Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Better to be blunt to combat tobacco

South China Morning Post – 12 July 2011

The campaign against smoking has come full circle in Hong Kong with a return to emphasis on the health risks highlighted in the mid-1990s. In the meantime, anti-tobacco advocates have won a long battle against passive smoking by having the habit banned in indoor public areas including restaurants and bars, and pressured the government into raising the tax on cigarettes to 70 per cent of the price of a packet, just short of the 75 per cent recommended by the World Health Organisation. And only an estimated one in eight or 12 per cent of Hongkongers still smoke.

But after years of subtle messages supportive of people wanting to quit, it has been judged time to refocus people’s minds on the harmful effects of smoking with explicit messages. The Tobacco Control Office will roll out fresh television advertisements next year, after being briefed on latest research by the World Lung Foundation. As one of its executives wrote in the Post last week, the foundation has tested campaign material in 12 countries and found that clear, blunt messages about how tobacco harms people are effective everywhere.

At the end of the day, as anti-smoking laws and tax increases show, sometimes only governments have the power and deep enough pockets to take on Big Tobacco. In that respect Hong Kong has an interest in a challenge by tobacco giant Philip Morris to the Australian government’s attempt to be the first to enforce plain, brandless packaging of cigarettes featuring only graphic health warnings. Philip Morris accuses Canberra of breaching a bilateral investment treaty with Hong Kong, where the company’s Asian arm is based, which it claims commits Canberra to protect investment in Australia by local investors and vice versa. The move faces numerous potential domestic and international legal challenges to defend intellectual property. Politically, however, there is an argument that so long as the majority has to fund the health costs of the smoking minority, governments and lawmakers have a duty to support measures to curb tobacco use

Cigarette smoke and mirrors

http://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010/indepth/2011-07/01/c_13961245.htm

BRUSSELS, July 1 (Xinhua) — No butts about it. Belgian bars become less hazy on Friday as the country becomes the 20th in Europe to widen its smoking ban.

Belgium’s new laws take effect close on the heels of China which also banned smoking in indoor public venues in May this year. So, what challenges do both countries face as they seek to control a notoriously addictive product sold by an equally powerful industry?

From July 1, people in bars and cafes in Belgium with the urge to light up will only be allowed to do so in designated smoking areas. By law, these zones need to be fitted with air vents and be no larger than 25 percent of the venue. Another rider is no sale of drinks and snacks will be permitted there.

Those caught violating the law can be fined between 143 and 1,650 euros. The onus of enforcing the ban is expected to lie on bar-owners and their employees.

For many campaigners, Belgium has been frustratingly slow in changing its smoking laws. The path to today’s smoking ban in pubs was paved by the ban of smoking in trains in 2004, in workplaces in 2006 and in restaurants in 2007.

“The anti-tobacco voice in Europe is growing louder,” tobacco control expert Luk Joossens from the Belgian chapter of the Foundation Against Cancer told Xinhua.

“Though we are extremely disappointed by the delay in getting to this stage, I’m optimistic now that the ban is in effect and I think it will work,” he said, stressing its main objective is not to reduce the consumption of cigarettes but to protect bar employees and the general public from passive smoking.

Because people will no longer be subject to passive smoking, Joossens hopes for a major drop in heart disease in Belgium. “After the smoking ban in Scotland, heart attacks in the country fell by 17 percent. If a similar thing happens in Belgium, there will be 2,500 fewer heart-attacks per year,” he said.

While tobacco control campaigners win the public health debate, tobacco lobbies often counter by mentioning government tax revenues. For example, Chinese newspapers in 2009 reported that more than 7.5 percent of Chinese government revenue, or 77.3 billion U.S. dollars, came from taxes and profits related to tobacco.

However, leading Belgian law academic and anti-tobacco campaigner Professor Roger Blanpain rubbishes the notion that revenues will be hit.

“The economic argument for tobacco is nonsensical. Governments spend three times their tax income from tobacco companies in treating the medical fallouts of tobacco-related illnesses. Not to mention, days off work due to tobacco-related illnesses or children getting sick because of their parents smoking,” Blanpain told Xinhua.

BMA conference backs doctors call for ban on smoking in cars

http://www.onmedica.com/NewsArticle.aspx?id=916aac35-0d55-4ba5-9eec-baf31f5c3a3c

Thursday, 30 June 2011

Doctors at the BMA’s annual conference are urging UK governments to introduce legislation to ban smoking while driving a motor vehicle.

They also passed a motion demanding that tobacco companies be forced to publish all payments to politicians and political organisations.

And during a debate on alcohol policy they once again called on the UK governments to introduce a realistic minimum price for alcohol.

Speaking in favour of the motion on smoking in vehicles, Northern Ireland Junior Doctors Committee Chairman Dr David Farren said: “I really like this motion, as it would improve transparency and perhaps highlight the political agenda of tobacco companies”. And Dr Charles Saunders, joint deputy chairman of the BMA’s Scottish Council speaking after the debate said:

“Tobacco smoke is a potent cocktail of over 4,000 toxins, including 50 known to cause cancer. Smoking in the confined space of a car is therefore a toxic threat to health and people sharing a car with a smoker will be exposed to in-car particle concentrations 27 times higher than in a smokers home and 20 times higher than the levels found in a smoky pub before the ban on smoking in public places was introduced. Rolling down the window does not eliminate this risk.

“Children exposed to smoking in cars will be at risk of the harmful effects of second hand smoke including persistent wheeze and respiratory disorders.

He said that the British Lung Foundation estimate that more than half of 8 to 15 year olds have been exposed to smoking in cars and 86% of children want people to stop smoking when they are in the car.

“There is an increasing awareness amongst the general population of the risks of exposure to second hand smoke and banning smoking in cars is another way in which we can protect non-smokers from the risk of harm from second hand smoke.

On the motion calling for a realistic minimum price for alcohol Dr Sue Robertson, a renal physician and member of the BMA’s Scottish Council, said: “I am delighted that doctors across the UK supported the motion as it sends a clear message to politicians at Westminster and in the devolved nations. A new bill for minimum pricing in Scotland is expected in the autumn and I hope this, as part of a wider alcohol strategy, will lead the rest of the UK in taking the much needed steps to tackle our country’s culture of excessive drinking.”

China’s anti-smoking activists try a new argument: that it’s bad for the economy

By William Wan, Monday, June 27, 9:42 AM

YUXI, China — When China issued its first national ban on public smoking last month, health advocates cheered but didn’t hold their breath. Like many anti-smoking regulations in China, this one seemed hollow, and for good reason.

A month later, the ban has had little, if any, effect. Smoking remains rampant in spaces where it has been prohibited, such as restaurants, schools and hospitals.

The main reason so few take China’s campaign against cigarettes seriously: The very government promising to crack down on tobacco use is the owner and chief beneficiary of the $93 billion industry.

For decades, that simple fact has blessed the state-run monopoly with custom-designed loopholes and stalled anti-smoking legislation.

As a result, China is tobacco’s biggest stronghold, the world’s largest producer and consumer. According to World Health Organization estimates, more than half of the men in China smoke, compared with roughly 20 percent in the United States. And cigarettes contribute to four of the top five causes of death in China, with 1.2 million tobacco-related fatalities a year.

In many ways, China’s struggle over smoking embodies a key dilemma facing its government: balancing the state’s obsession with economic growth with the appearance of looking out for the public interest.

So far, the public interest has been on the losing end. While tobacco users are dying in increasing numbers, tobacco farmers say they are sometimes forced to grow the low-earning crop by local officials eager to protect their key source of tax revenue.

Now, after years of working in vain, anti-smoking activists say they must move their fight away from simplistic arguments over health and morality and into the arena that matters most in modern China: economics.

A company town

Perhaps nowhere does the economic argument against smoking face a greater challenge than in the small city of Yuxi in Yunnan province, home of the Hongta Group, one of China’s biggest cigarette companies.

Residents work at the sprawling Hongta cigarette factory. Visitors stay at the Hongta Hotel. The rich play at Hongta golf courses. The poor toil in tobacco fields in surrounding villages.

For decades, Yuxi and the regional government of Yunnan have depended on the economic engine of tobacco. Yunnan, a relatively undeveloped region with many poor counties, receives almost half its tax revenue from tobacco.

As a result, the very idea of an anti-smoking movement remains foreign — an effort funded almost completely by international grants and often considered unwelcome.

“They call us crazy sometimes,” said Li Xiaoliang, who heads one of the few anti-smoking nonprofit groups in Yunnan. “People tell us, ‘The rice you eat, the clothes you wear come from the tobacco fields. Opposing tobacco is like opposing our right to a life.’ ”

Tobacco executives and local government officials declined requests for interviews, but workers for Hongta confirmed privately that their company and others in Yunnan have worked with local officials for decades to counter anti-smoking efforts.

When Li and other health advocates got cigarette billboards banned from some cities in Yunnan, tobacco companies responded by sponsoring events that allowed them to plaster their logos around town to promote auto races, charities and even marathons.

When activists appealed to local media, the companies poured money into newspapers for pro-tobacco fluff pieces and sidestepped TV advertising laws by sponsoring soap operas.

But the most frustrating setbacks for health advocates, Li said, have been in their work with schools. It took her years, she said, to persuade a small number of schools to declare themselves tobacco-free. At the same time, however, the companies expanded their presence in other schools through teacher awards and student scholarships.

In the poorest regions, schools built by tobacco companies include the cigarette brand in their names and adorn their halls with corporate slogans.

“Despite all our work, I don’t know if the tobacco companies even take us seriously,” Li said. “We are just a small gnat in comparison.”

Powerful partners

The power of the tobacco lobby is only magnified at the national level, where the government and the industry are deeply entwined.

Working together, they have jealously protected their monopoly and have largely fended off powerful foreign companies salivating over the Chinese market.

The same top administrators work overlapping positions at the National Tobacco Corp. — which produces China’s cigarettes — and the State Tobacco Monopoly Administration, which is supposed to regulate the industry.

And the Tobacco Control Office, created to reduce smoking nationwide, reports not to the Ministry of Health but to the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, which runs the tobacco industry.

As head of the Tobacco Control Office, Yang Gonghuan works in a dimly lighted Beijing building with a staff of two dozen.

An epidemiologist who studied at Harvard, Yang in the 1990s helped organize the government’s first attempt to gather mortality statistics. When she realized most of China’s top causes of death could be tied to smoking, she began pushing officials to tackle the problem.

Her influence these days stems from a World Health Organization treaty China signed a few years ago that specifies actions and deadlines aimed at reducing smoking.

Chinese leaders, however, have largely been able to skirt those requirements. In 2008, when tobacco companies were ordered to add warning labels covering 30 percent of cigarette packs, they created a mostly blank box with a vague warning in minuscule print. They filled leftover space with English text, incomprehensible to most in the country.

In 2009, when the treaty required an increase in the cigarette tax, the government and the industry worked together to switch many brands to lower tax categories, thereby negating the effect.

“In some cases, the cigarettes actually got cheaper instead,” Yang said.

For the past decade, Yang’s opponents within the government have trumped her efforts with a single, powerful argument: Tobacco is indispensable to China’s economy, and the economy is key to social stability — the one thing China’s leadership worries about most.

While the government has dismantled other state-owned enterprises, it has clung to its lucrative tobacco trade. Last year, China’s tobacco industry generated $93 billion in total revenue and contributed $77 billion in taxes, almost 7 percent of China’s total tax revenue. And the number of cigarettes it produces continues to grow, rising 40 percent during the past decade.

In response, health advocates in China are trying to craft economic arguments.

This year, Yang’s office teamed with some of China’s most prominent economists as well as international experts to produce an attention-grabbing study on the social cost of tobacco. Factoring in the cost of health-care and lost productivity from dying smokers, the report argued that the long-term expenses of tobacco outweigh its short-term gains.

“As long as they continue to believe there is profit there, we will never get the government to change,” Yang said.

Meanwhile, health advocates in Yunnan have begun making a similar pitch to local leaders and say they have seen glimmers of hope. This year, Zhao Yaqiao, an economics professor at Yunnan Agricultural University, launched a pilot project to find alternative industries, including vegetable farming and tourism.

“You can’t just tell people not to smoke, just like you can’t tell farmers to stop planting,” he said. “You need to show them a different way.”

One of Zhao’s first moves was to reach out to the tobacco companies, a crucial step, he said, because of their vast political and economic influence. Many in the anti-smoking movement questioned his motives, and tobacco executives avoided him for six months.

A surprising response

When he finally landed a meeting, what they said surprised him.

“In their hearts, they also believe that someday tobacco will die and that there is a need for transition,” he said. “They said they’ve seen what happened in the U.S., Japan, Singapore.”

One manager at Hongta, declining to speak on the record for fear of losing his job, said that his company and others have recently begun exploring alternatives, investing in hydroelectric projects, real estate and hotels. “But we were stopped by the government and told to keep our focus on tobacco,” he said.

Tobacco executives, however, see the writing on the wall, the Hongta manager said.

“The industry may not collapse within the next 10 or 20 years, but for the next generation here, it’s hard to say what their prospects are,” he said. “It doesn’t look promising.”

Researcher Wang Juan contributed to this report.

© The Washington Post Company

Chandy seeks countrywide ban on tobacco products

PTI | 08:06 PM,Jun 23,2011

Thiruvananthapuram, Jun 23 (PTI) Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy today sought Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s intervention in imposing a countrywide ban on tobacco products saying they posed a grim health threat to the people, especially the youth. In a letter to Singh, he said free availability of tobacco products in every nook and cranny of the country has become a serious threat to health of the people, especially youth and students. The viable option to fight the menace was to impose a total ban on them through legal means, he said. Such a step was essential to control incidence of cancer, heart ailments and other related health hazards, he said. Chandy recalled that the World Health Organisation had called for ban on advertisement on tobacco products.

http://ibnlive.in.com/generalnewsfeed/news/chandy-seeks-countrywide-ban-on-tobacco-products/735957.html

Shire bans smoking in outdoor dining areas

http://news.ninemsn.com.au/health/8264495/shire-bans-smoking-in-outdoor-dining-areas

23 June 2011

A local council in Victoria’s south-east has become the first in the state to put a blanket ban on smoking in outdoor dining areas.

Baw Baw Shire councillors voted in favour of the ban on Wednesday, and it also stretches to playgrounds, sporting fields and some pedestrian areas.

Quit director Fiona Sharkie says the ban reflects shifting community values on smoking.

“Cancer Council Victoria research shows over three-quarters (77 per cent) of Victorians believe smoking shouldn’t be allowed in outdoor areas where children are present while seven out of 10 Victorians believe smoking shouldn’t be allowed in outdoor restaurant dining areas,” Ms Sharkie said.

“The majority of Victorians want smoke-free outdoor areas so it’s only natural they should become more commonplace.”

Heart Foundation Victoria chief executive Kathy Bell believes the ban has the potential to lower smoking take-up rates among children raised in the shire.

“Smoke-free environments de-normalise smoking so children are less likely to see smoking, less likely to start smoking and therefore less likely to suffer from the negative effects of tobacco use.”

Smoking is already banned in playgrounds and beaches of some local government areas in Victoria

Time to ban smoking in cars

22ND JUNE 2011

British Lung Foundation chief executive Dame Helena Shovelton argues that it is time to ban smoking in cars.

http://www.hc2d.co.uk/content.php?contentId=18889

Every year more than 300,000 children in the UK present passive smoking-related illnesses to their family doctor.

This is a preventable statistic and a preventable cost to the NHS, with £10 million worth of primary care visits and asthma treatments, and £12 million in hospital admission costs, caused directly by passive smoking.

In the confines of a car, children are exposed to concentrations of passive smoke, equivalent, according to Aberdeen University research, of levels in a smoke-filled pub.

Smoking indoors in public places is banned so why should children suffer because smoking is not banned in cars?

British Lung Foundation research found 51% of 8-15-year-olds surveyed had been exposed to cigarette smoke in cars but were too scared or embarrassed to ask the adult smoker to stop. Some 86% of children want smoking made illegal in cars.

Steps have been taken elsewhere, notably in Canada, where a national media programme was supported by legislation in some states. Areas where legislation on smoking in cars when children are present was implemented saw a dramatic drop in exposure to smoke compared with states that just focussed on education and awareness campaigns.

In America, concern over the dangers to children of smoking in cars has been raised in California, Arkansas and Louisiana.

In Wales, similar concerns have been raised, while the Health Department of Jersey is already considering passing the ban and Stockton North MP Alex Cunningham has raised the issue in the UK Parliament.

It is now time for Westminster to take the lead in enacting legislative change in this vital aspect of child health.

Princess, Carnival and Holland America to ban smoking in cabins

http://travel.usatoday.com/cruises/post/2011/06/smoking-ban-princess-carnival-holland-america/174594/1

Princess Cruises, Carnival Cruise Lines and Holland America all announced major changes to their smoking policies. Smokers will soon be banned from lighting up in cabins on all the ships of all three lines.

The Princess smoking ban, which also applies to cabin balconies, will become effective on all sailings departing after Jan. 15.

Carnival said its ban on smoking in all cabins would take effect Dec. 1. The line will still allow both cigarette and cigar smoking on cabin balconies.

Holland America said its ban on smoking in cabins, but not on balconies, would take effect on Jan. 15.

Also effective today, Carnival said it was limiting smoking on its ships to dance clubs, designated areas within the casino and casino bar and certain sections on the open decks.

ALSO ONLINE: Carnival to cruise year-round from New York

All three lines said they were notifying those passengers already booked on cruises of their new policies.

Officials said the moves reflect changing customer preferences.

Carnival said it modified its policy as a result of recent guest surveys and onboard testing. Holland America said its new policy is “in keeping with the majority of guest preferences today.”

As for Princess, “Our consumer studies now show that smokers are a small minority of our passengers, and that the large majority of passengers value having their primary living space onboard smoke-free,” said Jan Swartz, the line’s executive vice president.
Princess spokeswoman Karen Candy says balconies were included in that line’s new policy “to enhance the onboard experience for the majority of passengers who don’t smoke.”

A fire that blackened 85 cabins on the Star Princess in the Caribbean in 2006 was blamed on a lit cigarette flung off a cabin balcony. The incident led to warnings about the need to carefully dispose of cigarettes.

Swartz said Princess would continue to welcome passengers who smoke on its ships, with smoking allowed in the Churchill’s cigar lounges, a section of the discos and casinos, and a portion of the open decks.
In a statement, Holland America likewise said guests who wish to smoke could continue to do so in designated areas both inside and on outside decks.

After the new cabin bans take effect, passengers caught breaking the rules on any of the three lines will be charged a $250 cleaning fee, officials said.

Princess, Carnival and Holland America are all owned by Miami-based Carnival Corp.

Other lines that ban smoking in cabins and on balconies include Celebrity, Azamara, Regent Seven Seas and Oceania. Crystal bans smoking on stateroom balconies. Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line ban smoking in cabins, but allow smoking on balconies.

Self-defence for tobacco officers

South China Morning Post – 19 June 2011

Inspectors will be offered training to fend off angry smokers who lash out when they’re issued with fines

An increasing number of tobacco control inspectors are being attacked by smokers caught puffing in banned areas, prompting the Department of Health to introduce self-defence training for the law enforcers.

The smokers, including women, have been jailed for up to three months for the assaults. The department’s Tobacco Control Office said the number of inspectors assaulted rose from five in 2008 and four in 2009 to 10 last year. There were five cases in the first four months of this year.

The head of the office, Dr Raymond Ho Lei-ming, said inspectors had faced increasing violence since the introduction of fixed penalties.

Since September 2009, inspectors have been issuing HK$1,500 fixed- penalty tickets to people caught smoking in banned areas, including restaurants, amusement centres, karaoke parlours and bus terminuses.

Ho said the attacks were probably the result of smokers reacting on the spot to the “immediate pain” of heavy fines. In the past they would have been summoned to court and fined just a few hundred dollars.

“In some cases, the attackers are not the smokers but their friends or families. Our team always assesses the potential risk of an operation. Sometimes they conduct a joint operation with the police.”

Last week lawmakers ratified the 41.5 per cent rise in tobacco tax – a move that will further anger smokers who feel they are being persecuted.

Ho said self-defence classes would start shortly for any staff members interested. Apart from regular inspections, the 99 tobacco control inspectors also visit no-smoking areas after receiving public complaints. The number of complaints of illegal smoking received by the office rose from 15,321 in 2008 to 17,089 in 2010. The number of inspections rose from 13,302 to 23,623.

Bars are the worst places for violent attacks; smokers at amusement centres and mahjong parlours are more co-operative. The inspectors who were attacked usually suffered bruises or abrasions, but none of the injuries were serious enough to require hospital treatment. Fines for those convicted ranged from HK$1,000 to HK$2,500. The more serious offenders were sentenced to between one and three months’ jail.

Smoking was banned in all indoor areas in 2007 and in entertainment premises in 2009. The government will later consider if venue operators should also be prosecuted. At present, only smokers are fined.

ella.lee@scmp.com

PRINCESS CRUISES have banned smoking in staterooms and, weirdly, on balconies from next January.

Jan Swartz, from Princess, said: “The new policy reflects changing customer preferences and the move around the globe – from North America to Europe – to further restrict areas where smoking is allowed, according to the line.”

She added that balconies are included in the new policy because they are a hallmark feature of Princess ships and the line believes it’s important to keep that peaceful space clear of smoke.

While smoking is still allowed in some areas on deck and in the casino, it is clear that the writing is on the wall for us smokers… even though we pay the same price as the non-smokers!

Read more: http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/travel/3646100/Smoking-banned-bron-Princess-Cruises.html#ixzz1PdwzsAsY