Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Smoking Ban

Benefits of smoking bans on preterm and early-term births

A natural experimental design in Switzerland

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2016/04/26/tobaccocontrol-2015-052739.short?g=w_tobaccocontrol_ahead_tab

Abstract

Background

Birth outcomes are relevant for future children’s heath. Capitalising on a natural experimental design in Switzerland, we evaluated how regional smoking bans introduced at different time points affected birth outcomes, including preterm and early-term births.

Methodology

We used birth registry data of all singleton neonates born in Switzerland (2007–2012). We developed canton-specific interrupted time-series followed by random meta-analysis to evaluate the benefits of smoking bans on preterm (<37 gestational weeks) and early-term (37–38 gestational weeks) births. Heterogeneity across type of ban and contextual characteristics was explored through metaregression. A time-to-event approach was used for evaluating duration of pregnancy under the smoking bans and effects, taking into account individual maternal factors.

Results

We observed a decrease in the risk of preterm birth of 3.6% (95% CI, −9.3% to 2.5%), and early-term birth of 5.0% (95% CI −7.5% to −2.5%). Results showed a clear dose–response relationship. Greater risk reductions were obtained for preterm births in areas with more comprehensive bans (−6.8%; 95% CI −12.1% to 0.1%), and for pregnancies with the longest gestational time under smoking bans (HR, 0.991; 95% CI 0.984 to 0.997 per 10% increase in duration). Benefits were unequal across outcomes and characteristics of cantons and mothers.

Conclusion

Smoking bans resulted in improved birth outcomes in Switzerland with cantons that adopted more comprehensive smoking bans achieving greater benefits. Early-term births constitute a previously ignored though important group.

Govt should ensure smoking ban is being properly implemented

http://www.chinadailyasia.com/opinion/2016-04/21/content_15420749.html

Over recent years, great strides have been made in the fight to limit smoking in public places in Hong Kong. This fight is being conducted to reduce the opportunities for smokers to light up, and thereby perhaps save their lives from constantly indulging their deadly addiction. It is also conducted to protect those people located nearby, who may not smoke, from the harmful — indeed from the life-threatening — effects of cigarette smoke reaching them from others.

It is heartening to note from recent reports that the incidence of smoking is generally being reduced — meaning that there are apparently somewhat fewer smokers in Hong Kong than there were a decade or more ago. That reduction, of course, must include the sad statistic of the many regular smokers who have since died from serious illnesses caused by their regular tobacco intake.

There is little to feel complacent about however, as many Hong Kong people continue to damage their own health and that of others near them, by lighting up. An especially lamentable sight is that of youngsters, even schoolchildren, taking up the deadly addiction, which will more than likely kill them before they die from national causes.

The advent of e-cigarettes has provided an alternative to smoking the more dangerous real tobacco products. The jury is still out, however, on whether or not e-cigarettes themselves present a danger to health. They are a comparatively new invention, so it is too early to be able to judge what a lifetime’s intake of e-cigarette smoke might or might not do to harm a person’s lungs and health. Let’s remember that it took many years of research before a confirmed link was established between smoking tobacco in cigarettes and severe damage to a smoker’s health. These days, everyone knows that smoking can kill you; yet many people continue to smoke and others take up the habit — which soon leads to a lifetime’s nicotine addiction.

It is now against the law for people to smoke inside a bar, restaurant or coffee shop in Hong Kong. However, you may commonly see customers sitting near the open frontage of such places, puffing away. Some are located actually within the establishment as they do so, meaning they are seated inside the place. The noxious smoke they emit thus blows in and poisons those customers seated within, as well as polluting the air just outside the place.

Others are technically outside, but positioned so near the place as to make little difference. They are facilitated in doing so by the establishment providing tables and ash trays just outside their open frontages. The prohibition needs to be extended, to outlaw smoking within five meters of a place’s entrance or frontage. Large and clear NO SMOKING signs should be required to be placed near the entrances of all bars and restaurants — preferably showing graphic pictures of diseased lungs and the other horrors that smoking causes.

Some others brazenly indulge their smoking habit well inside the place and, to their shame, some bars and other establishments provide ashtrays on every internal table, to facilitate (and really to encourage) breaking the law by having their customers smoke inside the place. The law needs to be strengthened by prescribing hefty fines for both the smoker and the establishment’s owner for such infringements. Presently, too few prosecutions are initiated against smokers and none against owners.

It is said that the price of freedom is constant vigilance. Similarly, the eradication of smoking inside Hong Kong’s bars and restaurants will happen only if firmer steps are taken to enforce the laws prohibiting it. That means that there need to be more governmental staff assigned as Tobacco Control Office inspectors; many more spot-checks need to be conducted on bars and restaurants; no verbal warnings should be given. Instead each infringement should be prosecuted, according to the law. Only a zero-tolerance approach, prosecuting every offender who so breaks the law and landing him with a hefty fine — and that includes the place’s owner — would have the desired deterrent effect.

For those frequent offenders among bar and restaurant owners, consideration should be made to rescinding their license to operate. That danger to their business would turn the tide, obliging them to do everything possible to stop people smoking on their premises, rather than — as now — some of them turning a blind eye to, or even encouraging, smoking on their premises.

Only through uncompromising law enforcement can smoking inside (or too near) a bar or restaurant really be brought to an end.

The writer is a seasoned Hong Kong commentator, who has lost close family members to the deadly effects of cigarette smoking.

Shanghai considers city-wide ban on smoking in public areas

http://english.cctv.com/2016/04/09/VIDEIm13t9lRKSJlgPxL7x2a160409.shtml

Shanghai has submitted a draft amendment on a city-wide ban on smoking to the legislative body. It follows the growing trend of anti-smoking rules across China. Officials are seeking input from various government agencies.

Currently in Shanghai, there are 13 types of public areas where smoking is banned. If the amendment bill is passed, the new legislation will be a complete ban which applies to all public venues. Shanghai then will be third city in China after Shenzhen and Beijing which have enacted a city-wide ban on smoking.

It’s not clear yet if these smoking bans are actually stopping smokers from lighting up.The figures from the medical side is appalling. More than 1 million people in China die every year in tobacco related illnesses.

About 740 million are routinely exposed to secondhand smoke, contributing to another 100,000 deaths annually. Local health authorities conducted a survey last year, it showed 94 percent of Shanghai residents are in favor of the law.”

“I think it’s very necessary. I don’t smoke and it’s very unpleasant for me to smell [?inhale? breathe?] smoke in some public areas.”

“Many people in public areas are unaware of others. Most women don’t smoke but they are the victims of secondhand smoke. It’s not fair. I am also a mother. I’m worried about my kid in some public areas with smokers. I think a city-wide ban on smoking is a good move.”

“I fully support the move of the new legislation. The current regulation doesn’t cover all the public areas. We are exposed to a lot of risks from secondhand smoke, which isn’t fair to non-smokers. I think the reason for the limited effect of the current regulation is that enforcement isn’t strict. The fine is affordable and it’s hard to get evidence when someone’s smoking and report to the appropriate departments or have them find it. I think the new legislation should focus more on that. What really matters is the effectiveness of enforcement.”

Probe on amid stink over smoking-ban checks

http://www.thestandard.com.hk/section-news.php?id=167166&story_id=46263811&d_str=20160311

The Ombudsman will investigate enforcement by the Food and Health Bureau and the Department of Health of the smoking ban in public places.

Its move comes after a barrage of media reports and public complaints over an ineffective government campaign, with critics slamming the ban as practically useless.

The bulk of the complaints center on the failure to deploy plainclothes officers.

Complainants also criticized the failure of certain departments to cooperate with the Tobacco Control Office and support its enforcement actions.

A preliminary inquiry by the Ombudsman found that the bureau and the health department have set up a mechanism to inspect no-smoking areas and conduct prosecutions.

Cooperation with other statutory authorities, including the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department, Leisure and Cultural Services Department, Housing Department and the police have also taken place.

However, the watchdog found that smoking-ban violations at certain spots remain serious, while many locations have turned into persistent black spots, raising questions over the adequacy of the existing mechanism.

“The government’s current tobacco- control policy aims to encourage people to quit smoking and minimize risks posed by second-hand smoke to the public,” Ombudsman Connie Lau Yin-hing said.

“The designation of no-smoking areas is an integral part of that policy. If the purpose of no-smoking areas is defeated by ineffective enforcement, it would mean a failure to discharge the duty of safeguarding public health, and thus it is a disappointment to the public.”

The investigation seeks, among other things, to find out if the mechanism of the bureau and the department for handling smoking offenses is effective. It will also look at how they coordinate their efforts with other statutory authorities in tobacco control and identify areas for improvement and enhancement.

The public have until April 14 to provide their written comments to the Ombudsman.

Smoking blackspots reportedly include restaurants and cooked food centers.

Ombudsman probes mechanism for handling smoking offences

http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201603/10/P201603090732.htm

The following is issued on behalf of the Office of The Ombudsman:

The Ombudsman, Ms Connie Lau, announced today (March 10) a direct investigation into the mechanism of the Food and Health Bureau (FHB) and the Department of Health (DH) for handling smoking offences to examine whether there are any inadequacies.

There have been media reports and public complaints lodged with the Office of The Ombudsman about the Government’s ineffectiveness in combating smoking in prohibited places, rendering the smoking ban in some no-smoking areas practically useless. As a result, the public continue to suffer from the nuisance of second-hand smoke. In a number of complaints, the DH is criticised for failing to respond quickly or deploy plain-clothes officers to conduct inspections. Some complainants are also dissatisfied that other relevant departments have failed to co-operate with the Tobacco Control Office under the DH and support its enforcement actions.

A preliminary inquiry by the Office has revealed that the FHB and the DH, which is under the FHB’s policy overview, have put in place a mechanism for carrying out inspections in no-smoking areas and instituting prosecutions. They have also worked together with other statutory authorities (including the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department, the Leisure and Cultural Services Department, the Housing Department and the Police Force) in tobacco control. However, the violation of the smoking ban in some no-smoking areas remains serious and many locations have become persistent black spots. This situation calls into question the adequacy of the existing mechanism.

Ms Lau said, “The Government’s current tobacco control policy aims at encouraging people to quit smoking and minimising the risks caused by second-hand smoke to the public. The designation of no-smoking areas is an integral part of that policy. If the purpose of no-smoking areas is defeated by ineffective enforcement, it would mean a failure to discharge the duty of safeguarding public health and thus a disappointment to the public.”

The ambit of this direct investigation includes:

(1) whether the mechanism of the FHB and the DH for handling smoking offences is effective;

(2) how the FHB and the DH co-ordinate their efforts with other statutory authorities in tobacco control; and

(3) areas for improvement and enhancement.

The Ombudsman welcomes views from the public on the above subject. Comments in writing should reach the Office of The Ombudsman by April 14, 2016:

Address: 30/F, China Merchants Tower, Shun Tak Centre
168-200 Connaught Road Central, Hong Kong
Fax: 2882 8149
Email: complaints@ombudsman.hk
Ends/Thursday, March 10, 2016
Issued at HKT 11:00

Watchdog probes action over smoking-ban breach

http://news.rthk.hk/rthk/en/component/k2/1247567-20160310.htm

The Ombudsman on Thursday launched an investigation into the handling of smoking offences in prohibited areas by the Food and Health Bureau and the Department of Health.

The watchdog said it is aware of media reports and public complaints about ineffective implementation of smoking ban in some places.

The complaints had to do with the Department of Health’s failure to respond quickly or deploy plain-clothes officers to conduct inspections. Other statutory authorities, such as the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department, the Leisure and Cultural Services Department and the police also came under fire for failing to co-operate with the Tobacco Control Office.

As a result, many people continue to be subjected to second-hand smoke.

The Ombudsman, Connie Lau, said the shortcomings call into question the efficiency of the government’s overall tobacco control policy.

Government accused not allocating sufficient resources to enforce smoking ban

http://news.rthk.hk/rthk/en/news-programmes/this-episode.htm?cmsid=78&episode_id=346407&livetime=20160310180000

The Chairman of Clear the Air, James Middleton, has accused the government of not allocating sufficient resources to enforce smoking ban in some places.

He says there is not enough staff to do the job and out of the billions of dollars being collected in tobacco tax, none of it goes towards tobacco control.

Middleton also says the mainland has better laws than Hong Kong on banning smoking.

He tells Ben Tse that when a suggestion was made to the Liquor Licensing Board to strengthen licensing conditions to prevent smoking in places like bars, it refused to do so.

VICTORIANS WANT OUTDOOR DINING SMOKE BAN: CANCER COUNCIL

https://ajp.com.au/news/victorians-want-outdoor-dining-smoke-ban-cancer-council/

Victorians expect to be able to eat and drink outside without being exposed to secondhand smoke and nearly three-quarters of a million of them will visit cafes and restaurants more often every year if smokefree outdoor areas are created, according to new research from the Cancer Council Victoria.

However, public expectations and the benefits for businesses won’t be met unless comprehensive laws to protect patrons and staff are implemented.

The large research study by the Cancer Council Victoria’s Centre for Behavioural Research in Cancer shows that:

  • 22% of Victorians said they would visit cafes and restaurants more often if an outdoor smoking ban was introduced
  • Only 5% of Victorians said they would visit cafes and restaurants less often.
  • This means that more than 700,000 Victorians would visit these venues more often each year if outdoor areas were smokefree.

In addition, the study tested public opinion on Queensland’s smokefree model, in which smoking is only allowed in designated outdoor smoking areas of licensed venues.

There was high support for this approach, with 71% of Victorians agreeing that smoking should be restricted to “outdoor areas of bars, pubs and clubs with a designated area separated from patrons by at least two metres”.

Even 88% of current Victorian smokers also supported this model.

More than half of all Victorians, including 52% of former smokers and 15% of current smokers, report they have avoided sitting outside at cafes or restaurants in the past year due to people smoking.

Quit Victoria Director Dr Sarah White says the findings demonstrated overwhelming public support for comprehensive protection from tobacco smoke when both dining and drinking in outdoor areas.

“The state government has announced that smokefree outdoor dining will be the norm across Victoria by August 2017, but it’s clear that most Victorians want this protection to also cover outdoor drinking areas,” she says.

“Victorians expect to be able socialise outside without being subjected to secondhand smoke, irrespective of whether they are having a sandwich or a coffee.

“It’s terrific that the Andrews Government is consulting with public health experts, businesses and other authorities such as liquor licensing regulators on new smokefree dining and drinking laws.

“This new data will give the Government confidence that smokefree laws in drinking and dining areas will not only be good for health, they will also be good for business,” says Dr White.

The alternative to the Queensland model is the NSW model, where smokefree protection applies only to outdoor dining areas. This has created a perverse incentive for some NSW venues to stop serving food outside altogether, and instead devote their outdoor area to smoking and drinking.

Dr White says Quit is aware of a case in Sydney where a woman was berated at length by staff at a well-known coffee chain for eating a piece of toast in an outside area while another customer was smoking. This created a situation in which the venue was breaching smokefree dining laws.

“Most Victorians support outdoor smokefree laws for good reason – they protect staff and patrons from dangerous and unpleasant secondhand smoke, and they support smokers trying to quit,’’ Dr White says.

“We don’t want Victoria to fall into the trap that has occurred in NSW, where smokefree laws that apply only to outdoor dining areas have created widespread confusion for patrons and an enforcement nightmare for venues.’

Smoking ban enforced at Confucius tourist attractions sites

http://www.newsghana.com.gh/smoking-ban-enforced-at-confucius-tourist-attractions-sites/

Three venues – the Temple, the Family Mansion and the Cemetery of Confucius (551-479 BC), have banned smoking.

The new ban is also applied to the gate towers, ancient trees, ticket offices and some enclosed areas, said the administration of cultural heritage in Qufu City, where the three venues are located.

Born in what is today Qufu, of Shandong Province, Confucius founded the school of thought that became known as Confucianism. He is believed to be the first person to have set up private schools in China.

UNESCO World Heritage sites, the three spots host around four million visitors each year.

Ancient Chinese architects used a lot of wood instead of stone to build houses, temples and gardens, so these buildings are fire risks.

The three tourist attractions are also home to 10,270 ancients trees.

China is yet to have national legislation on smoking in public places, but to date 16 cities have bylaws on tobacco control.

European Lung: Tobacco Smoking

Download (PDF, 665KB)