Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

France to introduce plain cigarette packaging

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-29367253

The new law would require packaging to be "the same shape, same size, same colour, same typeset"

The new law would require packaging to be “the same shape, same size, same colour, same typeset”

The French government has unveiled controversial new measures to cut the number of its smokers, including introducing plain cigarette packaging.

The proposals are specifically aimed at reducing the high rates of teenage smokers in France. Health Minister Marisol Touraine plans to follow Australia’s example, which introduced similar measures in 2012. Experts say removing branding on packets and adding large health warnings reduced smoking in Australia. However, some tobacco companies dispute the evidence for this and say France’s plans are incomprehensible. Smoking is the main cause of death in France, with more than 70,000 people dying each year of tobacco-related illnesses.

The new measures, which will come into effect once the law goes through the National Assembly, also includes a ban on smoking in children’s play areas in public parks and in cars carrying children under 12. In addition, advertising of e-cigarettes will be restricted before being banned in May 2016, except at the point of sale and in trade publications.

Ms Touraine says there are 13 million smokers in France – which has a population of around 66 million – and the “number of smokers is growing, especially among young people.”

“We can’t accept that tobacco kills 73,000 people every year in our country – the equivalent of a plane crash every day with 200 people on board,” she added.

The BBC’s Hugh Schofield in Paris says the move goes well beyond what France is required to do under European anti-smoking rules.

‘Completely incomprehensible’

EU laws already force tobacco firms to cover 65% of the packaging with health warnings, but Ms Touraine said they would be “the same shape, same size, same colour, same typeset” if the ban came into effect.

Celine Audibert, a spokeswoman for French firm Seita, which is a subsidiary of Imperial Tobacco, described the move as “completely incomprehensible”.

“It’s based on the Australian experience which, more than a failure, was a complete fiasco,” added Ms Audibert.

In 2012, Australia forced all cigarettes to be sold in identical brown packets, largely covered with graphic health warnings.

Tobacco clearances, an indicator of tobacco volumes in the Australian market, fell 3.4% in 2013 compared with 2012.

But Australia also raised cigarette taxes that led to consumer prices increasing, creating doubt over which move made the most difference.

Cigarettes, Unbranded

Lisa Shuchman, Corporate Counsel

September 8, 2014

The products are virtually indistinguishable from one another, yet they retain more loyalty than Mac computers. And an expensive international legal battle is raging over them. Why? Because the products—cigarettes—are a recognized public health hazard, and governments around the world are trying to do whatever it takes to stop their citizens from lighting up.

Many countries now require cigarette manufacturers to display on their packages huge warning labels with graphic photos depicting the effects of smoking. But the boldest move yet takes this a step further: It denies cigarette and cigar manufactures the ability to market their goods with any distinguishable colors, logos or other marks, requiring instead that all tobacco products be sold in “plain packaging.”

Tobacco companies have spent years perfecting their marketing strategies with the likes of a macho Marlboro Man and a kid-friendly Joe Camel. And their strategies have worked. The major way that consumers distinguish one brand from another is through branding—the packaging of the box and the image the cigarettes project for the smoker. Take away the brand image, cigarette makers say, and you take away their very identity.

Australia is the only country so far to enact a plain packaging law. But Ireland is brashly promising to be next. And other countries are also talking about adopting plain packaging for tobacco products—including the United Kingdom, New Zealand and even France, where smoking rates are still high and images of Pablo Picasso, Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus smoking unfiltered Gauloises are practically ingrained in the national consciousness.

So Big Tobacco is fighting back. Its principal weapon is intellectual property law. And in many ways it’s winning, with the threat of legal action acting as an impediment to cash-strapped nations.

“The tobacco industry believes that intellectual property laws give them the right to use their trademarks, and any law that limits that use constitutes infringement,” says Robert Stumberg, a law professor and director of the Harrison Institute for Public Law at Georgetown University Law, who has followed international tobacco litigation and regulation.

It’s important to understand that when people discuss plain packaging of tobacco products, the “plain” refers to the fact that all logos, distinctive fonts, colors and anything else that makes a cigarette brand appear distinctive in its box are stripped away. Beyond that, there is nothing “plain” about the packaging.

In fact, in Australia the boxes display huge warning labels depicting graphic photographs of the harmful effects of cigarette smoking: diseased lungs, a cancer-riddled mouth, a 34-year-old emaciated man dying of lung cancer. The warnings cover 75 percent of the front and 90 percent of the back of a cigarette pack, which is a uniform drab olive brown color. And the brand name, whether it be Marlboro, Camel, Lucky Strike or anything else, appears in a small, uniform font.

“The name of the brand is there, but you can only use the word mark in a prescribed way—using a specified size, font and color,” says Alistair Payne, an intellectual property attorney with the Dublin-based law firm Matheson who is an active member of the International Trademark Association (INTA) and has advised Philip Morris International on trademark issue arising from plain packaging proposals in Ireland. “There’s no special lettering permitted, no other word or logo. And from a trademark perspective, that is a taking of intellectual property.”

The tobacco industry tried to use that argument to stop Australia from implementing its plain packaging legislation. Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco sued, alleging that the law violated Australia’s constitution. The government would effectively be stealing their intellectual property, they said.

The High Court of Australia disagreed. The Australian constitution requires that there be an acquisition of property in order for there to be a taking, the judges ruled in 2012. But the Australian government did not acquire property, they ruled. The plain packaging law merely deprived tobacco companies from using their marks in any way they wished. And the country’s Trademark Act does not confer “a liberty to use registered trade marks free from restraints found in other statutes,” the judges wrote.

—

Big Tobacco lost that battle, but it was not ready to surrender. There is too much at stake. Australia’s win prompted other countries to start expressing interest in plain packaging. And for an industry already subject to strict advertising regulations, the possibility of losing individual brand logos, fonts and other distinctive marks on packaging could severely damage tobacco sales and the bottom line.

“What is at stake in these international cases is the very nature of trademarks in the global economy,” says Tyler Mace, assistant general counsel for Philip Morris International in Lausanne, Switzerland. “Is an owner of a trademark entitled to compensation when deprived of valuable property?”

Even before the loss in Australia’s domestic courts, Philip Morris had already found another venue to contest the law. In November 2011—on the same day Australia’s Parliament passed the plain packaging legislation—the tobacco company used its Hong Kong-based Asia subsidiary to file an investor-state claim against Australia. It alleged that the plain packaging law violated a bilateral investment treaty (BIT) between Hong Kong and Australia.

Philip Morris Asia charged that Australia’s plain packaging rules breached its obligations under the bilateral treaty. It deprived the company of the real value of its investments in Australia, it said, including “its brands, branding and intellectual property.” Investor-state disputes allow foreign corporations based in countries that are signatories to investment treaties to directly sue the countries in which they invest if they believe a government decision has unfairly affected their investment.

But the move by Philip Morris raised eyebrows. It wasn’t until the Australian government announced its intention to introduce a plain packaging law that the company did some corporate restructuring and had its Hong Kong-based subsidiary purchase its Australia-based counterpart—a move that positioned it to bring an investor-state case against Australia.

“Philip Morris went treaty shopping,” says Leonid Shmatenko, who has written about the tobacco disputes and is currently a Ph.D. candidate in public and international law at the University of Düsseldorf. “It had to do something, because Philip Morris International is based in Switzerland, a country that doesn’t have an investment treaty with Australia.”

Australia, in fact, is challenging Philip Morris’ right to bring the case, saying that the claim is an abuse of legal right and that the company does not have jurisdiction. It asked the three-judge tribunal hearing the case to first consider the question of Philip Morris’ jurisdiction. The company objected, but in April the international tribunal agreed to Australia’s request. It will first decide the jurisdiction question, and only if the judges determine that the court has jurisdiction will they hear arguments on the merits.

—

Meanwhile, five tobacco-producing countries have brought another intellectual property legal challenge to plain packaging laws—this one through the World Trade Organization. With financial assistance from the tobacco industry, the five—Honduras, Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Ukraine and Indonesia—have challenged Australia’s law, saying it violates the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, commonly known as TRIPS.

“This is the case everyone is watching now,” says Benn McGrady, a law professor and director of the O’Neill Institute Initiative on Trade, Investment and Health at Georgetown University Law. “There is a strong possibility that if Australia is successful at the WTO, a number of other countries will go down this path.”

TRIPS has been signed by more than 150 countries and sets minimum standards for intellectual property regulation. The WTO ruling would set a precedent, determining the extent to which a government can deny a company the right to use its own trademark and distinguish its product from others. Tobacco companies say they have a right to use their trademarks. Their opponents say trade agreements do not give companies that right. Instead, they argue, trademarks provide a negative right: They simply prevent others from using the same mark.

TRIPS is silent on this question, legal analysts say, and it will be up to the tribunal to interpret the treaty on this point. But the main argument, they say, will hinge on the judges’ interpretation of Article 20 of the TRIPS agreement, which states that the use of a trademark “shall not be unjustifiably encumbered” in the course of trade.

“The question is whether Australia’s actions are justifiable,” says McGrady, whose research has focused on the intersection of public health and international trade and investment law.

Australia and its supporters argue that evidence will show that it is justifiable. Data published in June indicates that smoking rates in Australia fell at their fastest pace in more than two decades following the introduction of plain packaging. Big Tobacco quickly disputed those statistics, but Australia’s Treasury, which collects data on sales in order to levy a tobacco excise tax, then published data showing that 3.4 percent fewer cigarettes were sold last year than in 2012. The graphic health warnings and plain packaging became mandatory on Dec. 1, 2012.

But beyond the data, Australia says its case is supported by Article 8 of the TRIPS agreement, which says countries may “adopt measures necessary to protect public health.” In addition, in 2001 the WTO issued the Doha Declaration on the TRIPS Agreement and Public Health—a document that reaffirmed flexibility of TRIPS member states in circumventing intellectual property rights in the name of public health. The TRIPS Agreement, the declaration states, “does not and should not prevent members from taking measures to protect public health.”

Moreover, the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, a United Nations treaty that is legally binding in almost 180 countries and was created “to protect present and future generations from the devastating health, social, environmental and economic consequences of tobacco consumption and exposure to tobacco smoke,” recommends most of the tobacco controls instituted by Australia. WHO also stated publicly that it supports Australia’s plain packaging legislation.

“It’s difficult to argue that what Australia has done is unjustifiable,” McGrady says.

—

But that’s exactly what Big Tobacco intends to do.

“This will be the first time that the full scope of Article 20 will be interpreted,” Philip Morris’ Mace says. “In the WTO, the issue is not whether tobacco is harmful. Instead, in the context of a treaty meant to protect intellectual property, can a government destroy the value and function of a registered trademark of a legal product?”

Groups such as the International Trademark Association and The U.S. Chamber of Commerce have issued statements in support of tobacco’s position. Plain packaging breaches intellectual property rights and infringes international trade agreements, they say. They add that it also will lead to smuggling and counterfeiting.

And since trademarks are dependent on “use” under common law, plain packaging laws will lead to the revocation of trademarks in many countries, notes Payne, the Dublin-based IP attorney. “If you don’t use it, you lose it—and any value attributable to the mark will go away,” he says.

To get around the “use” issue, Australia passed a law saying the nonuse of trademarks on tobacco products would not be grounds for revocation. But plain packaging still deprives a brand owner of a mark’s value, he says.

In addition, INTA is concerned that plain packaging will spread to other products—that tobacco is only the beginning. “Where will it end?” Payne asks. “This will set a precedent for other industries, and pretty soon we’ll be talking about restricting a brand owners’ trademark rights on fast food, sugary drinks and alcohol.”

While a domino effect is not imminent, legal analysts agree that there is sufficient vagueness in the treaties, and the WTO tribunal’s interpretation and ruling will set a new standard. “In the end, it will come down to finding a balance, says Shmatenko. “They’re going to have to weigh economic interests and property rights against the public good.”

While the legal battles continue, however, some tobacco critics say Big Tobacco has already won.

“Whenever a country goes beyond the WHO tobacco control recommendations, tobacco companies sue,” says Chris Bostic, policy director for the nonprofit group Action on Smoking and Health (ASH). “They do this not so much for a legal win, but to send a legal chill.”

Uruguay, for example, has been battling Philip Morris since 2010, with the tobacco giant alleging that the country is in violation of a bilateral investment treaty with Switzerland—home to Philip Morris International’s headquarters.

In 2009 Uruguay passed what was then the world’s most stringent tobacco control law, requiring that 80 percent of cigarette packs be covered by health warnings that include graphic photos of the health effects of smoking and restricting—but not eliminating—tobacco company branding. In its investor-state case, Philip Morris is demanding $25 million in compensation for damage to its brands.

The case is expected to cost Uruguay at least $8 million, an amount the country can ill afford. In fact, Uruguay was about to give up the fight because of the expense, according to Stumberg. But philanthropies owned by former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who founded the Bloomberg Initiative to Reduce Tobacco Use, pledged money to assist with Uruguay’s legal expenses.

“Philip Morris International’s annual global revenue is bigger than Uruguay’s GDP, and the tobacco industry is well aware of that,” says Bostic. “Tobacco will use whatever means it can to kill attempts at tobacco control, because it knows if one country succeeds, others may follow.”

Big Tobacco is also attacking countries in the European Union because they, too, have increased tobacco control measures. The countries, which already display graphic warnings on their cigarette packaging, adopted a revised EU Tobacco Products Directive in March. The new directive calls for an increase in the size of picture health warnings so they dominate each cigarette pack. In addition, flavored tobacco products, such as menthol cigarettes, are banned. And while the directive stops short of establishing plain packaging, it does allow each EU country to decide whether it wants its laws to go further.

In June, Philip Morris challenged the legislation, saying that it violates EU treaties governing competition and consumer rights.

Finally, the tobacco industry’s legal challenges have stalled moves by other countries considering the adoption of plain packaging, legal analysts say. New Zealand was one of the first countries to say it would follow Australia’s lead, but it is now waiting to see what happens in Australia’s bilateral treaty and WTO disputes.

The United Kingdom has also expressed interest in adopting plain packaging but is now concerned about the legal risk and is waiting to see what happens at the WTO. France, too, has vacillated about how far it will go in light of all the pending litigation.

Only Ireland appears to be pushing ahead, despite heavy lobbying from U.S. and European business, trade and intellectual property associations. Pressure has also come from U.S. elected officials, mostly from tobacco-growing states. And there have been legal threats from the tobacco industry. But in June, the country introduced its own plain packaging legislation. James Reilly, the country’s former health minister and a licensed medical doctor, has vowed to make Ireland smoke-free by 2025. The tobacco industry has said it will bring a legal challenge and demand compensation for the loss of its intellectual property if the legislation passes.

Some countries are growing increasingly concerned about the tobacco industry’s use of international treaties to squelch tobacco control efforts in the name of intellectual property. Malaysia has even suggested that a carve-out be created for tobacco so it is not included in the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement currently being negotiated.

Stumberg and other legal analysts say that in time, the tribunals may rule that trade agreements do not give companies an inherent right to use their trademarks, and they may issue a finding that governments have regulatory authority for tobacco products.

But, he says, they could also rule the other way.

“In the meantime, these cases cost governments huge amounts of time and money, and that creates a chilling effect, he says. “Win, lose or draw, the tobacco companies have already slowed momentum and the move toward plain packaging around the world.”

http://www.corpcounsel.com/id=1202669248576/Cigarettes-Unbranded?slreturn=20140809112743

Assessing the impact of plain packaging 1 year postimplementation

Download (PDF, 474KB)

Plain packaging leaves smokers with bad taste

A study by Newcastle medical researchers has found since the introduction of plain packaged cigarettes, many smokers are unable to identify the different brands.

The study took place before and after plain packaging was introduced and involved long-term smokers in the Hunter region.

The University of Newcastle study found the introduction of plain packaged cigarettes impacted smokers’ perception of how they taste.

Research associate Ashleigh Guillaumier says many smokers said all cigarettes now taste the same, showing the power branding has had on consumers.

“After plain packs hit the shelves they were saying that they’d noticed a deterioration in both the taste and the quality of their cigarettes,” he said.

“I think this study really shows the power of the branding and that’s one of the reasons why the tobacco industry fought so hard against the introduction of plain packs in Australia.”

15 Jul 2014

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-07-15/plain-packaging-leaves-smokers-with-bad-taste/5597860

Australia wins first battle in plain packaging trade dispute

July 2, 2014

Australia has had a victory in the first step of the plain packaging challenge being played out in an international investment tribunal.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration has ordered that Australia will be allowed to challenge Philip Morris Asia’s right to contest our plain packaging laws, on the grounds that the company only bought shares in its Australian arm so that it could launch the case.

If Australia wins, it could see the legal challenge wrap up far earlier than expected, at far less cost, as well being a blow to corporations that engage in “treaty shopping”, or buying shares in countries to use trade treaties to their advantage.

Jonathan Liberman, the director of the McCabe Centre for Law and Cancer, said the tribunal had essentially decided to agree to the request to split the case in two because they had accepted that Australia’s objections were, on the face of it, ”serious and substantial”.

Australia believes the fact that Philip Morris Asia only acquired its shares in the Australian company 10 months after the government had announced it would implement plain packaging means it does not rightly fall under a trade agreement we have with Hong Kong.

”The Australian Government argues that an investor cannot buy into a dispute by making an investment at the time when a dispute is either existing or highly probable,” Mr Liberman wrote in an update on the case.

In addition, the government believes Philip Morris Asia made ”false and misleading” claims when it applied to buy Philip Morris Australia and filled in a statutory notice explaining why it was intending to do so.

”It argues that the true purpose of Philip Morris Asia’s investment was to place [it] in a position where it could bring the claim once the legislation had been enacted,” he said.

It was on these two objections that the tribunal decided to split the case, hearing them before any full case was to proceed.

“The fact that they have decided they were worth hearing first means they think they have a substantial chance of success,” Mr Liberman said. ”If Australia wins on these grounds, it will set an important precedent. It would send a clear message that this kind of ‘treaty-shopping’ behaviour should not be allowed.”

Professor of health policy at Curtin University Mike Daube said if Australia won, even on jurisdictional grounds, it would inspire confidence in other countries.

”It is clearly in the industry’s interests to keep dragging this process on, because the longer it’s going on, the longer they can say it is under review,” he said, adding the company had tried to have all the hearings held in secret.

”We’ve already had the High Court victory, and as soon as a big international decision goes that will send out a pretty big signal.”

Chris Argent, a spokesman for Philip Morris, said it would be inappropriate to respond to Australia’s allegations outside of the tribunal.

But he said the plain packaging laws entailed the destruction of brands.

“Building a brand is a long-term, significant investment that international law protects from arbitrary government action of exactly the sort at the heart of our claim,” he said. “The forced removal of our brands and trademarks by the Australian Government is a clear violation of the terms of the bilateral investment treaty between Australia and Hong Kong, and we believe we have a very strong case for actual damages that may amount to billions of Australian dollars.”

“The transfer of ownership of the Australian operation to PM Asia occurred long before plain packaging was adopted.”

Plunge in smoking attributed to plain packaging

July 17, 2014

Harriet Alexander

A dramatic decline in smoking rates has coincided with the introduction of plain-packaging laws.

The daily smoking rate plunged from 15.1 per cent to 12.8 per cent between 2010 and 2013, according to the largest and longest-running national survey on drug statistics.

Most people are now 16 before they smoke their first full cigarette, up from 14 in 2010, and 95 per cent of 12 to 17-year-olds have never smoked.

Public health experts say the findings of the National Drugs Strategy Household Survey vindicate plain-packaging laws, which tobacco companies recently claimed to have boosted cigarette sales by leading to a price war.

“It’s almost like finding a vaccine that works very well against lung cancer,” said Simon Chapman, a professor in public health at the University of Sydney.

“It’s that big. This will give enormous momentum to the international push for plain packaging right around the world.”

India and France are considering plain packaging laws. Ireland, New Zealand and Britain have legislation before their parliaments.

The survey of nearly 24,000 Australians was conducted between July and December 2013, before the new 12.5 per cent tobacco tax.

“We know that that tax has a lot of influence over consumption so it’s really important that the data was collected before that,” Professor Chapman said.

“The only thing that happened in the 12 months before that was the introduction of plain packaging laws.”

Geoff Neideck of the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, which conducts the survey every two to three years, said the results were continued a longer trend, which has seen smoking rates halved since 1991.

The plain-packaging laws should be seen in the context of changing attitudes and cultural practices, he said.

Sixteen-year-old Gabe Hutcheon said on Wednesday he had no desire to try smoking.

“My granddad died from it, so I’ll go my whole life without smoking,” he said.

“It’s expensive, but I don’t care about that. All the ads show what it can do.”

The price of the the average packet of cigarettes has been in a steep upward trajectory since 2000.

Gemma Jones, 16, agreed, although she doubted whether the plain packaging was a deterrent.

“If people want to smoke they will do it,” she said. “It’s stupid, smells like shit and it kills people.”

The president of the Australian Council on Smoking and Health, Mike Daube, said they were the best results he had seen in his 40-year career in health policy.

The National Preventative Health Taskforce in 2009 set a target of 10 per cent adult prevalence by 2018.

” I think we are now going to beat that, and once we’re below 10 per cent I think we will see an even faster decline as smoking essentially becomes an abnormal behaviour,” Professor Daube said.

He attributed the figures to effective media campaigns, tax increases and bipartisan political approach to reducing smoking, as well as the plain packaging laws.

“The plain packaging has been a crucial factor in the last two to three years,” he said.

– with Eryk Bagshaw

World Health Organisation says Pacific considering cigarette plain packaging

The World Health Organisation says a number of countries across the Pacific are considering following in Australia’s footsteps and introducing plain packaging of cigarettes.

The WHO is set to join governments across the region in a major drive to make the Pacific tobacco free within 10 years.

The WHO Pacific coordinator of non-communicable diseases, Dr Temo Waqanivalu, says the project will be launched in Honiara in two weeks and plain packaging is among the tactics being considered.

“The actual measure itself is something that’s greatly supported and there are a few countries that are ahead of the game, (they) are actually talking of moving there now,” Dr Waqanivalu told Radio Australia’s Pacific Beat.

“They’ve done the graphic warnings on the packets so the next step after that is to actually move towards plain packaging.”

Dr Waqanivalu says increasing the tax on cigarettes and cracking down on the tobacco black market are the keys to reduce smoking.

“If those two happen, well then especially the young smokers, the youth, they’re the first ones who actually going to begin to quit,” he said.

“Economic ministers should really think seriously about assisting… part of that is facilitating increased taxation on tobacco cigarettes.”

The WHO says Cook Islands has been a leader on reducing smoking, having significantly increased the price of cigarettes with plans for further rises.

“Cook Islands is really exemplary of what we are trying to promote across the Pacific and they’ve done exceptionally well.”

But Dr Waqanivalu says the tobacco industry is fighting back.

“We know the tobacco industry is always at work,” he said. “We see them influencing ministries of health.”

Dr Waqanivalu says the WHO’s plans also involve setting up services to help people quit.

30 Jun 2014

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-06-30/an-who-to-launch-pacific-anti-smoking-campaign/5560166

Plain packs for tobacco would save £500m in first year, says PHE

Caroline White

Thursday, 7 August 2014

Standardised packaging for cigarettes and hand rolling tobacco could not only prevent countless smoking related deaths, but also chalk up £500 million in savings in the first year of its introduction, Public Health England has calculated.

The calculations have been submitted as part of PHE’s response to the Government’s consultation on whether to introduce mandatory plain packs for tobacco. The consultation closes today. It builds on PHE’s submission to Sir Cyril Chantler’s review on standardised packaging in January 2014.

In June 2014, the Department of Health published draft regulations for proposed requirements for the packaging of tobacco, to include policies on the colour of the packet, allowed text and typeface, and requirements for the appearance of individual cigarettes.

Recent official data from Australia, where standardised packaging has been in force since December 2012, show a 3.4% fall in tobacco sales by volume in the first year following the introduction of the measure.

If that was mirrored here, PHE predicts that total savings across England would be around £500 million, based on the estimated number of smokers in each local authority and unitary authority and the total spend on tobacco in the UK for 2012-13.

As tobacco is a major cause of health inequalities, the benefits would be most felt in areas of greater social deprivation, says PHE. This is because plain packs would not only reduce the ill health caused by smoking, but also increase families’ disposable income, and enable the money to be spent on other things in local economies.

Retailers have argued that the measure would hit their profits, but PHE says that they make relatively little profit from tobacco sales. On average, only 7-9% of the cost of tobacco is retained by the retailer, compared with 20-30% for food and drink products.

The estimated figures show potential knock-on local economic benefits of: £61.3 million in London; £9.2 million in Birmingham; £4.4 million in Hull; and £3.3 million in Plymouth.

Professor Kevin Fenton, National Director of Health and Wellbeing, Public Health England, said: “Smoking remains the biggest cause of premature mortality in England, accounting for 80,000 deaths every year. Standardised packaging is a powerful measure that would help to save lives.

“The evidence from Australia is adding to the substantial and irrefutable case that the absence of attractive packaging works to reduce the number of smokers, as well as encouraging others to cut down.”

He added: “Only last week we saw smoking levels among young people at an all-time low. The introduction of standardised packaging will be a major boost to our tobacco control efforts – helping move us closer towards achieving a tobacco free generation, which is now in our reach.”

John McClurey, an independent newsagent and member of Gateshead Council, said the PHE figures were “good news for local businesses.”

He continued: “Traders like me are well aware of the tiny profit from tobacco products – I make similar profit from a pack of chewing gum as a £6 pack of cigarettes. What my customers save by quitting or never starting to smoke, they can spend on other goods or services in the area – providing a real boost to the local economy.”

http://www.onmedica.com/newsarticle.aspx?id=30f975ec-48d8-44e5-ab96-dd46ac5953df

Plain packaging for tobacco an investment in kids’ health

Thursday, 7 August 2014, 10:01 am
Press Release: New Zealand Plunket Society

7 August 2014

Plain packaging for tobacco an investment in Kiwi kids’ health – Plunket

Plunket welcomes the Health Select Committee’s recommendation that the Bill to remove branding from tobacco products go ahead, saying the policy is ‘an important investment in the health of New Zealand children’. (The Select Committee’s report is here: http://www.parliament.nz/en-nz/pb/sc/documents/reports/50DBSCH_SCR57000_1/smoke-free-environments-tobacco-plain-packaging-amendment)

The Health Select Committee considered over 15,000 submissions on the Smoke-free Environments (Tobacco Plain Packaging) Amendment Bill and recommended it is passed, with the name of the proposed legislation altered to ‘standardised packaging’. Plunket was among organisations to make a submission to the Select Committee backing the Bill as a necessary measure to protect the health and well being of our current and future generations.

“Plunket strongly supports this Bill and we welcome the Select Committee’s recommendation that it be passed into law. The best Australian evidence shows it is effective at increasing attempts to quit smoking, as well as discouraging young people from starting,” said Clair Trainor, Plunket Senior Policy Analyst. “This represents a huge untapped health gain for New Zealand children. The sooner we get on and reduce children’s exposure to second-hand smoke and to tobacco advertising in the home, the quicker we’ll start to improve these children’s respiratory health – and that of future generations.”

She said children’s exposure to tobacco advertising from packaging was considerable: “The latest Census data indicates that as many as six out of ten New Zealand children live in households where tobacco is smoked by an adult who lives there. Our own data finds Māori and Pacific children living in highly deprived areas are up to three to four times more likely to live with a smoker than those in middle or low areas of deprivation. This Bill would mean that children of smokers are no longer exposed to tobacco branding on packs inside their homes, which would bring their tobacco advertising exposure into line with that of other Kiwi kids.”

Plunket supports the Government’s goal of halving tobacco consumption by 2015 and achieving a smoke-free New Zealand by 2025, and says the law change is essential if the Government is to achieve the goal it set itself in 2011.

Elaine Gordon, Plunket Clinical Advisor said the health risks to children from exposure to second-hand smoke were significant, and reducing the risks form a central part of Plunket’s work: “Second-hand smoke is a known risk factor in Sudden Unexpected Death of an Infant (SUDI – also known as SIDS or cot death) as well as coughs, colds, respiratory problems such as bronchiolitis, pneumonia, asthma and ear infections including glue ear. Children with asthma are especially sensitive to second hand smoke. It may cause more asthma attacks and the attacks may be more severe, requiring trips to the hospital.

“Plunket works in partnership with families and whānau to connect them with services that will support them to become smoke-free. During Plunket visits we have conversations and share information with families and whānau about the benefits of being smoke-free. All Plunket nurses are trained to deliver cessation support and in some cases Nicotine Replacement Therapy.”

She said that plain packaging was an important part of the range of policies and support services needed to protect children from the serious health impacts of second-hand smoke.

Notes

• Since introducing plain packaging in 2012, Australia’s Commonwealth Treasury reports tobacco clearances (including excise and customs duty) fell by 3.4% in 2013. The Australian Bureau of Statistics has reported that in the March quarter 2014 the consumption of tobacco was the lowest ever recorded. http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/tobacco-kff

• The Smokefree 2025 commitment was made by the Government in response to the Māori Affairs committee’s inquiry into the tobacco industry and the consequences of smoking for Māori.http://www.health.govt.nz/our-work/preventative-health-wellness/tobacco-control/smokefree-2025

• In August 2013 the New Zealand Medical Journal reported Māori children are at twice the risk of being exposed to second-hand smoke in the home.

• Smoke exposure assessment, cessation support, and the promotion of smoke-free environments is a part of Plunket’s everyday work to help give every child the best start in life. This includes advocating for plain packaging on tobacco products to prevent harmful advertising messages reaching the under fives.

• Along with more severe health impacts, children who are regularly exposed to second-hand smoke cough and wheeze more, have more difficulty getting over colds, and miss many more school days than children who aren’t exposed. Second hand smoke can cause other symptoms including stuffy nose, headache, sore throat, eye irritation, and hoarseness.

http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/GE1408/S00025/plain-packaging-for-tobacco-an-investment-in-kids-health.htm

Young women smokers’ response to using plain cigarette packaging: qualitative findings from a naturalistic study

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25100245

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

The aim of this study was to explore in-depth the response of young women smokers (18-35 years) to using dark brown ‘plain’ cigarette packs in naturalistic settings.

METHODS:

Participants were recruited in six towns and cities in Scotland to take part in a naturalistic study, where they used plain cigarette packs for a week. Participants completed a number of questionnaires during the study period (reported elsewhere), and a sub-sample participated in post-study telephone interviews to explore their experiences of using the plain packs. Of the 187 participants who completed the study, 23 were randomly selected to participate in the post-study interviews. Within the interviews a semi-structured topic guide was used to assess perceptions of the plain pack, feelings created by the pack, feelings about smoking, and avoidant and smoking behaviour.

RESULTS:

The brown (plain) packs were perceived negatively due to the colour, the undesirable image the pack conveyed, and the reaction from others. The plain packs were also associated with negative feelings, such as embarrassment, discomfort and guilt. Some participants also commented that they felt differently about the product, considered to be less enjoyable or more harmful, when using the plain packs, and were less interested in, or felt more negatively about, smoking. A number of participants said that they had engaged in avoidant behavior with the plain packs, such as hiding it, due to their negative thoughts about the packs and the reaction of others. Some participants also mentioned cessation-related behaviours when using the plain packs, such as forgoing cigarettes, stubbing cigarettes out early and thinking about quitting, largely due to the decreased enjoyment of smoking.

CONCLUSIONS:

The experience of using cigarettes in plain packs prompted a range of negative responses from young women smokers, who are a crucial target group for tobacco control interventions.