Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

2010 budget speech: Tobacco budget highlights

tobacco tax

Tobacco Control


133. For public health reasons, I increased tobacco duty substantially by 50 per cent last year. This year I propose to abolish the duty-free concessions on tobacco products for incoming passengers. To facilitate law enforcement, small amounts of tobacco products for own consumption will be exempted. The Food and Health Bureau and Customs and Excise Department will announce the details. This measure will take effect on completion of the legislative process.

134. Studies by the World Health Organization have clearly shown that increasing tobacco duty is an effective means of tobacco control. I am aware that tobacco duty in Hong Kong currently accounts for only about 60 per cent of the retail prices of cigarettes, some way below the 75 per cent recommended by the World Health Organization. The retail prices of cigarettes in Hong Kong are also lower than those in some international cities. The Food and Health Bureau will closely monitor the effectiveness of the various tobacco control measures in the year ahead. I will consider a phased increase in Hong Kong’s tobacco duty based on the Bureau’s recommendations.

Click here to read 2010 Budget: Clear The Air’s reply regarding the government’s plans for tobacco control.

What do you think about the government’s proposal? Voice your comments after the jump.

(more…)

Prisons end link between inmates’ pay, tobacco prices

smoking in prisonUpdated: February 24, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

Prisoners’ earnings will no longer rise or fall in line with cigarette prices. The government, which announced the move yesterday, hopes it will curb inmates’ smoking and improve their health.

Four-fifths of adult inmates smoke, and they spend 60 per cent of their prison earnings on cigarettes. Prisoners under 21 are banned from smoking.

Prisoners’ cigarette purchases have already fallen by a sixth in two years. Last year, prison canteens sold 526,645 packets, down from 631,870 in 2008 and 641,625 in 2007.

(more…)

Prof. Pushes for Ban on Cigarettes

no cigarettesFirst published: February 22, 2010

Source: Korea Times

Professor Park Jae-gahb
Seoul National University
By Bae Ji-sook
Staff Reporter

A group of health experts and civic activists Monday called for the government to ban the manufacturing and distribution of cigarettes.

They urged the government to conduct intensive rehabilitation programs for smokers and encourage tobacco farms to convert to other industries.

The Tobacco Free World and the Korea Association of Health Promotion, among others, are pushing to prohibit the selling and making of tobacco products
within 10 years.

Those who violate a proposed law would be imprisoned up to five years or fined up to 50 million won. The members are planning to submit the bill to
the National Assembly within a year.

(more…)

Obama Administration Seeks $300 Billion from Tobacco Industry

Obama smokingFirst published: February 22, 2010

Source: Join Together

Both sides are appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court to rule in an ongoing court battle between the federal government and the tobacco industry over
cigarette companies’ long history of deceiving the public about the health risks of smoking.

The Associated Press reported Feb. 19 that the Obama administration has appealed a lower court ruling denying the government’s attempt to collect
$280 billion in past tobacco profits and to compel the industry to pay $14 billion for a national smoking-cessation program. Tobacco firms, on the
other hand, are appealing the lower court’s ruling that they illegally concealed information about the hazards of smoking.

(more…)

In preparation to the Vote on the Budget, an Open Letter to the HK Government on Tobacco Tax

ashtrayPrice measures have been shown around the world to be the single, most effective measure in reducing tobacco use, especially among the young. Tobacco is responsible for 7,000 deaths and community costs of more than five billion dollars annually in Hong Kong. We urge the Government to review its tobacco control strategy and ensure that in particular its legislative and fiscal measures are comprehensive, coherent and rigorously enforced. The protection of young people from addiction to tobacco should be one of our highest public health priorities.

Read the full letter – download the English PDF.

Download the Chinese PDF here.

(more…)

Smokes and mirrors

The Standard – Thursday, February 18, 2010


I refer to the articles “Failed tobacco tax sees hopes go up in smoke” (The Standard, January 25) by Nicole Alpert of the Lion Rock Institute and “Youth quitters find smokes too much of a temptation” (The Standard, February 10), which quoted Deanna Cheung of the Tobacco Control Concern Group.

Alpert states that tobacco taxation does not work, increases tobacco smuggling and refers to a previous “study” issued by the self-interest TCCG as if it were gospel.

This non-peer-reviewed study, which represents just 0.25 percent of Hong Kong’s total smokers, interviewed 2,008 smokers with the offer of replacement packs of toxic cigarettes in return for the toxic ones the smokers held. The TCCG implied that this study applied across the board in Hong Kong.

It claimed that 49.9 percent of cigarettes sold in Hong Kong in 2009 (5.8254 billion) were not duty paid, hence the government was losing vast tax amounts; that 18.9 percent could be illicit (1.1 billion); 11.1 percent fake or parallel imports (646.6 million); 7.8 percent were from magical unknown sources (454.3 million); and of the remaining 12.1 percent (704.87 million), 192.42 million sticks came from legal duty free border shops and 26.78 million were bought legally overseas.

It omits the missing portion of this total figure, which amounts to 485.65 million sticks. Hence they allege, without a shred of evidence, that 280 40-foot containers filled with contraband tobacco evaded Hong Kong tobacco tax last year.

The World Health Organization and World Bank say tobacco taxation is the single most effective fiscal health measure governments can take to prevent youths starting smoking and to reduce overall smoking by 4 to 7 percent.

The Tobacco Atlas reveals 30 percent of cigarettes worldwide are smuggled and that the source of the smuggling is the tobacco companies themselves as admitted in online UCSF Legacy tobacco documents and a Guardian newspaper quote from Kenneth Clarke of British American Tobacco.

The TCCG stated that Hong Kong tobacco tax is the second highest in Asia. Actual comparisons per 1,000 sticks are: Hong Kong 159 euros (HK$1,703), Melbourne 203 euros, Paris 265 euros, Singapore 265 euros, New York 300 euros, London 369 euros, and Dublin 423 euros. Hence the cigarette price in Hong Kong is only 60 percent, 53 percent and 43 percent of that in Singapore, New York and London, respectively.

In an Economist Intelligence Unit survey of the world’s most expensive places to live, Hong Kong is 11th, ahead of Dublin in 13th. Yet cigarettes cost 423 euros per 1000 in Dublin versus just 159 euros for the like amount in Hong Kong in 2009.

Hong Kong people should treat this attempted misinformation with the contempt it deserves, emanating from an industry whose chief executives swore on oath that nicotine is not addictive and whose major players were convicted under US RICO anti- racketeering laws.

James Middleton

Chairman anti tobacco committee

Clear the Air

Tobacco tax increase is best way to curb smoking

A smoking shelter in United Kingdom.

A smoking shelter in United Kingdom.

It took years to extend anti-smoking laws to restaurants and bars, a ban which came into effect last July. It has taken only a few months for activists to take their campaign to curb smoking outdoors. The Council on Smoking and Health is considering recommending that the government should introduce measures to corral smokers into designated outdoor smoking areas. Because more smokers have been driven onto the streets, it argues that second-hand smoke is now an outdoor health hazard, especially in crowded pedestrian areas, and that this justifies further action. A street ban would be difficult to police, but council chairwoman Lisa Lau Man-man cites the example of Tokyo, another densely populated area, where smoking in the streets has been banned in some areas.

Designated non-smoking outdoor areas are already to be found, for example along the promenade outside the Central ferry piers. Smokers generally respect them and Lau believes they would also discipline themselves if the balance were reversed and smoking areas were designated instead.

So long as tobacco use remains lawful, however addictive and unhealthy it may be, these ideas raise the question of balance between personal freedoms and community interest. Bans respect non-smokers’ right to breathe clean air. But there is room for more effective enforcement of the recently introduced indoor bans and the HK$1,500 on-the-spot fines for breaches. That would reinforce the educational message to the slowly shrinking minority who smoke that theirs is an anti-social and risky habit.

Lau rightly concedes that the most effective way of curbing smoking remains rises in tobacco tax. Having raised it by 50 per cent last year – the first increase for eight years – the government should not shrink from imposing a smaller incremental rise in this year’s budget. Unfortunately this would hit the poor hardest. But given that smoking is addictive, and taxpayers at large fund the earlier, more frequent and extra health care that smokers are prone to need, this is one tax increase for which there is an argument in social equity.

Source: SCMP

Law has failed to stop tobacco sales to minors

The picture is taken on 2006 by Neighbourhood & Worker's Service Centre. But after fighting for years, there is not action taken by the government yet.

The picture is taken on 2006 by Neighbourhood & Worker's Service Centre. But after fighting for years, there is not action taken by the government yet.

I refer to the report (“Cigarettes easier for teenagers to buy”, January 21).

The Neighbourhood and Worker’s Education Centre has once again concluded, as expected, that 86 per cent of retail outlets are willing to sell cigarettes indiscriminately to underage smokers.

Does anyone really believe that the employees of 7-Eleven and Circle K stores, news-stands and other outlets will put up with abuse arising from their refusal to sell cigarettes to under-age smokers? Clearly the relevant legislation has failed and it remains an uphill battle to get smokers to quit and to prevent future generations of young people from taking up this destructive habit.

Because retail outlets can flout the law it makes a mockery of the legislation.

If a retailer refuses to sell to minors they will simply find another store.

There are too many of these outlets which makes meaningful enforcement impossible. Nicotine is a poisonous and cancer-causing substance and its availability must be restricted not facilitated at every street corner as it is now.

It seems totally irrational for a poisonous substance to be as conveniently and widely available as beverages, snacks, newspapers and other daily necessities.

We must fight the aggressive importers of cigarettes by restricting their access to the market place.

Even raising the tax will have only a limited and temporary effect.

Reducing the number of cigarette-vending outlets as soon as possible can help to minimise a potentially huge health care bill for smoking-related illnesses and is in the best interests of the community.

source: SCMP, Ang Ah-lay, Causeway Bay

Tobacco label fight heats up

“Plain packaging” can be a method to reduce tobacco use?

“Plain packaging” can be a method to reduce tobacco use?

International tobacco companies are preparing to mount a no-holdsbarred legal and lobbying campaign to stop Australia becoming the first country to introduce so-called “plain packaging” for cigarettes.

A United States-based lobby group took the unusual step of making a submission on the issue last year and the Australian-based American Chamber of Commerce is reviewing whether it will take a position.

Plain packaging, one of the key recommendations of a report last year to federal Health Minister Nicola Roxon on a national preventative health strategy, would stop tobacco companies using glossy paper, colours or fonts to decorate cigarette packets even in the parts of the package not already taken up by warnings.

Brand names such as “Marlboro” or “Peter Jackson” could still appear on the packet but would be much smaller and in a dull, nondescript font.

Ms Roxon said she would respond “in a short time” to the recommendations, which include a substantial increase in the excise tax on cigarettes and more funding for quit advertising.

A Senate inquiry is also due to start hearings soon on a private member’s bill by Steve Fielding on plain packaging.

In a sign of the global interest, Thomas Donohue, president of the US Chamber of Commerce, a major Washington-based business lobby group, made a submission to the preventative health taskforce.

“We think that a move to mandate generic packaging would establish a bad precedent for companies from both of our countries,“Mr Donohue said.

“We would hope that the Australian government will not take this step.”

Charles Blunt, chairman of the American Chamber of Commerce in Australia, said his group was now reviewing whether to take a position on the intellectual property implications of plain packaging.

Mr Blunt said the local American Chamber had been aware of the US Chamber’s submission last year but had not joined it.

Stanton Glantz, an anti-smoking campaigner at the University of California in San Francisco, said it was the first time he had ever heard of the US Chamber of Commerce, which usually deals with US domestic issues, getting involved in another country: “This is pretty amazing.”

Mr Glantz said internal documents made public during the US tobacco trials revealed close links between Big Tobacco and the US chamber.

Tobacco companies in the US are mounting a legal challenge after the Obama administration convinced Congress to pass a law that could allow the US Food and Drug Administration to regulate tobacco products, including by plain packaging.

The US Chamber has been split by its opposition to several Obama administration initiatives, and Apple quit the organisation over its stance on climate change.

Mathew Rimmer, an intellectual property expert at the Australian National University College of Law, said Australia was one of the first countries to give serious consideration to plain packaging and tobacco firms were concerned that once it was passed in one country, the approach could spread.

“There’s an international strategy. It’s part of an orchestrated campaign to squash plain packaging,” Dr Rimmer said.

The tobacco industry argues plain packaging breaches trademark law and amounts to confiscation of property without confiscation.

But anti-smoking groups say courts around the world have consistently upheld governments’ right to restrict the use of trademarks on serious public health grounds such as tobacco-related death.

Source: Prof. Judith Longstaff Mackay, Senior Advisor of worldlungfoundation.org & Geoff Winestock, Australian Financial Review

New York leads the charge in America’s anti-smoking laws

UNITED STATES, Paul Harris – SCMP

Once, America was in thrall to the Marlboro Man. The hard-smoking cowboy, staring moodily from his horse at a far-off horizon, symbolised a certain kind of freedom and – not coincidentally – helped sell millions of cigarettes.

But now America’s smokers are groaning – or maybe that should be wheezing – under a flood of new measures designed to make them give up. Or, at the very least, to drive their habits from public view to something furtively done in private.

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg has announced plans to try to ban smoking in the city’s public parks, adding to the 2002 ban on smoking in offices, restaurants and bars. That would see the Big Apple take on one of the most ambitious urban anti-smoking bans in the world, forbidding its citizens from lighting up in hundreds of city parks and 22 kilometres of beaches.

But the New York move is just the tip of an iceberg of anti-smoking policies spreading across the country in a variety of arenas, ranging from rental cars to the army and people’s homes.

From next month, Avis and Budget will be the first major American car rental companies to ban smokers from puffing away in their vehicles, charging cleaning fees of up to US$250 for those who flout the rules.

Chicago has already taken its ban outside by forbidding smoking on beaches and in playgrounds. In California, the small city of Belmont, just outside San Francisco, has even banned it in apartment buildings, marking the first real advance of anti-smoking laws into personal homes.

Perhaps the biggest recent shock has been a study commissioned by the Pentagon that said smoking should be banned in the military. Though few changes are expected soon in the army, the idea of stopping American soldiers lighting up in a combat zone after a firefight triggered a wave of headlines.

Yet it is still New York that is on the frontline of America’s anti-smoking wars. The city celebrates its global reputation for hard partying, tolerance of different lifestyles and rabid individualism, yet Bloomberg has successfully made the Big Apple’s smokers one of the few social groups it is considered acceptable to ostracise.

On Monday, Bloomberg – a former smoker himself – admitted that when he sees smokers hunkered together outside buildings he gives them “a not particularly nice look” as he walks past.

His comments appeared to be aimed at encouraging other New Yorkers to do likewise. “Social pressure really does work,” he said. It certainly seems to have made New York smokers into a fairly subdued bunch as they faced yet further constraints.

Hurrying across New York’s Madison Square park – one of the areas where a ban would come into place – Janaria Kelly shrugged off the news as he clutched a lighted cigarette.

“They have already banned it in so many other places, that it won’t make much difference,” said the 43-year-old salesman. Kelly added that he understood, and even sympathised with, the reasons for the ban. “Smoking is my choice, but I know it is bad for me, so I get why they are doing it,” he said.

That is music to the ears of the anti-smoking movement. Some reports have shown that smoking-related health care costs are almost US$100 billion a year, and this is against a background of rising health care costs for the government.

Bloomberg, and many others, have made it clear that they see smoking as expensive to wider society, not just as a private habit for the individual, and have not shied away from draconian measures that would be hard to impose on other products.

But smoking rights groups have made no secret of their horror at the latest moves, equating it with a loss of individual freedom being imposed on the public from above.

“The American public is not asking for this. It is coming from government and non-government groups, and it is attacking basic rights of freedom,” said Maryetta Ables, president of Forces International, a conservative group that campaigns on issues of personal freedom in smoking, eating and other consumer choices. But Ables admitted that the climate in the US seemed to indicate that her group was fighting a losing battle at the moment. “There is going to be more of this sort of thing to come,” she said.

That did not seem to bother Paul Collins, 39, another smoker lighting up in Madison Square park as he recovered from the stresses of his morning commute into the city.

“If they do it, they do it,” he said with an air of resignation. “The smoking ban in bars was actually good for me. I cut down a bit. So I don’t really mind.”

That is not the fighting spirit among smokers that the Marlboro Man was meant to encourage.

But then the Marlboro Man is perhaps not the best smoking symbol any more. Several of the cowboys used as models in the campaign contracted lung cancer and became anti-smoking campaigners.

New York banned smoking in most restaurants in 1995, followed by workplaces and indoor public places in 2003, three years before such bans in Scotland and four years before England and Wales.

However, the Department of Health in England said that it had no plans to extend smoke-free areas, saying such moves were up to local authorities.

In Australia, smoking was banned on Sydney’s Bondi beach in 2004, after similar prohibitions on dogs, ball games and frisbees. Soon after, the local council restricted alcohol consumption on the beach.

In Holland, Amsterdam’s coffee shops were not exempted from a ban on smoking in public places. There, pure cannabis or cannabis resin can be legally smoked – as long as it is not mixed with tobacco.

The Guardian