Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Standardised packaging of tobacco products in Australia

Early evidence about the predicted unintended consequences of standardised packaging of tobacco products in Australia: a cross-sectional study of the place of purchase, regular brands and use of illicit tobacco

Abstract

Objectives

To test for early evidence whether, following the standardisation of tobacco packaging, smokers in Australia were—as predicted by the tobacco industry—less likely to purchase from small mixed business retailers, more likely to purchase cheap brands imported from Asia and more likely to use illicit tobacco.

Design Serial cross-sectional population telephone surveys in November 2011 (a year prior to implementation), 2012 (during roll-out) and 2013 (a year after implementation).

Setting/participants Smokers aged 18 years and over identified in an annual population survey in the Australian state of Victoria (2011: n=754; 2012: n=590; 2013: n=601).

Main outcome measures

Changes between 2011 and 2013 in: proportions of current smokers who purchased their last cigarette from discount outlets such as supermarkets compared with small mixed business retail outlets; prevalence of regular use of low-cost brands imported from Asia and use of unbranded tobacco.

Results

The proportion of smokers purchasing from supermarkets did not increase between 2011 (65.4%) and 2013 (65.7%; p=0.98), and the percentage purchasing from small mixed business outlets did not decline (2011: 9.2%; 2012: 11.2%; p=0.32). The prevalence of low-cost Asian brands was low and did not increase between 2011 (1.1%) and 2013 (0.9%; p=0.98). The proportion reporting current use of unbranded illicit tobacco was 2.3% in 2011 and 1.9% in 2013 (p=0.46). In 2013, 2.6% of cigarette smokers reported having purchased one or more packets of cigarettes in non-compliant packaging in the past 3 months; 1.7% had purchased one or more packets from an informal seller in the past year.

Conclusions

One year after implementation, this study found no evidence of the major unintended consequences concerning loss of smoker patrons from small retail outlets, flooding of the market by cheap Asian brands and use of illicit tobacco predicted by opponents of plain packaging in Australia.

Download (PDF, 789KB)

Tobacco industry-funded research on standardised packaging: there are none so blind as those who will not see!

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2014/07/07/tobaccocontrol-2014-051734.short

Support for standardised packaging of tobacco products seems to be reaching a tipping point. Australia has already adopted this measure. In New Zealand, legislation is in progress. Ireland and England have now committed to implementing standardised packs while many other countries, including Canada, Norway and Turkey are actively considering them.

The tobacco industry, which has invested vast sums in the design of packs that appeal to new smokers, especially adolescents, is worried and, just as it did when bans on smoking in public places were being considered, is engaged in a wide-ranging and well-funded campaign to undermine the evidence.1 Laverty and colleagues warned about this, describing one such example using Australian data. They showed how the design of the study was such that it would have been virtually impossible to detect a significant effect.2 However, as we will now show, this was not an isolated incident.

Their warning would seem to be justified by a working paper published on the website of the Department of Economics of the University of Zürich, entitled ‘The (Possible) Effect of Plain Packaging on the Smoking Prevalence of Minors in Australia: A Trend Analysis’,3 funded by Philip Morris International. Its authors also conclude that there is no evidence that standardised packaging works and Philip Morris has press released it,4 generating headlines such as ‘Plain packs derided as not working’5 and ‘New data proves plain pack cigarettes doesn’t dissuade young smokers’.6 However, as we shall show, once again, it was almost inevitable that the data and methods used would fail to detect any expected effect.

The study looks at the ‘prevalence of smoking among Australians aged 14–17 years’, taking monthly prevalence …

Early evidence about the predicted unintended consequences of standardised packaging of tobacco products in Australia

Download (PDF, 789KB)

Australia: a cross-sectional study of the place of purchase, regular brands and use of illicit tobacco

Download (PDF, 777KB)

Standardised Packaging Bill 2014

Download (DOCX, 42KB)

Perceptions of plain packaging among young adult roll-your-own smokers in France: a naturalistic approach

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24920573

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

We explored, for the first time, young adult roll-your-own smokers’ response to using plain packaging in real-world settings.

METHODS:

Naturalistic research was employed, where 133 French young adult smokers (18-25 years of age) used plain roll-your-own packs for 10 days; the plain packs they were provided with contained their usual brand of rolling tobacco and displayed the name of their usual brand. Participants were recruited in five cities in France (Paris, Marseille, Metz, Nantes, Toulouse) and completed two questionnaires to measure their response to their own branded packs and the plain packs. Both questionnaires assessed pack perceptions, brand attachment, product perceptions (eg, taste, quality, natural), feelings about smoking (satisfying, pleasurable), feelings when using the pack in front of others (embarrassment, image), warning response (credibility, awareness of risks) and smoking-related behaviour (eg, consumption, quitting).

RESULTS:

Compared to their own fully branded packs, plain packs were associated with less positive pack and product perceptions, lower brand attachment and less positive feelings about smoking and feelings when using the pack in front of others. Participants were also more likely to report feeling like reducing consumption and quitting when using the plain packs, and more likely to feel like missing out on rolling a cigarette. No significant differences between the two pack types (plain and branded) were found in terms of credibility of warnings and perceptions of level of tar.

CONCLUSIONS:

The study suggests that the impacts of plain packaging for roll-your-own cigarette smokers are the same as for smokers of factory-made cigarettes.

Is smoking increasing in Australia?

http://www.theguardian.com/society/datablog/2014/jun/06/is-smoking-increasing-in-australia

Figures show the long-term trend in smoking is downwards. So is the Australian’s claim to the contrary just smoke and mirrors?

The front page of the Australian claims Labor’s plain packaging laws have failed, as industry research shows a small increase in tobacco sales volume between 2012 and 2013.

So, do the figures back up the Australian’s claim?

Firstly, it’s worth examining the industry data presented in the Australian’s article.

The key number they rely on is an increase in tobacco sales from 21.015bn in 2012 to 21.074bn in 2013*. Labor’s plain packaging laws were fully implemented in December 2012.

While this is a small 0.28% increase in sales year on year, they have failed to account for the increase in the population between 2012 and 2013.

Adjusted for population, tobacco sales per person have actually continued to decrease from 920.4 in 2012 to 906.9 in 2013:

Capture

Further, buried at the end of the article is another figure from British American Tobacco Australia spokesman Scott McIntyre:

“From 2008 to 2012 smoking incidence, or the number of people smoking, was declining at an average rate of 3.3% a year,” he said, pointing to Roy Morgan data.

“Since plain packaging was introduced, that decline rate slowed to 1.4%.”

So in their own article they have pointed out that the actual rate of smoking is continuing to decline. That is, the number of people smoking has decreased from 2012 to 2013.

Combined with the industry sales figures, all this suggests is that less people are smoking, but smokers may be buying slightly more tobacco.

These figures are at odds with the latest information from the ABS.

As Stephen Koukoulas points out, the latest ABS figures on household expenditure show as of March 2014, consumption of tobacco is the lowest it has ever been since 1959 when it first began to be recorded. Here’s a graph of said household expenditure, helpfully provided by Ketan Joshi.

The ABS national health survey has not yet covered the plain packaging time period, but again, the long-term trend is downwards.

Unfortunately we are unable to compare the methods of the ABS to the research body, InfoView, that provided the tobacco sales numbers as they’ve declined to release the full dataset.

The Australian also cites figures from the NSW population health survey showing a rise in smoking between 2011 (14.7% of all adults) and 2013 (16.4% of all adults). However between 2012, when plain packaging was introduced, and 2013, the figures for smoking in NSW actually show a small decline from 17.1% down to 16.4%:

3333

Statistically it’s likely that 2012 and 2013 are actually indistinguishable due to the sample size, and the jump from 2011 to 2012 is actually due to a change in methodology, as the NSW health department site says.

“In 2012 mobile phones were included in the survey methods for the first time and this increased the number of younger people and males in the survey sample. Both of these groups have relatively higher smoking rates, leading to a higher overall reported rate of current smoking. The rate for 2013 has stabilised.”

From 2002 to 2011, where the methods change, the long-term trend in smoking is downwards.

*Although the Australian’s graph showed 21.015m and 21.074m for 2012 and 2013 respectively, I’ve been told this should actually be in billions.

The (Possible) Effect of Plain Packaging on Smoking Prevalence in Australia: A Trend Analysis

Download (PDF, 188KB)

No lasting effects of plain packaging on cigarette pack retrieval time in small Australian retail outlets

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2014/05/30/tobaccocontrol-2014-051683.short

One of the many claims made by the tobacco industry against Australia’s plain packaging legislation was that plain standardised packaging would make it harder for retailers to locate and retrieve packs for customers.1 ,2 The industry argued this would lead to substantially longer transaction times, customer frustration, security issues and, ultimately, loss of trade from smaller convenience to larger discount outlets.3

A real-world study of a panel of small retail outlets by our group aimed to investigate this claim. We found only a small, temporary increase in cigarette pack retrieval times immediately following plain packaging implementation on 1 December 2012.4 By the second week of December 2012, pack retrieval times had returned to levels that were no different to baseline months, as was the case for February 2013.

The pack retrieval protocol was repeated a …

Tobacco health warning messages on plain cigarette packs and in television campaigns: a qualitative study with Australian socioeconomically disadvantaged smokers

http://her.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2014/06/25/her.cyu037.abstract?sid=efc70f55-d3c2-4e02-9b21-85b52c1c8c5a

Abstract

Television advertisements, packaging regulations and health warning labels (HWLs) are designed to communicate anti-smoking messages to large number of smokers. However, only a few studies have examined how high smoking prevalence groups respond to these warnings. This study explored how socioeconomically disadvantaged smokers engage with health risk and cessation benefit messages. Six focus groups were conducted over September 2012–April 2013 with adult clients of welfare organizations in regional New South Wales, Australia who were current smokers (n = 51).

Participants discussed HWLs, plain packaging and anti-smoking television advertisements. Discussions were audio-taped, transcribed verbatim and analysed using thematic analysis. Highly emotive warnings delivering messages of negative health effects were most likely to capture the attention of the study participants; however, these warning messages did not prompt quit attempts and participants were sceptical about the effectiveness of cessation programmes such as telephone quitlines. Active avoidance of health warning messages was common, and many expressed false and self-exempting beliefs towards the harms of tobacco. Careful consideration of message content and medium is required to communicate the anti-smoking message to disadvantaged smokers who consider themselves desensitized to warnings. Health communication strategies should continue to address false beliefs about smoking and educate on cessation services that are currently underutilized.