Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Plain cigarette packaging likely to snowball globally

http://www.chronicle.co.zw/plain-cigarette-packaging-likely-to-snowball-globally/

One of Australia’s leading anti-smoking campaigners says a “snowball” effect is likely to result in plain packaging for cigarettes being introduced in a number of new countries over the next decade, after tobacco company Philip Morris lost a court case challenging Australia’s strict packaging laws.

The Singapore-based Permanent Court of Arbitration declined on jurisdictional grounds to allow the company’s case to proceed against the Australian government’s plain packaging laws, which were passed in 2011 to curb smoking rates.

Under the Australian laws, the first of their kind, no branding is allowed on cigarette packages and retailers must store tobacco products behind blank screens or cabinets. In addition, cigarette packages in Australia also show large graphic warnings of the possible health effects of smoking.

Public Health Association of Australia spokesman Mike Daube, who chaired the government committee which recommended plain packaging, said the Singapore court’s decision was a major blow to “Big Tobacco”.

“People who work in tobacco talk about the scream test – the louder the tobacco industry screams the more you know you are on the right track,” he said.

“The tobacco industry’s campaign against plain packaging in Australia is more ferocious than anything I’ve seen in the 40 years I’ve been working in this area.

“They have fought it in the media, they have fought it in parliament, they have fought it in the courts – and they have lost all of the way through.”

Daube said that he expected to see the success of Australia’s policy – which researchers say has led to a reduction in smoking rates and the volume of tobacco sold – cause a “snowball effect”, encouraging other nations to implement similar laws.

Plain tobacco packaging is currently being introduced in the UK and Ireland, while a number of other countries are also considering legislative changes.

“Australia is showing that you can beat Big Tobacco,” Daube said.

“What we’re now seeing, and this often happens in public health, is that once one country successfully implements change, other countries follow. There is a leapfrog effect. “It’s going to be tough, because the industry is desperate for new markets, but I think we will see plain packaging in many more countries over the next decade.”

Tobacco companies say plain packaging laws breach international regulations for trademarks and, along with the case in Singapore, the Australian government is also still facing challenges within the World Trade Organisation.

Philip Morris’ International senior vice president and general counsel Marc Firestone said in a statement on Friday that it was “regrettable that the [Singapore court] outcome hinged entirely on a procedural issue”.

“There’s nothing in today’s outcome that addresses, let alone validates, plain packaging in Australia or anywhere else,” he said, adding that the company was considering further legal options.

But Australia’s Rural Health Minister Fiona Nash, who is in charge of the government’s smoking policies, said in a statement on Friday that “plain packaging…is consistent with Australia’s international legal obligations”.

“We welcome the unanimous decision by the tribunal agreeing with Australia’s position that it has no jurisdiction to hear Philip Morris’ claim,” she said.

“Smoking does untold harm to Australians, causing deaths from cancer, lung and heart disease, and hurting families.” – Al Jazeera

Push for plain-pack tobacco in NZ grows

http://home.nzcity.co.nz/news/article.aspx?id=218452&fm=newsmain%2Cnrhl

ASH and the New Zealand Nurses Organisation are urging the government to push ahead with its proposed plain-packaging tobacco laws.

The NZ government is being urged to get on with introducing plain-packaging laws for tobacco products after tobacco company Philip Morris failed in its bid to challenge such laws across the Tasman.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration, based in The Hague, on Friday rejected a case brought by the global tobacco giant, unanimously agreeing with Australia’s argument it had no jurisdiction to hear the claim.

Philip Morris believes plain-packaging laws breach foreign investment protections the Australian government guaranteed in its trade agreement with Hong Kong, which contains an investor state dispute settlement mechanism.

The New Zealand government has been waiting for the outcome of the Australian case before pushing forward with plans to introduce plain packaging.

Action on Smoking and Health NZ (ASH) director Stephanie Erick says the outcome of the protracted legal battle in Australia should give New Zealand greater confidence to introduce plain-packaging laws.

Meanwhile, the New Zealand Nurses Organisation says there’s no further reason to delay introducing such laws.

“I’m calling on the government to announce plain-packaging laws here immediately. Those lured to smoke by tobacco companies marketing are predominantly young, Maori and female,” NZNO spokeswoman Kerri Nuku said.

“Any further delays will be responsible for more grieving whanau missing out on years with their daughters, sisters and mums. The best Christmas present the government could give whanau is announcing plain packaging today.”

Plain-packaging laws require all branding to be removed from packaging, which reduces promotion of the product.

The government brought a plain-packaging bill to parliament in February last year, and it passed its first reading. The health select committee backed adopting the bill with just a couple of minor amendments, but it hasn’t proceeded any further.

Australia was the first country in the world to introduce plain packaging.

Reilly welcomes ruling on Australian tobacco packaging

http://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/reilly-welcomes-ruling-on-australian-tobacco-packaging-1.2471713

Minister says Ireland just as committed to standing up to big tobacco as Australia

Minister for Children James Reilly: “I admire Australia’s courage in standing up to the tobacco industry again and again in legal challenges. Today is a great day for the future health of Australian children.” Photograph: Gareth Chaney/Collins

Minister for Children James Reilly: “I admire Australia’s courage in standing up to the tobacco industry again and again in legal challenges. Today is a great day for the future health of Australian children.” Photograph: Gareth Chaney/Collins

Minister for Children James Reilly has welcomed the decision of an international court to throw out a challenge by the tobacco industry to Australia’s plain-packaging legislation for tobacco products. Dr Reilly said the Government, which plans to introduce plain packaging next May but is facing a similar legal challenge, was equally committed to standing up to the tobacco industry.

“I applaud the leadership shown by the Australian government in being the first country in the world to introduce plain packaging,” he said. “I admire their courage in standing up to the tobacco industry again and again in legal challenges. Today is a great day for the future health of Australian children.”

Dr Reilly’s officials are awaiting a key opinion from the advocate general of the European Court of Justice, due next Wednesday, on the competence of European Union member states to introduce plain packaging.

In the latest round of the international legal battle on the issue, a Singapore-based court refused a challenge by Philip Morris to Australia’s landmark 2011 plain-packaging law. The tobacco giant brought the case under a bilateral trade treaty with Hong Kong.

The permanent court of arbitration declined on jurisdictional grounds to allow the case to proceed, ending the challenge through this venue, which was based on claims that Australia was violating intellectual property laws.

The decision by the court not to hear the case is likely to be seen as a major victory for Australia, which is facing challenges in other forums such as the World Trade Organisation, and for other countries considering similar laws, including Ireland and Britain.

Australia was the first country to force manufacturers to strip all branding from cigarette packets, most of which are now sold over the counter from blank-fronted cabinets.

A boost to global drive for stricter anti-tobacco laws

http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/health/a-boost-to-global-drive-for-stricter-antitobacco-laws/article8006059.ece

In a significant boost to stricter tobacco control laws, the Australian government on Friday won an international legal battle against tobacco giant Phillip Morris, which had challenged “plain packaging” laws.

Globally, the public health community has been demanding implementation of “plain tobacco packaging” — which means standardised packaging of tobacco products without any exclusive branding (colours, imagery, corporate logos and trademarks). The laws will only allow the manufacturers to print the brand name in a mandated size and font. Australia, the first country to implement these laws, had passed the plain packaging legislation in November 2011.

The Australian tribunal in the arbitration, based in Singapore, unanimously agreed with Australia’s position and gave a verdict against Phillip Morris. The verdict was awaited by many countries wanting to implement stricter tobacco control legislation. “The judgment in favour of Australia is a vindication of policy taken in public interest. It is important that judiciary everywhere in the world recognises the irrefutable evidence on the incalculable harm done by tobacco to the health of millions across the world. Law must prioritise societal interest over narrow corporate interests, while adjudicating on matters of public policy,” said K. Srinath Reddy, the president of the Public Health Foundation of India (PHFI) and one of the leading voices of India’s anti-tobacco campaign.

According to the Global Adult Tobacco Survey (GATS) India report, smoking kills over one million people in India annually and is the fourth leading cause of non-communicable diseases (NCD) such as cancer and heart diseases, which account for 53 per cent of all deaths in India. According to the Health Ministry, economic burden of tobacco consumption is around Rs.1,04,500 crore per annum.

Biju Janata Dal MP Jay Panda had introduced a private member’s Bill on plain packaging, demanding that pictorial warnings occupy at least 60 per cent of the front panel of the pack. He welcomed the verdict given by the Australian tribunal.

“This is an issue that is close to my heart. I have been fervently advocating this reform as a measure to control tobacco consumption in our country; especially since India is the second largest consumer of tobacco. Given the scale of the issue facing us, today’s verdict would offer us greater confidence to follow Australia’s lead towards a stronger public health policy. In this light, I urge all stakeholders to stick to the important April 1, 2016 notification for increased pictorial health warnings.”

In July 2014, the Allahabad High Court allowed a writ petition asking for implementation of plain packaging and directed the government to implement the scheme at the earliest.

The laws are to be implemented in India by April 2016.

Nurses call for urgent tobacco plain packaging laws in NZ after Australia wins legal battle

http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/75293851/nurses-call-for-urgent-tobacco-plain-packaging-laws-in-nz-after-australia-wins-legal-battle

Nurses are calling on the Government to immediately introduce plain packaging for tobacco, following a landmark court decision in Australia.

Tobacco giant Philip Morris Asia had attempted to challenge the packaging laws introduced in 2011, saying they breached a trade agreement.

On Friday the tribunal in the arbitration agreed unanimously with Australia’s position that it had no jurisdiction to hear the company’s claim.

New Zealand Nurses Organisation spokeswoman Kerri Nuku said the New Zealand Government had been taking a “wait and see” approach, depending on the outcome.

“Today the court proved the tobacco giant had no leg to stand on, and there is no further reason to delay introducing plain packaging in New Zealand,” she said.

Nuku called on the Government to announce plain packaging laws immediately.

“Time lost is lives lost.”

Smokers hooked in by tobacco marketing were predominantly young, Maori and female, she said.

“Any further delays will be responsible for more grieving whanau missing out on years with their daughters, sisters and mums.”

Australia was the first country in the world to mandate plain cigarette packs with no brand logo or colours permitted.

Philip Morris has slammed the decision, saying it does not validate plain packaging in Australia or anywhere else.

It also said it would review the court’s decision, suggesting the battle may not be over yet.

The company brought the case against Australia using a legal mechanism called Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS).

ISDS clauses are included in many trade agreements, including the one signed between Australia and Hong Kong, where Philip Morris Asia is based.

The tobacco giant’s case is the first investor-state dispute to be brought against Australia.

New Zealand was the first foreign country to secure a free trade agreement with Hong Kong, through the Closer Economic Partnership (CEP).

Trade Minister Todd McClay, who is currently overseas, has been approached for comment.

Tobacco Industry nightmare, now a reality – ASH

http://www.voxy.co.nz/health/tobacco-industry-nightmare-now-reality-ash/5/240462

Australia has won an international legal battle to uphold its world-leading tobacco control measures, with Philip Morris failing in its long-running attempt to challenge plain packaging laws under a bilateral trade agreement with Hong Kong.

Action on Smoking and Health NZ (ASH) congratulate the Australian Government on their stand to back themselves and their decision on implementing Plain Pack Cigarettes, and now (as expected) have won their case against the tobacco industry.

The tribunal made a unanimous decision agreeing with Australia’s position that it has no jurisdiction to hear Philip Morris’s claim.

ASH Director Stephanie Erick says, “This is great news, this decision can give NZ greater confidence to pass Standardised (Plain) Packaging for immediate implementation.”

Research among young adult kiwi’s report that larger graphic health warnings are significantly more likely to help those who want to stop smoking. Furthermore, NZ research shows standardised packaging and dissuasive cigarette sticks can also deter people from ever starting or relapsing.

The recent 2015 NZ Health Survey results reported a very slow decrease in smoking rates and continued high smoking rates among Maori, Pacific and young adults.

“Smoking in Australia is falling in adults, in children and by tobacco volume sales,” said Australia’s Public Health Association chief executive, Michael Moore.

Australia has monitored plain packaging and published scientific research has shown that plain packaging works.

Emeritus Professor Robert Beaglehole says, “NZ’s Standardised Packaging legislation needs to be urgently finalised as part of the process of achieving the Government’s Smokefree 2025.”

Professor Mike Daube, who chaired the Australian government’s expert committee that recommended plain packaging, said the tobacco companies were “desperate to prevent plain packaging here and internationally because they know it works”.

Tobacco giant dealt setback after international tribunal dismisses legal challenge to Australian plain-packaging laws

http://www.scmp.com/news/world/article/1892599/tobacco-giant-dealt-setback-after-international-tribunal-dismisses-legal

Philip Morris launched the challenge in 2011 after plain-packaging legislation was passed, using a 1993 trade deal between Australia and Hong Kong that included foreign investment protections.

An Australian law requiring cigarettes to be sold in plain packaging has received a boost after an international tribunal said it would not hear a tobacco company’s legal challenge.

The government in Canberra on Friday welcomed the decision by the Permanent Court of Arbitration to refuse jurisdiction over a case brought by smoking giant Philip Morris.

“Plain packaging is a legitimate public health measure, which is consistent with Australia’s international legal obligations,” said Rural Health Minister Fiona Nash, who is responsible for tobacco policy.

“We welcome the unanimous decision by the tribunal agreeing with Australia’s position that it has no jurisdiction to hear Philip Morris’s claim,” she said in a statement.

“Smoking does untold harm to Australians, causing deaths from cancer; lung and heart disease, and hurting families.”

In 2012, Australia became the first country to mandate plain packaging for cigarettes, in a bid to reduce smoking rates, and has since been followed by other nations including France and Britain.

But big tobacco firms including Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International have launched legal challenges against such laws, arguing they impinge on their trademark intellectual property.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration, established to settle international disputes, declined to comment on its decision to refuse jurisdiction for the arbitration proceedings in Singapore.

Philip Morris accused Australia of using a procedural issue to avoid addressing the legality and effectiveness of plain packages, calling the move “regrettable”.

“There is nothing in today’s outcome that addresses, let alone validates, plain packaging in Australia or anywhere else,” Philip Morris’ senior vice-president and general counsel Marc Firestone said in a statement on Friday, adding that his firm was reviewing the decision to determine its response.

“This case has never been about a government’s undeniable authority to regulate in the public interest. Nor has there ever been any question that tobacco products merit strict oversight,” Firestone added.

“In our view, the real point is simply this: even when pursuing tobacco control objectives, governments are still accountable if they choose to use unlawful means.”

Philip Morris launched the challenge in 2011 after plain-packaging legislation was passed, using a 1993 trade deal between Australia and Hong Kong that included foreign investment protections.

Four tobacco firms including Philip Morris in 2012 lost a legal challenge against the laws in the High Court of Australia, which found they did not breach the nation’s constitution.

France votes for plain cigarette packaging from 2016

http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/dec/18/france-votes-for-plain-cigarette-packaging-from-2016

Cigarettes will be sold in logo-free packaging from May 2016, despite objections from the conservative opposition and tobacconists

Cigarettes in France will be sold in plain packaging under a law that was finally passed in parliament on Thursday despite objections from the conservative opposition.

Starting in May 2016, the brand name will appear but in a small, uniform typeface and packets will be shorn of logos.

With backing from the ruling Socialists and the Greens, the text finally came into law after mainly conservative senators added amendments to the draft that was first voted in April, which would allow the brand name to appear in small letters.

The senate had initially demanded that the neutral packaging clause be removed from the draft legislation.

Around a quarter of French adults indulge in the hazardous habit, according to the World Health Organisation, and one third of teenagers also smoke.

Nine years ago, France controversially banned smoking in enclosed public spaces, including bars and restaurants.

And only last month, Paris authorities doubled fines for dropping cigarette butts to 68 euros (£50/$75) in a city where some 350 tonnes of them are collected annually.

Last year, health minister Marisol Touraine estimated some 13 million people still light up in France and that smoking accounts for around 78,000 deaths, the leading cause of premature death in the country.

All cigarettes will from May next year have to be sold in neutral packaging of uniform size and colour in a move that is notably similar to legislation adopted in Australia three years ago.

The United Kingdom and Ireland have since followed suit.

Australian government wins plain packaging case against Philip Morris Asia

http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/australian-government-wins-plain-packaging-case-against-philip-morris-20151218-glqo8s.html

The federal government has won its case against tobacco giant Philip Morris Asia challenging Australia’s tobacco plain-packaging laws.

It means the former Gillard government’s plain-packaging laws, introduced in 2011, will remain in place.

The tribunal in the arbitration, based in Singapore, has issued a unanimous decision agreeing with Australia’s position that it has no jurisdiction to hear Philip Morris’s claim.

Philip Morris has slammed the decision, saying it does not validate plain packaging in Australia or anywhere else.

“It is regrettable that the outcome hinged entirely on a procedural issue that Australia chose to advocate instead of confronting head on the merits of whether plain packaging is legal or even works,” Marc Firestone, Philip Morris international senior vice president, said in a statement.

Fiona Nash, Minister for Rural Health, has welcomed the decision, saying plain packaging is a legitimate public health measure which is consistent with Australia’s international obligations.

“We welcome the unanimous decision by the tribunal agreeing with Australia’s position that it has no jurisdiction to hear Philip Morris’ claim,” Ms Nash said.

“Smoking does untold harm to Australians, causing deaths from cancer, lung and heart disease, and hurting families.

“The Coalition government has powered ahead with plain packaging and invested in reducing smoking rates across the board.”

The Public Health Association of Australia has also welcomed the decision.

“This is a massive win for public health. The tobacco industry’s desperate legal efforts have failed yet again,” said PHAA tobacco spokesperson Professor Mike Daube, who chaired the Australian government’s expert committee that recommended plain packaging.

The confidentiality protocol governing the arbitration means that the substance of the decision cannot be published at this stage.

The body responsible for the arbitration – the Permanent Court of Arbitration – will publish the decision on its website once issues regarding confidentiality have been resolved.

It means the arbitration is over, other than any proceedings related to the recovery of Australia’s cost, and subject to any appeal Philip Morris Asia may seek to institute in Singapore.

It is understood the federal government has received legal advice saying such a challenge would likely be unsuccessful.

Philip Morris Asia brought the case against Australia using a legal mechanism called Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS).

It was the first investor-state dispute brought against Australia.

It challenged Australia’s tobacco plain packaging legislation under a 1993 agreement between the Commonwealth government and the government of Hong Kong for the promotion and protection of investments.

Philip Morris Asia argued that Australia’s tobacco plain packaging measure constituted an expropriation of its Australian investments in breach of Article 6 of the agreement.

It further argued that Australia’s tobacco plain packaging measure was in breach of its commitment under Article 2(2) of the agreement to accord fair and equitable treatment to Philip Morris Asia’s investments.

It also asserted that plain packaging constituted an unreasonable and discriminatory measure and that Philip Morris Asia’s investments had been deprived of full protection and security in breach of the agreement.

The tobacco company on Friday attacked the federal government’s plain packaging laws, saying they have failed to deliver the promised health results.

“Australia’s former Labor government made bold promises regarding the public health benefits that its excessive, expropriatory trademark ban – which it labelled a policy experiment – would yield,” it said in a press release.

“Three years into the experiment, data from a range of sources consistently demonstrate that the promised outcomes are not being delivered.”

But PHAA chief executive, Michael Moore, says the laws have been working.

“Smoking in Australia is falling in adults, in children and by tobacco volume sales,” Mr Moore said.

“Now the tobacco companies have lost another crucial legal bid to stop this life-saving measure. The message is loud and clear – plain packaging works, and it is here to stay”.

Australia’s plain packaging win over Philip Morris should take the heat off ISDS

http://theconversation.com/australias-plain-packaging-win-over-philip-morris-should-take-the-heat-off-isds-52541

Christmas has come early for advocates of tobacco control, with tobacco giant Philip Morris’s lawsuit against Australian plain packaging legislation ruled invalid. Australia will not have to pay any damages to Philip Morris. Indeed, it is likely that Philip Morris will be ordered to reimburse the Australian government’s costs in defending this suit.

This outcome is also an early Christmas present for defenders of much maligned investor state dispute settlement (ISDS). The Philip Morris case had become the bogeyman of ISDS. It was held up as a reason to object to ISDS clauses in free trade agreements.

This is understandable. A tobacco company sued a government for enacting laws designed to improve public health. They used a little understood mechanism – ISDS – to sue, despite having lost in Australian courts. International trade law disputes rarely have such a clear-cut villain. It is natural to distrust the mechanisms they relied on. However, this victory – in the first ISDS claim brought against Australia – should allay those concerns.

The award

This determination is a victory for common sense. Philip Morris argued that the plain packaging legislation – which prevents them from using their trademarks on the packages of their cigarettes and in advertising – was “expropriatory”. That is it was akin to the government seizing their assets without compensation. Further, Philip Morris argued they were entitled to compensation for lost profits. I have previously noted that this position is nonsense. It has no basis in law. Philip Morris were seeking suspension of the plain packaging legislation and compensation of “an amount to be quantified but of the order of billions of Australian dollars.”] They will get nothing.

In a typically truculent press release Philip Morris continued its attack on plain packaging. Its grandiose claim that the “real point” of the dispute went to “the essence of the rule of law” is correct; though perhaps not in the way they intend.

Ultimately this dispute turned on a question of jurisdiction. Australia argued that Philip Morris was not entitled to bring ISDS proceedings. It argued that Philip Morris had improperly made a foreign “investment” so as to avail itself of these proceedings. It also argued that Philip Morris misrepresented the nature of its investment to the Australian government. Further Australia argued that the case constituted an abuse of right. For these reasons Australia argued that the case could not proceed. In essence Australia was asking the tribunal to find that Philip Morris had – to use a colloquialism – attempted to “game” the system. That jurisdictional argument succeeded.

While the specifics are not yet published, it is clear that the tribunal has rejected Philip Morris’ capacity to bring this suit. Multinational companies are not able to use free trade agreements and investment treaties to do an end run around the proper processes. This is entirely in keeping with the essence of the rule of law.

Myth busting

This case exposes many of the errors opponents of ISDS proceedings make. Claims that such proceedings are secret are simply untrue. Large swathes of this dispute are available online, just as court proceedings in Australia would be. The equivalent ISDS clause contained in the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement goes further. It has very far-reaching and specific provisions requiring disputes to be resolved transparently.

Equally, we can now demonstrate that these cases proceed according to fairly standard legal processes. Claims that such tribunals are not bound by precedent, and therefore not bound to follow the ordinary legal process are incorrect. That claim discloses a misunderstanding of the nature of precedent.

Many other jurisdictions do not share Australia’s technical rules of precedent – the “stare decisis” rule. Yet they still make predictable decisions. Civil law countries apply “jurisprudence constante”. This rule strikes a balance between the need for predictable decisions and the civil law insistence that only the legislature may make law. International law must accommodate a plurality of legal systems. Australia’s approach to legal reasoning is not the last word in justice. Predictable, coherent legal decisions are possible even without strict application of stare decisis.

I have previously called for a sober analysis of the costs and benefits of ISDS clauses. Australia’s victory over Philip Morris should take much heat out of this debate.

The bogeyman has been slain.