Plain Packaging
France orders plain packaging for cigarettes; Japan Tobacco to appeal
http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2016/03/23/business/corporate-business/france-orders-plain-packaging-cigarettes-japan-tobacco-appeal/#.VvJhvfnhA2w
PARIS – France published a decree on Tuesday that requires cigarette manufacturers to introduce plain packaging by the end of the year.
Japan Tobacco International immediately said it would challenge the measure.
The publication of the decree was the culmination of government efforts launched in 2014 to require tobacco firms to sell cigarettes in packages decorated with neither logos nor distinctive coloring.
But Japan Tobacco International’s French subsidiary quickly announced it would challenge the decree before the Council of State.
“The introduction of plain packages doesn’t take into account the damage it does to the property rights of companies, in particular intellectual property rights,” JTI France’s Corporate Relations and Communications Director Benoit Bas said in a statement.
That is the argument tobacco companies have used against the introduction of plain packaging in Australia.
In 2012, Australia became the first country to mandate plain packaging for cigarettes in a bid to reduce smoking rates, and is being followed by Ireland and Britain as well as France.
The British ban on logos and branding on cigarette packets goes into force in May, but tobacco firms have filed a legal challenge.
The appeal by JTI before the Council of State, the nation’s supreme court for administrative justice, will not suspend the introduction of plain packages.
Tobacco firms lost their legal cases in Australia and failed to have the matter accepted for international arbitration.
They also failed to overturn an EU law allowing member states to impose plain packaging.
PLAIN PACKAGING WORKS: REPORT
https://ajp.com.au/news/plain-packaging-works-phaa/
Tobacco plain packaging has been a remarkable success, and has already saved thousands of lives, according to the Public Health Association of Australia (PHAA) and other groups.
A report released today concludes that the effects of plain packaging are “underestimated” but these positive outcomes are expected to grow.
Plain packaging, which was a first for Australia, was introduced in December 2012 by the Gillard Government. Researchers now believe it has been essential in the decline of smoking rates.
PHAA Tobacco spokesperson Professor Mike Daube, who chaired the Australian government’s expert committee says “it is great news for everyone except big tobacco”.
“We know that smoking in adults and children and cigarette sales are declining, but it is especially rewarding that this meticulous independent analysis attributes part of that decline to plain packaging alone, even within its first three years.”
He adds that the plain packaging legislation has resulted in a stunning outcome.
“Even leaving aside the rest of the decline, and impacts on children, plain packaging alone has been responsible for tens of thousands of adults quitting since its introduction in late 2012.”
PHAA chief executive Michael Moore claims that plain packaging is a proven success.
“It is saving lives even in the short term, and will save many more in the years to come. No wonder the tobacco industry opposed it so desperately. All their arguments have failed, and plain packaging has become one of Australia’s most successful exports.”
“We congratulate all major parties for their continuing support of tobacco control and plain packaging. This is a triumph for public health and for a bipartisan approach to our largest preventable cause of death and disease. There is still work to be done, and the tobacco companies and their allies will do everything they can to keep selling their lethal products. This early outcome shows that the legislation is working, and Australia is winning the war on tobacco.”
Also the National Heart Foundation welcomed the results of the report.
Adding further credence to the results, the report also concluded that “this effect is likely understated and is expected to grow over time,” it said in a media statement today, adding it was another win against so-called “big tobacco”.
The figures come from the Government’s Tobacco Plain Packaging – Post Implementation Review that confirms approximately one quarter of the total decline in smoking rates were attributable to plain packaging since the legislation was introduced in December 2012.
National Heart Foundation tobacco control spokesperson, and President of the Australian Council on Smoking and Health, Maurice Swanson says this report sends a clear message that plain packaging on tobacco products works.
“The report undeniably shows that the legislation is working and has been the catalyst for tens of thousands of adults quitting and saved the lives of many thousands of Australians,” says Swanson
“The legislation was always designed for long-term impact and if these results are merely the start of the journey, a smoke-free Australia could one day be a reality.”
Tobacco Plain Packaging Post–implementation Review – Department of Health
https://ris.govspace.gov.au/2016/02/26/tobacco-plain-packaging/
In April 2010 the then Prime Minister announced a decision to require all tobacco products to be sold in plain packaging. The regulation also standardised the appearance of the tobacco products themselves.
A Regulation Impact Statement (RIS) was required but not finalised before the decision. Consequently, under the Government’s best practice regulation process a Post‑implementation Review (PIR) was required.
The measure was fully implemented from 1 December 2012.
A PIR was completed by the Department of Health in February 2016 and was assessed as compliant by the Office of Best Practice Regulation (OBPR). Regulatory costings have been agreed with the OBPR.
Malaysia Gov’t plans to introduce plain packaging for tobacco
http://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2016/02/24/govt-plans-to-introduce-plain-packaging-for-tobacco/
PETALING JAYA: The Health Ministry plans to introduce generic packaging for tobacco products with the aim of reducing brand recognition and ultimately reducing overall consumption, Malay Mail Online reported today.
According to the report, the Health Ministry’s director for the disease control division Dr Chong Chee Keong, said plain packaging would greatly impact the prevalence of smoking among new and light smokers.
Chong said there were plans to introduce the plain packaging using standardised colours and fonts in stages but that no specific date had been set as yet.
When asked if the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPPA) would affect the plan, Chong said the treaty had yet to be tested.
In 2012, Australia became the first nation to mandate plain packaging for cigarettes, in a bid to reduce smoking rates among its citizens.
Other nations that adopted the move later were France and Britain, much to the unhappiness of big tobacco firms including Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International.
These firms have since launched legal challenges against such laws, arguing the move had impinged on their trademark intellectual property.
In Australia, four tobacco firms including Philip Morris lost their legal challenges against the law.
Plain packaging another step closer
http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PA1602/S00275/plain-packaging-another-step-closer.htm
The Māori Party is thrilled plain tobacco packaging is another step closer to becoming law, now the Government has signalled plans to progress the Bill in Parliament.
“This is a message to international tobacco companies that New Zealand will not be intimidated by their threats of legal action,” says Māori Party Co-leader Marama Fox.
The Government has indicated that the Bill could return to the House for its second reading before the end of the year.
The Plain Packaging Bill drafted by the Māori Party went before the Health Select Committee in August 2014, just six months after it was introduced into the House by Dame Tariana Turia.
She was internationally recognised for her leadership in tobacco reforms.
Māori Party Co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell says the Bill is not about punishing smokers.
“Research tells us that plain packaging will turn people off who haven’t started smoking. It’s better to deter people from picking up the habit than having to support them to quit later on,” says Māori Party Co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell.
“It’s time to get the ball rolling again because the Māori Party will not stand by idly while 5,000 New Zealanders die each year of smoking-related illnesses,” says Mrs Fox.
Smoking has steadily declined largely as a result of Māori Party initiatives including the tax increase on cigarettes, banning shops from displaying them and securing Government funding for programmes to support people who want to quit smoking.
The Government says it remains committed to the Māori Party’s target of a Smokefree Aotearoa by 2025.
Exclusive: Legal fight looms for government over plain tobacco packaging
https://www.tvnz.co.nz/one-news/new-zealand/exclusive-legal-fight-looms-for-government-over-plain-tobacco-packaging.html
British American Tobacco has confirmed to ONE News that it will explore “all possible legal avenues” to fight the legislation, which will be debated later this year after a delay due to legal action against Australia’s government by another tobacco company.
However, Prime Minister John Key says he is not worried about the impending legal fight.
The case against Australia, brought by Philip Morris, failed, but there is still a World Trade Organisation case pending.
Both British American Tobacco and Philip Morris say forcing them to adopt plain packaging on their products breaches copyright.
ONE News also understands that the government is waiting for the Trans Pacific Partnership Agreement to be ratified, because it contains a clause that allows the government to make any changes to public health law it pleases without fear of reprisals like this.
Neither of the companies would comment on the issue, but they claim there is no evidence plain packaging reduces smoking rates, and say the government should be cracking down on home-grown tobacco instead.
The government is working towards the goal of New Zealand being smokefree by 2025.
Govt should raise tobacco taxes by up to 50 per cent: smoking opponents
There is very “strong scientific ground” for the government to increase taxes on tobacco to cut smoking rates, according to a public health expert.
Increasing tobacco taxes by as much as 50 per cent a year could form the “backbone” of efforts to make New Zealand smoke-free, politicians have been told.
Tobacco taxes increased by 10 per cent at the start of the year, and academics and anti-smoking groups have encouraged Parliament’s finance and expenditure select committee to support a bigger price hike.
Otago University public health professor Nick Wilson, who has studied the best-value methods for reducing the impact of smoking, said politicians were “on extremely strong scientific ground” when raising taxes on tobacco.
“It’s one of the most powerful things that can be done to improve the health of the population … tax can be the backbone of the strategy.”
Wilson said raising taxes would save money in the health sector within a year, due to a reduction in heart attacks and strokes, while it would also reduce the gap in smoking rates between Maori and non-Maori.
“This is in some way a no-brainer public health intervention if you’re actually gaining healthy years of lives and saving health costs.”
Wilson said the issue of e-cigarettes, which are not currently approved for smoking cessation in New Zealand, was “a very complex area” due to the amount of new studies coming out every week.
It would be best to control their use through pharmacies until their benefits and dangers were fully known, he said.
National Maori Tobacco Control Leadership Service kaiwhakahaere Zoe Hawke said tax increases were a “foundation policy” that anti-tobacco organisations could use to improve quitting rates.
“It gets people thinking about quitting, it moves people into accessing services more.”
Hawke said she was keen to see more progress on plain packaging rules for tobacco products, as well as the de-nicotinisation of cigarettes and consideration of e-cigarettes.
“We need to remove nicotine from the products out there and do some transitional moves to help people move away from it, and e-cigarettes could potentially be something that will help with that too.”
The health benefits of tax increases would outweigh the economic costs to smokers, but they would need to be backed up by support services “so they’re not just left out there stranded”, she said.
T&T Consulting director Sue Taylor said the smoking health programmes already in place were not doing enough to help people quit, and a significant price increase would make a big difference.
“Our people out there in the community … a lot of them are saying, ‘That’s the only thing that will encourage me to give up smoking’.
“My own father, when he smoked … he gave up because of the price increase: it was more important for him to be able to provide better things for us as children, than to continue smoking.”
Taylor said tobacco taxes should be increased by 50 per cent this year, followed by 25 per cent each year until 2020.
She did not support e-cigarettes as they “normalised” smoking, and was also concerned that the majority of e-cigarettes were produced by tobacco manufacturers.
“They’re still trying to double-dip everywhere, they’re still trying to introduce other ways of continuing to have the population addicted to nicotine, so we seriously need to think about how we’re going to tax those as well.”
Health New Zealand smoking policy researcher Murray Laugesen supported a tax increase, and said the Government should look at legalising the use of e-cigarettes.
“They’ve killed nobody so far, against 4000 deaths [a year] from ordinary cigarettes.”
Laugesen also said there was “sound” evidence for low-nicotine cigarettes from trials in New Zealand and the United States.
“They show clearly that this reduces the appetite for nicotine, and if we lose the appetite for nicotine, we smoke less.”
Dates confirmed for new tobacco restrictions
http://www.talkingretail.com/category-news/industry-announcements/dates-confirmed-new-tobacco-restrictions/
The Department of Health has confirmed the dates for the introduction of stricter controls on tobacco packaging, pack sizes and electronic cigarettes.
The new regulations will come into force in May 2016 – from May 2017 retailers cannot sell products that do not comply.
The new regulations include:
• a minimum pack size of 20 cigarettes
• a minimum weight of 30g for roll-your-own tobacco
• the size of health warnings (text and photograph) to cover 65% of the front and back of pack (previously 30% on front and 40% on back of pack)
• a ban on cigarettes and roll-your-own tobacco containing characterising flavours such as menthol is also being introduced from May 2020
• new regulations coming into force in November 2016 for e-cigarettes which require the products to carry a health warning. The sell through period for retailers with existing stock will be a period of six months to May 2017
Commenting on the changes, Association of Convenience Stores (ACS) chief executive James Lowman said: “The introduction of these regulations alongside the implementation of the plain packaging rules marks a significant change for retailers that will be disruptive to their businesses.
“Government must focus its attention on tackling the harmful illicit trade in tobacco through stricter border checks and better enforcement in local areas. We are concerned that the introduction of the Tobacco Products Directive regulations alongside plain packaging will fuel the illicit trade, and urge the government to publish further details of plans to introduce a ‘track and trace’ system for legitimate tobacco products.”
Australia tobacco clash reverberates in EU trade talks
http://www.politico.eu/article/australia-tobacco-clash-reverberates-in-eu-trade-talks/
Tribunal decision could undermine opposition to TTIP.
The end of a complex court case on the other side of the world could wreak havoc on a campaign in Europe against a proposed trade deal between the EU and the United States.
An international arbitration tribunal in December 2015 wound up a four-year dispute between the Australian government and tobacco company Philip Morris by announcing it was unable to rule on the matter — effectively siding with Australia’s position in the dispute.
The case has resonated in Europe, where for some time opponents of the proposed Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) have used the legal challenge as a cautionary tale against signing investment deals.
Philip Morris used an obscure investment agreement which Australia signed with Hong Kong in 1993 in an attempt to scuttle Australia’s “plain packaging” tobacco legislation, which has removed all branding from cigarette packets sold in the country.
But Australia’s ability to fend off the legal challenge could undermine the argument that legal provisions contained in international investment agreements leave legitimate legislative reform vulnerable to big corporations.
“It will be back to the drawing board for anti-TTIP campaigners,” said Hosuk Lee-Makiyama, director of the European Center for International Political Economy, adding that the parallels between Australia’s deal with Hong Kong and TTIP had always been overstated.
“Philip Morris was only able to sue Australia because of a technicality,” Lee-Makiyama said. “In free-trade agreements you always include an exception for public health, which Australia forgot to do. This entire case was the result of a drafting error by Australian negotiators.”
However, anti-tobacco campaigners in Brussels say the decision by the Permanent Court of Arbitration in Singapore does nothing for TTIP’s credibility.
“The arbitration court declined to hear the case on the grounds that it was not competent, as Philip Morris had shifted its commercial identity during the course of the case,” said Catherine Hartmann, vice president of the European Public Health Alliance.
“There is nothing in the outcomes of the arbitration attempt that validates or questions plain packaging in Australia or anywhere else,” Hartmann said.
Tobacco wars
The clash between Philip Morris and the Australian federal government began in 2011, when health authorities in Canberra drafted legislation to remove all branding from tobacco packets. The laws, designed to discourage people from taking up smoking, were implemented at the end of 2012.
The legislation was a world first and Philip Morris Asia Limited, a Hong Kong-based subsidiary of the tobacco company, launched a legal challenge. The company argued that the laws “forced removal of trademarks and other valuable intellectual property.”
The legal action was possible because the agreement between Australia and Hong Kong contained an “investor-state dispute settlement” provision (ISDS), an arbitration mechanism which enables investors to take legal action if they feel their interests have been harmed by government policy.
In 2012 the High Court of Australia, the country’s supreme court, found against Philip Morris, arguing the plain packaging legislation was not in violation of the constitution. The tobacco company then took its concerns to the international arbitrator, which effectively ruled against Philip Morris.
Yet Nina Renshaw, the secretary general of the European Public Health Alliance, is adamant the risks of industry using ISDS to challenge health reforms remain.
“The inclusion of an ISDS … in an EU agreement could raise the likelihood of such cases being brought against all kinds of public interest and health protecting policies in the future,” Renshaw said.
In an unusual alliance, Philip Morris agreed with anti-tobacco campaigners. Company vice president Marc Firestone argued that the Australian government’s win was “entirely procedural” with no bearing on either the merits of plain packaging legislation or the ISDS itself.
However, Lee-Makiyama said opposition in Europe to both ISDS and TTIP is based not on fact but misconceptions about American corporate culture.
“This is coming from business interests that are concerned with American market share and from outdated ideas of multinational corporations which may have been OK in the 1920s but are meaningless today,” Lee-Makiyama said.
“Opposition to the ISDS in Europe is also coming from national governments like Germany, which do not want a legal mechanism to stop them discriminating against foreign investors,” he said.
Packaging problems
The controversy has fed into a broader lobbying clash between the tobacco industry and anti-smoking campaigners in Europe, where plain packaging legislation is being hotly contested.
The EU’s revised Tobacco Products Directive, which entered into force in 2014, steered clear of plain packaging reforms after the European Commission came under pressure from the tobacco industry. However, the directive allowed EU member countries to adopt national plain packaging laws.
A number of EU governments have now done so. In December 2015, France passed tobacco legislation and will start to introduce plain packaging in May 2016.
However, the tobacco industry is maintaining its opposition to such laws. Australia’s legislation is also being challenged by a number of tobacco-producing countries at the World Trade Organization.
Meanwhile, on the other side of the Atlantic the EU’s soul-searching over the implications of an ISDS is being observed with interest by those opposing the inclusion of an arbitration mechanism in TTIP on the grounds that it is unnecessary.
“A company entering into a contract with a foreign government can accomplish the same objectives as an ISDS simply by insisting on including an arbitration clause,” said Dan Pearson from the Washington-based Cato Institute, a libertarian think-tank.
“Business associations in the U.S. would support TTIP without an ISDS because the reality is that they don’t need it,” Pearson said. “It mystifies me that the Obama administration has placed so much emphasis on an ISDS.”
This article was corrected to clarify details of the 2012 Australian High Court finding.