Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Quit Smoking

Don’t Look to E-Cigarettes as a Panacea for Smoking

To the Editor:

Re “Experts Say Vaping Alarm Is Overdone” (front page, Nov. 2):

A positive if unintended result of the e-cigarette controversy is that highlighting the relative dangers of tobacco cigarettes and e-cigarettes further deglamorizes them both. The discussion presents the public with the unpleasant truth that nicotine isn’t a recreational drug.

Addiction to nicotine in tobacco is the norm, not the exception, and smoking addiction is about compulsive behavior and suffering, not pleasure. All the current studies show that people who quit smoking enjoy improved mental health, more positive moods and better quality of life than those who continue to smoke.

Nicotine replacement comes in many forms, including e-cigarettes. It can help ease smokers out of smoking, but only if they stop completely. The case for e-cigarettes would be stronger if the United States, like the British National Health Service, offered clinical assistance to help addicted smokers quit, rather than just relying on our culture of self-help.

DANIEL F. SEIDMAN

New York

The writer, a clinical psychologist, is director of smoking cessation services at Columbia University.

To the Editor:

E-cigarettes are not the panacea to tobacco-caused addiction, death and disease. E-cigarettes are unregulated tobacco products, and e-cigarette companies are making unproven health claims.

The Food and Drug Administration has not found any e-cigarette to be safe and effective in helping smokers quit. Instead, almost 60 percent of all e-cigarette users continue to smoke cigarettes.

Tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable death and disease in our country, and there is real concern that if e-cigarettes delay or prevent smoking cessation, the overall burden on health caused by tobacco will remain unacceptably high.

In 2009, a bipartisan majority in Congress charged the F.D.A. with oversight over tobacco products, including new products. The agency has taken steps to use this authority, and it should proceed with its process that allows manufacturers to provide evidence to show that their products are less harmful.

Trusting the tobacco industry and circumventing robust scientific review and oversight of these products would be a mistake.

HAROLD P. WIMMER

National President and Chief Exec.

American Lung Association

Chicago

Dozens quit smoking thanks to HKU service hotline

Dozens of smokers have successfully kicked the habit with the help of a hotline set up by the University of Hong Kong.

Altogether, 1,147 people have used the service in the past five years, of whom 233, or 23.5 percent, have stopped smoking, the Hong Kong Economic Journal reports.

The success rate was achieved within six months.

Project director Dr. William Li said the average age of participants was 19.9 years.

Three in five were students including three in 10 who used to smoke more than 10 cigarettes a day.

Just 10 percent of the help seekers have cut down on their tobacco intake.

Li said the situation is “quite worrying” but some cases are promising.

Ah-Tung, 18, started smoking a year ago because of pressure from school and personal relationship issues.

He used to consume half a pack of cigarettes a day.

An avid runner, he decided to seek help after noticing his health had deteriorated.

“I could only complete two laps on the jogging track when I was a smoker, but soon after I quit, I was capable of doing a lot more laps,” he said.

Li said Ah-Tung’s case is typical.

About 43 percent of the people who called the Youth Quitline said they suffer from emotional stress.

Li said those who are emotionally disturbed are more easily influenced by their peers would usually find it more difficult to quit smoking.

HKU School of Nursing also found that 60 percent of young smokers who tried to quit smoking have switched to electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes), according to Ming Pao Daily.

The percentage was even higher among younger smokers.

Among e-cigarette smokers aged 25 and below, 43 percent are between 15 and 17 while those aged between 18 to 20 make up 35 percent of the group, followed by those from 21 to 25, which makes up 14 percent.

Lam Tai-hing, chair professor of the School of Public Health of the HKU Li Ka Shing Faculty of Medicine, said the success rate among traditional cigarette and e-cigarette smokers is more or less the same.

The figures suggest that e-cigarettes do not help smokers get rid of nicotine addiction, Lam said.

He said more effort is needed to educate the public about the dangers of smoking.

Lam also called for legislation to ban e-cigarettes.

Youth Quitline (5111 4333) targets smokers aged 25 and below.

CESSATION SUPPORT (ARTICLE 14) IS NOT COSTLY OR COMPLICATED – AND IT IS EFFECTIVE!

• CONDUCT A NATIONAL SITUATION ANALYSIS, AS RECOMMENDED IN THE FCTC ARTICLE 14 GUIDELINES;
• DEVELOP A NATIONAL CESSATION STRATEGY;
• MANDATE RECORDING TOBACCO USE IN ALL MEDICAL NOTES;
• OFFER MOBILE PHONE TEXT MESSAGING SYSTEMS;
• INTEGRATE BRIEF ADVICE TO ALL TOBACCO USERS INTO THE HEALTHCARE SYSTEM.

There is strong international support to strengthen and accelerate full implementation of Article 14 of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), as evidenced by the World Conference on Tobacco or Health Declaration in 2015 that “By 2018, at least 50% of FCTC Parties will have developed and published an official national tobacco dependence treatment strategy, in accordance with Article 14 Guideline recommendations”.

Most of the substantive FCTC Articles, especially 6, 8, 11, 12, 13 and 14, promote tobacco cessation (as opposed to discouraging young people from starting) in one way or another. It is important to note that only effective cessation will have a sufficient effect on mortality in the 9 years left to reach the UN/ WHO goal of a 25 percent reduction in premature mortality from NCDs by 2025.

The 2014 WHO Global Progress Report on FCTC implementation suggests good progress in FCTC implementation but notes that some treaty articles are being implemented more quickly than others. The report adds that only half of Parties said they were implementing Article 14 by 2014.

Evidence from MR’s group’s survey (at Nottingham University, UK) suggests perceived cost to be one concern about tobacco cessation support, another may be lack of clarity about the role of such support, including about its effectiveness and cost effectiveness.

Helping tobacco users stop is a cost effective healthcare intervention, which saves lives and improves population health.

Every day that smokers over 35 years old continue to smoke they lose about 3–6 hours of life, thus for the estimated 500 million current adult smokers, 62 million days of life are lost every day.

Some of these tobacco users will stop unaided, others will stop only after repeated attempts over time, and many more will die before they can stop, principally because
tobacco use is so addictive. The unaided population tobacco cessation rate after 1 year is very low, only about 3–5 percent, meaning that the majority of smokers who try to
stop without help fail. Adding comprehensive cessation support can be up to about four times more effective, at about 20 percent after a year, but even brief advice has a
worthwhile effect.

One key reason why the majority of ex-smokers stopped without help is because the majority do not have access to help.

According to WHO, just 15 percent of the world’s population have access to appropriate cessation support.

Arguably, cessation support should be provided alongside measures that prompt cessation attempts, like those in Articles 6, 8, 11, 12 and 13.

Given a genuine need for cessation support, the fact that globally most tobacco users don’t have access to it, and that providing it implies at least some basic infrastructure, can anything be done quickly to improve the situation, something that low and middle income countries can afford?

I think countries could consider the following relatively low-cost measures to build core infrastructure:

1. Conduct a national situation analysis, as recommended in the FCTC Article 14 guidelines;
2. Develop a national cessation strategy;
3. Mandate recording tobacco use in all medical notes;
4. Offer mobile phone text messaging systems;
5. Integrate brief advice to all tobacco users into the healthcare system.

As resources become available countries can consider adding the following:

6. Develop and disseminate national cessation guidelines;
7. Make affordable medicines available;
8. Establish mass communication and education programmes that encourage cessation and encourage tobacco users to use cessation support;
9. Offer specialist tobacco cessation support.

The availability of new, low-cost interventions and methods to help countries select affordable treatments (will remove significant barriers to the development of tobacco cessation support and make Article 14 implementation both feasible and a significant contributor to global health.

Martin Raw, Director, International Centre for Tobacco Cessation, London, UK; Visiting Scholar, New York University Medical School, New York, USA and Thomas Glynn, Consulting Professor, Stanford University Preveniton research Center, School of Medicine, Palo Alto, California, USA

This article draws extensively on a comment published in the Lancet in January: Raw M, Mackay J, Reddy S. Time to take tobacco dependence treatment seriously. Lancet, 30 January 2016. Further references and sources can be obtained from MR at martin@martinraw.com

Vaping does not help people stop smoking, says WHO report

Critics say World Health Organisation report is a backward step that will hamper fight to cut tobacco-related deaths

Countries might also want to ban nicotine delivery devices from all public places where smoking is not allowed, the report said.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/nov/04/vaping-does-not-help-people-stop-smoking-says-who-report

Countries should consider curbing the use of e-cigarettes because there is not enough evidence to show they help people stop smoking, according to a World Health Organisation report.

Vaping will be on the agenda of a major meeting starting in India on Monday of the 180 countries that have signed the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, aimed at combatting Big Tobacco and preventing the millions of deaths every year around the world caused by smoking.

But the public health community is split over whether e-cigarettes are friend or foe and some are outraged by the WHO’s advice to the meeting. It suggests countries that have not already banned e-cigarettes and other forms of nicotine delivery might want to consider imposing severe restrictions, including banning the flavouring of e-cigarettes as well as sales, advertising and possession by young people.

Countries might also want to ban nicotine delivery devices from all public places where smoking is not allowed, require health warnings about the chemicals in them, include information on the addictive potential of nicotine and ban any claims that they can help people give up tobacco smoking, the report says.

The WHO suggests these are reasonable measures to control the use of products with effects that are still unknown – and which are increasingly being manufactured by the multinational tobacco corporations the signatories to the convention are pledged to defeat.

But for some in the public health community, WHO’s report is a backward step that will hamper the fight to cut tobacco-related deaths.

Professor John Britton, director of the UK Centre for Tobacco and Alcohol Studies based at Nottingham University, said the WHO report was unbalanced. “There is nothing saying e-cigarettes are allowing hundreds of thousands of people to stop smoking,” he said.

The convention exists to combat tobacco use, not nicotine use, he said. “It is perfectly reasonable to be concerned that young people might use e-cigarettes and become addicted. All those arguments apply to licensed nicotine products that anybody can walk into Tesco and buy.” But nicotine regulation is for other agencies, he said.

Britton is concerned about the “flavour” of the WHO document “which is that these products are out there, they are being produced by tobacco companies and we should probably ban them – or if not, here are some regulations that you might want to introduce.”

The meeting in Delhi will be a conference of the parties (COP) that have signed the treaty, which includes national governments and the European Union. It takes place every two years to decide the future direction of tobacco control. The WHO report was written at the request of the parties who wanted to know about the scientific evidence for or against nicotine-delivery devices, said Dr Vera Luiza da Costa e Silva, head of the convention secretariat.

“So far there is a clear understanding that e-cigarettes should be regulated,” she said. “They should not be promoted among young people and pregnant women and other specific groups. They should not be promoted widely – there should be restrictions and regulations.” More monitoring of the effects and possible health benefits is needed, she said.

“While I don’t think COP will close the door [to e-cigarettes], I don’t think COP will open the door to them at this time,” she said.

The issue splits the public health community. Critics of e-cigarettes are concerned that they may be a “stalking horse” for Big Tobacco, which the Framework Convention has made a pariah.

Countries that have signed the treaty agree under Article 5.3 that the tobacco industry is beyond the pale and must never be allowed into negotiations. If e-cigarettes can help people stop smoking, the tobacco companies can argue for their rehabilitation and a presence at the table.

“While e-cigarettes offer a significant opportunity to public health, there are also risks. One is the way the tobacco industry uses harm reduction to secure reputational and access possibilities and to split the public health camp,” said Anna Gilmore, professor of public health at the University of Bath and the UK Centre for Tobacco Control Studies.

“The tobacco industry uses e-cigarettes to claim it is committed to harm reduction, but meanwhile it continues to engage in harm maximisation by spending millions to promote tobacco and oppose any policy that would reduce its use.”

Ahead of the Delhi meeting, rightwing thinktanks and libertarian groups have been on the attack, arguing that the COP is secretive and not transparent, because members of the public may be excluded from the proceedings. But, says Gilmore, that is because the industry and its representatives have to be kept out of the COP discussion, under Article 5.3, “yet we know the industry infiltrates these meetings often using third parties as a disguise,” said Gilmore.

It is impossible to screen every individual and group who wants to attend. “They are caught between a rock and a hard place, because of the industry’s underhand tactics,” she said.

The Tobacco Control Atlas: ASEAN Region

Download (PDF, 11.39MB)

Vaping: It’s not a safe way to quit smoking

http://www.dl-online.com/opinion/4147107-vaping-its-not-safe-way-quit-smoking

I am a respiratory therapist and tobacco specialist at Essentia Health St. Mary’s Hospital, and I work nearly every day with people struggling to breathe due to smoking cigarettes. It can be very difficult to quit smoking, and I want to offer smokers all the support they can get when quitting.

Unfortunately, I see a growing number of patients who turn to e-cigarettes as a means to quit smoking. That is why I felt I had to write the Detroit Lakes Tribune in response to an article “The End of Vaping?” that may have led some readers to believe that e-cigarettes have been conclusively proven safe and effective as a tool for people to quit smoking. I’d like to offer the following perspective as a local health care professional.

Research shows that the aerosol produced by e-cigarettes contains heavy metals, formaldehyde and other cancer-causing chemicals. E-cigarette aerosol also contains nicotine, the substance in tobacco that addicts smokers.

There is also no conclusive scientific evidence that e-cigarettes are effective for smoking cessation; in fact, quite often, users become addicted to both. If people wish to quit smoking, I encourage them to use evidence based support services and approved cessation aids.

At Essentia Health, we have specialists trained to provide these support services in person and for as long as you would like. Additionally, anyone in Minnesota can call QUITPLAN (1-888-354-7526) to find out about other free and low-cost services available to all Minnesota. Why would anyone want to take a chance on e-cigarettes when we already have tools that are safe and scientifically proven to work?

Also, despite the implication from the retailer in the article, there is no conclusive clinical research, or research of any kind, for that matter, that shows e-cigarettes reverse the symptoms of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). COPD is a debilitating disease that causes permanent damage to lung tissue.

This past summer, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration deemed e-cigarettes a tobacco product, just like cigarettes, cigars, and chewing tobacco. When the deeming regulations are fully implemented in 2019, manufacturers will have to disclose the ingredients in e-cigarette liquid and include the Surgeon General’s warning on all packaging, among many other important consumer protections. This will provide more transparency to consumers and will aid in research about the health effects of e-cigarette use. In the meantime, I urge our community not to be unduly swayed by the self-interested statements of the e-cigarette industry.

(Vickie Lee is a registered respiratory therapist and certified tobacco treatment specialist at Essentia Health in Detroit Lakes)

People trying to quit smoking don’t always focus on tobacco cessation

https://news.ok.ubc.ca/2016/10/25/people-trying-to-quit-smoking-dont-always-focus-on-tobacco-cessation/

Fifty per cent of statements made by smokers during counselling sessions designed to help them stop have nothing to do with quitting, a UBC study has found.

The study, which focused on conversations smoking cessation counsellors in the United Kingdom had with their clients, also found the 50 per cent of statements that did relate to quitting mostly focused on medical aids such as smoking cessation drugs, nicotine patches or inhalers.

“These findings may indicate that people trying to quit need time to talk about a variety of topics to feel comfortable talking with their practitioner about smoking,” says Heather Gainforth, an assistant professor of health and exercise sciences at UBC’s Okanagan campus. “It also highlights the importance of providing smokers with the opportunity to receive counselling about pharmaceutical aids that can help them quit.”

As part of her study, Gainforth reviewed the transcripts of 15 smoking cessation interviews and coded all 1,429 statements made by smokers during counselling sessions.

The data collected is part of a larger, ongoing study aimed at determining what tools and supports best help smokers quit.

According to a 2012 report from the UK’s National Centre for Smoking Cessation and Training, 20 per cent of adults in England reported smoking in 2010 and smoked an average of 12.7 cigarettes per day. In 2010/11 1.5 million hospital admissions (5 per cent) were estimated to be attributable to smoking, up from one million in 1997, and 18 per cent of deaths of adults over 35 were estimated to be smoking related.

Gainforth’s research was recently published in the British Journal of Health Psychology.

Livestream of brain could help smokers quit

Real-time data from smokers’ brains could help them re-programme their minds and stub out cigarettes for good.

http://horizon-magazine.eu/article/livestream-brain-could-help-smokers-quit_en.html

It’s one of the options being explored by researchers who are looking into the most successful ways to quit.

Neurofeedback is a brain-training technique that uses electrodes placed on a person’s head to create a live feed of their brainwaves. This information is displayed in front of the person who can then visibly reshape their thoughts.

The Issue

Smoking causes an estimated 650 000 EU citizens to die prematurely each year, but it is also the largest cause of preventable morbidity worldwide.

In 2009 the Council of the European Union called upon all Member States to protect their citizens from tobacco smoke by enhancing smoke-free laws such as encouraging efforts to quit and putting warnings on tobacco packages.

A European Commission follow-up report in 2013 found 17 EU countries have comprehensive smoke-free laws in place.

‘It allows them to control what they see,’ said Professor Panagiotis D. Bamidis from the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki in Greece, who is testing the effectiveness of the technique to help smokers give up.

‘Subjects are asked if they can do specific tasks and their reactions provide a feedback loop that lets them train their own brain.’

The ability of neurofeedback to identify negative thought processes has been used to treat mental illness and memory problems, but this is the first research looking into whether it is an effective technique for breaking an addiction.

‘With neurofeedback we can see what type of brain signals smokers are emitting when they are relaxed, then we ask them to follow specific tasks and record their reactions,’ said Prof. Bamidis.

When the subject encounters something that may trigger an urge to smoke, they will learn what the cause was and what thoughts could help them overcome the craving.

Prof. Bamidis says that smokers would need around twenty hours of treatment before feeling the effects from neurofeedback, but considering it’s a natural, drug-free treatment it could lead to high numbers of smokers willing to give it a try.

‘It’s a non-invasive, pain-free technique with no side effects so it has a lot of promise to change (smokers’) behaviour,’ he said.

Neurofeedback is just one of the quitting techniques being studied by Prof. Bamidis as part of the EU-funded SmokeFreeBrain project, to evaluate the best ways to stop smoking.

Another technique under examination is SoLoMo, which stands for social-local-mobile and focuses on using physical locations to send tailored information to a mobile device.

‘We are going to use social media techniques translated for local populations and ask them to follow healthy lifestyles with reminders and mini-games,’ said Prof. Bamidis.

SmokeFreeBrain will also assess the effectiveness of e-cigarettes, communication campaigns and more classic approaches like nicotine patches. At the end of the project in 2018, the researchers hope to have a guide outlining the best practices in smoking cessation and how these can be applied on a large scale.

‘We will figure out which approach is the most effective and economic,’ said Prof. Bamidis.

‘Our research will then help form tobacco policy at national and international levels.’

While these techniques and policies will help, any smoker knows that quitting is easier said than done. That leaves us with the bigger question – how do we motivate people to stop people smoking in the first place?

Over the last fifty years the number of smokers in Europe has been declining, but more than 20 % of the adult population still smoke.

‘Policies to ban smoking in public places and general social norms have changed and we see smoking rates have declined, but it has been quite slow,’ said Professor Anton Kunst from the University of Amsterdam, the Netherlands. ‘If it continues at this speed, smoking will persist for many decades to come.’

Ability to quit

In recent years smoking has become concentrated in lower socio-economic areas where the ability to quit is harder due to financial and employment circumstances and the subsequent emotional stress. This in turn creates a spiral where following generations are regularly exposed to those who smoke.

‘Among people in lower socio-economic circles, smoking is much more common and that could be related to factors like more emotional problems and being exposed to smoking amongst friends and parents,’ said Prof. Kunst.

Prof. Kunst is the coordinator of the EU-funded SILNE-R project which is examining how antismoking policies in seven European cities affect the smoking behaviour of 16-year-olds.

Through comparison, the project aims to use the data gathered to create better prevention programs.

‘Different countries and municipalities have different tobacco policies,’ said Prof. Kunst. ‘We want to understand why some policies are able to influence young people and why others are not.’

They have already looked at smoke-free policies in schools, which have revealed findings into youth smoking behaviour.

‘If you ban smoking from school premises it changes the way young people look at smoking and raises awareness of the health hazards,’ said Prof. Kunst.

But while these anti-smoking rules can protect some it could make matters worse for others.

‘Such policies may create peer groups that go out of school to smoke which reinforces the habit and attracts others to start smoking who just wanted to be part of the group,’ said Prof. Kunst.

Possible solutions are to ban smoking in places around schools or to discourage kids from leaving by offering more appealing activities like sports or hobby clubs.

At the end of the project in 2018, SILNE-R hopes to present policy makers with concrete suggestions on how to make anti-smoking policies more effective for young people. In the meantime, Prof. Kunst warns any young smoker not to overestimate their willpower.

‘Young people don’t see how addictive smoking can be and are very confident they will stop later in life,’ said Prof. Kunst. ‘They must be told that there is no silver bullet to quit, that they would need to try hard to stop and find help where they can.’

E-cigarettes: a consumer-led revolution

E-cigarettes are used by millions in the UK, but information about them is sometimes conflicting. So what is the current evidence on them?

https://www.theguardian.com/science/sifting-the-evidence/2015/oct/23/e-cigarettes-a-consumer-led-revolution

It has been described as a ‘disruptive technology’ potentially capable of breaking our fatal relationship with tobacco. So the setting for a public debate on e-cigarettes – a museum part-funded by the tobacco industry, in a city home to the global headquarters of one of the largest tobacco manufacturers – was perhaps ironic. Yet on Wednesday evening, I found myself at the M-Shed in Bristol, watching just that: a debate about whether e-cigarettes could be part of the solution to the tobacco epidemic.

To mark the launch of a new Integrative Cancer Epidemiology Programme, linked to the Medical Research Centre Integrative Epidemiology Unit at the University of Bristol, Professor Marcus Munafò (Professor of Biological Psychology at the University of Bristol) and Professor Linda Bauld (Professor of Health Policy at the University of Stirling), both collaborators of mine, discussed e-cigarettes. Professor Gabriel Scally (Public Health Doctor and former Regional Director of Public Health for the South West of England) chaired the discussion.

Billed as a debate about whether e-cigarettes might be ‘the key to reducing smoking’, some in the audience may have expected a heated discussion. However, with this line-up of academics, influential in the fields of public health, tobacco and addiction, the discussion was evidence-based and measured. As for the motion of the debate, the panel was unanimous: e-cigarettes may not be the key to reducing smoking, but they are certainly an important part of the solution.

This may be surprising to some, given ongoing discussions surrounding e-cigarettes in the media. So what is the current evidence on e-cigarettes?

Although we don’t know the long-term health effects of e-cigarette use, they’re less harmful than cigarettes

Pretty much everything is safer than cigarettes. There is no other consumer product, which, when used as the manufacturer intends, kills every other user, taking from them an average of 10 years of healthy life.

It’s been said that “people smoke for the nicotine, but die from the tar”. E-cigarettes present a solution to this problem by providing a ‘clean’ (or cleaner) method of nicotine delivery. They deliver nicotine in a similar way to a cigarette (and much faster than other forms of nicotine replacement therapy; NRT), but don’t contain the other chemicals that ultimately kill cigarette users.

A recent Public Health England report stated that e-cigarettes are 95% less harmful than cigarettes, a controversial figure. However, as Linda pointed out, it’s almost irrelevant whether e-cigarettes are 95%, 90% or even 80% less harmful than cigarettes. What’s important, is that they are less harmful.

Yes, there are still some concerns about e-cigarettes and increasing levels of confusion and misinformation among the public around them. Evidence suggests that both adults and teenagers are more likely to report that e-cigarettes are equally harmful as cigarettes today, than they were a few years ago. Both Marcus and Linda speculate that these views may have been shaped by media reports fueled by disagreements between academics.

Horror stories of children drinking the liquid nicotine (a problem which can be alleviated by having stricter controls on safety caps) and fires and accidents caused by exploding devices (the frequency of which is still far lower than the risk of fire posed by cigarettes) have been reported in the media. There are ongoing concerns about the chemicals produced when e-cigarettes are used, some of which are the same as the dangerous chemicals found in burning cigarettes (although the amount of these chemicals is a tiny fraction of the amounts found in cigarettes). Finally, we can’t yet be certain about the long-term health consequences of vaping, simply because people haven’t been using them for long enough to know (just like we didn’t know for decades that cigarettes definitely caused lung cancer).

For these reasons, we should be careful to ensure that children and non-smokers don’t start using e-cigarettes – currently there is very little evidence that these groups are regularly using the devices. However, most academics and public health officials are in agreement that for current smokers, e-cigarettes are a safer alternative to smoking.

E-cigarettes can be an effective method of stopping smoking

Linda presented evidence on the effectiveness of e-cigarettes for smoking cessation. E-cigarettes seem to be somewhere in the middle of the range when it comes to helping smokers quit. Some studies show that they are more effective than either willpower alone or NRT bought over the counter, but less effective than behavioural support.

The type of e-cigarette used matters too. The early models (‘1st generation’ or ‘cigalike’ models) don’t seem to be very effective methods of smoking cessation – interestingly, these are predominantly the models being bought up by the tobacco industry. The 2nd generation e-cigarettes and tank models (which can be refilled with liquids) seem to lead to higher levels of quitting success.

The sheer reach of e-cigarettes is their most powerful weapon. While behavioural support for cessation, combined with NRT or varenicline, has been underused by smokers wanting to quit, the rise of e-cigarette use over the past five years has been unprecedented. There are now an estimated 2.6 million vapers in the UK. With such a large numbers of users, even modest levels of smoking cessation success from their use will have a large impact on cessation rates.

E-cigarettes are a consumer-led revolution

The speed of the e-cigarette revolution and its ability to galvanize a whole community of individuals who now define themselves as ‘vapers’ is impressive. Never before has a route out of smoking garnered as much support from its users. As far as I know, there are no online forums for nicotine patch users to discuss optimal patch placement, no celebrity endorsements for nicotine lozenges and no users of nicotine nasal sprays challenging European Union Directives.

Many vapers feel passionately that e-cigarettes have enabled them to quit smoking. Indeed, a passionate crowd was in attendance at the debate. When asked at the beginning to raise their hands if they had ever tried an e-cigarette, over half of the audience did so. This is in comparison to population surveys that report 1.5%, 16.5% and 58.5% rates of ever use among non-smokers, ex-smokers and daily smokers respectively.

The last question in the debate came from a member of the public who defined himself as a ‘vaper and ex-smoker’. He expressed his dismay that new the EU Tobacco Products Directive (TPD – due to come into force in May 2016) will impose strict regulations on e-cigarettes, including bottle sizes, tank sizes and nicotine strength. In order to continue selling e-cigarettes not meeting these new regulations, retailers can instead apply for their products to be registered as medicines. But this is an extremely costly route, likely to be impractical for the majority of e-cigarette retailers other than the incredibly wealthy tobacco industry. The TPD is currently being challenged by one e-cigarette retailer. However, if it goes ahead, there are concerns from vapers and those in the public health community, that it may mean the end of vaping as we know it.

Arguably one of the reasons why e-cigarettes are so popular is that they reflect a consumer-led revolution, built from the ground up. Users can personalise their product, and many see vaping as a lifestyle choice rather than a smoking cessation aid or a medicine. If strict regulation means fewer smokers switch to using e-cigarettes, this could be a huge public health opportunity missed.

Olivia Maynard is a tobacco researcher at the University of Bristol. You can find her on twitter @oliviamaynard17.

Toxins Remain in Home Long After Smokers Quit

http://www.newsmax.com/Health/Health-News/toxins-tobacco-smoke-quit/2016/10/05/id/751753/

Toxins from tobacco smoke persists in smokers’ homes for at least six months after they quit and remain a threat to nonsmoking residents, according to researchers.

The team studied 65 smokers who were quit smoking and discovered that tiny particles from burning tobacco get into surfaces such as carpets, wallpaper, ceiling tiles upholstery, clothes, blankets and pillows and were still present long after a smoker quit, The New York Times reported.

There were large immediate declines in nicotine on surfaces and in dust, which then leveled off and remained the same, but still detectable, by the end of the study period, according to the study in the journal Tobacco Control.

And even six months after smokers quit, nonsmokers still in the same home still had detectable levels of a marker of tobacco exposure in their urine after six months, The Times reported.