.

Clear the Air queries why this seemingly tycoon friendly Hong Kong Administration has failed to emulate USA and now Canada to sue the tobacco companies for the substantial costs of medical treatment of tobacco related diseases.

Meanwhile the Canadian Province of Alberta has divested from tobacco stocks’ investments with others expected to follow.

The Governments of Norway and New Zealand have already divested from tobacco investments.

The Hong Kong Monetary Authority is in the process of like divestment also, having realised it is unethical, contrary to the FCTC Treaty

binding Hong Kong SAR and a poor long term investment which can only profit from the death and suffering of its citizens.

We trust the Hong Kong Mandatory Provident Fund will soon follow suit.

89% of Hong Kong people do not smoke and would not tolerate third parties investing their contributions in tobacco stocks whilst these lurid despicable companies will always continue to addict Hong Kong youth in the search for profits and replacement smokers.

Download PDF : Copyright

Bill Seeks To Raise Tobacco Purchasing Age To 21 – KTUL.com – Tulsa, Oklahoma – Coverage You Can Count On

http://www.ktul.com/story/16935017/bill-seeks-to-raise-tobacco-purchasing
-age-to-21

Bill Seeks To Raise Tobacco Purchasing Age To 21

Posted: Feb 15, 2012 5:52 AM Updated: Feb 15, 2012 6:16 AM

posted by: Kevin King – email

Tulsa –
A House committee has approved a bill that would gradually increase the
legal age to purchase tobacco in Oklahoma from 18 to 21.

House Bill 2314 would increase the age from 18 to 19 next year, to 20 in
2014 and 21 in 2015. The bill was authored by Representative Ann Coody of
Lawton, who says it would make Oklahoma the first state to increase the
age to 21.

“The younger someone starts smoking, the harder it is to break the
addiction later in life,” said Coody. “By raising the age restriction on
tobacco purchases, we can deter many young people from ever starting this
bad habit and save them years of health complications.”