Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Quit Smoking

‘E-cigarettes can reduce burden of smoking-related deaths in India’

Electronic-cigarettes, popularly known as e-cigarettes, provide a third line of option to stay away from harmful effects of tobacco, and can significantly reduce the burden of smoking-related deaths in India, a renowned expert on vaping has said.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/E-cigarettes-can-reduce-burden-of-smoking-related-deaths-in-India/articleshow/54692029.cms

“The first line option to shield yourself from the toxicity of tobacco products is to quit smoking altogether and the second line of option is to quit with the help of medication,” Konstantinos Farsalinos, from the University of Patras in Greece, told reporters at an event here.

Farsalinos, who is a research fellow at Onassis Cardiac Surgery Centre, is on a visit to India to interact with Indian medical fraternity and government authorities to share his latest findings on how e-cigarettes have helped millions of Europeans to quit smoking.

“Just as medicines offer a harm reduction technique for diseases or helmets provide bikers harm reduction in case of accidents, e-cigarettes adds a harm reduction option for smokers,” said Farsalinos.

He called upon Indian public health officials and anti-tobacco activists to maintain an open-minded and evidence-based approach, and provide proper education to the society concerning these products.

Use of electronic cigarettes has helped 6.1 million smokers in the European Union to quit smoking, according to a 2014 study that analysed data involving a representative sample of nearly 28,000 Europeans, Farsalinos pointed out.

“India is a country where smoking and harmful tobacco use is thriving. The WHO Global Adult Tobacco Survey (GATS) study found that 34.6 per cent of adults use some form of tobacco, while about one million Indians die annually from smoking-associated disease (2010 data),” Farsalinos said.

“For countries with high prevalence of smoking and harmful smokeless tobacco use (unfortunately snus is virtually non-existent in India), e-cigarettes should be considered a golden opportunity to reduce harm in a cost-effective manner,” he explained.

In November India will be the host to the Seventh Conference of Parties (COP-7) of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) where public health officials from 180 countries will participate in discussions on Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems and potentially agree on guidelines for policy and regulation.

The focus of tobacco control community and anti-smoking activists have been on nicotine, which, according to Farsalinos, is misleading because in reality none has ever died from nicotine dependence.

“Disease and death is associated with the vehicle used to deliver nicotine and is caused by the combustion of tobacco,” he noted, adding that e-cigarettes, on the other hand, involves evaporation of a liquid that contains nicotine, thereby reducing the harm associated with conventional cigarettes.

Association between use of flavoured tobacco products and quit behaviours

Download (PDF, 216KB)

Tonight with Tim Modise | A Billion Lives

Tobacco addiction has led to the deaths of millions around the world with South Africa is joining the cause to have smoking banned.

According to a new documentary, e-cigarettes and vaporizers are a solution to kicking addiction but they aren’t made accessible & this info is kept secret by large corporations because they st and to lose billions.

Tim Modise talks to Aaron Biebert, ‘A Billion Lives’ Film Director & Medical Expert, Dr Delon Human.

Using e-cigs to quit smoking?

http://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2016/08/07/using-ecigs-to-quit-smoking/

A NEW study reveals that 95% of Malaysian vapers surveyed have either quit or cut down on smoking, while over 80% of them reported improved health.

“More than two-thirds stopped smoking all together. Among the 27% that didn’t quit, the average consumption of cigarettes dropped from 19 to four a day,” Greek cardio­logist Dr Konstantinos Farsalinos said at a recent interview in Kuala Lumpur.

Sharing the results of his latest study, the Onassis Cardiac Surgery Center and University of Patras researcher says over 7,000 adult vapers – 97% of whom were male – participated in the online survey which was in English and Malay. The average age of respondents was 30.

Over 5,500 ex-smokers and more than 1,500 smokers, who are also vapers, were asked about their experiences with e-cigarettes, and the results were consistent with those from the United States and Europe.

“Malaysian vapers, like their global counterparts, generally use advanced e-cigs and were able to reduce their nicotine consumption gradually, feel healthier and eventually quit smoking.”

This, Dr Farsalinos claims, is the largest cross-sectional survey of adult vapers in Malaysia and Asia. The survey is an extension of his 2014 study involving over 19,000 participants worldwide. While his earlier study on the characteristics, side effects and benefits of e-cigs found that 81% of those surveyed had quit smoking with e-cigs, he admits that there was little participation from Asia. The Malaysian survey, he says, fills the gap.

“The vaping community here is more organised compared with those in other countries in the region. They reached out to me early on. There are lots of questions but no data so it was important to do a study here,” he says, explaining why he decided to conduct his latest survey in Malaysia.

The lack of data, he feels, is why e-cigs are feared. While admitting that some fears are legitimate, he argues that sound policy must be based on facts and data, not fears.

The most common side effect of vaping is dry throat and mouth, he says, dismissing fears that smoking e-cigs would lead to addiction. According to his findings, tobacco cigarettes were the first nicotine product used by 92% of the respondents while 95% denied ever using e-cigs to inhale anything other than e-liquids.

The Health Ministry’s recommendation for e-cigs to be strictly regulated as a pharmaceutical product is a “big step backward”, says Dr Farsalinos, arguing that whether the e-cig is a pharmaceutical, tobacco or consumer product was dealt with in Europe three years ago.

“The e-cig is not medicinal so that argument was thrown out. The EU regulates it under its Tobacco Products Directive but there’s a sepa­rate category for the e-cig where it’s treated as a consumer product.”

He believes the devices should be regulated as a consumer product but with restrictions, like banning its sale to minors.

“Smokers aren’t stupid. They know their habit causes diseases that kill but they like it. Smoking is pleasurable. E-cigs give them the same pleasure.

“Malaysia adopts harm reduction when they tell motorists to wear a seatbelt. Why is this different?” he asks, adding, however, that e-cigs should only be the option for those who failed to quit smoking by themselves or after they’ve tried medication.

Prof Datuk Dr Abdul Razak Muttalif believes it’s better to err on the side of caution as the long-term effects of e-cigs on the body are still unknown and may take years to find out.

He is the chairman of the Health Ministry’s technical committee tasked with studying the health effects of e-cigs and shisha smoking and also a senior consultant chest physician and former director of the Kuala Lumpur Hospital Institute of Respiratory Medicine.

“Look how long it took before we knew that cigarettes cause diseases. As doctors we are very careful,” Dr Abdul Razak says when asked to comment on the Farsalinos study.

When the committee was formed in 2013, there wasn’t much data on e-cigs, he says, but some studies now show that e-cigs could have acute and long-term effects on consumers.

Worried about the nicotine in e-liquids, he warns that it could lead e-cig users to other addictions.

Universiti Malaya nicotine addiction specialist Assoc Prof Dr Amer Siddiq Amer Nordin is also concerned.

“A single survey conducted on mainly Internet users is inadequate to change the understanding of the danger or benefits of e-cigs. Besides the ongoing national study findings, there are a number of studies looking at the prevalence, mode of use, safety of e-liquids and safety to the environment. These are conducted by local universities. Let’s compare their data with Dr Farsalinos’ data.

“If e-cigs are found to be a useful quit-smoking agent in future, it should be regulated as a medicinal device. Still, abstinence is the best way to quit,” he says, adding that nicotine is governed by the Poison Act and its distribution is controlled.

Calling for a ban on e-cigs, the Consumers Association of Penang (CAP) believes that instead of helping smokers quit, e-cigs just cause them to spend more on a new habit.

CAP education officer N.V. Subbarow insists that many vapers are still smoking.

“Now we have another problem besides smoking. Worse still, teachers and parents are at a loss because kids who have never smoked are vaping now.”

CAP, he says, conducts weekly consumer education programmes in schools, addressing topics like vaping and e-cigs.

“Our survey of eight primary and secondary schools in Penang last year found 150 regular vapers among the students.”

Model quitter: President Xi Jinping’s decision to give up smoking deserves praise, WHO chief says

http://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/1997897/model-quitter-president-xi-jinpings-decision-give

A compliment from the World Health Organisation chief to President Xi Jinping for quitting smoking will be a boost to tobacco control efforts, now in a vital phase ahead of a national anti-smoking law, observers said.

WHO director general Margaret Chan Fung Fu-chun said last week during an official visit to Beijing that Xi did not smoke any more and that this was “worth praising as a good model”.

Chan did not elaborate on when Xi quit smoking. Past media reports said Xi quit in the 1980s.

“There are about 300 million smokers. President Xi understands the importance of tobacco control,” Chan said.

Her compliment comes as the State Council, the cabinet, is contemplating whether to enforce stricter tobacco controls, and while the government also controls the nation’s tobacco industry, a major source of revenue.

Xi’s stance will be important in deciding which way the government will swing, according to Wu Yiqun, deputy director of the Think Tank Research Centre for Health Development, an anti-smoking group.

“China’s political system means in reality officials from the very top have a big influence,” Wu said.

“Xi’s remarks with Margaret Chan on tobacco control show he is aware of the importance of tobacco control, which is a good thing for a better smoke-free law,” Wu said.

Xi’s smoking habit dates back to his teenage years in the late 1960s when he did hard labour in rural areas of northwestern Shaanxi province, mainland media have reported.

A photo of Xi from 1983, published by Xinhua three years ago, shows him as a young regional party secretary holding a lit cigarette and with a pack of the Lotus brand on his desk.

The picture immediately sparked demand among Chinese smokers for the brand. Lotus stopped production in the 1990s, but a tobacco plant “redeveloped” the brand and launched it on the market in early 2014.

Consumers and dealers alike “queued up” to buy packs, according to a statement issued by the State Tobacco Monopoly Administration the following year.

Xi, however, had quit smoking as early as the 1980s when he was working as an official in Fujian province, the Beijing Morning Post reported last year.

“Smoking is bad for health,” a villager who knew Xi at the time quoted him as saying.

Former leaders Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping were known as heavy smokers, and more than half of the men in China have the habit. But there is an increasing awareness of the dangers of smoking.

This is particularly the case in big cities such as Beijing, which has its own regulations banning smoking indoors.

The national law’s first draft in 2014 proposed a ban on smoking in all indoor and some outdoor public areas. This would be in line with the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, which China has ratified.

The latest draft of the legislation has significantly back-pedalled, with exemptions for restaurants, bars, hotels and airports.

About 100,000 people die in China from passive smoking-related illness each year, the WHO says. About one million deaths were caused each year by tobacco and the number could rise to three million by 2050 if the country did not act, the organisation has warned.

Tobacco control in China was given a boost in 2013, months after Xi took office as president, when a circular from the Communist Party Central Committee and the State Council banned government officials from using public funds to buy cigarettes.

Officials were also banned from smoking when performing official duties.

They are not allowed to light up in schools, hospitals, sports venues, on public transport or at any venue where smoking is banned.

Xi’s wife, Peng Liyuan, a popular soprano, became an ambassador for the Chinese Association on Tobacco Control in 2009.

Public health experts have credited Xi’s sweeping anti-corruption campaign with causing a slump in cigarettes sales growth.

Revenue fell 11.7 per cent from January to May this year compared with the same period in 2015, and profits were down 24 per cent.

Cigarette sales reversed years of growth last year and fell 2.36 per cent.

The industry, however, generated about 1.1 trillion yuan (HK$1.28 trillion) in profit and tax revenue last year, 8.7 per cent more than in 2014.

Additional reporting by Sarah Zheng and Julia Hollingsworth

Motivating smokers at outdoor public smoking hotspots to have a quit attempt with a nicotine replacement therapy sample

Download (PDF, 1004KB)

Doctors should NOT recommend ecigarettes to smokers – existing treatments are more effective and safer, experts say

  • Existing smoking cessation therapies are ‘more effective than e-cigarettes’
  • New commentary warns of ‘no strong evidence’ e-cigarettes are safe
  • Warn doctors should not be recommending the devices to their patients

E-cigarettes should not be recommended to smokers who are trying to quit their habit, experts today said.

Existing treatments are more effective than the devices in helping people stub out their cigarettes, and there is no strong evidence that e-cigarettes are safe, new research suggests.

The health benefits of quitting smoking are widely accepted.

But, researchers at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill have taken issue with the suggestion that doctors should routinely recommend e-cigarettes as an alternative.

In a commentary published in today’s Annals of Family Medicine, they say there are professional ethical concerns about doctors who do recommend the devices – warning there is no evidence they are safe.

Professor at the UNC School of Medicine, Adam Goldstein, said: ‘Providers should not routinely recommend e-cigarettes to patients until we have far more data on their safety and effectiveness compared to established, FDA-approved medications.

‘There are very few therapeutic devices that we recommend that aren’t regulated, that have potential and real side effects, and that are addictive.

‘There are safer and more effective smoking cessation products for the same condition.’

The researchers warned of notable safety and health concerns linked to e-cigarettes.

Batteries inside the devices have caught fire or exploded, and particulate matter from e-cigarettes, which has been shown to be present in similar numbers to cigarettes, can increase the risk of cardiovascular and respiratory diseases.

The new commentary served as a counterpoint to a paper in the same journal issue by Professor of tobacco addiction, Ann McNeill, at King’s College London, that suggests e-cigarettes are a less harmful way for smokers, including those trying to quit, to use nicotine.

‘Though e-cigarettes are likely not as harmful as conventional cigarettes, a growing number of studies report that they are by no means harmless,’ said Clare Meernik, MPH, a research specialist in the UNC Department of Family Medicine.

‘Short-term effects include exposure to toxins, reduced respiratory and lung function and burn related injuries from exploding devices.’

The researchers also noted that e-cigarettes have been less effective than existing treatments to help people quit smoking.

‘People are focused on should they use ecigarettes or not. We can have a conversation about that, but part of the bigger picture is being lost,’ Professor Goldstein said.

‘And that is that we need be using the tools that we currently have available, including seven FDA-approved medications in combination with behavioral treatment.

‘We have quit lines that provide free counseling and physician counseling to help patients come up with concrete plans for quitting and developing the skills necessary to quit permanently and to increase social support – all of which significantly increase cessation.’

In May the U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced it was extending its authority over all tobacco products, including e-cigarettes.

Greater regulatory oversight of e-cigarettes, the researchers said, will be a significant step forward toward ensuring higher safety standards.

‘We need more data on effectiveness, we need more data on safety, we need technology that’s safe so the products don’t explode, we need to ensure they’re childproof,’ Professor Goldstein said.

Has New Zealand lost its way in tobacco control?

http://theconversation.com/has-new-zealand-lost-its-way-in-tobacco-control-62178

The New Zealand government has decided to reorient its priorities in tobacco control. It has announced it will be pulling 73% of its previous funding support for tobacco control advocacy. The only money allocated for tobacco control to do the vital work of building and sustaining community and multi-party support for tobacco control will go to an Auckland-based Māori health agency Hāpai te Hauora.

Instead, New Zealand will be ploughing nearly all funding into “frontline cessation services with improved training to get better quit results”. Decoded, this means sinking money into efforts focused on smokers in clinical or small group settings and defunding efforts focused on advocacy for policies that will motivate smokers across the community to quit.

This policy shift risks stalling or even starting to reverse the decline in smoking prevalence that New Zealand has experienced. Here’s why.

Five assumptions have almost certainly driven this worrying shift in policy.

First, there is likely to be a myopic preoccupation with lifting smoking cessation success rates rather than a priority focus on increasing the number of people who quit.

Advocates for encouraging what they amusingly call “evidence based” smoking cessation always highlight the generally better success rates obtained by smokers who use assistance compared to those who try to quit alone. From this they reason that the main game should therefore be convincing as many smokers as possible to use assistance.

But over 30 years of efforts in several nations to boost attendance at smoking cessation services have failed to lift attendance beyond fringe proportions of all smokers interested in quitting. Very few smokers are willing to seek anything more than brief assistance.

The number of people who quit is a function of the reach of a method and its rate of success. Consider this: in a million smokers, if 3% quit and stay quit unaided in a year, 30,000 ex-smokers result. But if 15% of 10,000 smokers convinced to attend professional smoking cessation services quit – five times the success rate – the yield is only 1,500 ex-smokers. Clearly, a lower success rate in a much larger number of people should always trump a much higher success rate in a much smaller number.

So the second problem is that intensive smoking cessation services usually requiring repeated contact have always failed to attract anything but tiny proportions of smokers.

In New Zealand, some 88% of smokers appear uninterested in even communicating via the quitline, by far the least demanding of all “interventions”. The number who would be willing to attend or engage with multiple session professional support services would be far, far less.

If you want to get smoking down across a whole population, there is no substitute for policies and campaigns that have mass reach potential, reaching nearly all smokers.

Tobacco tax, mass reach motivational media campaigns, smoke-free policies, and packaging controls all tick that box. Intensive smoking cessation services don’t.

Third, the cessation method that has delivered by far the most number of ex-smokers (unassisted cessation or cold turkey) is routinely neglected and often openly denigrated by smoking cessation specialists.

The conversation stopper here is that if you ask 100 ex-smokers how they stopped smoking, volumes of studies stretching back more than 40 years have shown that between two-thirds and three-quarters of ex-smokers used no pharmacological or professional assistance on their final successful quit attempt. Before the availability of nicotine replacement therapy, hundreds of millions of smokers globally quit smoking unassisted, including many heavily addicted smokers. So often denigrated by cessation specialists whose interests lie in providing assistance, the evidence shows unassisted cessation has the population cessation runs on the board.

The lesson from this is that ongoing, hard-hitting campaigns and evidence-based policies like tobacco tax to encourage quit attempts are of vital importance.

Fourth, those making the decisions are likely to have been mesmerised by clinical trial results, rather than real world data on how various smoking cessation strategies perform. Nicotine-replacement therapy (NRT) used with on-going support has better success than unassisted cessation. But again, we need to ask how many New Zealand smokers will realistically be interested in receiving that sort of support. Most will collect their subsidised NRT and not participate further.

New Zealand reportedly spends $NZ61m on tobacco control, with the great majority of this going to subsidised NRT. There is increasing evidence that handing out NRT to smokers away from ongoing professional support and over-the-counter use is all but useless. Evidence from England shows that the use of NRT bought over the counter is associated with a lower rate of abstinence than quitting unassisted.

Fifth, the seductive power of the so-called “hardening” hypothesis is likely to have tightened its grip on New Zealand policymakers. This hypothesis proposes that as smoking prevalence falls in a country, the proportion of “hard core” smokers rises.

True believers in this hypothesis then argue that the suite of comprehensive policies and campaigns that has caused smoking to fall over the past decades has seen nearly all the low-hanging fruit quit smoking and is now producing diminishing returns. Calls are then made to focus efforts on the burgeoning hard core smokers by labour and pharmacologically intensive cessation methods.

The problem with all this is that it is simply not true. New Zealand research just published found “no statistically significant changes in indicators of hardening including the proportion of smokers who were unmotivated or unable to quit despite repeat attempts” between 2008-2014. Similar findings have been reported in other studies internationally.

New Zealand could do with more commitment to the sort of large scale tough, motivating mass media campaigns that have contributed so much to motivating Australian smokers to quit and children not to start. Funding boosts to campaigns such as Stop before you start are likely to reach and influence far more people than giving extra support to low-demand services.

Advocacy groups have provided invaluable assistance to New Zealand governments over the years by making and defending the case for policies such as tobacco tax and plain packaging that can make a difference to the whole population of current and potential smokers. Former Australian health minister Nicola Roxon, the political architect of plain packaging (which is now spreading globally), told me that the call to legislate for plain packaging and very large tax increases was made politically and popularly palatable by the years of policy advocacy undertaken by NGOs and advocates for tough policy.

By all but removing advocacy funding in New Zealand, and filling the vacuum with funding for strategies simply incapable of reaching large numbers of smokers, the government is likely to be doing something it will regret.

New Zealand has some of the world’s most mature, astute and advanced strategic policy researchers. Together, they have punched well above their national weight in stimulating original thinking about pathways toward an endgame for tobacco use. The government would do well to provide support to harness their expertise to bring their analytic and research skills together rather than putting so many eggs in the individualistic smoking cessation basket.

More people turning to vaping as tobacco price rises

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/northern-advocate/news/article.cfm?c_id=1503450&objectid=11666207

A Northland retailer selling e-cigarettes is “astounded” by the growth in sales since tobacco prices increased 10 per cent on January 1.

People puffing on the electronic devices, or “vaping” as the practice was known, were becoming a common sight around Northland with the retailer – who spoke anonymously – describing the cigarette substitutes as “the best thing I’ve ever sold”.

E-cigarettes – or electronic cigarettes – are devices that allow users to mimic the ritual of smoking a cigarette. Many glow at the end when activated, as real cigarettes do. Instead of inhaling smoke from burning tobacco, users inhale vapour containing nicotine.

“I’m astounded at how many people are buying them, and at how many people are giving up smoking using them. It’s a quiet little revolution,” said the retailer, who lost both his parents to smoking-related illnesses.

“I gave up cold turkey 10 years ago and it was hell – for about a year. The hardest thing to give up about smoking is the puff and the kick. These [customers] say it’s easy, and they’ve been trying for years and years.”

Holly Bognar said she had smoked for most of her life from about age 13 – apart from when she was pregnant.

“I’d always gone back to it,” the 38-year-old said.

“I was heavily smoking until four months ago and now I don’t at all, not even when I drink alcohol, I’ve transitioned to e-cigarettes.”

Ms Bognar said, when she first switched to her e-cigarette, she puffed on it a lot, a pattern the retailer said a lot of his customers reported.

“Now I’ve sort of weaned myself down, which just gradually happened,” she said.

“It’s also the amount you can save. It was about $65 initially, and a thing of oil (for the e-ciggie) is about $10, which lasts a couple of weeks. That’s compared to probably a 30g in five days, which is $55 and heaps to take out of your benefit.”

The use of e-cigarettes was not governed by the Smokefree Act, meaning that, legally, users could vape where they liked.

“I’m studying at the moment, and, out of reflex, I put it to my mouth in class and my tutor wasn’t too impressed,” Ms Bognar said.

I’m astounded at how many people are buying them, and at how many people are giving up smoking using them. It’s a quiet little revolution.

“But apparently it’s OK in the pubs. I’ve had a few puffs in the shops, but more just to see if I got a reaction.”

From a health professional’s perspective, the jury was still out. Northland DHB general manager child, youth, maternal, public and oral health services Jeanette Wedding said research suggested e-cigarettes were about 90 per cent safer than smoking tobacco.

However, they had not been clinically trialled as a quitting method. She agreed, anecdotally, there was a rise in people using the devices to stop smoking.

“We’ve heard mixed results when discussing stopping smoking with patients. Some have successfully stopped smoking using e-cigarettes, while others had tried them with no success.”

She said while the most important thing was for tobacco smokers to quit, e-cigarettes could present new problems.

These could include “re-normalising” smoking which looked similar to the act of vaping, a lack of regulation of what went into the liquid vapour, and liquids coming in flavours that appeal to the young, like chocolate and strawberry.

E.U. Survey Finds E-Cigarettes Helped 15 Million Smokers Quit or Cut Back

There was little evidence that vaping leads to smoking.

http://reason.com/blog/2016/06/27/eu-survey-finds-e-cigarettes-helped-mill

A large survey of Europeans indicates that more than 6 million have quit smoking with the help of e-cigarettes, while more than 9 million have cut back, according to a study recently published by the journal Addiction. “These are probably the highest rates of smoking cessation and reduction ever observed in such a large population study,” says the lead researcher, Konstantinos Farsalinos, a cardiologist at the Onassis Cardiac Surgery Center in Athens. “The European Union data show that the use of electronic cigarettes seems to have a positive impact on public health for two main reasons: 1) High smoking cessation and reduction rates are observed, and 2) electronic cigarette use is largely confined to smokers (current and former), with minimal use by nonsmokers.”

The study, based on responses from 27,460 participants in the Eurobarometer survey, found that 48.5 million citizens of E.U. countries have tried e-cigarettes, while 7.5 million are current vapers. Within the latter group, 35 percent reported that e-cigarettes helped them quit smoking, while 32 percent said they were smoking less thanks to e-cigarettes. Such self-reports are not conclusive, since the study did not independently verify smoking status, smokers who try to quit by vaping are probably different from those who don’t, and it’s possible these outcomes could have been achieved without e-cigarettes. But policy makers and regulators should not lightly dismiss the experiences of millions who say e-cigarettes helped them make changes that dramatically reduced the health hazards they face.

Critics of vaping say the risk that it will lead to smoking in people who otherwise never would have used tobacco products must be weighed against the success stories of people who believe they’d still be smoking if it weren’t for e-cigarettes. But this study found very little evidence of such a risk. Just 0.8 percent of respondents who had ever tried tobacco products said they had tried e-cigarettes first (which does not necessarily mean that the latter led to the former). Only 1.3 percent of never-smokers reported using e-cigarettes with nicotine-containing liquids, and only 0.09 percent did so every day. “In nonsmokers we observed some experimentation with electronic cigarettes, but regular use is minimal,” says one of Farsalinos’ collaborators, Jacques Le Houezec, a neuroscientist at the French National Research Institute for Health and Medical Research. “The concern that electronic cigarettes can be a gateway to smoking is largely rejected by our findings.”