Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

The Standard: Activists push for 100% tax on tobacco

from Qi Luo, reporting for the Standard:

Anti-smoking lobbyists are urging the government to increase the tobacco tax to at least 75 percent immediately and to 100 percent by the next fiscal year.

The Council on Smoking and Health said the current tax accounts for between 65 and 68 percent of the retail price, which is below the 70 percent recommended by the World Health Organization.

Based on past experiences when tax was raised in the territory, the council estimates that the prevalence of smoking will further drop from 10.7 percent to single digits after one to two years from when the 100 percent tax hike takes effect.

“The tobacco tax was hiked by 50percent and 41.5 percent in 2009 and 2011, respectively. As a result, the incidence of smoking dropped from 12 percent in 2009 to 10.7 percent in 2012,” executive director Vienna Lai Wai-yin said. “A high tobacco tax will push smokers to quit or reduce tobacco consumption, as well as prevent those who plan to start smoking, especially youngsters.”

Lam Tai-hing, professor in the University of Hong Kong’s School of Public Health, said about one in two smokers die of diseases related to their habit.

“We are saving lives. The sooner, the better,” he said.

The tax on an average pack of cigarettes, sold for HK$52 over the counter, is HK$34.

If the proposal to hike the tax to 100percent is accepted by the financial secretary, the retail price for a pack of cigarettes will increase to HK$84. A survey by the School of Public Health found that a majority – 63.5 percent – of the 2,401 respondents supported an increase in tobacco tax.

“Nearly one-third of ex-smokers who quit after 2011 agreed that the tobacco tax increase that year made them more determined to quit,” Lam said.

“More than 31.4 percent of current smokers reduced their daily consumption after the 2011 tax increase.”

The council also called for more resources for tobacco control.

Chairwoman Lisa Lau Man-man said: “COSH wants more smoke-free education and other tobacco control measures, including combating smuggling and enforcement of smoking offenses.”

20 Nov 2013

Guardian: Cigarettes could get plain packaging by 2015 after (UK) government U-turn

from Denis Campbell and Patrick Wintour of the Guardian:

Cigarettes could be sold only in plain packets after a government U-turn on a major public health policy that previously appeared to have been dropped.

In a surprise move the coalition is set to give ministers the power to introduce the policy, although actual implementation will be subject to an evidence review.

The latest volte face came after a cross party group of peers tabled amendments to the children and families bill that would have introduced standardised packaging.

The group, led by Lord Faulkner, were confident of winning the vote in the Lords since they had prestigious medical support in the Lords for the measure.

The evidence review, which will be led by Sir Cyril Chantler, a distinguished doctor, academic and NHS administrator, will report by the end of March.

Subject to its findings, plain packaging could be in force before the 2015 general election.

(more…)

ITV: Plain packets ruling a ‘victory for public health’

from ITV news:

The chief executive of health charity Action on Smoking and Health (Ash) said the decision to introduce plain packaging is a “victory for public health” and hailed the “positive impact” of the move in Australia, which introduced standardised packaging almost a year ago.

This decision is a victory for public health, for common sense and for future generations who will as a result be protected from glitzy, colourful and misleading tobacco packaging.

The Government should be given due credit for being willing to listen to Parliament and to the experts and change its mind.

We understand the need for a review of the evidence and we are pleased that this will be carried out with the necessary speed to ensure that it reports early in the Spring.

– Deborah Arnott, Ash chief executive

28 Nov 2013

Jakarta Post: Indonesia to accede to tobacco treaty before 2014

from Nadya Natahadibrata of the Jakarta Post:

Health Minister Nafsiah Mboi said that Indonesia would finally accede to the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) before the end of this year, a major step in the fight against prevalent smoking addiction.

“The treaty accession will be completed through a presidential decree. The President has agreed [to accede to the treaty]. God willing we will accede to the treaty before the end of the year,” Nafsiah said.

As previously reported Nafsiah said that three ministries, namely the Trade Ministry, Industry Ministry and the Manpower and Transmigration Ministry, had previously rejected the accession, and added that it would hurt tobacco farmers and reduce the state’s income in tobacco excise, which had a big contribution to the state budget.

“All three ministries have agreed to accede to the treaty. They have agreed that the accession is solely aimed at protecting the public,” Nafsiah told reporters on the sidelines of the closing ceremony of National Health Day on Friday.

According to Nafsiah, the government is currently drafting the text to be submitted to the Foreign Ministry before being signed by President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

(more…)

Irish Times: Cabinet approves heads of Bill to force companies to sell cigarettes in plain cartons

from Eoin Burke-Kennedy for the Irish Times:

Minister for Health James Reilly said he would be “astonished” if legislation proposing cigarettes be sold only in plain packs did not prompt legal action from the tobacco industry.

He was speaking today after the Cabinet unanimously approved the heads of a Bill which will force tobacco companies to sell cigarettes in standardised cartons with graphic health warnings.

The Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill 2013 will outlaw all forms of branding on cigarette packs from trademarks and logos to colours and graphics.

The Bill, which will also determine the size and position of the warnings, will now be submitted for hearings by the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Health and Children for review and report.

Chairman of the Joint Oireachtas Health Committee Jerry Buttimer (left) and Minister for Health James Reilly during a media breifing at Government Buildings where it was announced that Cabinet had approved the General Scheme for the Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill 2013. (Irish Times/Gareth Chaney Collins)

(more…)

The road towards plain packaging

The issue of plain packaging for tobacco has come to the forefront, with Scotland following Australia’s legislation to enforce plain packaging on all tobacco products, for which studies conducted by the British Medical Journal has shown to be effective in discouraging smoking. Ria Patel reports for TopNews:

Scotland to introduce standardised packaging of cigarettes in 2014-15

After Australia, Scotland is going to be the second country that is introducing plain packaging for cigarettes. The Scottish Government has announced that the regulation will be active in 2014-15.

Scottish Public Health Minister Michael Matheson said he wants to see Scotland in the forefront when it comes to reducing the harms caused by tobacco.

Matheson informed that the tobacco industry has challenged them. But Matheson affirmed they will remain determined to introduce plain packaging.

“To build a generation free from tobacco it is necessary to restrict the imagery and design that tobacco companies use to pull in another generation to use these addictive and lethal products”, affirmed Matheson.

(more…)

Tax-News: Belgium Backs Royal Decree On Tobacco Tax Rise

by Ulrika Thomas, for Tax-News:

On the recommendation of Finance Minister Koen Geens, the Belgian Council of Ministers has approved a draft Royal Decree, providing for a rise in the excise duty rates imposed on tobacco.

As a result, from January 1, 2014, the excise duty on cigarettes will be fixed at EUR6.8914 (USD9.2) per 1,000 pieces, while the special excise duty rate will be EUR16.70 per 1,000 pieces. For smoking tobacco, the excise duty will be fixed at EUR0 per kilo, while the special excise duty rate will be set at EUR14.5 per kilo.

Furthermore, the minimal excise on the weighted average price is increased to 101 percent for cigarettes, and to 102 percent for smoking tobacco.

The draft Royal Decree provisionally modifies the Belgian law from April 3, 1997, governing the tax regime for manufactured tobacco.

11 Nov 2013

ASH News and Events Bulletin – 16-31 October 2013

ASH News and Events Bulletin – 16-31 October 2013
HEADLINES

Tobacco News
Australia’s ‘plain packaging’ stubs out cigarette branding, prompting backlash
Opinion: Communication is a determinant of public health
Opinion: Menthol cigarettes: Stub out these seductive smokes
Opinion: Tobacco companies are savvy about the power of branding
Reducing tobacco consumption among low-income smokers
Scotland set to go it alone with standard packs for cigarettes
Should advertising for e-cigarettes be more tightly regulated?
Should we raise the legal age for buying cigarettes?
The benefits of Stoptober
UK medical journals will no longer consider research funded by tobacco industry
USA: Getting schooled on tobacco
What’s smoking doing to your body?
Parliamentary News
Debate: Tobacco Products Directive
Parliamentary question: E-cigarettes
Parliamentary question: E-cigarette
Parliamentary question: Smoking trends
Parliamentary question: Smoking: Young People
Parliamentary question: Passive Smoking: Children
Jane Ellison: All hands on deck
Industry Watch
Price hikes offset sliding sales at cigarette maker Philip Morris
BAT apologises for advertising e-cigarette in kids’ app
Japan Tobacco International posts revenue growth despite volume dip
US cigarette industry registered a 4% drop in sales through 2012
Are tobacco stocks no longer bulletproof?
Nicolites ‘kicks butt’ with sales campaign
Recent Research
New statistic model forecasts effect of tobacco consumption on childhood asthma
Novel delivery systems for NRT
Perceptions of users of plain and branded cigarette packs
Smoking might influence pain tolerance

EVENTS

E-Cigarette Summit: Science, Regulation and Public Health
Going Local: Tobacco control in the new public health landscape
Sex, Drugs and Roll ups: Risky behaviour and public health
Reducing Smoking Prevalence through Tobacco Control and Smoking Cessation Conference
SmokeFree Sports Research Seminar
Smoking Cessation: Protecting the Health of the Nation

(more…)

Philip Morris leads bold challenge to Thai Government over legislation

While tobacco companies are known to lobby governments and MPs over legislation for tobacco control, Philip Morris is now leading them to take an even bolder step. They have filed an injunction against a move by Thailand’s health ministry to increase the size of graphic health warnings on cigarette packs to 85%, up from the current 55%, effectively making a direct challenge on the government’s mandate to rule. The court ruling for the injunction will delay the policy change by about 3 months, giving Philip Morris ample time to lobby against the new ruling.

from Ron Corben of Voice of America:

Thailand’s Health Ministry battles Big Tobacco over graphic health warnings

Major international tobacco companies are mounting a legal challenge to Thai health ministry plans to increase graphic health warnings on cigarette packaging. The court battle has wide implications for Thai health policy measures seeking to reduce smoking and combat cancer.

In Thailand lung cancer rates are rising for both sexes and becoming a leading cause of death in men.  In a policy backed by the World Health Organization (WHO) Thailand’s Ministry of Public Health is planning to increase the size of anti-smoking advertisements on cigarette packaging from 55 percent of the package, to 85 percent.

The WHO believes the large graphic pictures of sick people suffering from the effects of smoking are one of the most effective measures to reduce smoking.

The warning signs are printed on the cigarette packets on sale in Bangkok, Thailand. (AP, VOA)

But new regulations that were due to come into effect on October 2 were blocked by international tobacco companies led by Philip Morris with a legal injunction.

The companies argue the ministry exceeded its legal authority and failed to consult thousands of retailers and manufacturers. They also claim the larger warnings undermine the use of trade marks to differentiate products in the market.

Pokpong Srisanit, a Thammasat University law professor, says the challenge to the health ministry by the companies is a first in Thailand.  “When the Ministry of Public Health announce a new regulation normally the big company and the small tobacco company obey the regulation. Now, the case of the 85 per cent pictorial health warning the three big companies sued the Ministry of Public Health — just one [the first] case in the history of tobacco control in Thailand,” he stated.

Thailand is adopting measures set out by the WHO’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control which supports the use of health warnings on packaging to deter smokers.

The WHO said it is backing the Thai Government, and warnings on packaging are considered highly effective measures to reduce tobacco use.

International tobacco company, Philip Morris, argues that further regulations on the health effects of its products are unnecessary as the risks associated with smoking are already widely known.

Medical doctor, Prakit Vachesatogkit, an adviser to the Tobacco Control Division of the Ministry of Public Health, says Thailand is following policies similar to those in Australia, Uruguay and Sri Lanka in recent years.

“The net effect of the graphic warning is it will eventually decrease the smoking, it will make the smoker start to quit. It is not just on graphic warnings but other tobacco control measures such as the banning of smoking [in places], [and] price increases. So it’s a combination of effects,” said Vachesatogkit. “It will not just decrease the lung cancer it will also decrease other diseases as a result of decreased smoking.”

Australian lawyer and member of the Federal government’s expert advisory group on measures to reduce smoking, Jonathan Liberman, said the case is about governments ability to regulate industry in the interest of public health.

“Countries have to defend these measures against these legal claims and legal threats that are brought by the tobacco industry. It tries to intimidate governments and sue them, rather than just allow them to implement the measures that will reduce death and disease and enormous social and economic costs. The government’s can’t be intimidated there’s too much at stake,” said Liberman.

Both the companies and the Thai health ministry are presenting their cases before the Administrative Court. A ruling by the court is expected late this year or in early 2014.

8 Oct 2013

Tobacco industry victorious as EU fails to pass tougher laws against tobacco marketing

In the 12 years since the EU first passed the Tobacco Products Directive (TPD)- a set of regulations limiting tobacco sales and promotions aiming to reduce the number of smokers and thereby improving the health of EU citizens – the tobacco industry has been finding loopholes to get around the regulations. Last Tuesday (8 Oct 2013), Members of the EU Parliament (MEPs) were scheduled to vote on an important revision of the Directive. Health warnings on cigarette packets were to be increased, attractive cigarette marketing were to be banned, and electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) were to come under strict regulations.

As it turns out, the tobacco industry already got hold of every detail of the proposed revisions within the 24 hours that they were made behind closed doors. The tobacco companies launched an extraordinarily aggressive lobbying campaign, with Philip Morris International spearheading the effort. Third parties sympathetic to the tobacco cause, such as tobacco retailers and consumers, were roped in to speak against the TPD. More serious, though, is that the tobacco lobby managed to hold large numbers of meetings with some 233-250 MEPs, or about a third of the European Parliament, and used their large economic power to influence them in a period of austerity. Philip Morris’ response in light of the reports is that everything it has done is legitimate, and that if conversely they were to remain silent over the proposal (which was not meant for their ears anyway) it would have been illogical.

The tobacco lobby ropes in third parties and appeals for misplaced sympathy to their economic interests (ITGA)

The result of the vote was a victory for the tobacco lobby, as they succeeded in influencing several crucial areas of contention: increase in warning sizes on cigarette packs will be 65% rather than 75%, ‘slim’ cigarettes targeting young people will not be banned while menthol flavours will only receive a gradual phase-out into 2022, and e-cigarettes will not be regulated as medicines.

Not satisfied with the victory, the tobacco lobby and MEPs with outright support for the industry continues to defend the vote by labelling the initial proposals as ‘crazy’ or unnecessary. Health officials, on the other hand, calls it ‘shameful’ that the European Parliament settled for watered-down rules, placing the health and interests of EU citizens at risk.

More in-depth information can be read from an earlier post, taken from the blog Tobacco Unpacked.

Read more on the event below:

Taken from Reuters UK, 4 Oct 2013:

“There is an unprecedentedly intense lobbying campaign from the industry going on inside the European Parliament with the express intention of trying to frustrate this legislation,” a senior Irish official said on Friday, briefing journalists on condition of anonymity.

“This is completely on a scale way beyond lobbying that normally goes on.”

He said officials had been surprised to discover that cigarette manufacturers and their lobbyists had knowledge of precise elements of the law barely 24 hours after they were agreed behind closed doors.

Internal Philip Morris documents leaked to the media and seen by Reuters show that lobbyists have held over 250 meetings with members of parliament to discuss the legislation, especially with conservatives.

In a statement last month responding to criticism, Philip Morris said it was merely trying to express its views on the legislative proposals, and pointed out that it employed 12,500 people in the EU and had invested hundreds of millions of euros.

“The argument that we should remain silent in the face of a proposal that directly concerns us, and on which we have facts and improvement ideas to share, is illogical,” said Drago Azinovic, the president of the company for the EU region.

“We have and will continue to express our views proactively and transparently. As the EU itself says, this kind of interaction is ‘constant, legitimate and necessary for the quality of democracy’.”

Taken from a joint open letter of 11 health organisations to the President of the EU, 1 Oct 2013:

There is widespread concern that the decision to delay the plenary vote on the TPD was a result of tobacco companies like Philip Morris International and others using their economic and political power to influence MEPs. The postponement of the vote is widely believed to be part of a tobacco industry strategy to delay, weaken or even derail the TPD. The leaked documents show that no less than 233 MEPs (almost one third of the Parliament) have been met by Philip Morris International lobbyists at least once. Several MEPs were listed as having had four or five such meetings.

This large number of meetings (which have taken place behind closed doors, without any transparency such as the publication of minutes from these meetings), constitutes a serious violation of the World Health Organisation Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC) Article 5.3 which is geared towards safeguarding public health policy-making from tobacco industry interference. FCTC Article 5.3 recognises the fundamental and irreconcilable conflict of interest between the tobacco industry and public health policy-making. It also recognises that the tobacco industry has, for decades, been working tirelessly to delay, block, and weaken life-saving health measures, like those enshrined in the FCTC.

FCTC Article 5.3 requires all Parties, when deciding on their public health policies with respect to tobacco control to “. . . act to protect these policies from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry in accordance with national law”.

The WHO’s accompanying guidelines stipulate that decision-makers “should interact with the tobacco industry only when and to the extent strictly necessary to enable them to effectively regulate the tobacco industry and tobacco products.”

The guidelines state that “where interactions with the tobacco industry are necessary, Parties should ensure that such interactions are conducted transparently”.

Taken from European Voice, 3 Oct 2013:

Internal documents from American tobacco giant Philip Morris International, seen by European Voice, suggest that this company alone has used 161 lobbyists, who met 233 MEPs – 31% of the Parliament – from the start of 2011 to June 2012. About half of EPP and ECR MEPs met the company’s lobbyists during that time. A slide presentation from 2011 identified delaying the legislation as a possible way to defeat it.

Last month Margaret Chan, director-general of the World Health Organization (WHO), accused the tobacco lobby of using a “massive army” to “sabotage” the EU vote. She suggested that the lobbyists were trying to delay the legislation until the start of the Greek presidency of the EU on 1 January, hoping that Greece would shelve the directive because it was more tobacco-friendly than the preceding presidencies of Ireland and Lithuania. She also noted that Philip Morris is opening a European distribution centre in Greece.

“Here industry is counting on the historical pattern where economic and commercial interests trump public health concerns,” she told the conference.

The aftermath, taken from the Independent, 8 Oct 2013,

MEPs rejected plans to ban so-called “slim” cigarettes that are particularly attractive to young smokers and opted to phase out menthol cigarettes over eight years rather than three.

They also backed away from proposals to increase the size of health warnings on cigarette packs to cover 75 per cent of the box – agreeing instead to the 65 per cent figure suggested by the industry. The current requirement for health warnings is for 30 per cent minimum coverage on one side and 40 per cent on the other.

“This is a shameful day for the European Parliament, as a centre-right majority has done the bidding of the tobacco industry and voted for weaker rules, which are totally at odds with citizens’ interests and public health,” said Carl Schlyter, who co-chairs the public health committee. “The parliament’s public health committee voted for robust legislation, with a view to tackling the 700,000 Europeans who die from smoking every year, but the core proposals have been scaled back. The only real victors from today’s vote are big tobacco firms, whose aggressive and expensive lobbying campaigns have paid off.”

MEPs rejected calls for e-cigarettes to be subject to the same regulation as nicotine replacement therapies such as patches and gum. The lack of tobacco in e-cigarettes means they are “almost certainly” a much safer way of getting a nicotine hit than smoking cigarettes, according to Cancer Research.

Chris Davies, a Liberal Democrat MEP, said: “E-cigs can be a game changer. Hundreds of former smokers have written to tell me that they have helped them give up cigarettes when nothing else worked. They are successful because they are not medicines but products that smokers enjoy using as an alternative to cigarettes.”

Taken from the Guardian, 8 Oct 2013:

The UK e-cigarette industry, which broadly welcomed the parliament’s vote, said it was already in talks with the Advertising Standards Authority but added that it would not be “sensible, proportionate, reasonable or useful” to ban all advertising.

MEPs decided e-cigarettes should only be regulated as medical products if manufacturers claimed they could cure or prevent smoking tobacco – a decision criticised by the government’s main medicines regulator.

They want to put the products, used by an estimated 1.3 million people in Britain by next year, on the same legal basis as gums, patches and mouth sprays aimed at helping smokers to quit but the industry says the expensive process of licensing would help force alternatives to tobacco off the shelves.

Linda McAvan, Labour MEP for Yorkshire and the Humber and spokesman on tobacco issues for the parliament’s Socialist and Democrat group, said: “We know that it is children, not adults, who start smoking. And despite the downward trend in most member states of adult smokers, the World Health Organisation figures show worrying upward trends in a number of our member states of young smokers.

“We need to stop tobacco companies targeting young people with an array of gimmicky products and we need to make sure that cigarette packs carry effective warnings.”

Martin Callanan, the Conservative MEP for North East England, said: “Forcing e-cigs off the shelves would have been totally crazy. These are products that have helped countless people stop smoking more harmful cigarettes and yet some MEPs wanted to make them harder to manufacture than ordinary tobacco.”

Katherine Devlin, president of Ecita, the e-cigarette industry association, said “the really important” decision by MEPs not to support medicines regulation meant that was now off the table.

British American Tobacco claimed the larger health warnings demanded by MEPs went “well beyond” what was needed to inform consumers of health risks from smoking while a ban on mentholated cigarettes would increase demand for black-market goods.