Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Personal tobacco pack display before and after the introduction of plain packaging with larger pictorial health warnings in Australia: an observational study of outdoor café strips.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24428427

Abstract

AIMS:

We tested whether prevalence of cigarette pack display and smoking at outdoor venues and pack orientation changed following the introduction of plain packaging and larger pictorial health warnings in Australia.

METHODS:

Between October and April 2011-12 (pre-plain packaging, pre-PP) and 2012-13 (post-plain packaging, post-PP), we counted patrons, smokers and tobacco packs at cafés, restaurants and bars with outdoor seating. Pack type (fully branded, plain or unknown) and orientation were noted. Rates of pack display, smoking and pack orientation were analysed using multi-level Poisson regression.

RESULTS:

Pack display declined by 15% [adjusted incident rate ratio (IRR) = 0.85, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.79-0.91, P < 0.001], driven by a 23% decline in active smoking (IRR = 0.77, 95% CI = 0.71-0.84, P < 0.001) between phases. The decline in pack display coincided with the full implementation of plain packaging from December 2012, was stronger in venues with children present and was limited to mid and high socio-economic status (SES) areas. The proportion of packs orientated face-up declined from 85.4% of fully branded packs pre-PP to 73.6% of plain packs post-PP (IRR = 0.87, 95% CI = 0.79-0.95, P = 0.002). Alternatively, the proportions concealed by telephones, wallets or other items (4.4% of fully branded packs pre-PP and 9.5% of plain packs post-PP; IRR = 2.33, 95% CI = 1.72-3.17, P < 0.001) and in an external case (1.5-3.5% of all packs; IRR = 2.79, 95% CI = 1.77-4.40, P < 0.001) increased. Low SES areas evidenced the greatest increase in pack concealment and the greatest decline in face-up pack orientation.

CONCLUSIONS:

Following Australia’s 2012 policy of plain packaging and larger pictorial health warnings on cigarette and tobacco packs, smoking in outdoor areas of cafés, restaurants and bars and personal pack display (packs clearly visible on tables) declined. Further, a small proportion of smokers took steps to conceal packs that would otherwise be visible. Both are promising outcomes to minimize exposure to tobacco promotion.

Standardized Packaging Of Tobacco Products May Reduce Smoking, Especially Among the Youth

http://lungdiseasenews.com/2015/02/23/standardized-packaging-of-tobacco-products-may-reduce-smoking-especially-among-the-youth/

A collection of research papers and commentaries, peer-reviewed, were published in the journal Addiction under the title “Plain Packaging: Weighing up the evidence on standardized packaging for tobacco products” to reaffirm key parts of the evidence base, collected from years 2008 to 2015, for standardized packaging of tobacco products and its influence in reducing smoking rates and preventing lung diseases.

A recent announcement by the English government on new regulations regarding standardized packaging will be put to a vote before the general election that is set to take place in May 2015. In the event the vote is passed, England will be the second country worldwide to mandate standardized packaging, following Australia’s lead. Further, there is a strong possibility that this new measure would also be introduced in the other jurisdictions of the United Kingdom. These documents evidence the growing awareness of the potential of standardized packaging in reducing smoking.

Major findings say that plain packaging might reduce smoking in those who are current smokers since it reduces the influence of the packaging as an unconscious trigger for smoking impulses.

Further, following Australia’s 2012 policy, simple packages with larger pictured health warnings printed on it reduced smoking in outdoor and public areas such as restaurants, cafés and bars since the majority did not keep their packs on the tables. Current variations on package shape, opening method and size may also have an influence on the brand appeal and smoking risk perceptions which in turn increase cigarette sales. By removing the images regarding the brand from the cigarette packets, experimental adolescent smokers pay more visual attention to the warning health signs; however, adolescents that smoke daily remain indifferent. Standardized packaging could in fact be much more effective than large health warnings when it comes to undermining the appeal of cigarette brands and reducing the urge to buy cigarettes.

Ann McNeill, a professor who wrote the collection’s introduction, said in a press release: “Arguably, for an addictive product that kills so many of its users, the tobacco industry should consider itself fortunate that, purely through historical precedent, it is allowed to sell its toxic products at all, let alone try to make them attractive through the packaging. However, it is evidence on the likely public health impact that is the primary basis for the policy on standardized packaging.”

Philip Morris vs Oriental Republic of Uruguay

Download (PDF, 65KB)

Northern Ireland backs plain tobacco packet plan

02 February 2015

Northern Ireland’s health minister has backed plans to introduce standardised cigarette packaging.

Jim Wells said the region would be included in the UK Government’s proposals for plain tobacco product packets, which is set to be voted on by MPs in Westminster before the General Election.

Wales has already backed the potential UK-wide law change, with Scottish ministers also signalling their support for the measure.

If backed by MPs, plain packaging could be introduced by May 2016.

Some Conservative MPs have voiced opposition to the plans.

Announcing that he was giving consent for Northern Ireland to be included in the proposed legislation, Mr Wells said: “Smoking remains the single greatest cause of preventable illness and premature death in Northern Ireland. Half of all smokers will be killed by their use of tobacco products.

“Branding on cigarette packets provides one of the last opportunities for tobacco companies to promote their products. Evidence shows that young people are more receptive to this type of advertising than adults. I believe that standardised packaging has the potential to contribute to a further reduction in child and adult smoking prevalence and look forward to this measure being introduced in Northern Ireland.”

Standardised packaging will require all cigarettes and hand rolling tobacco for retail sale to meet certain conditions including:

:: Standard colour (dull brown on the outside and white on the inside)

:: All text on the packaging, including brand name and variant, to be in a standard typeface

:: No branding, advertising or promotion on the pack (except the use of the brand name)
advertisement

All tobacco products will continue to carry health warnings.

http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/local-national/northern-ireland/ni-backs-plain-tobacco-packet-plan-30957507.html

Use and abuse of statistics in tobacco industry-funded research on standardised packaging

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25650186

Abstract

In this commentary we consider the validity of tobacco industry-funded research on the effects of standardised packaging in Australia. As the first country to introduce standardised packs, Australia is closely watched, and Philip Morris International has recently funded two studies into the impact of the measure on smoking prevalence. Both of these papers are flawed in conception as well as design but have nonetheless been widely publicised as cautionary tales against standardised pack legislation. Specifically, we focus on the low statistical significance of the analytical methods used and the assumption that standardised packaging should have an immediate large impact on smoking prevalence.

Philip Morris vs Uruguay

Download (PDF, 1.89MB)

MPs vote on plain packaging signals industry defeat – but there may be a sting in the tale

 

The government’s decision to allow MPs to vote on standardised packaging before the general election will finally bring to an end the tobacco industry’s three-year campaign to prevent regulation of cigarette packs in the UK. A campaign, our research shows, in which they used misleading evidence on both the illicit tobacco trade and the health benefits of standardised packaging as a tool to delay legislation.

That MPs will have the opportunity to vote on standardised packaging has been widely welcomed by health advocates and the medical community – and strongly criticised by tobacco industry-supported organisations such as Forest and the Institute of Economic Affairs, which said it was a “gross infringement of the right of companies to use their trademarks and design their own packaging”.

But a wealth of evidence from the independent review by Sir Cyril Chantler, indicates that that this important measure is likely to help reduce the number of children and young people taking up smoking. It is hoped that this will reduce the number of deaths from smoking-related diseases, which currently stands at around 100,000 a year in the UK.

If introduced, standardised packaging regulations will prohibit all on-pack branding, except the name and brand variant, printed in a standard font. In place of branding, packs will feature written and graphic health warnings, covering a minimum of 65% of the pack, in line with the new EU Tobacco Products Directive.

The vote

The decision to allow a parliamentary vote before the election is hugely important. Despite broad cross-party support for the measure, there would inevitably have been a significant delay before standardised packaging made it back on to the parliamentary agenda – whether the government had changed after the election or not – if this decision hadn’t happened now.

It seems likely that standardised cigarette packaging will now be passed by parliament without any further delay. In a whipped vote last year, MPs showed their support for the idea in principle, with only 24 MPs not voting for the measure. The House of Lords has also shown its support by tabling the amendment to the Children and Families Bill in 2013 which allowed the first vote to take place.

The tobacco industry’s response

This decision signals the death knell to the tobacco industry’s campaign but it may yet mark the start of a new battle if tobacco companies take the issue to the courts.

In addition to their arguments about a rise in illicit trade and the questioning of health benefits, tobacco companies have also claimed that it is an infringement of their intellectual property. They have funded front groups, such as Forest and Hands Off Our Packs, using them as a vehicle to promote these arguments to the general public. And they have commissioned research of their own in a bid to undermine the evidence base for standardised packaging.

But research conducted by myself and colleagues at the University of Bath and the UK Centre for Tobacco and Alcohol Studies last year exposed the misleading nature of tobacco industry evidence on both the illicit trade and the health impacts of standardised packaging.

The government’s decision to progress standardised packaging to a vote in the House of Commons seems to show that while the legislative process may have been protracted by tobacco industry opposition, it has not ultimately been undermined by it.

The vote’s significance

If – or, as seems likely, when – MPs vote for standardised packaging, the UK will be one of the first countries to implement the measure in Europe – Ireland is also progressing legislation – and only the second or third globally, following in Australia’s footsteps. This ground-breaking innovation in tobacco control legislation illustrates the UK’s commitment to the health of its population and of its children: every year more than 200,000 11 to 15-year-olds start smoking in the UK (around 170,000 in England).

It is to be hoped that the devolved assemblies will also follow Westminster in introducing the measure and that the UK, like Australia, will stand firm against any legal action the tobacco companies may now undertake. This important measure will be worth defending: it will contribute to a reduction in the impact of smoking on our – and our children’s – health.

Plain packaging for cigarettes will see the end of some wickedly wonderful marketing

http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/features/plain-packaging-for-cigarettes-will-see-the-end-of-some-wickedly-wonderful-marketing-9996615.html

Another nail in the coffin for the tobacco industry, then, if not for its untapped markets. Should the Government get its way, the ability to buy the smoke you prefer – already hampered in supermarkets by shuttered cabinets that prevent you from viewing the full range – will be further curtailed by the introduction of plain packaging for fags and baccy. The idea is not to make smokers feel like social lepers, though brown wrappers do rather smack of the Soho sex shop, but to weaken the bonds of loyalty between addict and pusher; and to denude the products of any attractive associations that may still cling to them.

The smoking lobby may argue that, however impressionable the youth, they can resist striking colours and distinctive typefaces, which are now just about their only means of communication with the public (and even then with grisly pictures of shrivelled lungs and terrible health warnings). Their opponents would reply that, if the branding doesn’t matter, then why not dispense with it?

This approach ignores the fact that, while smokers in dire need will pull on anything to reduce the craving, they are loyal to their brand’s taste as well as the “values” implied by its wrapping. (And yes, abstainers, different cigarettes do have different tastes, from the toasty hit of a Marlboro Red to the creamier feel of a blue Pall Mall.) It also relies for support on statistics from Australia that are hotly contested.

The plain brigade claims that the number of smokers on the continent who daily drag on tax-legal fags has declined. The tobacco giants reply that household expenditure on tabs has actually increased. The legit business says that tax-evading smuggling and (even more dangerous) counterfeiting are on the rise in Oz, the government disputes that. And your correspondent? I can’t help but feel nostalgic for the far-off Fifties, when cigarette marketing was unregulated: when Consulates were “cool as a mountain stream” and “more doctors smoke[d] Camel than any other cigarette”.

MPs vote on plain packaging signals industry defeat – but there may be a sting in the tale

http://theconversation.com/mps-vote-on-plain-packaging-signals-industry-defeat-but-there-may-be-a-sting-in-the-tale-36622

The government’s decision to allow MPs to vote on standardised packaging before the general election will finally bring to an end the tobacco industry’s three-year campaign to prevent regulation of cigarette…

Put you off? That’s the point. Ella Pickover/PA

Put you off? That’s the point. Ella Pickover/PA

The government’s decision to allow MPs to vote on standardised packaging before the general election will finally bring to an end the tobacco industry’s three-year campaign to prevent regulation of cigarette packs in the UK. A campaign, our research shows, in which they used misleading evidence on both the illicit tobacco trade and the health benefits of standardised packaging as a tool to delay legislation.

That MPs will have the opportunity to vote on standardised packaging has been widely welcomed by health advocates and the medical community – and strongly criticised by tobacco industry-supported organisations such as Forest and the Institute of Economic Affairs, which said it was a “gross infringement of the right of companies to use their trademarks and design their own packaging”.

But a wealth of evidence from the independent review by Sir Cyril Chantler, indicates that that this important measure is likely to help reduce the number of children and young people taking up smoking. It is hoped that this will reduce the number of deaths from smoking-related diseases, which currently stands at around 100,000 a year in the UK.

If introduced, standardised packaging regulations will prohibit all on-pack branding, except the name and brand variant, printed in a standard font. In place of branding, packs will feature written and graphic health warnings, covering a minimum of 65% of the pack, in line with the new EU Tobacco Products Directive.

The vote

The decision to allow a parliamentary vote before the election is hugely important. Despite broad cross-party support for the measure, there would inevitably have been a significant delay before standardised packaging made it back on to the parliamentary agenda – whether the government had changed after the election or not – if this decision hadn’t happened now.

It seems likely that standardised cigarette packaging will now be passed by parliament without any further delay. In a whipped vote last year, MPs showed their support for the idea in principle, with only 24 MPs not voting for the measure. The House of Lords has also shown its support by tabling the amendment to the Children and Families Bill in 2013 which allowed the first vote to take place.

The tobacco industry’s response

This decision signals the death knell to the tobacco industry’s campaign but it may yet mark the start of a new battle if tobacco companies take the issue to the courts.

In addition to their arguments about a rise in illicit trade and the questioning of health benefits, tobacco companies have also claimed that it is an infringement of their intellectual property. They have funded front groups, such as Forest and Hands Off Our Packs, using them as a vehicle to promote these arguments to the general public. And they have commissioned research of their own in a bid to undermine the evidence base for standardised packaging.

But research conducted by myself and colleagues at the University of Bath and the UK Centre for Tobacco and Alcohol Studies last year exposed the misleading nature of tobacco industry evidence on both the illicit trade and the health impacts of standardised packaging.

The government’s decision to progress standardised packaging to a vote in the House of Commons seems to show that while the legislative process may have been protracted by tobacco industry opposition, it has not ultimately been undermined by it.

The vote’s significance

If – or, as seems likely, when – MPs vote for standardised packaging, the UK will be one of the first countries to implement the measure in Europe – Ireland is also progressing legislation – and only the second or third globally, following in Australia’s footsteps. This ground-breaking innovation in tobacco control legislation illustrates the UK’s commitment to the health of its population and of its children: every year more than 200,000 11 to 15-year-olds start smoking in the UK (around 170,000 in England).

It is to be hoped that the devolved assemblies will also follow Westminster in introducing the measure and that the UK, like Australia, will stand firm against any legal action the tobacco companies may now undertake. This important measure will be worth defending: it will contribute to a reduction in the impact of smoking on our – and our children’s – health.

Cancer Research UK welcomes action on tobacco packaging

http://www.theexeterdaily.co.uk/news/health-beauty/cancer-research-uk-welcomes-action-tobacco-packaging

Plain, standardised tobacco packaging is a step closer to being introduced to the UK after the Government announced they will proceed with a vote on the issue.

Cancer Research UK has welcomed the move which now allows a vote in the Commons.

The move would make brightly coloured and slickly designed packs illegal, with all packs becoming uniform in size, shape and design with large picture health warnings.

Initial consultation into standard packs began nearly three years ago in April 2012. Since then, there has been the independent Chantler Review which came out in favour of standardised tobacco packaging to reduce the appeal to children and young people. There has also been a second consultation as well as a vote in parliament overwhelmingly in favour of standard packs.

New figures released by Cancer Research UK this evening show that people back these plans.

Nearly three quarters (72 per cent) of voters across the political spectrum said they support removing the colourful designs and branding from tobacco packaging, replacing them with packs of uniform size and shape with prominent health warnings. Only 15 per cent were opposed to the measure.

The new survey of more than 1,800 adults from across Britain reveals high levels of support from potential Conservative, Labour, Liberal Democrats and UKIP voters.

Seventy-five per cent of potential Conservative, 75 per cent of Labour, 80 per cent of Liberal Democrat and 64 per cent of UKIP voters all said they backed making tobacco packs less attractive.

Government action to reduce smoking rates was also popular, with around four fifths (79 per cent) of the public supporting action to try and lower the number of young people under 18 who start smoking.

Again, this was high across the board with 86 per cent of Conservative supporters, 78 per cent of Labour, 90 per cent of Liberal Democrat and 76 per cent of UKIP supporters showing support.

Evidence from Australia – where standard packs were introduced over two years ago – continues to grow, showing that standard packaging of tobacco is hitting sales of this deadly product. Between 2010 and 2013 – the period where standard packs were introduced – Australia saw a 15 per cent relative reduction in the number of daily smokers aged 14 or older. Data also confirmed that a higher proportion of young people have never smoked.

Harpal Kumar, Cancer Research UK’s chief executive, said: “We applaud the Government for taking this big step towards getting plain, standardised cigarette packs on the shelves and protecting children from tobacco marketing.

“This is welcome news, and with such wide public and cross-party political support it’s vital this announcement leads to a vote on standardised packaging, as soon as possible, and certainly before the General Election.

“Two-thirds of smokers start before the age 18, beginning an addiction which will kill half of them if they become long-term smokers. By stripping cigarette packs of their marketing features, we can reduce the number of young people lured into an addiction, the products of which are death and disease.”