Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Europe

EU health chief compares tobacco deaths with terrorism

Health Commissioner Vytenis Andriukaitis said that “Two terrorist attacks in Brussels are very dangerous, but of course 700.000 premature deaths are also very dangerous.”

http://www.euractiv.com/section/health-consumers/news/eu-health-chief-compares-impact-of-tobacco-industry-to-isis-attacks/

Health Commissioner Vytenis Andriukaitis strongly criticised the tobacco industry on Thursday (19 May), saying it “only kills people”, while expressing his opposition to the renewal of an agreement to counter cigarette smuggling in the EU.

Speaking to a group of reporters on the eve of the entry into force of the new Tobacco Products Directive today (20 May), Andriukaitis wondered “Why we don’t see headlines, why we are so blind, so silent” in Europe concerning tobacco, the single largest cause of avoidable deaths in the EU.

The EU Health Commissioner then went on to draw unexpected parallels between deaths caused by the terrorist attacks in Brussels last march and those caused by tobacco.

“Two terrorist attacks in Brussels are very dangerous, but of course 700,000 premature deaths are also very dangerous,” he said referring to tobacco mortality figures which dwarf deaths caused by terrorism in Europe.

The former physician insisted that “Tobacco is a very profitable industry that only produces something that kills people, nothing more… such industrial activity is a mistake from different perspectives.”

Fight against smuggling

His comments came as the European Commission is about to decide whether to extend a controversial deal with Philip Morris and other big tobacco firms to fight against the smuggling of cigarettes in Europe.

Andriukaitis stated that “There is no legal need to continue with such an agreement.” The Commission is emphasising that the new directive will provide better tools to address such challenges.

According to the deal reached with Philip Morris, Japan Tobacco, British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco, the EU, and the member states, will drop all court cases against them, over the loss of tax revues caused by illegal trading in cigarettes. In return, Philip Morris, the world’s largest tobacco company, has to pay $1.25 billion over 12 years (2004-2016). The others will have to pay a total of $900 million.

Tobacco firms were sued for their alleged involvement in smuggling cigarettes in the EU.

The agreement with Philip Morris will be the first one to expire in July. The executive’s decision on its renewal will set the tone for the other three.

Decision by early June

Andriukaitis told reporters that Commissioners will make up their mind about continuing the agreement by the end of May, or the beginning of June.

He said that there was a very good cooperation ongoing with Commission Vice-President Kristalina Georgieva, who is in charge of the dossier, as she oversees OLAF, the EU’s anti-fraud agency.

Compared with Andriukaitis’ strong views, the Bulgarian Commissioner’s opinion is more “moderate” and “cautious”, EU officials told EurActiv.com.

In a debate held in the European Parliament in February 2016, Georgieva left all options open for a renewal of the agreement.

“The question is whether or not, between today and the time when we have the Tobacco Products Directive in place – 2019, or the time when we have the [World Health Organisation’s] Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products protocol enacted – 2022, we still need a legally binding instrument to fight illegal trade,” she told MEPs.

However, Georgieva faces strong arguments against maintaining close ties with big tobacco.

“Too close”

A European Commission assessment of the agreements noted that these deals bring “anti-fraud policy, if not EU policy at large, too close to comfort to the tobacco manufacturers”.

The report also highlighted that these companies are legally challenging the new Tobacco Products Directive. This “prompts some to question whether it is opportune for the EU to enter into a contract with an entity on policy issues related to the ones legally challenged.”

Georgieva is aware of the risk of the negative impact for the EU’s image that the continuation of such agreements could cause.

Moreover, the Commissioner does not want to antagonise MEPs by neglecting the negative opinion they gave on the deals, just when she is about to start negotiating the EU budget with co-legislators.

In a resolution voted on last March, a majority of lawmakers urged the Commission not to renew the deal, as they proved ineffective to stop the increase of smuggled non-branded “cheap white” cigarettes.

The executive and the European Parliament agreed that the WHO’s protocol could be a much more powerful instrument, as it will introduce at international level better tools to trace and track cigarettes.

The protocol will enter into force once it is ratified by 40 countries. Only 16 countries have done it to date, including only five member states (Austria, France, Latvia, Portugal and Spain).

Meanwhile, a majority of member states are in favour of prolonging the anti-smuggling agreements with the tobacco sector. EU officials said that around 20 member states responded affirmatively when the European Commission sent letters to the capitals last year to request their views.

Focus on implementation

In the meantime, the European Parliament called on the executive to focus on the implementation of the Tobacco Products Directive, which also includes similar tools at EU level.

Adopted in 2014, the directive will enter into force today. Andriukaitis was positive, as up to 19 national governments are preparing stronger measures.

But only Germany, Italy, Malta, Portugal and Slovenia completely transposed the directive on the eve of the entry into force, while it was partly adopted by Belgium, Estonia, Lithuania and the United Kingdom.

Britain, France, Ireland, Hungary and Slovenia either adopted or planned to include plain packaging, where brands and logos are removed.

The Lithuanian Commissioner warned laggard that he will be “very active” in ensuring that all member states bring their national legislation in line with the new EU rules.

Otherwise, he is ready to launch infringements procedures without delay.

The Commission, along with the member states, will assess the implementation of the Tobacco Products Directive during the next group of experts on tobacco policy, to be held on 15 June.

Positions

Ben Townsend, JTI’s EU Affairs Vice-President, noted that the new EU Tobacco Products Directive “is an attack on adult consumers’ freedom of choice and yet another example of extreme regulation.” Moreover, the EU move to further restrict packaging design and formats is so confusing and complex that regulators in EU member states are scrambling to draft national laws. JTI is a member of Japan Tobacco Group.

Background

EU member states and the European Commission entered into agreements with tobacco producers Philip Morris International (PMI) in 2004, Japan Tobacco in 2007, British American Tobacco (BAT) in 2010 and Imperial Tobacco in 2010 in which they agreed to pay a collective total of $2.15 billion to the EU, and member states.

Around 90% of the revenue from these deals goes to member states, and 10% to the EU budget, as own resources.

The tobacco firms pledged to prevent their products from falling into the hands of criminals, by supplying only quantities required by the legitimate market, taking care to sell only to legitimate clients and implementing a tracking system to help law enforcement authorities if cigarettes are traded illegally.

Meanwhile, the new Tobacco Directive updates the 2001Tobacco Products Directive, by bring it in line with market, scientific and international developments in the tobacco sector.

According to the new rules, the new cigarette packs will feature mandatory picture and text health warnings covering 65% of the front and the back of cigarette packs – to be placed on the top edge. 50% of the sides of packs will also be covered with health warnings (e.g. “smoking kills – quit now”; “tobacco smoke contains over 70 substances known to cause cancer”), replacing the current printing of tar, nicotine and carbon monoxide (TNCO) levels.

On top of this, flavourings in cigarettes and tobacco must not be used in quantities that give the product a distinguishable (‘characterising’) flavour other than tobacco.

Accordingly, Menthol is considered a characterising flavour and will be banned after a phase-out period of four years – a period which applies to all products with more than a 3% market share in the EU.

As cigarette packs all become the same, leading doctor reveals why standard packaging DOES save lives

  • New rules make all cigarette packs olive green, with same size and font
  • Menthols will be phased out before being banned outright in 2020
  • Dr Nick Hopkinson of the British Lung Foundation says evidence from Australia – where plain packaging has been introduced- shows it works
  • Says it lowers smoking rates – and vulnerable teenagers benefit the most

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-3601056/As-cigarette-packs-leading-doctor-reveals-standard-packaging-DOES-save-lives.html

Today, a strict new law banning 10-packs of cigarettes comes into place.

Cigarette boxes will look similar, all packets will have to be the same olive green colour, with the same font, size, case and text appearance.

The move follows a ruling from the European Court of Justice earlier this month which approved sweeping new rules in a bid to slash the number of smokers across the EU by 2.4 million.

While some have reservations about whether it will achievie its aims, Dr Nick Hopkinson, spokesperson for the British Lung Foundation, says evidence shows plain packaging does work to cut smoking rates.

Writing for medical blogging site The Hippocratic Post, here he explains why the changes ‘can’t come soon enough’…

New cigarette packaging laws are coming into force today, which means all boxes will have to be the same olive green colour, with the same font, colour, size, case and text appearance. Dr Nick Hopkinson, spokesperson for the British Lung Foundation, says evidence shows plain packaging works to cut smoking

New cigarette packaging laws are coming into force today, which means all boxes will have to be the same
olive green colour, with the same font, colour, size, case and text appearance. Dr Nick Hopkinson,
spokesperson for the British Lung Foundation, says evidence shows plain packaging works to cut smoking

From now on, you won’t see cigarette packs with imperial purple borders, gold lettering and enticing scenes from exotic locations.

Instead, all tobacco products will be sold in dull green packets with the brand name in regulation font, without a hint of a swirl or an embossed coat of arms.

The UK has become the second country in the world and the first in Europe to require cigarettes to be sold in plain standardised packaging – although there is a grace period of one year to allow manufacturers and retailers to use up current stock.

I think it is an important step forward for public health.

As a consultant chest physician based at the Royal Brompton Hospital in London and spokesperson for the British Lung Foundation, I see at first-hand what happens when someone starts smoking young, beguiled by glitzy packs and slogans suggesting cigarette smoking is glamorous and fun.

Every year, around 200,000 young people in the UK aged between 11 and 15 start smoking for the first time and many will go on to smoke for decades putting themselves at risk of lung cancer and emphysema.

It is this group who should benefit the most from the implementation of the Standardised Packaging Tobacco Products regulation.

At this age, their lungs are still growing so they are especially vulnerable to the toxic effects of cigarette smoke.

We know that standardised packaging works. In Australia, smoking rates are now at a record low level.

Overall smoking rate has fallen by 2.2 per cent since they brought in new rules in 2012.

There have been other measures which have helped to drive down the popularity of smoking, including hiking prices and making sure that health warnings now cover the majority of the packet, but we can show that plain packaging is responsible for about a quarter of this improvement.

This suggests that tens of thousands of people have not started smoking in Australia who would have done so otherwise.

In the UK, this move comes hard on the heels of other moves to make smoking a less attractive proposition.

Shops can no longer put cigarettes packets on display and cigarettes cannot have words associated with them including ‘lite’ and ‘natural’ which implies some kind of benefit.

Soon, flavoured cigarettes like menthol, will also be banned and this will be another turn off for younger smokers who may start with a ‘pleasant tasting’ brand before moving on.

This change, which is being introduced as part of the EU Tobacco Products Directive, will be phased in more gradually. It can’t come soon enough for me.

Delay in plain pack cigarettes a ‘missed opportunity’

As the new Minister for Health signs the European Tobacco Directive into Irish law, the Irish Cancer Society say it is a missed opportunity that plain packaging on cigarettes will not come into force on Friday, as originally planned.

On Friday, Simon Harris signed the European Tobacco Products Directive into Irish law. The new regulations include a ban on flavoured tobacco, misleading labelling (such as ‘natural’ or ‘organic), increased health warnings and stricter controls on e-cigarettes.

The introduction of standardised packaging on tobacco products was originally billed for Friday, 20 May but will not go ahead as it has not yet been passed through the Oireachtas.

The bill was initiated in the last Dáil, but did not make it past the second stage due to the “prolonged period of government negotiations.”

It comes as the UK’s legislation on plain packaging cigarettes, which will see them all be sold in drab green packages, came into force on Friday.

The Irish Cancer Society (ICS) have described the Irish governments delay as “a missed opportunity” to become the first country in Europe, along with the UK, to introduce plain packaging.

Plain packaging was introduced in Australia two years ago and has seen the smoking rates fall from 15.1% to a historic low of 12.8%.

The current smoking rate in Ireland stands at 19.5%, and Donal Buggy from the ICS says that the delay in introducing plain packaging puts the government’s commitment to be tobacco free by 2025 at risk.

“It is especially useful in stopping young people from smoking. We know that in Australia the daily smoking rate among 12-17 year olds has fallen to just 5%, compared to 8% here,” he explained.

The cancer charity say research shows 78% of people support the introduction of plain packaging.

“We’re encouraged by the level of support for plain packaging with almost four in five people behind it, while more than three in five smokers support it.

“The sooner plain packs are on the shelves in Ireland the better. Fasttracking plain packaging will put us on the road to a tobacco-free Ireland by 2025,” stated Mr Buggy.

Minister Harris said: “I look forward to progressing our Standardised Packaging Regulations in the near future.”

Menthol cigarettes banned by EU under stringent new tobacco laws

Plain packaging has made the headlines but new regulations will also crack down on flavoured tobacco

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/the-eu-is-banning-menthol-cigarettes-a7037346.html

New rules forcing tobacco companies to sell cigarettes in plain, olive green packets come into force on Friday. But restrictions on packets are only part of a raft of new EU regulations that include a ban on menthol cigarettes.

Most headlines have focused on standardised packaging, aimed at reducing the appeal of tobacco products, which Parliament voted for shortly before last year’s general election after an amount of prevarication by the Government.

Less publicised is the European Tobacco Products Directive, which the UK legislation builds on but has been held up by legal challenges from big tobacco companies.

Under the directive, picture health warnings must cover 65 per cent of the front and back of every packet of cigarettes, with additional warnings on the top of the pack.

It includes a ban on flavoured and menthol cigarettes and “lipstick-style” packs aimed at women – all packs must have at least 20 cigarettes to leave room for health warnings – and a ban on promotional statements such as “this product is free of additives” or “is less harmful than other brands”.

The directive also allowed the UK to go further and introduce its own regulations requiring all tobacco packaging to be uniformly olive green with large images designed to act as health warnings.

While many of the new rules on tobacco, including plain packaging in Britain, come in this week, the ban on menthol tobacco comes into force on 20 May 2020.

The latest legal challenge is being brought by the tobacco firms Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International.

A ruling was expected on Thursday in the High Court on a challenge to the legality of the new British rules on plain packaging.

The firms sought a judicial review of the UK’s Standardised Packaging of Tobacco Products Regulations 2015, which the companies say will destroy their highly valuable property rights and render products indistinguishable from each other.

Earlier this month, in a separate legal challenge, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that the Tobacco Products Directive is lawful.

The ruling is likely to have an influence on the High Court’s decision, which will be made by Mr Justice Green, and campaigners are confident that the tobacco firms will not succeed.

The new rules are an attempt to cut the number of smokers across the EU by 2.4 million. An estimated 700,000 smoking-related premature deaths are caused in the EU each year, and cancer charities are backing the measures.

Peer tables motion to kill vaping rules

Plain pack rules set to come into force tomorrow

A motion has been tabled in the House of Lords to annul the UK implementation of the EU’s new tobacco directive, which comes into effect tomorrow, potentially triggering a debate and a vote.

Motion SI 2015/507 was tabled by Lord Callanan, the former MEP and leader of the Conservatives in Europe. Callanan attempted to temper new regulations which included e-cigarettes, now enshrined as the Tobacco and Related Products Regulations of 2016 (PDF) while an MEP.

The motion calls for the TRP regulations to be annulled “on the grounds that its restrictions … were devised before evidence had accumulated that vaping was enabling many people to quit smoking”.

An online petition in support of Lord Callanan’s motion has collected almost 7,000 signatures in just two hours.

UK court quashes tobacco firms’ packaging challenge

http://www.politico.eu/article/uk-court-quashes-tobacco-firms-packaging-challenge/

LONDON — A High Court judge Thursday quashed the tobacco industry’s challenge to U.K. rules to require drab packaging stripped of logos and other branding on cigarettes and other products.

The 386-page judgment addressed all 17 grounds on which the tobacco industry challenged the U.K.’s rules, and sided with the government.

“I have found that the Secretary of State has adduced ample evidence to support the suitability and appropriateness of the Regulations,” the ruling reads.

The U.K. law is part of the country’s effort to implement the EU’s tobacco products directive, which comes into force on Friday.

The British standardized packaging regulations also take effect that day. Health warnings will have to cover 65 percent of the front and back of cigarette packaging. Anti-smoking advocates praised the decision.

“This landmark judgment is a crushing defeat for the tobacco industry and fully justifies the government’s determination to go ahead with the introduction of standardized packaging,” said Deborah Arnott, chief executive of ASH, an anti-smoking charity.

Cigarettes and hand-rolling tobacco will be sold in plain brown packages, which have had all the attractive features and colors removed. This so-called plain packaging is not required by the EU, but member countries can go beyond the floor set by the directive.

However, new packets will not be on sale until stocks of existing cartons have been sold over the next year.

The U.K.’s biggest tobacco firm, JTI, and British American Tobacco, both said they will challenge the ruling.

“We will continue to challenge the legality of plain packaging. The fact remains that our branding has been eradicated and we maintain that this is unlawful,” Daniel Sciamma, U.K. managing director of JTI, said in a statement on the decision.

ASH supported the government’s defense and provided written evidence and gave oral testimony to the court.

According to Arnott, who was in the London court, the judgment rejected every argument the industry put forward.

It was “highly critical” of the industry’s use of commissioned expert evidence, its failure to disclose any internal assessments on how packaging design affects children and young people, and the effect of standardized packaging on sales, according to Arnott.

The case was the first challenge to plain packaging laws, coming into force in France and Ireland among other countries.

700,000 deaths a year: tackling smoking in the EU

http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/news-room/20160518STO27901/700000-deaths-a-year-tackling-smoking-in-the-EU

tobacco-lung-story

More than one in four Europeans smoke. Half of them will die prematurely, shortening their life by 14 years on average. From 20 May new European legislation will be in place to make smoking and cigarettes less attractive, especially among young people. Read on to find out what will change and check out our infographic about smokers in the EU.

What is changing

The new directive, which enters in force in all EU countries on Friday 20 May, sets more stringent rules regarding tobacco and related products.

Some of the new rules aim to make smoking less attractive for young people by banning cigarettes and rolling tobacco with charactering flavours, as well as small and cheaper packages for certain tobacco products.

Health warnings – including both picture and text – need to cover 65% of the front and the back of cigarette and roll-your-own tobacco packages, while all promotional and misleading elements on tobacco products are banned.

Manufacturers are obliged to notify novel tobacco products before placing them on the EU market, while they are also required to submit detailed reports to EU countries on the ingredients used in tobacco products, in particular cigarettes and roll-your-own tobacco.

In addition EU countries are allowed to prohibit internet sales of tobacco and related products and e-cigarettes are regulated either as medicinal products – if they are used to help people quit smoking – or as tobacco products.

End of gimmick tobacco products

Tobacco companies tried to prevent the new rules entering into force, but the European Court of Justice ruled against them.

UK S&D member Linda McAvan, who was responsible for steering the new rules through Parliament, welcomed the legislation entering into force this week: “People across the whole of the EU will see tobacco packs change from now on as gimmick tobacco products disappear from the market and tobacco packs carry more health warnings than adverts. These new clear rules, together with other national measures such as bans on smoking in public places, should help stop the tobacco industry from recruiting a new generation of young smokers in Europe. And now that the big tobacco companies lost their case in the European Court of Justice, those member states who have still not fully transposed the directive need to get on and do it.”

The lethal habit

Tobacco consumption is responsible for nearly 700,000 deaths in the EU every year. Smokers suffer more from poor health (as they are more at risk of cancer, cardiovascular and respiratory diseases) and half of them die prematurely (14 years on average).

No good news on packaging regs

The European Court of Justice has backed the EU Tobacco Directive and told producers of packaging for tobacco products that they cannot use fancy substrates, designs or techniques to differentiate brands following the plain packaging requirement that comes into force on 20 May.

One such firm is Amcor, whose designs include the ‘scissor’ pack, which opens sideways to reveal hidden branding.

The directive will also ban packs of 10 cigarettes, rolling tobacco in packs under 30g and all menthol cigarettes, from 20 May 2020. Packs across the EU are required to have health warnings across 65% of their surface.

Meanwhile, the sector is on tenterhooks awaiting the decision of the UK High Court in an intellectual property case brought by Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International.

Many businesses due to be affected by the legislation are reserving comment until the decision comes through but the mood is not good. In Australia, which introduced plain packaging in December 2012, a similar high-profile and very expensive legal battle between the Australian government and tobacco titans did not go the tobacco lobby’s way.

Mike Ridgway of the Consumer Packaging Manufacturers Alliance says: “A lot of printing will be badly affected by the implementation of plain packaging. Plain packaging means standardised packaging doing away with branding and ID, having health warnings and an olive green background with a small font.

“It’s not just graphics, it’s the construction and the substrates. There’s no hot-foil stamping, no embossing, graining or anything that gives the pack any sort of particular graphical marketing characteristics.”

While the plain packaging law, barring a last-minute reprieve by the court, will be introduced in the UK, Ireland and France, the EU directive affects all EU states. Any converter who has decided to make up for lost printing income through focusing on packaging shape, will find itself at the mercy of a double whammy.

Ridgway, a former Chesapeake Branded Packaging executive, adds: “I’m a non smoker; I just think it’s excessive regulation and there’s no proof it works, from a packaging and printing point of view it’s affecting tins, pouches, the whole packaging industry. They have really got issues.”

The pro-plain packaging lobby, however, claims Australian cigarette packs which feature large, gory photographs, do work.

Research by the Cancer Council, published in the medical journal Tobacco Control last year, found 20% of smokers were trying to quit the month before the ban and 27% the month after.

UK substrate manufacturer API is one company that was actively targeting tobacco packaging and at Packaging Innovations at London’s Olympia in September last year, cigarette packets featuring its signature Fresnel Lens PET laminate took pride of place on its stand. API also produces foils used on the front of cigarette packs and the plain packaging legislation has “badly knocked” its business, according to Ridgway.

Printed tobacco packets will not suddenly disappear from shelves. Retailers have a year for ‘sell-through’ and the introduction of standardised packaging could also produce opportunities for creative businesses.

When the Australian ban was introduced in December 2012, enterprising label printers, including Box Wrap and Stickerette, decided to print sticker covers for cigarette boxes.

Stickerette has patented its whole pack wraps and now calls itself a global brand which aims to increase sales in the UK and the US under its ‘Your Pack – You Decide’ slogan.

The standardised plain pack design can be produced litho or even digitally, according to Ridgway.

Parkside, Amcor and Multi Packaging Solutions are among the packaging firms likely to be hit. The latter prints cigarette packets on gravure. Amcor Tobacco Packaging president Jerzy Czubak said the legislation posed “a real risk” to consumers.

“Standardised packaging lowers barriers of entry into the tobacco market, leading to de facto creation of scale benefits for criminal organisations trading in counterfeit tobacco. Consumers are exposed to hazardous contents in illicit tobacco products and there will be a limited capacity to authenticate and differentiate between products.

“Amcor Tobacco Packaging believes that standardised packaging represents an unnecessary intervention into not only tobacco, but also packaging in general – a legitimate and essential industry that employs hundreds of thousands of people worldwide.”

Another gravure printer which is likely to be affected by the rules is Benkert. Its Alva, Clackmannanshire plant prints the paper which goes around cigarettes.

“Our argument has always been that if you take complexity out of the packs you’re opening the market up to illicit trade,” Ridgway says. “Over £2bn is lost through tax revenue losses per year through counterfeiting. That’s £8m a day. This business about increasing price is just not going to help. The projection is that by 2020 a packet of  cigarettes will be £20 and 14% of trade will be illicit.”

Countefeiting also concerns the BPIF. General manager at BPIF Cartons Neal Whipp, says: “BPIF Cartons supports any packaging initiative that has been proven to improve public health by reducing smoking. However thus far we have not seen sufficient evidence to this effect and so there is a risk that plain packaging may make matters worse by facilitating more counterfeit products at lower prices.”

Another fear is that the incoming rules will have a knock-on effect, in other countries and in terms of other sectors coming under the plain packaging microscope.

Alcohol is the obvious contender but concerns, espoused by the anti plain-packaging fraternity at least, is that fatty and sugary foods could also be in the firing line, as a way to be seen to be doing something to appease the health lobby.

The government claimed sound reasons for pressing ahead with plain packaging. In 2012-13 it spent £87.7m on services to help people stop smoking. It says the new packs will save lives and, in addition, money. Public Health England estimates a £500m healthcare saving if the fall in smoking seen in Australia is mirrored here.

So why not ban them completely? In 2014-15 the government received £9.5bn in revenue from tobacco tax and that excludes VAT. So we have a compromise which benefits some, but packaging printers and converters least of all.

Tobacco Firms Lose Packet Legal Challenge

The European Court of Justice dismisses the final legal challenge to EU rules which aim to stop youngsters from starting smoking.

http://news.sky.com/story/tobacco-firms-lose-packet-legal-challenge-10268916

Europe’s highest court has rejected a legal challenge by tobacco firms against standardised packaging rules for cigarettes.

The ruling, at the European Court of Justice, essentially dismissed complaints that changes to EU laws went beyond what was necessary on health grounds.

It also paves the way for member states to impose further requirements such as plain packaging measures proposed in the UK, France and Ireland.

In addition, the ruling removes legal barriers to the banning of menthol cigarettes from 2020 and also electronic cigarette advertising.

The updated Tobacco Products Directive will take effect on 20 May though cigarette retailers will have a year to sell off their remaining stocks before the standardised packaging rules take effect.

They are designed to make the cartons less attractive to youngsters – with health warnings more prominent and covering 65% of a packet.

The EU hopes the move will cut smoking numbers by 2.4 million and prevent 700,000 premature deaths.

A separate legal challenge by tobacco firms against UK Government plans to remove all branding from cigarette packs is due to be heard on 18 May at the High Court and could be subject to appeal.

The packaging case against the EU was brought to by Philip Morris International, the maker of Marlboro, and the firm behind Rothmans and Benson & Hedges, British American Tobacco.

They argued that the bloc was abusing its authority.

But the ruling said: “The court finds that, in providing that each unit packet and the outside packaging must carry health warnings … the EU legislature did not go beyond the limits of what is appropriate and necessary”.

The Directive was due to be introduced in 2014 but was held up in the courts.

Deborah Arnott, chief executive of the anti-smoking charity Ash, welcomed the ruling.

She said: “We (now) await the UK court judgement, which is expected shortly, but we are optimistic that the court will confirm that the introduction of standardised packaging in the UK is lawful.

“From 20 May, all packs manufactured for sale in the UK will have to be plain, standardised, in the same drab green colour with the product name on the pack in a standard font”.

A spokesman for British American Tobacco said: “The reality is that many elements of the directive are disproportionate, distort competition and fail to respect the autonomy of member states.”

WHO’s strategy to put Big Tobacco ‘out of business’

Industry fights public health agency’s veteran chief Margaret Chan on taxes, labeling and trade.

http://www.politico.eu/article/the-whos-strategy-to-put-big-tobacco-out-of-business-margaret-chan-tax-cigarettes-labeling-rules-trade/

GENEVA — The embattled tobacco industry is struggling to fight off one of its fiercest and possibly most dangerous foes to date: the World Health Organization.

The Hong Kong native who has run the U.N. body for the past decade, Margaret Chan, takes evident pride in being called Big Tobacco’s public enemy No. 1, saying that her goal is to “make sure that the tobacco industry goes out of business.”

In the past year alone, the WHO has called for a 75 percent tax on tobacco products. It’s urging countries to set up their own “track and trace” technology to fight cigarette smuggling, ignoring pleas from tobacco companies to use their own technology. The WHO is actively lobbying European countries to keep Big Tobacco out of discussions about how to implement the EU’s 2014 directive on tobacco products ahead of a May 20 deadline. The EU directive will, among other things, put in place new package labeling rules and ban flavored cigarettes.

Behind the scenes, WHO lawyers are helping governments across the world design anti-smoking policies. In a rare move for the agency, it is taking sides in legal disputes between countries over tobacco, all the way up to the World Trade Organization.

This aggressive approach has prompted howls from the industry. To them, the organization and its boss are straying beyond the WHO’s public health mandate by seeking to regulate — and as Chan openly said, kill — the industry. The tobacco industry says they want to be treated just like any other business.

Smoking and related habits cause six million deaths each year, WHO says.

“We are being ostracized,” said Alan Hardacre, head of corporate affairs strategy at Imperial Tobacco. “One wonders who’s next: alcohol, sugar, salt? Who else is going to be arbitrarily excluded from discussions about their own business, simply because it’s decided their product is not a good one?”

Chan and the WHO are unmoved. Smoking and related habits cause six million deaths each year, the agency says, so its mission is to reduce smoking by any fair means at its disposal. “They simply have to be defeated,” Roberto Bertollini, the WHO’s representative to the EU, told a conference organized by the EU ombudsman on tobacco in late April.

Chan, the WHO director-general, declined requests for an interview.

Undue influence, or free speech?

The Geneva-based agency gained power over tobacco with adoption of the first global public health treaty negotiated under the auspices of the WHO, the so-called Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC). Signed in 2003 and ratified in 2005, the FCTC has become one of the most swiftly embraced treaties in the United Nations’ history, with 180 parties to date. Its implementation is supported by a Geneva-based secretariat housed at the WHO headquarters.

The body promotes higher tobacco taxes to cut consumption, although it only has its moral authority to do that. Since the treaty came into force, the price of tobacco products has increased on average by 150 percent, according to estimates provided by the FCTC secretariat.

“We still have a lot to cover, and our targets are modest,” Vinayak Prasad, head of the WHO’s Tobacco Free Initiative, told POLITICO. Industry fights taxation “tooth and nail” because it’s the most powerful tool to fight smoking, he added. According to Prasad, only one in 10 countries is following through on promises to raise taxes and too few are banning advertising and slapping health warnings on packs.

For the champions of the WHO’s hard line on cigarettes, one of the problems is the undue influence of the tobacco lobby. The FCTC secretariat invoked a provision in the treaty that governs ties between the industry and governments to restrict Big Tobacco’s access to meetings on how to implement the accord.

Not fair, say tobacco representatives, who accuse Chan of stifling debate. At a recent gathering in Moscow on the FCTC, industry representatives, members of the public and journalists were reportedly thrown out of the room. Attendees are now screened ahead of the meetings.

“The process has been increasingly exclusionary and lacking integrity, balanced decision-making and transparency,” said Ben Townsend, a lobbyist for Japan Tobacco International.

Industry representatives have managed to sneak into the meetings, in some cases swapping badges with other delegates, said Katharina Kummer Peiry, a senior legal adviser at the FCTC secretariat. “It’s really quite a dirty fight sometimes,” she told POLITICO.

The fox and the cigarette

Separately, the WHO and the FCTC secretariat are urging the EU to keep its distance from industry as Brussels looks at ways to fight the illicit trade in cigarettes under a recent addition to the FCTC.

The WHO push comes as the EU is mulling whether to renew anti-fraud settlements struck with tobacco companies to compel them to take responsibility for when their products are smuggled across borders, avoiding taxes. EU anti-fraud officials are also considering a tracing technology developed by the world’s four largest tobacco companies, known as Codentify.

European cigarette manufacturers contend they simply have practical know-how that could help identify “solutions and realistic ways forward.”

WHO officials have been outspoken on this point. They argue this would run against the FCTC Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, which was signed in 2012 but still needs to be ratified by around two dozen parties, including by the EU, to become legally binding. The protocol states that obligations to clamp down on smuggling “shall not be performed by or delegated to the tobacco industry.”

“Imagine that you are approached by a fox who offers help, including a hi-tech tracking system so that you can trace the chickens and find out who is stealing them,” the head of the FCTC secretariat, Vera Luiza da Costa e Silva, said in a February op-ed in the EU Observer. “Is it wise to put a fox in charge of a hen house?”

The WHO’s Prasad says that the EU should be able to do this job itself, noting that Kenya and Turkey, with much smaller economies than Europe’s, have set up independent track and trace systems in just three years. “Why can’t the EU? Why do they want kids’ gloves?” Prasad asked.

European cigarette manufacturers contend they simply have practical know-how that could help identify “solutions and realistic ways forward.”

“This is an incredibly technical area and it’s very difficult to imagine finding some solution without including us in the discussion,” Imperial Tobacco’s Hardacre said. “This is core to what we do. These are our factories. This is going to impact us, and we have a lot of technical expertise.”

‘Clouded by zealousness’

Peter van der Mark, secretary-general of the European Smoking Tobacco Association, called the WHO “clouded by emotion and zealousness” in its bid to eradicate smoking.

“A smoke-free Europe is very difficult to achieve, because you’re bending the habits of people who in many countries regard it as a free choice,” he said.

Even as they battle, both sides admit smoking is a habit that’s tough to change.

Large no-smoking signs greet visitors at WHO’s leafy Geneva headquarters, and for eight years now, the organization has had a policy of not hiring smokers, or at least those who don’t want to quit.

But within the entirely “healthy, smoke-free” campus, on one wing of the building, a smaller laminated note is pinned onto a pillar.

“Do not throw butts on the ground,” it read. “Use your own ashtray. Thanks, the gardeners.”