Plain Packaging
NZ smoking rates decrease – but not as fast as Australia
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/lifestyle/news/article.cfm?c_id=6&objectid=11520097
Smokers are a dwindling group in New Zealand with tobacco consumption down 23 per cent in the past five years.
But anti-smoking advocates say rates here are still not falling as fast as in Australia, where the introduction of plain packaging has been credited with a 20 per cent drop in consumption in just three years.
The figures, supplied to the Ministry of Health by New Zealand tobacco manufacturers, show average cigarette consumption has declined 6.3 per cent each year since 2010 equating to a 23 per cent decline in consumption overall.
In Australia figures show consumption has plunged 13 per cent in the last year and 19.6 per cent in the three years since plain packaging laws and tobacco tax increases were introduced.
“Standardised packs and annual tax increases have provided a powerful double-whammy that’s saving many lives across the ditch,” said Smokefree Coalition Chair Dr Jan Pearson.
“New Zealand’s falling smoking rates must have big tobacco worried, but if we stopped playing ‘wait and see’ and introduced standardised packs we’d worry them even more and prevent a lot of sickness and suffering.”
The coalition and another group, Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), are calling on Government to make plain packaging legislation an immediate priority.
“Standardised packs are inevitable. Britain and Ireland will introduce them from May next year and the entire European Union is expected to do the same. Many other countries are considering the move and in years to come we’ll wonder what the fuss was about – just as we did with smokefree bars and workplaces,” Dr Pearson said.
“The evidence is clear that plain packaging stops tobacco companies’ ability to advertise through their clever and attractive branding. That means fewer people will die of smoking-related diseases, and fewer children will grow up to become the next generation of addicted smokers. Other states aren’t scared of big tobacco and we shouldn’t be either.”
ASH director Stephanie Erick said standardised packs and annual tax increases were just two of 13 measures Smokefree Coalition members advocate for through an evidence-based National Action Plan to achieve the Smokefree 2025 Goal.
She said smoking rates had reduced sharply in a generation – from 33 per cent of adults in 1983 to less than 15 per cent right now – but more could be done to become smokefree.
The Smokefree National Action Plan was developed by the smokefree sector pending the Government’s development of a strategy towards Smokefree 2025.
The pending development of a governmental tobacco control plan was announced by Associate Minister of Health Peter Dunne recently, during his launch of the Alcohol and Drug Policy in August.
Plain packaging legislation could decrease number of smokers in NZ even further
http://www.maoritelevision.com/news/national/plain-packaging-legislation-could-decrease-number-smokers-nz-even-further
According to the Ministry of Health, there are less smoking adults in New Zealand. In 1983, 33% of adults were smokers, compared to 15% right now. But smokefree organisations say the Government need to make plain packaging of cigarettes an immediate priority.
Australia have taken the lead and have seen results since implementing plain cigarette packaging.
Figures show that in the last year, the consumption of cigarettes in Australia has decreased by 13%. In the last three years since the plain packaging and tobacco tax increases came in to effect, consumption of cigarettes has plunged 19.6%.
Smokefree Coalition Chair and National Smokefree Working Group member Dr Jan Pearson says, “Standardised packs and annual tax increases have provided a powerful double-whammy that’s saving many lives across the ditch,”
The evidence is clear that plain packaging stops tobacco companies’ ability to advertise through their clever and attractive branding. That means fewer people will die of smoking-related diseases, and fewer children will grow up to become the next generation of addicted smokers. Other states aren’t scared of big tobacco and we shouldn’t be either.”
A pilot study of research methods for determining the impact of pictorial cigarette warning labels among smokers
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25276116
Abstract
BACKGROUND:
Science to determine the impact of pictorial cigarette warning labels can inform decisions about warning label implementation and adjustments to their contents to maximize impact. This pilot study builds from earlier research on plain cigarette packaging to examine the feasibility of a method for determining the impact of pictorial warnings among smokers.
FINDINGS:
The study was a prospective, within-subjects pilot trial where smokers ages 18-30 (n = 10) were exposed to pictorial warnings on their cigarette packs. On day one, participants completed a baseline interview with an expired carbon monoxide reading and affixed pictorial warning labels to their cigarette pack(s) they would use the next day. On day two, participants completed mobile phone text message assessments of smoking behaviors and protocol adherence. On day three, participants completed a follow-up interview similar to baseline. We achieved 100% sample retention and adherence with procedures. Compared with baseline assessments of perceptions and behaviors related to existing text-only warnings, at follow-up participants were more likely to report that pictorial warnings used during the study were noticeable (M 4.1, SD 1.3 vs. M 2.7, SD 1.2, p = .013), stopped them from smoking (M 1.6, SD 0.8 vs. M 1.1, SD 0.3, p = .052), and conveyed health risks of smoking (M 3.5 SD 1.3 vs. M 2.2, SD 1.1, p = .006). At follow-up, participants also reported the protocol was acceptable.
CONCLUSIONS:
These findings suggest this is a feasible method that with further validation could provide evidence that can inform decisions regarding implementation of pictorial cigarette warnings.
Tobacco evidence – The Scotsman
To: ‘istewart@scotsman.com‘
Subject: Tobacco evidence – The Scotsman
Dear Sir,
I refer to the letter from Neil McKeganey (11 Sep 2015) in response to Sheila Duffy of ASH Scotland.
On the writer’s own website (http://www.drugmisuseresearch.org/funders) he lists Big Tobacco among his funding sources: Philip Morris / BAT/ Nicoventures & also Reckitt Benckiser BAT’s CEO Nicandro Duranante was appointed as a Non-Exec Director of Reckitt Benckiser Group plc in December 2013.
GTNF – Global Tobacco & Nicotine Forum aka the ‘Davos of Tobacco’ since 2008, is a yearly gathering of tobacco industry executives, invited front groups & paid friends of the industry where tricks of the trade are exchanged.
http://www.gtnf-2014.com/agenda/
“what really distinguishes the GTNF is its “two-way traffic” approach. The essence of the forum and workshop sessions is interaction, conversation, debate, consensus—a sharing of knowledge, expertise and wisdom”
The writer is a repeat yearly speaker/panelist at GTNF conferences dating back numerous years & is scheduled to attend GTNF in Bologna this month
http://gtnf-2015.com/look-whos-talking/
Big Tobacco does not invite dissenting voices to speak at its own industry conferences.
Indeed the writer sees nothing wrong with convicted Rico racketeers funding selective research
http://www.who.int/tobacco/media/en/TobaccoExplained.pdf
“it is a predatory industry whose market dynamics demand that it recruits young people. It does this by deploying vast promotional expenditures to create, communicate & amplify a set of positive values associated with the product. Once the glamour phase subsides, nicotine addiction takes over making the customer dependent on the product & securing a profitable cash flow. Trapped by nicotine addiction, the smoker is subject to a variety of sub-lethal illnesses which culminate in a one in two probability of death through smoking-related disease. The smoker’s death means a replacement customer must be found – and the cycle begins again”
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2509609/
“After combing through nearly 50 million pages of previously secret, internal tobacco-industry documents, UC Davis and UC San Francisco researchers say they have documented for the first time how the industry funded & used scientific studies to undermine evidence linking secondhand smoke to cardiovascular disease.”
Moreover, another frequent speaker at the GTNF conferences each year is Dr Delon Human, a South African doctor based in Switzerland who was funded by BAT to write a book on nicotine.
Human’s EuroSwiss Health company along with LIAF (Italian anti tobacco foundation) http://www.liaf-onlus.org/ funded the recent Nutt report https://www.karger.com/Article/FullText/360220 relied upon by PHE for its ‘e-cigs 95% safer’ report.
The chief executive of LIAF is Dr Riccardo Polosa. A search of Legacy tobacco documents online https://industrydocuments.library.ucsf.edu/tobacco/ reveals 134 links for ‘Polosa’ & shows his University department received Euro 400,000 study funding from PMI 12 years ago. Another regular GTNF panelist is South African opthamologist Kgiso Letlape with connections to Delon Human thru the African Medical Assn. http://www.africama.net/about_afma.htm
Polosa & Letlape are amongst the authors of the Nutt report funded by Human /LIAF and the writer rubs shoulders with them at the GTNF conferences. Another Nutt report author, K Fagerstrom is shown as a recipient of industry funding.
http://www.tobaccoreporter.com/gtnf-2013/
http://www.gtnf-2014.com/ (the Davos of Tobacco)
As for the writer’s query on the effectiveness of killing the ‘Silent Salesman’ (the last available advertising outlet for Big T = the pack) combined with a multi pronged approach of increased taxation , health warnings replacing the glitz & control of point of display, Health Australia states:
http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/content/tobacco-kff
Q: Have any early impacts of tobacco plain packaging been identified?
A: Research undertaken during the roll-out phase of the tobacco plain packaging legislation, when both plain and branded packs were available found that plain packaged cigarettes with larger health warnings increased smokers’ urgency to quit and lowered the appeal of smoking
Australia’s plain packaging laws successful, studies show The first comprehensive evaluation of Australia’s ground-breaking plain packaging tobacco laws shows they are working, the Victorian Cancer Council says.
Fourteen separate studies on the impact of plain packaging in its first year were published today in a special supplement to the British Medical Journal.
The research found after the laws were implemented, there was a “statistically significant increase” in the number of people thinking about & making attempts to quit smoking
http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/24/Suppl_2.toc
Readers must query the possible bias and intentions of the correspondent with a pinch of salt, which is also bad for the health.
People in glass houses should not throw stones.
James Middleton
Chairman
——————————————————————-
http://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/letters/tobacco-evidence-1-3883447
00:29 Friday 11 September 2015
HAVE YOUR SAY
Sheila Duffy (Letters, 9 September), like many single-issue lobbyists, celebrates the data that confirms her view while casually disregarding other evidence that contradicts it.
In her letter, she refers to the dozens of studies that have focused on tobacco plain packaging without mentioning the “inconvenient finding” that not a single one of those studies has actually shown a reduction in smoking prevalence attributable to plain packaging.
In advance of this policy being implemented in Australia, leading tobacco control researchers were advising that plain packaging would result in a 1 per cent reduction in adult smoking and a 3 per cent reduction in children’s smoking within two years of the policy being implemented.
Those same researchers are now advising that plain packaging may be a “slow burn distal” influence on smoking with its impact best considered in the long term when it is used alongside a whole host of other tobacco control measures such as taxation.
Tobacco plain packaging was implemented as a way of reducing smoking prevalence and while it may well reduce the attractiveness of smoking, nobody ever died from the attractiveness of a cigarette packet.
The key to reducing smoking-related health harm, as Duffy well knows, is to reduce smoker numbers.
Those who advocated for plain packaging should be demanding the evidence on whether it has reduced smoker numbers rather than switching the assessment criteria to a range of soft, subjective measures, such as determining if plain packaging reduces the appeal of smoking.
Neil McKeganey PhD
Centre for Drug Misuse Research Glasgow
19:56 Tuesday 08 September 2015
HAVE YOUR SAY
In THE midst of a recent article about alcohol minimum unit pricing, Neil McKeganay, from the Centre for Drug Misuse Research, casually dismisses proposals for standardised tobacco packaging as lacking in evidence. Far from being rushed this policy has been years in the making, and the subject of dozens of studies – I wish all policy initiatives were so carefully considered and had such strong public support.
Plain, standardised packaging makes the look of tobacco more truthful and is designed to disrupt tobacco companies’ attempts to hook in new consumers through presenting their product as sophisticated, rugged or slimming. In 2011 the UK Department of Health commissioned a systematic review of 37 studies on the likely impact of standardised packaging, later updated with 17 further studies. This evidence consistently demonstrated that standard packs would reduce the appeal of tobacco products and increase people’s awareness of health warnings.
In Australia where tobacco has been sold in standardised packaging since December 2012, all the early signs are encouraging. Smokers say the cigarettes don’t taste as good, and that they are more likely to think about quitting. Smoking rates in Australia are plummeting. Figures from the Australian department of health show that tobacco consumption in the first quarter of 2014 was at the lowest ever recorded.
McKeganay’s own tobacco-industry funded group claims an interest in researching “harm reduction”. Standardised tobacco packaging is a well-evidenced harm reduction measure.
Sheila Duffy
ASH Scotland Frederick Street Edinburgh
Why Big Tobacco is after our children
http://www.theage.com.au/comment/no-smoke-without-fire-in-big-tobaccos-pr-storm-20150824-gj6v53.html
Mike Daube
There are signs the tobacco industry will fight to the bitter end to make sure nothing gets in the way of their goal of profiting from death and disease.
There are three possible explanations for British American Tobacco’s attempts to use Freedom of Information legislation to access Cancer Council research on children’s attitudes to smoking, as reported in The Age last week.
The first is that nobody in the company realised that this would be a PR disaster, confirming yet again Big Tobacco’s reputation as both the world’s most lethal industry and its most ruthless. As such it gives the lie to industry rhetoric about not being interested in children, justifies comment about tobacco companies sinking to new lows, has led politicians to consider amending FOI legislation, and generated a magisterial rebuke from Federal Assistant Health Minister Senator Fiona Nash. PR myopia is always possible in a global tobacco company that claims to be “applying exemplary corporate conduct in our markets” despite selling and promoting a product that kills when used precisely as intended.
The second is that tobacco companies are terrified that Australia’s world-leading plain packaging legislation will spread to other countries. Thus they will go to any lengths in their efforts to undermine it.
If ever a measure passed the tobacco “Scream Test” (the louder the industry scream, the more impact you know a measure will have) it is plain packaging. Plain packaging deprives tobacco companies of their last opportunity to promote cigarettes in ways that children may find attractive. Always intended as a long-term part of the comprehensive approach to reducing smoking, peer-reviewed research is already encouraging about its impacts on both children and adults. Perhaps crucially, it sends out a signal to the entire community that this product is so uniquely harmful that it may only be sold in packaging designed to be repellent.
Small wonder that this has sent Big Tobacco into a tailspin. It has led to litigation here and internationally and triggered advertising and public relations programs, lobbying, and commissioned reports from tobacco-funded groups, industry-friendly think-tanks and bloggers. Tobacco industry lawyers have also generated media speculation that pictures of cirrhotic livers on beer bottles could be the next target. So it is possible that trying to get hold of Cancer Council research on children is further evidence of the industry’s desperation.
But there is a third, darker possibility. The tobacco industry has known for 65 years that its product is lethal. Smoking kills some 6 million people each year, and has been identified by the McKinsey Global Institute as the top global social burden generated by human beings, ahead even of armed violence, war and terrorism. But despite the overwhelming evidence about the galaxy of diseases caused by cigarettes, and despite innumerable exposes about their tactics, tobacco companies have survived and continue to promote their products wherever they can, notably in developing countries.
And yet the tide is turning – too slowly to prevent hundreds of millions of deaths, but it is turning nonetheless. The WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control has been signed by 168 countries. Around the world, governments are increasingly taking action that will over time reduce smoking and with it the massive profits that come to the merchants of death. It will all take far too long, but it will happen, and Australia is often held up as an example of the art of the possible.
So it may be that this always ruthless industry has decided to step up yet further its campaigns to oppose and undermine tobacco control and its advocates.
After more than 40 years in tobacco control, here and internationally, my sense is that in recent years the global tobacco industry has become even tougher and more aggressive. The companies are unashamedly taking legal action against governments in developed and developing countries. They have already used FOI against the Federal Health Department. Public relations and lobbying efforts are being ramped up (to tackle one measure recently proposed for the European Union, one tobacco company employed 161 people), and, with stunning effrontery, the industry is trying to improve its image by presenting itself as health conscious. Tobacco companies have reportedly funded lawyers to help remote countries oppose plain packaging in international trade forums. Tobacco control advocates find themselves increasingly under attack from shadowy think-tanks and other internet activists.
Now we have British American Tobacco trying to use FOI legislation to get research on children from the Cancer Council, with the added bonus that this will be a huge distraction for the Council, which must also incur significant legal costs in fighting them off.
It may be a PR blunder and it may be desperation about plain packaging. But it may also be a signal from Big Tobacco that they are in this business for the long haul, the war is about to get even tougher, and nothing and nobody will be allowed to get in the way of profiting from death and disease.
Mike Daube is Professor of Health Policy at Curtin University and president of the Australian Council on Smoking and Health.
Cigarette plain packaging war heating up as new Australian study due for release
http://www.cityam.com/222420/cigarette-packaging-war-heating-new-study-due-release
by Edith Hancock
The tobacco industry has hit back at the government’s plan to enforce plain packaging for cigarettes, warning that the ruling will cause a rise in counterfeits being smuggled into the UK.
As legal battles rage between the UK government and British American Tobacco, this latest challenge comes after it was revealed yesterday that an official Australian study, to be published next month, will be used by the UK government as ammunition in its battle to remove tobacco branding.
The report by Australia’s department for health will show that smoking rates have reduced since the introduction of plain packaging. Some opponents argue that a combination of factors have led to a decline in smoking rates over many years.
The UK government ruled in favour of removing branding from cigarette packets last March.
Tobacco industry sources have warned of a rise in the UK’s counterfeit trade and questioned the validity of the study in the UK.
Industry sources said that removing branding will put the accessibility of “non-shop” and illegal tobacco in the spotlight.
“The UK now has the most expensive tobacco in Europe, but the number of quitters has flatlined.
“People are not stopping smoking, they are using increasingly illicit means.”
The UK department for health could not be reached for comment.
The Business Behind Plain Packaging Tobacco
http://themarketmogul.com/business-behind-plain-packaging-tobacco/
On the 20th of May 2016, the increasingly progressive anti-tobacco efforts of the UK and Ireland will once again come into effect. This time it will be the introduction of plain packaging, involving the standardisation of all tobacco products. Products will appear homogenous with the removal of all marketing features, allowing for only the brand name and imagery promoting public heath warnings.
Understanding the implications of plain packaging tobacco is multiplex, which derives from the number of perspectives that need to be taken into consideration. A common, but somewhat naive outlook would be to simply suggest plain packaging results in a demand contraction, causing less people to smoke, thus lower profits for firms. In reality it important to consider that plain packaging is likely to have an array of effects beyond and even contrary to the theoretical predictions. This articles takes a forward looking analysis of the tobacco market, to uncover the likely effects and success of the plain packaging policy.
Market Analysis
In economic terms, the tobacco market can be classified as an oligopolistic structure, arising from the small number of companies with high individual market concentration, such as the well known Imperial Tobacco and Phillip Morris. The prominence of this market should not be understated, in 2012 the six largest tobacco companies outperformed; McDonalds, Microsoft and Coca-Cola’s earnings combined. In fact, the second largest US company Reynolds (RAI) share price has increased over 170% in the last five years, with others following similar growth.
However, the imposition of plain packaging policy is likely create permanent structural changes in the market, which will effect both the conduct and performance of incumbent firms. Firstly it’s important to recognise that firms currently compete on non-price factors, dominant firms have a high degree of brand loyalty, built up from years of marketing. Cigarette consumers often identify and associate branding with personal characteristics and have been found to value this superior to other factors such as taste and quality (Padilla). For example, one may associate a premium brand with higher social status – including characteristic such as wealth or attractiveness. This branding therefore acts as a significant barrier to entry for new firms aiming to successfully enter the market. Plain packaging is likely to reduce this barrier as product differentiation and this intrinsic value is removed, whilst the substitution ability between brands increases.
Plain packaging policy will force price competition, this is likely to encourage predatory pricing type behaviour, which has the potential to increase demand (opposite effect). Alternatively there could be a decrease in consumption, from the mandates on marketing and lower quality needed to retain profit margins whilst reducing prices. It would seem the desired effects of plain packaging on tobacco consumption is somewhat of a paradox. This may also be influenced by the ability of new firms to compete with incumbents and to combat other barriers such as economies of scale and market concentration.
Australia leading the way?
Although the UK, among many other advanced economies have previously remained hesitant over implementing plain packaging, Australia led the way. Australia is currently the only country to implement the policy, which they enforced in December 2012 and have since showed apparent signs of success. Recent figures released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics suggest an estimated $103 billion expenditure reduction on tobacco products between December 2012 (introduction of policy) and March 2014. Meanwhile daily smokers aged ’14 or older’ have significantly decreased from 15.1% to 12.8% between 2010 and 2013, with similar results in the ’18 or older’ group. Although causal relationships between plain packaging and consumption are difficult to make from these figures, they importantly show effectiveness in Australia’s anti-tobacco measures and they’re are on track to achieving smoking rates below 10% by 2018.
The future
In the short term, plain packaging policy may result in positive market performance, but it is important to recognise the new policy is likely to highly effective in deterring new smokers, especially if branding is such an influential factor. This will lead to a gradual reduction in the market size, which is the most important factor when considering the long-term health of the UK population. It would seem plain packaging may very much become a natural measure in efforts taken to reduce smoking rates in advanced economies, with many countries in the EU and beyond now considering it.
Farmers rejoice over bringing down GHW to 50 percent
http://www.brecorder.com/agriculture-a-allied/183/1213450/
On Friday the federal government has agreed with the tobacco industry that the size of pictorial warning on cigarette packets should be increased to 50% from the current 40% and after two years a survey will be conducted to assess if increasing the size of the warning indeed made smokers quit smoking cigarettes, or they have started smoking smuggled cigarettes.
This decision is highly welcomed by the farmers association. “We are grateful to Finance Minister Ishaq Dar, Health Minister Saira Afzal Tarar and the Members of the Inter-Ministerial Committee for withdrawing the 85% GHW SRO which had raised concerns in the farmers community because of its negative impact on the local tobacco industry including 75000 tobacco farmers whose livelihoods were at stake,” said Rustam Khan Swati- President Anjuman Kashtkara and Tobacco Hazara Division.
He specially thanked Ishaq Dar for sharing the concerns of the poor tobacco farmers by timely intervening in the matter and forming an Inter-Ministerial Committee to assess the impact of the 85% GHW on cigarette packs. He further stated, “It is of great satisfaction that policymakers have considered and acknowledged legitimate request of the tobacco farmers to secure their future due to the excessive regulatory order which was bound to hit the local industry while paving way for illicit smuggled cigarettes with no health warnings”.
Swati also thanked Chairman PTB Faridullah Khan for providing support to tobacco farmers in difficult times. He expressed hope that in the future government will consult farmers before issuing any excessive regulatory order aimed at harming thousands of tobacco farmers in that process.-PR
Govt should own up to cost of tobacco litigation
http://www.theage.com.au/comment/govt-should-own-up-to-cost-of-tobacco-litigation-20150731-gion8s.html
Kyla Tienhaara and Deborah Gleeson
·
On Tuesday, Fairfax Media economics writer Peter Martin made the startling revelation that the government’s ongoing legal dispute with Philip Morris has already cost the country $50 million (“Tobacco box legal row costs hit $50m”, July 29, p5). Martin’s information was from an unnamed source. The government has refused to disclose what is being spent, even to the Productivity Commission.
Most legal experts agree that Australia should eventually win the case. But the reasoning provided by these experts is largely based on legal technicalities. No one is suggesting that health policy is immune from challenge in “investor state dispute settlement” (ISDS).
What is also concerning is that even if the government wins it may not be able to recoup the enormous cost of defending the plain packaging legislation. We know very little about the case, which is being heard by a private arbitration tribunal behind closed doors in Singapore. But what is certain is that the arbitrators are not bound by a “loser pays” rule. What that means is that Australian taxpayers may end up footing the bill regardless.
While it is outrageous that Australia should have to spend millions defending our right to regulate a product that is expected to kill two thirds of Australia’s 2.7 million smokers, there is no question that plain packaging is a policy worth defending.
Even at this early stage, the evidence is clear: plain packaging is achieving its objectives: reducing the appeal of tobacco packs, increasing the effectiveness of health-warnings and reducing the ability of packaging to mislead people about the harm that tobacco causes. Since the introduction of tobacco plain packaging and the suite of other tobacco control measures that came in at the same time, tobacco consumption has fallen at record rates. In this context, even $50 million is money well spent.
However, while it is laudable that the government continues to fight Philip Morris despite the cost, other countries put in the same position may not have this luxury. The government of Uruguay has admitted that it would have had to give up its defence of similar tobacco packaging rules in ISDS, had it not received financial support from an non-profit organisation in the United States.
And US news reporter/comedian John Oliver revealed earlier this year that Togo, Namibia, and the Solomon Islands have all received letters from Big Tobacco threatening litigation over proposed laws. These countries would not be able to fathom a $50 million legal bill.
Given the high costs and the importance of the public policy issues at stake, it is not hard to understand why the list of opponents to ISDS continues to grow. The Productivity Commission, the Chief Justice of the High Court, a Reserve Bank board member, and the director-general of the World Health Organisation have all criticised ISDS. The Greens are firmly opposed to ISDS and at its recent party conference, Labor committed to eliminating ISDS from all existing Australian treaties if it is returned to power.
In fact, the only people in Australia that seem ready to defend ISDS are the Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Investment.
Initially, the Abbott government suggested that it would consider ISDS on a case-by-case basis, but provided no objective criteria for how decisions on this issue would be made. Having signed agreements with Korea and China that include ISDS, the government is now faced with its biggest decision yet: whether to agree to ISDS in the Trans Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPP).
Negotiators are currently in Hawaii trying to bash out a deal to get the TPP signed before the narrow window that President Obama has to get it through Congress before the 2016 elections closes.
Statements from Andrew Robb suggest that Australia’s acceptance of ISDS is up for grabs.
The TPP is significant not just because it is big – 12 countries are involved in the negotiations – but also because the US is at the table. US corporations are the biggest users of ISDS.
One of the main reasons that Australia hasn’t yet been exposed to more ISDS cases is that the Howard government declined to accept its inclusion in the Australia-US Free Trade Agreement.
We now know how much just one case (that hasn’t even ended) can cost taxpayers. To avoid having to make such expenditures in the future to defend much-needed health and environmental policies, the government needs to reject an ISDS clause applying to Australia in the TPP.
Kyla Tienhaara is a research fellow at the Regulatory Institutions Network, Australian National University.
Deborah Gleeson is a lecturer in public health at La Trobe University. She is currently in Maui observing the TPP negotiations from the sidelines.