Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

August, 2012:

In China, Anti-Smoking Efforts Hindered by Big Tobacco

http://blogs.voanews.com/breaking-news/2012/08/17/in-china-anti-smoking-efforts-hindered-by-big-tobacco/

Posted Friday, August 17th, 2012 at 5:45 am

A new study says China has the largest number of tobacco users in the world. And analysts say efforts to curb the habit are being hindered by the country’s state-owned tobacco enterprises.

The British-based medical journal Lancet said Friday in a report on global smoking rates that around 300 million people, about 28 percent of the population, use tobacco products in China, despite new restrictions on public smoking.

The study’s lead author, Dr. Gary Giovino, says China’s government-owned cigarette companies, an important source of revenue, are even encouraging the deadly habit with advertisements in elementary schools.

“The China National Tobacco Company has supported elementary schools in China, dozens and dozens of them. And they use their support to promote propaganda about tobacco use, and they are basically telling students that genius comes from hard work and tobacco helps them to be successful. That to me is mind boggling, that a government would tell its children to use tobacco to be successful when tobacco will addict them and shorten their lives.”

China has taken some recent steps to lessen public tobacco use, banning smoking in restaurants, bars, and other outdoor venues.

But Angela Merriam of the Beijing-based China Policy organization says the new smoking ban is not being consistently enforced.

“The ban on smoking in public spaces is completely ineffective. For example, I have a student who did an informal survey of just over 60 establishments in China. Of those polled, almost 70 percent said they permit smoking. And while 80 percent had heard of the regulations, only 12 percent of people in the restaurants had heard of a fine for a violation of the regulation.”

Other say that any substantial progress will be difficult as long as the same authorities responsible for controlling tobacco use are also in charge of tobacco production.

Bruce Jacobs, a China analyst at Monash University in Australia, says part of the problem is that health advocacy groups in China are being marginalized by the country’s big tobacco companies.

“A lot of the tobacco growing and the manufacturing of cigarettes in China is done by big state-owned corporations, and they bring in money. (So) the health organizations don’t have as much clout as these big economic organizations.”

The Lancet study said that tobacco use around the world is greatly influenced by the pro-tobacco lobby. The World Health Organization estimates that six million people worldwide die annually of tobacco-related illnesses. At least one million of those deaths occur in China.

HK in the firing line for global tobacco

SCMP

Aug 17, 2012

The threat by a global tobacco company to invoke its Hong Kong-derived rights in Australia carries about it a strong whiff of desperation. The warning was made by Philip Morris, owner of Marlboro, which along with other companies has lost a court challenge in Canberra against the world’s first law banning cigarette branding.

Instead of packaging that manages to be familiar despite health warnings and obscene images, in Australia cigarettes will be sold only in “generic packaging” – making all varieties indistinguishable from one another and bearing images of the dead and dying. Along with the Marlboro cowboy, billions of dollars worth of branding is about to head off into the sunset, starting in Australia.

Philip Morris says it will seek compensation under the terms of Australia’s bilateral investment protection treaty with Hong Kong. In reports on this week’s hearings in Canberra, it emerged that Philip Morris’ brands in Australia are owned by Philip Morris Asia, which has been incorporated in this city since 1994.

Article 1 (e) (iv) of the 1993 Hong Kong-Australia bilateral investment treaty does offer protection for trademarks, but subject to the laws of either country, which in the case of Australia have now been changed and will take effect in December. Article 5 allows for compensation but only in the case of losses owing to war, revolution, insurrection “or other similar events”. It says nothing about compensation for losses caused by legislation which has been constitutionally enacted by a democratic country acting out of concern for the health of its citizens.

Much to the horror of Big Tobacco, Australia’s new law will be copied by other countries if it is shown that such legislation can overcome the hurdles thrown up by tobacco companies. If not, an obscure treaty with Hong Kong will have served as global tobacco’s last line of defence. That’s a dubious honour for this city, but an unlikely one, with the tobacco industry showing all the signs of someone who should have stopped smoking ages ago: shortness of breath and a haunted, deathly pallor.

bonny.schoonakker@scmp.com

Customs seizes HK$22.5 m worth of cigarettes

http://www.thestandard.com.hk/breaking_news_detail.asp?id=23386&icid=a&d_str=

17 Aug 2012

Description: http://thestandard.com.hk/images/instant_news/20120816/49C6150D718F4BAAB2F1A53A896B30DD_B.JPG

Hong Kong Customs smashed a transshipment smuggling case with the seizure of 9 million sticks of duty-not-paid cigarettes on August 14. The illicit cigarettes were worth about HK$22.5 million with a duty potential of about HK$15.3 million.
Through risk assessment, Customs officers of the Harbour and River Trade Division picked a 40-foot container declared to contain 253 packages of women’s apparel and trousers from a river trade vessel for examination. The container was destined for Jamaica.
Customs officers found the consignment was camouflaged with 40 cartons of toilet paper and a total of 9 million sticks of illicit cigarettes were found at the back of the container

Lancet article and Commentary, August 16, 2012

Download PDF :

GATS_Lancet

Lancet_Press_Release

UB_Press_Release_Giovino

GATS_LancetArticle_Factsheet

Lancet Comment. First we need to know the numbers. Koplan, Mackay. Lancet 12 08 18

Australian court approves tobacco pack logo ban

http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/08/15/us-australia-tobacco-idUSBRE87D0PI20120815

Description: A woman smokes next to a cigarette pack in central Sydney in this October 12, 2011 file photo. REUTERS-Daniel Munoz-Files

Description: A woman holds a packet Winfield cigarettes at Bondi beach in Sydney August 15, 2012. REUTERS-Daniel Munoz

CANBERRA (Reuters) – Australia called on the world to match its tough new anti-tobacco marketing laws that will ban logos on cigarette packs, after its highest court on Wednesday dismissed a challenge from global manufacturers.

The decision means that from December 1, cigarettes and tobacco products must be sold in plain olive green packets with graphic health warnings, such as pictures of mouth cancer and other smoking-related illnesses.

Although the impact of Australia on their global business is small, the law could have a major effect if it is adopted as a precedent in other countries, especially the fast-growing economies that cigarette firms see as markets of the future.

The laws are in line with World Health Organisation recommendations and are being watched closely by countries including Britain, Norway, New Zealand, Canada and India, which are considering similar measures to help fight smoking.

British American Tobacco, Britain’s Imperial Tobacco, Philip Morris and Japan Tobacco challenged the laws in Australia’s High Court, claiming the rules were unconstitutional because they effectively extinguished their intellectual property rights.

In a brief statement, the High Court said a majority of its seven judges believed the laws did not breach Australia’s constitution. A full judgment will be released later.

The World Health Organisation estimates that more than 1 billion people around the world are regular smokers, with 80 percent in low- and middle-income countries.

Shares in tobacco groups dipped lower with Philip Morris down 0.5 percent in New York and BAT off 1.9 percent and Imperial Tobacco down 1.7 in London.

Supporters of the measure hailed the legal victory as an important step for public health in Australia and any other countries that may copy it.

Australian Attorney-General Nicola Roxon hailed the ruling as “a watershed moment for tobacco control around the world”.

“The message to the rest of the world is big tobacco can be taken on and beaten,” said Roxon, whose father, a smoker, died of cancer when she was 10.

“Without brave governments willing to take the fight up to big tobacco, they’d still have us believing that tobacco is neither harmful nor addictive,” she said after the ruling.

According to the global Tobacco Atlas, a report on smoking produced by the World Lung Foundation and the American Cancer Society, 17 percent of male deaths and 14 percent of female deaths in Australia are due to tobacco.

“We hope other nations follow Australia’s lead and eliminate the use of tobacco packaging as a marketing tool, to help reduce the global tobacco death toll — which is on track to reach half a billion people this century,” said Australia’s Cancer Council Chief Executive Ian Olver.

FIRST OF MANY BLOODY NOSES?

Countries with legal systems similar to Australia’s may be among the first to try to copy the packaging logo ban.

New Zealand’s Associate Health Minister Tariana Turia said the decision gave New Zealand more confidence to push ahead with similar measures. In Britain, which is also considering such steps, anti-smoking and health campaigners welcomed the ruling.

“This is a major victory not just for Australia but for the world and the first of many bloody noses for the tobacco industry on plain packaging. It should encourage the British government to go ahead with legislation,” said Deborah Arnott, chief executive of anti-smoking lobby group Action on Smoking and Health.

Britain finished a four-month consultation process on plain packaging last week and will now analyze the thousands of responses it has received. It is expected to make a decision on whether to push ahead with legislation later this year.

The Department of Health said no decision had been taken, although Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has been quoted as saying “we no longer see smoking as part of life” and that he wanted tobacco companies to have “no business in the UK”.

Canada, meanwhile, has just implemented graphic warning rules and is watching developments in Australia.

“At this time, the Department is not planning any regulatory action to require plain packaging for tobacco packages. Health Canada continues to review available research on plain packaging as a form of tobacco control and closely monitors plain packaging proposals put forward in other countries, such as Australia,” Olivia Caron, a spokeswoman for Health Canada, said.

A spread of plain-package laws to emerging markets, such as Brazil, Russia or Indonesia, could threaten cigarette firms’ sales growth.

In Indonesia, the government said it would like to follow Australia’s example. “That’s excellent … this is one way to protect the people,” Health Minister Nafsiah Mboi told Reuters.

However, anti-tobacco campaigner Tulus Abadi, head of the national commission on tobacco control, said there had been little movement from the government on a draft law to include graphic warnings on cigarette packets like those in Australia.

Russia’s Rospotrebnadzor, the state consumer protection agency, was not available for comment on Wednesday.

But plain-package laws are not likely to come to that country anytime soon, one Russian anti-tobacco analyst said.

“For now, we (Russia) would not be able to get rid of companies’ logos from cigarette packages,” said Dmitry Yanin, a Russian anti-tobacco activist and head of the International Confederation of Consumer Societies. “But we do hope the ruling will help us implement a law that calls for introduction of graphic images of the effects of smoking on cigarette packages.”

CHALLENGES

Tobacco firms say plain packaging laws violate their intellectual property rights and will stimulate a black market in fake or illegally imported cigarettes.

“It’s still a bad law that will only benefit organized crime groups, which sell illegal tobacco on our streets,” British American Tobacco Australia spokesman Scott McIntyre said after the decision. However, he said the firm would comply.

Firms can also use free trade arguments against plain packaging laws. Australia is already fighting trade complaints in the World Trade Organization (WTO) from Ukraine, Honduras and the Dominican Republic, which claim the laws unfairly restrict trade, although their trade with Australia is negligible.

Philip Morris said it would launch a legal challenge against the laws under a bilateral Australia-Hong Kong investment agreement.

“There is still a long way to go before all the legal questions about plain packaging are fully explored and answered,” Philip Morris spokesman Chris Argent said in a statement.

(Additional reporting by Gyles Beckford in WELLINGTON, Olivia Rondonuwu in JAKARTA,; Kate Kelland David Jones in LONDON; Ece Toksabay in ISTANBUL; Lidia Kelly in MOSCOW; Louise Egan in OTTAWA; and Brad Dorfman in CHICAGO; Writing by Paul Tait and David Jones; Editing by Peter Graff and Marguerita Choy)

Smoke signals rule in tobacco identity crisis

http://www.caseyweeklyberwick.com.au/news/national/national/general/smoke-s
ignals-rule-in-tobacco-identity-crisis/2650573.aspx

RACHEL WELLS

16 Aug, 2012 03:00 AM

”IMAGINATIVE” use of brand names and social media could become the next
big marketing weapons for tobacco companies, as cigarette packs look set to
be stripped of their branding, experts said.

Anti-smoking groups were also concerned that incentives for vendors to
promote certain cigarette brands could increase as tobacco companies fought
for their share in a declining market.

”It’s impossible to exaggerate what a massive blow this is for tobacco
companies because their pack is their brand identity,” Professor Simon
Chapman, a public health academic at the University of Sydney, said.

”But what they’ve still got is their name and I think we’ll see companies
really start trying to introduce compelling new brand names that in
particular will appeal to a young demographic.”

Professor Chapman pointed to boutique cigarette brands such as Pink Dreams
and German brand, Sex Smooth ‘n Easy, as examples of brand names that could
lure young smokers.

Becky Freeman, from the University of Sydney, whose research into online
tobacco marketing was published in the international journal Tobacco
Control, said cigarette companies would increasingly look to the ”poorly
regulated” online space to promote its products.

”Already we are seeing a lot of activity here with fan pages for
cigarette brands on Facebook and product reviews on YouTube. As another
avenue for marketing closes in Australia, this industry is going to look at
what avenues are still open to them and invest in those areas in very
creative ways.”

Tobacco companies are banned from advertising on Australian websites but
there is nothing stopping them directly, or indirectly, from setting up
Facebook pages that promote their brands.

A Melbourne Business School associate professor of marketing, Don
O’Sullivan, said the best form of advertising left open to tobacco
companies in Australia was word of mouth and people seeing others smoking,
”whether it be within their social network or on TV”.

Confusing smoke signals after Oz cigarettes victory

The health chief appears to have backtracked from an earlier promise to clamp down harder on tobacco.

Mary Ann Benitez

Thursday, August 16, 2012

The health chief appears to have backtracked from an earlier promise to clamp down harder on tobacco.

There were high hopes that, under Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying and health minister Ko Wing-man, Hong Kong could follow Australia in banning “mini-billboard advertising” by imposing plain cigarette packaging.

Canberra won its battle against Big Tobacco yesterday when the High Court of Australia ruled that forcing cigarettes and tobacco products to be sold in drab green uniform packaging with graphic health warnings from December 1 this year does not contravene the country’s constitution.

Asked by The Standard whether Hong Kong would follow suit, a spokesman for the Food and Health Bureau said the government is committed to control tobacco use “in accordance with the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control.”

She added: “We will continue to monitor the situation and review our measures with a view to protecting public health in Hong Kong. We do not have any concrete proposal for new measures at this juncture.”

In June, before he was officially appointed as secretary for food and health by Leung, Ko told The Standard: “As a doctor and as chairman of the Hong Kong Anti-Cancer Society, I would support any initiative to help eliminate tobacco.”

At least 20 countries have introduced plain packaging but have been challenged in the courts.

Hong Kong-based Philip Morris Asia has already launched a lawsuit in Hong Kong alleging the law on plain packaging breached Australia’s bilateral investment treaty with the territory.

WHO welcomes landmark decision from Australia’s High Court on tobacco plain packaging act

Statement WHO / 8

15 August 2012

WHO welcomes landmark decision from Australia’s High Court on tobacco plain packaging act

Statement from Dr Margaret Chan, Director-General, World Health Organization

GENEVA 15 August 2012 – The World Health Organization (WHO) strongly welcomes the landmark decision from Australia’s High Court to dismiss a legal challenge from the tobacco industry, and calls on the rest of the world to follow Australia’s tough stance on tobacco marketing.

Several major tobacco companies challenged Australia’s legislation to require cigarettes and other tobacco products to be sold in plain packaging without any branding.  But the industry’s attempt to derail this effective tobacco control measure failed. As of December 2012, Australia will be the first country to sell cigarettes in drab, olive-green packaging without branding.

With Australia’s victory, public health enters a brave new world of tobacco control. Plain packaging is a highly effective way to counter industry’s ruthless marketing tactics. It is also fully in line with the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. The lawsuits filed by Big Tobacco look like the death throes of a desperate industry. With so many countries lined up to ride on Australia’s coattails, what we hope to see is a domino effect for the good of public health.

The case is being watched closely by several other countries who are considering similar measures to help fight tobacco.

The evidence on the positive health impact of plain packaging compiled by Australia’s High Court will benefit other countries in their efforts to develop and implement strong tobacco control measures to protect the health of their people and to stand resolute against the advances of the tobacco industry.

Tobacco use is one of the most preventable public health threats.  Tobacco products will eventually kill up to half of the people who use them – that means nearly 6 million people die each year.  If governments do not take strong action to limit exposures to tobacco, by 2030 it could kill more than 8 million people each year.

The WHO Framework Convention for Tobacco Control entered into force in 2005. Parties are obliged over time to take a number of steps to reduce demand and supply for tobacco products including: protecting people from exposure to tobacco smoke, counteracting illicit trade, banning advertising, promotion and sponsorship, banning sales to minors, putting large health warnings on packages of tobacco, increasing tobacco taxes and creating a national coordinating mechanism for tobacco control. More than 170 countries are Parties to the Convention.

For more information:

Glenn Thomas

Communications Officer

World Health Organization

tel +41 22 791 3983

mobile +41 79 509 0677

thomasg@who.int<mailto:thomasg@who.int

TI influencing tobacco tax TC 12 08.pdf

Download PDF : TI influencing tobacco tax TC 12 08

WHO welcomes landmark decision from Australia’s High Court on tobacco plain packaging act

Statement WHO / 8

15 August 2012

WHO welcomes landmark decision from Australia’s High Court on tobacco plain packaging act

Statement from Dr Margaret Chan, Director-General, World Health Organization

GENEVA 15 August 2012 – The World Health Organization (WHO) strongly welcomes the landmark decision from Australia’s High Court to dismiss a legal challenge from the tobacco industry, and calls on the rest of the world to follow Australia’s tough stance on tobacco marketing.

Several major tobacco companies challenged Australia’s legislation to require cigarettes and other tobacco products to be sold in plain packaging without any branding.  But the industry’s attempt to derail this effective tobacco control measure failed. As of December 2012, Australia will be the first country to sell cigarettes in drab, olive-green packaging without branding.

With Australia’s victory, public health enters a brave new world of tobacco control. Plain packaging is a highly effective way to counter industry’s ruthless marketing tactics. It is also fully in line with the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. The lawsuits filed by Big Tobacco look like the death throes of a desperate industry. With so many countries lined up to ride on Australia’s coattails, what we hope to see is a domino effect for the good of public health.

The case is being watched closely by several other countries who are considering similar measures to help fight tobacco.

The evidence on the positive health impact of plain packaging compiled by Australia’s High Court will benefit other countries in their efforts to develop and implement strong tobacco control measures to protect the health of their people and to stand resolute against the advances of the tobacco industry.

Tobacco use is one of the most preventable public health threats.  Tobacco products will eventually kill up to half of the people who use them – that means nearly 6 million people die each year.  If governments do not take strong action to limit exposures to tobacco, by 2030 it could kill more than 8 million people each year.

The WHO Framework Convention for Tobacco Control entered into force in 2005. Parties are obliged over time to take a number of steps to reduce demand and supply for tobacco products including: protecting people from exposure to tobacco smoke, counteracting illicit trade, banning advertising, promotion and sponsorship, banning sales to minors, putting large health warnings on packages of tobacco, increasing tobacco taxes and creating a national coordinating mechanism for tobacco control. More than 170 countries are Parties to the Convention.

For more information:

Glenn Thomas

Communications Officer

World Health Organization

tel +41 22 791 3983

mobile +41 79 509 0677

thomasg@who.int<mailto:thomasg@who.int