Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Hopes of Leung tobacco war grow

HK Standard

The combination of “people’s chief executive” Leung Chun-ying and his possible “wingman” in the health department is raising hopes the government will take the next big step towards a smoke-free city.

Mary Ann Benitez

Friday, June 08, 2012

The combination of “people’s chief executive” Leung Chun-ying and his possible “wingman” in the health department is raising hopes the government will take the next big step towards a smoke-free city.

That move is to ban “mini-billboard advertising” by imposing plain cigarette packaging.

A former Hospital Authority director of public affairs and human resources, who went into private practice, Ko Wing-man, is tipped to become the secretary for food and health in the new Cabinet.

Ko temporarily stepped in for authority chief executive William Ho Shiu-wei when Ho contracted SARS nine years ago.

With Leung expected to announce his team soon, Ko is tipped to succeed York Chow Yat-ngok.

Ko, who describes himself on Twitter as “This is Wing Man. I’m your friend,” earlier told The Standard he favors tobacco control initiatives, without going into details.

“As a doctor and as chairman of the Hong Kong Cancer Society, I would support any initiative to help eliminate tobacco.”

World Lung Foundation senior adviser Judith Mackay said she is “fairly optimistic” about plain packaging being adopted in Hong Kong. “A lot will depend on CY Leung,” she said. “And, to my knowledge, he does not have tobacco connections.”

Tobacco companies have warned they will file lawsuits if Hong Kong goes for plain packaging. A spokeswoman for the Coalition on Tobacco Affairs said there has been no case study in the world to show plain packaging will curb smoking.

Australia is set to be the first nation to enforce plain packaging on December 1.

Hong Kong-based Philip Morris Asia has filed a lawsuit against Canberra, claiming plain packaging legislation deprives it of investment under the Hong Kong/Australia Bilateral Investment Treaty Agreement.

Smoking ban begins at Sonoma County outdoor restaurant areas

By MARTIN ESPINOZA
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Thursday, May 31, 2012 at 7:00 p.m.

Last Modified: Friday, June 1, 2012 at 7:20 a.m.

Beginning today, smoking is prohibited in outdoor restaurant and bar areas that fall within the jurisdiction of Sonoma County.

The new rule is part of a larger anti-smoking package that seeks to bring the county in line with cities such as Santa Rosa and Sebastopol that have strict smoking prohibitions.

“This is part of envisioning Sonoma County as one of the healthiest places to live, work and play,” said Lynn Silver Chalfin, the county’s new health officer.

“It means that you will be able to go out to dinner, a picnic or celebration and not be exposed to second-hand smoke.”

The areas affected are outside the boundaries of the county’s nine cities and include large swaths of Wine Country, along with smaller communities of Kenwood, Boyes Hot Springs, Bodega, Bodega Bay, Guerneville, Forestville and Graton.

The rule bans smoking in outdoor dining areas such as patios at restaurants, bars and wineries. Designated smoking areas, while permitted,cannot be less than 25 feet from an outdoor dining area, nor can they be within 25 feet of any operable window, door or vent into an enclosed area.

“They can’t set up a designated area that infringes on anybody else’s space,” said Kelly Elder, manager of the healthy communities section of the Sonoma County Department of Health Services.

Last fall, the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors strengthened its existing no-smoking ordinance by banning smoking in multi-unit housing, all county owned property and certain outdoor areas. The no-smoking rules were to take effect in stages.

Since November, smoking has been prohibited in outdoor common areas of multi-unit complexes.

In December, smoking was banned on all county-owned property, entryways and service lines such as theater lines.

Smoking inside apartments, condos and duplexes and in their attached patios will be prohibited beginning next January.

Designated smoking areas are permitted but heavily restricted.

Kerry Andrade, coordinator for the county’s tobacco education program, said that Petaluma, which bans smoking in parks, is considering banning smoking in outdoor dining areas and entryways.

Smoking ban begins at Sonoma County outdoor restaurant areasBy MARTIN ESPINOZA

http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20120531/articles/120539871&tc=yahoo?p=2&tc=pg

World No Tobacco Day 2012 Brochure

We are pleased to share with you the final version of the brochure for World No Tobacco Day 2012.  Please feel free to circulate within your network.  More information is also available on the WHO website:

http://www.who.int/tobacco/wntd/2012/announcement/en/index.html

The Tobacco Free Initiative in WPRO will be releasing press statements and an opinion editorial by the Regional Director. We will share these — when they are available. A letter has also been sent to Ministers of Health from the Regional Director.

With warm regards and congratulations in advance on all your efforts to raise awareness on World No Tobacco Day 2012.

Download PDF : NTD brochure final

Ramadoss seeks ban on tobacco products

http://www.thehindu.com/news/states/tamil-nadu/article3459921.ece

CHENNAI,May 27, 2012

Special Correspondent

PMK founder S. Ramadoss on Saturday demanded a ban on the manufacture and sale of tobacco products in Tamil Nadu on the lines of the one imposed by the Kerala government.

Citing a report published by the Cancer Institute, Adyar, that the sale of tobacco products had increased in Tamil nadu, Dr. Ramadoss said that according to the report of the World Health Organisation (WHO), around 20 crore people in India chewed tobacco and 40 per cent of them died of the habit.

In Tamil Nadu, though there was a ban on selling tobacco products within a 400-metre radius of educational institutions, it was not being implemented, resulting in more and more students falling prey to the products.

Dr. Ramadoss said that the Supreme Court had suggested a ban on tobacco products and Madhya Pradesh had implemented it.

“States such as Odisha, Rajasthan, Bihar, Maharashtra, Assam and Jammu and Kashmir are considering a ban. Chief Minister Jayalalithaa, who is keen on making Tamil Nadu the number one State, should immediately ban tobacco products,” he said.

A smoke-free country? New Zealand taxes aim for it

http://wcfcourier.com/lifestyles/health-med-fit/a-smoke-free-country-new-zealand-taxes-aim-for-it/article_eb51b260-4a0e-561f-ba36-262b37ae252a.html

A smoke-free country? New Zealand taxes aim for it

Associated Press | Posted: Thursday, May 24, 2012 7:01 pm | (0) Comments

Brett Phibbs

In this Jan. 18, 2012 photo, a smoker puffs on a cigarette in the central business district in Auckland, New Zealand. New Zealand’s government on Thursday, May 24, 2012, squeezed smokers more than ever by announcing a 40 percent hike in tobacco taxes over the next four years. Officials hope higher taxes and new restrictions will bring the nation of 4.4 million closer to a recent pledge to snuff out the habit entirely by 2025. (AP Photo/New Zealand Herald, Brett Phibbs)

There are smoke-free bars, smoke-free parks, even smoke-free college campuses. But a smoke-free country?

New Zealand’s government on Thursday squeezed smokers more than ever by announcing a 40 percent hike in tobacco taxes over the next four years. Prices here are already among the highest in the world, and by 2016 they will top 20 New Zealand dollars ($15) a pack on average.

Officials hope higher taxes and new restrictions will bring the nation of 4.4 million closer to a recent pledge to snuff out the habit entirely by 2025. Other countries have lauded the idea of trying to wean their populace off tobacco, but few, if any, have been willing to put a date on it.

Health officials here are so serious they recently considered hiking the cost of a pack of cigarettes to 100 New Zealand dollars ($75). Although that idea was dismissed, another measure, which will force retailers to hide cigarettes below the counter rather than putting them on display, will come into effect in July.

Smoking rates among New Zealand adults have fallen from about 30 percent in 1986 to about 20 percent today. Cigarette sales have fallen more sharply, suggesting that even people who haven’t quit cut back as prices rose.

People who are still smoking aren’t happy about where prices are going.

Chris Hobman said the cost is “horrendous” and could drive some low-income people to commit crimes to support their habit. He said the government needs to provide more support and alternatives to smokers if it’s serious about making them quit.

Wellington resident Hayley Mauriohooho, who has smoked for about 20 years, said that although it would be good if more people quit, higher taxes won’t stop her.

“It’s quite ridiculous for the government to be concentrating on that,” she said. “They have bigger things to worry about.”

New Zealand’s Cancer Society reacted to Thursday’s announcement by sending out a press release titled “Thumbs Up!”

Michael Colhoun, a spokesman for the anti-smoking lobby group ASH, said the fact that a higher percentage of low-income people smoke will mean the tax increases will force many to cut back or quit entirely because they simply won’t be able to afford their habit.

The New Zealand branch of cigarette company British American Tobacco says the tax increases will force consumers to turn to the black market.

“Consumer demand is far better served by legitimate companies than by the illegal operators that will surely grow as the government makes it increasingly difficult for people to buy their product of choice,” wrote Susan Jones, head of corporate and regulatory affairs, in an email.

So far, New Zealand officials have seen few cases of illegal tobacco sales.

The South Pacific nation’s smoking statistics are similar to those in other developed countries. According to a 2011 study by the World Health Organization, about 20 percent of adult New Zealanders smoke. That compares to about 16 percent of adults in the U.S., 17 percent in Australia, 23 percent in China and 27 percent in France.

New Zealand already charges more than 70 percent tax on cigarettes, compared to 41 percent on average for China, 45 percent on average for the U.S., 64 percent for Australia and 80 percent for France.

Read More: http://wcfcourier.com/lifestyles/health-med-fit/a-smoke-free-country-new-zealand-taxes-aim-for-it/article_eb51b260-4a0e-561f-ba36-262b37ae252a.html#ixzz1vzMUbdvx

South Korean smokers to feel the heat

http://www.iol.co.za/business/business-news/south-korean-smokers-to-feel-the-heat-1.1305380

May 26 2012 at 01:53pm
By Nam You-Sun

Comment on this story


Copy of cigarette jan 10sxc.hu

File Photo

Seoul – After decades of indifference, big businesses and the government are turning up the heat on smokers in South Korea, a nation with one of the developed world’s highest male smoking rates.

Some firms are pressing workers to kick the habit or miss out on promotion and the health ministry will toughen warnings on cigarette packs.

Seoul council plans eventually to make one fifth of the city’s total area smoke-free. Even the military is getting in on the act:

army draftees undergoing basic training will get advice from a clinic on ways to quit.

But successive national governments – fearful of an electoral backlash – have held back from raising the tax on cigarettes.

About 44.3 percent of South Korean men smoked in 2009, according to the latest available data from the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). This compares to an average among all member nations of 26.5 percent for men.

The smoking rate among Korean women is low due to social taboos.

Samsung Electronics, the country’s largest employer, is at the forefront of efforts to cajole workers to quit smoking.

Executives of its Device Solutions (DS) department, which employs 35,000 people out of a total of 101,970 Samsung Electronics staff in Korea, recently called on staffers to join a non-smoking programme.

A company spokesman said almost all DS employees had made non-smoking pledges as part of what it called a “well-received” voluntary programme.

The department “considers employees as the company’s most valuable asset, and their health and well-being are a top priority. The recent smoking cessation programme is an extension of that belief,” a statement said.

The spokesman said the company as a whole was considering strengthening anti-smoking policies.

“Certain consequences for smokers are under consideration. They haven’t been finalised nor enforced,” he said, adding smoking could be a factor affecting promotion prospects.

The Woongjin Group, which has wide ranging businesses, has also tightened its policies. It said promotions made in February took smoking into account and all new employees must sign an anti-smoking pledge.

“The announcements were made prior to the promotion process, so there weren’t any complaints from those who didn’t get promotion,” said its spokeswoman.

Woongjin conducts random hair and urine tests on a large number of employees at irregular intervals.

Media reports say some other major companies employ similar tactics, even though they publicly deny pressuring employees. Some employees say they don’t object.

“At first, I had negative feelings about the policy because it was too forceful. But as I followed along, I began to think it was good for me,” said Che Young-Jin, 31, who recently quit smoking.

Outside the workplace, Seoul city government has banned smoking in plazas and parks and near bus stops and schools. Offenders face a 100,000 won (about R700) fine.

“We caught 240 cases last year at main plazas and parks and this year, our 23 officers are going to random spots and catching about three to five smokers every day,” said Song Yo-Sang, a manager at the city government.

By 2014, the city plans to make 21 percent of its total area a non-smoking zone. It is considering a blanket ban on smoking in all public areas except for some designated spots.

The health ministry will increase the size of warning messages on cigarette packs from 30 percent of the surface area to 50

percent.

“Two more messages, which are a counselling hotline number and a message that inhalation of tar depends on smoking habits, will be printed with the original message,” said Song Myoung-Jun, a ministry deputy director.

The ministry also plans to use graphic warning pictures, such as diseased lungs, on packs although it may take time to amend laws to permit this.

But officials are still hesitant to raise the cigarette tax, the lowest among OECD nations. A pack of Marlboro costs just 2,700 won ($2.31).

Song acknowledged the price was low but said a rise “requires social consensus”.

Some smokers say South Korea’s new-found zeal is excessive.

“Conducting tests and constantly pressuring employees to quit smoking even after work clearly violates human rights,” said Hong Sung-Yong, director of the Korea Smoker’s Association.

“People shouldn’t make smokers look like barbarians when smoking is legal and we pay the rightful amount of taxes,” he said, calling on Seoul city to designate public smoking areas.

“Prohibiting smoking is like pushing smokers off the brink and merely shows that they don’t care at all about smokers’ rights,” Hong said. – Sapa-AFP

Lord’s smoking alert after Sky complains about MCC members’ cigars during England versus West Indies Test

And the Lord said, thou shalt not smoke…………………old chap.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/cricket/news/9283516/Lords-smoking-alert-after-Sky-complains-about-MCC-members-cigars-during-England-versus-West-Indies-Test.html

MCC is reviewing its smoking policy after complaints from Sky Sports over members smoking cigars close to its cameramen.

Lord's smoking alert after Sky complain about MCC members' cigars during England versus West Indies Test

Taking a puff: MCC is to look into the placing of smoking areas at the ground Photo: GETTY IMAGES

By Nick Hoult

8:11PM BST 22 May 2012

6 Comments

The broadcaster wrote to complain during the Lord’s Test and the MCC moved one of the cameras away from the smoking area on the final two days of the match.

But the cameraman was moved to an area not usable when the ground is full as it would obstruct the view of paying spectators, leaving the club with a problem before the one-day international against Australia on June 29.

Lord’s is the only Test ground in England which has designated smoking areas in the stands and moves to ban it would be unpopular with some members, who are unlikely to be calmed by the use of health and safety regulations as an explanation.

But a stand-off between the club and English cricket’s host broadcaster, which props up the game to the tune of nearly £100  million per year, could follow if the matter is not resolved.

“Smoking is allowed in 10 percent of seating on the lower concourse of the pavilion and a small area in the upper balcony as well,” said an MCC spokesman.

“We will review the placing of these smoking areas and will do so before the next major match. We are a members club so if a small percentage of members want an area in which to smoke we have to take that into account but we will review our smoking policy as we always do on an annual basis.”

Unpaid smoking fines put bar licenses in jeopardy

http://www.middletownjournal.com/news/middletown-news/unpaid-smoking-fines-put-bar-licenses-in-jeopardy-1381803.html

Area liquor permits at risk over fines from smoking violations. Ohio’s anti-smoking law gains traction.

HANDOUT

http://www.ohio-share.coxnewsweb.com/multimedia/dynamic/01133/hjn052612a1Smoking_1133510b.jpg

ENLARGE PHOTO

The Froggy Blues Café in Monroe owes $34,000. Staff photo by Gary Stelzer

GARY STELZER/MBR The Froggy Blues Café in Monroe owes $34,000. Staff photo by Gary Stelzer

  • ·

By Beena Raghavendran, Staff Writer 12:56 AM Saturday, May 26, 2012

A number of area drinking establishments are at risk of losing their liquor permits if they don’t pay smoking fines levied against them, health officials said.

Ohio’s Smoke-Free Workplace Act gained more teeth this week when it was ruled constitutional by the Ohio Supreme Court. The court rejected a Columbus tavern owner’s case that said requiring establishments to pay the smoking fine was an illegal taking of property. The law, passed in 2006, makes smoking in most public places illegal. Easy’s in the Village has the most unpaid fines from smoking violations in Butler and Warren counties, according to hundreds of Ohio Health Department records examined by the Middletown Journal.

Owners of Easy’s in the Village did not returns calls for comment. The Hamilton bar owes $245,000 in unpaid smoking fines from the past five years. It’s one of several bars and pubs that still owe thousands of dollars in fines.

Unpaid smoking fines in area businesses add up to $34,000 at Froggy Blues Café in Monroe, $16,600 at Towne Pub in Hamilton and $11,500 at Scotty’s Pub in Fairfield, according to Ohio Department of Health invoices.

A bar’s first violation of the smoking ban is a warning from the Ohio Department of Health and a $100 fine; the second is a $500 fine; the third is a $1,000 fine; and the fourth and each subsequent offense is a $2,500 fine, according to ODH spokeswoman Shannon Libby.

State records show $3 million in fines have been issued in the past five years, but almost $2.3 million remains unpaid.

Ohio health officials say they hope collections improve now that the Supreme Court has declared the law constitutional and removed one of the justifications some businesses have used to withhold payment of fines.

However, budget cuts, a bad economy and the difficulty of collecting fines for offenses that are, legally speaking, the equivalent of parking tickets all play a part in the low collection rate.

“We have had some difficulty collecting,” said Amanda Burkett, chief of the Ohio Department of Health’s indoor environment section. “It’s not like you have a huge stick to get people to pay fines.”

The Butler County Health District has 57 smoking ban violations at or over the fourth offense, the fourth highest in Ohio, state records say. The county has had 1,810 reports and has undergone 862 investigations since the ban was enacted — the 11th highest number in the state.

Five Ohio establishments that have refused to pay could face revocation of their liquor licenses, said Ohio Attorney General spokesman Dan Tierney.

However, several area bars have continued to violate the ban and not pay, Libby said, and those that don’t pay risk not having their licenses renewed.

Jim Coffman, owner of Scotty’s Pub, said because the bar business is slow in the summer, many establishments cannot pay.

“If there’s a bar that says, ‘We’re not going to smoke anymore,’ they’re just going to go to another bar,” Coffman said.

The manager at Froggy Blues Café refused to comment, and the manager at Village and Towne Pub could not be reached.

The Associated Press contributed to this story.

Bars that ban smoking will do well

SCMP Letters

The Dickens Bar of the Excelsior Hotel in Causeway Bay has strictly enforced the no-smoking ban from day one without apparently losing customers.

They are happy to go there to watch a soccer game and have a beer, knowing they cannot light up, because they are in a well-run bar. They will come even though the prices are not cheap.

Contrast that with a bar I visited in Sheung Shui about nine months ago to watch a match. Locals looked at me initially as if I was a spy, then lost their inhibitions and started smoking.

When you are in a bar like that, it makes you wonder what other laws are being broken; perhaps, for example, the sale of drugs or counterfeit goods.

Don’t these publicans realise they are shooting themselves in the foot? They should pay a visit to the Dickens and copy its entrepreneurial strategy.

Because it is so well run and sticks to the law, in business terms it will do well in the long run. As I said, non-smokers are happy to pay the relatively high prices so they can enjoy a few quiet hours in a clean and tidy environment.

Pang Chi-ming, Fanling

US Supreme court ruling Good Guys 10 – Bad Guys Zero

http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/PIO/summaries/2012/0523/110019.asp

Supreme Court Upholds Ohio’s Smoke Free Workplace Law

Enforcement of Law Against Columbus Tavern Is Not Unconstitutional ‘Taking’ of Property

Please note:Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion released by the Court, but only for those cases considered noteworthy or of great public interest. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of Court opinions. The full text of this and other Court opinions from 1992 to the present are available online from the Reporter of Decisions. In the Full Text search box, enter the eight-digit case number at the top of this summary and click “Submit.”

2011-0019. Wymsylo v. Bartec, Inc., Slip Opinion No. 2012-Ohio-2187.

Franklin App. No. 10AP-173, 2010-Ohio-5558. Judgment affirmed.

O’Connor, C.J., and Pfeifer, Lundberg Stratton, Lanzinger, Cupp, and McGee Brown, JJ., concur.

O’Donnell, J., concurs in judgment only.

Opinion: http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/2012/2012-Ohio-2187.pdf

View oral argument video of this case.

(May 23, 2012) The Supreme Court of Ohio today affirmed a ruling by the Tenth District Court of Appeals that upheld the Ohio Smoke Free Workplace Act as constitutional.

The court’s 7-0 decision, authored by Justice Judith Ann Lanzinger, rejected claims by the owner of Zeno’s Victorian Village that fines assessed against his establishment for violating the statewide ban on smoking in places of employment exceeded the state’s legitimate police powers or were an unconstitutional governmental “taking” of private property.

In November 2006, Ohio voters passed a ballot initiative to enact the Smoke Free Act, which was codified in R.C. Chapter 3794 and became effective December 7, 2006. Subject to certain exemptions, the act prohibits proprietors of public places of employment from permitting smoking in their establishments, and authorizes the Ohio Department of Health (ODH) and local agencies designated by ODH to enforce the smoking ban, including the authority to impose fines that increase in severity for repeat violators.

On ten separate occasions between July 2007 and September 2009, Zeno’s Victorian Village, a privately owned bar in Columbus, was cited by the Columbus City Health Department for smoking ban violations and assessed fines, none of which were paid. Zeno’s did not file administrative appeals on eight of the citations. Two citations were appealed to the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas, but Zeno’s did not contest them and did not pursue further legal challenges to those citations or the resulting fines.

The director of ODH filed a complaint in the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas seeking preliminary and permanent injunctions ordering Bartec, Inc., d.b.a. Zeno’s Victorian Village, and Richard Allen, the CEO and sole shareholder of Bartec, Inc., to comply with the Smoke Free Act and to pay all outstanding fines. Bartec filed an answer asserting the affirmative defense that the Smoke Free Act was unconstitutional both on its face and as applied. The bar owner also filed a counterclaim seeking a declaratory judgment and injunction against ODH invalidating the citations against Zeno’s and vacating the resulting fines on constitutional grounds.

The trial court denied ODH’s requested injunctions. In its decision, the trial court reviewed rules and procedures that had been adopted by ODH to enforce the Smoke Free Act, and held that those rules exceeded the department’s statutory authority by holding proprietors “strictly liable” for illegal smoking by their customers. Based on that finding, the trial court vacated all of the citations and fines that ODH had imposed against Zeno’s.

ODH appealed. On review, the Tenth District Court of Appeals reversed the trial court and remanded with instructions to issue the injunction requested by ODH.

Bartec sought and was granted Supreme Court review of the Tenth District’s rulings.

In today’s unanimous decision, Justice Lanzinger affirmed the Tenth District’s finding that because the constitutional arguments raised by Bartec regarding its past citations presented “as applied” challenges to the Smoke Free Act, and such challenges must be advanced in administrative appeals in order to be preserved for appellate review, Bartec’s failure to raise those arguments in administrative appeals of its ODH citations waived those issues, and the trial court erred by considering them.

Justice Lanzinger wrote: “Appellants had the opportunity to request an administrative hearing in which they could have developed a record to show that ODH’s investigators used a strict-liability approach. … Because appellants failed to request an administrative hearing for eight of their violations and because they failed to prosecute the two administrative appeals they did request, appellants did not raise any constitutional challenge regarding any of its ten violations. Therefore, appellants failed to exhaust their administrative remedies, and this constitutional issue is not properly before the court.”

“In their second proposition of law, appellants assert that their inclusion as proprietors subject to the Smoke Free Act exceeds the outer limits of the state’s police power and unreasonably extinguishes property rights. Additionally, they argue that prohibiting smoking in an adults-only liquor-licensed establishment, such as Zeno’s, is unduly oppressive and amounts to a taking. It is clear that this is an as-applied challenge. Appellants are not contending that there is no set of circumstances under which the Smoke Free Act would be valid. Again, appellants are contending that, as applied to their particular circumstances, R.C. 3794.02 is unfair and unconstitutional. … (A)s discussed above, because appellants did not raise this as-applied constitutional challenge in any of the violations they failed to exhaust their administrative remedies, and this challenge is not properly before the court.”

With regard to Bartec’s request to enjoin future enforcement of the Smoke Free Act against Zeno’s, Justice Lanzinger wrote: “In their counterclaim, appellants requested that ODH be enjoined from unlawful enforcement of R.C. Chapter 3794. Specifically they contended that ODH’s policy of strict liability − where there’s smoke, there’s a violation − exceeds the authority R.C. Chapter 3794 grants to ODH. A rule adopted by an administrative agency is ‘valid and enforceable unless unreasonable or in conflict with the statutory enactment covering the same subject matter.’ … Appellants’ main contention is that investigators never inquired of appellants’ employees whether they had taken steps to prevent smoking in prohibited areas. The smoking enforcement coordinator for the city of Columbus, however, testified that when he observed a patron smoking at Zeno’s, he would on occasion speak with the employees and that none had told him that they had asked the patron to stop smoking.”

“Substantial evidence exists that appellants at least implicitly permitted smoking. For instance, on August 6, 2007, a Columbus City Health Department investigator witnessed two people smoking at Zeno’s and observed cigarette butts in plastic cups filled halfway with water. On November 29, 2007, another investigator found multiple Zeno’s patrons who were smoking and who were using partially filled plastic cups as ashtrays. Although appellant Richard Allen was present at the time, the investigator did not witness him address any of the smoking patrons. On November 6, 2008, a third investigator witnessed at least eight patrons smoking and using small plastic cups as ashtrays.”

“R.C. 3794.06(B) requires proprietors to remove all ashtrays and ‘other receptacles used for disposing of smoking materials’ from any area where smoking is prohibited. Finally, in eight of the violations, the investigator determined that the violation was intentional and doubled the fine. The court of appeals agreed: ‘On this record, the evidence is overwhelming that Bartec repeatedly and intentionally violated the Smoke Free Act, failed to comply with its provisions as R.C. 3794.09(D) requires, and in so doing exposed patrons and employees to the very harm the statute is designed to prevent. Due to the hearing the court conducted and the evidence adduced as a result of the hearing, the trial court could reach no other conclusion.’ We therefore conclude that appellants have failed to establish that appellants will be subject to an unlawful policy of strict liability.”

Citing a 2002 Supreme Court decision, D.A.B.E., Inc. v. Toledo-Lucas Cty. Bd. of Health, Justice Lanzinger wrote: “We have previously stated that the General Assembly has the authority to enact a public-smoking ban. … Although the Smoke Free Act was ultimately passed pursuant to a ballot initiative, the voters of Ohio also have a legitimate purpose in protecting the general welfare and health of Ohio citizens and workforce from the dangers of secondhand smoke in enclosed public places. By requiring that proprietors of public places and places of employment take reasonable steps to prevent smoking on their premises by posting ‘no smoking’ signs, removing ashtrays, and requesting patrons to stop smoking, the act is rationally related to its stated objective.”

“Although appellants complain that the Smoke Free Act is not being enforced against actual smokers themselves, the evidence establishes that ODH has not received a complaint against an individual smoker. The trial court may have also questioned how much a property owner can do, but the evidence also establishes that during their on-site visits, the investigators did not witness appellants or their employees ask patrons to stop smoking or remove the makeshift ashtrays being used. It is not unreasonable or arbitrary to hold responsible the proprietors of public places and places of employment for their failure to comply with the Smoke Free Act. … Our review of the act leads us to conclude that it is neither unduly oppressive nor arbitrary in its restrictions. Appellants’ own witness testified that most patrons who are asked to stop smoking readily do so. We therefore hold that the Smoke Free Act is a valid exercise of police power.”

Finally, in rejecting Bartec’s claim that application of the smoking ban to Zeno’s constituted a governmental “taking” of the bar’s property (i.e., that the ban confiscated the owner’s control of the indoor air), Justice Lanzinger noted that, except for narrow exceptions that do not apply in this case, regulatory takings claims are governed by standards set in the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1978 decision in Penn Central Trasport. Co. v. New York City.

Justice Lanzinger wrote: “With a Penn Cent. regulatory taking, a court engages in a factual inquiry of the following three factors: ‘(1) the economic impact of the regulation on the claimant, (2) the extent to which the regulation has interfered with distinct investment-backed expectations, and (3) the character of the governmental action.’ … Appellants submitted evidence that their gross sales declined in 2009, but the Smoke Free Act became effective in December 2006, and in 2007 and 2008 appellants’ gross sales actually increased. Furthermore, Columbus’s smoking ban, found at Columbus Code of Ordinances Chapter 715, is very similar to R.C. Chapter 3794 and went into effect in January 2005. Still, appellants’ gross sales increased in 2005 and 2006. Thus, appellants have failed to demonstrate that the Smoke Free Act has had a significant economic impact on their business.”

“The second and third factors also do not support finding a taking in this case. … The ‘taking’ of appellants’ indoor air space is not the type of taking contemplated by either the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution or the Ohio Constitution, Article I, Section 19. Appellants have also failed to demonstrate that the Smoke Free Act interfered with a distinct investment-backed expectation. The goal of this legislation is to protect the health of the workers and other citizens of Ohio. … It does so by regulating proprietors of public places and places of employment in a minimally invasive way. We therefore hold that the Smoke Free Act does not constitute a taking.”

Justice Lanzinger’s opinion was joined by Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor and Justices Paul E. Pfeifer, Evelyn Lundberg Stratton, Robert R. Cupp and Yvette McGee Brown. Justice Terrence O’Donnell concurred in judgment only.

Contacts

Alexandra T. Schimmer, 614.995.2273, for Ohio Department of Health Director Theodore E. Wymsylo.

Maurice A. Thompson, 614.340.9817, for Bartec, Inc. and Richard Allen.