Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Legislative smoking bans for reducing harms from secondhand smoke exposure, smoking prevalence and tobacco consumption

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD005992.pub3/abstract

Abstract

Background

Smoking bans have been implemented in a variety of settings, as well as being part of policy in many jurisdictions to protect the public and employees from the harmful effects of secondhand smoke (SHS). They also offer the potential to influence social norms and the smoking behaviour of those populations they affect. Since the first version of this review in 2010, more countries have introduced national smoking legislation banning indoor smoking.

Objectives

To assess the effects of legislative smoking bans on (1) morbidity and mortality from exposure to secondhand smoke, and (2) smoking prevalence and tobacco consumption.

Search methods

We searched the Cochrane Tobacco Addiction Group Specialised Register, MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, CINAHL and reference lists of included studies. We also checked websites of various organisations. Date of most recent search; February 2015.

Selection criteria

We considered studies that reported legislative smoking bans affecting populations. The minimum standard was having an indoor smoking ban explicitly in the study and a minimum of six months follow-up for measures of smoking behaviour. Our search included a broad range of research designs including: randomized controlled trials, quasi-experimental studies (i.e. non-randomized controlled studies), controlled before-and-after studies, interrupted time series as defined by the Cochrane Effective Practice and Organisation of Care Group, and uncontrolled pre- and post-ban data.

Data collection and analysis

One author extracted characteristics and content of the interventions, participants, outcomes and methods of the included studies and a second author checked the details. We extracted health and smoking behaviour outcomes. We did not attempt a meta-analysis due to the heterogeneity in design and content of the studies included. We evaluated the studies using qualitative narrative synthesis.

Main results

There are 77 studies included in this updated review. We retained 12 studies from the original review and identified 65 new studies. Evidence from 21 countries is provided in this update, an increase of eight countries from the original review. The nature of the intervention precludes randomized controlled trials. Thirty-six studies used an interrupted time series study design, 23 studies use a controlled before-and-after design and 18 studies are before-and-after studies with no control group; six of these studies use a cohort design. Seventy-two studies reported health outcomes, including cardiovascular (44), respiratory (21), and perinatal outcomes (7). Eleven studies reported national mortality rates for smoking-related diseases. A number of the studies report multiple health outcomes. There is consistent evidence of a positive impact of national smoking bans on improving cardiovascular health outcomes, and reducing mortality for associated smoking-related illnesses. Effects on respiratory and perinatal health were less consistent. We found 24 studies evaluating the impact of national smoke-free legislation on smoking behaviour. Evidence of an impact of legislative bans on smoking prevalence and tobacco consumption is inconsistent, with some studies not detecting additional long-term change in existing trends in prevalence.

Authors’ conclusions

Since the first version of this review was published, the current evidence provides more robust support for the previous conclusions that the introduction of a legislative smoking ban does lead to improved health outcomes through reduction in SHS for countries and their populations. The clearest evidence is observed in reduced admissions for acute coronary syndrome. There is evidence of reduced mortality from smoking-related illnesses at a national level. There is inconsistent evidence of an impact on respiratory and perinatal health outcomes, and on smoking prevalence and tobacco consumption.

Plain language summary

Does legislation to ban smoking reduce exposure to secondhand smoke and smoking behaviour?

Since the first national legislation banning indoor smoking in all public places was introduced in 2004, there has been an increase in the number of countries, states and regions adopting similar smoke-free legislation banning smoking in public places and work places since this review was first published. The main reason is to protect nonsmokers from the harmful health effects of exposure to secondhand smoke. Another reason is to provide a supportive environment for people who want to quit smoking.

Study characteristics

We searched for studies that investigated the effect of introducing a ban on any measures of health, or on smoking behaviour (up to February 2015). Since the previous version of this review had shown clear evidence that introducing legislation to ban smoking in public places does reduce exposure to secondhand smoke (SHS) in those places, we did not include studies that only reported exposure to SHS. We included 77 studies from 21 countries in this updated review. Studies of health outcomes typically used data from hospitals to look for changes in rates of admissions, discharges or deaths. Most studies looked at illnesses related to the cardiovascular system (heart or blood vessels), such as heart attacks and strokes. Studies also looked at effects on respiratory health, including chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (e.g. bronchitis), asthma and lung function. Seven studies looked at the health of newborn children. Eleven studies reported death rates. The best-quality studies collected data at multiple time points before and after the introduction of a ban in order to adjust for existing time trends. Some studies could compare events rates in areas with and without bans, or where bans were introduced at different times.

Key results

There is evidence that countries and their populations benefit from improved health after introducing smoking bans, importantly to do with the heart and blood vessels. We found evidence of reduced deaths. The impact of bans on respiratory health, on the health of newborn children, and on reducing the number of smokers and their cigarette use is not as clear, with some studies not detecting any reduction.

Quality of the evidence

Legislative bans have not been evaluated by randomized trials, and the quality of the evidence from the types of studies contributing to this review is lower. Changes in health outcomes could be due to other things, such as change in healthcare practices. However, many of the studies used methods of analysis that could control for underlying trends, and increase our confidence that any changes are caused by the introduction of bans.

National (enforced) smoking bans improve health outcomes, Cochrane review shows

National smoking bans do reduce the harms of passive smoking, specifically cardiovascular disease, an updated systematic review from the Cochrane Library has found.1

Since the first version of this review in 2010, more countries have introduced national legislation to ban indoor smoking. The authors said that the updated review provided the most robust evidence yet that smoking bans have led to improved health outcomes.

A team of researchers based in Ireland included 77 studies, representing 21 countries, that investigated the effect of introducing a smoking ban on any measures of health or on smoking behaviour. They retained 12 studies from the original review and identified 65 new studies. Health outcomes were reported in 72 studies, of which 44 specifically assessed cardiovascular disease, 21 assessed respiratory disease, and seven assessed perinatal outcomes.

The review found consistent evidence of a positive effect from national smoking bans on improving cardiovascular health outcomes and reducing mortality from associated smoking related illnesses.

The clearest evidence it found was in reduced admissions for acute coronary syndrome. For example, one study in Ireland found a 12% reduction in admissions for acute coronary syndrome in the first year after the smoking ban, and another Irish study found an 18% reduction.

The greatest reductions in admissions for heart disease after smoking bans were identified in populations of non-smokers, the researchers found. Overall, they said that the evidence was of moderate quality in relation to cardiovascular disease.

But the effects of smoking bans on respiratory and perinatal health were found to be less consistent. Six of the 11 studies reported considerable reductions in admissions for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and seven of 12 reported considerable reductions in hospitalisations for asthma. In the seven studies looking at perinatal health the data produced conflicting results, and the study authors said that more research was needed in this area.

The review found 24 studies evaluating the effect of national smoke-free legislation on smoking behaviour. Evidence of an effect from legislative bans on smoking prevalence and tobacco consumption was found to be inconsistent, as some studies did not detect any additional change in existing prevalence trends.

Cecily Kelleher, a review author based at University College Dublin, said, “The current evidence provides more robust support for the previous conclusions that the introduction of national legislative smoking bans does lead to improved health outcomes through a reduction in secondhand smoke exposure for countries and their populations.

“We now need research on the continued longer term impact of smoking bans on the health outcomes of specific sub-groups of the population, such as young children [and] disadvantaged and minority groups.”

BMJ 2016; 352 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i701 (Published 04 February 2016) Cite this as: BMJ 2016;352:i701

Italy cracks down on smokers as tough law takes effect

Health officials and consumer groups estimate that smoking causes some 80,000 deaths a year in Italy.

http://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-italy-smoking-idUSKCN0VB1I3

Tough anti-smoking laws came into effect in Italy on Tuesday, imposing large fines for several offences and making it illegal to smoke in a car carrying children or pregnant women.

The laws require cigarette packs to carry stark pictures of people who suffered from the effects of smoking, including one of a woman coughing up blood and another of a man who died of a heart attack being zipped up in a body bag.

Those caught smoking in cars with children or pregnant women risk fines of up to 500 euros ($546). Smoking will also be prohibited outdoors near schools and hospitals. Tobacconists caught selling cigarettes to minors risk fines of up to 3,000 euros or losing their license.

Throwing cigarette butts on the pavement could cost an offender up to 300 euros.

The laws were passed in 2015 in response to an EU directive requiring member states to toughen smoking laws. Health officials and consumer groups estimate that smoking causes some 80,000 deaths a year in Italy.

Extension of Hong Kong no-smoking areas cut hospital admissions among children by almost half, HKU study finds

Doctor calls for areas close to schools, playgrounds and childcare centres to be made smoke-free

The extension of no-smoking areas has been found to reduce by almost half the number of children admitted to hospital with more severe forms of respiratory infection, a University of Hong Kong study found.

HKU researchers looked into 75,870 hospital admission cases between 2004 and 2012 involving patients aged 18 or younger suffering from lower respiratory tract infections. The number of cases dropped 47.4 per cent in the first year after no-smoking regulations were extended to indoor area of all restaurants, workplaces and public places in 2007.

A sustained reduction of 13.9 per cent was observed in the following five years – meaning an estimated 13,635 fewer admissions in the six years after the new regulations were implemented.

Lower respiratory infections usually refer to more serious forms of illness, including pneumonia, acute bronchitis and excess fluid in the lungs. Acute respiratory infection is a leading cause of death among children aged under five around the world, killing 1.6 million every year.

The effect was more marked among school-age children aged between six and 18, who are believed to spend more time away from home and stand a higher chance of breathing in second-hand smoke compared to preschool children.

Paediatrics professor Lau Yu-lung, who co-authored the study, said smoke can harm lung tissue.

“There are more than 5,000 types of harmful substances in tobacco. When one inhales, lung tissue becomes inflamed easily and immunity is weakened,” said Lau. Some 70 chemicals found in tobacco are carcinogenic.

The study took outdoor air pollution into account and found higher levels of respirable suspended particulates and ozone also led to more admission cases, particularly among preschool children

Dr Lee So-lun, who also worked on the study, said younger children tended to be more vulnerable to air pollution.

“They have weaker immunity and a smaller trachea. The impact of cold is greater than for school-age children,” said Lee.

The researchers acknowledged that other factors including flu epidemics and weather could have affected the results. However, they admitted their study had limitations as they did not assess how legislation was enforced and the time that children spent indoors and outdoors.

No-smoking areas will be further extended to eight bus interchanges on March 31. But Lau said this was not enough as areas close to schools, playgrounds and childcare centres should also be included.

Professor Lam Tai-hing, the university’s chair professor of community medicine who did not take part in the study, said quitting cigarettes was still the best way to reduce health problems.
________________________________________
Source URL: http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/1906295/extension-hong-kong-no-smoking-areas-cut-hospital

Turkmenistan becomes the first country to effectively ban tobacco products

http://www.albawaba.com/loop/turkmenistan-becomes-he-first-country-effectively-ban-tobacco-products-793994

The president of Turkmenistan has upped the ante on anti-smoking laws this week by banning the sale of all tobacco products in the country.

Shops in the country can apparently now face fines to the tune of $1,700 if caught selling cigarettes. Of course, this isn’t exactly stopping things in their tracks—already, the sale of cigarettes on the black market has risen to over $11 a pack, according to the news site Chrono-TM, who reports on affairs under the country’s repressive regime from outside.

Meanwhile, in-country media is under lockdown. Reporters Without Borders ranked Turkmenistan the third worst place for press freedom in the world, preceded only by North Korea and Eritrea. The country’s leader, Gurbanguly erdymukhamedow, appears to be taking those controls a step further this week with the smoking bans.

This isn’t the first time the subject of smoking has come up in the country—Berdymukhamedow is frequently seen in PR shoots riding a bicycle or doing similar healthy activities and has led an aggressive anti-smoking campaign country-wide. At the beginning of January, he removed Atadurd Odmanov, the head of the State Service for Protecting the Security of a Healthy Society, from his post as Colonel for failing to effectively coax Turkmenistan’s smokers to stub out.

Last July, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared Turkmenistan had the lowest rate of smokers in the world, with only 8 percent of the population recorded as tobacco users. Yet, with such restrictive media laws inside the country, we’re a little skeptical about those figures.

Norway under pressure to ban sale of tobacco to adults

http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/norway-under-pressure-to-ban-sale-of-tobacco-to-adults-a6795971.html

Medics say access to tobacco is ‘not a basic human right’

Norway’s biggest medical organisation wants to ban the sale of cigarettes to adults.

In a drive towards a smoke-free society by 2035, the Norwegian Medical Association (NMA) is pressing the government to back its proposal for a ban on tobacco sales to citizens born after the year 2000.

Marit Hermansen, the president of the NMA, told Norwegian newspaper Aftenposten that access to cigarettes was not a basic human right.

“We have long had the policy of phasing out smoking by 2035. This is a measure to achieve this goal. We want a tobacco-free generation,” she said, according to The Local.

“It shouldn’t be forbidden to smoke, but we want young people to not get started with tobacco.”

They hope the proposed legislation will mean future generations are unable to buy tobacco in Norway when they reach 18 years old, which is the current age limit. Given the choice of 2000, the law would technically come in to until 2018.

“The [health] minister has said that the main objective is to hinder young people from beginning to smoke,” Ms Hermansen told Aftenposten.

“That means that when the new generations come of age, they won’t be able to buy tobacco in Norway.”

The emphasis will be on denying access to the substances, rather than criminalising use, she added according to The Nordic Page.

In 2013, about 32 per cent of the Norwegian population were smokers – a steady decline from 36 per cent in 2008.

Among young people, seven per cent had reported that they smoked daily, the Nordic Page reported.

Yet despite the NMA’s hopes, health spokespeople for the Conservative, Labour, Centre and Christian Democrats parties in the country told Aftenposten the idea was not currently feasible.

In the UK, meanwhile, eight percent of 15-year-olds smoked regularly in 2014 – a significant decline compared to the 20 percent who were smoking eight years earlier.

Russian upper house approves bill banning snus

http://www.rapsinews.com/legislation_news/20151225/275119865.html

MOSCOW, December 25 (RAPSI) – The Federation Council, Russia’s upper house of parliament, on Friday approved a bill that prohibits the retail and wholesale trade of sucking tobacco (snus), RIA Novosti reports.

The bill drafted by the State Council of Tatarstan would introduce fines of between 2,000 and 4,000 rubles ($29-$58) for individuals, 7,000 to 12,000 rubles ($101-$173) for officials, and 40,000 to 60,000 rubles ($575-$863) for legal entities.

The regional authorities would have the right to introduce additional restrictions on trade in smokeless tobacco products, including a ban on retail sales.

The bill was drafted to further reduce smoking and to prevent the proliferation of new smokeless tobacco products in Russia.

Snus is a form of smokeless tobacco product. It is placed under the upper lip for extended periods. Snus is not fermented and contains no added sugar, but tobacco content in one portion of snus is approximately five times greater than in a cigarette.

The production and sale of smokeless tobacco in the EU was prohibited in 2001. India prohibited the sale of smokeless tobacco in 2003, although using smokeless tobacco is a longtime tradition. In 2004, serious restrictions were placed on the sale and use of naswar (a moist, powdered tobacco snuff similar to dipping tobacco or snus) in Turkmenistan. In January 2010, the sale of naswar, snus and other chewing products that include tobacco, lime or other non-tobacco products was prohibited in Belarus.

Heavy crackdown needed on smoking in public places

http://www.gulf-times.com/opinion/189/details/467217/heavy-crackdown-needed-on-smoking-in-public-places

Though Qatar has a law banning smoking in public places, it is unfortunate that the implementation part is lacking, Dr Ahmed Mohamed al-Mulla, director of Anti-Smoking Clinic, Hamad Medical Corporation, had pointed out to Gulf Times earlier this year. We are approaching the end of the year and sadly nothing has changed in this regard.

“The Supreme Council of Health has deputed several officers to check the practice. But at the ground level, not much action is taking place. There must be a greater enforcement of the law,” the senior Qatari official had urged. It seems the powers that be are yet to listen to his fervent plea.

On the contrary, smoking in public places has gone up of late. Smokers are puffing away, as if with a vengeance, polluting the air and endangering the lives of non-smokers, who are helpless victims of a crime against good health and wellness.

It is very difficult for non-smokers to visit many public places in Qatar these days. Even a family-friendly recreation location such as the picturesque Museum of Islamic Art Park in Doha reeks of tobacco smoke. Entrances of all popular malls in the country are clouded with tobacco smoke as smokers crowd around and smoke.

Though the managements of malls generally succeed in enforcing the ban on smoking inside their premises, it is unfortunate that some individuals continue to violate the law with impunity, smoking in some coffee shops, sitting right under the ‘No Smoking’ signs. This is nothing but arrogance coupled with ignorance. The staff members at such outlets plead helplessness as the persons who break the law against smoking in public places happen to be “very influential.”

According to facts from the World Health Organisation, tobacco kills up to half of its users. Around 6mn people die each year because of tobacco use. More than 5mn of those deaths are the result of direct tobacco use while more than 600,000 are the result of non-smokers being exposed to second-hand smoke, which fills restaurants, offices or other enclosed spaces when people burn tobacco products such as cigarettes, bidis and water-pipes. There are more than 4,000 chemicals in tobacco smoke, of which at least 250 are known to be harmful and more than 50 are known to cause cancer.

There is no safe level of exposure to second-hand tobacco smoke. In adults, second-hand smoke causes serious cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, including coronary heart disease and lung cancer. In infants, it causes sudden death. In pregnant women, it causes low birth weight.

Almost half of children regularly breathe air polluted by tobacco smoke in public places. In 2004, children accounted for 28% of the deaths attributable to second-hand smoke.

A decision by Katara, the Cultural Village Foundation, earlier this year banning shisha smoking at restaurants at its premises, ought to be emulated elsewhere in Qatar. In an interview with Gulf Times, Dr al-Mulla had called for shifting shisha outlets out of the Doha city limits.

Also needed is a heavy crackdown on all other forms of smoking in public places. Every person should be able to breathe tobacco-smoke-free air. When will Qatar residents be able to breathe clean air? The ball is in the court of the authorities concerned.

Law Society welcomes ban on smoking in cars with children

https://www.lawscot.org.uk/news/2015/12/law-society-welcomes-ban-on-smoking-in-cars-with-children/

Smoking in cars where children are present will now be a criminal offence, after the legislation was passed by the Scottish Parliament today, 17 December.

The Smoking Prohibition (Children in Motor Vehicles) (Scotland) Bill was debated this afternoon at stage 3 by MSPs. When the legislation comes into force, it will be a criminal offence to smoke in a car where a child is present. An amendment to the bill tabled by Jackson Carlaw MSP proposed a review of the legislation after 5 years.

Alison Britton, convener of the Law Society of Scotland’s health and medical law committee said:

“The passing of this bill is great news for the health and wellbeing of children, the harmful effects of tobacco and smoking are undisputed, as well as the effects of second hand smoke. We had hoped that the legislation be extended to expressly prohibit the use of e-cigarettes as well as conventional cigarettes, especially in relation to young people, so it is disappointing to see this hasn’t been included.

“We also proposed a review of the legislation within five years to ascertain how well it was working, and we are disappointed that MSPs voted against such a review. Taking into account there will undoubtedly be an updating of research, not only into the effects of e-cigarettes, but the harmful effects of tobacco in general in the next few years, this would have potentially given us the opportunity to ensure that the legislation remained fit for purpose.”

Why smoking bans may have advantage over higher tobacco taxes

http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2015-12/osu-wsb121415.php

A first look at how city-level policies impact individual smokers

COLUMBUS, Ohio – If governments want to discourage smoking among young people, both high taxes and smoking bans do the job – but bans may have one key advantage.

A first-of-its-kind national study found that bans worked best at limiting smoking among more casual users: Those who smoked less than a pack a day. Heavy taxes worked best with those who smoked more than a pack a day.

“Both taxes and bans have their place. But bans might stop casual smokers from becoming heavy tobacco users,” said Mike Vuolo, lead author of the study and assistant professor of sociology at The Ohio State University.

“If you think of casual smoking as the beginning of the path to addiction, then bans might be the way to go.”

The study is the first to look at how city-level government policies – both taxes and bans – affected actual smokers.

“We’re not just looking at how state policies affect smoking rates in general. We were able to determine how individual smokers reacted to changes in government policies at the city level,” Vuolo said.

“We were never able to get to that level of detail before.”

Another key finding of the study was that combining smoking bans with high taxes didn’t reduce overall smoking rates in a city more than either of the policies by itself.

The study was published online Dec. 17, 2015 in the American Journal of Public Health. Vuolo conducted the study with Brian Kelly and Joy Kadowaki of Purdue University.

Data on smokers came from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997. This study included 4,341 people from 487 cities who were interviewed every year from 2004 to 2011. All participants were between the age of 19 and 31 during the study. The NLSY97 is conducted by Ohio State’s Center for Human Resource Research for the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics

Data on city-level smoking bans and tax rates came from the Americans for Nonsmokers’ Rights Foundation (ANRF) tobacco policy database.

The database told the researchers which participants lived in cities where there was a comprehensive smoking ban, which means that workplaces, bars and restaurants are 100 percent tobacco free with no indoor exceptions.

The database also includes information on the total state and local tobacco excise taxes for cigarette packs sold in each city.

The researchers found big changes in both bans and taxes from 2004 to 2011. The percentage living in a city with a comprehensive ban increased from 14.9 percent to 58.7 percent during that time, while average taxes increased from 81 cents to $1.65 per pack.

The cities with the highest rates of smoking were those that had no smoking bans and low or no taxes on cigarettes, Vuolo said.

Results showed that those residing in cities with bans were 21 percent less likely to currently smoke at all when compared to those who lived in cities without bans. But taxes did not have a significant effect on casual smokers.

“There’s a lot of evidence that casual, social smokers are influenced by their environment. If they can’t smoke inside with their friends at a restaurant or bar, they may choose not to smoke at all,” Vuolo said.

By contrast, those who smoked more than a pack a day were primarily deterred, not by the bans, but by the economic costs – in other words, higher taxes.

The fact that combining high taxes with smoking bans didn’t have an additional impact on smoking rates means that policymakers have several effective options for tobacco control, Vuolo said.

“They are both effective in different ways. Smoking bans might be more effective in preventing new smokers, but it definitely pays to do something,” he said.

“The worst case is not having bans or taxes.”