Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Letter from Clear The Air

SCMP 22 April, 2011

‘Lawmakers in cigarette duty revolt’ states that certain Legco members and parties are considering voting against the increase in tobacco tax in the latest Budget. Their reasoning is none other than for political gain with District Council elections in 2011 and Legco elections in 2012, they are seeking to attract blue collar votes by attempting to repeal this important preventative health measure. James To and Starry Lee already stated in a local English language  television interview they will vote against the tobacco tax. Tobacco tax increases are targeted at preventing children from becoming addicted for life to nicotine by way of lack of affordability; nicotine is more addictive than heroin or cocaine. Unlike alcohol or other self abuse lifestyle choices, tobacco smoke kills innocent bystanders. The paid tobacco soldiers state that smoking is an adult choice, but how can being a nicotine addict be deemed choice ?  The number of non smoking voters in Hong Kong far exceeds the smoking voters and we would urge these voters to place their votes with those politicians who are working in the interests and health of Hong Kong people and their children rather than those working on behalf of the tobacco companies. Seven thousand people die each year in Hong Kong because of illnesses associated with tobacco use and of those 1,324 (HKU study) die as a result of  illnesses related to passive smoking. Hong Kong does not need self serving lawmakers but those who will represent the health and welfare of the people. Recently a lobby group seemingly paid for its actions named Momentum 107 has been opposing the tobacco tax increase; its leader Raymond Ho Man Kit a Saikung District Councillor was reported in SCMP last week to have testified under immunity against his accomplices , former district councillors in an ICAC case, who were all jailed.  Tobacco disproportionately affects the less well off in society, their overall family income and wellbeing and instead of pushing Government for additional funded resources to remove their addiction these shameful lawmakers are working hand in hand with Big Tobacco; voters can prevent this and consign them to the political wilderness in the interests of our children and future generations.

James Middleton

Chairman

www.cleartheair.org.hk

tel 26930136

address on above webpage

http://www1.umn.edu/perio/tobacco/nicaddct.html

  • Nicotine is:
    • 1000 X more potent than alcohol
    • 10-100 X more potent than barbiturates
    • 5-10 X more potent than cocaine or morphine
  • A 1-2 pack per day smoker takes 200-400 hits daily for years. This constant intake of a fast acting drug (which affects mood, concentration & performance).. eventually produces dependence.

Plain packaging bill to extinguish some tobacco trade marks

15 April 2011

Tim Wilson’s piece on the plain packaging legislation basically repeats the claims that have previously been made by him. Last year, I gave a detailed response to Tim’s claims about the Constitution and international treaties. A webcast of that response can be seen here.

As for the Constitutional argument that the legislation acquires property on other than just terms, Professor Craven, a noted Constitutional expert, has since observed on Radio National’s Background Briefing that the tobacco industry’s prospects of success are about the same as a three legged horse has of winning the Melbourne Cup. The reason for his view is simply explained. The extinction of rights or the reduction of rights is not relevant. The government or a third party must acquire property as a consequence of the legislation. The government does not wish to use the tobacco trade marks. Nor does it want third parties to do so. It does not desire to or intend to acquire any property. The proposition that prohibitions on the use of property do not constitute an acquisition of property was confirmed by the High Court as recently as 2009. In that case, the High Court held that the government was entitled to extinguish property rights in licences of farmers to take bore water.

It is true that the government has now worded the legislation so that even if a three legged horse does win the Melbourne Cup, it can still impose very significant restrictions on tobacco packaging. If you had a lawyer, you would expect them to give you an excellent fallback position, even in the event of the worst of all possible outcomes. It would not mean that the lawyer considers your position to be even marginally weak. It most certainly does not mean ‘oops’, as Tim inaccurately states.

Just by the way, the tobacco industry’s argument is that what the government will acquire is more effective health warnings although that’s not an acquisition of property. The interesting point is that tobacco’s complaint is that the measures will work to reduce smoking. This honesty is welcome.

As for the international law claims, Tim continues to refer to one short e-mail from one staff member of IP Australia. He chooses not to refer to IP Australia’s official statement describing Tim’s interpretation of the e-mail as ‘misleading and incorrect’.

What he also does not tell us is that major global tobacco companies held a meeting in 1994 at a cost of about US$650,000 to discuss this very issue. Due to discovery of the documents in the course of tobacco litigation in the US, we know that a presentation to that meeting revealed the carefully considered legal advice that TRIPS provided ‘little joy’ to the tobacco industry. See the overhead slides here.

Since then, there have been further developments that have further eroded the tobacco industry’s already untenable claims. First, there has been considerable jurisprudence at the WTO concerning the capacity of member nations to take independent regulatory action in respect of public health measures. See the webcast referred to above. Second, the guidelines to the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control which has over 170 signatories have now recommended the adoption of plain packaging.

Tim refers to Article 20 and Article 8 of the TRIPS agreement but manages to obfuscate the issue. If these measures are necessary for public health, they will be justifiably imposed within the meaning of Article 20.

The issue boils down to whether there is evidence that the measures are necessary for public health. The tobacco industry has always challenged the suggestion that there is evidence of any facts justifying any regulation of its industry. In 1994, its executives swore on oath before Congress that they did not believe that nicotine is addictive. Tobacco companies have denied that there is any evidence that smoking causes cancer, any evidence that it causes heart disease, any evidence that passive smoking is harmful and any evidence that bans on advertising would lower smoking rates. Now, they question the evidence that the packaging that they spend so much money and time on developing attracts non-smokers and continues to attract existing smokers.

Here’s the problem for Tim and the organisations that he may or may not represent. The Internet and the academic literature are swarming with evidence directly from the internal documents of marketing departments of tobacco companies of their use of packaging to attract and retain smokers, especially ‘young adults’. In addition, there are numerous studies, dating back to at least 1995, showing that plain packaging will have a negative effect on uptake of smoking. The WTO and the scientific world will assess the evidence from a neutral, disinterested perspective.

As for declarations of qualifications and interests: I am a Professor in the Faculty of Law at Monash University, specialising in intellectual property. Further details are available on my website. I am a member of the Expert Advisory Group referred to in the Consultation Paper. I have spoken to employees of the Cancer Council Victoria about this issue. No financial benefit has been offered, promised or provided to me. I have been given some nice sandwiches at meetings and I have now accepted assurances that the orange juice was fresh.

Professor Mark Davison teaches law at Monash University and is the author of several major works relating to intellectual property and competition law.

Australia’s plain cigarette packaging debate could have domino effect overseas

http://www.packagingmag.com.au/news/australias-plain-cigarette-packaging-debate-c–1

Australia’s plain cigarette packaging debate could have domino effect overseas

The Federal Government’s plan to force all tobacco companies to sell cigarettes in plain packaging later this year could have a domino effect overseas.

According to ABC News, the European Union’s latest tobacco products directive is now being revised. Also, researcher Dr Crawford Moodie from Stirling University in Scotland has said that if the push for plain packaging is successful in Australia, other countries will follow.

“Really, the eyes of the world will be on what happens in Australia,” he told ABC News.

The enforcement of plain packaging will mean tobacco companies will not be able to display colours, brands, logos or promotional text on cigarette packets.

Research by Citigroup predicts smoking will die out in Australia by 2030 – only two years before Sweden, and a whole decade ahead of the UK – according to the ABC.

Professor of Health Policy at Curtin University, Mike Daube, said that he hoped cigarettes would no longer be sold in the next decade.

“I think we’re going to see a time where cigarettes can only be obtained from certain sales outlets, and possibly over time only with some kind of sign off that these people are registered smokers,” he told ABC News.

FDA requires list of tobacco ingredients

Last updated: January 9, 2011

Source: NewsOK

By late March, manufacturers of most tobacco products must begin giving the Food and Drug Administration information on new additives and other alterations in their products – enabling the agency for the first time to weed out chemical or manufacturing tweaks that make cigarettes and other products more addictive or otherwise more harmful.

Read the full story here: http://newsok.com/fda-requires-list-of-tobacco-ingredients/article/3530724

Smoking Also Kills The Environment; California Launches A New Strategy

Last updated: December 27, 2010

Source: Medical News Today

Smoking is a killer. We all know this. However, as we face a decaying environmental landscape, discarded cigarette butts have become the focus of a new ad campaign announced this week by the California Health and Human Services Agency (CHHS).

Thirty years ago, California began the fight to squelch tobacco use in their state, but today the newly launched ads include a focus attention on smoking’s environmental side effects of toxic tobacco waste. The themes of the new ads also include an awareness of progress California has made to date combating big tobacco, the challenges and importance of quitting smoking and bringing tricky marketing ploys front and center to the public’s awareness lens.

Secretary Kimberly Belshé of Public Health (CDPH) stated:

“I am proud of the tremendous progress that California has made during the past 20 years, but our job is not yet complete because nearly four million Californians still smoke, and tobacco remains the number one cause of preventable death and disease.”

Director of the CDPH, Dr. Mark Horton continued:

“California is proud, once again, to be a national leader in the fight against tobacco use and addiction, and is launching a new strategy – focusing attention on the degradation of the environment caused by discarded cigarette butts.”

The new focus of ads drives home the message that cigarettes are not just toxic to people, they are toxic to the environment as well. Cigarette butts are made of cellulose acetate, a plastic that does not biodegrade and can remain in the environment for years. Incredibly, as the most common trash found on beaches and roads, more than 100 million pounds of cigarette butts are discarded in the United States annually.

The campaign also includes television ads featuring Debi Austin. Austin first appeared in an iconic CDPH anti-tobacco ad in 1997 in which she smoked through her tracheotomy shortly after cancer surgery. As a Tobacco Educator, Debi does not preach right and wrong, instead she makes it a point that her audiences of young people and adults alike know that it is their beliefs that guide one’s own choices, that choices that guide actions, and actions that lead to consequences.

Aside from the announcement of this new campaign’s focus, California health leaders shared the latest statewide trends surrounding tobacco and the successes of the . These trends highlight the successes of California’s Tobacco Control Program over the years and challenges that still lie on the horizon. The California Tobacco Control Program was established by the Tobacco Tax and Health Promotion Act of 1988. The act, which was approved by California voters, instituted a 25-cent tax on each pack of cigarettes and earmarked 5 cents of that tax to fund California’s tobacco control efforts.

From 1988, there was a 42 percent decline in adult smoking prevalence from 22.7 percent in 1988 to 13.1 percent in 2009. Also, there has been a 42 percent decline among Asian/Pacific Islanders, and a 41 percent decline in smoking for both African American and Latino adults who smoke.

More than 1 million lives have been extended because of those who have given up smoking and by young adults that have not started due to awareness of the harm it causes.

Fiscally, $86 billion dollars in health care costs have been saved in the state alone, and lung cancer is declining more than three-times faster in California than in the rest of the nation.

Belshé and Horton also pointed out that research shows smoking rates are higher in less densely populated areas of the state. On average, people who live in rural California counties smoke at a higher rate of 15.9 percent than those who live in urban areas, which accounts for 10.9 percent of the general population.

To learn more about California’s tobacco control program visit www.TobaccoFreeCA.com.

Effectiveness of tax and price policies in tobacco control Frank J Chaloupka,1 Kurt Straif,2 Maria E Leon

Economics, College of Business Administration, Health Policy and Administration, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago,
Illinois, USA

29 NOV 2010

Smoking kills, says big tobacco on hacked plain packaging campaign site

Last updated: August 30, 2010

Source: Crikey

Retailers and big tobacco have ended their campaign against plain cigarette packaging, conceding ”colourful packaging does indeed promote smoking.” Or so the website for the alliance of associations and cigarette manufacturers backing the campaign says.

So has the website been hacked? Crikey was sent an anonymous tip off this morning that said: “The Alliance of Australian Retailers Pty Ltd. have quit their campaign against plain-packaging for cigarettes.”

But we couldn’t find anyone — retail associations, tobacco companies or the PR agency responsible for the website — to confirm whether the campaign against the Labor Party’s anti-smoking initiative is continuing.

From 2012, cigarettes will be sold in plain, standardised packages carrying only explicit images and warnings against smoking under a Labor plan angrily attacked by manufacturers and sellers.

As Crikey’s deadline approached the website for the Alliance of Australian Retailers was still declaring on the front page: “The campaign has ended.”

“In the interest of public health and aligning with society’s values, we have decided to end this campaign. All Australian Retailers operate in mixed communities, and we believe the greater good of the non-smoking majority is worth more than that of the smoking minority.

“Current smokers will continue to smoke regardless of packaging. We refuse to give incentive to those that don’t smoke in any form whatsoever – thus we have ended our campaign against plain packaging.”

The alliance includes the Service Station Association, Australian Newsagent Federation and the National Independent Retailers Association. Neither group wanted to speak about the campaign, directing Crikey to Craig Glasby as the “only authorised spokesperson”. He didn’t return calls by deadline.

The campaign is also “supported” by tobacco giants British American Tobacco, Philip Morris and Imperial Tobacco Australia. A spokesperson for British American Tobacco confirmed the campaign is continuing but was “taking a different shape” without wanting to give more details.

Sheryle Moon, executive director of the Australasian Association of Convenience Stores, was leading the campaign as ‘director’ of the alliance, including a disastrous interview with the ABC’s Lateline program earlier this month where she admitted she wished her son would quit “because stopping smoking in the community is a good thing.”

Moon has since withdrawn from the campaign and her association has left the alliance. She told Crikey today the priorities of the action were “slightly different” to that of her association. She says plain packaging and a ban on retail display promotions is “another impost on retailers” but says the focus should be on the growing counterfeit tobacco market.

On its ‘what we stand for’ page, the seemingly hacked alliance website lists a number of diseases and health complications associated with smoking. It goes on to say:

“In recent times we have been hit with an excessive tax hike that has made our businesses a target for theft and only further fuelled the flourishing black market in tobacco products. Yet after reviewing the above diseases and compelling evidence that smoking is a negative strain on society, we have decided that we can bear plain packaging.

“In fact, it will even reduce cigarette companies’ printing costs, thus off-setting some of the tax hike burden.

“We believe that reducing smoking is good for our community. But good policies require more than good intentions. Whilst there is no reliable evidence anywhere in the world that plain packaging will stop people from taking up smoking, or help people to quit, it can’t hurt to try.

“With no credible evidence to support plain packaging, the Alliance has statement for Canberra:

“If it might work, but we’re not sure, and it decreases printing costs, let’s do it.”

Its links page includes references to ‘myths and misconceptions’ about smoking from the Cancer Council of Australia, while the contact page says: “Any comments or queries can be directed to mediawatch@your.abc.net.au”.

Duty-free tobacco allowance cut

Last updated: July 27, 2010

Source: Hong Kong Government News

The tobacco allowance for incoming passengers will be tightened to 19 cigarettes, or 25 grams of cigar or 25 grams of other manufactured tobacco, from August 1.(2010)

The Customs & Excise Department said today passengers exceeding these quantities must make a declaration to customs officers or face two-years’ jail and a $1 million fine.

The move will be promoted via television and radio announcements, and leaflets, posters and banners at control points and cross-boundary transportation facilities.

Singapore Looks To Be Tobacco Free

Last updated: July 20, 2010

Source: Government of Singapore

Tobacco  (Control of advertisements and Sale) Act closing speech by Mr Khaw
Boon Wan.

Mr Speaker, Sir, 11 Members have spoken on this Bill. Dr Lam Pin Min gave us
a good account of the harm of tobacco.

Mr Hri Kumar’s passionate speech struck a chord. Your common message is loud
and clear: “tobacco is harmful, let’s do our best to protect our people from
its harm”.

Thank you for supporting this Bill. We will do what is practical to
implement it effectively.

Emerging Products

First, many members support the ban on emerging tobacco products. Mr Seah
Kian Peng’s account on snus, a smokeless product, is instructive. Let’s not
allow them to land here.

However, Dr Lam Pin Min and A/Prof Fatimah Lateef suggested that we do not
ban such products entirely, but to consider some of them as part of a harm
reduction strategy to help smokers quit smoking.

It reminded me of our experience with Subutex as a harm reduction strategy
to get drug addicts off heroin. The West touted this strategy and we tried
it out with disastrous results. It took MHA and I quite some time to reverse
the policy.

A less harmful tobacco product is an oxymoron. I share Mr Hri Kumar’s view
on this subject and agree with his robust approach. In the 1970s, the
tobacco companies introduced cigarettes purported to be “low tar”, “light”
or “mild” as safer alternatives.

They promoted such cigarettes to smokers who had heath concerns and were
thinking of quitting. These products rapidly gained market share. As a
result, there was a net increase in cigarette consumption. Independent
research later on showed that smokers compensated by smoking more cigarettes
or inhaling more deeply.

Prof Lateef quoted the positive experience of snus in Sweden. The Swedish
experience has never been replicated outside of Sweden. I note that snus is
a Swedish product.

The evidence is actually the opposite, with the use of snus resulting in
smokers becoming addicted to both cigarettes and snus. More smokeless
tobacco use does not mean less cigarette smoking.

Smokers use smokeless tobacco products to tide over nicotine craving in
places where smoking is prohibited while continuing to smoke in other places
where smoking is allowed – this perversely reduces the impetus for them to
quit smoking.

Meanwhile, tobacco companies get to entice non-smokers to develop nicotine
addiction, adding to their customer base.

Our experience with Subutex as a less harmful heroin substitute is similar.
Instead of reducing the number of drug addicts, we ended up with more. I
strongly advise against adopting such so-called harm reduction strategy.

But I agree with Dr Lam and Prof Lateef that we should try to help smokers
“to gradually quit in a controlled manner”. There are proper ways to do so,
one is through controlled Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT), by following
strict guidelines. We do not prohibit nicotine used in such a manner.

I would like to assure Mr Alvin Yeo that we will, in the assessment process,
undertake the necessary studies before imposing any ban under Section 15. We
will keep an open mind about this.

Education and Smoking Cessation

Second, all the members expressed concerns over the rising smoking
prevalence among certain population groups, including the young, the ladies
and the Malays. Mdm Halimah’s speech in Malay made a heart-felt appeal to
the Malay smokers to think about the welfare of their children and to get
them to stop smoking.

To be credible, they have to walk the talk by quitting smoking themselves. I
join her in this appeal. I also thank Mdm Halimah for highlighting the harm
pregnant mothers bring to their infants if they smoke.

All the Members called for stronger smoking control measures. I agree
entirely.

We have implemented various programmes, and we will continue to try new
ones. We work with schools, religious institutions, the employers, the
charity sector and the community at large. I note Mdm Halimah’s illustration
of the Sheraton Towers as an exemplary employer who went the extra mile to
get their employees to quit smoking. I applaud such employers and urge more
to join the movement.

I heard Mdm Cynthia Phua’s call for schools to reach out to students who
smoke and get them to quit. I appreciate her sharing several research
findings done in schools overseas on effective counselling, including
telephone counselling. I note her point that with teens, enforcement and
penalty do not work as well.

The psychology often works the other way. What is prohibited becomes highly
valued. We try to tap on the young to guide us on how to reach out to their
peers.

I had focus group discussions with young lady smokers. They knew the harm of
tobacco and had tried to quit but when their own family members and close
friends are smokers, they found it difficult. This is obviously a complex
issue. As Prof Straughan noted, one underlying cause could be the larger
problem of some youths needing to embrace “sub-cultures” in order to seek
“affirmation from like-minded peers”.

We will definitely try to do more and learn from others. We have discussed
the various initiatives in this House before. In the interest of time, I
will not repeat them here.

Our efforts have not been futile. Let me quote one indicator. The proportion
of Secondary School students who have ever tried cigarette smoking has
dropped from 26% in 2000 to 16% in 2009. This is a victory for us. But we
need to do better.

Third, Ms Ellen Lee, Mdm Halimah, and Prof Straughan called for stronger
enforcement against sales to the under-age. I agree. We will step up
policing on tobacco retail outlets. We will consider raising the penalty on
repeat offenders. We are also considering disallowing tobacco sales in
outlets frequented by young customers.

FCTC Obligations

Fourth, Dr Lam Pin Min asked about Singapore’s compliance with the Framework
Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) and whether we had been tardy. To date,
we will be the third country in the world to fulfil all the obligations on
tobacco labelling should this Bill be passed.

Dr Lam wondered if the delay in implementing the FCTC was a cause for the
increase in smoking prevalence here. I doubt it. We have been ahead of the
curve in tobacco control and in any case were largely FCTC compliant right
from the start.

Dr Lam asked if we should give the tobacco companies more than 12 months to
implement the changes to tobacco product packaging. We decided on “12
months” based on actual past experience when we introduced mandatory health
warning labels. They were able to comply.

I appreciate Mr Sin Boon Ann’s thoughtful piece on “lateral advertising”,
“subliminal marketing” and “advertising through the internet”. Mr Calvin
Cheng made a similar observation. Indeed, these are the innovations that
tobacco companies are mounting to get around the FCTC. It is a hot topic
currently being discussed among international regulators including
ourselves.

We do not yet have all the answers to these challenges. For example, how do
we deal with internet advertising?

How do we censor out scenes of James Bond smoking a particular brand of
cigarette? I have not noticed Mr Sin’s observation that Mark Lee seemed to
be particularly fond of Marlboro cigarettes. I will have a quiet word with
him the next time I see him.

But where we can, we should act. For example, we have removed the exemption
for congratulatory messages and sponsorship publicity.

Mr Hri Kumar has described past misleading behaviours by tobacco companies.
This is unethical behaviour. I agree with his observations.

From a public health perspective, misleading terms are just as misleading,
even if they are part of a trade mark. Mr Alvin Yeo raised several legal
queries on this. The new s17A will affect trademarks if they contain
misleading descriptors.

We are aware of our TRIPS and other international obligations and have
consulted the relevant authorities extensively on this point. The proposed
section 17A is aligned closely to the FCTC and will not violate Singapore’s
international obligations. We are in good company: the EU prohibits
misleading terms and descriptors even if they are part of the trademarks or
brand names.

Other Issues

Lastly, there were some comments which do not pertain to the proposed
amendments in the current Bill. But let me briefly address them.

Ms Ellen Lee and Mr Hri Kumar made a plea on behalf of the non-smokers and
especially innocent children, from the effects of second hand smoke from
inconsiderate neighbours, and irresponsible parents. Ms Lee asked the NEA to
widen the outdoor smoking ban to include more common places in HDB towns,
such as void decks and common corridors.

I will raise her suggestion with the NEA. Mr Hri Kumar asked rhetorically
how we could extend the law to the privacy of the home, in order to protect
the children from second-hand smoke. He knew it is outside my purview. But I
note his point.

Dr Lam suggested that we control retail pricing of tobacco products, to make
them expensive, thus curbing consumption. In practice, price fixing seldom
works, as we live in a region where cigarettes are cheap. For the same
reason, while we have been aggressive in tobacco taxation, there are limits,
but we will continue to use this strategy where practical and feasible.

Conclusion

Mr Speaker, Sir, tobacco related deaths and illnesses are preventable. Let’s
try to make Singapore as tobacco free as possible. When drafting this Bill,
we had extensive consultation with Singaporeans. The amendments received
strong support from them.

Mr Speaker Sir, I beg to move.

How Smokeless Tobacco Became Banned in Hong Kong

smokeless-tobaccoRead here the 1986 original correspondence between the US Congress and the HK Government.