Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Street loitering and smoking from July 1st onwards

EXTENSION OF ANTI SMOKING LAWS IN HONG KONG – JULY 1ST 2009

as you are no doubt aware from July 1st 2009 all smoking exemptions in Hong Kong are revoked.

It will be illegal from midnight on June 30th to smoke in any workplace including restaurants, bars, night clubs, mahjong rooms, karaokes, saunas etc.

It is expected that some smokers will give up smoking as a result of the new legislation commencement ; however it seems also obvious that many smokers will step out of premises and smoke in the street near to office, pub, restaurant etc entrances.

The Hong Kong Government has not followed overseas laws which

a) place the onus on licensees to enforce non smoking in their premises and to lose their liquor licence if they default

b) ban smoking within a set distance (varies by country between 3 meters and 10 meters) of an office

bar, hospital, school, park , pub , restaurant or other workplace entrance

Accordingly we must currently operate to prevent this situation by using existing Hong Kong laws until we can lobby for better ones to suit these circumstances.

Below please find Clear the Air’s interpretation of Hong Kong laws and how they can be applied

Cap 200 section 160 (3)

Secondhand cigarette smoke is at least 4 times more toxic than mainstream smoke and proven to kill people. (see attached reports)

1,324 people die from passive smoking (HKU report) each year here. With the extension of the law many smokers will now block entrances to buildings, restaurants and bars etc after July 1st in order to smoke. The Administration has chosen not to follow sensible overseas laws which ban smoking within a set distance of entrances to offices, bars, restaurants etc. Most people have the knowledge that secondhand tobacco smoke kills and causes serious illnesses ; any person therefore concerned for their safety and well being ofthemselves, their children and others who might be affected by persons loitering in public spaces and smoking near entrances that they might wish to use to enter premises or even to pass by, have reason to fear for their well being, and those persons smoking would seem prima facie to be in breach of Cap 200 S160 (c).

CRIMES ORDINANCE Cap 220 – SECT 160

Loitering

PART XIII

MISCELLANEOUS OFFENCES

(1) A person who loiters in a public place or in the common parts of any

building with intent to commit an arrestable offence commits an offence and is liable to a fine of $10000 and to imprisonment for 6 months. (Replaced 74 of 1992 s. 3)

(2) Any person who loiters in a public place or in the common parts of any building and in any way wilfully obstructs any person using that place or the common parts of that building, shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on conviction to imprisonment for 6 months.

(3) If any person loiters in a public place or in the common parts of any building and his presence there, either alone or with others, causes any person reasonably to be concerned for his safety or well-being, he shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on conviction to imprisonment for 2 years.

(4) In this section “common parts” (公用部分), in relation to a building,

means-

(a)  any entrance hall, lobby, passageway, corridor, staircase, landing, rooftop, lift or escalator;

(b)  any cellar, toilet, water closet, wash house, bath-house or kitchen  which is in common use by the occupiers of the building;

(c)  any compound, garage, carpark, car port or lane. (Added 37 of 1979 s. 2)

“common parts” (公用部分)

Non compliant licensees

The Hong Kong Government does not under Cap 371 put the onus on the licensees of premises previously exempted under the ‘Qualified Establishment’ smoking ban deferment or on other licensees to enforce the prevention of smoking in their premises.

However under the Liquor Licence licensing conditions Annex VI paragraph 7 it states:

“7. The licensee shall not permit any person to occupy or use any portion of the premises for any immoral or illegal purpose.”

It therefore seems reasonable to hold that any licensee allowing the liquor licensed premises to be used for the illegal purpose of smoking from July 1st 2009 commits a breach of his / her liquor licensing conditions (attached below).

The Hong Kong Police are the authority which usually inspects premises for breaches of liquor licensing conditions.

Annex VI

Licensing Conditions for Liquor Licence

1. No disorder shall be permitted on the premises.

2. No person shall be allowed to become drunk on the premises, nor shall liquor be supplied to any person who is drunk.

3. No games of chance shall be played on the premises.

4. The licensee shall personally supervise the premises.

5. The licensee shall display a warning notice at a conspicuous place inside the premises containing the words “NO LIQUOR FOR PERSON UNDER THE AGE OF 18”. In the said notice, the size of each Chinese character shall not be less than 3 cm (height) x 3 cm (width) and the size of each English letter shall not be less than 2 cm (height) x 2 cm (width).

6. The licensee shall exhibit and keep exhibited a notice denoting its licensed status provided by the Board at the main entrance of the premises.

7. The licensee shall not permit any person to occupy or use any portion of the premises for any immoral or illegal purpose.

8. The licensee shall not permit any common prostitutes or reputed thieves to assemble or remain on the premises.

9. The licensee shall not permit drunkenness, or violence, quarrel or other disorderly conduct on the premises and shall not permit persons of known bad character to assemble and remain on the premises.

10. The name of any liquor for which a standard of quality is prescribed by regulations shall be clearly marked on the container in or from which the liquor is supplied to any customers.

11. No bar business shall be operated on the premises, except with the permission of the Board endorsed herein.

12. No dancing shall be permitted on the premises, except with the permission of the Board endorsed herein.

13. Toilets shall be maintained in a state of cleanliness and good repair for the use of customers

http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/338/feb12_2/b462

Exposure to secondhand smoke and cognitive impairment in non-smokers: national cross sectional study with cotinine measurement

Conclusions Exposure to secondhand smoke may be associated with increased odds of cognitive impairment. Prospective nationallyrepresentative studies relating biomarkers of exposure to cognitive decline and risk of dementia are needed.

WHAT YOU CAN DO IF YOU SEE PEOPLE SMOKING OR CARRYING A LIT TOBACCO PRODUCT ILLEGALLY IN ANY PREMISES:

– USE YOUR PHONE CAMERA TO TAKE A PICTURE OF THE INCIDENT – A PICTURE IS WORTH A THOUSAND WORDS

– REPORT THE INCIDENT TO THE PREMISES’ LICENSEE

– REPORT THE INCIDENT TO TOBACCO CONTROL (TCO) AND ADVISE THEM WHETHER THE LICENSEE TOOK ACTION OR NOT – THEY WILL ASK YOU WHETHER YOU ARE WILLING TO TESTIFY IN COURT IF REQUIRED. TCO WILL PROBABLY VISIT THE PREMISES WITHIN THE WEEK OR IN CONJUNCTION WITH OTHER RAIDS

– REPORT THE INCIDENT TO THE POLICE STATION IN THE AREA WHERE THE LICENSED PREMISES IS LOCATED AND CONSIDER A COMPLAINT THAT THE LICENSEE IS IN BREACH OF LICENSING CONDITION 7 OF HIS LIQUOR LICENCE CONDITIONS. THIS WILL REQUIRE THE POLICE STATION LICENSING OFFICER TO OPEN A LOOSE MINUTE FILE AND INSPECT THE PREMISES.

– IF YOU SEE PEOPLE SMOKING OUTSIDE ENTRANCES OF PUBS AND RESTAURANTS CONSIDER A REPORT UNDER CAP 200 SECTION 160 ( 3)TO THE POLICE STATION IN THE AREA WHERE THE PREMISES IS LOCATED.

– IF YOU SEE TABLES AND CHAIRS ON THE PAVEMENT OUTSIDE LICENSED PREMISES TO CATER FOR SMOKERS THIS IS AN OBSTRUCTION UNDER THE SUMMARY OFFENCES ORDINANCE AND CAN BE REPORTED TO THE POLICE


Address :

Tobacco Control Office
Department of Health18th & 25th Floor, Wu Chung House,
213 Queen’s Road East,
Hong Kong

Telephone :

2961 8823

Facsimile :

2575 8944

Email:

tobaccocontrol@dh.gov.hk

SO WHERE CAN PEOPLE STILL LEGALLY SMOKE IN ENTERTAINMENT PREMISES ?

OSA (outside seating accommodation ) patio areas of bars and restaurants as long as they are not 50% or more enclosed on the sides and have a roof. The roof can be parasols covering tables or a moveable cloth roof as well as a standard roof. The premises must have a valid OSA licence and this can be searched on the FEHD website.

HK extends smoke ban to bars, clubs, etc

chinadaily.com.cn

HONG KONG: Smokers in Hong Kong will have to stub out their cigarettes before entering recreational venues to avoid hefty fines as an extended smoking ban comes into effect July 1.

A spokesperson of the HKSAR Health Department said late Monday that smoking will not be allowed in bars, night clubs, bathhouses, massage and mahjong premises and violators of the rule could have to pay 5,000 HK dollars in financial punishment at the most.

The spokesperson called for cooperation from the management of these venues in providing a smoke-free environment for their staff and customers, noting “they are authorized to require anyone to stop smoking in no-smoking areas and can request those refusing to produce their identity and address for follow-up action, or ask them to leave.”

Hong Kong health authorities have already implemented a smoke ban covering all indoor areas of workplaces, public places, restaurants, and karaoke lounges since 2007.

The extended ban “can further protect the public from exposure to second-hand smoke,” the spokesperson said.

According to a survey released by the government in March, more than 70 percent of those polled support the extension of the smoke ban to take effect July 1.

However, an activist group for the recreational industry argued that an overwhelming proportion of the 1,018 respondents never or seldom go to recreational venues and less than 20 percent of them are smokers, so the survey may “lack credibility.”

The group made a statement in major local newspapers published Tuesday, saying it is “totally disappointed” that the government gives no regard to appeals of the industry as the financial tsunami already hits hard on the sector, which is bound to be impacted further by the ban.

Asia’s one-woman anti-tobacco campaign still going strong

Guy Newey, AFP

HONG KONG (AFP) — For most of the past 25 years, Hong Kong-based, British-born doctor Judith Mackay has been the tobacco control movement in Asia.

She has pushed for tougher laws and higher tobacco taxes, lobbied for bans on advertising, and advised and cajoled governments in Hong Kong, Laos, China, Vietnam and most other Asian countries.

She drafted Mongolia’s first post-Soviet anti-smoking law in her hotel room on the last night of her trip there, after spending most of the visit under suspicion of being an American spy.

Her success is based on her ability to convince the right person with the right power to make changes that will save lives. And she is happy to take advantage of non-democratic regimes.

“That is one of the reasons I was so active in the 1980s. Once you had democracies, you have white papers and green papers, you had public debates and forums and it went on forever,” the 65-year-old said from her Hong Kong home.

“I found I could jump over quite a few fences in one go,” added Mackay, who has been a senior policy adviser to the World Health Organization for more than 10 years.

Her vigour has inevitably drawn the attention of the tobacco industry — she was once described by a trade organisation as one of the three most dangerous people in the world.

She has been threatened with lawsuits, had secret dossiers prepared on her and even received death threats from one pro-smoking group.

“Every time my spirits are sagging all I have to do is be threatened with another lawsuit or a death threat and I am up and running again,” she said.

In recent years, Mackay’s efforts have been recognised — she was awarded an OBE by Queen Elizabeth last year, as well as many other accolades.

Most importantly, she now spearheads the growing professionalism of the Asia’s anti-tobacco movement, boosted by a grant from New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s foundation.

It funds her position at the World Lung Foundation working on cutting tobacco use in low- and middle-income countries, with a focus on Asia.

“Bloomberg has brought business management into tobacco control. It is not an option to run over deadlines, like some academics and governments,” she said.

“You are now offered a career path in tobacco control. Before, there was nobody to employ you.”

Mackay was born in Yorkshire and went to medical school in Edinburgh, where she was briefly a smoker, before giving up after a few months because her roommate had asthma.

She later moved to Hong Kong and worked in a hospital, but the satisfaction of saving lives dimmed as she realised that so many were coming in with the same, smoking-related problems.

“We used to joke that in the male medical wards we never admitted a non-smoker. Everyone was coming in with cancer or heart disease or chronic bronchitis or bleeding duodenal ulcers,” she said.

Mackay, who completed Asia’s first study on domestic violence, began writing a column for the South China Morning Post newspaper on women’s health issues, and one of her early topics was smoking.

Unbeknown to her, one of the major tobacco firms prepared a dossier on her saying the anti-smoking forces in Hong Kong were “unrepresentative and unaccountable.”

When it was leaked to her, she said, “I was so outraged.

“I sometimes say that I have (that company) to thank for getting into tobacco control,” she said, adding that the surveillance highlighted how crucial Asia was to Big Tobacco’s expansion plans.

“At that stage, Big Tobacco were looking at Asia as their utopia,” she said.

“If they could persuade Asian men to change to international brand cigarettes, and persuade Asian women to smoke, everybody in North America could give up tomorrow and it wouldn’t make any difference.”

She became a full-time campaigner, representing Asia at conferences (“There was really only one person working in Asia,” she said of herself), educating government ministers and pushing for changes, even if they were merely symbolic.

She convinced Cambodia to ban tobacco advertising during children’s television programmes, even though there wasn’t any. Such decisions put down a marker which can then be extended and expanded incrementally, she said.

“China has just banned vending machines selling cigarettes. I am not sure if anyone has seen a vending machine there,” she said.

John Crofton, the British campaigner who found the first cure for tuberculosis and is Mackay’s mentor, said she has been a powerful force.

“I have immense admiration for her energy, drive, skill in managing people and her utter devotion to saving the world from its most lethal habit,” he said.

Mackay shows no sign of slowing down, despite reaching retirement age, but she remains careful not to hector governments.
“My whole modus operandi is not telling people what to do. I say ‘what do you think might be the next step forward for China?’ I put decisions and thinking on to the people in the country,” she said.

Copyright © 2009 AFP. All rights reserved.

Drink-drivers face stiffer penalties under study set to go before Legco

Anita Lam, SCMP

First-time offenders for drink-driving should be banned from getting back behind the wheel for at least two years if their blood-alcohol level was three times over the legal limit when they were caught, according to a consultation paper to be discussed by the Transport Advisory Committee today.

The paper proposes that the government introduce a three-tier penalty to replace the current three-month suspension period, sources said.

First-time offenders would have their licences suspended for a minimum of six months, one year or two years depending on whether their alcohol level exceeds 50mg, 80mg or 150mg per 100ml of blood, respectively. They currently face a minimum three months’ suspension.

For second-time offenders, the minimum suspension would be two years, three years and five years. At present, they are banned from driving for at least two years.

The suggestions came out of a four-month review of drink-driving legislation and other related laws following a fatal collision between a taxi and a truck in Lok Ma Chau that claimed six lives last December. The truck driver is awaiting trial on a charge of dangerous driving causing death.

The minimum two-year disqualification for a conviction for dangerous driving causing death will not be changed. That means it would be possible for a drink-driver to be banned from getting behind the wheel for a longer period than someone who kills a person while driving.

But the government is suggesting that drink-driving be introduced as an aggravating factor for cases of dangerous driving causing death, allowing judges to add an extra 50 per cent to the sentence and the disqualification period, a well-placed source said. “It is a guideline, after all. Two years [of disqualification] is a minimum,” the source said. “The judge can exercise his discretion.”

The maximum jail term for dangerous driving causing death was increased from five years to 10 years in July. Authorities were also planning to introduce a charge called dangerous driving causing grievous bodily harm. It is understood the offence will carry a maximum jail term of seven years and at least two years’ licence disqualification.

“The new charge is to address drink-driving accidents in which the victims are critically injured or in coma,” another source said. The existing penalty for drink driving, a maximum of three years’ jail, “does not seem appropriate for such cases”.
Officers studied overseas legislation and World Health Organisation guidelines on alcohol consumption to reach the suggestions. The proposal will be discussed by the Legislative Council’s transport panel on July 17.

Families of victims have called for jail terms to be separated from the disqualification period, with the two penalties to be served one after the other, rather than concurrently.

But the source said that would require further study and there were few precedents on the matter in other jurisdictions.

______________________________________________

CTA says : 1,324 people die from passive smoking per year in Hong Kong – it’s time the Government took similar action against passive smoking

Smoking Ban Broadcast in RTHK

RTHK – click link 1 or link 2 to listen

8:30- 9:15 Smoking Ban

Interviewee

  1. James Middleton, Chairman of the Anti-Tobacco Committee of Clear The Air
  2. Dr. Ignatius Yu is a Professor in the Department of Community and Family Medicine of The Chinese University of Hong Kong
  3. Paul Tse, Legislator representing Tourism Functional Constituency
  4. Simon Wong, President of the Federation of Restaurants
mfile_514_93514_1.jpg (240×180)

Today on Backchat, we talk about the full enforcement of smoking ban in the local community

Dr. Ignatius Yu (L) and James Middleton

Click here to RTHK website to listen: http://www.rthk.org.hk/rthk/radio3/backchat/20090629.html

Struggling venues may turn a blind eye to smoking ban

Danny Mok and Dan Kadison – SCMP

Come Wednesday, smoking will be banned in all indoor areas at workplaces and in public spaces – and bars, nightclubs, clubs, saunas, massage parlours and mahjong parlours will no longer be exempt.

Many such venues are ready to comply, but several establishments could be a bit hazy when it comes to the spirit of the law, the Sunday Morning Post has learned.

Several venue owners and members of an association said they feared business would plummet as a result of the ban, and they would take a fairly lenient enforcement stance.

Chin Chun-wing, vice-chairman of the Bar and Club Association, a group which represents about 200 bars in the city, said he believed members would lose 50 per cent of their business as a result of the ban, the financial downturn and swine flu.

“We have to remove ashtrays, but honestly, if we find customers smoking, we can’t do much as business has already been very bad. We can’t stop them smoking and drive them out of there. We won’t do anything. We don’t want to annoy smoking customers, especially those drunken ones, who might react very unexpectedly,” Mr Chin said.

Mr Chin did say, however, that his group members would let offenders know about the smoking ban. “Being licence-holders, we have to display smoke-ban posters and stickers as required by the government, or we will have to worry about applications for licence renewals in the future.”

Christopher Cheung Ka-ning, managing director of the Hong Kong Mahjong Company, a parlour in Wan Chai and an industry delegate, pointed out that mahjong rooms provided customers with free cigarettes.

“We will remove ashtrays but still give out free cigarettes,” he said. “We can only try to discourage them [patrons] from smoking here.

“I will definitely try to persuade them [not to smoke] and I will ask staff to do so if they find customers smoking. But if they ignore us, we can’t do anything else.”

Mak Cheong, a nightclub owner and spokesman for the Federation of Hong Kong and Kowloon Ballroom and Nightclub Merchants, said his club would not even give “verbal notices to smoking customers”.

“If we find smoking customers, we won’t execute the ban,” he said. “We will just let the TCO [Tobacco Control Office] do it. We are not game to do the job. It means driving customers away.”

Under the law only offenders, not venue managers or landlords, may be summonsed by tobacco control inspectors. However, there are owners and managers who say they will play by the rules.

Ray Ng, co-owner of Halo and Volar, said he expected to see some losses from the ban, but his nightclubs were on board.
“Unfortunately, both our venues … are underground. Instead of going out to a balcony, I’m afraid our customers will have to walk up a staircase and come back in,” he said. “That’s unfortunate. Hopefully, in the long run, it will be better. Maybe fewer people will smoke.”

A spokesman for Wan Chai bar Mes Amis said there would be full compliance there, too. “We shall be toeing the line – no smoking, guaranteed,” the spokesman said. Ashtrays would be taken off the bar, and no-smoking signs would be hung up.
Gilbert Yeung Kei-lung, co-owner of Dragon-I, said his nightclub also backed the ban. “This is a world trend and I think the reason why the Hong Kong government and a lot of countries are doing this is for the good of people,” he said.

Lee Thomas, operations director for Beijing Club, Billion Club and Club No9, said his establishments would take no nonsense when it came to smoking on the premises.

The smoking ban “hasn’t affected the UK, it hasn’t affected America, it hasn’t affected Australia, it hasn’t affected Ireland”, he said. He said his clubs would all have legal balcony spaces for smoking.

Winners and losers
WINNERS
Anti-smoking advocates They’ve come a long way, but still have miles to go. Still, a victory’s a victory. Light ’em if you got ’em. (We’re just kidding, of course.)

Establishments with outdoor seating or balconies Smokers can puff away in peace, as long as venue operators don’t have an overhang blocking over 50 per cent of their outdoor space.

Tourists Even if handed a summons, there’s no mechanism to force visitors to show up to court, critics say.
Snitches An offender who smokes in a bar and leaves can still be slapped with a summons if a witness chooses to rat them out in court.
Your health Need we say more?

LOSERS
Smokers If caught by the city’s tobacco control inspectors, offenders can face a penalty of up to HK$5,000. That will change in September when the government switches to a fixed ticketing system of HK$1,500 per fine.

Tobacco companies Less puffing means less sales.

Bars and clubs in basement spaces or on the upper floors of commercial buildings Smokers may bolt for clubs with outdoor areas or balconies.

Smokers who drive with children in the car Plenty of people want to see this banned
Dan Kadison

‘I might just stay home and smoke’

Fox Yi Hu – SCMP

Smokers lit up as usual to enjoy the final Saturday night of puffing in bars – before a full ban takes effect on Wednesday – with some feeling frustrated but others thinking it may help them quit the habit.

Non-smokers working in bars said they looked forward to the clean air that was long overdue.

Jacob Bluhme, a smoker and shipping company sales director, said he had already encountered smoking bans in Los Angeles, Chicago and Singapore.

“I hate the smoking ban,” he said, drawing on a cigarette in a Lan Kwai Fong pub. “Hong Kong is like my last safe haven.”
He said he might go out less at night as a result of the ban. “I might just stay home and have a cigarette on my balcony,” he said.

At the stroke of midnight on Tuesday, June 30, smoking will no longer be permitted in bars, nightclubs, clubs, massage venues, mahjong parlours and bathhouses.

But Christen Ho, 29, said she was comfortable with the ban, which she said would help her quit smoking. “I intend to quit anyway, so this can help a little bit,” Ms Ho said in a pub.

The full ban may worry some pub managers, but Warren McInnes, manager of The Keg on D’Aguilar Street in Central and a non-smoker, said he felt great about the whole thing.

“I will be extremely happy with the smoking ban when it comes into effect,” he said, adding that he believed the full ban would not have a big impact on his business.

The Keg would still sell cigarettes under the full smoking ban, as it was easy for smokers to walk a few steps and light up outdoors, he said.

“In a small bar like this, people can step outside and smoke.”

Bartender Sheela Guoung said she had long been hoping for clean air in her workplace.
“I’ve had coughing problem for six months. I need fresh air,” she said.

The punishment for lighting up in a smoke-free establishment will be a fine of up to HK$5,000.

_____________________________________________________________________

CTA, James Middleton

Dear Tobacco Control

last week I had a discussion with a friend who used to manage a bar in Shatin / Tai Wai. He is still  a shareholder of the Railway Tavern in Shatin.

He told me his directors had said they thought TCO would take a lenient view on continued smoking and that they expected it to take 6 months before anything happened if they continued smoking and that in any case, they had no legal onus to stop people smoking in the pub.

The article below is clear what needs to be done and that is to follow overseas legislation on making the licensee responsible to prevent smoking in his premises or face the loss of the liquor / sauna / mahjong / night club licence. Licensees are already bound not to serve drunken people by law and the same should happen with smoking. In the meantime TCO should write to all licensees to inform them that their liquor / other licence renewals might be affected by allowing smoking to take place on their premises.

The comments of the mahjong parlours to continue to provide cigarettes is another reason why premises managers should be made responsible under the law with the threat of loss of licence for non compliance.  It works everywhere else in the world so why not here ?

It seems obvious that smokers will step outside the bars and pubs and the Government must look at similar legislation overseas that bans smoking within 10 meters of a building entrance and on restaurant and bar patios.

We concur with your statement on smoking in cars with children present and look forward to the Government following overseas jurisdictions on plain packaging of cigarettes, point of sale displays and the regulation and control of tobacco ingredients as enacted by the US FDA and signed into law.

Kind regards,

James Middleton

www.cleartheair.org.hk

Activists advocate tougher laws to close loopholes on lighting up

Dan Kadison – SCMP

Even with the smoking ban going into full effect this week, anti-smoking advocates say there is still a lot more work to be done in the city.

First, the smoking ban was not completely effective, said James Middleton, chairman of the anti-tobacco committee Clear the Air. “I think overall most Hong Kong people are law-abiding and will comply.”

Still, the government needs more tobacco control inspectors, a law to ban smoking at venue entrances and outside seating areas and fines for landlords.

“At the moment, there’s no onus on the landlord,” he said. “They don’t put the legal onus on the landlord.”

The burden was on the person smoking – and it would be the locals who would face the brunt of the penalties, as tourists can fly out before paying their fines, he said.

“[Preventing] smoking in cars is probably the next thing that must happen, especially with children present,” Mr Middleton said. “They’ve done tests in the UK which show that the contents of the car, even with the window open, are up to 100 times more toxic than in a bar.”

Smoking in condominiums had also been targeted in other cities, he said.

Where should people smoke then? “Dig a hole in the ground and then they’re ready to go when they’re dead,” he replied.

Anthony Hedley, chairman of the department of community medicine at the University of Hong Kong, said the government should institute an annual “progressive tax hike” on cigarettes and close a loophole which allows tobacco companies to advertise on products such as watches.

“There are many other issues. There’s a long shopping list. Just to name one is the point-of-ale advertisements. We’ve still got faulty legislation at that level,” he said. “I was in Thailand recently and their point-of -sale registration is very effective. You can’t display cigarettes front-of-house in a 7-Eleven or any other shop. They have to be covered up.”

One government official said he had a “wish list” of his own. Ronald Lam Man-kin is the head of the Tobacco Control Office.
“We are trying, of course, to strive for a smoke-free environment,” he said. “So the next step forward may include, for the protection of children, forbidding smoking in cars or putting in place some smoke-free movie [content] restrictions. But that’s just a wish list.”

Judith Mackay, director of the Asian Consultancy on Tobacco Control, said Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand and Mongolia were doing well with their anti-smoking measures, but more steps had to be taken. “I tend to rejoice in the fact that we have got this far because I remember what it used to be like.”

Shops should sell cigarettes in plain brown packs and Hong Kong should understand its obligations under the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, she added.

Danvers state rep takes smoking to the airwaves

By Cathryn Keefe O’Hare/cohare@cnc.com

Danvers – Danvers State  Rep. Ted Speliotis is getting a bit of radio and TV time, as a result of sponsoring a bill that would prohibit people from congregating while smoking within 25 feet of commercial doorways.

Speliotis describes it as having a less draconian effect than some have supposed, which is that it would effectively prohibit smoking in downtowns. The bill, H-2162, would allow smokers to walk along the street, but not to congregate in doorways, he said this week.

He was on Dan Rea’s nighttime talk show on WBZ radio recently and on Emily Rooney’s Greater Boston show on Channel 2 last week, explaining the law.

The issue has been smoldering in Danvers since the Cigars R Us store opened in the Square about five years ago. The bench outside invites the smokers to sit and relax while they smoke. But, some nearby businesses and a number of residents haven’t always been happy about the wall of smoke — nor sometimes the comments from the men.

Town Meeting member John Zavaglia asked Danvers Board of Health in 2006 to prohibit smoking within 25 feet of a public doorway, noting the health hazard it presents to children and to people like his wife, who has asthma. The health board said they had no policing ability, so Zavaglia turned to Town Meeting. When this proposal was snuffed out at the local level back in 2007, he turned to Speliotis for help.

John Palmisano, owner of Goodie’s Ice Cream Shop, and Nick Pasciutto, owner ofGiogi Salon, had said in a March 2007 Danvers Herald interview that they had asked the owner of the Cigars R Us to curtail the smoking, since it bothers their customers.

“It’s a matter of respect,” Palmisano said at the time. “We’ve talked to Frank (Ciampa, the cigar shop owner) before, but nothing changes,” Palmisano said.

Ciampa asked the town for an exception to the indoor smoking law because of its desire to provide a relaxing atmosphere for its customers to enjoy a smoke. No surprise: Not allowed.

So, now the state might chime in on the issue, although a similar bill didn’t ignite any passions in the Legislature last year.

“This is the first year it has really gotten a full-blown hearing,” said Speliotis, who also noted that the responses he has had from the public have “shocked” him because they are almost all in favor of the proposal.

“I am hoping we can get the American Cancer Society and other groups together to support it,” he said.

John Zavaglia praised Speliotis for his support.

“Smoke all you want, but smoke 25 feet from entrances at supermarkets, eating establishments, and other public places so people, but especially children, the elderly, asthmatics and other high-risk individuals don’t have to walk through a wall of smoke,” Zavaglia said.

Malibu to ban public smoking

Olivia Damavandi, Malibu Times

The Malibu City Council on Monday voted to adopt an ordinance that would prohibit smoking in public open spaces beginning July 31.

The ordinance, as proposed, would ban smoking within 20 feet of a public event, such as a farmers’ market. It would also ban smoking within 20 feet of outdoor dining areas on public or private property, such as hotels and supermarkets.

Businesses with outdoor dining areas would be also required to conspicuously post and maintain “no smoking” signs within the area.

The cost to implement such an ordinance has not yet been determined, but will be based on the amount of public outreach and level of enforcement, a city report states.

All council members except John Sibert, who did not attend the Monday meeting, supported the ordinance. However, Councilmember Sharon Barovsky said she would not support the ordinance unless it required the implementation of smoking waste receptacles, or freestanding ashtrays, at least 24 feet from business entrances. Where that is not possible, the waste receptacles must be located at the furthest points from the entrances, she said.

Barovsky argued that while banning smoking in dining areas and at public events would improve air quality, it would actually increase pollution. People would smoke outside the prohibited area and drop their cigarette butts on the ground when they are finished, she said.

Furthermore, she said, the purpose of the city’s ban on smoking at the beach would be defeated, as littered cigarettes would ultimately end up there.

Councilmember Jefferson Wagner agreed with Barovsky, and said, “Most of the [cigarette] butts will end up in the storm drain. I feel that we do need to provide some kind of receptacle.”

“To write an ordinance that doesn’t provide for the unintended consequences of that ordinance isn’t a good idea,” Barovsky said.

But City Attorney Christi Hogin disputed that business owners would not be responsible for individuals who littered their cigarettes outside the prohibited smoking area because they would be doing so on public property enforced by Sheriff’s deputies.

“Don’t tell me there’s going to be a cop there every time someone puts a cigarette out on the street,” Barovsky said to Hogin.

The council had listed the smoking ordinance as one of its top priorities in May, after the American Lung Association’s annual report card gave Malibu an “F” grade along with 60 percent of cities within Los Angeles County.

Longtime Malibu resident William McCarthy, a professor of public health at UCLA, told the council in February that a measurable decrease in lung cancer rates, particularly in California, has been noted in places such as Calabasas that have adopted ordinances banning smoking. The majority of the population will benefit from adopting the ordinance, he added.

Residents have also voiced their support for the ordinance not only for its health benefits, but for environmental ones as well.

“The Pepperdine fire happened from someone allegedly throwing a cigarette butt out of their car,” Marshall Thompson said before the council in February. “It’s obnoxious, and it’s a public health issue.”

The council directed staff to make a second reading and adopt the ordinance on July 13.