Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

KPMG Conflicting Reports

James Middleton – CTA – 21 June 09

KPMG Hong Kong discounted the ‘once a week pub brigade’ in their survey produced to Legco which was considering the anti smoking legislation

Legislative Council

LC Paper No. CB(2)491/02-03
http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr02-03/english/panels/hs/minutes/hs021025.pdf

18. Mr Thomas Stanley of KPMG replied that he could not give an answer to Ms HO’s first question, as the customers who indicated that they would eat and drink out less often when the smoking ban was in place were not asked whether they intended to do so on a short-term or long-term basis. As regards Ms HO’s second question, Mr Stanley said that including people who never set foot in restaurants, cafes, bars and food and beverage outlets in hotels in the survey would not significantly alter the existing findings, as the number of people from this group who would patronise catering venues when the smoking ban was in place would be a very negligible number. Ms HO queried the validity of Mr Stanley’s reply to her second question, as it could not be assumed that people who presently did not dine and drink out would continue to do so after the implementation of the smoking ban if no studies had been made to find out the reasons why they presently did not set foot in catering venues.
Whereas KPMG UK found they were the most significant factor set to make the difference
“The key group of people within the survey is the ‘once a week brigade’.

http://www.kpmg.co.uk/news/detail.cfm?pr=2085

KPMG: Smoking ban to boost pub company profits
Industries 10 November 2004

Increased custom from the ‘once a week’ pub-goer looks set to make the difference
Despite fears to the contrary, pub landlords seem set to profit from a smoking ban being introduced into pubs, according to new survey data released today.

The survey, undertaken by YouGov on behalf of professional services firm KPMG, shows that people who normally visit pubs infrequently will visit more often with a ban in place, while more regular pub-goers are unlikely to be discouraged from going as a result of a ban.

Over 2100 people took part in the on-line YouGov survey, of whom a quarter were smokers. Sixty-four percent of respondents were in favour of a ban with only 26% firmly against. Of those survey respondents who do visit pubs, 27% believe they will go more often with a ban in place, 19% would visit less often with 54% unconcerned by the issue.

Commenting on the results, David Matthews, Head of Drinks at KPMG, said: “The key group of people within the survey is the ‘once a week brigade’. Representing 56% of the survey base, they are the single largest group within the survey and thus have the most clout. Sixty-five percent of them are in favour of a smoking ban and 29% believe they would visit pubs more often if a ban was introduced. Even when balanced against an anticipated small loss of trade amongst more regular pub-goers, this indicates that landlords and pub companies will benefit from a net increase in trade.”

“The net increase in profits may not be a huge amount but it will come as an unexpected bonus for those involved in the pub trade who may have thought that a smoking ban could only have a detrimental effect on their business.”

Amongst those people who visit pubs two or three times a week, 25% are likely to visit less often with a ban in place yet 22% would visit more often. As for the true pub regulars (more than three visits per week) 24% would visit less often with a ban in place but 20% would step up their attendance even further. This represents a small net trading deficit in both instances but as these two groups only make up 20% of the total survey database, that deficit is easily off-set by the increased custom amongst those who visit just once a week.

The survey also highlights how a smoking ban would even be sufficient to convince habitual non-pub goers into visiting at some point. Around a quarter of the people surveyed claim they never visit pubs yet 40% of that same group would be more inclined to visit if a ban was in place.

Further good news for pub landlords comes in the results of whether people would be inclined to spend longer in a pub, on average, per visit if a ban was in place. Twenty-seven percent of people believe they would stay in the pub longer, compared to 20% who believe their visits would be shorter because of a ban.

David Matthews continued: “The stats on increasing average visit times may not come as a real surprise as a smoking ban is always going to make a pub a more attractive venue to many people. However, combined with the efforts which some pub companies are making to encourage responsible drinking and to eliminate binge drinking, a ban should be sufficient to see a whole new wave of customers coming through pub doors – and staying for longer.”
“Pub companies may not be the only ones to benefit. Of those people who believe they would spend less time in pubs due to a ban, just over half of them believe that their alcoholic consumption levels would not fall as a result. Assuming they’re not simply spending the same amount of money in a pub – just in shorter visits – then their custom will be transferred to off-licenses and supermarkets. The purchases may subsequently be consumed at home but at least these people’s spending power is not being lost to the drinks industry as a whole.”

Other findings of the survey include:
§ Only 59% of smokers were against a smoking ban. Twenty-five percent were actually in favour;
§ Forty-nine percent of people visiting pubs more than once a week are in favour of a ban, compared to 65% amongst the ‘once a week’ group and 70% of those who don’t visit pubs;
§ You can’t please all of the people all of the time: 49% of non-smokers who never go to pubs would still not be enticed in by the prospect of a ban.
-Ends-

Media enquiries: Please contact Simon Griffiths (KPMG Corporate Communications) on 0121 232 3760 or 07887 657919 or at simon.m.griffiths@kpmg.co.uk

Notes to Editors:
KPMG is the global network of professional services firms who provide audit, tax and advisory services.
KPMG LLP operates from 22 offices across the UK with 9,000 partners and staff.
KPMG recorded a UK fee income of £1,008 million in the year ended September 2003.
KPMG LLP, a UK limited liability partnership, is the UK member firm of KPMG International, a Swiss cooperative.
http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr02-03/english/panels/hs/papers/hs1025cb2-1-2e.pdf

In 2001 KPMG Hong Kong was engaged by the Hong Kong Catering Industry Association to report on how a proposed smoking ban in Hong Kong restaurants would affect business. The report predicted multi billion dollar losses and loss of jobs in the Hong Kong catering industry. This has been proven to be completely wrong (by a massive margin of +40%) by HK Government Census and Statistics department data. However an exemption period was granted to the bars, mahjong parlours, nightclubs and karaoke establishments until July 01 2009.

Public money paid for this KPMG Hong Kong report.

The Government must investigate why the consultants got it so wrong and whether tobacco money was paid through the HK Catering Industry Association to fund this report.
Whereas when the KPMG client was the City of Ottawa in the same timeframe it found completely differently:
KPMG LLP was engaged by the City of Ottawa to provide assistance in the ongoing
monitoring of the economic and health impacts of the smoke free by laws covering public places and places of work that went into effect August 01, 2001

http://www.ocat.org/economics/index.html
December 2001 KPMG report
The first KPMG report, The Economic Impact Analysis of the No-Smoking Bylaw on the Hospitality Industry in Ottawa was released December 2001. It discussed factors taken into considering when trying to gauge the exact economic impact of the smoking bylaws, which included September 11/01, tourism trends, and the general economic climate. The first report found no evidence that the bylaws had a negative economic impact on the hospitality sector. Some other findings were:

Employment in the Ottawa accommodation and food service sector rose 6.5 percent from June to October (from 22,800 to 24,300) despite the decline in total employment from 585,500 to 566,900 (a decline of 18,600 or 3.1 percent).

Employment Insurance claims in the accommodation and food service industries declined by 5 percent in August 2001 compared to August 2000 and by 9 percent in October over a year previous. Claims increased by 1 percent in September 2001 relative to a year earlier.
Bankruptcy and insolvency statistics for restaurants were lower for the period August to November than they had been the last 2 years (7 versus 12 last year and 8 in 1999). Two tavern, bar or nightclub operations underwent insolvency procedures this year, versus 1 last year and 2 in 1999.

The number of bars and taverns by the end of 2000 was 122. By June 2001, the number had climbed to 130, a 6.5% increase over six months

November 2002 KPMG report
As a follow-up to its December 2001 report, KPMG was asked by the City of Ottawa to conduct a second study, focused exclusively on Ottawa bars and pubs, in order to determine if they were adversely affected as a sub-sector. The decision to proceed with the second study followed allegations by PUBCO (an association of pubs and bars opposed to Ottawa ‘s smoking bylaws) that the impact on bars and pubs is much greater than the impact on restaurants, and would be hidden in sector-wide examinations of economic impacts.

After consultation and developing the study methodology with PUBCO and the Ottawa chapter of the Ontario Restaurant, Hotel and Motel Association (ORHMA), KPMG attempted to carry out this survey in March-May 2002, but was unable to obtain responses from a sufficient number of identified bars and pubs in order to produce statistically valid results. ( Click here to access the letter from KPMG to Ottawa ‘s Medical Officer of Health which describes the methodology and lack of cooperation by bar and pubs). The high refusal rate raised the question of why bars and pubs allegedly losing money as a result of Ottawa ‘s bylaws would not wish to provide economic data proving the allegation, and called into question PUBCO’s assertions of economic loss in this sector.

Despite the low number of survey responses, the second KPMG report, Economic Impact Analysis of the Smoke-Free Bylaws on the Hospitality Industry in Ottawa, (“This suggests the smoke free by law has had little or no negative impact on the industry as a whole”)
was made public on November 2002. Because only 51 bars and pubs out of the 150 sample submitted sales tax receipts and some bars with increased sales did not respond to the survey, no conclusion could be drawn regarding whether or not the smoking bylaws have had any economic impact on bars and pubs in Ottawa .

Instead, the second KPMG report discussed the many factors that have affected the Ottawa business climate over the year prior to the release of the November 2002 report. Factors such as the high-tech industry crash and corresponding layoffs, decreased tourism and business travel following September 11/01, increased consumption of liquor and decreased consumption of beer, and changing customer preferences are factors when taken together or separately, have had more impact on the hospitality industry than the smoking bylaws in isolation.

However, KPMG noted that overall, the hospitality sector in Ottawa continued to grow, with 90 establishments closing since the bylaws were implemented and 123 establishments opening, resulting in approximately 1,600 licensed establishments, and an increase in 33 new restaurants and bars opening over the last year. The growth in numbers of new establishments indicates a healthy hospitality sector, despite changes in consumer preferences and normal turnover fluctuations. Furthermore, Employment Insurance applications significantly decreased since May 2002.

KPMG finally concluded: “in the overall economic context, the food and beverage industry appears to be stronger than one would expect. This suggests the smoke-free bylaw has had little or no negative impact on the industry as a whole.”

As of March 2003, 181 new bars and restaurants have opened in Ottawa since August 2001. For a list of establishments, and the accompanying press release from the office of Ottawa City Councillor Dwight Eastman, contact OCAT.

In June 2003, the Ontario Tobacco Research Unit released a study that showed Smoking Ban Has No Impact on Food, Drink Sales: U of T Research
http://www.ocat.org/pdf/Final_KPMG_report_Nov_2002.pdf

New Sheriff in Town

June 13, 2009

The Senate passed a bill Thursday giving the FDA a say in how the tobacco industry conducts its business. Newsy.com looks at how the story was covered.

http://www.newsy.com/videos/new_sheriff_in_town

Senate Votes for F.D.A. Rules on Tobacco

DUFF WILSON ,  www.nytimes.com, June 12, 2009

WASHINGTON – The Senate voted overwhelmingly Wednesday to impose federal regulation on cigarettes and other forms of tobacco, passing a landmark bill to empower the Food and Drug Administration to control products that eventually kill half their regular users.

The House expects to vote Friday on the legislation and quickly send it to the President Obama for signing into law, Karen Lightfoot, spokeswoman for Henry A, Waxman, its prime sponsor, said in an interview late Thursday afternoon. The Senate legislation has only minor differences from a version the House passed in April. A White House spokesman, Reid H. Cherlin, said that President Obama, who was a co-sponsor of the bill when he was in the Senate, would sign the legislation when it reached his desk.

An estimated one in five people in this country smoke, and more than 400,000 of them die each year from smoking-related disease. But for decades, even after the surgeon general’s 1964 report declaring cigarettes a health hazard, Congressional efforts to regulate tobacco had met stiff opposition from lawmakers from tobacco-growing states and their political allies. And when the F.D.A. tried on its own to start regulating nicotine as a drug, the Supreme Court struck down that effort in 2000, saying the agency could not take such a step without Congressional authority. Cigarettes remained less regulated than cosmetics or pet food.

But with broad bipartisan support in both the Senate and House, and a campaign pledge by Barack Obama to sign such legislation if he became president, the anti-tobacco forces came into alignment. “This long-overdue grant of authority to F.D.A. to regulate tobacco products means that the agency can finally take the actions needed to protect our people from the most deadly of all consumer products,” Edward M. Kennedy, the Massachusetts Democrat who was chief sponsor of the legislation in the Senate, said in a statement from home, where he is receiving treatment for a brain tumor.

The Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, as it is called, would empower the F.D.A. to set standards for cigarettes, regulating chemicals in cigarette smoke and outlawing most tobacco flavorings. It could also study whether to also ban menthol. Flavorings are considered a lure to first-time smokers, especially the young. Menthol is used by three-quarters of black smokers, who also have a disproportionate share of lung cancer.

The law would also further restrict marketing and advertising of tobacco products. Colorful advertising and store displays will be replaced by black-and-white-only text as part of restrictions aimed at reducing the appeal to youth to try smoking. Cigarette makers will be required to stop using terms like “light” and “low tar” by next year and to place large and graphic health warnings on their packages by 2012.

But while the F.D.A. could mandate a reduced level of nicotine, an addictive chemical, the law expressly says the agency cannot ban it. Public health advocates say outlawing nicotine would force addicts would turn to a black market or other sources.
Still, health advocates predict that F.D.A. product standards could eventually reduce some of the 60 carcinogens and 4,000 toxins in cigarette smoke, or make them taste so bad they deter users.

“This is a bill not for a one-year or two-year splash, but for a long-term impact,” said Matthew L. Myers, president of the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, a Washington advocacy group that took a lead in coordinating support for the legislation. The Altria Group, the parent company of Philip Morris, whose Marlboro brand helps make it the nation’s leading tobacco seller, endorsed the F.D.A. legislation and negotiated some of its crucial provisions with Congress.

The Congressional Budget Office had estimated that the F.D.A. legislation would reduce youth smoking by 11 percent and adult smoking by 2 percent over the next decade beyond the declines that had already resulted from public education, higher taxes and smoke-free indoor space laws.

At least partly because of such other efforts, cigarette smoking has declined measurably over the last decade: in 2005, about 21 percent of adults in the United States were smokers, compared with about 25 percent in 1995. Reynolds America and Lorillard, the second- and third-largest companies, opposed the legislation and criticized it as being intended to protect Philip Morris’s market dominance by restricting advertising and new products.

But Brendan McCormick, a spokesman for Philip Morris’s parent, Altria, argued that previous marketing restrictions, like the television advertising ban imposed in 1971, had not frozen companies’ market shares.

He said his company supported “federal regulation and the benefits it will bring to tobacco consumers and the greater predictability and stability we think it will bring to the tobacco industry.”

There are only minor differences between the Senate bill and the one the House passed in April – the main one involving the size of the graphic warnings on cigarette packs, which would be bigger under the Senate version.

Henry A. Waxman, the California Democratic who was chief sponsor of the House bill, said in an interview that he hoped the House could simply pass the Senate version of the bill next week to send quickly to the President.

“I would prefer we do that,” Mr. Waxman said, adding that it was still possible to call a conference committee instead to negotiate the minor differences. But that process, he said, could delay action and risk another Senate filibuster of the type that was broken Monday in a crucial vote of 61 Senators, two more than needed to proceed to final action. That filibuster had been mounted by Richard M. Burr, Republican of North Carolina, the nation’s leading tobacco-growing state. Only one Democrat – Kay Hagan, also of North Carolina – had voted to uphold the filibuster.

On Tuesday, the Senate voted 60 to 36 against a substitute bill by Mr. Burr and Ms. Hagan to promote smokeless and other “reduced risk” products rather than strictly regulate all new tobacco products.

Under the law, new products could be approved only if makers could demonstrate health benefits to society as a whole – meaning the products would not induce too many nonsmokers or would-be quitters to try them, rather than abstaining.

Another crucial procedural vote Wednesday passed 67-30, cutting off amendments. And the final action Thursday came on a 79 to 17 vote, with Ms. Hagan of North Carolina the only Democrat voting against it.

The voting reflected a political shift from years past, when tobacco state senators could count on support from other Southern conservatives. John Cornyn of Texas, who is chairman of the Senate Republican campaign committee, co-sponsored the tobacco bill and voted against the filibuster. “This is a rarity these days in Washington,” Mr.
Cornyn said in debate Tuesday. “It is actually a bipartisan bill.”

Michael B. Enzi of Wyoming, the ranking Republican on the Senate health committee, also supported the tobacco legislation. “Smoking killed my dad and my mom and my mother-in-law, and second-hand smoking conclusively affected me,” he said during the Senate debate. “So this isn’t political. This is about the health of all Americans.” Although tobacco companies have also lost a series of recent rulings in court, tobacco industry financial analysts say federal regulation, higher taxes and court verdicts are all manageable because the companies, with a market of addicted customers, can raise prices to remain profitable.

A Goldman Sachs analyst, Judy Hong, wrote in a report to investors last week, “Some of the new remedies may be unpleasant but not financially disabling to the tobacco companies.” Under the law, tobacco regulation would be introduced in stages. First, the F.D.A. would hire a director and staff and find space for a new Tobacco Center, to be financed by industry fees. The projected budget is $85 million the first year, $450 million by the third year and more than $700 million in 10 years. A scientific advisory committee would be set up by next year.

New marketing restrictions next year would include a ban on all outdoor advertising of tobacco within 1,000 feet of schools and playgrounds. The Association of National Advertisers, a trade organization, says the legislation’s “massive crushing and unprecedently broad advertising restrictions” violate First Amendment protections for
commercial speech. A court challenge is probable.

While cigarette consumption has declined in most Western countries, it is growing in Asia and Eastern Europe. An estimated 1.3 billion people now smoke worldwide, according to the World Lung Foundation.

“The unfortunate thing,” Nancy Brown, president of the American Heart Association, said in an interview, “is the bad American habit is now being exported to other countries.”

Bill Gives FDA Broad Powers to Regulate Tobacco

By Lyndsey Layton, The Washington Post Company – June 11, 2009

The Senate approved landmark legislation today that would give the government sweeping new power to oversee tobacco, a centuries-old product used by 20 percent of Americans yet largely unregulated in this country. The bipartisan measure, approved by a margin of 79 to 17, largely mirrors a measure passed by the House last month. The House has indicated it will accept the Senate version and will vote on it early next week before a bill is sent to President Obama. Obama, a smoker who has struggled to quit, has said he is eager to sign the bill into law. It comes 50 years after the surgeon general first warned of the health effects of tobacco.

Congress has been trying for more than a decade to regulate tobacco, coming close several times but faltering in the face of opposition from the tobacco lobby, the White House or procedural hang-ups. But in the years that the debate has raged, changing social attitudes toward tobacco helped transform the idea of regulation from controversial to common sense. “There’s not a smoker in the country that’s an adult who wishes their children would begin smoking,” said Sen. Christopher J. Dodd (D-Conn.), himself a former smoker.

“And there are many adult smokers today who wish they never started. . . . This has been a very long battle. . . . For the first time we’re going to make a difference. The FDA is going to regulate the production, sale and marketing of these products. That is history.”The legislation would give broad new authority to the Food and Drug Administration to regulate the manufacturing and marketing of tobacco.

For the first time, the $89 billion tobacco industry would have to disclose the ingredients in its products. Under the new authority, the FDA could ban the most harmful of the estimated 6,000 chemicals used in cigarettes, cigars and other tobacco products. And it could reduce the amount of nicotine, perhaps to a point where tobacco is no longer addictive and smokers who want to quit can break free more easily. The legislation requires tobacco companies to expand the size of warning labels and include graphic images of the health effects of tobacco.

Advertising and promotion will also would be restricted. Tobacco manufacturers would be unable to use the terms “light,” “mild” and “low” unless they can scientifically prove that the product so labeled is less harmful than standard tobacco. The bill would also create a tobacco center within the FDA funded by fees from the industry that are estimated to reach more than $500 million annually by 2013, according to the Congressional Budget Office.

Government Communicates With Listed Establishments On Full Indoor Smoking Ban

HK Gov press release – June 4, 2009

A spokesman of the Department of Health (DH) said today (June 4) that a smoking ban at six types of listed establishments – bars, clubs, night-clubs, bathhouses, massage establishments and mahjong-tin kau premises – would take effect on July 1 in accordance with the Smoking (Public Health) Ordinance.

The same as those of other indoor public places, staff and customers of these listed establishments would be protected from hazards of passive smoking, the spokesman said.

As in the past, the authorities would adopt a multi-pronged approach which comprised publicity, education, persuasion, and enforcement to implement the smoking ban and appeal for the co-operation of the management of relevant establishments.

“Since early this year, the Tobacco Control Office (TCO) has, via various channels, including sending letters to the management of these six types of listed establishments and meetings with the trades’ representatives, explained to the trades the relevant measures and reminded them of the upcoming expiry of the more-than-two-year exemption from the smoking ban.

“Starting last month (May), TCO organised a number of workshops to assist the trades to understand the full implementation of the indoor smoking ban as well as the specific measures. So far, a total of 132 people have enrolled in nine of these workshops,” the spokesman said.

Management of the listed establishments where the smoking ban would be implemented were invited to participate in seminars on the Smoking (Public Health) Ordinance to acquire a better understanding of the relevant statutory requirements. If necessary, staff of these establishments could also join the smoking cessation seminars organised by the TCO to quit early, he said.

“Starting this month (June), TCO will distribute guidelines, posters, leaflets, logos and other publicity items on the relevant measures of smoking ban to the management of the six types of listed establishments.

The spokesman said the policy objective of implementing a full indoor smoking ban in listed establishments was to protect the health of staff and customers.

“An opinion poll conducted by the Government also showed that the majority of the public supported the anti-smoking policy. More than 88% of our population are non-smokers. We thus appeal for the co-operation and understanding of the trades in implementing this policy,” he said.

“The Government is ready to continue to maintain dialogue with the trades, and to assist both the staff and customers to adapt to the new measures,” he said.

Around 40,000 Vietnamese Die Of Cigarettes A Year

VietNamNet Bridge – 26 May 2009

As one of the countries with the most male smokers, the number of cigarette-related deaths in Vietnam is four-fold the number of casualties from traffic accidents.

The Health Ministry’s Health Treatment and Examination Agency chief Ly Ngoc Kinh talked about the situation.

Government Decree 45 issued in 2005 stipulates a 50,000-100,000 dong fine for smoking in public sites. But it seems that this regulation is ineffective. What do you think about it?

It is impossible to implement this rule. We don’t lack regulations or sanctions on smoking, issued by the government and the Health Ministry, but they cannot be implemented effectively.

Not only in this field, in other areas people don’t obey the rules. For example, may people cross the road on a red light or they don’t wear helmets.

Why don’t people obey the ban on smoking at public sites?

Cigarettes are allowed to circulate in the market. It is very difficult to issue measures against cigarette smoking because we can’t ban them like drugs, only educate people to help them understand the danger and change their behaviour.

Moreover, profit from cigarettes is huge, only behind oil and alcohol, so producers seek every way to attract smokers.

How can other countries ban smoking at public sites?

Our sanctions are not strong enough. In Hong Kong, the fine for smoking at public sites is HK$5,000, equivalent to 11 million dong. They have smoking supervision teams at public sites.

In Vietnam, this job is assigned to police officers or guards but they don’t do it because the fine is very small, 50,000-100,000. If we impose higher fines and pay them commissions, the ban will be effective.

Moreover, many people are not familiar with living under and following the law.

Vietnam forced cigarette producers to print warnings on cigarette packs. How will this help change people’s awareness?

Most people have only vague understanding about the harms of cigarettes to health and they lack knowledge about diseases caused by cigarettes.

The warning accounts for around 30 percent of the area of a cigarette pack, and it is not strong enough: “Smoking can cause cancer”.

The warning would be better if it was expressed in an image.

It has been suggested that the warning contain an image but it has not been done yet. Why?

This issue has been discussed at many seminars. Many people think that this task is simple and useful but because of different reasons, especially strong reactions from cigarette producers, the implementation has been delayed.

Cigarette producers say that it is costly or they don’t have suitable technology to print warnings with images. But exported cigarette products have warnings with images. We will try to enforce this in 2010.

VietNamNet/VNE

From 2011, Smoking Will Be Banned Completely in the Medical and Healthcare System

By James Middleton, Clear The Air – 23 May 09

The Chinese Ministry of Health yesterday released its much awaited “Decision” requiring all medical administration offices and medical facilities to go completely smoke-free by 2011. The date on the document is May 20.

All health administration offices (i.e. health bureaus, CDCs, etc.) and half of medical and health institutions (i.e. hospitals and clinics) are required to go smoke-free by 2010. The other half of hospitals and clinics are required to be completely smoke-free by 2011.

The document is issued jointly by the Ministry of Health, the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, the Health Department of the General Logistics Department of People’s Liberation Army, and the Logistics Department of the Armed Police Forces. It thus covers most health facilities in China, including military hospitals, armed police hospitals, traditional Chinese medicine hospitals, and hospitals in the Ministry of Health system. It would seem not to include hospitals run by the railways.

The head of the leading small group for the initiative is Minister of Health Chen Zhu. The initiative’s office is headed by Yang Qing, Director General of the Department of Maternal and Child Health and Community Health at MOH.

____________________________________________________________

http://news.workercn.cn/contentfile/2009/05/22/13390758461983.html
http://www.moh.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/mohfybjysqwss/s3590/200905/40809.htm

Website of Ministry of Health, May 22, 2009

(This English Version was translated by James Middleton, CTA)

On May 20, the Ministry of Health, the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, the Health Department of the General Logistics Department of People’s Liberation Army, and the Logistics Department of the Armed Police Forces jointly issued the “Decision on banning smoking completely in the medical and health system from 2011”. The “Decision” provides that by the year 2010, all health administration offices, both military and non-military, and at least 50% of all medical and health institutions should become smoke-free units, so that the goal of a total smoking ban in all health administration offices and medical and health institutions can be fulfilled by 2011.

The “Decision” requests that all localities and units should set up multi-agency FCTC Implementation Leading Small Groups, responsible for developing specific work plans for banning smoking completely in health administration offices and health institutions under their jurisdiction; strengthen the building of professional teams; and by 2010 gradually establish and improve the tobacco control network from provincial level to county level, from military region level to regiment level. All localities and all units should adopt the creation of smoke-free medical institutions into their merit rating systems and their spiritual civilization construction activities; the realization of a total smoking ban in health administration offices and health institutions should be included in the annual work plan with financial support provided. Health administration offices (both military and civil) at all levels should enhance tobacco control publicity and legal system construction, in combination with the creation of Healthy Cities (Townships), Civilized Cities, and Civilized Military Camps. Indicators such as medical staff quitting smoking, no smoking in public places and workplaces, publicizing knowledge on hazards of tobacco, dissuading people from smoking, and providing smoking cessation services should be adopted into the “Guidelines on Hospital Management Evaluation,” “Basic Functions of Centers for Disease Control and Prevention at All Levels,” and other regulations on management of health institutions. All kinds of medical institutions (both military and civil) at all levels should establish a system of inquiring about patients’ smoking history, integrate it into standard medical evaluation, and provide smoking cessation guidance to smoking patients. All kinds of health administration offices and medical and health institutions at all levels (both military and civil) are not allowed to entertain guests with cigarettes, and should provide smoking cessation assistance to smoking staff.

Meanwhile, military and civil health administration offices at all levels should make the most of important events such as World No Tobacco Day to actively promote the importance of implementing a total smoking ban in health administration offices and medical and health institutions; mobilize and guide the media to actively publicize the idea of a total smoking ban in military and civil health administration offices and medical and health institutions, and through such mass media publicity activities, get other sectors involved in the tobacco control initiative and consciously stay away from tobacco. Strengthen multi-agency cooperation to promote the total smoking ban in health administration offices and medical and health institutions.

Decision on banning smoking completely in medical and health system from 2011
Health Maternal and Child Health and Community Health (2009) No. 48
To
Health bureaus / departments of all provinces, autonomous regions, and municipalities directly under the Central Government;
State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine;
Health Bureau of the Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps;
Relevant Units Directly Under the Ministry of Health;
Units Directly Under the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine;
Hospitals Directly Under or Managed by the Ministry of Health;
Hospitals Directly Under or Managed by the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine;
Combined Logistics Departments of all Military Regions;
Health Departments of Logistics Departments of all Categories of Troops;
Logistics Department of the Third Department of the General Staff Headquarters;
Management and Logistics Department of the General Staff Headquarters;
Direct Subordinate Workforce of the General Political Department;
Health Bureau of the Logistics Department of the General Armaments Department; Health Departments (Divisions) of the PLA University of National Defense;
National University of Defense Technology;
Academy of Military Sciences;
Health Departments Directly Under the General Logistics Department;
Logistics Departments of all Corps;
Mobile divisions, Commands, and Academies Directly under the Armed Police:
The World Health Organization’s “Framework Convention on Tobacco Control” (hereinafter referred to as the “Convention”) is the first legally binding multilateral treaty in the field of medicine and public health. On January 9, 2006, the “Convention” came into effect in China.
Article 8 of the “Convention” requires Parties to take effective measures to guard against public exposure to tobacco smoke. In July 2007, the Second Conference of the Parties to the Convention adopted the “Guidelines on Protection from Exposure to Tobacco Smoke” (hereinafter referred to as “Guidelines”). In accordance with the requirements of the “Guidelines,” starting from January 2011, China should ban smoking completely in all indoor public places, indoor workplaces, public transport vehicles and other possible outdoor public places.

Banning smoking in public places and workplaces has become the trend of the times. In December 2005, the World Health Organization announced that it would no longer employ smokers and would provide smoking cessation assistance to smoking staff. According to World Health Organization statistics on 194 countries, by the end of 2007, 84 countries and regions had passed laws and regulations to ban smoking in public places and workplaces, of which 16 countries and regions had enforced total smoking bans in all institutions, and 68 countries and regions had implemented total smoking bans in more than two categories of institutions including medical and health institutions. In January 2007, China’s Hong Kong Special Administrative Region implemented its “Smoking (Public Health) Ordinance”, requesting to meet the target of “Smoke-free Hong Kong” before June 30, 2009. By that time, all indoor public places and workplaces in Hong Kong should have banned smoking completely.

In 1998, the World Health Organization classified tobacco dependence as a chronic disease and listed it in the International Classification of Diseases as No. F17.2, confirming that tobacco is the greatest threat to the health of mankind. China now has more than 300 million smokers and 540 million people exposed to secondhand smoke, including 180 million children under the age of 15. Each year about 1 million people die from smoking-related diseases.

Controlling smoking and fulfilling the requirements of the FCTC are the responsibility of everyone. Military and civil health administration offices and medical and health institutions, in particular, should play a leading role. To take the lead in implementation of FCTC, in line with the spirit of the “Convention” and the “guidelines” and combined with the reality of our country, it is decided that from 2011, all health administration offices at all levels and medical and health institutions all around the country shall implement a total smoking ban. And the following requirements are made.

1. Strengthen leadership; make sure health administration offices and medical institutions meet their responsibilities in implementing the FCTC.

A total ban on smoking in all military and civil health administration offices at all levels and medical and health institutions is an important aspect of FCTC implementation. All localities and units should fully understand the importance, necessity and urgency of this work, set up a multi-agency FCTC implementation leading small group, with the chief responsible official as group leader, and the officials in charge as deputy leaders, thus effectively strengthening organization and leadership.
In combination with the current deepening reform of the medical and health system, the job functions of competent responsible departments should be clarified. Study and formulate FCTC implementation work plan, formulate detailed work plan on implementation of the total smoking ban in local health administration offices. Strengthen the construction of professional teams, by 2010 gradually establish and improve the tobacco control network from provincial level to county level, from Military Region level to regiment level.

2. Strengthen tobacco control measures; strengthen tobacco control efforts in a comprehensive way

All localities and all units should follow the requirements of the “Standards for Smoke-free Medical and Health Institutions (trial version)” jointly issued by the Ministry of Health and National Patriotic Health Campaign Committee, actively implement a total smoking ban in health administration offices and medical and health institutions, and adopt the creation of smoke-free medical institutions into the merit rating system and spiritual civilization construction system in both military and civil units;

The establishment of a total smoking ban in health administration offices and health institutions should be adopted into the annual work plan with financial support provided. Combine with the “Central Government subsidizing local governments” program and various smoke-free public places creation programs, earnestly implement the total smoking ban in health administration offices and medical and health institutions, actively create smoke-free medical and health institutions, and conduct smoke-free environmental monitoring in health administration offices and medical and health institutions.

Both military and civil health administration offices at all levels should enhance tobacco control publicity and legal system construction, in combination with the creation of Healthy Cities (Townships), Civilized Cities, and Civilized Military Camps. Indicators such as medical staff quitting smoking, no smoking in public places and workplaces, publicizing knowledge of the hazards of tobacco, dissuading people from smoking, and providing smoking cessation services should be adopted into the “Guidelines on Hospital Management Evaluation,” “Basic Functions of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention at All Levels,” and other regulations on management of health institutions, so as to comprehensively promote the creation of smoke-free health institutions of all categories at all levels and realize the goal of a total smoking ban in all indoor public places and workplaces. All kinds of medical institutions (both military and civil) at all levels should establish a system of inquiring about patients’ smoking history, integrate it into standard medical evaluation, and provide smoking cessation guidance to smoking patients. All kinds of health administration offices and medical and health institutions at all levels (both military and civil) are not allowed to entertain guests with cigarettes, and should provide smoking cessation assistance to smoking staff.

3. Conduct extensive mobilization; actively create an atmosphere favorable for tobacco control

While carrying out daily tobacco control work, military and civil health administration offices at all levels should make the most of important events such as World No Tobacco Day to actively promote the importance of implementing a total smoking ban in health administration offices and medical and health institutions. They should mobilize and guide the media to actively publicize the idea of a total smoking ban in military and civil health administration offices and medical and health institutions, and through such mass media publicity activities, get other sectors involved in the tobacco control initiative and consciously stay away from tobacco. Meanwhile, make use of public opinion supervision to push health administration offices and medical and health institutions to implement a total ban on smoking.

Strengthen multi-agency cooperation, mobilize the whole society, bring into full play the strength of tobacco control associations all over the country and other organizations, and promote a total smoking ban in health administration offices and medical and health institutions.

4. Conduct supervision and inspection; strive to fulfill the goal of a total smoking ban in the whole health system nationwide

By 2010, all military and civil health administration offices and at least 50% of medical and health institutions should become smoke-free units, so that the goal of total smoking ban in all health administration offices and medical and health institutions can be achieved by 2011.

Health administration offices at provincial level and top military level should organize regular supervision and inspection based on the actual situation. The Ministry of Health, State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Health Department of the General Logistics Department, and Logistics Department of the Armed Police Forces shall, at appropriate times, jointly organize supervision and appraisal on the creation of smoke-free health administration offices and medical and health institutions, circulate the results of the supervision and appraisal, and cite the units with outstanding achievements.

Health administration departments at the top military level and provincial level and the Health Department of State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine are requested to report the implementation plans of this Decision to the Ministry of Health, State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Health Department of the General Logistics Department, and Logistics Department of the Armed Police Forces. The relevant health offices should summarize and circulate it in due course.

_____________________________________________________

Ministry of Health
State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine Health Department of the General Logistics Department,
Logistics Department of the Armed Police Forces
May 20, 2009

Addendum: Name list of the National Medical and Health System FCTC Implementation Leading Small Group

Leader: Chen Zhu, Minister of Health

Deputy Leaders:
o Huang Jiefu, Vice Minister, Ministry of Health
o Liu Qian, Vice Minister, Ministry of Health
o Li Ning, Deputy Chief of State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine
o Wang Yumin, Deputy Director General of Health Department of the General Logistics Department
o Shi Liqiang, Director General of Health Department of the Armed Police Forces
Members:
o Yang Qing, Director General, Department of Maternal and Child Health and Community Health, Ministry of Health
o Ren Minghui, Director General, Department of International Cooperation, Ministry of Health
o Sun Jiahai, Deputy Director General, General Office, Ministry of Health
o He Jinguo, Deputy Director General, Department of Planning and Finance, Ministry of Health
o Liu Xinming, Director General, Department of Health Policy and Regulation, Ministry of Health
o Qi Xiaoqiu, Director General, Disease Prevention and Control Bureau (National Patriotic Health Campaign Committee Office), Ministry of Health
o Wang Yu, Director General, Department of Medical Administration, Ministry of Health
o Zhang Zongjiu, Director General, Department of Medical Services Supervision and Management, Ministry of Health
o Wang Xuening, Deputy Director General, Health Supervision Department, Ministry of Health
o Yu Xiucheng, Deputy Inspector, Department of Science, Technology and Education, Ministry of Health
o Li Liming, Party Secretary of Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences
o Yang Gonghuan, Deputy Director General, Chinese Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
o Zha Dezhong, Deputy Director General, Department of Medical Affairs, State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine
o Wang Xiaopin, Deputy Director General, Department of International Affairs, State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine
o Zhu Hao, Director General, Health and Epidemic Prevention Bureau, Health Department of General Logistics Department
o Li Qingjie, Director General of Medical Management Bureau, Health Department of the General Logistics Department
o Xu Tianhao, Deputy Director of Comprehensive Planning Division, Military Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

o Hou Donghong, Deputy Director of Health Department, Logistics Department of the Armed Police Forces
An office has been set up under the leading small group and is headed by Yang Qing, Director General, Department of Maternal and Child Health and Community Health,

U.S. Sen. Kohl: Sponsors Bill to Prevent Black Market Cigarette Smuggling

Source: WisPolitics, 2009-05-22

U.S. Senator Herb Kohl today reintroduced the Prevent All Cigarette Trafficking (PACT) Act of 2009 to provide law enforcement with the tools they need to crack down on black market tobacco selling. Cigarette trafficking has developed into a popular, and highly profitable, means of generating revenue for criminal and terrorist organizations. Hezbollah, al Qaeda and Hamas have all generated significant revenue from the sale of counterfeit cigarettes. That money is often raised in the United States, and it is then funneled back to these international terrorist groups. Cigarette smuggling is a multibillion dollar a year phenomenon and it is getting worse. In 1998, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (BATFE) had six active tobacco smuggling investigations. In 2005, that number swelled to 452. Today there are more than 400 open cases. Cigarette trafficking, including the illegal sale of tobacco products over the internet, costs states billions of dollars in lost tax revenue each year. It is estimated that states lose $5 billion in revenues due to illegal tobacco sales.

Please visit http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=159529 for more information

HK Gazettes Legislative Amendments for Tobacco Duty Rates

Xinhua, Web Editor: Hu Weiwei, english.cri.cn – 2009-04-30

The Hong Kong government Thursday announced the gazetting of the legislative amendments required for giving effect to the Budget proposal of increasing the duty rates on tobacco by 50 percent.

The Hong Kong government Thursday announced the gazetting of the legislative amendments required for giving effect to the Budget proposal of increasing the duty rates on tobacco by 50 percent.

In his 2009-10 Budget, the financial secretary proposed to increase the duty rates on various types of tobacco by 50 percent for public health reasons.

The proposal came into immediate effect from on Feb. 25 this year under the Public Revenue Protection Order 2009.

As the order gives provisional legal effect to the proposal for only four months, it is necessary for the government to introduce a Bill containing the proposal into the Legislative Council for enactment.

“The proposed increase in tobacco duty will strengthen our tobacco control efforts to protect public health and will further discourage smoking. It can also reduce the long-term disease burden for Hong Kong,” a government spokesman said.

The Bill will be introduced into the Legislative Council on May 13.

Texas Lawmakers Push to Raise Smoking Age to 19

NewsWest 9 by Victor Lopez

They’re considered adults for just about everything. If passed, a bill headed to the Senate, would make 18-year-olds minors when it comes to smoking and tobacco products.

The idea behind it is to cut back on the number of teens that smoke. But everyone NewsWest 9 spoke to, agrees. People should be allowed to make up their own mind, especialy if they’re already adults in the eyes of the law.

“It’s just a perogative, dude. If you choose to smoke, you choose to smoke, plain and simple,” one man, said.

Bryan Allen owns and runs The Tobacco Shack in Midland. His customers range from the barely legal to retirement age. He says, by this time, they should be allowed to smoke if they want too, “I get people from 18 years of age all the way to 80. If you’re 18 and you’re old enough to go fight for your country in war and die, then you ought to be old enough to smoke cigarrettes.”

To him, raising the age by one year, isn’t going to change things much, if at all because if they want it bad enough, they’re going to find a way to get their hands on a cigarette. “If they’re 18 they’re going to know somebody that’s 19 and they’re going to be able to get one of their friends to buy it for them.”

Some Midland residents, like Jan Lawbaugh, have their own similar opinions, “If the kids are going to buy cigarettes, they’ll get them somehow, if that’s what they want to do. So I don’t think it will make any difference what age they put on it.”

Midland mom, Linda Palmer had this to say, “I think it would be pointless. The legal age is 18. You can vote at 18. You can do anything at 18, so why not be able to buy cigarrettes at 18?”

Her 16-year-old daughter Ariel English agrees, “I think it’s pointless. I think their friends would buy them for them.”

Buying underage or selling tobacco products to minors is a punishable offense. Allen makes sure they follow the letter of the law, “We just ID them. We need a Texas ID. You know, that’s the law, sorry. It’s not worth the fine or the hassle.”

Four other states have already raised their legal age to 19. The same bill was passed by the Texas Senate, but failed in the House back in 2007.