Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Statistics ‘do not bear out claims’ of major tobacco firms

http://www.thenational.scot/news/statistics-do-not-bear-out-claims-of-major-tobacco-firms.17559

‘BIZARRE’ claims that tougher tobacco laws will boost crime must be ignored to protect public health, an anti-smoking charity said yesterday.

ASH Scotland’s ‘Dodgy Cigs’ report shows the UK trade in black market cigarettes and tobacco has declined every year since 2000, despite the introduction of stronger regulations and the increasing price of over-the-counter packs.

The report is released as new standardised plain packaging and other tobacco regulations come into force.

Major tobacco firms have claimed such moves would boost the trade in smuggled and counterfeit goods.

However, ASH Scotland head Sheila Duffy called this claim bizarre, in light of current trends.

Considering the impact on the Scottish government’s 2034 smoke-free target, she said: “The tobacco industry has often predicted that public health measures will cause rises in illicit tobacco. But this stance looks increasingly bizarre as illicit tobacco continues to reduce while regulation and price increase.

“We need to be wise to these tactics, and support proven public health measures. Standardised packaging will help put tobacco out of sight, out of mind and out of fashion for the next generation, making smoking less attractive for our children. Although it will take many years to see the full effects of this policy, the evidence from Australia, where plain packs have been used since 2012, shows that they can help to protect children from starting smoking and could help adults to quit.

“These new laws won’t single-handedly solve the problem of tobacco addiction. But they are another step on the journey to a tobacco-free Scotland by 2034.”

Updated packaging rules come into force on May 20, requiring new cartons to feature drab colours and graphic health warnings.

By May 2017, all packs sold in the UK will be required to adhere to the regulations.

Tobacco industry delaying tactics criticised as new tobacco laws come into force

http://www.ashscotland.org.uk/media/news/2016/05/tobacco-industry-delaying-tactics-criticised-as-new-tobacco-laws-come-into-force/

As standardised “plain” packaging and other tobacco regulations come into force (20 May), health campaigning charity ASH Scotland has released a new report, Dodgy Cigs, detailing the way the tobacco industry has raised ill-founded concerns about illicit tobacco to oppose public health measures.

Big Tobacco has claimed in the past that new public health laws will cause rises in the market for illicit tobacco, such as smuggled tobacco and counterfeit cigarettes. This has been particularly prominent in Australia, the first country to introduce plain packaging. The tobacco industry claimed that the policy would cause rises in illicit tobacco use, but official figures in the years since implementation have not agreed.

In the UK, the illicit tobacco market has declined since the year 2000, despite new laws protecting people from tobacco and increases in the price of a pack of twenty cigarettes.

dodgycigs-fig-1_500x299

Figure 1 – HMRC’s estimate of the size of the illicit tobacco market in the UK, plotted alongside to the price of a pack of 20 cigarettes (in 2014 GBP). The illicit market has consistently fallen at a time when tobacco prices have increased.

Commenting on the release of Dodgy Cigs, ASH Scotland Chief Executive Sheila Duffy said:

“The tobacco industry has often predicted that public health measures will cause rises in illicit tobacco. But this stance looks increasingly bizarre as illicit continues to reduce while regulation and price increase.

“We need to be wise to these tactics, and support proven public health measures. Standardised packaging will help put tobacco out of sight, out of mind and out of fashion for the next generation, making smoking less attractive for our children. Although it will take many years to see the full effects of this policy, the evidence from Australia, where plain packs have been used since 2012, shows that they can help to protect children from starting smoking and could help adults to quit.

“These new laws won’t single-handedly solve the problem of tobacco addiction. But they are another step on the journey to a tobacco-free Scotland by 2034.”

Ends

Notes –

Dodgy Cigs isavailable from www.ashscotland.org.uk/dodgycigs. A two-page key points report is available at /media/547507/dodgy-cigs-key-points-nt.pdf.

For further information please contact ASH Scotland on 0131 225 4725 or enquiries@ashscotland.org.uk Out of hours mobile 07776 142 299

Standardised “plain” packaging

From 20 May, plain packs of cigarettes will start to appear in the shops. These packs (above) feature drab colours and graphic health warnings to show the real impact of smoking tobacco. By 20 May 2017, all tobacco sold in the UK will have to be in plain packs.

Plain packs have led to a significant drop in the smoking rate in Australia, and are a key component in putting tobacco out of sight, out of mind and out of fashion to meet the Scottish Government’s target of a smoke-free Scotland by 2034.

Plain packs are not blank, white packs,but instead feature drab colours and graphic health warnings about the dangers of smoking (see picture above). Print quality images are available – please contact enquiries@ashscotland.org.uk.

EU Tobacco Products Directive (TPD)

The TPD will make certain changes to all tobacco products sold in every country in the EU:

All products in the EU must have 65% of the front and back of their packaging covered by health warnings
No cigarettes will be able to use misleading descriptions like “light” or “natural”, which promote the false idea that some cigarettes are less harmful
Cigarette packs will contain a minimum of 20 sticks, with hand-rolling tobacco pouches containing at least 30g of tobacco
There will be new regulations on the sales of e-cigarettes containing nicotine, including:

Television and other “cross-border” advertising will no longer be permitted
Mandatory warning labels about the addictive nature of nicotine
All products must be registered with the UK Government by 20 May 2017

Tobacco Firms Lose Packet Legal Challenge

The European Court of Justice dismisses the final legal challenge to EU rules which aim to stop youngsters from starting smoking.

http://news.sky.com/story/tobacco-firms-lose-packet-legal-challenge-10268916

Europe’s highest court has rejected a legal challenge by tobacco firms against standardised packaging rules for cigarettes.

The ruling, at the European Court of Justice, essentially dismissed complaints that changes to EU laws went beyond what was necessary on health grounds.

It also paves the way for member states to impose further requirements such as plain packaging measures proposed in the UK, France and Ireland.

In addition, the ruling removes legal barriers to the banning of menthol cigarettes from 2020 and also electronic cigarette advertising.

The updated Tobacco Products Directive will take effect on 20 May though cigarette retailers will have a year to sell off their remaining stocks before the standardised packaging rules take effect.

They are designed to make the cartons less attractive to youngsters – with health warnings more prominent and covering 65% of a packet.

The EU hopes the move will cut smoking numbers by 2.4 million and prevent 700,000 premature deaths.

A separate legal challenge by tobacco firms against UK Government plans to remove all branding from cigarette packs is due to be heard on 18 May at the High Court and could be subject to appeal.

The packaging case against the EU was brought to by Philip Morris International, the maker of Marlboro, and the firm behind Rothmans and Benson & Hedges, British American Tobacco.

They argued that the bloc was abusing its authority.

But the ruling said: “The court finds that, in providing that each unit packet and the outside packaging must carry health warnings … the EU legislature did not go beyond the limits of what is appropriate and necessary”.

The Directive was due to be introduced in 2014 but was held up in the courts.

Deborah Arnott, chief executive of the anti-smoking charity Ash, welcomed the ruling.

She said: “We (now) await the UK court judgement, which is expected shortly, but we are optimistic that the court will confirm that the introduction of standardised packaging in the UK is lawful.

“From 20 May, all packs manufactured for sale in the UK will have to be plain, standardised, in the same drab green colour with the product name on the pack in a standard font”.

A spokesman for British American Tobacco said: “The reality is that many elements of the directive are disproportionate, distort competition and fail to respect the autonomy of member states.”

Studies are conclusive: plain packaging of tobacco works

An expert commentary on the global tobacco control treaty, the WHO FCTC

http://www.fctc.org/fca-news/opinion-pieces/1409-studies-show-that-plain-packaging-of-tobacco-works

Tobacco use kills nearly six million people every year worldwide, according to the World Health Organization.1 In response to this pandemic, WHO developed the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC), a comprehensive treaty with 180 Parties.2

The WHO FCTC provides various support tools for countries to develop effective tobacco control policies, such as high taxes on tobacco, advertising regulations and tobacco warnings.

The present article focuses on plain packaging of tobacco, proposed in Articles 11 and 13 of the FCTC, to eliminate the use of tobacco packaging as a marketing tool. Plain packaging means that the brand name is printed in a standardized font and typeface, and trademarks (including logos or any decorative elements) are prohibited. The pack must use unattractive colours and contain no text other than health warnings and information required by law (see photo).

3 more countries

Australia adopted plain packaging in 2012; Ireland, Great Britain and France will implement it in 2016; and New Zealand, Norway, Finland, Sweden, Turkey, and Canada are considering its implementation.

While plain packaging is increasingly gaining the support of governments, the tobacco industry has been lobbying hard to curb its development: actions include a lawsuit filed against Australia and the threat of legal proceedings for other countries planning to introduce it; the launch of anti-plain-pack campaigns and Internet sites, and scaremongering about a rise in counterfeiting and contraband. Such hostility begs the question of why the tobacco industry is so opposed to plain packaging if it claims that it is inefficient or useless.

“Clearly favourable”

An analysis of the research carried out since the early 1990s on the efficiency of plain packaging makes it easier to understand these hostile reactions: it has been proven that plain packs are clearly favourable for public health.

The first benefit is for adolescents: compared with the “branded” pack, the plain pack is less appealing and diminishes the incentive to start smoking. Plain packaging reduces the packet’s attractiveness and the positive image of the smoker, which ultimately diminishes the appeal of smoking. (Minors consider plain packs to be uglier, bland and boring).

Furthermore, the plain pack also has an impact on smokers. Australian smokers who were questioned following the introduction of the plain pack in 2012 said that they were more motived to stop smoking, had made more frequent attempts to stop smoking, and had put out an unfinished cigarette more often (compared to the period in which “branded” packs were used). They also made more telephone calls to the smoking cessation helpline (which experienced a 78 percent increase in calls during and after plain pack implementation) and had the impression that the cigarettes were of lower quality and did not taste as good.

Similar findings elsewhere

Similar findings have been highlighted in studies on perceptions of plain packaging conducted in other countries, including Great Britain, France and New Zealand.<

Plain packs also prevent consumer misinformation. The tobacco industry uses colour codes (light blue, white) to evoke the “mildness” of cigarettes and places reassuring text on the packaging (“100% tobacco”, “0 additives”, “organic”, etc.). This misleads individuals into thinking that harmful effects can differ according to the product, which in turn encourages them to carry on smoking certain brands of cigarettes instead of others. Plain packaging eliminates these false beliefs.

Another benefit of the plain pack is that it increases the impact of tobacco packaging health warning messages. On “branded” packages, these health messages are thwarted by marketing stimuli (logos, colour, images, etc.) that reduce their visibility, credibility and impact on the desire to stop smoking.

‘Denormalize’ smoking

Finally, the Australian experience shows that plain packs reduce the visibility of tobacco products and contribute to denormalizing smoking: given the ugliness of the packaging, smokers are less likely to take out their packet of cigarettes in front of family, children and friends.

To conclude, the numerous published studies on plain packs show that they are effective. Additionally, tobacco industry internal reports and documents have highlighted the importance that packaging and product play in increasing and maintaining market share:3 if tobacco companies no longer have control over their packaging, then they lose an essential means of communication, particularly in countries where advertising is prohibited or limited in the media. To defend this communication space, they have adopted the mantra that the plain pack is ineffective.

However, the Australian experience contradicts their arguments: when the country implemented plain packs, in combination with other measures (large warnings, a rise in the price of tobacco products), the number of smokers dropped and smoking by young people declined.4

– See more at: http://www.fctc.org/fca-news/opinion-pieces/1409-studies-show-that-plain-packaging-of-tobacco-works#sthash.q4m3Us89.dpuf

Canada: Plain Packaging For Tobacco Products

http://www.mondaq.com/canada/x/489914/food+drugs+law/John+McKeown+Publishes+Plain+Packaging+For+Tobacco+Products

Plain packaging for tobacco products may soon be implemented in Canada. Plain packaging in this context means that tobacco company brand elements consisting of colours, logo and design elements of the brand will not be allowed to be used on product packaging. However, there are potential conflicts between government and suppliers and manufactures of tobacco products. The issues are becoming increasingly politicized.

The Supporters

The World Health Organization is actively lobbying to support the implementation of plain packaging. They have prepared and posted on their website an evidence brief.1

An abstract of their position is set out below:

“Evidence shows that the packaging of tobacco products is designed for badge products targeting specific groups, particularly women and young people, and that attractive packaging tends to weaken warnings about the harmful health effects of the products. To preserve the effectiveness of the health warnings – a requirement under Articles 11 and 13 of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco – the guidelines on the implementation of these articles recommend the adoption of plain-packaging measures.

Studies have revealed that plain packaging reduces the attractiveness of the product, particularly to women and young people. They also show that, when combined with large pictorial health warnings, plain-packaging measures increase awareness about the risks related to tobacco consumption, encouraging more people to quit and fewer to start. In that these measures merely regulate the use of logos or colours for public health purposes, they are in compliance with international trade and intellectual property law.”

The Canadian Cancer Society is also highly energized concerning this issue and has caused a video to be prepared and posted on its website. They suggest that there is increasing global momentum to implement plain packaging for tobacco products,

“Plain packaging is an important and logical next step for Canada to curb tobacco marketing, reduce smoking and save lives,” says Rob Cunningham, Senior Policy Analyst, Canadian Cancer Society. “Cigarette packages should not be minibillboards promoting tobacco use. We urge Health Canada to follow the lead of Australia and other countries and take action to implement plain packaging in order to reduce the appeal of these cancer-causing products.”2

The Opposition

Tobacco companies have actively opposed and attacked plain packaging legislation. Philip Morris Asia challenged the Australian tobacco plain packaging legislation under the 1993 Agreement between the Government of Australia and the Government of Hong Kong for the Promotion and Protection of Investments. However the panel hearing the dispute, on 18 December 2015 issued a unanimous decision finding that it had no jurisdiction to hear Philip Morris Asia’s claim.

Honduras requested consultations under the World Trade system with Australia concerning the Australian laws and regulations that impose trademark restrictions and other plain packaging requirements on tobacco products and packaging. Honduras claims that Australia’s measures appear to be inconsistent with Australia’s obligations under the TRIPS Agreement, among other grounds.

A panel has been established to hear the dispute. Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, China, Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Ecuador, the European Union, Guatemala, India, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Malawi, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Norway, Oman, Panama, Peru, the Philippines, Singapore, South Africa, Chinese Taipei, Thailand, Turkey, Ukraine, the United States, Uruguay, Zambia and Zimbabwe have reserved their third-party rights. The panel expects to issue its final report to the parties not before the first half of 2016. Similar proceedings have been initiated by Ukraine, the Dominican Republic, Cuba and Indonesia.

The International Trademark Association (“INTA”) has submitted an amicus brief to the panel. INTA contends that the plain packaging measures implemented by Australia erode internationally protected IP rights under the Paris Convention, the Trans-Pacific Partnership (“TPP”) Agreement and other agreements.

In addition to the above tobacco companies can attack relevant legislation implementing plain packaging on the basis that such legislation does not comply with domestic legislation. For example in 1995, the Supreme Court of Canada struck down provisions of the Tobacco Products Control Act that broadly prohibited all advertising and promotion of tobacco products, subject to specific exceptions, and required that unattributed warning labels be affixed on tobacco product packaging, as contrary to Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The Government Position

In response to these proceedings a number of governments have commenced a campaign to preclude tobacco companies from initiating investor-state dispute settlement proceedings under the relevant treaties. For example, the recently concluded TPP contains the following provision:

“A party may elect to deny the benefits of Section B of Chapter 9 (Investment_ with respect to claims challenging a tobacco control measure of the Party. Such a claim shall not be submitted to arbitration under Section B of Chapter 9 (Investment) if a Party has made such an election. If a Party has not elected to deny benefits with respect to such claims by the time of the submission of such a claim to arbitration under Section B of Chapter 9 (Investment), a Party may elect to deny benefits during the proceedings. For greater certainty, if a Party elects to deny benefits with respect to such claims, any such claim shall be dismissed.”

The Canadian Position

The recently elected Liberal government has indicated that it plans to force tobacco companies to sell their cigarettes in packages that lack distinctive brand designs aimed at enticing smokers to buy their products. This was part of an election promise and has now been escalated to a part of the mandate of the Health Minister. This mandate seems to be a top priority for a majority government.

At the present time there is no indication how quickly the government will move, or when the necessary legislation or regulations will move forward.

1 http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0011/268796/Plain-packaging-of-tobaccoproducts-Evidence-Brief-Eng.pdf?ua=1
2 Media release dated October 4,2015 at https://www.cancer.ca/en/about-us/for-media/mediareleases/national/2014/international-warnings-report/?region=on

Lázár: Hungary eyes unified packaging for tobacco products, could ban menthol cigarettes

Following the European Court of Justice ruling on Wednesday that introducing standardized packages, prohibiting menthol cigarettes and applying special rules to e-cigarettes are all lawful practices, the Hungarian government will start drafting a bill on such measures next week, Hungary’s Cabinet Chief János Lázár said yesterday.

http://bbj.hu/business/lazar-hungary-eyes-unified-packaging-for-tobacco-products-could-ban-menthol-cigarettes_115719

During his regular weekly press conference, the cabinet chief said that under the planned legislation, menthol cigarettes will be banned in Hungary, and tobacco products could be sold only in unified packages in the country. Lázár added that special rules will apply to electronic cigarettes as well.

The Hungarian government was first said to be planning such changes in June 2015. Professionals working in the tobacco industry have criticized the measures, claiming they will not reduce the consumption of tobacco products.

UK’s policy on standardised tobacco packaging given EU backing

http://www.charitytoday.co.uk/uks-policy-on-standardised-tobacco-packaging-given-eu-backing/

Plans to introduce plain, standardised packaging for cigarettes in the UK have been given European backing.

The European Court of Justice ruled (link is external) that the EU Tobacco Products Directive is lawful and has overturned the tobacco industry’s challenge to it.

The court also confirmed that EU Member States can go further than the requirements set out in the Directive with regard to packaging.

This, essentially, allows countries to bring in standardised packaging. The directive, along with standardised packaging, will now enter into force on May 20.

George Butterworth, Cancer Research UK’s tobacco policy manager, said: “This court decision tells us what we knew all along – that the Tobacco Products Directive is an effective and proportional set of measures to stop children taking up smoking.

“This will help to lower smoking rates in the UK and protect more people from developing cancer.

“It’s truly shameful that the tobacco industry has poured so much time, effort and money trying to undermine it. UK laws can now continue as planned and from May 20 the rollout of plain, standardised packaging begins.”

The UK, France and Ireland have already passed legislation on standardised packaging.

This new ruling will give support to other member states who also wish to proceed with the measure.

The Court also dismissed other legal challenges claiming regulations on e-cigarettes were disproportionate and the ban on menthol flavouring was unjustified.

Deborah Arnott, Chief Executive of health charity ASH said the Court’s decision was “welcome”.

“The Directive is lawful and the UK is allowed to go further than the Directive in standardising tobacco packs with respect to matters not harmonised by the Directive,” she added.

“We await the UK court judgement, which is expected shortly, but we expect that the court will also confirm that the introduction of standardised packaging in the UK is lawful.

“From May 20, all packs manufactured for sale in the UK will have to be plain, standardised in the same drab green colour with the product name on the pack in a standard font.”

Tougher Rules On Electronic Cigarettes: European Court

http://www.ndtv.com/world-news/tougher-rules-on-electronic-cigarettes-european-court-1402713

Brussels: The European Union’s top court has approved new rules requiring plain cigarette packs, banning menthol cigarettes and regulating the growing electronic cigarette market.

Tobacco companies had protested a 2014 EU tobacco directive, calling it disproportionate. But the European Court of Justice today ruled the directive is in line with efforts to protect public health.

The court upheld a ban on menthol and other flavorings that make tobacco more appealing. The directive also requires standardized, plain labels that cover cigarette packs at least 65 percent with health warnings.

The rules will require warnings for e-cigarettes, limit their nicotine levels to 20 grams and restrict advertising and sponsorship by their makers.

The Independent British Vape Trade Association argued the ruling could push some e-cigarette smokers back to tobacco.

EU Court Upholds Tough Tobacco Law On Packaging, Flavors, E-Cigarettes

http://www.ibtimes.com/eu-court-upholds-tough-tobacco-law-packaging-flavors-e-cigarettes-2363884

Tobacco companies, led by Philip Morris International, lost an appeal in the European Union’s top court Wednesday against strict packaging rules for cigarettes. The Court of Justice for the European Union also dismissed appeals by Poland and Romania to the EU decision to ban flavored cigarettes, such as menthol.

In the matter of flavored cigarettes, the court reasoned that tobacco products with menthol or another “pleasant flavor” makes them “more attractive to consumers and that reducing the attractiveness of those products may contribute to reducing the prevalence of tobacco use and dependence among new and continuing users.”

In a statement on the official EU website, the court also said that the EU legislature was right in forming the law in 2014, which guards against divergences in different rules of various member states, especially when it came to health matters.

In a setback to tobacco companies, led by Philip Morris and British American Tobacco, the court also ruled in favor of EU regulations on cigarette packaging, which mandate a message and a color photograph — covering at least 65 percent of each packet’s front and back — warning of the dangers of smoking. The court said that “the EU legislature did not go beyond the limits of what is appropriate and necessary,” and added that individual countries could impose stricter rules, such as plain packaging without any branding.

The court also upheld new limits on e-cigarettes, despite manufacturers claiming they should be dealt with under a different law because e-cigarettes were not actually tobacco products. A limit on maximum nicotine content, of 20 mg/ml, was declared valid, along with requirements of specific warnings and leaflets, and a prohibition on advertising.

“The identified and potential risks linked to the use of electronic cigarettes have led the EU legislature to act in a manner consistent with the requirements stemming from the precautionary principle,” the court said.

The ruling by the Court of Justice for the European Union cannot be appealed.

EU’s highest court upholds new restrictive law on cigarettes

http://english.vietnamnet.vn/fms/world-news/155936/eu-s-highest-court-upholds-new-restrictive-law-on-cigarettes.html

Europe’s highest court on Wednesday upheld a tough EU law on standardizing cigarette packaging and banning advertising of e-cigarettes, paving the way for its adoption later this month.

The court rejected a legal challenge brought by Philip Morris International and British American Tobacco, with Japan Tobacco International and Imperial Brands acting as interested parties.

“The court finds that, in providing that each unit packet and the outside packaging must carry health warnings…. the EU legislature did not go beyond the limits of what is appropriate and necessary,” the court said.