Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Plain Packaging

Tobacco giants to appeal High Court dismissal of plain packaging challenge

https://www.thelawyer.com/issues/online-may-2016/tobacco-giants-to-appeal-high-court-dismissal-of-plain-packaging-challenge/

British American Tobacco (BAT) will seek leave to appeal a decision by the High Court rejecting its attempt to overturn UK legislation introducing plain packaging for tobacco products.

The ruling, handed down on Thursday (19 May), dismissed the judicial review brought by BAT and other global tobacco giants.

Plain packaging laws, which BAT said breached its intellectual property rights, will come into force on 20 May.

BAT revealed following the ruling it will seek leave to appeal the decision through its lawyers, Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF). JT International and Imperial Tobacco confirmed they will join BAT in the appeal, but Philip Morris – one of the lead claimants on the initial action – said it would not.

The judicial review brought by the four tobacco companies was dismissed on Thursday (19 May) in a 400-page ruling by Mr Justice Green.

Green J upheld the lawfulness of the new regulations and rejected the grounds of challenge in their entirety. He said the regulations were “proportionate”, both when they were first drafted by Parliament and in light of recent evidence following similar legislation in Australia.

The tobacco giants had sought to challenge the law on the grounds it was unlawful under international law, EU law and domestic common law.

Earlier this month the EU’s highest court similarly upheld a law that will standardise packaging and ban the advertising of e-cigarettes. Philip Morris and BAT challenged the proposed legislation and said the EU was overstepping its authority to direct laws in member states.

Ashurst, Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, HSF and Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom were instructed to bring the legal challenges in the UK. Leigh Day also appeared during the court proceedings last December for the intervener, Action on Smoking and Health.

In a statement, BAT said: “This decision by the English High Court is by no means the final word on the lawfulness of plain packaging. We believe that the judgment contains a number of fundamental errors of law and we are applying for leave to appeal the decision.

“The judgment, if left to stand, should also raise real concerns for many other legitimate businesses as it creates a worrying precedent whereby public policy concerns can ride roughshod over long established fundamental commercial rights.”

The legal line-up:$$$

For the first claimants, British American Tobacco

39 Essex’s Nigel Pleming QC, One Essex Court’s Geoffrey Hobbs QC and Philip Roberts and Brick Court Chambers’ David Scannell, instructed by Herbert Smith Freehills partner Andrew Lidbetter

For the second claimants, Philip Morris

Brick Court’s Marie Demetriou QC and Daniel Piccinin, instructed by Skadden partner Karyl Nairn QC

For the third claimants, JT International

Brick Court’s David Anderson QC and Jennifer MacLeod, and One Essex Court’s Emma Himsworth QC, instructed by Freshfields partner Tom Snelling

For the fourth claimants, Imperial Tobacco Ltd

Blackstone Chambers’ Dinah Rose QC, Brian Kennelly QC and Jason Pobjoy, and 8 New Square’s Lindsay Lane and Maxwell Keay, instructed by Ashurst

For the defendant, the Secretary of State for Health

Blackstone Chambers’ James Eadie QC and Catherine Callaghan, 8 New Square’s Martin Howe QC, Monckton Chambers’ Ian Rogers QC, Julianne Kerr Morrison and Nikolaus Grubeck, and 8 New Square’s Jaani Riordan, instructed by the Government Legal Department

For the intervener, Action on Smoking and Health

Monckton Chambers’ Peter Oliver and Ligia Osepciu, instructed by Leigh Day

700,000 deaths a year: tackling smoking in the EU

http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/news-room/20160518STO27901/700000-deaths-a-year-tackling-smoking-in-the-EU

tobacco-lung-story

More than one in four Europeans smoke. Half of them will die prematurely, shortening their life by 14 years on average. From 20 May new European legislation will be in place to make smoking and cigarettes less attractive, especially among young people. Read on to find out what will change and check out our infographic about smokers in the EU.

What is changing

The new directive, which enters in force in all EU countries on Friday 20 May, sets more stringent rules regarding tobacco and related products.

Some of the new rules aim to make smoking less attractive for young people by banning cigarettes and rolling tobacco with charactering flavours, as well as small and cheaper packages for certain tobacco products.

Health warnings – including both picture and text – need to cover 65% of the front and the back of cigarette and roll-your-own tobacco packages, while all promotional and misleading elements on tobacco products are banned.

Manufacturers are obliged to notify novel tobacco products before placing them on the EU market, while they are also required to submit detailed reports to EU countries on the ingredients used in tobacco products, in particular cigarettes and roll-your-own tobacco.

In addition EU countries are allowed to prohibit internet sales of tobacco and related products and e-cigarettes are regulated either as medicinal products – if they are used to help people quit smoking – or as tobacco products.

End of gimmick tobacco products

Tobacco companies tried to prevent the new rules entering into force, but the European Court of Justice ruled against them.

UK S&D member Linda McAvan, who was responsible for steering the new rules through Parliament, welcomed the legislation entering into force this week: “People across the whole of the EU will see tobacco packs change from now on as gimmick tobacco products disappear from the market and tobacco packs carry more health warnings than adverts. These new clear rules, together with other national measures such as bans on smoking in public places, should help stop the tobacco industry from recruiting a new generation of young smokers in Europe. And now that the big tobacco companies lost their case in the European Court of Justice, those member states who have still not fully transposed the directive need to get on and do it.”

The lethal habit

Tobacco consumption is responsible for nearly 700,000 deaths in the EU every year. Smokers suffer more from poor health (as they are more at risk of cancer, cardiovascular and respiratory diseases) and half of them die prematurely (14 years on average).

New standardised tobacco packaging laws welcomed in Cumbria

http://www.cumbriacrack.com/2016/05/18/new-standardised-tobacco-packaging-laws-welcomed-cumbria/

Public health experts at Cumbria County Council have welcomed laws that will come into force from 20 May 2016, which mean cigarettes made for sale in the UK will have to be sold in drab green packaging with dramatic visual health warnings.

Standardised packaging

Standardised packaging, also known as plain packaging, refers to packaging that has had the attractive promotional branding removed. In March 2015 MPs voted for standardised tobacco packaging regulations which will be implemented from 20 May 2016 across the UK. The new packs are required under the Standardised Packaging Regulations, secondary legislation under the Children and Families Act 2014.

This means that the appearance of all cigarettes and hand rolling packs will be standardised, including:

The material, size, shape and opening mechanism of packaging;
The colour of packaging and cigarettes;
The font, colour, size, case and alignment of text.
Transitional period

Whilst all cigarettes and hand rolling tobacco products manufactured for sale in the UK must comply with these regulations from 20 May 2016, there is a one year transitional period for the sell-through of old stock. From 21 May 2017 all tobacco products on sale in the UK must comply with these regulations.

Local trading standards officers will be responsible for ensuring compliance with the law.

Cllr Ian Stewart, the county council’s Cabinet member for Public Health, said: “We’ve long had concerns that cigarette packs can be attractive and misleading, especially to children. These new laws are a vital step forward in ensuring future generations are protected from the dangers of smoking.”

Colin Cox, Cumbria County Council’s Director of Public Health, said: “This is a proud moment for public health in the fight to reduce smoking prevalence. Many of us have worked on this for a number of years.

“The percentage of young people smoking in Cumbria has steadily and dramatically decreased since 2003, which is a trend that we are delighted about. These new laws can only help contribute to this decline and ultimately cut the risks associated with smoking, saving more lives.”

Australia versus Philip Morris. How we took on big tobacco and won

http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/australia-versus-philip-morris-how-we-took-on-big-tobacco-and-won-20160517-gowwva.html

Previously sealed documents reveal the tobacco giant Philip Morris lost its case against Australia over plain packaging because the international tribunal considered it an “abuse of rights”.

Philip Morris sued Australia under the provisions of an obscure Hong Kong Australia investment treaty in 2012 after British American Tobacco and Japan Tobacco lost a challenge to the plain packaging legislation in the High Court.

As had its competitors in the failed High Court challenge, the manufacturer of Marlboro and Longbeach cigarettes argued Australia had confiscated its trade marks, turning from “a manufacturer of branded products to a manufacturer of commoditised products”.

Philip Morris wanted the tribunal to order Australia to withdraw the law or to award damages of at least $US4.2 billion plus compound interest at the Australian bank cash management rate dating back to the to the law’s introduction.

Its use of an outside tribunal rather than an Australian court to sue the government was unusual, in that it was making use of a provision available to foreign companies under trade agreements but denied to Australian companies.

The government spent more than $50 million defending the case, assembling a team including two Queens Counsels and two Senior Counsels and ferrying to Singapore witnesses including the former treasurer Wayne Swan and former judge Roger Gyles QC.

The 186-page judgement, unsealed on Tuesday, shows the tribunal rejected the claim at the first hurdle, finding Philip Morris had moved its Australian and Asian headquarters to Hong Kong for the express purpose of making the claim.

“The tribunal cannot but conclude that the initiation of this arbitration constitutes an abuse of rights, as the corporate restructuring by which the claimant acquired the Australian subsidiaries occurred at a time when there was a reasonable prospect that the dispute would materialise and as it was carried out for the principal, if not sole, purpose of gaining treaty protection,” the judgement finds.

A spokesman for assistant health minister Fiona Nash said she welcomed the decision which validated the government’s decision to take on Philip Morris.

Originally rare, the use of so-called investor-state dispute settlement provisions in international treaties has ballooned in the past decade. Australia’s Productivity Commission counted 42 in 2014.

Productivity Commission count of iinvestor-state dispute settlement cases

Productivity Commission count of iinvestor-state dispute settlement cases

Investor-state dispute settlement provisions have been included in Australia’s recently-signed treaties with Korea and China and the 12-nation Trans-Pacific Partnership which has been signed but not yet ratified by the Australian parliament.

La Trobe University public health academic Deborah Gleeson said the victory would add to momentum for the spread of plain packaging legislation around the world, but she said it didn’t mean that investor-state dispute settlement provisions weren’t a threat to public health.

“If we ratify the Trans-Pacific Partnership transnational corporations based in the United States will gain an avenue to sue Australia. There’s an exclusion for tobacco control measures, but no solid exclusion for other health measures.”

Australia continues to face challenges to its plain packaging laws in the World Trade Organisation from tobacco-growing nations including Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Honduras and Indonesia. The Ukraine withdrew its challenge last year.

Court condemns tobacco giant Philip Morris over secret bid to sue Australia

Tribunal rejected the move to challenge plain packaging laws, calling it an ‘abuse of rights’

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/may/17/court-condemns-tobacco-giant-philip-morris-over-secret-bid-to-sue-australia

An international tribunal has unveiled a secret ruling confirming it rejected a bid by tobacco giant Philip Morris to sue Australia over its plain packaging laws, calling the attempt “an abuse of rights”.

In its heavily redacted 186-page ruling dating from 17 December 2015, the permanent court of arbitration said it had no jurisdiction over the case brought by Philip Morris.

In 2012 Australia became the first country to mandate that cigarettes must be sold in plain packages, in an attempt to reduce smoking rates. This initiative has since been followed by other nations including France and Britain.

But big tobacco firms including Philip Morris have launched legal challenges against such laws, arguing the rules impinge on their trademark intellectual property.

Philip Morris, manufacturers of some of the world’s most recognisable brands, including Marlboro, lodged the challenge with the arbitration court based in The Hague in 2011 after the plain-packaging legislation was passed, using a 1993 trade deal between Australia and Hong Kong that included foreign investment protections.

But the permanent court of arbitration found in its unanimous ruling that “the main and determinative, if not sole, reason” for a restructuring of the company as far back as 2005 was to enable it “to bring a claim under the treaty, using an entity from Hong Kong” after it received ample warnings that such legislation was being considered.

“The record indeed shows that the principal, if not sole, purpose of the restructuring was to gain protection under the treaty in respect of the very measures that form the subject matter of the present arbitration,” the court ruled.

It added: “The tribunal cannot but conclude that the initiation of this arbitration constitutes an abuse of rights.”

The court therefore found that Philip Morris’s claims were “inadmissible” and it was “precluded from exercising jurisdiction over this dispute”.

The ruling came after a closed-door hearing held in Singapore in February 2015.

Canberra had welcomed the decision saying “plain packaging is a legitimate public health measure”.

Tobacco plain packaging bites as Parkside announces redundancies

http://www.packagingnews.co.uk/news/markets/food/tobacco-plain-packaging-bites-as-parkside-announces-redundancies-17-05-2016

Parkside Flexibles Europe is set to make redundancies following the closure of a major tobacco packaging customer in May.

With the implementation of plain packaging legislation in the UK to be phased in from 20 May, and the general decline of tobacco sales in Europe, Parkside is reducing its staff levels at its headquarters in Normanton, West Yorkshire.

The firm’s managing director Nick Smith confirmed the impact of the market changes and customer closures has prompted the decision.

“It is with deep regret that we have commenced the consultation process with the Parkside workforce today and we are proposing a number of roles will be made redundant as a result of the reduction in tobacco related work.”

He said the company has been working hard over the past two years to reshape its business in response to this predicted market situation and diversify into a broad range of higher growth speciality packaging markets.

“We have invested in our APEX innovation strategy to meet brand and retailer needs and despite securing a number of new significant contracts, as well as volumes with alternative tobacco brands, the impact is simply too large for us to continue at current staff levels. Our Asian business remains solid and with this move we will place Parkside on a more secure footing for growth in the UK packaging market going forward.”

Parkside specialises in printing, lamination, laser, thermal and sustainable solutions for the food, drink and tobacco sectors.

Sheila Duffy: Standard designs part of package to tackle smoking

CTA says:

Why is there no Government movement in Hong Kong towards standardised packaging ?

http://www.scotsman.com/news/sheila-duffy-standard-designs-part-of-package-to-tackle-smoking-1-4129839

FROM Friday, cigarettes will be sold in plain packs, writes Sheila Duffy

Plain, standardised tobacco packaging will come in throughout the UK from Friday. It will make the packaging for an addictive and toxic substance more truthful and will prevent tobacco companies peddling the pack images, colours and designs that have helped entice generations of young people to start experimenting with their brands.

Retailers will have a year to sell through their existing stock before plain packs become mandatory.

This is not primarily intended to reduce adult smoking rates, although it might help. For example researchers in Australia, where standardised tobacco packaging has been in place since late 2012, report that smokers say they are less inclined to pick up the sludge green packs with their simple fonts and prominent picture health warnings, and that they say the cigarettes don’t seem to taste as good in plain packs. Reducing adult smoking rates would be a welcome side-effect if it happens here, but it is not the main aim of standardised packaging nor should we expect to see quick results.

Plain packaging is a long-term measure. It aims to disrupt the carefully targeted brand recognition and image-mongering which tobacco companies use to build familiarity and hook the interest of new and mainly young consumers.

Cigarettes are highly engineered products and for many consumers they can easily become habit-forming or addictive, which undermines free choice. Tobacco packaging has long been used as a lure to entice people to try the contents, and to buy into the sizzle of carefully designed and targeted marketing imagery. It’s what profit-making corporations do.

Tobacco companies go much further than marketing in seeking to protect their profits. They have a long and well-documented history of public scaremongering and of seeking to derail or delay public health measures that aim to reduce tobacco use. Tobacco company Japan Tobacco International (JTI) has seeded the media with misleading images of stark, white packs omitting the mandatory picture health warnings, juxtaposed with unfounded claims that illicit tobacco will increase following their introduction. Tobacco company Philip Morris International (PMI) has weighed in with inflated claims about illicit tobacco which fail to stand up under scrutiny.

If you listened only to the tobacco industry and their allies and vested interests, you would think that black market tobacco was booming here. Actually the rates of illicit tobacco in the UK have been declining since the start of the century according to the official figures from HMRC. Illicit tobacco remains a real problem, but not in the way the industry claims. No credible links have been demonstrated between illicit tobacco and either standardised tobacco packaging or tax increases. In fact since 2000 the size of the illicit market in the UK has declined by more than half even though the price of cigarettes has risen significantly over that period.

The Tobacco Retailers’ Alliance (TRA), a tobacco industry funded campaign group, recently posted an article under the Tobacco Manufacturers’ Association’s ‘Friends of the Scotsman’ slot that perpetuated many myths about the impacts of tobacco reduction measures, in particular the predicted effects on small retailers. For those of us who ten years ago lived through the opposition arguments to proposed legislation to remove tobacco smoke from enclosed public spaces, it is all depressingly familiar.

Standardised tobacco packaging will not stop existing adult smokers buying their usual brands at their usual retail outlets, but it should make the packaging less of a brand accessory or statement for young people. It will work alongside covered-up point of sale displays by putting tobacco branding out of sight and out of mind in our society.

There is no reason why it would increase the illicit tobacco trade, and no evidence that it has done so in Australia. Those working in enforcement say that they will have no problems detecting illicit tobacco just as readily with the new packaging.

Most of all, standardised packaging is truthful packaging. It signals to the next generation that this is a product that damages people’s bodies and their lives. The images of tumours, rotten teeth, infertility and early death represent the contents far more accurately than the previous bright colours and stylish designs. These picture health warnings will also increase in size from Friday. I am wondering where the tobacco companies plan to spend their vast marketing and promotional budgets next.

• Sheila Duffy, Chief Executive, ASH Scotland

Tribunal Publishes Redacted Version of Award on Jurisdiction and Admissibility

Download (PDF, 132KB)

No good news on packaging regs

The European Court of Justice has backed the EU Tobacco Directive and told producers of packaging for tobacco products that they cannot use fancy substrates, designs or techniques to differentiate brands following the plain packaging requirement that comes into force on 20 May.

One such firm is Amcor, whose designs include the ‘scissor’ pack, which opens sideways to reveal hidden branding.

The directive will also ban packs of 10 cigarettes, rolling tobacco in packs under 30g and all menthol cigarettes, from 20 May 2020. Packs across the EU are required to have health warnings across 65% of their surface.

Meanwhile, the sector is on tenterhooks awaiting the decision of the UK High Court in an intellectual property case brought by Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International.

Many businesses due to be affected by the legislation are reserving comment until the decision comes through but the mood is not good. In Australia, which introduced plain packaging in December 2012, a similar high-profile and very expensive legal battle between the Australian government and tobacco titans did not go the tobacco lobby’s way.

Mike Ridgway of the Consumer Packaging Manufacturers Alliance says: “A lot of printing will be badly affected by the implementation of plain packaging. Plain packaging means standardised packaging doing away with branding and ID, having health warnings and an olive green background with a small font.

“It’s not just graphics, it’s the construction and the substrates. There’s no hot-foil stamping, no embossing, graining or anything that gives the pack any sort of particular graphical marketing characteristics.”

While the plain packaging law, barring a last-minute reprieve by the court, will be introduced in the UK, Ireland and France, the EU directive affects all EU states. Any converter who has decided to make up for lost printing income through focusing on packaging shape, will find itself at the mercy of a double whammy.

Ridgway, a former Chesapeake Branded Packaging executive, adds: “I’m a non smoker; I just think it’s excessive regulation and there’s no proof it works, from a packaging and printing point of view it’s affecting tins, pouches, the whole packaging industry. They have really got issues.”

The pro-plain packaging lobby, however, claims Australian cigarette packs which feature large, gory photographs, do work.

Research by the Cancer Council, published in the medical journal Tobacco Control last year, found 20% of smokers were trying to quit the month before the ban and 27% the month after.

UK substrate manufacturer API is one company that was actively targeting tobacco packaging and at Packaging Innovations at London’s Olympia in September last year, cigarette packets featuring its signature Fresnel Lens PET laminate took pride of place on its stand. API also produces foils used on the front of cigarette packs and the plain packaging legislation has “badly knocked” its business, according to Ridgway.

Printed tobacco packets will not suddenly disappear from shelves. Retailers have a year for ‘sell-through’ and the introduction of standardised packaging could also produce opportunities for creative businesses.

When the Australian ban was introduced in December 2012, enterprising label printers, including Box Wrap and Stickerette, decided to print sticker covers for cigarette boxes.

Stickerette has patented its whole pack wraps and now calls itself a global brand which aims to increase sales in the UK and the US under its ‘Your Pack – You Decide’ slogan.

The standardised plain pack design can be produced litho or even digitally, according to Ridgway.

Parkside, Amcor and Multi Packaging Solutions are among the packaging firms likely to be hit. The latter prints cigarette packets on gravure. Amcor Tobacco Packaging president Jerzy Czubak said the legislation posed “a real risk” to consumers.

“Standardised packaging lowers barriers of entry into the tobacco market, leading to de facto creation of scale benefits for criminal organisations trading in counterfeit tobacco. Consumers are exposed to hazardous contents in illicit tobacco products and there will be a limited capacity to authenticate and differentiate between products.

“Amcor Tobacco Packaging believes that standardised packaging represents an unnecessary intervention into not only tobacco, but also packaging in general – a legitimate and essential industry that employs hundreds of thousands of people worldwide.”

Another gravure printer which is likely to be affected by the rules is Benkert. Its Alva, Clackmannanshire plant prints the paper which goes around cigarettes.

“Our argument has always been that if you take complexity out of the packs you’re opening the market up to illicit trade,” Ridgway says. “Over £2bn is lost through tax revenue losses per year through counterfeiting. That’s £8m a day. This business about increasing price is just not going to help. The projection is that by 2020 a packet of  cigarettes will be £20 and 14% of trade will be illicit.”

Countefeiting also concerns the BPIF. General manager at BPIF Cartons Neal Whipp, says: “BPIF Cartons supports any packaging initiative that has been proven to improve public health by reducing smoking. However thus far we have not seen sufficient evidence to this effect and so there is a risk that plain packaging may make matters worse by facilitating more counterfeit products at lower prices.”

Another fear is that the incoming rules will have a knock-on effect, in other countries and in terms of other sectors coming under the plain packaging microscope.

Alcohol is the obvious contender but concerns, espoused by the anti plain-packaging fraternity at least, is that fatty and sugary foods could also be in the firing line, as a way to be seen to be doing something to appease the health lobby.

The government claimed sound reasons for pressing ahead with plain packaging. In 2012-13 it spent £87.7m on services to help people stop smoking. It says the new packs will save lives and, in addition, money. Public Health England estimates a £500m healthcare saving if the fall in smoking seen in Australia is mirrored here.

So why not ban them completely? In 2014-15 the government received £9.5bn in revenue from tobacco tax and that excludes VAT. So we have a compromise which benefits some, but packaging printers and converters least of all.

Cigarette packets set for redesign to stop people smoking with 65% of box given over to warnings

Fags to be packaged in drab green boxes with standard fonts and sizes

https://www.thesun.co.uk/archives/news/1177239/cigarette-packets-set-for-redesign-to-stop-people-smoking-with-65-of-box-given-over-to-warnings/

PACKAGING for cigarettes is being changed as part of a new plan to stop people from smoking and to deter young people from taking up the habit.

MPs approved the new rules in March which will see the tobacco products sold in drab green boxes with large health warnings and graphic photographs.

The new law will come into effect on 20 May this year and will also make all cigarette packets the same size and shape.

The words printed on the packet will also have to use the same typeface, colour, case and alignment of text.

It will also mean the end for large and prominent logos that have become so well-known over the years including Marlboro and Silk Cut.

The new packets will give over more space to health warnings and graphic photos with 65% of the box used to deter smokers.

Campaign groups, including Cancer Research UK, say well designed packaging and effective marketing have unconsciously drawn people into smoking.

They say young people are particularly vulnerable to taking up the habit and that standardised packaging will help prevent them from smoking.