Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

The (Possible) Effect of Plain Packaging on the Smoking Prevalence of Minors in Australia: A Trend Analysis

Download (PDF, 197KB)

Availability of illicit tobacco in small retail outlets before and after the implementation of Australian plain packaging legislation

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2014/04/10/tobaccocontrol-2013-051353.abstract

Abstract

Objective

We aimed to assess change in the availability of illicit tobacco in small mixed business retail outlets following the December 2012 introduction of plain packaging in Australia.

Methods

303 small retail outlets were visited in June and September 2012 (baseline months), and in December 2012 and February, April and July 2013. Fieldworkers requested a particular low-cost brand of cigarettes and then pressed the retailer for an ‘even cheaper’ brand. The cheapest pack of cigarettes offered was purchased and later examined to assess any divergence from prescribed Australian packaging regulations. The price paid was compared with tax liability and recommended retail price for the particular brand and pack size. In a sub-set of 179 stores, fieldworkers then asked the retailer about availability of unbranded (chop-chop) tobacco.

Results

Thirteen (2.2%) of 598 packs purchased pre-plain packaging were either non-compliant with Australian health warnings and/or suspiciously priced. Four packs (1.3%) of 297 met either or both criteria in the December implementation month, and five (0.6%) of 878 did so in the three collection months following implementation. Chop-chop was offered upon enquiry on 0.6% (n=2) of 338 occasions prior to implementation, 0.6% (n=1) of 170 occasions in the December 2012 implementation month, and 0.6% (n=3) of 514 occasions postimplementation. The likelihood of a ‘positive’ response (either an offer to sell or information about where unbranded tobacco may be purchased) did not differ across preimplementation, during-implementation and postimplementation waves.

Conclusions

Overall, packs judged likely to be illicit were sold in response to requests for cheapest available packs on fewer than one percent of occasions. Offers to sell unbranded tobacco were rare. No change in availability of illicit tobacco was observed following implementation of plain packaging.

Standardised packaging of tobacco

Download (PDF, 1.16MB)

Comments on Kaul & Wolf “The (possible) effect of plain packaging on the smoking prevalence of minors in Australia: a trend analysis”

Download (PDF, 250KB)

Effects of standardised cigarette packaging on craving, motivation to stop and perceptions of cigarettes and packs

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24559249

Abstract

OBJECTIVE:

To assess whether standardised packs of the form introduced in Australia are associated with a reduction in acute craving and/or an increase in motivation to stop, and to replicate previous findings on perceptions of packaging, perceptions of smokers using it and perceived effects on behaviour.

DESIGN:

Following abstinence of at least 12 h, 98 regular and occasional smokers were randomised to exposure to their own cigarette package, another branded package or a standardised package.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:

Craving (QSU-brief), motivation to stop, both at baseline and post-exposure. Ratings of 10 attributes concerning package design, perceived smoker characteristics and effects on behaviour, post-exposure only.

RESULTS:

For craving, a mixed model ANCOVA showed a significant interaction of packaging and time of measurement (F(2,94) = 8.77, p < .001, partial η(2) = .16). There was no significant main effect or interaction for motivation to stop smoking (p = .9). The standardised pack was perceived to be significantly less appealing and less motivating to buy cigarettes, smokers using them were perceived as less popular and cigarettes from them expected to taste worse.

CONCLUSION:

Standardised cigarette packaging may reduce acute (hedonic) craving and is associated with more negative perceptions than branded packaging with less prominent health warnings.

Personal tobacco pack display before and after the introduction of plain packaging with larger pictorial health warnings in Australia: an observational study of outdoor café strips

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24428427

Abstract

AIMS:

We tested whether prevalence of cigarette pack display and smoking at outdoor venues and pack orientation changed following the introduction of plain packaging and larger pictorial health warnings in Australia.

METHODS:

Between October and April 2011-12 (pre-plain packaging, pre-PP) and 2012-13 (post-plain packaging, post-PP), we counted patrons, smokers and tobacco packs at cafés, restaurants and bars with outdoor seating. Pack type (fully branded, plain or unknown) and orientation were noted. Rates of pack display, smoking and pack orientation were analysed using multi-level Poisson regression.

RESULTS:

Pack display declined by 15% [adjusted incident rate ratio (IRR) = 0.85, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.79-0.91, P < 0.001], driven by a 23% decline in active smoking (IRR = 0.77, 95% CI = 0.71-0.84, P < 0.001) between phases. The decline in pack display coincided with the full implementation of plain packaging from December 2012, was stronger in venues with children present and was limited to mid and high socio-economic status (SES) areas. The proportion of packs orientated face-up declined from 85.4% of fully branded packs pre-PP to 73.6% of plain packs post-PP (IRR = 0.87, 95% CI = 0.79-0.95, P = 0.002). Alternatively, the proportions concealed by telephones, wallets or other items (4.4% of fully branded packs pre-PP and 9.5% of plain packs post-PP; IRR = 2.33, 95% CI = 1.72-3.17, P < 0.001) and in an external case (1.5-3.5% of all packs; IRR = 2.79, 95% CI = 1.77-4.40, P < 0.001) increased. Low SES areas evidenced the greatest increase in pack concealment and the greatest decline in face-up pack orientation.

CONCLUSIONS:

Following Australia’s 2012 policy of plain packaging and larger pictorial health warnings on cigarette and tobacco packs, smoking in outdoor areas of cafés, restaurants and bars and personal pack display (packs clearly visible on tables) declined. Further, a small proportion of smokers took steps to conceal packs that would otherwise be visible. Both are promising outcomes to minimize exposure to tobacco promotion.

Association between tobacco plain packaging and Quitline calls: a population-based, interrupted time-series analysis

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24438415

Abstract

OBJECTIVES:

To investigate whether the introduction of tobacco plain packaging in Australia from 1 October 2012 was associated with a change in the number of calls to the smoking cessation helpline, Quitline, and to compare this with the impact of the introduction of graphic health warnings from 1 March 2006.

DESIGN AND SETTING:

Whole-of-population interrupted time-series analysis in New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory between 1 March 2005 and October 2006 for the comparator, graphic health warnings, and October 2011 and April 2013 for the intervention of interest, tobacco plain packaging.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE:

Weekly number of calls to the Quitline, after adjusting for seasonal trends, anti-tobacco advertising, cigarette costliness and the number of smokers in the community.

RESULTS:

There was a 78% increase in the number of calls to the Quitline associated with the introduction of plain packaging (baseline, 363/week; peak, 651/week [95% CI, 523-780/week; P < 0.001]). This peak occurred 4 weeks after the initial appearance of plain packaging and has been prolonged. The 2006 introduction of graphic health warnings had the same relative increase in calls (84%; baseline, 910/week; peak, 1673/week [95% CI, 1383-1963/week; P < 0.001]) but the impact of plain packaging has continued for longer.

CONCLUSIONS:

There has been a sustained increase in calls to the Quitline after the introduction of tobacco plain packaging. This increase is not attributable to anti-tobacco advertising activity, cigarette price increases nor other identifiable causes. This is an important incremental step in comprehensive tobacco control.

Cigarette packaging and health warnings: the impact of plain packaging and message framing on young smokers

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24420310

Abstract

OBJECTIVE:

This study examined the impact of pictorial cigarette-warning labels, warning-label message framing and plain cigarette packaging, on young adult smokers’ motivation to quit.

METHODS:

Smokers aged 18-30 years (n=740) from a consumer research panel were randomised to one of four experimental conditions where they viewed online images of four cigarette packs with warnings about lung disease, cancer, stroke/heart disease and death, respectively. Packs differed across conditions by warning-message framing (gain vs loss) and packaging (branded vs plain). Measures captured demographics, smoking behaviour, covariates and motivation to quit in response to cigarette packs.

RESULTS:

Pictorial warnings about lung disease and cancer generated the strongest motivation to quit across conditions. Adjusting for pretest motivation and covariates, a message framing by packaging interaction revealed gain-framed warnings on plain packs generated greater motivation to quit for lung disease, cancer and mortality warnings (p<0.05), compared with loss-framed warnings on plain packs.

CONCLUSIONS:

Warnings combining pictorial depictions of smoking-related health risks with text-based messages about how quitting reduces risks, may achieve better outcomes among young adults, especially in countries considering or implementing plain packaging regulations.

ABC: India urged to follow Australian lead on cigarette plain-packaging

Stephanie March, reporting for ABC:

Anti-tobacco campaigners in India are calling for the country to follow Australia’s lead on plain packaging for cigarettes.

India is the second largest tobacco producing nation in the world and 1 million Indians die each year from cancer caused by smoking and chewing tobacco.

After lengthy court battles the Indian government has now introduced mandatory health warnings on tobacco packets, but health advocates say they’re weak.

Video: India looks to Australia for help in tobacco fight (ABC News)

Dr Ranga Rao, an Oncologist working in Delhi, says he sees some alarming cases.

“I remember a 21-year-old young girl who has been smoking from the age of 13 and she has grown up in the atmosphere of smoking – her parents used to smoke,” he said.

“So she picked up the smoking and she died of lung cancer at the age of 22 and a half.

“Fifty per cent of the people pick up the habit at the age of 12 to 15 years.”

One third of Indians use tobacco – about 400 million people.

It’s estimated the cost of treating tobacco related illness is more than $US5 billion a year.

Cigarettes, chewing tobacco and beedis, known as the poor man’s cigarette are all cheap and readily available to people of all ages.

Dr Monika Arora from the Public Health Foundation of India has done a survey of tobacco users and says the results are worrying.

She says despite the health warnings, many smokers – including children – still find the cigarette packaging appealing.

“They did say that the packs were very, very attractive for them, to the extent that when they looked at one of the pack, they were not sure if it is a candy or a cigarette pack,” she said.

An opposition MP has introduced a private members bill into the Indian parliament calling for logos and company branding to be totally removed from tobacco products.

Dr Arora says it’s based on plain packaging legislation passed in Australia last year.

“For Australia it was a big battle because they didn’t have a precedent to follow but for any country that is following, now it’s easier,” she said.

An Australian study has shown plain packaging makes smokers think about quitting more often.

The Indian legislation is yet to be debated in parliament and supporters of it are predicting staunch opposition from the tobacco industry.

Dr Arora says some politicians are also likely to oppose the changes.

“They have constituencies which are predominantly rolling beedis, so there is an interest why they should protect beedis, why they should protect tobacco products, smoking products,” she said..

The ABC asked India’s two biggest tobacco companies – Godfrey Philips, which is part owned by Phillip Morris and the Indian Tobacco Company – for comment on the legislation.

Neither company responded to the request.

29 Oct 2013

Global Mail: Big Tobacco’s Lawsuits Of Mass Destruction

from Michael Sofi, reporting for the Global Mail:

If Big Tobacco’s ongoing legal onslaught against the Australian government is intended to intimidate other countries considering plain-packaging laws, it’s not working. Not according to the architect of Ireland’s incoming plain-pack scheme, at least.

“It makes me more determined,” Irish Health Minister Dr James Reilly tells The Global Mail.

“It indicates to me that the tobacco industry know [plain packaging] is going to work, and that’s why they fear it.”

Draft legislation modelled on Australia’s plain-packaging laws was approved by the Irish cabinet in November, clearing the way for a bill to be introduced into Ireland’s national parliament, the Oireachtas, early next year.

It follows a surprise announcement on November 28 by British Prime Minister David Cameron, of an independent inquiry into the effectiveness of Australia’s laws, with a view to implementing similar legislation in the UK before 2015 national elections. In July this year, PM Cameron had appeared to abandon the tobacco-control measure.

(more…)