Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Europe

EU court rules against Maltese ex-commissioner Dalli

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-32702526

image001

The EU’s top court has dismissed a case brought by Maltese ex-Commissioner John Dalli against the European Commission in which he sought compensation.

Mr Dalli left his job as EU health commissioner in 2012, accused of improper links to tobacco lobbyists.

The European Court of Justice has ruled that he resigned voluntarily. He had argued that ex-Commission chief Jose Manuel Barroso had asked him to resign.

Mr Barroso said Mr Dalli had put the Commission’s integrity at risk.

Tobacco furore

A statement from the court said that, when Mr Barroso met Mr Dalli on 16 October 2012, Mr Barroso “decided… that Mr Dalli should leave the Commission”.

Despite Mr Barroso’s decision, he did not utter a “clearly formulated” request for his resignation, according to the Luxembourg judges.

“Since the existence of that request… has not been established, the Court dismisses the action as inadmissible. The court also rejects Mr Dalli’s claim for compensation,” the ECJ statement said.

EU anti-fraud agency Olaf had earlier delivered a report asserting that Mr Dalli had held unauthorised secret meetings with tobacco industry representatives.

According to Olaf, a Maltese entrepreneur had sought a “considerable” payment from a Swedish producer of oral tobacco, called snus, after which Mr Dalli would lift an EU ban on the product.

Sweden has an exemption from the ban, but it cannot export snus to other EU countries. Mr Dalli denied any knowledge of such an approach by the entrepreneur.

If the ECJ had supported his allegation of unfair dismissal he could have been entitled to compensation for loss of earnings.

Commission calls on EU to ratify FCTC illicit trade protocol

http://www.tobaccojournal.com/Commission_calls_on_EU_to_ratify_FCTC_illicit_trade_protocol.52990.0.html

The European Commission called on the European Union to follow through on a commitment made more than two years ago to ratify the illicit tobacco trade protocol of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC).

Only seven countries, including EU members Spain and Austria, have ratified the Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products since it was approved at an FCTC meeting in Seoul, Korea, in November, 2012. Forty ratifications are necessary for the protocol to take effect, the Commission noted in its statement. Ratification by the 26 member countries that have not done so and the EU as a ratifying body would add raise the number of approving parties to 34.

FCTC is the first international treaty operating under the auspices of the World Health Organisation.

Commission proposes EU joins international agreement fighting tobacco smuggling

Download (PDF, 170KB)

International Conference on the Shadow Economy and Taxation

Download (PDF, 1.39MB)

First tobacco giant challenges plain package laws

http://www.independent.ie/irish-news/health/first-tobacco-giant-challenges-plain-package-laws-31106383.html

Japan Tobacco International has launched a legal bid to halt the Government’s controversial plain packaging measures

ONE of the world’s largest tobacco firms has launched a legal bid to halt the Government’s controversial plain packaging measures, the Irish Independent can reveal.

Japan Tobacco International (JTI) formally lodged papers in the High Court yesterday which names the State, the Attorney General and Health Minister Leo Varadkar as defendants.

While tobacco firms have previously threatened legal action over the plain packaging measures, JTI is understood to be the first firm to launch a legal bid.

The cigarette giant, which owns the Benson & Hedges and Silk Cut brands, is seeking to halt the plain packaging plans on the basis that the European Court of Justice is hearing a case that bears directly on the right of an EU member state to introduce such measures.

The company will argue Ireland is operating outside of the parameters of EU law.

European Tobacco Products Directive

http://www.packagingtoday.co.uk/features/featureeuropean-tobacco-products-directive-4542138/

Robert Sykes, Commercial Development Director at Essentra, explains how the European Tobacco Products Directive may impact on the packaging industry and what is already being done to protect consumers and fight the illicit trade in counterfeit and smuggled product.

1) What is the European Union Tobacco Product Directive and its objectives?

The World Health Organisation’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) Protocol requires the implementation of systems to track and trace tobacco products throughout the supply chain. As a result of this the European Commission has recently revised its Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) and is currently drafting implementing and delegated acts for Article 15 – Tracking & Tracing and Article 16 – Security Feature.
How Article 16 is implemented in particular will have an ongoing effect on the packaging industry. If the commission goes ahead and defines the very specifics of visible and invisible security features on the packaging in implementing acts, given both visible and invisible security feature technologies evolve with unprecedented speed, the status quo would be cemented for years.

2) Why is the illicit tobacco trade such a concern?

CTA COMMENT: THE WRITER IGNORES THE FACT THAT THE TOBACCO COMPANIES SMUGGLE THEIR OWN PRODUCTS AND KPMG REPORTS PAID FOR BY BIG TOBACCO ARE CRITICALLY DESTROYED BY ACADEMICS USING FACTUAL EVIDENCE!

Illicit tobacco is a crime that’s significance is often underestimated. It’s seen as something that only hurts the industry. Yet that pack of cigarettes bought in the pub is part of a criminal trade that, according to KPMG, accounts for up to 12% of the global cigarette market and more than 58 billion cigarettes in the EU alone. A single lorry of illicit cigarettes can net more than €1.3m for the criminal gangs that are largely behind this trade. Part of annual profits estimated at €5bn each year, these proceeds are often used to fund other illegal activities such as people trafficking, drugs and even terrorism. Not only do the criminals profit, but Treasuries, and public spending, lose out, as smugglers don’t pay excise duty.

3) What options are being considered regarding changes to packaging?

A number of security measures are being considered, from solutions built into the pack, such as invisible inks, digital codes and forensic technology to paper-based stick-on authentication stamps. The commission is also considering whether or not to mandate features according to a set of open standards or whether to stipulate one proprietary system.
The worry of mandating a one-size-fits all, EU-wide, security feature is the risk of giving counterfeiters a specification for them to copy; particularly is that is a relatively easy to forge stamp based solution. Furthermore, even genuine paper based stamps can be removed, stolen or diverted and reused on other products to legitimise an illegal product.

4) When will decisions be made and the laws come into force?

The European Commission included tracking and tracing (Article 15) and product authentication (Article 16) in its Tobacco Products Directive, which came into force on 19 May 2014.
The European Commission is still considering the best way to implement this Directive. The implementing acts directives will be determined by early 2017.

5) Why is the legislation relevant to the packaging industry?

The security feature mandated by Article 16 will be incorporated into and attached to the packaging, affecting the manufacturing process. Packaging already plays an essential role in the fight against counterfeit tobacco products and there are a range of security solutions and technologies in the market to enable this.

6) Would this affect current packaging?

In consumer goods, from alcohol and pharmaceuticals to cigarettes, the issue of the illicit trade in potentially harmful counterfeit and contraband products is being tackled by a wide variety of innovative covert, overt and forensic solutions within packaging to authenticate genuine products. And this variety of supply of solutions and suppliers is an essential part of staying ahead of counterfeiters and enabling packaging companies to deliver continued value in protecting brands and products for companies.
Dependent on the solution or solutions mandated by the directive the packaging industry could have to adapt to a specified proprietary solution which would stifle competition and prevent new innovative authentication measures being implemented.

7) What is the industry’s preferred solution?
We fully support the objectives of Article 16 of the EU TPD, in terms of improving efforts to tackle the illicit trade. However, based on our experience, we would urge the EU to include two principles that we believe are key in relation to ensuring the effectiveness of Article 16
i. Specification of a standard, not a prescribed technology
In our opinion, prescribing a single solution as the security feature within Article 16 runs the risk of providing counterfeiters with a ‘recipe’ for manufacturing illicit tobacco products, as much as it helps to protect genuine ones. Were the technology to be compromised – either through direct counterfeiting or ‘passing off’ – then there would be no accepted alternative solution to counter this, nor to provide a mechanism by which consumers could validate a product’s authenticity.
ii. Make the security feature an intrinsic part of the pack
We believe that the implementing act should also ensure the security feature takes a multi-layered approach, combining instantly recognisable visible features together with hidden covert and forensic elements as an intrinsic part of the pack, rather than having to be separately applied.

In this way, the security device cannot be removed or reused, and the feature therefore verifies the authenticity of the pack – and not just the security feature itself. Taggant technology for example, is directly integrated as part of the packaging and immediately demonstrates through the use of simple readers if the pack is genuine, ensuring highly effective product authentication.
By taking these key principles into account the implementing act should ensure – even in the event of a technology being compromised – that there are other available options and, importantly, that there are a range of authorised suppliers which are able to provide a range of credible alternative security solutions. Also by integrating technology directly onto the packaging this ensures the product can be authenticated as genuine and not just the security feature itself.

8) Why would this be favourable to the packaging industry?

Defining a standard, not a prescribed technology, ensures the ability to use a variety of security features within packaging to protect against counterfeit and benefits a number of packaging technology providers not just one, ensuring competiveness as well as security.

9) Are these solutions being implemented in any other markets?

While Europe looks at blanket solutions for the TPD, Member States like the UK are already leading the field in implementing authentication technology from digital codes and unique identifiers to the use of secure covert technologies such as taggant inks. It is this layered approach that works best, whether it’s illicit cigarettes or other products facing similar challenges at the hands of counterfeiters, like alcohol and pharmaceuticals.

10) What will be the impact of proposals in to introduce standardised packaging for tobacco products in the UK and Ireland?

While we do not know what the results will be in these markets, it is likely the introduction of standardised packaging could offer an opportunity for criminals to more easily create counterfeit products. As such, the requirement to use integral, covert and overt authentication measures becomes more pressing as consumers and authorities will not be able to use packaging designs as a visual identification of a product’s authenticity. It should be noted that plain packaging is not part of the EU TPD.

11) What is the industry doing to ensure its voice is heard in Brussels?

Companies are engaging with European political representatives to ensure the voice of the packaging industry is heard in the debate around and creation of the implementing acts.
The illicit trade isn’t going away; and if anything the criminals are getting ever more sophisticated. The European Commission has the ability to implement standards across the region that make it much harder for counterfeit and contraband to slip through the net, but it must be careful not to prescribe a ‘recipe’ for criminals in this fight against counterfeit products. Open standards keep the industry innovating, a prescribed solution makes it easier for the criminals to catch-up.

As Europe adopts Australia’s plain packaging reforms, big tobacco fights back

http://www.smh.com.au/world/as-europe-adopts-australias-plain-packaging-reforms-big-tobacco-fights-back-20150321-1m3bwk.html

There are winners and losers in the plain packaging for cigarettes battle. Big business is trying valiantly to its protect its ground.

Weed killers: Former attorney-general Nicola Roxon has been meeting European campaigners such as Norwegian Cancer Society's Anne Lise Ryel about the push for plain paper packaging. Photo: Supplied

Weed killers: Former attorney-general Nicola Roxon has been meeting European campaigners such as Norwegian Cancer Society’s Anne Lise Ryel about the push for plain paper packaging. Photo: Supplied

“It’s a bit stunning … dominos falling everywhere.”

Mike Daube, mild-mannered health policy professor from Western Australia, is surveying the virtual battlefield in the war against big tobacco. And he likes what he sees.

“It really is the most dramatic global development in tobacco control that I can remember in more than 40 years.”

A pile of cigarette packets with plain packaging. Photo: Nic Walker

A pile of cigarette packets with plain packaging. Photo: Nic Walker

This month alone saw Ireland and Britain legislate for plain cigarette packets with big ugly health warnings, following Australia’s 2012 lead. Norway and France – and others – are hard on their heels.

These wins have come despite fierce opposition from the tobacco industry. Lawyers have threatened huge lawsuits, piles of specially-commissioned reports have been delivered to key lobbyists, legislators and opinion-makers, and the industry even (Daube’s colleagues claim) played dirty tricks along the way.

“I haven’t seen the industry as ferocious about anything in more than 40 years,” says Prof Daube. “They clearly do see it as a massive threat, especially now that so many dominos are falling.”

Also this week, billionaire philanthropists Michael Bloomberg and Bill Gates dug for small change in the sofa and found $US4 million to help developing countries fight legal threats from tobacco companies.

The fund was launched (and Prof Daube was speaking) from Abu Dhabi, where the 16th World Conference on Tobacco has the air of a war room, mid-campaign.

There were rousing speeches. Talk of tactics and strategies and alliances. War stories were shared and heads put together to try to read the mind of the enemy.

Deterrent packaging

Deterrent packaging

Dr Douglas Bettcher, director of prevention of noncommunicable diseases at the WHO, was there. He agrees tobacco control measures are being adopted at “an extraordinary pace”.

Two and a half weeks ago Ireland passed plain packaging legislation, last week similar legislation passed the UK House of Commons and Singapore announced a public consultation on plain packaging. This week the House of Lords passed it into law in the UK, Norway released a public consultation document proposing it and plain packaging bills are under discussion in Panama and South Africa, Dr Bettcher says.

This is not to mention moves in France, New Zealand, Burkina Faso and Turkey.

“All of this progress is being made despite the industry’s best efforts to thwart it,” he says. “Given that the industry fights hardest against the most effective tobacco control measures, it must be very worried about what the globalisation of plain packaging could do, and it is very busy concocting false evidence and lobbying hard against it.

“This is an important moment in the history of tobacco control. We are witnessing the creation of a global movement.”

A keynote presenter in Abu Dhabi was Dr James Reilly, a mellifluous Irishman with a flair for the dramatic. He sounds like a victorious general back from the front.

This month Ireland became the second country in the world and the first in Europe to enact plain packaging legislation. Reilly shepherded the law through, as Minister for Children.

“This has been a long journey,” he says. He called for a round of applause for Australia for paving the way and inspiring their decision to follow – however, he says, “there were far more twists and turns than we ever anticipated.”

To start with, European law did not permit plain packaging. Ireland had to use its 2013 presidency of the EU to push new laws through.

“But when the directive made its way to the European Parliament we saw the full power and influence of the tobacco industry at work,” Reilly says.

Documents leaked to The Observer newspaper showed 161 lobbyists were hired by just one tobacco company. Philip Morris International strategised to delay the directive until the EU presidency passed to tobacco-friendly Lithuania.

In one year lobbyists claimed almost £1.24 million in expenses for meetings with MEPs, The Observer reported. They held personal meetings with a third of all the huge parliament’s members, some up to five times. They targeted farmers’ organisations, retail bodies and trade and business organisations.

“Members of the EU parliament complained that the scale of lobbying on this directive was unprecedented,” Reilly says. “There was a very real danger that the parliament would vote in favour of reducing the size of warnings.”
The Irish prevailed in Brussels. The focus switched back home – and the tobacco industry followed.

They enlisted members of the EU parliament, US congressmen, Indonesian farmers and Irish retailers to their cause.

“We were lobbied on a scale that Irish politics had never seen before,” Reilly says.

Benson and Hedges owner JTI Ireland (a 55-billion-euro multinational based in Geneva) warned in the last desperate week before the bill went to parliament, that the government had just days to withdraw or face a High Court claim for hefty damages.

“(Their) letter was especially aggressive,” says Reilly. “Not only did they attempt to tell a sovereign government that we did not have the authority … they attempted to tell us how far we could progress it through our parliament and insisted that we provide them with a written undertaking within a matter of days not to progress it any further.”

Imperial Tobacco and Philip Morris echoed the threats.

“But we had built a strong coalition that proved impenetrable,” Reilly says. As a doctor he had seen firsthand the devastation caused by lung cancer. He told his stories to his colleagues. Not one member of parliament voted against the law, he says.

“[Big tobacco’s] only aim is to protect their profits. Our aim and our duty is to protect the health of our people especially that of our children. We have the truth on our side and truth, as an old lady once told me, is not fragile, will not break. Nor will we.”

Cigarette companies including BAT are now “considering their legal options”, Fairfax was told.

Then it was the UK’s turn. Prime minister David Cameron had once been a plain packaging fan but by 2013 the plan sat in the coldest corner of the backburner after his Australian strategist-for-hire Lynton Crosby reportedly told him to “scrape the barnacles off the boat” in preparation for the 2015 election.

Crosby, who also consults for Philip Morris, denied that he had ever discussed plain packaging with the PM. But for whatever reason, it seemed dead.

But then up popped the policy again, suddenly, amid the dying embers of the final legislative sitting. Fairfax understands the government’s hand was forced by a strong push for a private members bill in the House of Lords.

Again, the tobacco companies campaigned strongly. Media were heavily briefed against plain packaging, as were MPs. Opinion columns rehearsed the tobacco lobby’s song sheet (to be fair, by now the anti-tobacco lobby’s arguments were just as well-practised).

The law passed, despite a sizable rebellion among MPs (and many who had to abstain, citing conflicts of interest or revealing previous tobacco lobby gifts such as tickets to the Chelsea Flower Show).

A spokesperson for British American Tobacco told Fairfax there will be legal action. “This legislation is a case of the UK Government taking property from a UK business without paying for it. That is illegal under both UK and European law.”

“The UK Government has left us with no other choice… Any business that has property taken away from it by the state would inevitably want to challenge and seek compensation.”

You could call it The Castle argument. As Darryl Kerrigan might put it, a cigarette packet is more than just a drawing on a box. By removing a company’s right to use their own brand, you are stealing something from them. The tobacco lobby has other arguments but this is the core of their fight: not to lose their identity.

Unlike in The Castle, this line failed in Australia’s High Court. But it is now being fought in two international jurisdictions including the WTO, on the basis that the laws breach Australia’s treaty obligations. And it will be fought again against the UK and possibly Ireland.

And now it is Norway’s turn to enter the fray.

This week, in a restaurant on a scenic hill overlooking Oslo, Norway’s health minister lunched with the local secretary-general of the Norwegian Cancer Society, Anne Lise Ryel, on the day of the launch of a consultation paper on plain packaging – which also proposed new transparency rules on tobacco industry lobbying.

There was another guest at the table: Nicola Roxon, Australia’s former health minister and attorney-general, the politician who used her two key roles in the former Labour government to formulate and then enact the laws that set a precedent for the world.

Roxon is out of politics but finds herself in demand globally for her experience in the fight for plain packaging.

“We were looking to Australia to see what happened and to learn,” Ryel tells Fairfax. “In this consultation paper Australia is mentioned many times.”

They wanted to see, particularly, how the industry would fight. “All the time they become more sophisticated because they need to… they always try to be a step or two ahead,” Ryel says.

They have seen dirty tricks already: in a previous legal fight against Philip Morris the tobacco companies spread their money around Oslo’s law firms, leaving them unable to advise the government.

Bent Hoie, Norway’s health minister, tells Fairfax that Australia should be “commended” for leading the way. “That has been very important for us, we have a complete example to follow. We can use their experience and be better prepared for what kind of resistance we will meet.”

Ms Roxon says she is proud – and Australia should be proud of what it has achieved and what might yet be achieved following Australia’s lead.

“I’m really pleased to be able to share our experience and hope that other countries will be able to avoid some of the problems,” she says.

“You can’t just have the first, you need to have the second, third and fourth for it to become something that people will do as a matter of course.”

She says the Norwegians are “super-organised and super-committed” but have been picking her brains on the tobacco industry’s likely response, especially how they brought employer and business lobbies into the argument.

It may sound like big tobacco is losing an existential battle. But not so fast. Last year the world smoked more than 5.8 trillion cigarettes. The number was comparable to the year before, in which tobacco industry profits were more than $US44 billion according to Tobacco Atlas.

Barely a 10th of the world’s population lives in countries with bans on tobacco advertising. Low- and middle-income countries now account for more than 80 per cent of tobacco users – and tobacco-related deaths.

The reduction in smoking rates in countries such as Britain, Australia and Brazil was more than offset by growing consumption in China alone.

“Developing markets are driving our growth – while developed markets are the source of current profits, developing markets are the drivers of future profits,” a BAT spokesperson tells Fairfax.

So why bother with Norway, when you’ve got China?

Ryel says she believes her country, and others, are setting an example, and providing a template that others can follow.

“That’s why it’s so important that we help the other countries, to see the force we put the other way. What happens in Norway, we think and hope is helpful for other countries that want to go on board, they will feel more secure.”

If this idea catches on, it could snuff out tobacco on a global scale

‘Constant meddling’ of tobacco lobbies preventing effective anti-smoking legislation

https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/articles/opinion/constant-meddling-tobacco-lobbies-preventing-effective-anti-smoking-legislation

Gilles Pargneaux outlines why the EU must act urgently to counter the growing influence of tobacco manufacturers.

Tobacco is the only legal consumer product that kills its users when they follow the manufacturer’s exact instructions.

Currently, smoking kills nearly six million people a year, including 700,000 in Europe – this is the equivalent of the population of a city the size of Frankfurt. By 2030, this number could rise to eight million.

In order to reverse this worrying trend, strong action must be taken.

We already know what measures best serve the fight against smoking. What gets in the way of effectively implementing them is the tobacco industry’s constant meddling in our policymaking.

This meddling is continuous and premeditated. It occurs on all levels of tobacco manufacturing – from its cultivation, to its transformation, all the way to its marketing.

“Currently, smoking kills nearly six million people a year, including 700,000 in Europe – this is the equivalent of the population of a city the size of Frankfurt. By 2030, this number could rise to eight million”

This is why I have decided to create a working group against tobacco manufacturers’ interference in decision making. Joining me in this endeavour are Paris councillor Pauline Delpech (Greens), Françoise Grossetête (EPP, FR), Robert Rochert (ALDE, FR), Frédérique Ries (ALDE, BE), José Bové (Greens/EFA, FR), Bart Staes (Greens/EFA, BE), Michèle Rivasi (Greens/EFA, FR), Younous Omarjee (GUE/NGL, FR), Eleonora Evi (EFDD, IT) and Fabio Massimo Castaldo (EFDD, IT).

This group will bring together MEPs from all parties and all nationalities, as well as representatives from anti-smoking organisations. Over 40 deputies have already indicated that they would like to join the working group.

Our logic is simple, but radically different from what has been done in the past. We will strive to set up new anti-smoking policies that take aim at manufacturers.

During the revision process of tobacco products directive, we witnessed cigarette producers prospering through the use of a wide array of tactics and strategies to defy anti-smoking policies.

200 lobbyists were recruited by the three main tobacco producers – Philip Morris, British American Tobacco and Japan Tobacco – with a budget of €5m at their disposal to kill the tobacco products directive.

The forced resignation of European health and consumer policy commissioner John Dalli and classification of MEPs according to their stance on tobacco products by Philip Morris are sad illustrations of this.

Fortunately, there is a solution to counter this global threat – the world health organisation’s framework convention on tobacco control. In total, 179 countries, in addition to the EU, have decided to adopt this international convention to contain the smoking epidemic and its slew of illnesses.

These countries have signalled their commitment to fighting against tobacco lobbies’ influence, as stated by the convention, “by defining and applying their public health policies related to anti-smoking measures, the signatories will ensure that these policies are not influenced by the commercial interests of the tobacco industry, in line with national laws”.

Our working group’s main goal will be to ensure this article is respected within the European and national institutions.

In this context, we will oversee the ambitious implementation of the tobacco products directive in all member states and will do everything we can to prevent the renewal of dubious cooperation agreements between the EU and tobacco manufacturers in the fight against the illegal sale of cigarettes.

About the author

Gilles Pargneaux (S&D, FR) is a vice-chair of parliament’s environment, public health and food safety committee

 

‘Constant meddling’ of tobacco lobbies preventing effective anti-smoking legislation

https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/articles/opinion/constant-meddling-tobacco-lobbies-preventing-effective-anti-smoking-legislation

Tobacco is the only legal consumer product that kills its users when they follow the manufacturer’s exact instructions.

Currently, smoking kills nearly six million people a year, including 700,000 in Europe – this is the equivalent of the population of a city the size of Frankfurt. By 2030, this number could rise to eight million. In order to reverse this worrying trend, strong action must be taken. We already know what measures best serve the fight against smoking. What gets in the way of effectively implementing them is the tobacco industry’s constant meddling in our policymaking. This meddling is continuous and premeditated. It occurs on all levels of tobacco manufacturing – from its cultivation, to its transformation, all the way to its marketing. “Currently, smoking kills nearly six million people a year, including 700,000 in Europe – this is the equivalent of the population of a city the size of Frankfurt. By 2030, this number could rise to eight million”

This is why I have decided to create a working group against tobacco manufacturers’ interference in decision making. Joining me in this endeavour are Paris councillor Pauline Delpech (Greens), Françoise Grossetête (EPP, FR), Robert Rochert (ALDE, FR), Frédérique Ries (ALDE, BE), José Bové (Greens/EFA, FR), Bart Staes (Greens/EFA, BE), Michèle Rivasi (Greens/EFA, FR), Younous Omarjee (GUE/NGL, FR), Eleonora Evi (EFDD, IT) and Fabio Massimo Castaldo (EFDD, IT).

This group will bring together MEPs from all parties and all nationalities, as well as representatives from anti-smoking organisations. Over 40 deputies have already indicated that they would like to join the working group. Our logic is simple, but radically different from what has been done in the past. We will strive to set up new anti-smoking policies that take aim at manufacturers. During the revision process of tobacco products directive, we witnessed cigarette producers prospering through the use of a wide array of tactics and strategies to defy anti-smoking policies. 200 lobbyists were recruited by the three main tobacco producers – Philip Morris, British American Tobacco and Japan Tobacco – with a budget of €5m at their disposal to kill the tobacco products directive.

The forced resignation of European health and consumer policy commissioner John Dalli and classification of MEPs according to their stance on tobacco products by Philip Morris are sad illustrations of this. Fortunately, there is a solution to counter this global threat – the world health organisation’s framework convention on tobacco control. In total, 179 countries, in addition to the EU, have decided to adopt this international convention to contain the smoking epidemic and its slew of illnesses.

These countries have signalled their commitment to fighting against tobacco lobbies’ influence, as stated by the convention, “by defining and applying their public health policies related to anti-smoking measures, the signatories will ensure that these policies are not influences by the commercial interests of the tobacco industry, in line with national laws”.

Our working group’s main goal will be to ensure this article is respected within the European and national institutions.

In this context, we will oversee the ambitious implementation of the tobacco products directive in all member states and will do everything we can to prevent the renewal of dubious cooperation agreements between the EU and tobacco manufacturers in the fight against the illegal sale of cigarettes.

About the author
Gilles Pargneaux (S&D, FR) is a vice-chair of parliament’s environment, public health and food safety committee.

MEPs declare ‘war’ on tobacco companies

https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/articles/news/meps-declare-war-tobacco-companies

A cross-party working group has been set up in the European parliament to counter the growing influence of tobacco companies.

The group was put together by S&D deputy Gilles Pargneaux, who is a vice-chair of parliament’s environment, public health and food safety committee, at the behest of Paris councillor Pauline Delpech, who has been campaigning against the tobacco industry in France.

Pargneaux pointed out that “currently six million deaths worldwide are linked to smoking, including 700,000 in Europe – this is equivalent to the population of a city the size of Frankfurt”. He added that this amounts to “1900 deaths a day” and that “by 2030, tobacco could cause up to eight million deaths a year”.

Outlining the working group’s priorities, he said, “our main focus is to make sure the tobacco products directive is implemented in all member states”. The new rules were adopted by parliament in March last year, and include banning flavoured cigarettes, tougher measures for eCigarettes and more health warnings on cigarette packaging.

The Frenchman added that the group would be looking at “combating contraband, counterfeiting and cross-border shopping”.

Additionally, he called for the enforcement of “article 5.3 of the world health organisation’s framework convention on tobacco control”. This rule “requires all parties, when setting and implementing their public health policies with respect to tobacco control, to act to protect these policies from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry in accordance with national law”.

Pargneaux accused tobacco companies of “spending a lot of money to keep tribunals off their back” and said, “we know that by going after these firms, we are unlikely to make many friends”.

“Every day, every second, someone dies because of tobacco, and every second, the main tobacco companies continue to churn out profits of up to €7bn” – Fabio Massimo Castaldo

He also insisted that this new working group “is not here to engage in anti-smoking politics”.

However, not all members of the group went along with this rhetoric, with ALDE deputy Robert Rochefort saying that he was staunchly opposed to smoking.

The French MEP, who is a vice-chair of parliament’s internal market and consumer protection committee, commented that “the tobacco lobby is certainly one of the most powerful in the world”, explaining that “it has evolved and learned to negotiate”.

José Bové, a member of parliament’s Greens/EFA group, accused the tobacco industry of “shopping around Europe without anyone getting in the way – this is an extremely serious threat to democracy”.

He was especially critical of the European anti-fraud office (Olaf), saying cigarette companies had “received an unbelievable amount of support” from the organisation.

According to the French deputy, this was proven by “the John Dalli case”. John Dalli was European health and consumer policy commissioner from 2010 but 2012, but was forced to resign after one of his associates was accused of requesting over €60m from Swedish snus producer Swedish Match, in exchange for the commissioner’s help changing tobacco regulations. Dalli has always denied any knowledge of the alleged bribery.

Bové claimed that Olaf director general Giovanni Kessler “covered up investigations into the matter”.

Kessler was not the only European official to come under fire, with Belgian MEP Bart Staes accusing “budget and human resources commissioner Kristalina Georgieva, or perhaps members of her staff and even Olaf representatives [of] entering into secret negotiations with tobacco manufacturers” to come up with a new agreement.

The commission currently has a deal with the four main tobacco companies (Philip Morris International, Japan Tobacco, British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco Limited) whereby they pay a collective total of €1.9bn to the EU and taking steps to prevent the illegal trade of cigarettes.

EFDD MEP Fabio Massimo Castaldo highlighted that “every day, every second, someone dies because of tobacco, and every second, the main tobacco companies continue to churn out profits of up to €7bn”.
He underlined, “we are at war – and I am not afraid of using that word – with tobacco companies, both for medical and ethical reasons”.

Seeking to take the working group into yet another direction, his fellow group member, Eleonora Evi, said that the new set-up should be “part of a larger battle against lobbies in general”.

About the author
Julie Levy-Abegnoli is a journalist and editorial assistant for the Parliament Magazine