Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

EU dismisses Big Tobacco challenge, paving way for standardised cigarette packaging in the UK

http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/eu-dismisses-big-tobacco-challenge-paving-way-standardised-cigarette-packaging-uk-1558188

A claim made by big tobacco companies against plans to standardise tobacco packaging in the UK has been dismissed by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) on Wednesday (4 May). The ECJ clarified that EU member states can introduce further requirements on the packaging of tobacco products.

A prohibition of “any element or feature that is such as to promote a tobacco product or encourage its consumption” on tobacco packaging is considered protecting consumers from the risks of tobacco consumption “even if these are factually accurate”, said the court’s ruling.

The ruling means that standardised packaging for cigarettes should come in from 20 May, though another challenge in the High Court, due to be ruled on on 18 May, may halt the plans or lead to further delay if there is an appeal from the tobacco industry.

In 2015 parliament passed laws on standardised tobacco packaging in the UK − originally slated for 20 May. However, with or without legal delays, the new packaging may not be seen until old stocks are sold out. The packaging will likely simply show the brand name and product variant.

The ECJ ruling also upheld rules banning advertising by e-cigarette companies. The Independent British Vape Trade Association struck out immediately, claiming that the regulations could force e-cigarette users back to smoking regular tobacco products:

“The Tobacco Products Directive will have a significant impact on our sector as higher strength e-liquids and larger tanks are removed from the market, almost all advertising is banned, manufacturers and importers have to comply with a costly and bureaucratic notification process, and free trade across the EU is hampered. At the very least, this will force some vapers back to smoking and cause a number of smaller businesses to close.”

The new EU directive on tobacco products is valid

Download (PDF, 171KB)

Australia hails plain packaging on tobacco

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/6248cfee-11e3-11e6-91da-096d89bd2173.html

When Australia introduced plain packaging for tobacco products in December 2012, the industry funded an advertising campaign warning that smuggling would shoot up, retailers would go broke and the government would have to pay out millions in damages.

A little more three years later, and on the eve of the introduction in the UK of non-branded packs carrying prominent health warnings, Australia says the plain packaging experiment is working well.

“The measure has begun to achieve its public health objectives of reducing smoking and exposure to tobacco smoke in Australia and it is expected to continue to do so into the future,” concluded the government’s post-implementation report published in February.

The review said plain packaging and the enlarging of graphic health warnings on packs resulted in a “statistically significant” decline in smoking prevalence of 0.55 percentage points.

It accounted for a quarter of the 2.2-point decline in average smoking rates among Australians from 19.4 per cent to 17.2 per cent between the 34 months before plain packaging’s introduction and the 34 months afterwards.

“This reduction alone would result in at least 118,000 fewer smokers,” said Mike Daube, professor of health policy at Curtin University. But plain packaging was never seen as a magic bullet to stop people smoking, he added. Rather it was intended to deter young people from taking it up in the first place.

The report cited several studies that claim plain packaging is having a positive impact — reducing the appeal of tobacco products and the potential for packaging to mislead people, and enhancing the effectiveness of the health warnings.

It also references a big drop in consumption of tobacco products, down more than 20 per cent between the end of December 2012 and December 2015, while acknowledging limitations in the data and the short time that has passed since plain packaging has been in force.

The big tobacco companies and lobbyists dispute the findings of the government’s review, saying the evidence suggests smoking prevalence rates have not deviated from a historical downward trend.

Big tobacco has commissioned research that contradicts the findings of the review and is funding the Dominican Republic’s legal challenge to plain packaging at the World Trade Organisation. This challenge says the plain packaging measures “do not and will not change smoking behaviour in Australia”.

British American Tobacco said: “Australia remains the only country to date to have introduced plain packaging — and despite three years’ worth of data, is still no closer to demonstrating that plain packaging works to reduce smoking levels.

“Governments are ignoring the evidence that it does not work to reduce smoking levels — and this is why we are challenging the policy in the UK in the High Court of England and Wales.”

Plain packaging in the UK is due to come into effect on May 20, with the High Court set to rule on the legal challenge two days earlier.

The UK, France and Ireland have passed legislation to introduce plain packaging on May 20.

Dr Tasneem Chipty, who wrote the report, said smoking had indeed been falling in Australia for some time but added that the decline she had measured took this into account and was “beyond historical trend”.

“Suggestions . . . that the observed decline in smoking prevalence would have happened anyway, in the absence of plain packaging, are simply false,” she said.

So far the tobacco industry has lost challenges to Australia’s plain packaging law in the courts.

The last big hurdle for the law is the WTO, which is hearing complaints from Indonesia, the Dominican Republic, Honduras and Cuba. Those countries claim plain packaging violates WTO agreements by creating an unnecessary barrier to trade and by impeding the use of trademarks.

Tobacco companies also argue there is no evidence to suggest a link between the appeal of packs and smoking rates. They attribute any fall-off in tobacco consumption in Australia since December 2012 to increases in excise duty and other health education policies.

They also cite a KPMG study funded by the tobacco industry showing the consumption of illicit tobacco in Australia has risen to 14 per cent of the overall market from 11.5 per cent in 2012.

Proponents of the policy reject these arguments, saying big tobacco has spent tens of millions of dollars lobbying against the measure is because it poses such a threat to their profits.

“Right from the beginning, plain packaging was the component of our anti-tobacco policies that the industry screamed the loudest about,” says Nicola Roxon, the former Labor party health minister who steered plain packaging legislation through the Australian parliament.

“It is no surprise that its effectiveness and the fact it is spreading around the world has them so worried.”

Ireland, France and New Zealand are among several countries committed to following Australia and the UK in introducing plain packaging.

Mr Daube says the industry is merely repeating the claims it made in Australia in its campaigns against plain packaging in the UK and elsewhere. “These arguments failed in Australia and they should not be allowed to become zombie arguments — killed off in one country only to be brought back to life in others,” he says.

“Plain packaging is the tobacco industry’s worst nightmare as it takes away their last marketing opportunity.”

European Court judgement clears way for plain packaging of tobacco in Ireland

Big Tobacco arguments rejected by CJEU

https://www.cancer.ie/about-us/news/european-court-judgement-clears-way-plain-packaging-tobacco-ireland#sthash.TTszgZlV.dpbs

The Irish Cancer Society has today welcomed a Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgement that has stopped attempts by the tobacco industry to block the introduction of plain packaging of tobacco in Ireland in 2016.

The CJEU judgement upholds the rights of EU member states to introduce standardised packaging of tobacco products, where it is justified on grounds of public health.

The Court considered that that prohibition protects consumers “against the risks associated with tobacco use”.

The Irish Cancer Society says that this is a defeat for the tobacco industry who knows plain packaging works.

Donal Buggy, Head of Services and Advocacy at the Irish Cancer Society said: “Plain packaging of tobacco will save lives. The rejection of the tobacco industry’s case against the tobacco products directive (TPD) highlights the fatuous nature of their arguments and their fear that plain packaging will eat into profits.”

“Big tobacco knows that plain packaging, as a health measure, works, and are doing everything to prevent its introduction because they need to recruit 50 new smokers every day in Ireland to replace those dying and quitting.”

The CJEU found that the standardisation of labelling and packaging is a ‘proportionate’ measure and that EU legislature allowing for its introduction from May 20 is “appropriate and necessary”. The judgement clears the way for the introduction of plain packaging here in Ireland this summer.

Mr. Buggy said: “Today’s ruling represents the overcoming of another legal hurdle to the introduction of plain packaging in Ireland. What remains to be done now is the passing of minor technical amendments to legislation here so that plain packaging can be introduced in the very near future.”

The formation of a Government will, according to Mr. Buggy, “hopefully see the speedy progression of this legislation through the Oireachtas very shortly”.

The Irish Cancer Society warned however, that this will not be the last legal challenge to plain packaging either in Ireland or at EU level.

Mr. Buggy said: “The tobacco industry has deep pockets and will continue to fight these life-saving measures. Australia, the first country to introduce the measure, is still battling spurious cases from the industry four years on.”

Figures from the Australian Government show that since the introduction of plain packaging the number of people smoking has dropped to historically low numbers. Daily smoking rates have fallen from 15.1% in 2010 to 12.8% in 2013 – compared to 19% in Ireland. And among 12-17 year olds, only 5% smoke in comparison to 8% here.

“The louder Big Tobacco shout about this, the more we know it works.”

Mr. Buggy commended the efforts of the European Commission and Irish Government in “remaining steadfast in the face of enormous and costly legal pressure by the industry”.

“5,870 people die from tobacco related disease every year. The challenge now is to commit to public health, to commit to plain packaging and to reject the actions of a tobacco industry in crisis.”

Mr. Buggy said: “This is another big step towards achieving the goal of a tobacco-free Ireland by 2025”.

The Department of Health have committed to a Tobacco Free Ireland by 2025 – which means an overall smoking rate of less than 5%.

Today’s CJEU judgement also dismissed actions against the prohibition of menthol cigarettes and special rules concerning warnings, content and advertising of e-cigarettes.

– See more at: https://www.cancer.ie/about-us/news/european-court-judgement-clears-way-plain-packaging-tobacco-ireland#sthash.TTszgZlV.dpuf

Australia To Charge Cigarette Smokers A$45 Per Pack By 2020

http://www.inquisitr.com/3058181/australia-to-charge-cigarette-smokers-45-per-pack-by-2020/

Australian cigarette smokers will pay over $45 per pack (about $33.86 in US Dollars) by 2020, in a move the Australian government hopes will cut back on smoking Down Under, as well as raise $4.7 billion in tax revenue.

As The Guardian reports, Australia intends to raise the cigarette tax incrementally, 12.5 percent each year beginning in 2017 and ending in 2020. Some of the additional revenues raised by the tax will go to fight smuggling of cigarettes into the country, which the government believes will increase due to the high taxes.

The Australian cigarette tax increase comes as the nation undergoes an aggressive, decades-long nationwide anti-smoking campaign. Backers of the high cigarette taxes say the high tax rates along with other measures taken by the government, have cut cigarette smoking rates in Australia from 25 percent of the population in 1993 to less than 15 percent in 2013.

In addition to high cigarette taxes, the Australian government also tightly regulates cigarette packaging, according to a November 2011 Guardian report. Smokes are sold in plain, olive-green boxes – determined to be the least-appealing color – and the manufacturer and brand names are only allowed in small print. Much of the space on the boxes is given over to government-mandated warnings containing disgusting and disturbing photographs intended to deter smokers.

“If this legislation stops one young Australian from picking up a shiny, coloured packet and prevents them becoming addicted to cigarettes then in my view it will have been worthwhile.”

Meanwhile, Scott McIntyre, spokesman for British American Tobacco Australia, said that the Australian government is taking property – that is, valuable space on the packaging – from tobacco manufacturers.

“The government can’t take away valuable property from a legal company without compensation.We’re a legal company with legal products selling to adults who know the risks of smoking. We’re taking this to the high court because we believe the removal of our valuable intellectual property is unconstitutional.”

Australia’s strict cigarette-packaging laws are the subject of an international lawsuit, and some of the money raised from the increased taxes will be set aside to fight that lawsuit.

Worldwide, the World Health Organization (WHO) is calling on governments to aggressively fight tobacco use, through bans on tobacco ads, graphic warnings on packaging, strong efforts at fighting cigarette smuggling, and high taxes on cigarettes.

“The tobacco epidemic is one of the biggest public health threats the world has ever faced, killing around 6 million people a year. More than 5 million of those deaths are the result of direct tobacco use while more than 600 000 are the result of non-smokers being exposed to second-hand smoke.”

In the United States, the price of a pack of smokes varies widely from state to state, as each state adds their own unique taxes. The most expensive place to be a smoker in the US, according to International Business Times, is New York City. Thanks to a state excise tax of $4.35 per pack, and a city excise tax of $1.60 per pack, a pack of smokes in the Big Apple costs over $14.

The cheapest place to be a smoker in the US is Kentucky. With a total tax bil of only $.60, a pack of smokes in The Bluegrass State costs about a third of what a New Yorker pays – around $4.96 per pack.

PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 17

Regarding Redaction of Confidential Information in the Award on Jurisdiction and Admissibility

Download (PDF, 41KB)

SEATCA Tobacco Packaging and Labelling Index

Download (PDF, 6.52MB)

How might Big Tobacco react to a rise in cigarette excise?

http://theconversation.com/how-might-big-tobacco-react-to-a-rise-in-cigarette-excise-57895

There now appears to be bipartisan recognition in Australia of the political stench of cigarettes. Labor governments have taken a dim view of smoking for at least a decade, but now even the Liberal Party is joining the attack.

As the campaign donations from the tobacco industry dry up, the Turnbull government has set its sights on a product that, thanks to its unfortunate tendency to kill off its natural constituency, makes for an obvious target. The government is expected to announce a rise in tobacco excise in the coming federal budget.

The current taxation debate is just a small part of a much wider effort to curb smoking rates. And with every successful legislative change in Australia, other nations are increasingly emboldened to take on an industry once considered too politically powerful and dangerous.

Australia’s plain-packaging laws are already viewed as a model for Ireland, the UK and France. Its taxes – among the highest in the world – have routinely been shown to cut smoking rates to historic lows. Its citizens now overwhelmingly accept bans on passive smoking.

Still, Big Tobacco will never give up its fight against regulation and taxes. It knows that for every day it delays change, it saves millions in profits. As such, it relies on tactics of deceit, delay and frustration, which it has developed and refined over half a century.

But it also knows that it can’t make its argument directly. Instead, it relies on rhetorically gifted proxies. To that end, Big Tobacco has collaborated with a global web of friendly lobby groups, researchers and free-market think-tanks, such as the Institute of Public Affairs (IPA). Each proxy is expected to push an agenda, such as suggesting that research on tobacco smoke is “junk science” and critics of tobacco are “biased”.

Once the research has been completed, there are always media outlets willing to dutifully repeat the industry’s claims, which are used to build a narrative of the “nanny” state repeatedly kicking the mature and informed smoker.

Capitalism and freedom – for smokers

In the West, the freedom-of-choice argument has been at the heart of most of Big Tobacco’s campaigns since the 1970s. It’s a powerful idea, but it deliberately ignores the issue of child and passive smoking.

As such, Big Tobacco primarily relies on the argument that the state is trampling on personal liberty. When plain-packaging laws were being debated in Australia in 2010 – the first such laws in the world – the industry and its allies leapt into action.

The resultant advertising campaign was designed to portray the government and anti-smoking campaigners as part of a “nanny state” that was determined to tell adults how to live their lives.

An anti-plain-packaging advertisement.

(Stuck in) Nineteen Eighty-Four

The liberty argument may be a legitimate point of debate. But Big Tobacco also contended that plain-packaging laws would fail to deter people from smoking.

The IPA pointed out the tremendous monetary value of packaging, and Australia’s vulnerability to legal challenges that would cost billions of taxpayer dollars.

But, later, a senior IPA member released a study that showed spending on tobacco products had – controlling for other factors – increased following the plain-packaging laws’ passage.

Writers in the Murdoch press reported both stories, unaware of their contradictory nature.

Media Watch on how the plain-packaging studies were reported.

(Big Tobacco’s) crime and punishment

Another line of attack suggests that high taxes on cigarettes cause crime.

In 2015, the tobacco industry commissioned KPMG to study the effects of cigarette taxes on smuggling and black market sales. Unsurprisingly, the report said exactly what the tobacco industry wanted it to – going so far as to suggest that one in seven cigarettes smoked in Australia were smuggled.

As with all industry-funded “research”, government critics were keen to regurgitate the findings.

This is a distraction tactic. It is true that very high taxes, or a prohibition, will create a black market. It is also beside the point of plain packaging – which is to reduce smoking, while allowing for some free choice, provided it is informed and adult. Such laws have proved successful to that end.

The tobacco industry, insisting that we look anywhere but at them, wants to repaint a health issue as a law-enforcement one.

However, the tobacco industry is deeply hypocritical on smuggling. It systematically floods key foreign markets with its product, in turn facilitating smuggling in Western markets. The tactic allows it to claim plain-packaging laws and taxes cause the same crime it creates.

The heart of darkness

Big Tobacco fights in this way because of what it stands to lose.

So, the industry of death continues to exact its toll. It knew that people died from smoking and passive inhalation decades before it conceded the point. It knew of children taking up smoking – it even helped them do so. It complains of smuggling while being the biggest source of the problem.

Big Tobacco does these things because it is afraid. Imagine the profits lost should other countries adopt similar messages. Tens of billions every year are at stake.

In the tobacco wars, the strategic importance of Australia is critical. Big Tobacco will go to extraordinary lengths to ensure moves to quell smoking fail.

Effects of plain package branding and graphic health warnings on adolescent smokers in the USA, Spain and France

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2016/04/18/tobaccocontrol-2015-052583.short?g=w_tobaccocontrol_ahead_tab

Abstract

Objective

The purpose of this study is to provide an experimental test of the effects of plain pack branding and graphic health warnings (GHWs) in three different countries for an important and vulnerable population, that is, adolescents who are experimenting with smoking.

Methods

The effects of plain pack branding (logo present, logo absent), and graphic visual warning level (absent, low, medium, high) are studied experimentally for their impact on adolescent cigarette craving, evoked fear, pack feelings and thoughts of quitting in the USA, Spain and France. A total of 1066 adolescents who were experimenting with smoking served as participants in the study. A quota sample produced 375 respondents in the USA, 337 in Spain and 354 in France.

Results

Overall findings indicate that the GHWs were effective in impacting adolescent cigarette craving, evoked fear, pack feelings and thoughts of quitting. The plain pack effects were not as strong, yet reduced craving, increased fear, and decreased pack feelings for all three samples combined, and for US adolescent smokers individually, irrespective of the GHWs. For French adolescent smokers, plain pack effects for craving were limited to low/moderate GHW levels. For Spanish adolescent smokers, plain pack feeling effects were limited to the absence of the GHWs.

Conclusions

The results show that plain packs can independently strengthen the more instantaneous, direct effects (short of quitting thoughts) found with the GHWs. Yet, the plain pack results were attenuated for Spanish and French adolescent smokers, who are currently exposed to GHWs.

New Zealand study: Dissuasive cigarette sticks – the next step in standardised (‘plain’) packaging?

http://blogs.bmj.com/tc/2016/04/01/new-zealand-study-dissuasive-cigarette-sticks-the-next-step-in-standardised-plain-packaging/?q=w_tc_blog_sidetab

A study published by Tobacco Control in December 2015 by a team of New Zealand and Australian researchers explored extending the concept of plain packaging one step further – to the cigarette stick itself. New Zealand is moving towards introducing plain packaging; incorporating dissuasive cigarette sticks would put it at the forefront of innovative tobacco control measures.

The study authors explain more in a blog published by Aspire 2025 and reproduced here with permission:

As New Zealand moves towards legislating for plain packaging of cigarettes, the Government should consider measures that extend and improve upon Australia’s model, ASPIRE2025 researchers believe.

In this study, based on an online survey of 313 New Zealand smokers, our researchers and colleagues in Australia have found that cigarette sticks with printed health warnings or unattractive colours could enhance the effects of plain packaging and further reduce the appeal smoking has to young people.

Professor Janet Hoek says the team tested reactions to images of four cigarette sticks that either featured printed warnings or had unattractive colours, such as yellow-brown and green.

“We found that smokers were significantly less likely to choose the test sticks and found all significantly less appealing than the status quo — a white cigarette with a brown filter tip,” she says.

A “minutes of life lost” graphic that went from one minute near the tip up to 15 near the butt had the strongest aversive effect relative to the other sticks tested.

“Requiring cigarette sticks and rolling paper to feature such a graphic, or to be produced in dissuasive colours, would likely increase the impact plain packaging will have on those who smoke, while also deterring others from taking up smoking,” Professor Hoek says.

View a short video about this research here:

Study abstract:

Background

Standardised (or ‘plain’) packaging has reduced the appeal of smoking by removing imagery that smokers use to affiliate themselves with the brand they smoke. We examined whether changing the appearance of cigarette sticks could further denormalise smoking and enhance the negative impact of standardised packaging.

Methods

We conducted an online study of 313 New Zealand smokers who comprised a Best–Worst Choice experiment and a rating task. The Best–Worst experiment used a 2×3×3×6 orthogonal design to test the following attributes: on-pack warning message, branding level, warning size and stick appearance.

Results

We identified three segments whose members’ choice patterns were strongly influenced by the stick design, warning theme and size, and warning theme, respectively. Each of the dissuasive sticks tested was less preferred and rated as less appealing than the most common stick in use; a ‘minutes of life lost’ stick was the most aversive of the stimuli tested.

Conclusions

Dissuasive sticks could enhance the effect of standardised packaging, particularly among older smokers who are often more heavily addicted and resistant to change.

Countries introducing standardised packaging legislation should take the opportunity to denormalise the appearance of cigarette sticks, in addition to removing external tobacco branding from packs and increasing the warning size.

Citation

Hoek, J., Gendall, P., Eckert, C., & Louviere, J. (2015). Dissuasive cigarette sticks: the next step in standardised (‘plain’) packaging?. Tobacco control, tobaccocontrol-2015. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2015-052533

For more information, contact:
Professor Janet Hoek
University of Otago
Email janet.hoek@otago.ac.nz