Europe
MP decries illegal tobacco trade
http://in-cyprus.com/mp-decries-illegal-tobacco-trade/
Akel MP Irene Charalambidou told the House Watchdog Committee that there exists a ring of illicit tobacco traffickers involving known members of the Cyprus elite.
Charalambidou criticised state authorities for lack of co-ordination between relevant departments and claimed these cases are handled in a particularly compromising way.
Speaking before the Watchdog Committee on Tuesday, Charalambidou said the man who was a key suspect in the case of illegal tobacco imports, which made headlines in 2009, is also involved in the record tobacco haul in Aradippou in October 2015.
In October, police raided a warehouse in Aradippou and found hauls of illegal tobacco worth €2million in unpaid taxes. Six people –including what investigators suspect is a Cypriot operations manager– were arrested in the joint operation between the customs officers and police.
Police later raided more warehouses – being run by a bogus company – seizing more illegal tobacco. The overall seizure has come to just under 20 tonnes making it the biggest haul ever recorded on the island.
Charalambidou had then spoken of a “cover-up” because the company owner had yet to be found while she also questioned why the foreign workers at the factory have all been deported from Cyprus.
The Cyprus Customs and Excise Department had denied all accusations.
British American Tobacco and Stella Artois among 35 companies ordered to cough up £524m in unpaid taxes after Belgian ‘excess profit’ dodge is ruled illegal
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3394337/British-American-Tobacco-Stella-Artois-35-companies-ordered-cough-35m-unpaid-taxes-Belgian-excess-profit-dodge-ruled-illegal.html
• Stella Artois among 35 companies ordered to pay more than half a billion pounds in unpaid taxes
• European Commission competition officials said Belgium had wrongly given tax breaks worth 700million euros (£524m)
• Instead of paying tax on their full profits, companies were taxed on hypothetical profits of smaller companies
The makers of Stella Artois and Benson & Hedges were last night among 35 companies ordered to stump up more than half a billion pounds in unpaid taxes after deals they had with the Belgian government were ruled illegal.
European Commission competition officials said Belgium had wrongly given tax breaks worth 700million euros (£524m) under a scheme that helped multinationals reduce their taxable profits by up to 90 per cent.
British American Tobacco, which makes Dunhill, Lucky Strike and Pall Mall, and brewer AB Inbev, whose brands include Budweiser, Corona and Beck’s, were named as among the companies that had benefited.
Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager said: ‘The European Commission has concluded that selective tax advantages granted by Belgium under its “excess profit” tax scheme are illegal under EU state aid rules.
‘Belgium has given a select number of multinationals substantial tax advantages that break EU state aid rules. It distorts competition on the merits by putting smaller competitors who are not multinational on an unequal footing.’
Under the tax scheme, launched in 2005 with the tagline ‘Only in Belgium’, international companies were encouraged to invest in the country with the promise they could cut their tax bills.
Instead of paying tax on their full profits, companies were taxed on hypothetical profits of what it was estimated a smaller company without their international scale and global brand recognition would earn.
The EU tax investigation follows those looking at Apple’s deals with Ireland, coffee-shop chain Starbucks’s arrangements with The Netherlands and McDonald’s with Luxembourg.
In October, the Commission decided that Luxembourg and the Netherlands had granted unfair tax advantages to Fiat and Starbucks, respectively, and ordered the firms to repay some taxes.
EU rules say some tax breaks offered to big companies breach the bloc’s rules on state aid, as they amount to a government subsidy that is aimed at attracting multinationals to do business in certain countries.
Belgian finance minister Johan Van Overtveldt yesterday said: ‘At this point we do not exclude any option. This also applies to the possibility of an appeal against the decision.’
An AB Inbev spokesman said: ‘While we are disappointed by this decision, we remain confident that our tax rulings are in full compliance with the EU jurisprudence on state aid and that we have always complied with Belgian and international tax provisions.
‘We will consider our options, taking into account the reactions by the Belgian authorities.’
British American Tobacco did not respond to a request for comment.
Australia tobacco clash reverberates in EU trade talks
http://www.politico.eu/article/australia-tobacco-clash-reverberates-in-eu-trade-talks/
Tribunal decision could undermine opposition to TTIP.
The end of a complex court case on the other side of the world could wreak havoc on a campaign in Europe against a proposed trade deal between the EU and the United States.
An international arbitration tribunal in December 2015 wound up a four-year dispute between the Australian government and tobacco company Philip Morris by announcing it was unable to rule on the matter — effectively siding with Australia’s position in the dispute.
The case has resonated in Europe, where for some time opponents of the proposed Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) have used the legal challenge as a cautionary tale against signing investment deals.
Philip Morris used an obscure investment agreement which Australia signed with Hong Kong in 1993 in an attempt to scuttle Australia’s “plain packaging” tobacco legislation, which has removed all branding from cigarette packets sold in the country.
But Australia’s ability to fend off the legal challenge could undermine the argument that legal provisions contained in international investment agreements leave legitimate legislative reform vulnerable to big corporations.
“It will be back to the drawing board for anti-TTIP campaigners,” said Hosuk Lee-Makiyama, director of the European Center for International Political Economy, adding that the parallels between Australia’s deal with Hong Kong and TTIP had always been overstated.
“Philip Morris was only able to sue Australia because of a technicality,” Lee-Makiyama said. “In free-trade agreements you always include an exception for public health, which Australia forgot to do. This entire case was the result of a drafting error by Australian negotiators.”
However, anti-tobacco campaigners in Brussels say the decision by the Permanent Court of Arbitration in Singapore does nothing for TTIP’s credibility.
“The arbitration court declined to hear the case on the grounds that it was not competent, as Philip Morris had shifted its commercial identity during the course of the case,” said Catherine Hartmann, vice president of the European Public Health Alliance.
“There is nothing in the outcomes of the arbitration attempt that validates or questions plain packaging in Australia or anywhere else,” Hartmann said.
Tobacco wars
The clash between Philip Morris and the Australian federal government began in 2011, when health authorities in Canberra drafted legislation to remove all branding from tobacco packets. The laws, designed to discourage people from taking up smoking, were implemented at the end of 2012.
The legislation was a world first and Philip Morris Asia Limited, a Hong Kong-based subsidiary of the tobacco company, launched a legal challenge. The company argued that the laws “forced removal of trademarks and other valuable intellectual property.”
The legal action was possible because the agreement between Australia and Hong Kong contained an “investor-state dispute settlement” provision (ISDS), an arbitration mechanism which enables investors to take legal action if they feel their interests have been harmed by government policy.
In 2012 the High Court of Australia, the country’s supreme court, found against Philip Morris, arguing the plain packaging legislation was not in violation of the constitution. The tobacco company then took its concerns to the international arbitrator, which effectively ruled against Philip Morris.
Yet Nina Renshaw, the secretary general of the European Public Health Alliance, is adamant the risks of industry using ISDS to challenge health reforms remain.
“The inclusion of an ISDS … in an EU agreement could raise the likelihood of such cases being brought against all kinds of public interest and health protecting policies in the future,” Renshaw said.
In an unusual alliance, Philip Morris agreed with anti-tobacco campaigners. Company vice president Marc Firestone argued that the Australian government’s win was “entirely procedural” with no bearing on either the merits of plain packaging legislation or the ISDS itself.
However, Lee-Makiyama said opposition in Europe to both ISDS and TTIP is based not on fact but misconceptions about American corporate culture.
“This is coming from business interests that are concerned with American market share and from outdated ideas of multinational corporations which may have been OK in the 1920s but are meaningless today,” Lee-Makiyama said.
“Opposition to the ISDS in Europe is also coming from national governments like Germany, which do not want a legal mechanism to stop them discriminating against foreign investors,” he said.
Packaging problems
The controversy has fed into a broader lobbying clash between the tobacco industry and anti-smoking campaigners in Europe, where plain packaging legislation is being hotly contested.
The EU’s revised Tobacco Products Directive, which entered into force in 2014, steered clear of plain packaging reforms after the European Commission came under pressure from the tobacco industry. However, the directive allowed EU member countries to adopt national plain packaging laws.
A number of EU governments have now done so. In December 2015, France passed tobacco legislation and will start to introduce plain packaging in May 2016.
However, the tobacco industry is maintaining its opposition to such laws. Australia’s legislation is also being challenged by a number of tobacco-producing countries at the World Trade Organization.
Meanwhile, on the other side of the Atlantic the EU’s soul-searching over the implications of an ISDS is being observed with interest by those opposing the inclusion of an arbitration mechanism in TTIP on the grounds that it is unnecessary.
“A company entering into a contract with a foreign government can accomplish the same objectives as an ISDS simply by insisting on including an arbitration clause,” said Dan Pearson from the Washington-based Cato Institute, a libertarian think-tank.
“Business associations in the U.S. would support TTIP without an ISDS because the reality is that they don’t need it,” Pearson said. “It mystifies me that the Obama administration has placed so much emphasis on an ISDS.”
This article was corrected to clarify details of the 2012 Australian High Court finding.
European court gives the go ahead for plain cigarette packs
http://www.newstalk.com/reader/47.301/61879/0/
“A wonderful Christmas present for children” – Minister gives ecstatic reaction
Minister for Children James Reilly has welcomed a European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruling that clears the way for plain packaging laws for tobacco products in Ireland.
The court has made a preliminary ruling this morning against tobacco giants Philip Morris and British American Tobacco.
They took proceedings to the ECJ over an EU directive which would see health warnings on two thirds of tobacco packaging.
The Children’s Minister James Reilly wants to go one step further in Ireland and ban tobacco branding on packets altogether.
He says: “Tobacco companies may have more manoeuvres, but the Irish Government stands ready to meet any challenge on the way to implementing this law.”
In its ruling this morning, the ECJ said the new EU tobacco directive of 2014 is valid.
Legislation to introduce plain packaging of tobacco products was unanimously passed by both houses of the Oireachtas, without any dissent.
Dr Reilly says more than 5,000 people a year die from smoking-related illness in Ireland.
Tobacco firms’ challenge to plain packaging stubbed out
http://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/tobacco-firms-challenge-to-plain-packaging-stubbed-out-1.2476697
EU advocate says 2014 EU tobacco directive calls for plain packaging on cigarette packs
The introduction of plain packaging rules for cigarettes is provided for in the 2014 EU tobacco directive, an advocate general to the European Court of Justice has said. She rejected arguments against the directive by major global tobacco groups.
Advocate general Juliane Kokott issued her opinions on a number of applications against the directive taken by tobacco firms and, in relation to one issue, Poland. Her opinions will be considered by the court which will make its findings at a later date.
Ms Kokott found the directive’s requirements relating to the size, shape and minimum content of cigarette packets were proportionate and made a particular contribution to the visibility and efficacy of health warnings.
New requirements to have health warnings covering 65 per cent of the front surface and back surface of a packet were neither arbitrary nor disproportionate, and it was right that the directive prohibited true statements which cast a tobacco product in a deceptively positive light.
“Even an organically farmed cigarette, for example, is still a product that is extremely harmful to health.”
Basic design
She also said that since the directive specified only a basic design for cigarette packets, “it also still leaves scope for additional national packaging standards, for example in respect of the colouring of surfaces not reserved for warnings (possibly through to the introduction of ‘plain packaging’).”
She said none of the arguments invoked by Poland against the prohibition on menthol cigarettes were well founded and its case should be dismissed. The new rule comes into effect in May 2020.
The flavouring of cigarettes could camouflage the generally very bitter and even pungent taste of tobacco smoke and create a serious risk of initiation for non-smokers into tobacco consumption, she said.
She also said the rules concerning e-cigarettes were moderate and not disproportionate. It was not manifestly wrong or unreasonable to accept that e-cigarettes possibly caused harm and could develop into a gateway to traditional tobacco consumption.
The directive’s implementation into British law is being challenged in the English high court.
E-cigarette restrictions ‘would not break EU law’, advocate general says
http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/dec/23/e-cigarette-restrictions-eu-advocate-general
Manufacturers say EU rulings limiting advertising and strengths of electronic cigarettes, due next year, will damage industry
Rules on e-cigarette production, sales and marketing due to come into force across Europe next year are relatively moderate and would not break European law, a senior legal officer at the European court of justice has said.
The opinion of the advocate general, Juliane Kokott, is a severe blow to e-cigarette manufacturers who have claimed the new rules risk the future of the nicotine-based products, even though the NHS has said they are 95% less harmful than tobacco cigarettes.
The opinion does not mean the court will automatically dismiss the legal challenge headed by Blackburn-based Totally Wicked, and supported by other manufacturers, but most judgments later endorse the position of advocate generals. The ruling in this case is expected early next year.
Totally Wicked, which also operates in the US and Germany, has argued the limits on the size of bottles of e-liquids, restrictions on nicotine strengths and curbs on advertising and sponsorship, plus other measures, would damage an emerging industry and make it subject to more stringent regulation than some tobacco products.
Kokott’s opinion, summarised in a court press statement, is that the rules are relatively moderate compared with those for tobacco products. It emphasised that e-cigarettes are, for large parts of the population, “still relatively little known products for which there is a rapidly developing market”.
She said it is not unreasonable or wrong to accept that e-cigarettes possibly cause risks to human health and that they “could – above all in the case of adolescents and young adults – develop into a gateway to nicotine addiction and, ultimately, traditional tobacco consumption”.
Ian Gregory, a leader of the 100K group, representing several independent e-cigarette companies, claimed that if the court backed their legal officer, vapers would start playing “a game of ‘Brexit poker’” by threatening to vote to leave the EU in the forthcoming referendum unless there was a British opt-out on the issue.
“Britain’s vapers are determined to save the devices which they believe save their lives,” he said.
Dan Marchant, owner of the e-cigarette retailer Vape Club, which is part of the group, said there was little awareness of how the new rules would damage the industry. “Nearly every current device could become illegal.”
Fraser Cropper, Totally Wicked’s managing director, said: “This is not a formal decision, nor a legal judgment on the questions we raised in our challenge … It is not binding on the judges.”
Adviser to top EU court says EU cigarette law is valid
An adviser to Europe’s highest court in Luxembourg on Wednesday said an EU law on cigarettes was valid, rebuffing a challenge from Philip Morris International, although the court still has to deliver a final ruling. The opinion, if adopted by the court, would be a blow to Big Tobacco, which had lobbied vigorously against what was seen as some of the world’s strictest anti-tobacco legislation.
In a majority of cases, opinions of the court advisers are reflected in the final ruling, which should follow in the coming months. “(The advocate general) considers the EU tobacco directive of 2014 to be valid, in particular the extensive standardization of packaging, the future EU-wide prohibition on menthol cigarettes and special rules for e-cigarettes are lawful,” the opinion said.
Smoking remains the most significant cause of premature death in the European Union, responsible for nearly 700,000 deaths every year. The EU Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) was adopted in May 2014 and comes into force in 2016. It requires measures including a ban on menthol cigarettes by 2020 and pictorial and text health warnings across 65 percent of tobacco packages. It also preserves the right of member states to introduce packaging rules that are stricter, such as the “plain packaging” law the British government has passed that bans all colors and logos on cigarette boxes. The legal challenge by Marlboro cigarette maker Philip Morris was combined with one from Lucky Strike maker British American Tobacco. Neither company was immediately available to comment.
http://uk.reuters.com/article/us-eu-court-pmi-idUKKBN0U60R920151223