Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Cluster bomb of new research explodes tobacco industry lies about plain packs

http://theconversation.com/cluster-bomb-of-new-research-explodes-tobacco-industry-lies-about-plain-packs-38978

There is near-universal agreement that Australia’s implementation of tobacco plain packaging in December 2012 has seen the most virulent opposition ever experienced from the global tobacco industry.

While the industry bravely insisted early in its campaigning that plain packs “would not work” their legal actions, campaign expenditure, lobbying and general apoplexy rather suggests they feared it would be a devastating policy, with long term global ramifications.

Indeed, eleven other nations (Ireland, England, New Zealand, France, Norway, Finland, Chile, Brazil, India, South Africa, Turkey) have either legislated plain packaging or are now warming up to do so.

University of Sydney researcher Becky Freeman and I catalogued the full range of industry lies in our recently released (free) book Removing the Emperor’s Clothes. The Cancer Council Victoria has also published extremely detailed rebuttals to the major industry scuttlebutt.

Now today, the British Medical Journal’s specialist journal Tobacco Control has published a special collection of new research which puts further 10,000 watt arc lights on specious industry claims.

Key industry claims have included that plain packs would:

  • Drive prices down, as smokers turn away from buying expensive premium brands because they look exactly the same as cheap brands (other than brand names). More affordable cigarettes, they argued, would cause more smoking, including among children
  • Flood Australia with illegal tobacco
  • Cause smokers would stop buying cigarettes at small convenience stores
  • Prompt smokers to use special covers to conceal the large-scale graphic warnings on packs.

Price falls?

One of the new Tobacco Control papers monitors changes in recommended retail prices RRPs from one year before plain packs were introduced until one year after. Prices were adjusted to 2013 prices, and for inflation and average cigarette price stick and grams of roll-your-own tobacco.

The RRPs of tobacco products were higher in real terms one year after the legislation was implemented. Importantly, these increases exceeded increases resulting from consumer price indexation of duty and occurred across all three major manufacturers for both factory made and roll-your-own brands, all three cigarette market segments and all major pack sizes.

Tobacco prices rose most for leading and premium brands 10.0% and 10.1%, respectively) and among packs of 30s (18.3%) and 50s (12.5%). So far from seeing cigarette prices fall across the board, the industry raised prices.
Floods of illicit tobacco?

The tobacco industry’s most common claim was that plain packs would see smokers turn away from buying the purposefully confronting and unattractive plain packs and seek out illegal products not in plain packs.

Tobacco spokespeople made the outrageous claim that about one in seven of all cigarettes being smoked were such illegally obtained cigarettes. Apparently, while ordinary smokers across the country knew where to buy these easily, the full might and resources of the Australian Federal Police could not work out where these were being sold.

Another study in the collection questioned 8,679 smokers across the country in telephone surveys conducted continuously, from six months before plain packs until 15 months afterwards.

The study found no significant increases in reported purchasing of “cheap whites” (illegally imported Asian sourced brands), of international brands selling for 20% or more less than the normal retail price, or of unbranded loose tobacco (so-called “chop chop”).

Rates of purchase of cheap whites and heavily discounted products were at around half of one per cent of smokers, nothing remotely like one in seven.

Small shops losing customers?

One of the most bizarre claims the industry made was that plain packs would see smokers deserting corner stores for larger retail outlets like supermarkets. This was an appeal designed to tap into wider public sentiment about local corner store owners being crushed under the dead weight of government regulation.

Those making the claim never explained why smokers would abandon small retailers for large ones because of plain packs when the very same packs would be sold in both. Consumer preference for larger retailers is entirely driven by price discounting, something never mentioned in the industry propaganda.

A third paper in the collection examined where smokers purchased their cigarettes. Unsurprisingly, it found no changes from prior to and after the introduction plain packs in where smokers bought their supplies.

Covering up the packs?

In the month that plain packs were introduced, a Queensland small businessman got his 15 minutes of fame from publicity about special pack covers that could block out the unforgettable graphic warnings. Like children covering their eyes from scary scenes in movies, the idea was that many smokers would rush to do the same, outsmarting the hapless bureaucrats who planned the legislation.

A fourth paper which reports on unobtrusive observations of smokers handling their packs in outdoor cafés found that prior to plain packs, just 1.2% of outdoor café smokers used pack covers. This rose to 3.5% in the early months of plain packs and then fell back to 1.9% one year later.

In any event, evidence shows that smokers who actively try to avoid exposure to pack warnings by covering them up, have higher subsequent rates of quit attempts than those who don’t.

Importantly too, these observations recorded that of all café outdoor patrons, one in 8.7 displayed a pack prior to the introduction of plain packs with this reducing to one in 10.3 afterwards. Such a fall is consistent with both a reduction in smoking prevalence and with growing self-consciousness among smokers about showing that they smoke in public.

Impact on adolescents?

There were several principal objectives of the plain packs legislation. But outstanding among these was the goal of making smoking less desirable among young people. This would continue the trend away from smoking, as each successive cohort of children chose not to take up the habit.

A fifth paper used school-based surveys prior to and after plain packs to examine students’ ratings of the “character” of four popular cigarette brands, and variables including perceived harmfulness, look of pack and positive and negative perceptions of pack image.

Positive character ratings for each brand reduced significantly between 2011 and 2013. Significantly fewer students in 2013 than 2011 agreed that “some brands have better looking packs than others” and packs were rated more negatively, with positive ratings decreasing most in smokers.

The tobacco industry and its acolytes can be expected to try to torture these reports to spin yet more denials of the impact it fears will quickly inspire even more countries to follow Australia’s lead.

Australia is fortunate in having some of the very best researchers in the world whose work has contributed to the development of plain packs and now to the evaluation of its impact.

Download (PDF, 288KB)

Interview with Prof Mike Daube & Prof Melanie Wakefield on Plain Packaging

BMJ publishes ‘clusterbomb’ of evidence on benefits of tobacco plain packaging, but fight with companies ‘far from over’

http://blogs.crikey.com.au/croakey/2015/03/19/bmj-publishes-clusterbomb-of-evidence-on-benefits-of-tobacco-plain-packaging-but-fight-with-companies-far-from-over/

The British Medical Journal today published the findings of a series of studies in a special Tobacco Control supplement showing that Australia’s plain packaging laws are delivering on their promise.

Cancer Council Victoria’s Professor Melanie Wakefield, whose team led the evaluation, said research shows plain packaging reduced positive perceptions of cigarette packs among teenagers and reveals that smokers were noticing and paying more attention to the graphic health warnings.

“These papers provide the first comprehensive set of results of real world plain packaging and they are pointing very strongly to success in achieving the legislation’s aims.

“These results should give confidence to countries considering plain packaging that plain packs not only reduce appeal of tobacco products and increase the effectiveness of health warnings but also diminish the tobacco industry’s ability to use packs to mislead consumers about the harms of smoking.”

All papers are available open access. See also Cancer Council Victoria’s media release.

In the post below, Jonathan Liberman, Director of the McCabe Centre for Law and Cancer, outlines the research findings but says the fight against tobacco companies is far from over – for Australia still but also for other countries, particularly those who are less resourced but vulnerable to the social and health costs of tobacco in coming decades.

That’s a big driver behind the announcement, earlier today, that Bill Gates and Michael Bloomberg have created a $US4 milion anti-tobacco trade litigation fund, so countries with limited resources should not be bullied into making bad health policy choices.

“This new fund is going to help countries who are sued by the tobacco industry fight back in court and win,” Bloomberg said.

A series of papers published this week in a special supplement of the British Medical Journal’s Tobacco Control provide evidence that Australia’s tobacco plain packaging laws are achieving their public health objectives.

The first comprehensive evaluation of the legislation has found that, a year into its operation, the scheme has reduced the appeal of tobacco packs, particularly among adolescents and young adults, increased the effectiveness of health warnings, and encouraged thinking about quitting and quit attempts. The evaluation has also shown the tobacco industry’s insistence that tobacco plain packaging would lead to a collapse in prices and an explosion in illicit tobacco use is baseless.

Other countries are now following Australia’s lead. Over the last fortnight, Ireland and the UK have enacted laws for tobacco plain packaging. France, New Zealand, Norway and Turkey have all taken steps towards doing so. Other countries will follow. These are important developments in the global drive to reduce the terrible toll that tobacco takes.

The World Health Organization estimates that 6 million people die annually as a result of tobacco use. Tobacco use accounts for approximately 7 per cent of all female deaths and 12 per cent of all male deaths globally. The WHO estimates that unless strong action is taken, the annual toll will rise to 8 million deaths per year by 2030, or 10 per cent of all deaths projected to occur that year. More than 80 per cent of these deaths will be in low- and middle-income countries. Tobacco-caused death and disease are major contributors to poverty, and a giant handbrake on social and economic development.

It would be nice if the tobacco industry had by now processed its grief over the introduction of plain packaging – which it had managed to stave off for over 20 years, until Australia acted – and moved on. But alas when the tobacco industry is involved, that’s seldom the case. Nearly five years since the laws were announced, over three years since the legislation was enacted, two-and-a-half years since a resounding High Court decision dismissing the tobacco industry’s constitutional challenge, and two years since plain packaging’s full implementation, international legal challenges are ongoing.The Australian Government continues to defend legal proceedings in the World Trade Organization (WTO), and under a 1993 bilateral investment treaty between Australia and Hong Kong. Every country that so much as intimates that it is considering tobacco plain packaging is subjected to a barrage of legal threats should it dare to proceed.

Litigating, and threatening litigation, have become just another part of the tobacco industry’s business operations. The strategy has a number of aims: make what would otherwise be very cheap policy interventions to reduce death and disease expensive; drain governments’ resources; delay the implementation of laws that will reduce the industry’s profits; and bully and intimidate governments out of enacting these laws at all. It’s a grim business, at its worst when this behaviour is inflicted on the least-resourced governments, which are both in greatest need of strong tobacco control laws to protect the health of their people, and least able to respond to the tobacco industry’s modus operandi.

It’s worth trying to imagine for a moment how a government official in a low-resource country might feel upon receiving a letter, a phone call or a visit from the tobacco industry or its high-powered lawyers threatening litigation, being bombarded with an alphabet soup of treaties and cases that he or she has never heard of, ill-equipped to recognise how disingenuous the claims may be. Thankfully, these officials can now receive support, through the networks of knowledge and expertise that have developed over the last few years around litigation experiences like Australia’s, but the disparity in resources remains vast.

The overwhelming view among those with relevant legal expertise (and not on the tobacco industry’s payroll) is that the Australian Government is on solid legal ground. The laws are an exercise of Australia’s sovereign power to regulate to protect public health, do not discriminate between domestic and imported products, are based on evidence, and have behind them the legal and political force of the global public health treaty, the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC), as well as implementation guidelines and other decisions adopted by consensus of the States Parties to the treaty, and other international instruments including the Doha Declaration on TRIPS and Public Health.

In the case of the investment treaty challenge, the case could be thrown out before getting to the merits of the arguments on the basis that the suing company, the Hong Kong-based Philip Morris Asia, only bought into the Australian business after the Australian Government announced that it would introduce plain packaging laws, and should not be allowed to use the Australia-Hong Kong treaty to pursue a legal challenge to these very laws.

International trade and investment laws are not supposed to promote trade and investment for their own sake and at any cost. And they are not supposed to be cynically used to prevent governments from protecting the health of their citizens.

The international legal challenges to Australia’s tobacco plain packaging still have a way to run. The panel considering the WTO cases has said that it won’t hand down its report until the first half of 2016 at the earliest. A decision on whether the investment challenge should be allowed to proceed to a hearing on the merits of the case is some months away.

The resolution of the cases will likely have profound implications for global health and sustainable development in the twenty-first century, and for the WTO and the international investment law system. There is a lot at stake.

Enormous credit is due to successive Australian Governments – Labor and Coalition – for adopting the laws and vigorously defending them, and to other countries for following Australia’s lead. Let’s hope that WHO’s projection that the death toll from tobacco this century could reach one billion people is nowhere near realised.

Jonathan Liberman is Director of the McCabe Centre for Law and Cancer, a joint initiative of Cancer Council Victoria and the Union for International Cancer Control, and a Senior Fellow of the Melbourne Law School. Jonathan is a lawyer with over fifteen years’ experience in legal and policy research, advice, training and technical support relating to cancer control at both domestic and global levels.

The McCabe Centre’s mission is to contribute to the effective use of the law for cancer prevention, treatment, supportive care and research. It is a WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control knowledge hub. With support from the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and Cancer Council Australia, the McCabe Centre runs an intensive legal training program for government lawyers from low- and middle-income countries on the use of law to prevent and control cancer and other non-communicable diseases

Australia’s Plain Packaging is Working: First Comprehensive Evaluation of World-First Tobacco Laws Released

http://medianet.multimediarelease.com.au/bundles/00c88263-2031-4fd8-bc0d-d7ee8dd8ed0b

The introduction of plain packaging of tobacco products in Australia is delivering on its promise to restrict the ability of the pack to create appeal, according to the first comprehensive evaluation of the legislation.

Published in a special supplement to the British Medical Journal, fourteen peer-reviewed papers examine various aspects of the implementation and the impact it has on the community, including young people and adult smokers.

Key findings of the evaluation include:

• Plain packaging has delivered on its aim to reduce appeal of packs, particularly with adolescents and young adults

• There was no evidence of an increase in the consumption of illicit “cheap white” cigarettes

• The impact of plain packaging extends beyond expectation with studies suggesting the initiative encourages thinking about quitting and quit attempts

Cancer Council Victoria’s Professor Melanie Wakefield, whose team led the evaluation, said research shows plain packaging reduced positive perceptions of cigarette packs among teenagers and reveals that smokers were noticing and paying more attention to the graphic health warnings.

“These papers provide the first comprehensive set of results of real world plain packaging and they are pointing very strongly to success in achieving the legislation’s aims.

“These results should give confidence to countries considering plain packaging that plain packs not only reduce appeal of tobacco products and increase the effectiveness of health warnings but also diminish the tobacco industry’s ability to use packs to mislead consumers about the harms of smoking.”

Study co-leader Dr Michelle Scollo examined claims made by the tobacco industry concerning prices and illicit tobacco, noting:

“The tobacco industry has been very vocal in its concerns that plain packaging would result in a collapse in prices and increased use of illicit tobacco – these studies found no evidence of either of these effects, and despite an increase in use of value brands, a clear indication of increased prices across the board.”

Cancer Council Victoria CEO Mr Todd Harper said the research debunked the scare tactics of the tobacco industry which has been tirelessly lobbying politicians and decision makers with exaggerated tales of black markets, criminal gangs and a proliferation of cheap cigarettes.

“The pack is one of the last pillars of tobacco industry marketing, and in jurisdictions without plain packaging the pack will continue to be used as an unscrupulous tool to keep and attract customers.”

Mr Harper said this was especially dangerous in a time when marketing innovations of packaging could evolve to include music, touch and smell to increase appeal.

Professor Melanie Wakefield, Dr Michelle Scollo and Todd Harper are available for interview, as is another study author, Kylie Lindorff.

For further information, or interviews, please contact:

Edwina Pearse on 0417 303 811 or edwina.pearse@cancervic.org.au, or Thea Cargill on 0429 000 450 or thea.cargill@cancervic.org.au

Cancer Council Victoria is a non-profit organisation that has been leading the fight against all cancers for 79 years in the areas of research, patient support, cancer prevention and advocacy. Visit www.cancervic.org.au for details.

Protecting the brand: British American Tobacco instructs Herbert Smith Freehills for plain packaging challenge

http://www.legalbusiness.co.uk/index.php/lb-blog-view/3852-significant-mandates-british-american-tobacco-instructs-herbert-smith-freehills-on-plain-packaging-battle

British American Tobacco (BAT) has gifted Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF) with a major disputes mandate, and instructed the firm as the tobacco giant challenges the UK government’s plans to bring in plain cigarette packaging.

The London-headquartered BAT has further instructed Hogan Lovells to advise on intellectual property issues, while barristers brought in includes 39 Essex Chambers’ Nigel Pleming QC and One Essex Court’s Geoffrey Hobbs QC.

BAT constitutes a longstanding client of HSF, with City partner Philip Pfeffer advising on numerous judicial challenges to tobacco control regulatory measures including plain packaging, graphic health warnings, and ingredient bans. New York partner Benjamin Rubinstein also successfully represented the tobacco major in a decade-long civil racketeering lawsuit, filed by the US justice department against multiple US tobacco companies, seeking $280bn in disgorgement of past profits.

BAT is one of several tobacco giants vowing to fight the UK government in court, after Parliament approved the Standardised Packaging of Tobacco Products Regulations 2015 which includes a ban on cigarette packet branding. Set to come into force in May next year, tobacco manufacturers will be forced to sell cigarettes in plain packets with uniform size, shape and design featuring only brand name and health warnings.

Prior to a debate in the House of Lords, BAT confirmed it would ‘commence a legal challenge against the UK Government, if the House of Lords supports MPs who voted to implement plain packaging for tobacco products’.

BAT’s corporate and regulatory affairs director Jerome Abelman said: ‘This legislation is a case of the UK Government taking property from a UK business without paying for it. That is illegal under both UK and European law.’

‘Legal action is not something we want to undertake, nor is it something we enter into lightly – but the UK Government has left us with no other choice after running what can only be described as a flawed consultation process. Any business that has property taken away from it by the state would inevitably want to challenge and seek compensation.’

BAT intends to argue that plain packaging violates a number of UK, European Union (EU) and international laws, including EU trademark laws, as well as World Trade Organisation rules regarding international trade.

In December 2012 Australia became the first country to introduce plain packaging while last month Ireland’s president signed into law the Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill.

Other firms acting on behalf of Big Tobacco include Arthur Cox which is currently representing Japan Tobacco in its dispute over plain packaging legislation against the Irish government.

sarah.downey@legalease.co.uk

Plain Packaging for Tobacco Users

Download (PDF, 529KB)

WHO chief wants tobacco firms pushed ‘out of business’

http://medicalxpress.com/news/2015-03-chief-tobacco-firms-business.html

World Health Organization chief Margaret Chan urged global action Wednesday to drive tobacco companies “out of business” and hailed progress in tackling smoking in many countries.

Speaking at the World Conference on Tobacco or Health in Abu Dhabi, she welcomed steps taken by several countries, led by Australia, to introduce plain packaging for cigarettes.

The WHO chief called for similar action by other nations.

Tobacco companies “use all sorts of tactics including funding political parties, individual politicians to work for them… There is nothing they would not exploit to undermine the governments’ resolve and determination to protect their own people,” Chan told reporters.

“It’s going to be a tough fight… (but) we should not give up until we make sure that the tobacco industry goes out of business,” she said.

Edouard Tursan d’Espaignet, the WHO coordinator of comprehensive information systems for tobacco control, said the industry “has lobbies, has very strong powerful friends, and these people can interfere in the right working of the government.

“That’s why we’re here to defy and eradicate it,” he told AFP.

Despite a decline in the number of smokers in many countries, more needs to be done to curb tobacco use to meet the global target of a 30 percent reduction in consumption by 2025, participants said.

“Largely thanks to legislative measures, smoking has plummeted in several countries,” Chan told the meeting, referring to the latest WHO report showing that the proportion of men who smoke is going down in 125 countries.

Chan said non-smoking was “becoming the norm”.

“We are happy to see this progress in so many countries,” she told AFP on the sidelines of the conference.

However, she urged countries that produce tobacco leaves to “move faster” to fight the tobacco industry in cooperation with the Food and Agriculture Organization and the WHO.

‘Plain packaging works’

The five-day conference aims to prove that tobacco use, in all its forms, is a major contributor to the occurrence of non-communicable disease (NCD)—cancer, cardiovascular diseases, diabetes and chronic respiratory diseases.

Organisers warn that tobacco causes one in six of all NCD deaths and that almost half of current tobacco users will eventually die of tobacco-related disease.

“Tobacco use is one of the biggest risk factors for NCDs, and especially for cancer,” Chan said. “It is also one of the most responsive to control measures.”

According to the WHO, one person dies every six seconds due to tobacco—nearly six million people each year.

Smoking could kill one billion people this century, it says.

Participants at the conference have warned that unless urgent action is taken, the annual death toll could rise to eight million by 2030.

“Tobacco use is rising fastest in countries where control measures are relatively new,” Chan warned.

China is “number one… in terms of smokers, so it is important that China takes appropriate action to reduce tobacco consumption.”

WHO says NCDs kill 35 million people annually, of whom 80 percent live in low- and middle-income countries.

Chan voiced support for measures taken by Australia, Ireland, and most recently Britain, to introduce plain cigarette packaging, despite “being intimidated by tobacco industry threats of lengthy and costly litigation”.

But “the train has already left the station. The evidence base is strong, empirical and comes from well-qualified, respected, and credible sources… We know that plain packaging works.”

Smoking rates have fallen in Australia since it introduced plain packaging in 2012, although tobacco companies have attributed the decline to tax hikes.

Turkey ‘leader’ in tobacco fight

Similar legislation passed in Ireland last month has been fully implemented, while Britain is set to bring in such measures in May next year.

Tobacco companies argue that plain packaging infringes their intellectual property rights.

“More than 10 countries are considering plain packaging,” said Chan, noting that Burkina Faso and New Zealand were next in line, followed by Chile, Panama, France, Norway and Turkey.

Participants have hailed Turkey’s anti-tobacco push.

“Turkey has been able to reduce its tobacco use by about 13 percent over three years… That is a tremendous amount of reduction,” said d’Espaignet.

“Turkey is one of our few countries that we are really really proud of in terms of tobacco control in the world. It’s a leader,” he told AFP.

Game changer for Canadian Tobacco Control: Quebec Class Action Lawsuits

Interview with Dr. Tara Singh Bam, Regional Advisor for The Union

Unscrupulous methods used by tobacco industry revealed over illicit trade

Download (PDF, 309KB)