Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Letters to Editor

South China Morning Post, Hong Kong May 22, 2012

Simple way to curb law breakers

I refer to the letter by Leigh-Anne Wong (“Bar staff have ashtrays for smokers”, May 17).

The solution to the ongoing lack of compliance of smoking in bars is surprisingly simple. Place the legal onus on the owner/manager, not on the individual smoker.

As the legislation stands, bar owners have no interest in making sure their premises are smoke-free, and some even plant look-outs to alert the establishment if tobacco control officers are seen nearby, so they could warn their customers to put out their cigarettes. But if owners feared losing their licence, the law would become enforced overnight.

Current enforcement of smoke-free restaurants and bars is particularly difficult. Legco could change this at the stroke of a pen.

Dr Judith Mackay, senior adviser, World Lung Foundation

Prof .   J u d i t h   L o n g s t a f f   M a c k a y , O B E , S B S , J P

MBChB, FRCP (Edin), FRCP (Lon)

Senior Advisor

t:  +852.2719.1995 f:  +852.2719.5741

Riftswood, 9th Milestone

DD 229, Lot 147, Clearwater Bay Road

Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR

worldlungfoundation.org

Bar staff have ashtrays for smokers

SCMP May 17, 2012

Bar staff have ashtrays for smokers

I could not agree more with Gibson Wong Lok-tak (“Many bars now ignore smoking ban”, May 9).

The stagnant air sickens people, particularly in upstairs bars, and nobody seems to care about this situation.

Even non-smokers going to these bars are afraid to raise the issue with the landlord or waitresses, as they see ashtrays placed almost everywhere. I even once saw a customer asking a member of staff to provide him with an ashtray; she willingly complied.

The attitude in those bars appears to be that people go there to light up even though it is against the law and that non-smokers who are unwilling to be harmed by second-hand smoke should meet somewhere else.

We all have rights. When people light up in these bars, they violate the right of non-smokers to breathe fresh air.

Customers who realise what is happening is wrong may wish to try to rectify the situation. However, they are often scared of getting a violent response or they know that their request for people to adhere to the law will be ignored.

It seems that only bars in places like shopping malls or well-known tourist spots such as LanKwai Fong will abide by the law. This is probably because of tighter security measures in these areas.

Maybe it is now time for the government or the Tobacco Control Office to step up patrols and launch a crackdown, particularly at night.

Leigh-Anne Wong, Sha Tin

World No Tobacco Day Action Toolkit May 2012

“It is horrific to think that an industry known for its dirty tricks and dirty laundry could be allowed to trump what is clearly in
the public’s best interests. Big Tobacco can afford to hire the best lawyers and PR firms that money can buy. Big money can
speak louder than any moral, ethical or public health argument and can trample even the most damning scientific evidence. I
urge all these countries to stand firm together, do not bow to pressure… we must never allow the tobacco industry to get the
upper hand.”
-Dr. Margaret Chan, Director General of the World Health Organization

Download PDF : WNTD 2012 Action Toolkit FINALhk

Butt out! Tassie smokes ban

http://www.themercury.com.au/article/2012/05/12/327411_print.html

Description: http://www.themercury.com.au/images/uploadedfiles/editorial/pictures/2012/05/12/SMOKEMAN1_CROP-1_DD190582_245430.JPG

ZERO TOLERANCE: Professor Jon Berrick is urging a ban on smoking for people born after the year 2000. Picture: RICHARD JUPE

TASMANIA is being promoted as the ideal testing ground to introduce a ban on cigarette sales to everyone born after the year 2000.

The radical health proposal would see younger generations, and all future generations, forbidden to use tobacco products forever.

The plan, promoted by a university professor from Singapore, has won praise from Tasmania’s anti-smoking lobby groups.

Quit Tasmania, the Cancer Council and the Asthma Foundation said the proposal had merits and should be further investigated.

Professor Jon Berrick, from the National University of Singapore, is visiting Tasmania to promote his vision, which he hopes will end nicotine addiction.

Prof Berrick said Tasmania would be an ideal place to trial the proposal because the state had a good record of bipartisan political support on tobacco controls.

He has taken his plan to anti-smoking groups as well as scientists and researchers at the Menzies Research Institute.

Prof Berrick said the idea was a “decisive measure”, unlike other anti-smoking moves that only “chipped away” at the problem.

“Once you do this, the end is in sight,” he said.

Prof Berrick said the ban would rely on proof of age, either through drivers licences that showed people’s birthdates or some other proof of ID card.

Cancer Council Tasmania CEO Simon Barnsley said the initiative would be “very worthwhile” to investigate.

“It’s quite a different way to do it because you build an expectation of change, you don’t set out to achieve it through prohibition,” he said.

He supported the idea of a Tasmania-only trial as it would be hard to achieve nationally.

Prof Berrick, whose background is in science and mathematics, has formulated the idea with a group of experts in Singapore.

He said a 2007 survey of awareness of lung cancer in Singapore included questions about the idea.

“The first thing we asked people was how important they feel it is to prevent children ever taking up smoking and we got over 98 per cent who said it was very important or important,” Prof Berrick said.

“The next question we asked was what about this particular proposal for those born from 2000 forever. From the population as a whole we got over 70 per cent support and for smokers we got 60 per cent support.”

Prof Berrick said many smokers regretted they had started smoking and certainly did not want to inflict it on their children.

Quit Tasmania executive director Michael Wilson said on face value Prof Berrick’s proposal seemed a great idea and fairly easy to administer, but he said there were issues with ID.

“You hear lots of stories in the community about fake ID to me that seems to be the only thing that would be a hindrance,” he said.

Using Tasmania as a pilot had merit, Mr Wilson said, as it had been used for other health pilot studies. But he said it was easy to buy cigarettes interstate.

Asthma Foundation of Tasmania CEO Cathy Beswick said the proposal was worth investigating.

She said tobacco smoke was harmful to people with asthma and respiratory conditions and the foundation was interested in any measure that would reduce or limit the number of people who smoked.

Tasmania’s Director of Public Health, Roscoe Taylor, said a report published in 2008 found that in 2005 tobacco use accounted for $1.836 billion in costs for tobacco-related healthcare and $31.5 billion in indirect social costs in Australia.

He said the most recent figures showed that between 2003 and 2007 an average of 471 Tasmanians died each year due to tobacco use.

Call to cut smoking in local films

http://www.news.com.au/breaking-news/call-to-cut-smoking-in-local-films/story-e6frfku0-1226351110049

May 9, 2012

AUSTRALIAN films receiving government assistance should cut down on depictions of actors smoking, parliament has been told.

Labor senator John Faulkner said the commonwealth provided generous tax incentives for film, television and other screen production in Australia, giving about $145 million in tax offsets to producers in 2010/11.

“I believe it’s now time for the government to consider the introduction of conditions to be applied about the smoking content of any production before government funding is provided,” he told the Senate today.

“It is also time to seriously investigate the application of such constraints to overseas productions filmed in Australia.”

But Liberal senator Simon Birmingham used Twitter to remark the imposition of such limits would be an interference in personal choice.

“John Faulkner currently telling @AuSenate we should regulate art by restricting portrayal of smoking in films – more #NannyState anyone?” he tweeted.

Senator Faulkner said the government’s new plain-packaging law was another example of Labor targeting tobacco advertising promotion and sponsorship.

All cigarettes and tobacco products will have to be sold in drab olive-brown packs from December.

“We are setting a global precedent that has big tobacco shaking in its boots,” Senator Faulkner said.

The federal budget handed down yesterday has cut the amount of cigarettes and tobacco that could be purchased duty-free.

Under existing rules, inbound travellers aged over 18 are allowed to bring in 250 cigarettes or 250 grams of tobacco products tax-free.

This will be cut to 50 cigarettes.

Read more: http://www.news.com.au/breaking-news/call-to-cut-smoking-in-local-films/story-e6frfku0-1226351110049#ixzz1uLt3SImb

Ifugao town imposes no smoking in public places and utility vehicles

http://www.pia.gov.ph/news/index.php?article=161336430638

By Marcelo L. Lihgawon

Tuesday 8th of May 2012

HUNGDUAN, Ifugao, May 8 (PIA) – – Smokers have to be more restrained and self-disciplined with the municipal government imposing no smoking policy in government offices, public schools premises, and public utility vehicles.

The passage of the municipal ordinance banning smoking in public places is in support of the anti-smoking campaign and the unrelenting effort of the local government unit to protect non-smokers from the harmful effects of tobacco products.

This is also in line with Republic Act 8749 or the “Philippine Clean Air Act of 1999 that prohibits smoking inside enclosed or confined public places and all public transportation.”

Introduced by councilor Lucas A Bugatti, it is unlawful for any person to smoke cigarettes inside public buildings and places, school premises, restaurants, public utility passenger vehicles and other similar places in the municipality. However, a smoking area can be designated which shall not be located in or near areas where people usually gather .

Any person found guilty of violating the ordinance would be penalized P150 or four hours community service for first offense; P300 or eight hours community service for second offense; and P500 or 16-hour community service for third offense and subsequent offenses or imprisonment upon the discretion of the court.

For owners and operators of businesses, their license to operate will be suspended in case of third and consequent offenses and failure of the establishment to pay the fine indicated in a citation ticket within five regular business days from its issuance.

Mayor Hilario T. Bumangabang enjoined the local police, barangay officials, municipal heads and schools administrators, including drivers of public utility vehicles to fully implement this anti-smoking campaign. *(JDP/MBL-PIA CAR,Ifugao)

COUNCILS, sporting clubs, public-event organisers and businesses will start imposing bans on smoking in outdoor areas within three weeks.

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/power-to-ban-smoking-in-public-areas-by-may-31/story-e6frea6u-1226348103846

Health Minister John Hill said the power to ban smoking in any public area would take effect on May 31 and he predicted some strongly anti-smoking councils and private organisations would act immediately.

“I think trail-blazing organisations will act almost immediately and others will follow,” he said. “It will be parks, streets, music festivals, sporting events, outside private hospitals, beaches, pageants, anywhere they like and I think councils like Unley, who are very keen, will act quickly.”

Mr Hill said the new powers would be similar to the anti-drinking “dry zone” powers; areas able to be proclaimed as non-smoking by councils and private organisations after public consultation.

Smoking in children’s playgrounds and public transport shelters is automatically banned and will be subject to a $200 fine.

Mr Hill was speaking after the Australian Medical Association called for bans on smoking in any outdoor area where people gathered in numbers, including sporting events, busy pedestrian street crossings and streets which had outdoor dining such as Hutt and Rundle streets in the central business districts.

“Smoking should be banned in outdoor areas where there are public gatherings, altogether,” AMA SA president Dr Peter Sharley said.

“There is evidence that second-hand smoking is linked to cancer, heart disease and respiratory problems.”

Dr Sharley said smoking cost Australia $31 billion each year and killed 15,000 people.

He said it would be difficult to police such bans but believed many people would do the right thing if public warnings were posted.

The AMA called for funding to implement the bans in its submission to the State Budget.

Mr Hill said the Government would not force groups to enact the new laws, except in areas such as playgrounds.

“It will not be compulsory but I think citizens will start insisting especially that councils stop people smoking in some areas, and I think that is a good way of spreading it throughout the community,” Mr Hill said.

Ban on sale of tobacco in Sharjah welcomed

http://www.khaleejtimes.com/kt-article-display-1.asp?xfile=data/nationhealth/2012/May/nationhealth_May12.xml&section=nationhealth

Lily B Libo-on / 5 May 2012
The draft legislation of the Sharjah government to ban tobacco sale at supermarkets and groceries around residential areas has been received favourably by various sectors of society.
Ramez Sawiris, Regulatory Affairs Director of GSK Consumer Healthcare, told Khaleej Times that the legislation is a positive step in raising awareness on the ills of smoking and minimising its affects on the community. “It is yet to be known how this move will impact consumption, but the decrease on the widespread availability of cigarettes will surely help smokers think more closely about the warning labels on each cigarette pack.”
Similarly, Saul Shiffman, Consultant for GSK Consumer Healthcare (NiQuitin), said that despite constant reminders by the health authorities and warning labels on cigarette packs, smoking remains one of the leading preventable causes of several fatal diseases.
“It has the distinction of being one of the few substances affecting all the systems in the human body, from head to toe. Besides being a leading cause of the obvious cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, smoking is known to be a major contributor to many forms of cancer. Additionally, smoking has many adverse effects that are known causes for infertility, preterm delivery and low birth weight,” he said.
A very specific recommendation from Dr Ghada Fahmy, medical director and in-charge of Smoking Cessation Clinic of Al Etihad Health Centre, Ministry of Health, is that shops which continue to sell tobacco to young children and teenagers be closed down.
She said that there is a proliferation of ‘meduakh’, an Arabic term for some sort of smoking pipe where powdered tobacco or tobacco leaves are put in small holes of these pipe and smoked by children as young as 10. “Many Emirati mums have brought their kids in the age-group of 10 and 11 years for medical counseling. The government has to close down the shops selling such stuff as it is very harmful to them. It is indeed a great step by the Sharjah government to ban the sale of tobacco over the counter,” she added.
Sudheer DH, manager of Abraj Al Nahda, a supermarket in Sharjah, said that the tobacco ban, when it will be finally implemented, will affect supermarkets because sales from tobacco alone accounts for about Dh600 daily. “It will definitely affect us as an estimated 15 to 20 per cent of our daily customers are tobacco buyers.”
Filipino Ronald Villanueva, a non-smoking resident of Sharjah for the past eight years, said that even with the ban, it will be difficult to implement the rule as 70 to 80 per cent of males smoke in this emirate. “Many might protest against it and trade in the blackmarket may rise.”
Lebanese Elizabeth Mekhjian, whose husband died of lung cancer, told Khaleej Times that this is good news for her as she supports anti-smoking. “My husband died of lung cancer at 71 even though he quit smoking 20 years before he died. But, the effect of tobacco had long settled in his system.”
Emirati smokers Ahmed Al Shamsi, 18, and his cousin Jassim Al Shamsi, said they would stop smoking when the ban is implemented. But, they believed that the ban will lead to ‘blackmarket selling’ of tobacco and may not really contribute much in stopping teenagers from smoking.
lily@khaleejtimes.com

Lily B Libo-on / 5 May 2012

The draft legislation of the Sharjah government to ban tobacco sale at supermarkets and groceries around residential areas has been received favourably by various sectors of society.

Ramez Sawiris, Regulatory Affairs Director of GSK Consumer Healthcare, told Khaleej Times that the legislation is a positive step in raising awareness on the ills of smoking and minimising its affects on the community. “It is yet to be known how this move will impact consumption, but the decrease on the widespread availability of cigarettes will surely help smokers think more closely about the warning labels on each cigarette pack.”

Similarly, Saul Shiffman, Consultant for GSK Consumer Healthcare (NiQuitin), said that despite constant reminders by the health authorities and warning labels on cigarette packs, smoking remains one of the leading preventable causes of several fatal diseases.

“It has the distinction of being one of the few substances affecting all the systems in the human body, from head to toe. Besides being a leading cause of the obvious cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, smoking is known to be a major contributor to many forms of cancer. Additionally, smoking has many adverse effects that are known causes for infertility, preterm delivery and low birth weight,” he said.

A very specific recommendation from Dr Ghada Fahmy, medical director and in-charge of Smoking Cessation Clinic of Al Etihad Health Centre, Ministry of Health, is that shops which continue to sell tobacco to young children and teenagers be closed down.

She said that there is a proliferation of ‘meduakh’, an Arabic term for some sort of smoking pipe where powdered tobacco or tobacco leaves are put in small holes of these pipe and smoked by children as young as 10. “Many Emirati mums have brought their kids in the age-group of 10 and 11 years for medical counseling. The government has to close down the shops selling such stuff as it is very harmful to them. It is indeed a great step by the Sharjah government to ban the sale of tobacco over the counter,” she added.

Sudheer DH, manager of Abraj Al Nahda, a supermarket in Sharjah, said that the tobacco ban, when it will be finally implemented, will affect supermarkets because sales from tobacco alone accounts for about Dh600 daily. “It will definitely affect us as an estimated 15 to 20 per cent of our daily customers are tobacco buyers.”

Filipino Ronald Villanueva, a non-smoking resident of Sharjah for the past eight years, said that even with the ban, it will be difficult to implement the rule as 70 to 80 per cent of males smoke in this emirate. “Many might protest against it and trade in the blackmarket may rise.”

Lebanese Elizabeth Mekhjian, whose husband died of lung cancer, told Khaleej Times that this is good news for her as she supports anti-smoking. “My husband died of lung cancer at 71 even though he quit smoking 20 years before he died. But, the effect of tobacco had long settled in his system.”

Emirati smokers Ahmed Al Shamsi, 18, and his cousin Jassim Al Shamsi, said they would stop smoking when the ban is implemented. But, they believed that the ban will lead to ‘blackmarket selling’ of tobacco and may not really contribute much in stopping teenagers from smoking.

lily@khaleejtimes.com

Anti-smoking law may dispense with warnings

By Zheng Caixiong (China Daily)

People who light up in non-smoking areas in Guangzhou may soon be slapped with a fine without warning.

The current law in the Guangdong provincial capital requires enforcement officers to provide a warning before fining someone 50 yuan ($8) for smoking in indoor workplaces and other public areas.

So far this year, officers in the city have received more than 1,200 complaints for smoking in public places, with 84 percent occurring in restaurants and entertainment venues such as nightclubs and karaoke bars.

But only one smoker has been fined so far this year, according to enforcement officials.

Guangzhou People’s Congress is now seeking public opinions for a draft amendment that would drop the requirement for a warning before a fine. The public can visit the legislature’s website to see the full text of the draft and email, fax or write to the legislature to air their opinions before May 15.

After hearing from the public, the legislature will update the draft and put it to a vote at next month’s legislative session.

An official from the Guangzhou enforcement bureau, who would not be named as he is not allowed to receive media interviews without official authorization, admitted that the bureau lacks manpower to enforce the regulation.

“And law enforcers usually find it difficult to collect evidences to fine the smokers,” the official said on Thursday.

But he said the bureau plans to work with relevant departments to handle the issue in the following months.

Many local residents welcome the revised anti-smoking regulation, but fear it will be ineffective.

Chen Wenjie, a Guangzhou office worker, said the draft is an improvement.

“But a fine of only 50 yuan for smokers is still not severe enough to deter law breakers,” he said.

Wang Fangwei, a local housewife, said the draft amendment is good, but she does not think it could be fully carried out.

“Many law enforcement agencies in the city are lax on punishment in fighting illegal smoking,” she said.

Also, by the time enforcement authorities arrive, the smokers might have stopped because it takes only two to three minutes to finish a cigarette, she added.

She called for more concrete and effective measures, such as fining the operators of restaurants instead of smokers.

However, many restaurant and bar managers and bosses are opposed to the proposed smoking ban.

“The smoking ban and the fine to the smokers would certainly affect the restaurant’s business,” said Zheng Canrong, a restaurant manager in Guangzhou’s Yuexiu district.

According to statistics from the Guangzhou Tobacco Control Association, Guangzhou is estimated to have more than 2 million smokers, representing 18 percent of the city’s population.

That figure has been on the rise in recent years.

Copyright By chinadaily.com.cn. All rights reserved

Government urged to ban smoking in outdoor areas

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-04-26/government-urged-to-ban-smoking-in-outdoor-areas/3973064

Government urged to ban smoking in outdoor areas

Updated April 26, 2012 13:15:21

Four of Victoria’s leading health groups have stepped up pressure on the Baillieu Government over smoking in outdoor areas.

Quit Victoria, the Australian Medical Association, the Heart Foundation and the Cancer Council want a ban on smoking in outdoor dining and drinking areas.

The groups have also recommend a ban on smoking in children’s playgrounds, at public transport stops and even between the flags on patrolled beaches.

Quit Victoria’s Fiona Sharkie says Victoria is lagging behind other states on this issue.

“Victoria remains the only state that doesn’t have a ban on smoking in outdoor drinking and dining areas and we feel that we need to rectify that as soon as possible, given that Victoria has been such a leader in tobacco control,” she said.

Ms Sharkie says even some smokers support the changes.

“What we do find is that smokers are generally pretty supportive of bans, particularly if they’re bans in areas where children and families congregate,” she said.

Health Minister David Davis says the outdoor bans are under consideration.

“It’s certainly is one of a number of measures that are being considered and are being looked at very closely,” he said.

“There’s been consultation on that and other measures with a wide range of organisations.”

First posted April 26, 2012 08:16:46

Clear the Air says: In Hong Kong the following set of questions  was raised inLegco in 2007 – guess what has happened since 2007! Well,  nothing. Why not ?

The new Secretary for Health can do one simple thing and does not even have to go toLegco to achieve it  – that is to add an additional  single paragraph to every liquor licence in Hong Kong :  the current licences state –

7.        The licensee shall not permit any person to occupy or use any portion of the premises for any immoral or illegal purpose.

Smoking in a licensed premises and workplace is an illegal activity and the licensee is bound to prevent it in the same way they are obliged to obey the other licensing conditions.  By not doing this the licensee breaks the conditions of the premises’ liquor licence. The onus must be placed on the licensee to prevent smoking in his/her premises as is the case everywhere overseas.

Accordingly we would urge the new Secretary for Health to direct the  Liquor Licensing Board to be proactive and to add  :

iii) 持牌人須確保處所內無人吸煙或攜帶燃着的香煙、雪茄或煙斗。(新增)

iii) The licensee shall ensure no smoking or carrying a lit cigarette, cigar or pipe in any area of the licensed premises. (New)

to ALL issued Liquor Licenses  as a matter of course and to advise the licensees of their duty to abide by all the conditions of their liquor licences and the pitfalls of not doing so.  The amendment should cover all parts of the liquor licensed premises, including patio areas , Outside Seating Accommodation whether more than 50% enclosed or not and within 15 meters of said premises to prevent smokers congregating at entrances and those who currently sit and smoke half in and half out of premises.   The law is to prevent damage to the health of staff in the workplace and should cover all parts of the licensed area whether covered , indoor or otherwise.

If people cannot go out and smoke in entertainment areas, many will quit. This means also an urgent increase in the staffing of the Tobacco Control Office who have insufficient staff for preventative  patrols and who can act only days later on telephone or email complaints.  53 officers per each of two shifts to cover the whole of HK, Kowloon, NT and the Islands is ludicrous and a deliberate ploy of the incumbent administration to produce a potholed legislation then fail to allocate enough staff to enforce it.

Then even worse, the massive sums taken in from tobacco taxation are not used for anti -smoking measures , whether cessation or advertising , but just enter the General Fund to be used to build more concrete white elephants.

Time for change.

From: Astor Chan [mailto:astorchan@dphk.org]
Sent:
Tuesday, July 24, 2007 12:39 PM
To:
dynamco@netvigator.com
Subject: EXPOSURE_TO_SECONDHAND_SMOKE

Dear Mr. Middleton,

Thanks for your email. We have raised a Legco question regarding this issue. Attached plsfind the question and answer.

Regards,

Astor Chan

Research Officer (Health Policy)

Legco Secretariat

Democratic Party

Following is a question by the Hon Andrew Cheng and a written reply by the Secretary for Food and Health, Dr York Chow, in the Legislative Council today (July 4):

Question:

Regarding smoking in outdoor public places, will the Government inform this Council:

(a) whether it knows if smoking outside designated no smoking areas (e.g. outside restaurants) has become prevalent since the implementation of the Smoking (Public Health) (Amendment) Ordinance 2006, the locations where the situation is particularly serious, as well as the impact on the health and smoking habits of members of the public (especially the problem of smoking among children); if it knows, of the details; if not, whether it will consider conducting a survey to understand the situation;

(b) of the number of prosecutions instituted by the Government against smoking in designated no smoking areas of outdoor public places since January 1 this year; whether there are difficulties in implementing the smoking ban in such places; if so, of the details and locations where the implementation of such a ban is particularly difficult, as well as the measures taken by the Government to resolve the difficulties; and

(c) whether it will consider amending the legislation to designate areas within 15 metres from the entrance to indoor designated no smoking areas (e.g. shopping arcades) as no smoking areas; if it will not, of the reasons for that, as well as how it protects the public from exposure to heavy second-hand smoke before they enter the premises concerned?

Reply:

Madam President,

My reply to each part of the question is as follows:

(a) The purpose of designating no-smoking areas is to minimise the effect of secondhand smoke on the public.  In so doing, we have balanced the interests of all parties, including both smokers and non-smokers.  With the vast expansion of statutory no-smoking areas since January 1 this year, the exposure of the public to secondhand smoke has already been greatly reduced.  At present, our priority is to implement the smoking ban in statutory no-smoking areas.  As for changes in the number of smokers and their smoking frequency and habits, the impact of secondhand smoke outside the statutory no-smoking areas, as well as public reaction towards the overall tobacco control efforts after the implementation of the amended Smoking (Public Health) Ordinance, we will conduct survey and study at a later stage to assess the effect of the new legislation.

(b) Statutory no-smoking areas designated under the Smoking (Public Health) Ordinance are set out in Part 1 of Schedule 2 to the Ordinance.  Since January 1 this year, the Tobacco Control Office has arranged to issue 70 summonses for smoking offences committed in outdoor no-smoking areas, including 69 cases that took place in public pleasure grounds under the management of the Leisure and Cultural Services Department and one case that took place in a public hospital.  Generally speaking, most people have complied with the smoking ban since the expansion of no-smoking areas. The Administration has encountered no particular difficulty in its enforcement of the smoking ban in outdoor areas.

(c) The amended Ordinance has vastly expanded the statutory no-smoking areas and the new legislation has only been in force for six months.  It would take time for the public to get accustomed to the new requirements and the Administration to review the effect of the new law.  At the present stage, we have no plans to further expand the statutory no-smoking areas.  As stated in part (a) of my reply, we will conduct survey and study after the new law has been in force for some time.  We should also note that no matter by how much the no-smoking areas were expanded, clear and conspicuous demarcations between smoking areas and no-smoking areas would still be needed.  Before putting in place any smoking ban, we must consider how to ensure effective enforcement and easy compliance by the public.

The long-term objective of tobacco control is to reduce the number of smokers, in particular young smokers.  Smoking cessation services are now made available by the Department of Health (DH) and the Hospital Authority.  In the past five months, the number of people calling DH’s smoking cessation hotline has increased twofold as compared with the same period last year.  Many family doctors and pharmacists working in the community have also joined in the provision of smoking cessation services.  We will continue to work with all sectors of the community to encourage smokers to quit smoking and hope that the trend of cessation will continue.

———- Forwarded message ———-
From: James Middleton < dynamco@netvigator.com>
Date: 19-May-2007 11:16
Subject: EXPOSURE_TO_SECONDHAND_SMOKE
To: Legco < pi@legco.gov.hk>, chengkarfoo@dphk.org, mswlai@legco.gov.hk
Cc: Judith Mackay <jmackay@pacific.net.hk>, Professor Hedley < hrmrajh@hkucc.hku.hk>, COSH < enq@cosh.org.hk>, “Dr. Wan” < ed@cosh.org.hk>, tobaccocontrol@dh.gov.hk

Legco

Attention

the Honorable Cheng Kar Foo

Ms Monna Lai

Dear Sir,

please find attached a late 2006 report on second hand smoke.

Currently there are designated smoking areas in parks and smoking is allowed in outdoor areas of restaurants and bars open to all ages that are not 50% enclosed.

Whilst being contrary to existing Hong Kong laws as addressed previously, this causes Outdoor Tobacco Smoke that is a proven danger to persons nearby or downwind of the smoke, especially chidren and susceptible adults. It also gives the impression to our youth that smoking in public is  acceptable behaviour and can encourage our youth to smoke and become addicts.
Please give consideration to amending the exemptions which currently allow designated smoking areas outdoors, especially in parks and restaurants which are open to all ages. Furthermore please give consideration to banning smoking within 15 meters of doorways, lifts,  escalators and building entrances. Our children and the 86% of our population that does not smoke in Hong Kong should not have to walk through the cancerous and irritating obnoxious smoke of the minority in order to enter and leave buildings.

Yours faithfully,

James Middleton

Skip to content

Search

Stanford Report, May 2, 2007

Exposure to secondhand tobacco smoke in outdoor settings a risk, study shows

BY MARK SHWARTZ

L.A. Cicero  

Wayne Ott and Neil Klepeis were members of a team of Stanford researchers who conducted the first in-depth study on how smoking affects air quality at sidewalk cafés, park benches and other outdoor locations.

Tens of thousands of Americans die each year from secondhand tobacco smoke, according to a 2006 report by the U.S. Surgeon General. While the health risks associated with indoor secondhand smoke are well documented, little research has been done on exposure to toxic tobacco fumes outdoors.

Now, Stanford University researchers have conducted the first in-depth study on how smoking affects air quality at sidewalk cafés, park benches and other outdoor locations. Writing in the May issue of the Journal of the Air and Waste Management Association (JAWMA), the Stanford team concluded that a non-smoker sitting a few feet downwind from a smoldering cigarette is likely to be exposed to substantial levels of contaminated air for brief periods of time.

“Some folks have expressed the opinion that exposure to outdoor tobacco smoke is insignificant, because it dissipates quickly into the air,” said Neil Klepeis, assistant professor (consulting) of civil and environmental engineering at Stanford and lead author of the study. “But our findings show that a person sitting or standing next to a smoker outdoors can breathe in wisps of smoke that are many times more concentrated than normal background air pollution levels.”

Klepeis pointed to the 2006 Surgeon General’s report, which found that even brief exposures to secondhand smoke may have adverse effects on the heart and respiratory systems and increase the severity of asthma attacks, especially in children.

“We were surprised to discover that being within a few feet of a smoker outdoors may expose you to air pollution levels that are comparable, on average, to indoor levels that we measured in previous studies of homes and taverns,” said Wayne Ott, professor (consulting) of civil and environmental engineering at Stanford and co-author of the JAWMA study. “For example, if you’re at a sidewalk café, and you sit within 18 inches of a person who smokes two cigarettes over the course of an hour, your exposure to secondhand smoke could be the same as if you sat one hour inside a tavern with smokers. Based on our findings, a child in close proximity to adult smokers at a backyard party also could receive substantial exposure to secondhand smoke.”

Unlike indoor tobacco smoke, which can persist for hours, the researchers found that outdoor smoke disappears rapidly when a cigarette is extinguished. “Our data also show that if you move about six feet away from an outdoor smoker, your exposure levels are much lower,” Klepeis added.

The public has become increasingly concerned about the effects of outdoor smoking, Ott noted. More than 700 state and local governments have passed laws restricting outdoor smoking at playgrounds, building entrances and other public areas, according to the American Nonsmokers’ Rights Foundation. Some of the strictest ordinances are in California. The city of Santa Monica, for example, recently banned smoking at parks, beaches, automatic teller machines, theater lines, open-air restaurants and other outdoor locations.

“Throughout the country, cities and counties are looking at various laws against outdoor smoking, and some of the proposals are pretty drastic,” Ott said. “The problem is that until now, there have been virtually no scientific data to justify such restrictions. In fact, our paper is the first study on outdoor smoking to be published in a peer-reviewed scientific journal.”

Particulate matter

In the study, the researchers used portable electronic monitors to make precise measurements of toxic airborne particles emitted from cigarettes at 10 sites near the Stanford campus. “We wanted to quantify the potential level of exposure to outdoor tobacco smoke that could occur in everyday settings,” Klepeis said. “To do this, we used five different, state-of-the-art instruments to measure secondhand smoke at parks, open-air cafés, sidewalks and outdoor pubs where smokers were present.”

Each instrument was calibrated to measure an airborne pollutant known as particulate matter-2.5 (PM2.5), which consists of thousands of microscopic particles that are less than 2.5 micrometers in width—about 30 times narrower than a human hair.

“PM2.5 is a toxic pollutant produced by cigarettes, wood-burning stoves, diesel engines and other forms of combustion,” Ott explained. “It contains benzo(a)pyrene, a carcinogen, and many other toxic chemicals that can penetrate deep inside the lungs.”

According to the Environmental Protection Agency, exposure to PM2.5 can lead to serious health problems, including asthma attacks, chronic bronchitis, irregular heartbeat, nonfatal heart attacks and even premature death in people with heart or lung disease. The current EPA ambient air standard for PM2.5 is 35 micrograms per cubic meter of air averaged over 24 hours. Levels that exceed 35 micrograms are considered unhealthy. “However, since tobacco smoke contains many toxic components, including carcinogens, it may be even less healthy than typical ambient air pollution,” Klepeis noted.

Test results

To measure PM2.5 levels in secondhand smoke, the researchers placed the instruments near actual smokers in different open-air environments. “We also performed controlled experiments with burning cigarettes, which allowed us to make precise measurements of PM2.5 levels at different distances,” Klepeis said.

The results were clear: The closer you are to an outdoor smoker, the higher your risk of exposure.

“A typical cigarette lasts about 10 minutes,” Klepeis said. “We found that if you’re within two feet downwind of a smoker, you may be exposed to pollutant concentrations that exceed 500 micrograms of PM2.5 over that 10-minute period. If you’re exposed multiple times to multiple cigarettes over several hours in an outdoor pub, it would be possible to get a daily average of 35 micrograms or more, which exceeds the current EPA outdoor standard.”

Outdoor tobacco smoke consists of brief plumes that sometimes exceed 1,000 micrograms, Klepeis added. “On the other hand, clean air typically contains less than 20 micrograms of PM2.5,” he said. “Therefore, a person near an outdoor smoker might inhale a breath with 50 times more toxic material than in the surrounding unpolluted air.”

However, the researchers found that air quality improved as they moved away from the smoker. “These results show what common sense would suggest—when you’re within a few feet downwind of a smoker, you get exposed,” Ott explained. “But likewise, when you go a little distance or stay upwind, the exposure goes way down. If there’s just one smoker, and you can sit six feet away, you would have little problem. At the same time, if there are a lot of smokers nearby, you may be exposed to very high levels of secondhand smoke. So this thing that critics have been dismissing as trivial is not.”

Added Klepeis: “If people realize that being near outdoor smokers can result in potentially large exposures to toxic air pollution, they may decide they do not wish to be exposed in a variety of outdoor settings. This realization may lead to an increased number of smoking bans in public locations.”

The study also was co-authored by Paul Switzer, professor of statistics and of geological and environmental sciences at Stanford. The research was supported by grants from the State of California and the Flight Attendant Medical Research Institute in Miami.

Related Information

© Stanford University. All Rights Reserved. Stanford, CA 94305. (650) 723-2300.


Smoke-free Parks http://www.breath-ala.org/html/about.html

  • As of January 1, 2003, children and their families will have a 25-foot safe zone around playgrounds and toddler sandbox areas by state law. Kids should be able to play without being directly exposed to the harmful effects of secondhand smoke. It’s common sense to protect children where they play and socialize.
  • The reasons for protecting people, especially children, from secondhand smoke are convincing and overwhelming. Scientific evidence proves that exposure to secondhand smoke poses a serious health risk and there is no safe level of exposure. It is not only dangerous – it can also be deadly – especially for children and adults with asthma or other chronic illnesses.
  • Studies have shown that adult smoking behavior significantly influences youth smoking behavior. When Children see adults smoking in a family friendly place, they see the behavior as acceptable.
  • A critical component in addressing youth smoking is to create an environment in which tobacco use is not considered the norm in adult society. Every day in California, nearly 300 children begin smoking. Of those, 200 will go on to become addicted smokers. Half of those children will die prematurely of smoking-related diseases.
  • Cigarette butts are hazardous to children, animals and the environment. Smokers regularly discard their cigarette butts and empty packages on the ground. Small children are at risk of swallowing, choking, or burning themselves with discarded butts.
  • Cigarette butts are the most common litter in our parks and the clean up is time consuming and costly to taxpayers

Banning outdoor smoking is scientifically justifiable

Simon Chapman has argued that smoking should not be in outdoor public venues such as hospital patios, beaches, and outdoor sporting areas, and this might also encompass building entrances, waiting lines for cinema tickets, and outdoorcafés. However, failure to ban smoking in such venues may expose non-smokers to levels of environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) as high or higher than received in indoor spaces where smoking is unrestricted.

The reality of atmospheric dispersion of ETS in outdoor settings is this: individual cigarettes are point sources of air pollution and, therefore, smoking in groups becomes an area source. Outdoor air pollutants from individual point sources are subject to plume rise if the temperature of the smoke plume is hotter that the surrounding air. However, if the plume has a small cross-section, as far a cigarette, it will rapidly cool and lose its upward momentum, and then will subside as the combustions particles and gases are heavier than air. Thus, in the case of no wind, the cigarette plume will rise to a certain height and then descend. In a case where a group of smokers are sitting in an outdoor café, on a hospital patio, or in stadium seats, their smoke will tend to saturate the local area with ETS.

Where there is wind, the amount of thermally induced plume rise will be inversely proportional to the wind velocity–doubling the wind velocity will halve the plume rise. In this case, the cigarette plume will resemble a cone tilted at an angle to the vertical. The width of the cone and its angle with the ground will depend upon the wind velocity: a higher wind will create a more horizontal cone, a smaller cone angle, and a higher concentration of ETS for downwind non-smokers. If there are multiple cigarette sources, the downwind concentrations will consist of multiple intersections cones–that is, overlapping plumes. As the wind direction changes, ETS pollution will be spread in various directions, fumigating downwind non-smokers. ETS contains a large quantity of respirable particles, which can cause breathing difficulties for those with chronic respiratory diseases, or trigger an asthmatic attack in those with disabling asthma. For the remainder of non-smokers, ETS causes eye, nose, and throat irritation, just like any other noxious outdoor fumes, such as bus exhaust. If smoking is freely permitted in these venues, hospital orderlies, sports spectators, outdoor café aficionados, and beach goers might have to be restricted to the ranks of the non-asthmatic.

Have you ever had dinner in an outdoor café in Pairs, Athens, Las Palmas, or Salt Lake spoiled by smokers at adjacent tables? Have you ever had to move your blanket on a public beach because someone suddenly started smoking upwind, replacing clean salt air with irritating smoke? Smoking has no social value other than to create unnecessary work for physicians, and windfall profits for morticians. Even if outdoor environmental tobacco smoke were no more hazardous than dog excrement stuck to the bottom of a shoe, in many places laws require dog owners to avoid fouling public areas. Is this too much to ask of smokers?

JAMES REPACE

Repace Associates Inc,
Secondhand Smoke Consultants
101 Felicia Lane
Bowie, MD 20720, USA;
<www.repace.com >

OUTDOOR TOBACCO SMOKE FACT SHEET

“CLEARING THE AIR”

“Failure to ban smoking in outdoor public venues may expose non-smokers to levels of environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) as high or higher than received in indoor spaces where smoking is unrestricte

…

[Message clipped]  View entire message