Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Europe

UK’s policy on standardised tobacco packaging given EU backing

http://www.charitytoday.co.uk/uks-policy-on-standardised-tobacco-packaging-given-eu-backing/

Plans to introduce plain, standardised packaging for cigarettes in the UK have been given European backing.

The European Court of Justice ruled (link is external) that the EU Tobacco Products Directive is lawful and has overturned the tobacco industry’s challenge to it.

The court also confirmed that EU Member States can go further than the requirements set out in the Directive with regard to packaging.

This, essentially, allows countries to bring in standardised packaging. The directive, along with standardised packaging, will now enter into force on May 20.

George Butterworth, Cancer Research UK’s tobacco policy manager, said: “This court decision tells us what we knew all along – that the Tobacco Products Directive is an effective and proportional set of measures to stop children taking up smoking.

“This will help to lower smoking rates in the UK and protect more people from developing cancer.

“It’s truly shameful that the tobacco industry has poured so much time, effort and money trying to undermine it. UK laws can now continue as planned and from May 20 the rollout of plain, standardised packaging begins.”

The UK, France and Ireland have already passed legislation on standardised packaging.

This new ruling will give support to other member states who also wish to proceed with the measure.

The Court also dismissed other legal challenges claiming regulations on e-cigarettes were disproportionate and the ban on menthol flavouring was unjustified.

Deborah Arnott, Chief Executive of health charity ASH said the Court’s decision was “welcome”.

“The Directive is lawful and the UK is allowed to go further than the Directive in standardising tobacco packs with respect to matters not harmonised by the Directive,” she added.

“We await the UK court judgement, which is expected shortly, but we expect that the court will also confirm that the introduction of standardised packaging in the UK is lawful.

“From May 20, all packs manufactured for sale in the UK will have to be plain, standardised in the same drab green colour with the product name on the pack in a standard font.”

What the EU has done to take on Big Tobacco

http://theconversation.com/what-the-eu-has-done-to-take-on-big-tobacco-58941

Three landmark cases in the EU Court of Justice have dealt an important blow in the long-running campaign by Big Tobacco to use legal challenges to avoid regulation. The big question at stake is about how effective is the EU at taking on the might of the multinationals – the huge and well-funded companies in the tobacco industry – in the name of health protection.

The decisions, which unequivocally support the EU’s latest package of tobacco regulation, will be warmly greeted by pro-Europe campaigners in the UK’s referendum – such as Scientists for EU – who argue that on balance, staying in the EU is better for health.

One case was brought by the Polish government and the others were referred by the English High Court, which asked the EU court to interpret EU law. Based on this judgment, the English court will now decide claims brought by tobacco companies, or suppliers to the industry and a retailer of e-cigarettes.

The EU began to regulate tobacco in the late 1980s, as information about the dangers of tobacco came to greater public awareness and the EU’s competence to regulate in its market expanded. Of course, the world knew about the dangers of tobacco well before that – see, for instance, the US Surgeon General’s Report of 1964 and earlier research such as the work of Doll and Hill in Oxford in the 1950s.

But it is notoriously difficult for governments or international organisations to control the tobacco industry. Tactics include undermining anti-tobacco cancer research, relying on ideas such as freedom or human rights, appealing to social norms or drawing shocking historical parallels – which have included calling anti-smoking campaigners “Nicotine Nazis”.

Then factor in the level of lobbying and persuasion of law and policy-makers, which is considerable. And the power of these companies to engage in expensive litigation tactics, which – in the case of tobacco – include repeatedly making the legal argument that the EU has exceeded its powers.

Setting the rules

The question in these recent cases was whether the EU is competent to adopt the latest Tobacco Products Directive of 2014, which must be implemented in national law by May 20 2016. That directive revises and tightens up existing EU rules about cigarette packaging, prohibits vouchers and discounts, and strengthens health warnings.

The directive also prevents misleading words on cigarette packaging (such as “natural”, “slim” or “light”) and regulates the size of packages, banning what have been called “lipstick-style” packs of fewer than 20 cigarettes which are targeted at women and young people. It also sets rules about flavourings and additives such as menthol or cinnamon, which are used to make cigarettes more palatable – especially for young people when they first try them – and regulates e-cigarettes and other novel tobacco products.

The EU’s court has ruled that the EU’s powers allow it to adopt the directive. The judgment stressed that the EU must secure high levels of health protection in all its policies, including its trade law. It rejected arguments that relevant EU laws are a disproportionate paternalistic incursion on autonomy, by emphasising that the rules seek especially to protect young people.

The court confirmed that EU law may adopt a precautionary approach when the dangers associated with new products, such as e-cigarettes, are still being explored. It also rejected arguments based on freedom of expression, including the freedom of companies to advertise, saying that these entitlements are outweighed by the “proven harmfulness of tobacco consumption”.

The EU court confirms that the directive does leave discretion to member states. In the UK there has been discussion about whether this includes power to adopt plain packaging (as in Australia), or standardised packaging – which was called for in the independent report by Sir Cyril Chantler, and adopted by the Children and Families Act 2014.

Note that the current UK government does not intend to adopt plain packaging, and the question of whether it could lawfully do so was debated only as a theoretical or hypothetical one in the legal hearing.

Taking on the smoking guns

The EU’s track record on tobacco regulation is far from perfect from a health point of view. The imbalances of lobbying power are legendary: the WHO noted that some 20 people advocated the health policy aspects of this directive, whereas more than 160 lobbyists represented the industry.

In October 2012, the EU health commissioner John Dalli resigned amid allegations uncovered by the European Anti-Fraud Office regarding links between Dalli and the tobacco industry. Dalli was unsuccessful in subsequent legal claims about the nature of the resignation process and the European Union’s ombudsman has recommended release of all pertinent documents after the conclusion of those proceedings.

The EU’s tobacco law has been hailed as a public health success story – and perhaps with some justification. From a position in which several EU countries had no effective tobacco regulation at all, by the early 1990s the EU had adopted a suite of laws on tobacco product regulation, labelling and packaging, and taxation.

From the 1990s onwards, EU anti-tobacco law has proceeded at a slower pace, involving a “nudging” approach focused mainly on young people. There is undoubtedly more that the EU could do to stop Big Tobacco, especially as it develops new products. But the EU has been more effective than its member states acting alone. And its transparency rules mean citizens have greater abilities to track industry influence on policy than in many of its member states.

The example of EU tobacco regulation is important for the UK referendum. There are understandable concerns about the impacts of EU membership on health issues. But let’s look beyond the discussions of the NHS and TTIP – important as they are. If there is political will to go further in regulating tobacco than EU law requires, our government has the discretion to do so. But EU laws provide a public health baseline, which even the tobacco industry cannot easily undermine.

Tougher Rules On Electronic Cigarettes: European Court

http://www.ndtv.com/world-news/tougher-rules-on-electronic-cigarettes-european-court-1402713

Brussels: The European Union’s top court has approved new rules requiring plain cigarette packs, banning menthol cigarettes and regulating the growing electronic cigarette market.

Tobacco companies had protested a 2014 EU tobacco directive, calling it disproportionate. But the European Court of Justice today ruled the directive is in line with efforts to protect public health.

The court upheld a ban on menthol and other flavorings that make tobacco more appealing. The directive also requires standardized, plain labels that cover cigarette packs at least 65 percent with health warnings.

The rules will require warnings for e-cigarettes, limit their nicotine levels to 20 grams and restrict advertising and sponsorship by their makers.

The Independent British Vape Trade Association argued the ruling could push some e-cigarette smokers back to tobacco.

EU Court Upholds Tough Tobacco Law On Packaging, Flavors, E-Cigarettes

http://www.ibtimes.com/eu-court-upholds-tough-tobacco-law-packaging-flavors-e-cigarettes-2363884

Tobacco companies, led by Philip Morris International, lost an appeal in the European Union’s top court Wednesday against strict packaging rules for cigarettes. The Court of Justice for the European Union also dismissed appeals by Poland and Romania to the EU decision to ban flavored cigarettes, such as menthol.

In the matter of flavored cigarettes, the court reasoned that tobacco products with menthol or another “pleasant flavor” makes them “more attractive to consumers and that reducing the attractiveness of those products may contribute to reducing the prevalence of tobacco use and dependence among new and continuing users.”

In a statement on the official EU website, the court also said that the EU legislature was right in forming the law in 2014, which guards against divergences in different rules of various member states, especially when it came to health matters.

In a setback to tobacco companies, led by Philip Morris and British American Tobacco, the court also ruled in favor of EU regulations on cigarette packaging, which mandate a message and a color photograph — covering at least 65 percent of each packet’s front and back — warning of the dangers of smoking. The court said that “the EU legislature did not go beyond the limits of what is appropriate and necessary,” and added that individual countries could impose stricter rules, such as plain packaging without any branding.

The court also upheld new limits on e-cigarettes, despite manufacturers claiming they should be dealt with under a different law because e-cigarettes were not actually tobacco products. A limit on maximum nicotine content, of 20 mg/ml, was declared valid, along with requirements of specific warnings and leaflets, and a prohibition on advertising.

“The identified and potential risks linked to the use of electronic cigarettes have led the EU legislature to act in a manner consistent with the requirements stemming from the precautionary principle,” the court said.

The ruling by the Court of Justice for the European Union cannot be appealed.

EU’s highest court upholds new restrictive law on cigarettes

http://english.vietnamnet.vn/fms/world-news/155936/eu-s-highest-court-upholds-new-restrictive-law-on-cigarettes.html

Europe’s highest court on Wednesday upheld a tough EU law on standardizing cigarette packaging and banning advertising of e-cigarettes, paving the way for its adoption later this month.

The court rejected a legal challenge brought by Philip Morris International and British American Tobacco, with Japan Tobacco International and Imperial Brands acting as interested parties.

“The court finds that, in providing that each unit packet and the outside packaging must carry health warnings…. the EU legislature did not go beyond the limits of what is appropriate and necessary,” the court said.

The new EU directive on tobacco products is valid

Download (PDF, 171KB)

Tobacco companies lose EU court appeal over graphic cigarette packaging rules

The decision sets a precedent that could see other governments launch a crackdown on a habit that kills six million people a year

Tobacco firms have lost a legal challenge against EU rules that force them to put graphic images on cigarette packages warning people of the dangers of smoking.

Health companies have welcomed the decision by Europe’s highest court to reject the challenge brought by Philip Morris International and British American Tobacco (BAT).

The decision sets a precedent that could see other governments launch a crackdown on a habit that kills six million people a year.

“The court finds that, in providing that each unit packet and the outside packaging must carry health warnings… the EU legislature did not go beyond the limits of what is appropriate and necessary,” the court said in its decision.

It said EU member states might choose to go further than the ruling to including health warnings on packs of cigarettes, by introducing standardised “plain” packaging.

The decision to introduce plain packaging goes beyond the requirements of the European directive and must still comply with the EU and international law. Whether plain packaging meets these requirements is currently the subject of ongoing litigation before the English Courts and the World Trade Organization.

The UK, France and Ireland have passed legislation that will see plain packaging introduced on 20 May.

Philip Morris and BAT have sought to overturn measures on plain packaging to be introduced in May. The tobacco companies said the measures deprived them of property in the form of trademarks and was a violation of European intellectual property law.

In the UK, MPs voted to back plain packaging by 367 to 113 in March 2015.

The vote came one year after the publication of an independent review of evidence by Sir Cyril Chantler, which concluded it was “highly likely that standardised packaging would serve to reduce the rate of children taking up smoking and implausible that it would increase the consumption of tobacco.”

Ash said it expects the UK court judgement to confirm that the introduction of standardised packaging in the UK is lawful.

“From 20th May all packs manufactured for sale in the UK will have to be plain, standardised in the same drab green colour with the product name on the pack in a standard font,” Deborah Arnott, chief executive of health charity Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), said.

In Australia, where the measure was introduced in 2012, smoking rates fell by more than 12 per cent between December 2013 and 2014.

A spokeswoman from British American Tobacco said that the European court decision does not directly authorise EU member states to adopt plain packaging.

“Despite today’s decision by the European Court of Justice, we stand by our belief that the Tobacco Products Directive is a clear example of the EU overstepping the limits of its authority. The reality is that many elements of the directive are disproportionate, distort competition, and fail to respect the autonomy of the member states,” the spokeswoman said.

European Court judgement clears way for plain packaging of tobacco in Ireland

Big Tobacco arguments rejected by CJEU

https://www.cancer.ie/about-us/news/european-court-judgement-clears-way-plain-packaging-tobacco-ireland#sthash.TTszgZlV.dpbs

The Irish Cancer Society has today welcomed a Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgement that has stopped attempts by the tobacco industry to block the introduction of plain packaging of tobacco in Ireland in 2016.

The CJEU judgement upholds the rights of EU member states to introduce standardised packaging of tobacco products, where it is justified on grounds of public health.

The Court considered that that prohibition protects consumers “against the risks associated with tobacco use”.

The Irish Cancer Society says that this is a defeat for the tobacco industry who knows plain packaging works.

Donal Buggy, Head of Services and Advocacy at the Irish Cancer Society said: “Plain packaging of tobacco will save lives. The rejection of the tobacco industry’s case against the tobacco products directive (TPD) highlights the fatuous nature of their arguments and their fear that plain packaging will eat into profits.”

“Big tobacco knows that plain packaging, as a health measure, works, and are doing everything to prevent its introduction because they need to recruit 50 new smokers every day in Ireland to replace those dying and quitting.”

The CJEU found that the standardisation of labelling and packaging is a ‘proportionate’ measure and that EU legislature allowing for its introduction from May 20 is “appropriate and necessary”. The judgement clears the way for the introduction of plain packaging here in Ireland this summer.

Mr. Buggy said: “Today’s ruling represents the overcoming of another legal hurdle to the introduction of plain packaging in Ireland. What remains to be done now is the passing of minor technical amendments to legislation here so that plain packaging can be introduced in the very near future.”

The formation of a Government will, according to Mr. Buggy, “hopefully see the speedy progression of this legislation through the Oireachtas very shortly”.

The Irish Cancer Society warned however, that this will not be the last legal challenge to plain packaging either in Ireland or at EU level.

Mr. Buggy said: “The tobacco industry has deep pockets and will continue to fight these life-saving measures. Australia, the first country to introduce the measure, is still battling spurious cases from the industry four years on.”

Figures from the Australian Government show that since the introduction of plain packaging the number of people smoking has dropped to historically low numbers. Daily smoking rates have fallen from 15.1% in 2010 to 12.8% in 2013 – compared to 19% in Ireland. And among 12-17 year olds, only 5% smoke in comparison to 8% here.

“The louder Big Tobacco shout about this, the more we know it works.”

Mr. Buggy commended the efforts of the European Commission and Irish Government in “remaining steadfast in the face of enormous and costly legal pressure by the industry”.

“5,870 people die from tobacco related disease every year. The challenge now is to commit to public health, to commit to plain packaging and to reject the actions of a tobacco industry in crisis.”

Mr. Buggy said: “This is another big step towards achieving the goal of a tobacco-free Ireland by 2025”.

The Department of Health have committed to a Tobacco Free Ireland by 2025 – which means an overall smoking rate of less than 5%.

Today’s CJEU judgement also dismissed actions against the prohibition of menthol cigarettes and special rules concerning warnings, content and advertising of e-cigarettes.

– See more at: https://www.cancer.ie/about-us/news/european-court-judgement-clears-way-plain-packaging-tobacco-ireland#sthash.TTszgZlV.dpuf

Health Commissioner vows to lobby Commission on tobacco transparency

The event discussing tobacco lobbying.

http://www.euractiv.com/section/health-consumers/news/health-commissioner-vows-to-lobby-commission-on-tobacco-transparency/

Commission health chief Vytenis Andriukaitis wants the European Commission to be more transparent when it comes to tobacco lobbying and warned that EU institutions faced losing citizen’s trust if no action was taken.

While Andriukaitis’ DG Sante was proactive in releasing details of meetings with the tobacco industry when the EU’s new Tobacco Products Directive was negotiated, other DGs failed to disclose such meetings.

According to some, this lack of transparency breaches Article 5.3 of the World Health Organisation’s (WHO) Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC).

The convention says that parties are obliged to protect public health policies from commercial or other vested interests of the tobacco industry.

European Ombudsman Emily O’Reilly, who investigates complaints about maladministration in the EU institutions and bodies, organised an event in Brussels on Wednesday (27 April) to push for the other Commission DGs as well as other EU institutions to follow Andriukaitis’ lead.

Andriukaitis acknowledged that the Commission could be more transparent, but said that he sees “good attitudes” among his colleagues.

“DG Sante is very active in explaining rules and procedures at different inter-sectoral levels, to raise questions and in encouraging colleagues to follow these procedures,” he said.

“From my point of view, we must show absolutely show our engagement and our fight against tobacco lobbying. Or else citizens won’t believe in the EU institutions,” the Commissioner added.

Roberto Bertollini, the chief scientist and WHO representative to the EU stated that the European Commission had nothing to discuss with the tobacco industry.

“We have an industry which kills half of its users. Their products have no added value. We would like to see this tobacco lobbying finished,” he said.

Tobacco lobbying has played an important part of the transparency discussion related to the Commission over the past years.

In October 2012, the European Union’s top health official, John Dalli, resigned after an anti-fraud investigation connected him to an attempt to influence EU tobacco legislation.

A report from OLAF, the EU’s anti-fraud office, claimed that a Maltese lobbyist had approached the tobacco producer Swedish Match and proposed making use of his contacts with Dalli to fix the EU export ban on powder tobacco.

The report claimed that, while Dalli was not involved, he knew what was going on. Dalli rejected OLAF’s findings, denying that he was in any way aware of any of these events.

The new Commission led by Jean-Claude Juncker has taken steps to improve transparency, O’Reilly said.

But she was puzzled why meetings with tobacco lobbyists and other DGs were not disclosed, as publishing them online would not have added an extra layer of bureaucracy or burden for the administration.

Tobacco industry objections

The event caused controversy before it was held. Tobacco lobbyists complained they were excluded from being part of the panel.

Instead, the lobbyists showed up in great numbers in the audience, according to the list of participants.

Ronan Barry, of the Confederation of European Community Cigarette Manufacturers, argued that by not inviting the industry to be on the panel, the Ombudsman was excluding the industry from the public health debate.

“I’m aware that the tobacco industry is unhappy about not being represented on the panel today,” O’Reilly said.

“I can of course invite whoever I wish to take part in a seminar that I organise. But I did make a decision not to invite tobacco industry representatives.

“That is how I interpret my obligation under the convention. This is, however, a public event and I did not exclude any interest group from taking part,” she said.

Background

The first tobacco control legislation in the EU was introduced in the 1980s. Since then, EU legislation and policy has been further developed in the areas of product regulation, advertising and protecting people from second-hand smoke, as well as prevention.

The new Tobacco Product Directive seeks to regulate products that look and taste like tobacco with the aim of discouraging young people from taking up smoking in the first place.

The compromise stipulates that e-cigarettes will be considered like regular tobacco products if they contain nicotine in a concentration of more than 20 mg/ml.

However, individual member states can regulate e-cigarettes as medicines, if they are presented as having curative or preventive properties.

Refillable e-cigarettes will not be banned, but member states can ban specific types of cartridges for e-cigarettes, if they can justify the ban by safety concerns.

Contribution of smoking to socioeconomic inequalities in mortality

A study of 14 European countries, 1990–2004

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2016/04/27/tobaccocontrol-2015-052766.short?g=w_tobaccocontrol_ahead_tab

Abstract

Background

Smoking contributes to socioeconomic inequalities in mortality, but the extent to which this contribution has changed over time and driven widening or narrowing inequalities in total mortality remains unknown. We studied socioeconomic inequalities in smoking-attributable mortality and their contribution to inequalities in total mortality in 1990–1994 and 2000–2004 in 14 European countries.

Methods

We collected, harmonised and standardised population-wide data on all-cause and lung-cancer mortality by age, gender, educational and occupational level in 14 European populations in 1990–1994 and 2000–2004. Smoking-attributable mortality was indirectly estimated using the Preston-Glei-Wilmoth method.

Results

In 2000–2004, smoking-attributable mortality was higher in lower socioeconomic groups in all countries among men, and in all countries except Spain, Italy and Slovenia, among women, and the contribution of smoking to socioeconomic inequalities in mortality varied between 19% and 55% among men, and between −1% and 56% among women. Since 1990–1994, absolute inequalities in smoking-attributable mortality and the contribution of smoking to inequalities in total mortality have decreased in most countries among men, but increased among women.

Conclusions

In many European countries, smoking has become less important as a determinant of socioeconomic inequalities in mortality among men, but not among women. Inequalities in smoking remain one of the most important entry points for reducing inequalities in mortality.