Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Plain packaging effective in reducing misperceptions of tobacco products among Australian Indigenous

http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2015-12/smh-ppe122115.php

Following the introduction of plain packaging on tobacco products in 2012, Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people were 12 per cent less likely to think certain tobacco brands were less harmful than others, a new study found.

Plain packaging means tobacco company colours, logos and design elements are not allowed on tobacco products, but government health warnings still appear. Australia was the first country to implement plain packaging in December 2012 in an effort to curb national smoking rates. Canada plans to implement plain packaging as part of Prime Minister Trudeau’s Safer Kids Initiative.

The research, published today in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, studied the effects of plain packaging on Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people’s perceptions of different brands being less harmful or more prestigious than others.

“We know that brand imagery and design elements influence perceptions of consumer risk and status,” said Dr. Raglan Maddox, a postdoctoral fellow at the Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute of St. Michael’s Hospital, specializing in Aboriginal tobacco use, public health and evaluation. “Colours, shapes and symbols on packaging contribute to beliefs that certain brands are more high-status, while using words like mild, light or slim can give consumers the impression that some tobacco products are less harmful than others.”

The study found plain packaging not only reduced overall misperceptions that there are healthier tobacco brands, but also found that participants under the age of 35 were 16.5 per cent less likely to view some brands as more prestigious than others. Research also indicates that smokers, especially those ages 18 to 29, found the new plain packs less appealing.

“These age-specific findings provide important insight for changing perceptions of status or prestige associated with tobacco brands in the younger indigenous population,” said Dr. Maddox. “Preventing uptake and eliminating tobacco use in this demographic is central to addressing the disproportionate burden of smoking-related death and disease, while also improving overall health and life expectancy.”

In 2013, approximately 42 per cent of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people were smokers – a substantially higher rate than the general population. Tobacco-related illness is the most preventable cause of disease and death in both Australian Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people, contributing to heart disease, chronic respiratory disease and various forms of cancer.

Dr. Maddox said the study adds to growing literature indicating the world’s first plain packaging initiative is associated with increased thoughts of smoking cessation, attempts to stop smoking and calls to cessation helplines.

“The findings are consistent with recent, broader research that smokers were more likely to correctly identify that cigarette brands are equally harmful and similar in prestige after plain packaging was implemented,” said Dr. Maddox. “The findings on Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people further support plain packaging and health warnings as an effective strategy in reducing global tobacco use.”

As Canada and Australia are both Commonwealth countries with similar health and social systems, Dr. Maddox said he believes Australia’s documented success combined with this study’s findings could haves huge potential for Canadians – especially vulnerable populations, which include First Nations, Inuit and Métis people.

Both countries observe much higher rates of smoking among Indigenous people than non-Indigenous citizens. According to Statistics Canada, First Nations, Inuit and Métis people are twice as likely to smoke or use tobacco products as non- Indigenous people. Among those who smoke, the majority started between the ages of 13 and 16 years of age.

###

This study was conducted in conjunction with Winnunga Nimmityjah Aboriginal Health Service and received funding from the ACT Health Directorate and the University of Canberra.

About St. Michael’s Hospital

St. Michael’s Hospital provides compassionate care to all who enter its doors. The hospital also provides outstanding medical education to future health care professionals in 27 academic disciplines. Critical care and trauma, heart disease, neurosurgery, diabetes, cancer care, care of the homeless and global health are among the hospital’s recognized areas of expertise. Through the Keenan Research Centre and the Li Ka Shing International Healthcare Education Centre, which make up the Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, research and education at St. Michael’s Hospital are recognized and make an impact around the world. Founded in 1892, the hospital is fully affiliated with the University of Toronto.

Anti-Tobacco Campaigners Celebrate Australia’s Plain Packaging Win

http://www.justmeans.com/blogs/anti-tobacco-campaigners-celebrate-australias-plain-packaging-win

(3BL Media/Just Means) – ​The Australian government ha​s​ scored a win against smoking: plain packaging will remain. Philip Morris had been fighting a lawsuit against a legislation introduced in 2011, but ​a​ Singapore tribunal​ agreed that ​the Australia’s position ​is right: the tribunal ​has no jurisdiction to hear ​the tobacco company​’s claim.

The law was introduced to protect young people who are more vulnerable to advertising and being lured into smoking. According to the Sydney Morning Herald, Philip Morris Asia brought the case against Australia using a legal mechanism called Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS)​, and it was the first time Australia had to fight this type of litigation.​

As a rich country, Australia is in advantageous position to fight such legal cases. But it is not the same for developing countries, where smoking rates remain higher and governments don’t have robust financial resources​ to fight the problem and attacks from stakeholders.

​“Tobacco companies will do whatever it takes to undermine efforts to reduce smoking, especially in low-income countries that don’t have the resources to fight expensive lawsuits,” said Mike Bloomberg said in a blog post published by Bloomberg’s charitable arm, Bloomberg Philanthropies.

Bloomberg ​celebrated the Australian victory as an indication that the anti-tobacco campaign has gained momentum with ​the outcome in Singapore. The organization is focused on helping vulnerable countries fight back through the litigation fund it has launched with the Gates Foundation and the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids.

​The purpose of the new fund, which was launched in March, is to assist governments in low- and middle-income countries by defending their tobacco control laws from suits brought by the tobacco industry through international trade agreements. CTFK will direct financial, legal, and other technical assistance t​o those countries when they need to defend themselves from tobacco multinationals, who will fight tooth and nail to keep​ and, if possible, increase​ their market share.

According to the World Health Organization, tobacco kills around six million people every year​, mostly from direct tobaccl use but also from second-hand smoke. Most smokers (nearly 80% of ​one billion across the globe)​​ live in low- and middle-income countries.

– See more at: http://www.justmeans.com/blogs/anti-tobacco-campaigners-celebrate-australias-plain-packaging-win#sthash.nHN0fsgh.dpuf

Kenya: Lighting Up

http://www.westfieldtimes.com/world/kenya-lighting-up/16702/

Last year, the British parliament, despite fierce lobbying from tobacco companies, decided that from May 2016 cigarettes would be sold only in plain packaging in the UK.

Anti-smoking campaigners in that country were quick to declare it as the latest nail in the coffin of an industry that has seen consumption of its products shrink inexorably in the West over the past three decades.

But while it is true that health concerns, public education, and increasingly stringent controls on the advertising, sale and use of tobacco have brought about that decline in North America and Europe, anyone thinking to write the obituary of Big Tobacco had better think again, because elsewhere in the world, especially in the developing world, smoking is increasing dramatically.

Nearly 80 percent of the world’s one billion smokers now live in low- and middle-income countries, a figure that continues to rise year on year. In China, for example, an estimated 350 million adults are hooked on tobacco; smoking in Indonesia has more than quadrupled in the past four decades; and in Russia around a third of all teenagers will have tried their first cigarette by age 12.

But it is Africa that is probably most critical to the long-term future of the multinational tobacco firms, because it is relatively unexploited. For all the continent’s other woes, Africa has traditionally had some of the lowest smoking rates in the world, largely because most people can’t afford it. That, though, is now changing as parts of the continent become more prosperous, disposable incomes increase and populations mushroom.

It has become an enticing target for a profit-hungry industry as other routes to growth have been closed off by rules, directives and worries about life-threatening diseases.

With the most smokers in sub-Saharan Africa, Kenya is one of the biggest prizes on offer.

The problem for the industry is that Kenyan health officials are as aware as anyone else about the dreadful menace smoking poses to their nation’s health. Kenya was the first African nation to ratify the World Health Organization’s Convention on Tobacco Control. One of its key sections, Article 5.3, says that countries must “protect their tobacco control and public health policies from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry”.

It gave officials the impetus to work with legislators on drafting strict regulations. These include putting graphic images on cigarette packets, banning advertising, promotion and sponsorship of tobacco and the imposition of a 2 percent health tax on every packet.

Professor Peter Odhiambo, chairman of the Tobacco Control Board, said: “We are already sitting on an epidemic of the cancers from tobacco. The tobacco problem is the most silent undeclared disaster in Kenya and therefore the more we delay the more we will see Kenyans dying.”

But as investigative journalist Purity Mwambia and filmmaker Giovanni Ulleri have been finding out, the industry hasn’t been slow to fight back, going to court in Kenya to argue about the legality of the rules and the proposed timetable for their introduction.

And now, most recently, disturbing allegations about the bribery of government figures have begun to emerge.

FILMMAKER’S VIEW

By Giovanni Ulleri

Around the town of Migori, beside the dusty country roads, you’ll find them: groups of farmers sharing a social moment away from their football pitch-sized plots of tobacco. Here, in one of the most important agricultural regions in Kenya, tobacco is king but, as I discovered in making Lighting Up, this is a crop that demands a high price from those who grow it and those who smoke it.

When I got a phone call from my former boss over the summer about me directing a film on tobacco in Kenya, I hesitated before saying yes. Not because I didn’t want to do it, but because of a potential conflict of interest; I was a former smoker – and in my eyes, once a smoker, always a smoker.

I was fully aware of all the known cancer risks of smoking and I had tried to quit many times over the years, but like most addicts I kept falling off the wagon and stealing a cigarette from friends. I had starting smoking as a stupid act of rebellion as a teenager behind the bike sheds at school and here I was heading off to Kenya to see how they have been trying to prevent other youngsters from doing what I did – lighting their first cigarette and starting down a path that could eventually lead to an untimely death.

On arriving in Nairobi and meeting up with my colleague Purity Mwambia, the first thing I noticed walking around the streets was how few people smoked in public.

Unlike any high street in the UK, where you see smokers huddled up in doorways of offices and in the cold and rain trying to light up, here in Kenya you are allowed to smoke only in designated smoking zones which, I imagine, makes the city centre of Nairobi one of the largest no-smoking zones in the world.

There’s even a 50,000 Kenyan shilling ($490) fine if you are caught smoking outside these zones. But despite this, eight billion cigarettes are smoked in Kenya every year and the government is trying to introduce new regulations to try to prevent what it fears is just around the corner: a veritable host of tobacco-related diseases.

However tobacco companies view Africa as one of their largest growing markets.

They are eager to keep their market share and to persuade policymakers, not to penalise them. We spoke to a young MP, Stephen Mule, who sits on the Kenyan parliamentary health committee. He told us that he was offered an expenses-paid fact-finding trip to the UK from Kenya’s largest tobacco manufacturer, British American Tobacco. What BAT didn’t know was that Mule’s father had died of a tobacco-related disease and nothing would ever weaken his resolve to introduce strict tobacco control regulations back home.

I also met his mother, who told me how she looked after her dying husband and how she tried to get him to stop smoking. She is rightly proud of her son, whose aim is to stop other Kenyan families from suffering the way his family did caring for a smoker.

But everyone involved in tobacco regulation in Kenya knows they have a fight on their hands. They are up against a rich and powerful industry, battle-scarred from years of similar confrontations in Europe and the US and determined to protect its burgeoning African businesses from government interference.

The more we began to look into this story, the more we began to realise exactly what that determination meant in practice.

European court gives the go ahead for plain cigarette packs

http://www.newstalk.com/reader/47.301/61879/0/

“A wonderful Christmas present for children” – Minister gives ecstatic reaction

Minister for Children James Reilly has welcomed a European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruling that clears the way for plain packaging laws for tobacco products in Ireland.

The court has made a preliminary ruling this morning against tobacco giants Philip Morris and British American Tobacco.

They took proceedings to the ECJ over an EU directive which would see health warnings on two thirds of tobacco packaging.

The Children’s Minister James Reilly wants to go one step further in Ireland and ban tobacco branding on packets altogether.

He says: “Tobacco companies may have more manoeuvres, but the Irish Government stands ready to meet any challenge on the way to implementing this law.”

In its ruling this morning, the ECJ said the new EU tobacco directive of 2014 is valid.

Legislation to introduce plain packaging of tobacco products was unanimously passed by both houses of the Oireachtas, without any dissent.

Dr Reilly says more than 5,000 people a year die from smoking-related illness in Ireland.

Tobacco firms’ challenge to plain packaging stubbed out

http://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/tobacco-firms-challenge-to-plain-packaging-stubbed-out-1.2476697

EU advocate says 2014 EU tobacco directive calls for plain packaging on cigarette packs

The introduction of plain packaging rules for cigarettes is provided for in the 2014 EU tobacco directive, an advocate general to the European Court of Justice has said. She rejected arguments against the directive by major global tobacco groups.

Advocate general Juliane Kokott issued her opinions on a number of applications against the directive taken by tobacco firms and, in relation to one issue, Poland. Her opinions will be considered by the court which will make its findings at a later date.

Ms Kokott found the directive’s requirements relating to the size, shape and minimum content of cigarette packets were proportionate and made a particular contribution to the visibility and efficacy of health warnings.

New requirements to have health warnings covering 65 per cent of the front surface and back surface of a packet were neither arbitrary nor disproportionate, and it was right that the directive prohibited true statements which cast a tobacco product in a deceptively positive light.

“Even an organically farmed cigarette, for example, is still a product that is extremely harmful to health.”

Basic design

She also said that since the directive specified only a basic design for cigarette packets, “it also still leaves scope for additional national packaging standards, for example in respect of the colouring of surfaces not reserved for warnings (possibly through to the introduction of ‘plain packaging’).”

She said none of the arguments invoked by Poland against the prohibition on menthol cigarettes were well founded and its case should be dismissed. The new rule comes into effect in May 2020.

The flavouring of cigarettes could camouflage the generally very bitter and even pungent taste of tobacco smoke and create a serious risk of initiation for non-smokers into tobacco consumption, she said.

She also said the rules concerning e-cigarettes were moderate and not disproportionate. It was not manifestly wrong or unreasonable to accept that e-cigarettes possibly caused harm and could develop into a gateway to traditional tobacco consumption.

The directive’s implementation into British law is being challenged in the English high court.

EUROPEAN COURT TO RULE ON PLAIN PACKAGING FOR CIGARETTES IN IRELAND

http://www.carlow-nationalist.ie/2015/12/23/european-court-to-rule-on-plain-packaging-for-cigarettes-in-ireland/

The European Court of Justice will rule today on whether Ireland can go ahead with plain packaging laws for cigarettes.

Tobacco giants Philip Morris and British American Tobacco took proceedings to the ECJ over an EU directive which would see health warnings on two thirds of tobacco packaging.

The Children’s Minister James Reilly wants to go one step further in Ireland and ban tobacco branding on packets altogether.

The ECJ will issue a preliminary ruling today.

European court paves the way for plain cigarette packaging

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/5469463a-a968-11e5-955c-1e1d6de94879.html#axzz3vF5CU4yL

Aliya Ram in London

The EU’s highest court has opened the path to the introduction of plain cigarette packaging laws across the continent, striking a significant blow against tobacco companies.

In an opinion delivered on Wednesday, Juliane Kokott, the European Court of Justice’s advocate general, dismissed a legal challenge from the tobacco industry against EU plans to increase health warnings, ban menthol cigarettes and regulate ecigarettes.

The industry hoped that a ruling in its favour would block attempts by the UK, France and Ireland to introduce so-called “plain packaging”, when branded cigarette packs are replaced with dark brown or green boxes without pictures or design features.

The advocate general’s opinion is not binding but is usually upheld by the ECJ. It will come as a further setback to tobacco companies, which are facing declining smoking rates and greater regulation across the developed world.

The French parliament last week voted to introduce plain packaging just a day before the Australian high court defeated a challenge from Philip Morris International against branding restrictions.
PMI, British American Tobacco, Japan Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco have also challenged the UK government’s plain packaging rules, which will come into effect from May 2017. A decision is expected in the new year.

“While we are still analysing the [advocate general’s] opinion, we are obviously disappointed with its conclusions,” BAT said. “We have always maintained that the Tobacco Products Directive represents an unlawful and disproportionate incursion into the autonomy of the [EU] member states.”

When it launched its challenge, PMI said the EU directive would “disrupt the balance . . . between the union and the member states” by allowing nations to introduce rules above those in the directive that says cigarette packs have to be 65 per cent covered with health warnings.

“Rather than respecting such basic principles as genuine harmonisation and free movement, the [TPD] inexplicably encourages a patchwork of regulations,” it added on Wednesday.

But Ms Kokott said individual countries can introduce full plain packaging. “Since the directive specifies only a basic design, it also still leaves scope for additional national packaging standards, for example in respect of the colouring of surfaces not reserved for warnings,” she said.

Deborah Arnott, chief executive of antismoking group Ash, says if the opinion is upheld by the ECJ it would strengthen antismoking advocates across the developed world.

“The advocate general’s opinion that standardised packaging of cigarettes is legal in Europe, one of the world’s big trading blocks, sets the scene for it to go global,” she said.

On Wednesday Ms Kokott also said separate challenges against the directive’s ban on menthol cigarettes and regulation of ecigarettes should be dismissed.

Pillbox, an ecigarette manufacturer, said the regulation of ecigarettes under tobacco legislation is disproportionate. Ms Kokott said ecigarette rules will be “moderate” compared with tobacco regulations.

She also said menthol cigarettes should be banned under the TPD, despite a challenge from Poland where flavoured products are popular. Ms Kokott said “none of the arguments invoked by Poland and supported by Romania . . . is well founded”.

Tobacco case ‘should encourage plain packaging here’

http://www.voxy.co.nz/politics/tobacco-case-should-encourage-plain-packaging-here/5/240578

The MÄ ori Party is delighted that tobacco giant Philip Morris has lost one of its legal bids in Singapore to overturn Australian’s plain packaging laws. Philip Morris has initiated at least three international challenges against Australia which was the first country in the world to introduce plain packaging.

MÄ ori Party Co-leader Marama Fox says the legal action brought by international tobacco companies has dissuaded the New Zealand Government from passing similar legislation here.

“Dame Tariana Turia introduced a plain packaging Bill into Parliament more than two years ago and we are still sitting on our hands.

“I’m encouraged to hear the Trade Minister Todd McClay say he believes New Zealand is well positioned to defend a legal challenge if we were to pass plain packaging legislation here.”

Mrs Fox says the MÄ ori Party is hopeful that the Bill will be passed by Parliament next year.

MÄ ori Party Co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell says the Australian example has shown how stripping the branding off cigarettes packets has reduced smoking rates.

“The number of new smokers has dropped dramatically and if we want to prevent rangatahi from picking up smoking this appears to be an effective strategy,” he says.

According to the Ministry of Health, around 5000 individuals die each year from smoking or second-hand exposure.

MÄ ori Party Co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell says New Zealand has an international reputation for its smokefree reforms.

“The Government, with the support of the MÄ ori Party, has committed to a Smokefree Aotearoa by 2025.

“If we’re going to reach this target we need to show some courage. We should be doing everything we can to eliminate the harmful effects of smoking on our whÄ nau.”

The simple trick Australia is using to reduce smoking rates

http://www.vox.com/2015/12/20/10629896/australia-plain-packaging

Australian cigarette packages have graphic health warnings. Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

Australian cigarette packages have graphic health warnings. Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

Cigarette packs in Australia look different from anywhere else in the world. There are no brand logos, no bright colors. Every pack is the same shade of dull brown, plastered with graphic images showing the health impacts of smoking. There’s the gangrenous foot, mouth cancer, and everyone’s favorite, the creepy sickly eye.

Tobacco companies don’t do this by choice. In 2011, Australia became the first country in the world to pass plain packaging laws that severely restrict what can appear on cigarette packs.

Naturally, Big Tobacco hates these laws and has done everything it can think of to get rid of them. On Friday, Australia defeated a challenge by cigarette giant Philip Morris after a four-year international trade dispute in Singapore.

Big Tobacco is clearly running scared — and it should be. The latest ruling is likely to open the door for plain packaging laws around the world. Already, 11 other countries — including England, New Zealand, France, Brazil, India, and South Africa — have plans to implement their own plain packaging rules.

Other countries, including the United States, should follow Australia’s lead. Plain packaging laws are a simple, cost-effective way to cut smoking rates. That’s why tobacco companies hate them.

Big Tobacco has been fighting plain packaging on many fronts

Philip Morris exploited an obscure clause in Australia’s free trade agreement with Hong Kong known as investor-state dispute settlement. President Obama’s controversial Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement includes an ISDS provision, and it has caused a lot of controversy. Critics worried that big companies — like Philip Morris — could use the ISDS process to overturn countries’ democratically enacted laws.

Australia may have won this round, but its government now faces an estimated $50 million legal bill. And Philip Morris is not the only company to push back against plain packaging laws. In 2012, British American Tobacco (BAT) challenged the laws in Australia’s high court, alleging they infringed the company’s intellectual property. The court ruled in favor of the government.

Eyebrows were raised at the World Trade Organization when Ukraine — a country that doesn’t actually export tobacco to Australia — challenged plain packaging as anti-trade. Later, it was discovered BAT had footed the country’s legal bill.

It’s not clear whether similar challenges from Cuba, the Dominican Republic, and Honduras are also funded by Big Tobacco.

While in public the tobacco giants insist plain packaging laws won’t work, behind closed doors they have spent millions of dollars trying to discredit the laws.

In 2010, a newly formed group called the Alliance of Australian Retailers launched a media blitz criticizing plain packaging. It was a case of “astroturfing” — an attempt to give the impression of a widespread grassroots backlash against the laws that just didn’t exist

Australian investigative journalists unearthed that Philip Morris, BAT, and Imperial funneled more than A$5 million into forming the Alliance of Australian Retailers. The group’s argument against plain packaging was distilled into a simple message: “It won’t work, so why do it.”

Of course, the obvious response is: If it won’t work, why are you spending millions of dollars to fight it? The alliance wasn’t effective. In fact, one study found for some people the ads increased their support for plain packaging.

Early evidence suggests plain packaging is working

The goal of the plain packaging laws is to make cigarettes less attractive and reduce the glamour of smoking. In lab studies, researchers have found they achieve this. More than 20 studies, undertaken over two decades in five countries, strongly suggest that plain packaging increases the impact of health warnings and reduces the appeal of cigarettes.

The laws aren’t a silver bullet to make people stop smoking. Instead, they work alongside higher taxes, public health campaigns, and education to reduce smoking rates over time.

As Australia is the only country to have implemented the laws, real-world evidence on plain packaging is limited. However, there is a growing body of research gathered since the laws were enacted three years ago. While we don’t yet have long-term evidence pointing to changes in smoking rates, short-term shifts seem positive.

A large study in the Australian state of Victoria found that in just 12 months plain packaging both reduced the appeal of smoking and increased desire to quit for adult smokers. Another study found calls to Quitline, an Australian government service to help people quit smoking, rose by 78 percent after the plain packaging laws came into effect. Smoking in outdoor areas, where the graphic packaging is visible to more people, also declined.

British American Tobacco hit back with its own study by Deloitte, which argued health warnings haven’t been effective in reducing consumption of cigarettes. But this study wasn’t independent — it was commissioned and funded by BAT. The study itself admits the researchers were highly selective about what brands they included.

Tobacco taxes alone are not enough

If cigarettes were like any other product, high taxes would be enough to make people stop buying them. But cigarettes are highly addictive, so rising prices don’t have too much impact on a smoker’s decision to buy cigarettes.

It’s estimated that in rich countries, a 10 percent increase in the price of cigarettes will only bring about a 4 percent drop in demand. In poor to middle-income countries, the figures vary quite a bit because of a host of cultural and economic factors. For some though this sizable price bump would reduce demand by just 2 percent.

Of course, smokers could just take their cigarettes out of the packs. They could smoke rollies and put their tobacco in a tin. However, the evidence suggests very few people do. So the plain packs are always there, a graphic reminder of the harms of smoking. It’s a behavioral nudge that smokers carry around with them.

Globally, tobacco kills around 6 million people every year. Smoking costs the US more than $300 billion a year through both direct medical bills and lost productivity. Taxes, education, and public health campaigns are all important in reducing harm. However, Australia has shown that plain packaging needs to be in the mix too. It’s a simple and effective tool in the fight against a deadly habit

Govt urged to act on plain packaging

http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/national/292542/govt-urged-to-act-on-plain-packaging

The government is being urged to speed up plain packaging laws for cigarettes following the Australian government’s win against one of the world’s biggest tobacco companies.

Australia introduced plain packaging for all tobacco products in 2012, which resulted in a four-year legal challenge by Philip Morris.

The company tried to challenge the laws at a tribunal in Singapore, using an investment agreement that Australia signed with Hong Kong in 1993.

But the Arbitration Tribunal ruled that it had no jurisdiction to decide whether plain packaging is legal in Australia.

Nurses Organisation spokesperson Kerri Nuku said New Zealand’s government has been very clear about wanting to wait to see what would happen in Australia.

Now that it’s happened, plain packaging should be introduced immediately, she said.

The organisation planned to put more pressure on the government to act as part of its goal for a smokefree country by 2025.

Action on Smoking and Health NZ (ASH) director Stephanie Erick said the legislation urgently needed to be finalised in order for the country to be smokefree by 2025.

“This decision can give New Zealand greater confidence to pass Standardised (Plain) Packaging for immediate implementation.”

Research showed large graphic health warnings helped people who wanted to stop smoking, but standardised packaging and dissuasive cigarette sticks can also deter people from ever starting or relapsing, ASH said.

Australia has been monitoring its implementation of plain packaging and research was showing it works, Australia’s Public Health Association chief executive Michael Moore said.

“Smoking in Australia is falling in adults, in children and by tobacco volume sales.”

Australia’s law is still facing challenges in other forums, such as the World Trade Organisation.

But Maori Party co-leader Marama Fox said yesterday’s court decision was still a victory.

“This is a strong signal to the government that we should be expecting a favourable outcome from WTO, but despite that the government should be making stronger moves to advance the tobacco control legislation.”

The Public Health Association of Australia (PHAA) has described the decision as a massive win.

“The tobacco industry’s desperate legal efforts have failed yet again,” said PHAA tobacco spokesperson Professor Mike Daube.

“They are the big losers, but the thousands who will not die from smoking are the winners.”

Tobacco companies were “desperate to prevent plain packaging here and internationally because they know it works”.

Philip Morris said it was reviewing the tribunal’s decision in detail.