Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Officials need to enforce smoking ban

SCMP

I refer to the letter by David Tjian (“Officers failing to be proactive”, July 3) about people breaking no-smoking rules.

There are some people who break the law on purpose. I saw a man smoking at a food stall in the government market complex at Sheung Shui. Rather than phoning the Tobacco Control Office, diners just moved away from him. I can understand this. Gangsters can cause problems and the ones who eventually suffer can be stall owners and their families.

I saw a Hospital Authority poster at Fanling Medical Centre in nine languages reminding people that those who violated the no-smoking ban would be fined.

However, I see no similar posters from the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department or Tobacco Control Office in food courts. The authorities are not treating the smoking ban as a priority.

This is in contrast to America, where they take the smoking ban regulations very seriously.

Pang Chi-ming, Fanling

New Study: E-Cigarettes Endanger Bystanders – Bans Growing

New Study: E-Cigarettes Endanger Bystanders – Bans Spreading

“Passive Vaping” Exposed Them to Toxic Cancer-Causing Chemicals

E-cigarettes, also called “electronic cigarettes” or “ecigs,” were recently blamed for a suspected terrorist incident in London and for a fire which burned 350 acres, but, more importantly, a new study confirmed earlier reports that ecigs give off toxic and cancer-causing chemicals which can endanger bystanders through a process similar to “passive smoking” called “passive vaping.”http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/police-shut-part-uk-motorway-bus-incident-article-1.1108204 **http://www.kob.com/article/stories/S2679801.shtml?cat=500

The study showed that ecigs give off a variety of volatile organic compounds, including formaldehyde, a toxic and allergenic irritant listed as “known to be a human carcinogen” by the U.S. National Toxicology Program; acetaldehyde, an irritant of the skin, eyes, mucous membranes, throat and respiratory tract, and classified by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency [EPA] as a “probable human carcinogen”; acetone, an industrial solvent; as well as 1,2-propanediol, 1,2,3-propanetriol, diacetine, and a variety of tiny particles which lodge themselves into the lungs of those who inhale them. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1600-0668.2012.00792.x/abstract;jsessionid=33855B65D8E691F5D7D3BE1E9818DFC3.d02t04

The authors also report concerns that the solvents emitted by ecig may remain on surfaces “and be a source of the contamination of residents,” including changes over time which could make them more carcinogenic, and that the liquids used to refill ecig cartridges could spill and create additional health hazards. They conclude, with regard to concerns about “passive vaping” by bystanders, that, “with regard to a health related evaluation of e-cigarette consumption, the impact of vapor inhalation into the human lung should be a primary concern.”

Many earlier reports also warned about the dangers of chemicals found in ecig vapors which are inhaled by bystanders. For example, the Harvard Medical School warned: “electronic cigarettes deliver an array of other chemicals, including diethylene glycol (a highly toxic substance), various nitrosamines (powerful carcinogens found in tobacco), and at least four other chemicals suspected of being harmful to humans. To be sure, the dose of these compounds is generally smaller than found in ‘real’ cigarette smoke. But it isn’t zero.” http://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/electronic-cigarettes-help-or-hazard-201109223395

Indeed, although the most recent study also found that the concentrations of dangerous chemicals in ecig vapors were lower than those found in tobacco smoke, in some cases the amounts could still be considerable. For example, the concentration of acetone in ecig vapors is almost 40% of that found in smoke from conventional tobacco cigarettes.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration [FDA] has warned the public that ecigs contain various toxic, mutagenic, carcinogenic, and genotoxic chemicals, and that ecig cartridges containing the nicotine and other toxic chemicals, many of which come from China, are subject to “none of the manufacturing controls required for FDA-approved nicotine-delivery products” [like nicotine gum, patches, inhalers, sprays, etc.].

In addition to nicotine and propylene glycol, the FDA reported that it found in samples of e-cigarettes a variety of “toxic and carcinogenic chemicals” including diethylene glycol, “an ingredient used in antifreeze, [which] is toxic to humans”; “certain tobacco-specific nitrosamines which are human carcinogens”; and that “tobacco-specific impurities suspected of being harmful to humans – anabasine, myosmine, and nicotyrine – were detected in a majority of the samples tested.”

The principal components of ecig vapors are nicotine (a dangerous and addictive drug) and propylene glycol (which is used in antifreeze, and may cause respiratory tract irritation), notes public interest law professor John Banzhaf, who brought a law suit which helped establish the FDA’s jurisdiction over nicotine products. Until recently, nicotine was not generally regarded as a chemical capable of causing cancer, but recent research shows that it can be a carcinogen, either by itself or when modified by other chemicals found in the air.

Because of the dangers these many chemicals present to innocent bystanders, more and more jurisdictions are banning the use of ecigs in areas where the use of conventional tobacco cigarettes is prohibited, notes Banzhaf, who was the first to direct attention to the potential health risks to people in the vicinity of ecig users. His scheduled appearance on a major national news program pressured the FDA into releasing a previously-secret report about the dangers of ecigs, and he helped persuade New Jersey and Suffolk County, NY, to ban their use in no-smoking sections.

JOHN F. BANZHAF III, B.S.E.E., J.D., Sc.D.
Professor of Public Interest Law
George Washington University Law School,
FAMRI Dr. William Cahan Distinguished Professor,
Fellow, World Technology Network,
Founder, Action on Smoking and Health (ASH)
2000 H Street, NW, Suite S402
Washington, DC 20052, USA
(202) 994-7229 //  (703) 527-8418
http://banzhaf.net/ https://twitter.com/#!/profbanzhaf

News

Santa Monica moves toward smoking ban in apartments

‎Los Angeles Times – 6 hours ago

Santa Monica smoking ban: The Santa Monica City Council has approved an ordinance that would prohibit smoking for new tenants in …

Local: Santa Monica tightening smoking restrictions‎ San Jose Mercury News

Ineffective action puts people at risk

SCMP Letters 12 July 2012

Allan Dyer (“Punish this aggressive minority”, July 2) provides a concise summary of the woeful gaps in enforcing the protection of both the public and occupational health against passive smoking.

It beggars belief that after more than two decades of providing objective scientific evidence on the serious detriment to health – both that of smokers and non-smokers – from second-hand smoke, we still have business venues able to defy the law and so far little prospect of effective action and compliance.

The combined effects of weak or delayed government action, intense and effective tobacco industry lobbying, opposition from tobacco-friendly legislators, and ambiguous law drafting has ensured that the health of thousands of hospitality workers has been seriously harmed.

In addition to the unresolved problem of lethal outdoor pollution, the new chief executive and director of health must give Hong Kong’s indoor air quality the highest possible priority.

Anthony Hedley, honorary professor, school of public health, University of Hong Kong

State smoking ban doesn’t affect restaurant sales

http://chippewa.com/news/local/state-and-regional/state-smoking-ban-doesn-t-affect-restaurant-sales/article_56632748-c786-11e1-b89f-001a4bcf887a.html?mode=story

By ASSOCIATED PRESS | Posted: Friday, July 6, 2012 11:17 am | (14) Comments

Font Size: Default font size Larger font size

MILWAUKEE — When Wisconsin enacted a workplace smoking ban in in 2010, the state’s hospitality industry worried the move would drive away customers. But two years on, the industry says its sales were largely unaffected.

State tax-collection data show that sales at restaurants and taverns increased 1 percent in 2010 and 2 percent last year, mirroring national trends, according to a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel report.

The ban “wasn’t a boon to our industry, but it doesn’t seem to have hurt our sales,’’ said Pete Hanson, a spokesman for the Wisconsin Restaurant Association.

While sales were up overall for the industry, the subcategory of bars and taverns did see a decrease of about 4 percent in that period, Hanson said. However, he noted that trend has been going on for a number of years and couldn’t necessarily be attributed to the smoking ban.

The law, which bans smoking in public places and workplaces, took effect two years ago Thursday. It prohibits smoking in a wide range of locations, including state or local government buildings, bars, restaurants, stores, hotels, day care centers, and hospitals.

Opponents, especially those in the tavern industry, criticized the ban as an unnecessary intrusion that would deter customers who want to smoke.

Supporters countered that the law would protect the health of both customers and employees, such as waitresses, who would otherwise be exposed to secondhand smoke. They also predicted the ban would attract business from asthmatics and other nonsmokers who previously avoided smoky establishments.

Some taverns compromised by adding open-air shelters when customers can smoke. Kathy Martin, the owner of Dockside Pub and Grille in Beaver Dam, said that solution worked for her but that not every business has the space.

Legally, the enclosed areas where smoking is prohibited are defined as spaces with a roof and at least three “substantial walls.’’ There has been no agreement on what constitutes a substantial wall.

An official with the Tavern League of Wisconsin wonders whether the ban might have contributed to some bars going out of business. Pete Madland, the group’s executive director, said its membership is down over the last two years. The recession was a big reason, he said, but the smoking ban was a “contributing factor.’’

Martin, who is also the president of the Dodge County Tavern League, agreed. Despite adding a new smoking area, business was down 30 percent, she said.

“People were used to coming in, sitting at the bar, and having a drink and a cigarette,’’ Martin said, but now “people don’t stay.’’

Maureen Busalacchi, the executive director of SmokeFree Wisconsin, said it’s nearly impossible to quantify why customers stop coming in, especially when economic times are tough.

When the Legislature is back in session next year, Martin said the Tavern League hopes to pursue legislation that would allow indoor smoking areas that are closed off from the rest of the bar, a solution she says would please both smokers and nonsmokers.

But Busalacchi said SmokeFree Wisconsin would fight any legislation of that nature.

“You start messing around with partially enclosed or that kind of thing, and you end up contaminating all of the air,’’ she said.

.

Copyright 2012 Chippewa.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Read more: http://chippewa.com/news/local/state-and-regional/state-smoking-ban-doesn-t-affect-restaurant-sales/article_56632748-c786-11e1-b89f-001a4bcf887a.html?mode=story#ixzz1zzDt8bBq

Police turn blind eye to bar smokers

Clear the Air says:

This is the job of the Tobacco Control Office who carry the Fixed Penalty Notices; the police will only act in cases of breach of the peace or during a liquor licence check.

Sadly the last Tsang administration allocated only 106 Tobacco Control officers to operate in two shifts per day for the whole of HKI, Kowloon, NT and Islands to ’control’ 680,000 smokers and 36 million Mainland visitors where the males have a smoking rate of 63% . From the 106 officers, take away leave days , holidays and sickness and the result is – they cannot patrol, hence no prevention. Meanwhile there is no legal onus on bar licensees to enforce the law as there is overseas – in fact many bar owners encourage smoking so as to steal business from other bars and hotels that rightly prevent smoking and protect their staff and customers.

TCO can only operate on complaints, several days later which is less than ideal. There is no prevention capability. The number of tickets issued in bars is minimal, the majority being in game centres and outside the Hunghom railway station.

Macau has 77 TCO’s including auxiliaries for 514,000 population whilst HKG has only 106 TCO’s for 7.2 million and the smokers amongst 40 million tourists ( all of the tourists walk free from a ticket given the payment time allowed).

Making premises’ managers legally responsible for enforcing the law within the whole area of their licensed premises (or lose their licence to operate) would add perhaps 15,000 additional enforcement individuals to the Tobacco Control Office.  These laws are made to protect workers in the workplace and are being openly flouted with little chance of being caught.

SCMP Letters Jul 05, 2012

Police turn blind eye to bar smokers

My son is visiting Hong Kong from Colombia where he normally lives.

He was born here and still has a number of friends living in the city. On Saturday night, he went with some of those friends to Lan Kwai Fong, spending the evening in a few bars.

He has told me that he may not go there again because of the large number of people smoking in the bars.

It is an obnoxious habit, which research shows shortens people’s lives.

It also often affects in a negative manner the health of those who are unfortunate enough to be close to those smoking, especially bar staff, and it is against the law to smoke in bars and restaurants in Hong Kong.

My son was astonished and not a little upset to find out that the law is being flouted so openly.

In Colombia, a country which has a negative reputation regarding law and order, there is a similar law and it is, apparently, strictly adhered to. In Hong Kong, the police appear to have little interest in enforcing it.

If this is the case, and the evidence appears to concur with this opinion, then the police need to be brought to task.

May I suggest that people who are concerned about this issue contact the Office of the Ombudsman ( 2882-8149) to complain about the police wasting taxpayers’ money through not enforcing the relevant law?

Chris Stubbs, Discovery Bay

SCMP letter

SCMP Letters 02 July 2012

Punish this aggressive minority

Is P. A. Crush suggesting that we should be lenient on offenders if they become abusive and violent (“It would not be feasible to make bar owners responsible for illegal smokers”, June 27)?

In my letter that Mr Crush objects to (“Smoking bans are not enforced”, June 20), I did particularly mention that bar owners should be made responsible for illegal smoking on their premises, but I said the same for management companies.

I did not only pick on small-bar owners, but mentioned bars as a location where a lot of illegal smoking occurs. Yes, directors of major property companies should be made responsible for the illegal smoking which goes on in the toilets of their malls and office blocks.

I suggest that they immediately start installing smoke detectors linked to showerheads above each toilet cubicle, thus neatly combining extinguishing the cigarette with a mild punishment of the offender.

As for employees, they should be provided with clear guidelines: ask the offender to stop, then call the police and identify the offender when they arrive.

The anti-smoking law was passed because of the danger to people’s health. Why are we letting an aggressive minority of smokers continue to inflict this harm?

Allan Dyer, Wong Chuk Hang

Smoking in Private Vehicles Bill 2010-12

http://services.parliament.uk/bills/2010-11/smokinginprivatevehicles.html

The Himalayan Times : Smoking in public to cost up to one lakh – Detail News : Nepal News Portal

http://www.thehimalayantimes.com/fullNews.php?headline=Smoking+in+public+
to+cost+up+to+one+lakh&NewsID=337865

HIMALAYAN NEWS SERVICE

KATHMANDU: The Metropolitan Police Range Hanumandhoka in coordination
with the Kathmandu District Administration Office (KDAO) is slapping on
people smoking in public places penalty ranging from Rs 100 to Rs 1 lakh.

DSP Dhiraj Pratap Singh, spokesperson for the range, informed they have
not fined anyone for smoking in public areas till date.

Police have kept a record of smokers arrested on the first and the second
day of the crackdown. Singh said they are also taking classes to educate
people on the harmful effects of the tobacco.

Police release the offenders three hours after their attention. Singh
said they will not spare repeat offenders and they will have to pay steep
fines.

Since Wednesday, the day the crackdown began, police have arrested 247
for the smoking offence. The anti-smoking law defines government offices,
corporations, educational institutions, libraries, airports, public
vehicles, orphanages, childcare centres, cinema halls, elderly homes,
cultural centres, children’s parks, hotels, restaurants, resorts,
hostels, department stores, religious sites and industries as public
places, prohibiting the sale and distribution of tobacco-related products
in these areas. The Anti-Tobacco Act-2010, which the Parliament passed in
April 2011 and took effect from August 2011, has it that individuals and
firms, which breach the law, will have to pay a fine of Rs 100 to 100,000
depending on the nature of violations. The Act has also made mandatory to
allocate 75 per cent of the space on cigarette packs or wrappers for
pictorial health warning.

Komal Acharya, member-secretary of the policy framework committee on
anti-tobacco act, said they are working in close coordination with KDAO
and the metropolitan police for effective implementation of the act.

He said the police crackdown on smoking in public places is in keeping
with the act.

Every year 16,000 people die because of tobacco consumption in Nepal, 90
per cent of them from lung cancer, according to records at hospitals.
Twenty-nine per cent smokers are females and 49 per cent are male. There
are 38 tobacco factories in the country and four per cent of the total
income goes on tobacco consumption.

According to the Nepal Demographic Health Survey 2011, 52 per cent male
and 13.3 per cent female (15-49) use tobacco.

Landlord ordered to pay £500 as she and customers found smoking

http://www.theboltonnews.co.uk/news/9791851.print/

HKG needs to place the legal onus on licensees to prevent smoking in their premises -or nothing will change and licensees will continue to encourage smokers to snatch business from law abiders

1:15pm Saturday 30th June 2012

A LANDLADY has been ordered to pay almost £500 after she and several drinkers at her pub were caught smoking.

Sara Anne Moorcroft, who is in charge of the Cross Guns in Deane Road, Deane, had a cigarette in her hand when police and licensing officers raided the pub.

Several customers were also smoking in the lounge area when the raid happened just after 2am on February 18.

Now Moorcroft, aged 45, has been fined and ordered to pay legal costs, leaving her with a bill for £495.

Her conviction comes almost five years to the day after smoking was banned in all workplaces across the country.

While the council hailed the result of her court case yesterday, pro-smoking lobbyists condemned the move as “draconian”. Moorcroft appeared at Bolton Magistrates Court on Wednesday, where she admitted failing to prevent smoking in a smoke-free premises.

Every customer who was caught smoking in the pub was also given a £50 fine.

Moorcroft, who lives at the pub and is the designated premises supervisor and licence holder, declined to comment when The Bolton News contacted her.

However, she was backed by pub landlord Nick Hogan, who was jailed for letting customers smoke at the Swan Inn, in Churchgate, Bolton.

Mr Hogan, who now runs the Swan With Two Necks pub in Chorley, said: “Everything I predicted in 2007 has come true. The loss of pubs has been phenomenal. Bolton town centre is no longer the vibrant place it used to be.

“To be fining people operating their own businesses, with the consent of their customers, is draconian. This woman is probably trying to make her business work and has bills to pay. Tobacco is still a legal product.”

Mr Hogan was fined by Bolton magistrates after he was found guilty of breaching the smoking ban in January, 2008, for allowing customers to smoke in his pub. He was jailed in 2010 for failing to pay those fines, only to be released when an internet campaign raised more than £10,000. Simon Clark, director of smokers’ lobbying group Forest, said: “These are consenting adults and a pub is a private property.”

Since the smoking ban was introduced on July 1, 2007, any place of work which is open to the public and enclosed must be smokefree.

Cllr Nick Peel said: “There are still some business owners who continue to disregard the Act. In this case, the business owner was not only allowing smoking, but was caught in the act of smoking herself and we are pleased with the substantial fine awarded.”

© Copyright 2001-2012 Newsquest Media Group

http://www.theboltonnews.co.uk

http://www.theboltonnews.co.uk/trade_directory/