Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Europe

One in four e-cigs will be banned in Britain next year after being branded too strong in European Court ruling

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3372351/One-four-e-cigs-banned-Britain-year-branded-strong-European-Court-ruling.html

  • Experts are concerned that e-cigs are gateway for teens to smoke tobacco
  • Under new EU directive e-cigs will have to carry a health warning on them
  • New rules, in May, could also see cigarettes only sold in packets of 20
  • Around 2.6 million adults in UK have used e-cigs in the past decade

A quarter of e-cigarettes are set to be banned in Britain next year after Europe’s highest court paved the way for tough new regulations.

Juliane Kokott, advocate general to the European Court of Justice, warned that e-cigarettes may act as a ‘gateway’ for teenagers to go on to smoke tobacco.

Dr Kokott, the EU’s most senior legal officer, said regulation is needed because of ‘possible risks to human health’.

Her intervention will have huge implications for the debate currently raging between health experts in Britain, some of whom insist that e-cigarettes will save thousands of lives, and others who are concerned that they have not yet been proven to be safe.

Dr Kokott said an industry challenge against the new rules – which are due to be introduced in May as part of a new EU directive – should be dismissed.

Judges at the court will have the final say when they deliver a ruling in March.

If they take Dr Kokott’s advice, and dismiss industry objections, vaping devices will no longer be allowed to contain more than 20 mg of nicotine per ml of liquid.

Analysis by London Economics, a policy consultancy, suggests that 25 per cent of the gadgets currently on sale use liquid stronger than this threshold.

The EU Tobacco Products Directive will also mean adverts have to be much more strictly regulated so that teenagers are not targeted.

E-cigarettes will have to carry health warnings telling people they contain a ‘highly addictive substance’.

And the size of refills and of the ‘tanks’ on the gadgets will also be limited for the first time.

Dr Kokott also said that a separate challenge from big tobacco firms over plain packaging for cigarette boxes should be dismissed, paving the way for rules to be brought in from May.

If that change goes through, cigarette packets will only be sold in boxes of 20, the packets will only allowed to be brown or green, and will carry a health warning covering 65 per cent of the box.

E-cigarettes contain a liquid form of nicotine that is heated into vapour to be inhaled, avoiding the harm caused by tobacco smoke.

Industry figures yesterday warned that the new rules will mean vapers are ‘outlawed’ and may go back to smoking if they cannot get the strongest e-cigarettes – but health charities say it is right that emerging industry is properly regulated.

Health experts agree that the devices are much safer than smoking tobacco – but some are concerned about unresolved safety concerns.

The World Health Organisation has warned that they may be toxic to bystanders, many rail companies have banned people from vaping on trains or in stations, and the Welsh Government is planning to prohibit the practice in restaurants, pubs and offices from 2017.

Yet Public Health England claimed in a report earlier this year that vaping was ‘95 per cent safe’ – a claim that was widely criticised when it emerged that it originated with scientists in the pay of the e-cigarette industry.

Dr Kokott said in a written ‘opinion’ presented to the court yesterday: ‘It is not manifestly wrong or unreasonable to accept that e-cigarettes possibly cause risks to human health and that that product could — above all in the case of adolescents and young adults — develop into a gateway to nicotine addiction and, ultimately, traditional tobacco consumption.’

Around 2.6 million adults in Britain have used e-cigarettes in the decade or so that they have been on the market.

Public health experts are keen to promote the gadgets as a smoking-cessation tool.

But they are concerned that the devices are being advertised as a lifestyle accessory – in much the same way that tobacco was in the past.

Ian Gregory, who runs the 100K group of e-cigarette companies, threatened that vapers would feel ‘outlawed’ – and would vote to leave the EU in a bid to rid themselves of the regulation.

He said: ‘Britain’s vapers are determined to save the devices which they believe save their lives.

‘They will now start playing a game of Brexit Poker with the Commission – threatening to vote for Britain to leave the EU in the referendum unless the Commission insists on Britain having an opt-out.

‘There is little awareness yet among politicians as to just how damaging the EU Tobacco Products Directive could be for the e-cigarette industry.’

He claimed that the ban on stronger e-liquid would drive so many vapers back to smoking that it would cost 105,000 lives every year across Europe.

But Alison Cox, director of prevention at Cancer Research UK, said regulation is needed.

‘We believe e-cigarettes need light touch regulations which will help guarantee products are safe and effective, and prevent them being promoted to non-smokers and children,’ she said.

‘But the implementation of these regulations needs to be monitored to ensure that they don’t prevent smokers who want to use e-cigarettes from doing so. It’ s important that people who want to, are able to move away from tobacco cigarettes, which are responsible for one in four cancer deaths.’

Deborah Arnott, chief executive of health charity Action on Smoking and Health, added: ‘Growing numbers of governments around the world are banning the sale of electronic cigarettes.

‘The EU, by regulating them as consumer products, and allowing their sale and use, is recognising the value of these products as alternatives to smoking.’

Totally Wicked, the Blackburn-based e-cigarette company which headed the legal objection, last night played down the significance of the document.

Fraser Cropper, Totally Wicked’s managing director, said: ‘This is not a formal decision, nor a legal judgement on the questions we raised in our challenge.

‘It is a legal opinion prepared to assist the judges in making their decision and will be considered alongside the written and oral submissions. It is not binding.’

European court paves the way for plain cigarette packaging

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/5469463a-a968-11e5-955c-1e1d6de94879.html#axzz3vF5CU4yL

Aliya Ram in London

The EU’s highest court has opened the path to the introduction of plain cigarette packaging laws across the continent, striking a significant blow against tobacco companies.

In an opinion delivered on Wednesday, Juliane Kokott, the European Court of Justice’s advocate general, dismissed a legal challenge from the tobacco industry against EU plans to increase health warnings, ban menthol cigarettes and regulate ecigarettes.

The industry hoped that a ruling in its favour would block attempts by the UK, France and Ireland to introduce so-called “plain packaging”, when branded cigarette packs are replaced with dark brown or green boxes without pictures or design features.

The advocate general’s opinion is not binding but is usually upheld by the ECJ. It will come as a further setback to tobacco companies, which are facing declining smoking rates and greater regulation across the developed world.

The French parliament last week voted to introduce plain packaging just a day before the Australian high court defeated a challenge from Philip Morris International against branding restrictions.
PMI, British American Tobacco, Japan Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco have also challenged the UK government’s plain packaging rules, which will come into effect from May 2017. A decision is expected in the new year.

“While we are still analysing the [advocate general’s] opinion, we are obviously disappointed with its conclusions,” BAT said. “We have always maintained that the Tobacco Products Directive represents an unlawful and disproportionate incursion into the autonomy of the [EU] member states.”

When it launched its challenge, PMI said the EU directive would “disrupt the balance . . . between the union and the member states” by allowing nations to introduce rules above those in the directive that says cigarette packs have to be 65 per cent covered with health warnings.

“Rather than respecting such basic principles as genuine harmonisation and free movement, the [TPD] inexplicably encourages a patchwork of regulations,” it added on Wednesday.

But Ms Kokott said individual countries can introduce full plain packaging. “Since the directive specifies only a basic design, it also still leaves scope for additional national packaging standards, for example in respect of the colouring of surfaces not reserved for warnings,” she said.

Deborah Arnott, chief executive of antismoking group Ash, says if the opinion is upheld by the ECJ it would strengthen antismoking advocates across the developed world.

“The advocate general’s opinion that standardised packaging of cigarettes is legal in Europe, one of the world’s big trading blocks, sets the scene for it to go global,” she said.

On Wednesday Ms Kokott also said separate challenges against the directive’s ban on menthol cigarettes and regulation of ecigarettes should be dismissed.

Pillbox, an ecigarette manufacturer, said the regulation of ecigarettes under tobacco legislation is disproportionate. Ms Kokott said ecigarette rules will be “moderate” compared with tobacco regulations.

She also said menthol cigarettes should be banned under the TPD, despite a challenge from Poland where flavoured products are popular. Ms Kokott said “none of the arguments invoked by Poland and supported by Romania . . . is well founded”.

Advocate General Kokott considers the new EU tobacco directive of 2014 to be valid

Download (PDF, 724KB)

United Nations agency gives EU a tobacco warning

http://www.politico.eu/article/united-nations-eu-tobacco-warning-smuggling-health-lobbying/

Top official tells Commission to steer clear of the industry as it works on new smuggling controls.

The United Nations public health agency in charge of tobacco control has warned EU policymakers to keep their distance from industry as they consider reforms to fight cigarette smuggling.

The head of the World Health Organization’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control secretariat, Vera Da Costa e Silva, wrote senior European Commission officials earlier this month, saying the EU’s close working relationship with tobacco companies to fight cigarette smuggling may violate Europe’s international commitments.

Citing a recent report in POLITICO, Costa e Silva said the “continuation of an illicit trade agreement with a major tobacco company” on the part of the Commission could be in contravention of international commitments, which state that obligations to clamp down on smuggling “shall not be delegated to the tobacco industry.”

One of the letters, addressed to Commission Vice President Kristalina Georgieva and Health and Food Safety Commissioner Vytenis Andriukaitis, points to growing concern over the Commission’s position on two key reform areas, in which the Commission is considering working closely with the world’s four largest tobacco companies.

The first area of concern is the anti-smuggling agreements which the Commission and EU national governments signed with tobacco producers Philip Morris, Japan Tobacco International, British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco Limited between 2004 and 2010.

The agreements are legally binding, enforceable anti-fraud deals involving EU and national counterfeit investigators and have been used as a way to compel tobacco companies to take responsibility for genuine tobacco products that end up on EU black markets, avoiding tax. The Philip Morris agreements expire in 2016 and Georgieva is now deciding whether to renew them.

In another letter, Costa e Silva raised concern about POLITICO’s revelations that anti-smuggling officials within the European anti-fraud office OLAF are both in favor of the Philip Morris deal being renewed and of a controversial packet-tracing technology being promoted by a consortium of tobacco companies.

“I have raised concerns regarding these matters with both [the directorate general for health and food safety] and OLAF,” Costa e Silva wrote, adding that OLAF investigators had expressed to POLITICO a preference for a “track and trace” technology being promoted by tobacco companies.

“I believe this to be of some importance, especially in light of the future membership of OLAF in the Panel of Experts on the Protocol,” Costa e Silva said.

Asked about the letters from Costa e Silva, a Commission official said: “As we said on numerous occasions, there are no negotiations with PMI, or any other companies about the ‘track and tracing’ in the tobacco agreement.”

The European Union is a signatory to the World Health Organization’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, an international treaty which came into force in 2005.

Under the convention’s framework, governments around the world are now considering an additional protocol, signed in 2012, which targets the illicit trade of tobacco products. That protocol must now be ratified and accepted by the 53 states and the European Union that have signed it.

The text of the protocol requires signatories to avoid outsourcing enforcement requirements to the tobacco industry and commits competent authorities to “interact with the tobacco industry and those representing the interests of the tobacco industry only to the extent strictly necessary” to implement the track and trace requirements.

The Commission is considering how best to balance its own “track and trace” provisions under the EU’s 2012 revised Tobacco Products Directive and the requirements of the World Health Organization protocol.

Under the directive, the EU will be required by 2019 to “ensure that all unit package of tobacco products are marked with a unique identifier” which will be “irremovably printed or affixed” to cigarette packets. The Commission is preparing a second feasibility study to examine which type of technology it should recommend EU member states employ.

The tobacco companies are lobbying vigorously for the adoption of their in-house technology, called Codentify. However, other packaging and printing companies are also in the running, including the Swiss-based Sicpa, a high-tech printing company which provides package tracking technology in a number of countries.

The European Carton Makers Association is also watching the process keenly, with a number of its members preparing to counter bids of both SICPA and Codentify if and when public tenders are issued.

Tobacco firms challenge packaging law

http://www.bqlive.co.uk/2015/12/11/tobacco-giants-challenge-new-packaging-law/

Some of the world’s largest Tobacco firms have gone to the High Court to challenge the lawfulness of the government’s new packaging rules.

The case has been brought by four of the world’s biggest firms against regulations which come into force in May next year banning companies from using any logos or branding on packets of tobacco products.

Mr Justice Green, sitting in London, is being asked to rule on the legality of the new “standardised packaging” regulations in a judicial review action by Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International.

The challenge is being contested by Heath Secretary Jeremy Hunt, who argues that the regulations are lawful.

At the start of an estimated six-day case, David Henderson QC, for Japan Tobacco International (JTI) said the companies were “entitled to know” whether the regulations “are lawful or not.”

He told a packed court: “The claimants manufacture products which are lawful, which contribute approximately £10bn per year in excise duty alone for the UK exchequer, which are used by some 19% of the adult population, and which the secretary of state … has never sought to ban.”

Anderson, referring to written legal submissions before the court on behalf of the secretary of state, said he was “quite wrong when he says that we are trying to protect our ability to market unencumbered by legitimate legislation.”

The QC submitted that “on the contrary” the industry was “regulated in a way almost unprecedented in any other field.”

At the heart of the case are the Standardised Packaging of Tobacco Products Regulations 2015, which the companies argue will destroy their highly valuable property rights and render products indistinguishable from each other.

Under the regulations any part of tobacco packaging not covered by the health warning carried on it must be a dark brown or green colour, and brand names must be in small, non-distinctive lettering.

The government argues that the new measure will discourage more people from smoking.

As well as hearing arguments from lawyers for each of the companies and the Health Secretary, the judge will hear submissions from campaigning public health charity Action on Smoking and Health (Ash), which says it “works to eliminate the harm caused by tobacco.”

The firms are putting forward a number of grounds of challenge, including a claim that the regulations violate a number of UK and EU laws, and that they are “disproportionate.”

In written submissions to the judge, Philip Morris International (PMI) argues that the regulations are “disproportionate and so must be quashed.”

PMI QC Marie Demetriou said the defendant (the health secretary) has “failed to demonstrate” that the regulations are suitable or appropriate to meet the objective of “improving public health by reducing smoking” because “it has failed to establish that the regulations will cause a material decrease in smoking rather than an increase”.

PMI further submits that the health secretary has failed to demonstrate that the regulations “are necessary in that the same public health objective cannot be achieved through a less restrictive means, namely taxation.”

Demetriou said: “The defendant has failed to demonstrate that the regulations strike a fair balance between their public interest objectives and the interests of the claimants, given that the regulations will substantially interfere with the claimants’ fundamental rights and freedoms, and destroy their valuable, and often very long-standing, property rights.”

James Eadie QC, representing the health secretary, said in written submissions that the companies manufacture and sell tobacco products “which are the only legal consumer products in the world that cause half of their long-term users to die prematurely.”

He said: “At the heart of the claimants’ case is the assertion that the regulations will not be effective in achieving their public health objectives.

“In short, according to the claimants, standardised packaging will not reduce the appeal of smoking and will not achieve a reduction in tobacco consumption.

“To the contrary, standardised packaging is likely to increase tobacco consumption, and have other adverse consequences such as an increase in illicit trade in tobacco.”

Eadie added: “The secretary of state’s case is that none of the grounds of challenge are made out and the regulations are lawful.

“The claimants’ attack on the proportionality of the regulations is without substance.”

The QC said that “independent and systematic reviews of the evidence” concluded that branded packaging plays an important role in encouraging young people to smoke, and that “standardised packaging is highly likely to reduce both uptake and prevalence of smoking, and thus will have a positive impact on public health.”

He argued that if the tobacco industry “is prevented from using packaging to promote its products to consumers or potential consumers, the appeal of cigarettes is likely to diminish, with inevitable reducing effects on smoking itself.”

Tobacco giants and Government in plain packaging showdown

British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco will line up against the Government

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandconsumer/leisure/12035251/Tobacco-giants-and-Government-in-plain-packaging-showdown.html

The world’s biggest tobacco companies will this week start their High Court battle with the Government over plans to sell cigarettes in plain packets, a controversial law that the manufacturers argue deprives them of their property rights.

FTSE 100 companies British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco, along with Marlboro maker Philip Morris International and Japan Tobacco, will line up against the Government on Thursday, when a six-day hearing will start.

The firms are not claiming compensation or costs, but if they succeed in scrapping the ban they could receive large payouts.

Although the companies originally lodged papers separately, their bids to have plain packaging ruled illegal will be heard as one case. The new law is due to come into force in May next year.

The four cigarette companies are co-operating with each other so that each one will present a different argument against the legislation on standardised packets.

Mr Justice Green will hear the case, with a decision expected by January. Whatever the outcome of the hearing, the side that loses will almost certainly appeal.

MPs voted to ban brands and logos on cigarette packets in March, becoming only the third country in the world to do so after Australia and Ireland.

The Government hopes the measures will make smoking less appealing, particularly to youths.

The tobacco companies, however, argue that the measures are unlawful. They believe plain packaging breaches European Union law on community trademarks and that they have been deprived of their valuable brands without compensation.

The firms will also argue that the introduction of plain packaging in Australia, in December 2012, did not lead to a reduction in smoking, although the Government is expected to counter by saying that it is too early to judge the impact of that ban.

In a separate case in Luxembourg, the manufacturers are also attempting to prove that the plain packaging measure in the UK exceeds the EU Second Tobacco Products Directive.

The advocate general will issue an opinion on the matter in less than three weeks, with a ruling to follow early next year. The outcome of the High Court battle will become irrelevant should the tobacco companies win in the EU, because they will have proven that the UK had no legal right to introduce plain packaging.

It is hoped that, even in the event of an appeal, the matter will have been decided one way or another before plain packaging is introduced in May.

If that looks unlikely, the companies are expected to try to delay the start of the ban.

How did EU spend its €110mn of tobacco money?

https://euobserver.com/investigations/131310

The European Union and its member states have so far received at least €1.4 billion from four tobacco giants as a result of anti-smuggling cooperation agreements. The EU budget received almost 10 percent, or €110 million, so far. How have they spent that money?

The short answer to that question is: we have no idea, and this is normal.

Some members of the European Parliament (MEPs), worried that the tobacco’s companies’ payments have bought them influence in EU policy, have asked the Commission to show how the money has been used to fight cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting.

But the EU commissioner in charge of the budget, Kristalina Georgieva, has told them that the millions are not stored in separate ‘tobacco jars’.

“The money collected by the Commission and the member states as a result of the agreements is not earmarked for any particular ensuing actions,” the commissioner wrote in response to questions from MEPs.

“Therefore, there is no link between the incoming funds and specific expenditure. This is in line with the principle of the universality of the budget which applies to the EU budget and the budgets of numerous Member States”.

‘Could be’

Indeed, when going back to the time of the signing of the first such agreement, between Philip Morris International (PMI) and the EU, no hard promises were made that the PMI money would be spent on combating cigarette smuggling.

On the day the PMI agreement was signed, then budget commissioner Michaele Schreyer was already cautious not to rule out that some of the money would be used for other purposes.

She noted the agreement “provides for substantial payments by PMI”.

“These could be used to combat smuggling and counterfeit”, she said.

The phrase “could be” would be repeated in later communications, also on three additional similar agreements signed with other tobacco firms.

Olaf, the EU’s antifraud agency, referred in its annual report for 2007 to the second such agreement that was concluded that year between the European Commission, member states, and Japan Tobacco International.

“The agreement, which runs for 15 years, makes provision for the payment of $400 million (approximately €250 million), which could be used to combat the smuggling and counterfeiting of cigarettes”, Olaf’s report noted.

‘Could be’. Not ‘will be’.

In total, the four tobacco giants have paid €1.4 billion until June 2015, with 9.7 percent, or €110 million, going to the EU budget. The rest has gone to member states’ budgets.

The commission does not monitor how member states use these funds, nor did it track how the money it received was spent.

Napkin calculation

Of course, one can still compare how much money was spent on fighting cigarette smuggling to how much money was received. However it is a bit of a napkin calculation, because the commission itself does not officially add up all EU action on cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting.

Several EU agencies deal with the issue.

Looking at EU funds going to anti-fraud agency Olaf, judicial cooperation agency Eurojust, and the EU’s law enforcement agency Europol, one can say that indeed several tens of millions of euros have been spent on combating cigarette smuggling during the eleven years since the first PMI agreement was signed.

This is when taking into account the expenditure on salaries, and looking at how many staff are assigned to fighting tobacco fraud. But it would be a guess at best.

It is even harder to know if those funds would have been spent had there been no such agreement, and the expiration of the PMI agreement next year raises the question whether reliance on the annual payments plays a role on the decision whether or not to negotiate.

Herculean task

There is however one programme which very directly came out of the PMI agreement.

In 2006, two years after the deal was signed, the European Commission proposed to increase the budget for Olaf’s Hercule II programme by €44 million (for the period 2007-2013), specifically to finance training activities and equipment that are aimed at fighting cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting.

Denmark’s custom authorities for example received €335,000 in grants in 2010 and 2011 to buy X-ray scanners to scan for illegal shipments of tobacco products. According to an official Commission evaluation, 9,000 cartons of smuggled cigarettes were detected in the first nine months.

But while the programme was praised by several member states, the evaluation report’s annex showed that there was limited hard proof of its effectiveness.

“Overall, the beneficiary survey showed that 75% of beneficiaries agreed or strongly agreed that the Programme multiplied and intensified the measures in the areas identified as the most sensitive, in particular cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting,”, the report noted.

“However, … the evaluator had limited data available on the numbers of arrests or numbers of seizures of smuggled cigarettes and counterfeit products, which made it difficult to assess the effectiveness of these actions in purely quantitative terms. For the same reason it was not possible to determine whether the Programme contributed to increased numbers of arrests or increased numbers of seizures of smuggled cigarettes and counterfeit products.”

The report adds: “A case study confirmed that the equipment would not have been purchased in four Member States without the co-financing provided by Hercule II. Due to the lack of quantitative data on seizures of smuggled or counterfeit cigarettes, the evidence is limited.”

“This makes it difficult to estimate precisely the extent to which the actions have multiplied and intensified existing measures. However, the qualitative data provided strong evidence showing that the programme intensified measures in the area of cigarette smuggling, because it contributed to projects which improved staff‘s analytical capacity to counter cigarette smuggling.”

This lack of data will make it challenging for the Commission to complete its assessment of the benefits that the agreement with PMI has brought, and whether to aim for a renewal next year.

EU Tobacco Agreement Hasn’t Significantly Slowed Smuggling

The landmark deal with Philip Morris International was supposed to greatly reduce the influx of illegal and counterfeit cigarettes.

http://www.nacsonline.com/News/Daily/Pages/ND1204155.aspx#.VmFZFeKE4hw

BRUSSELS – Eleven years after the European Union inked a landmark deal with Philip Morris International (PMI) to curb cigarette smuggling, some are questioning its effectiveness, the EU Observer reports. “We have concluded an agreement with PMI, which is quite unique in its scope. and I am not afraid to use the term ‘landmark’ agreement here,” Michaele Schreyer, European Union (EU) commissioner for budgetary affairs, said in July 2004. “We have built an efficient system to fight against future cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting.”

Now, that arrangement is close to expiring and the EU has been conducting an assessment of the agreement. “The main objective of the PMI agreement to reduce the presence of smuggled PMI products on the EU black market has been achieved,” said Kristalina Georgieva, head of the European Union’s budget office. “Between 2006 and 2014, the volume of illegal PMI products seized by member states under the agreement has dropped by 85%. That substantially exceeds the overall downward trend in seizures. This drop applies equally to both genuine and counterfeit PMI products.”

EU members reported seizing 4.5 billion illegal cigarettes in 2005, which dropped to 3.1 billion contraband cigarettes in 2013. During the same time period, PMI brands also plummeted among the seized smokes.

However, some say that because some member states only started reporting smuggled cigarette numbers in 2005, there’s a lack of accuracy as to contraband numbers before the agreement. The amount of estimated lost taxes because of smuggling has stayed steady since 2010, at €10 billion.

EU admits parts of tobacco deal too bureaucratic

https://euobserver.com/justice/131355

The EU’s anti-fraud agency Olaf has said that an agreement the EU signed with tobacco company Philip Morris International (PMI) in 2004 has given PMI an incentive to cooperate in cigarette smuggling investigations, but also indicated that some of the inquiry tools the EU acquired under the agreement may have been too bureaucratic to work in practice.

The EU-PMI deal, which ended a legal struggle and cemented a cooperation to combat cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting, will expire next year.

EUobserver has looked at various aspects of the agreement, and uncovered PMI’s annual compliance reports via a freedom of information request.

The reports showed that Olaf had made little use of several of the investigative tools it was given under the agreement.

For example, the deal gave Olaf the power to interview PMI employees, but PMI said it never received any request for such interviews during the 11 years the agreement has been in place.

According to the reports, Olaf also blindly trusted PMI’s promise to hold due diligence probes into the company’s business partners – Olaf never requested the due diligence reports despite the right to ask for them.

Olaf was unavailable for comment before publication of the article about its investigative tools under the agreement, but their press office has sent this website an e-mail with comments since.

Responding to questions why Olaf never used some of the options given under the agreement, its press office said “the specific situations envisaged in certain clauses have not arisen in the context of Olaf investigations”.

Although Olaf did not specify how or quantify how often, the spokesperson wrote that PMI “has on multiple occasions provided national investigators and Olaf with information of direct investigative value”.

“This information has regularly led to seizures by Member States’ enforcement authorities, and in many cases to arrests and criminal indictments,” it said.

“Transnational criminal organisations were dismantled and potential losses to Member States’ and the EU budget of many million euros were prevented. PMI and other companies also provided assistance to dismantle illegal cigarette production facilities in some EU Member States and neighbouring countries,” the e-mail continued.

Olaf noted that “on several occasions Olaf has addressed requests to PMI for information in relation to on-going investigations”, but also hinted that not all the inquiry tools put in place by the deal were considered effective.

“Investigative needs will also frequently dictate much faster means of enquiry than formal requests with a deadline of 45 days for replies, such as when a container with a suspicious load is already en route,” said Olaf’s press office.

The European Commission has promised an assessment of the agreement before the end of the month. Based on that assessment, a decision will be made whether or not to start negotiations for a possible renewal of the deal.

EUobserver has published a four-part series of articles about the EU’s agreement with tobacco company PMI

Scant evidence EU tobacco deal curbed smuggling

https://euobserver.com/investigations/131266

Cigarettes seized at the Ukraine-Polish border in October 2011. EU member states reported that they seized 4.5 billion cigarettes in 2005, and 3.1 billion in 2013. (Photo: European Commission)

Cigarettes seized at the Ukraine-Polish border in October 2011. EU member states reported that they seized 4.5 billion cigarettes in 2005, and 3.1 billion in 2013. (Photo: European Commission)

Michaele Schreyer was in the last months of her mandate as European commissioner for budgetary affairs when in July 2004 the European Union signed an agreement with tobacco multinational Philip Morris International (PMI).

She did not mince words when she assessed the deal.

“We have concluded an agreement with PMI, which is quite unique in its scope and I am not afraid to use the term ‘landmark’ agreement here,” she said. “We have built an efficient system to fight against future cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting.”

Fast forward eleven years – and four budget commissioners later – and the agreement with PMI is nearing its expiration date. According to current EU budget chief Kristalina Georgieva, the commission is almost done with its assessment of the agreement.

So has cigarette smuggling and counterfeiting dropped in the past eleven years?

In May 2015, Georgieva came to the plenary session in Strasbourg at the request of several MEPs, to talk about the PMI deal.

“There are some facts that are very clear,” she noted.

“The main objective of the PMI agreement to reduce the presence of smuggled PMI products on the EU black market has been achieved. Between 2006 and 2014 the volume of illegal PMI products seized by member states under the agreement has dropped by 85 percent. That substantially exceeds the overall downward trend in seizures. This drop applies equally to both genuine and counterfeit PMI products.”

According to the Commission, EU member states reported that they seized 4.5 billion cigarettes in 2005, and 3.1 billion in 2013.

In parallel, the occurrence of PMI brands among the seized cigarettes has also dropped.

In a 2013 report to the parliament and national capitals, the commission said that the agreement with PMI, and three others like it with the other big tobacco companies, “have clearly led to a significant reduction in the presence of these companies’ products on the illicit market”.

In 2011, the share of seized cigarettes with “other brands”, i.e. brands from companies that don’t have an agreement with the EU, reached 58 percent.

But a decreased share of PMI’s cigarettes in seizures does not automatically mean an absolute decrease in smuggled goods, just as that a rise in police reports does not directly prove an increase in crime.

The trouble with crime data

The honest answer is of course: we don’t know for sure. By their very nature, illegal activities are difficult to quantify.

In any case, there are several factors that complicate matters.

Member states have only begun to report their seizures of smuggled cigarettes systematically in 2005, which means there is no accurate picture of the situation before the agreement went into force.

Also, as seizures were decreasing in the past decade, the estimates of the overall size of illicit trade in cigarettes went up.

The commission said in the same 2013 document in which it signalled a downward trend in seizures that consumption of illicit cigarettes has increased by 30 percent in six years. The EU executive cited a study by audit company KPMG, which had said that 8.4 percent of all cigarettes smoked by Europeans in 2007 were illegal, while in 2012 that share was 11.1 percent.

KPMG has written annual reports on the state of illicit tobacco trade in Europe, commissioned by PMI, but they are not completely uncontroversial.

This website was granted access via a freedom of information request to the minutes of a 2 July, 2013 meeting with representatives of PMI, KPMG, the EU and 23 of its member states in Brussels.

The minutes noted that that year’s KPMG report “were released by PMI without consultation with member states”, which one ber state called “very embarrassing”.

Another member state (MS) pointed out a “significant difference between the figures from the KPMG report and MS figures”.

A representative of Olaf, the EU’s agency that deals with tobacco fraud, said that: “the difference between the OLAF/MS and KPMG figures is huge, it represents a gap of 25 per cent. OLAF/MS figures show a decrease of 12% (around 3,8 billion cigarettes seized) while the KMPG points out the increase of 11%.”

At a similar meeting a year earlier, one country “congratulated KPMG for the excellent analytical and statistical work” but also noted “that the statistics provided by KPMG are the only tool member states have at their disposal to check the global trends and figures”.

Lack of independent data

And this is problematic, say a group of researchers in an article published earlier this year in the peer-reviewed medical journal Tobacco Control. The article tried to assess the impact of the PMI agreement and three other similar deals that were struck with other tobacco giants.

“Full evaluation of the agreements is almost impossible, as there are no independent publicly available data on the origins and brands of illicit tobacco products and the size of the illicit market in the EU … The only publicly available data on the EU illicit cigarette trade over time are data produced by KPMG for the tobacco industry”, said the article.

Two years earlier, another article was published in Tobacco Control, specifically about the KPMG reports.

The researchers noted there was “lack of transparency, inadequacy of methodological details and subsequent quality of the data inputted to the model, the over-reliance on PMI data, and the lack of external validation.”

Wrong incentive?

Another problem when evaluating whether the agreements have reduced PMI’s share of illicit cigarettes traded, is that PMI itself gets to say whether a seized cigarette was a genuine or counterfeit.

Under the agreement, PMI has to make a payment that is equivalent to 100 percent of the evaded taxes when a batch of 50,000 or more smuggled cigarettes are seized that carry its brand. However, if it is determined they are fake, PMI does not have to pay. The same goes for the other three manufacturers.

As of June 2015, all four manufacturers have paid €88 million in seizure payments, and €1.3 billion in annual payments, as stipulated by the agreements.

The Tobacco Control authors, who want the EU to end the tobacco agreements, criticized the fact that PMI is allowed to say whether seized cigarettes are fake or not, because it has an interest in the outcome.

“The intention of the seizure-based payments to deter the tobacco industry from further involvement in the illicit cigarette trade has failed because the agreements contain too many loopholes that provide [tobacco multinationals] with both the incentive and opportunity to classify seized cigarettes as counterfeit”.

While the EU and its member states have the option to do random checks and test the seized cigarettes which PMI claimed to be counterfeit in an independent laboratory, there has never been a dispute that triggered such an investigation.

A commission document sent to MEPs in the spring said that one “(large) member state has over a certain period of time verified 123 determinations ‘genuine or counterfeit’ made by manufacturers, and not found any error”.

The text also notes that EU anti-fraud agency Olaf has requested an independent laboratory in Scotland to “analyse more than 300 samples of seized cigarettes. (….) Of these random checks, none has revealed a false determination.”

Lost taxes

Meanwhile, the €88 million in recovered seizure payments is nowhere near enough to make up for the tax revenue that is reportedly lost due to smuggling.

The commission says that every year the EU and member states budgets lose €10 billion in potential tax revenue.

Curiously, it has used the same figure since at least July 2010.

Green MEP Bart Staes recently noted in a parliament debate with Georgieva that despite the agreement with PMI and other tobacco companies, the financial loss is steady at €10 billion.

“That figure is apparently not coming down, because I have heard that figure of €10 billion for years,” said Staes.

The 2013 commission communication explained that the estimate of €10 billion annual loss “is based on seizures reported by the member states which amounted to 4.5 – 4.6 billion cigarettes per year between 2005 and 2011”.

But since the volume of seized cigarettes has slowly been going down, to 3.1 billion in 2013, it may be time for the commission to update the figure, before deciding on a possible renewal of the agreement with PMI.