Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Might isn’t right, Labor tells big tobacco

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/breaking-news/might-isnt-right-labor-tells-big-tobacco/story-e6frf7jx-1226082990152

PRIME Minister Julia Gillard believes the federal government is capable of winning a legal stoush with big tobacco over plain packaging of cigarettes because it’s on the right side of the argument.

Philip Morris has launched an action suggesting the commonwealth is effectively planning to steal the company’s brand in contravention of a bilateral investment treaty Australia signed with Hong Kong 20 years ago.

But Ms Gillard says Labor isn’t about to be intimidated.

“We’re going to deliver cigarette packages in that drab green with no logos,” she told ABC Radio on Monday.

“We’re very confident of our position.”

Philip Morris spokeswoman Anne Edwards is equally convinced the cigarette maker has “an extremely strong case”.

She says if plain packaging is introduced companies should be compensated.

“By attempting to take our company property (brand) … it’s a very, very clear violation of the investment treaty that Australia has with Hong Kong,” Ms Edwards told Fairfax Radio.

But legal experts say things aren’t that clear cut.

A lawyer who’s had more experience than most fighting cigarette companies in court, Peter Gordon, believes Philip Morris is actually on shaky ground.

“The suggestion that the commonwealth is trying to take away the property rights of tobacco companies is of course a farcical proposition,” he told AAP.

“No one’s suggesting they’re not allowed to own these trademarks, they’re just suggesting they’re not allowed to use them in a way which improperly promote cigarette use among kids.”

Mr Gordon, formerly of Slater and Gordon, worked on the marathon Rolah McCabe cancer case against British American Tobacco until he was sued by the company himself.

He says while big tobacco is normally successful against smaller claimants it doesn’t have such a good track record against larger litigants it can’t outspend.

Manufacturers have had to cough up billions of dollars when they’ve gone up against the US federal government, combined US states and even Australian retailers backed by a wealthy litigation funder.

“Every time that a sovereign nation or a sufficiently funded private litigant has taken them on over a good case they’ve won,” he said.

It’s a point Health Minister Nicola Roxon rammed home on Monday too.

“It may be that big tobacco are famous for taking on victims – we’ve seen that over the past decades,” she told reporters in Canberra.

“(But) this is a course of action which is in the public interest.

“We won’t be frightened off by threats of legal action.”

International law expert Don Anton thinks the commonwealth is right to argue plain packaging is about protecting peoples’ health – not stealing intellectual property.

“(It’s arguable that) public regulation for a public purpose is not direct or indirect expropriation and therefore is not prohibited by the investment treaty,” the Australian National University academic told ABC TV.

Fellow ANU expert Donald Rothwell says until Labor introduces its draft laws into parliament, which could occur as early as next week, it’s not even clear Philip Morris has a cause of action.

The company is yet to suffer any damage, Prof Rothwell told AAP.

“So I see this more as an attempt to fire a shot across the bows.”

Printing, ink and packaging suppliers discuss ways to make packs more appealing

Brandy Brinson http://www.tobaccoreporter.com/home.php?id=119&cid=4&article_id=10817

Everyone in the industry is looking for the next latest and greatest innovations as the bar is raised higher and higher for cigarette packs. All the focus on advertising and marketing is now turned to the pack, as restrictions abound and the pack remains the one avenue of communication with the consumer. Today’s packs are certainly turning heads with glitz and glamour—flashy foils, fancy paperboard featuring unique curves, and etching and embossing that you just have to touch. And all the while, these eye-catching designs serve another purpose—thwarting counterfeiters.

Tobacco Reporter caught up with a few leading suppliers to discuss packaging trends.

Foil

“Packaging has evolved greatly over the past 40 years, moving from simple printed cartons to lacquered finished boxes to plastic shrink sleeves with foil imprints. In the 1960s, the trend was multicolor printing with lacquering and/or lamination,” says Jacquie Wells, spokesperson for foil supplier Kurz.

Hot stamping dates back to the late 1800s with the use of authentic gold foil “leaf,” and it wasn’t until the past 40 years or so that the commercial use of foil as a decorative enhancement became widespread. “Hot stamping didn’t get its legs until the mid 1980s. At that time, an advance in application equipment allowed for higher speeds, making hot foils more flexible. Hot foil also gave products more appeal and allowed designs to become very diverse.”

Hot foils are transferred using a combination of heat and pressure, providing a very unique advantage—gloss level. “Structural and relief stamping are not only eye-catching, they also possess tactile characteristics offering even further potential for product positioning,” says Wells.

One of the most noticeable changes in packaging today is the use of hot and cold foil to give products more “pop” and shelf appeal, she says. “Many brands not only use hot or cold foil on the exterior package, but also on the product itself to make the brand and product more memorable. Foil increases the product’s overall appeal and brand imagery, and it can create more purchase interest.” Growth of foil use is due in part to the effectiveness of true product differentiation, luxury presentation and brand security features through foil stamping and embossing techniques, she adds.

Cold foils are gaining popularity in the market because they are cost effective and can be applied more quickly than hot foils, as today’s machinery allows faster application speeds. These foils are applied with adhesive, are highly versatile and have excellent design qualities.

“Today, cold foil is coming of age, bringing packaging houses a quick, efficient, cost-effective means of decorating with foil. Over the coming year, it is anticipated that cold foil will gain more ground in the marketplace and we will continue to see a trend towards more ‘green’ packaging.”

As for product security, Kurz offers a proprietary technology called Trustseal, which combines a variety of security features for brand owners and consumers. Wells says, “Tamper-evident seals and beautifully designed, custom-tailored solutions minimize brand erosion and maximize product visibility.”

Embossing cylinders

Engraved embossing cylinders are used to decorate cigarette packaging by running in line with printing presses in a single pass. Thus, no additional processes or raw materials such as special inks or foils are required to enhance the package, explains Peter Spector, vice president of sales for Eastern Engraving.

“This is especially advantageous for point-of-purchase selling where no other form of advertising is permissible. Embossing cylinders can be housed in existing press rotary die stations or in stand-alone units. Embossing can be registered to print with tight tolerance, overall patterns and textures, or blind (non-registered). Ribs that produce the round corner effect to create elliptical-shaped packages can also be engraved on the embossing cylinders either alone or in conjunction with registered embossing.”

Embossing cylinders can be engraved by chemical etching (photo engraving) or CNC milling. Overall patterns or textures may be engraved by machine engraving using die and mill tooling. Eastern Engraving uses a wax jet digital imaging system as a means of more accurately “printing” the cylinder prior to etching. The cylinders themselves can be solid steel, segmented inserts or copper-covered bases.

Etched embossing cylinders.

Gerrit van der Veen, division manager for tobacco and member of the board of ATG-Systems, discussed embossing and mock-up service in the tobacco industry at a presentation at TABEXPO Interactive. ATG manufactures engraved and etched embossing cylinders.

He discussed a new service from ATG regarding the initial design of new packs. “The usual way of starting a redesign, a limited edition or a new brand is using the design agency. The mock-ups they create are made in offset. Sometimes even with flatbed embossing. After approval from the brand manager, the printers, together with the cylinder manufacturers and the ink companies, try to reproduce this mock-up. Often they find out that the first mock-up cannot be reproduced, because of various reasons. A lot of time is lost and the brand manager doesn‘t understand why it all starts over again,” says Van der Veen.

ATG is offering a new kind of service—producing a “realistic” mock-up, which can be reproduced later on the gravure printing machine. ATG can make “barrel proofing“ cylinders. “With this, we can make on the original material and with the original inks, a realistic sample. Because this has been made with gravure cylinders, this can be reproduced later for the production cylinders in the same way. We start with several options, and the brand manager chooses the best option,” says Van der Veen.

If the brand manager has approved one of the versions, ATG can do the embossing on the same samples. After the printing and the embossing, ATG makes the mock-up and the brand manager has a “realistic“ pack in his hands. This is a sample that can be reproduced later in production.

“We can also use this service to find out how an old design looks with new (“all-over”) embossings,” says Van der Veen. “In this way, we save a lot of time—and money—because marketing will get a sample made with the right tools—in gravure and with rotary embossing, instead of an offset proof with flatbed embossing.”

Gravure printing

Gravure printing has come a long way in recent years. “Looking back in time, only pure engraved or conventional etched cylinders were in place. About 20 years ago, with the invention of laser technique to harden the light-sensitive cover, a much better definition of the text element became possible. The latest steps in direct laser engraving widen the technical possibilities as well. But also the classical engraving became better by innovations like the extreme gravure,” says Ruediger Brinkmann of Gundlach Verpackung GmbH, a supplier of printing solutions for the tobacco industry.

“Nowadays we make use of all applicable cylinder manufacturing techniques—depending on the special nature of the print jobs, it can be a combination of different techniques. This offers the tobacco industry a wide range of high-quality text elements, four-color pictures and, especially in gravure, very good effects with metal inks and varnishes.”

Precision has increased over the years due to sophisticated data workflow. This is vital to meeting the tight print and converting tolerances of customers, says Brinkmann.

“Last but not least the price for gravure cylinders became more competitive—a very important development for gravure versus flexo.”

In the future, he says, “We expect a further technical development with direct laser cylinders in view of cost and quality in order to keep the gap to alternative printing methods.”

New Packaging

Oscar Bos, sales director for Gestel Printing Co. says today’s trends in packaging and printing are to “create and use more space for communication with the consumer to compensate for the loss of advertising possibilities for tobacco products; and to introduce limited-edition packs (LEPs), often using nonconventional materials to draw the consumer’s attention and to make the product more attractive.”

In line with these goals, Gestel Printing Company B.V. recently introduced a brand-new packaging concept—the Zmart Box. The company launched the pack at TABEXPO.

Interestingly, the pack finds its origin in the roots of the company. In the late 19th century, Gestel started as a supplier for the cigar industry, which was located mainly in the area around Eindhoven in the south of the Netherlands. The products that Gestel supplied started from cigar bands and cigar box labels but were later followed by the well-known shoulderboxes—the main type of cigar packaging nowadays. Over the years, Gestel broadened its market by adding some of the world’s largest cigarette manufacturers to its customer list, besides various other “luxury” markets such as the chocolate, liquor and cosmetics industries.

“Having produced shoulderboxes for such a long time already, we wanted to find a type of packaging that had the manufacturing features of a modern cigarette hinged lid but the looks of the more luxurious shoulderbox,” says Bos.

Although the shoulderbox looks great, it is more expensive than a hinged lid due to several reasons. For one, it is made up of four separate parts (bottom, lid, label and shoulder) instead of one; also, after printing it has to be assembled into a shoulderbox; and furthermore, it has higher freight costs due to the transport of boxes instead of flat-packs.

The Zmart Box is unique because it is a one-piece flat-pack, based on the same wrap-around concept as a hinged lid. However, once made up, it looks like a shoulderbox. This offers a unique opportunity to cigarette manufacturers as they can now produce high volumes of shoulderbox-like packs at ta speed and cost almost comparable to that of normal hinge-lid packs.

Compared with a conventional shoulderbox, the manufacturing costs are about 40 percent lower, and the assembling/filling speed is up to five times quicker. “For Gestel, this means we can expand our market for this type of packaging to not only cigar but also cigarette manufacturers, which obviously means larger volumes. This is not entirely unwelcome considering these volumes have been decreasing substantially over the last years due to more rigid government legislations,” says Bos.

To be able to offer a complete solution, Gestel has established a partnership with a machine manufacturer to develop a brand-new machine. Some of the features of the machine include an assembling/filling speed up to 300 boxes per minute and the possibility to vary shapes and sizes using Flex Units. Depending on the customer’s requirements, the machine can be installed in a production plant within seven or eight months.

Bos says, “Adding everything up, we are convinced that we have developed a unique concept for tobacco manufacturers and look forward to making it a success together with our valued customers.”

Bloomberg – Philip Morris Claims Australia’s Plain Cigarette Package Plan is Illegal

Philip Morris International Inc. (PM), the world’s largest publicly traded tobacco company, said it has started legal action against
the Australian government over plans to allow the sale of cigarettes only in plain packages. The company filed a notice of claim
against the government saying the proposals violate terms of Australia’s Bilateral Investment Treaty with Hong Kong, Philip
Morris’ Asian unit said in an e-mailed statement today. A copy of the court document wasn’t immediately available. Australia,
which has already banned the public display of tobacco products in retail outlets, plans to outlaw logos on cigarette packs and
force them to be sold in plain dark olive packaging, carrying health warnings instead of company logos. Cigarette brand names
will appear on the packages in the same size and style of printing. The legislation, if passed by parliament, will come into force
on Jan. 1, 2012. “The forced removal of trademarks and other valuable intellectual property is a clear violation of the terms of
the bilateral investment treaty between Australia and Hong Kong,” Anne Edwards, a spokeswoman for Philip Morris Asia, said in
the statement. “We believe we have a very strong legal case and will be seeking significant financial compensation for the
damage to our business.” The government raised tobacco taxes by 25 percent last year as it seeks to curb smoking, which is the
nation’s largest single preventable cause of death, according to Health Minister Nicola Roxon. “We don’t believe that taking
that action is in breach of any of our international obligations,” Roxon told Sky News today. “We believe that we are able, and
the Australian people I think would expect their government, to take action in the interests of public health.” To contact the
reporter on this story: Robert Fenner in Melbourne at rfenner@bloomberg.net To contact the editor responsible for this
story: Neil Denslow at ndenslow@bloomberg.net

Philip Morris International Inc. (PM), the world’s largest publicly traded tobacco company, said it has started legal action againstthe Australian government over plans to allow the sale of cigarettes only in plain packages. The company filed a notice of claimagainst the government saying the proposals violate terms of Australia’s Bilateral Investment Treaty with Hong Kong, PhilipMorris’ Asian unit said in an e-mailed statement today. A copy of the court document wasn’t immediately available. Australia,which has already banned the public display of tobacco products in retail outlets, plans to outlaw logos on cigarette packs andforce them to be sold in plain dark olive packaging, carrying health warnings instead of company logos. Cigarette brand nameswill appear on the packages in the same size and style of printing. The legislation, if passed by parliament, will come into forceon Jan. 1, 2012. “The forced removal of trademarks and other valuable intellectual property is a clear violation of the terms ofthe bilateral investment treaty between Australia and Hong Kong,” Anne Edwards, a spokeswoman for Philip Morris Asia, said inthe statement. “We believe we have a very strong legal case and will be seeking significant financial compensation for thedamage to our business.” The government raised tobacco taxes by 25 percent last year as it seeks to curb smoking, which is thenation’s largest single preventable cause of death, according to Health Minister Nicola Roxon. “We don’t believe that takingthat action is in breach of any of our international obligations,” Roxon told Sky News today. “We believe that we are able, andthe Australian people I think would expect their government, to take action in the interests of public health.”

Download PDF : Combined(1)

Plain Packaging

Download PDF : Plain-Packs-Sydney-Institute

Factoids and legal bollocks in war against plain packaging

by Simon Chapman

With the passage of the government’s bill on plain packaging now assured by the support of the opposition, the Greens and all but one of the independents, an ever-desperate tobacco industry is now  concentrating on the legal apocalypse that they say will descend on Australia through the courts.

These arguments are all a paper-thin house of cards, starting with the central problem that plain packaging will not extinguish brand identities. All brands will still carry brand names allowing smokers to clearly exercise their freedom of choice to select between the much-vaunted but mostly non-existent differences in brands. This is critical, because in the highly unlikely event of a ruling by the High Court in favour of the industry, all calculations of compensation will need to take account that branding differences have only been diminished, not extinguished.

Given that some 30-40 nations now have appropriated massive sections of packs with graphic warnings and that not a cent has been claimed or awarded in brand damage  anywhere in the world for this egregious assault on brand identity, the prospects of any claim for huge compensation even in the unlikely event of a favourable ruling are vanishingly small. The companies would need to demonstrate with precision that sales losses arose from losing colours, logos and different pack shapes, not brand names.

Given that consumption is falling every year, this task would be like unraveling gossamer while wearing boxing gloves.

Few of those megaphoning this legal Armageddon appear to have even read the draft Bill itself. Section 11  makes it clear that plain packaging won’t apply if it were to be determined (by a court) that its operation would result in an acquisition of property otherwise than on just terms. So in the unlikely event that the High Court says there is an acquisition of property (more on this below), the legislation would revert to a fallback position in the regulations under which “the trade mark may be used on the packaging of tobacco products, or on a tobacco product, in accordance with any requirements prescribed in the regulations”.

In other words, the bill has been drafted with a get-out-of-jail-free card under which plain packaging will not proceed if the court said it was an unjust acquisition. So massive damages or compensation will simply not arise.

Moreover, Monash University’s Prof Mark Davison has explained “As for the Constitutional argument that the legislation acquires property on other than just terms, Professor Craven, a noted Constitutional expert, has since observed on Radio National’s Background Briefing that the tobacco industry’s prospects of success are about the same as a three-legged horse has of winning the Melbourne Cup. The reason for his view is simply explained. The extinction of rights or the reduction of rights is not relevant. The government or a third party must acquire property as a consequence of the legislation.

“The government does not wish to use the tobacco trade marks. Nor does it want third parties to do so. It does not desire to or intend to acquire any property. The proposition that prohibitions on the use of property do not constitute an acquisition of property was confirmed by the High Court as recently as 2009. In that case, the High Court held that the government was entitled to extinguish property rights in licences of farmers to take bore water.”

But the industry and its errand boys, such as those at the Institute of Public Affairs, nonetheless know that the threat of a massive legal penalty will get them headlines. A big number is required and the number that has been selected is $3 billion … per year. So where did this satisfyingly large number come from? It started circulating in May 2010 and has been repeated countless times since by frothing shock-jocks and some who should have known better.

Step forward Tim Wilson, the director of intellectual property and the Free Trade Unit and the IPA. Wilson sent asubmission to Senator Steve Fielding’s inquiry into plain packaging where we can examine his prowess with the numbers.

At page four in his executive summary he says plain packs would lead to a court order to award the tobacco industry  between $378 million and $3027 million per year. Table 2 (page 13) in his submission shows two lines of numbers for the total value of tobacco sales in Australia in 2006: one for the value including excise tax (which goes to the government) and one for the sales value ex-tax (in other words the returns to manufacturers and retailers combined). By taking the trouble to differentiate the two, Wilson must know that no court would order the return of the tobacco tax component to the companies: it’s the ex-tax value that fuels such a pipe-dream.

Wilson then calculates the ex-tax value on two assumptions: a 10% and a 30% fall in sales  each year that might follow the introduction of plain packs. He calculates these two figures at $378 million and $1.135 billion. So where does the $3 billion factoid come from? Are you ready for this? The tax-included sales value of a 30% fall is $3.027 billion.

So how reasonable are Wilson’s assumptions that plain packs will cause a fall of a minimum 10% through to 30% a year? Between 1999 and 2003 the average annual fall in total dutied cigarettes was just 2.6%. The most sales haveever fallen in one year was just shy of 10% in 1999 after the combined impact of a change in the way  cigarettes were taxed (from weight to per stick) and a big boost to the national quit campaign by health minister Michael Wooldridge.

Most analysts of the likely impact of plain packaging believe that its main impact will be on children over the next generations. Just as no Australian aged under 19 today has ever seen a local tobacco ad or tobacco sponsored sporting event, no child growing up after 2010 will ever see carcinogenic  tobacco products packaged in carefully market researched attractive boxes. Smoking rates by kids today are the lowest ever recorded. Plain packs are expected to continue that downward momentum, starving the industry of new generations of new smokers as older smokers quit and die early. Plain packs will probably not influence long-term, older smokers much.

Wilson’s $3 billion number is thus based on a projected decline, which is so far off the planet of declines ever recorded, that it is dreamland stuff. Worse, it appears to be a willful selection of the tax-included biggest number he could sight in his own table. To the delight of the industry, it has now become a virulent factoid with Google showing more than 7000 hits for “plain packs cigarettes” and “$3 billion”.  Tim, you are a true contributor to informed public debate.

*Simon Chapman is professor of public health at the University of Sydney.

Moves by Big Tobacco to use Australia / HKG bilateral investment agreement in its favour against incoming Plain Packaging legislation – Huff and Puff threats

http://www.abc.net.au/am/content/2011/s3253997.htm

Tobacco giant ready to launch legal action against Govt

Alexandra Kirk reported this story on Monday, June 27, 2011 08:04:00

Listen to MP3 of this story ( minutes)

Alternate WMA version | MP3 download

TONY EASTLEY: The Federal Health Minister, Nicola Roxon says the Government is on “very strong legal ground” and can withstand a legal challenge to its plain packaging legislation from tobacco giant, Philip Morris.

Philip Morris says it will begin the process today – serving a “notice of claim” on the Government, which triggers a three-month negotiating period.

The cigarette manufacturer says if there’s no resolution, the matter will then go to international arbitration, arguing the Government is breaching a bilateral investment treaty between Australia and Hong Kong, where Philip Morris’s parent company is based.

It says if it wins the compensation bill it may run into billions.

The Federal Health Minister, Nicola Roxon spoke to Alexandra Kirk in Canberra.

NICOLA ROXON: We believe that we are on very strong legal ground. We are breaking new ground around the world. This is the first time any country has taken this step and of course our Government would take proper advice to ensure that we can do that.

ALEXANDRA KIRK: Did you take advice on this bilateral investment treaty that Australia has with Hong Kong which Philip Morris maintains your plain packaging legislation would breach?

NICOLA ROXON: Well, I’m not going to go through the details of all of our legal advice in the media. Suffice to say we are very confident that we are on strong ground and I do need to point out to the public that I think they would expect that their own government, Australians expect the Australian Government to be able to take action which are in the community’s interests and in the interest of public health.

The World Health Organization recommends that states consider taking this action. We believe that it will be an effective part of our fight against tobacco and our determination to reduce the harm caused from smoking. But obviously big tobacco is going to fight this tooth and nail and we said from day one that we expected they would.

ALEXANDRA KIRK: And how much are you willing to spend defending your position? Presumably big tobacco has very deep pockets.

NICOLA ROXON: Well, they do because they make very large profits out of a lot of misery and death caused to thousands of Australians every year. So we already spend billions of dollars dealing with the harms caused from tobacco. Of course, we can’t stop tobacco companies taking legal action. We’ll defend our determination to protect public health and try to reduce the harms of smoking and ultimately I am confident that we are on very strong ground.

ALEXANDRA KIRK: Do health reasons though, which you cite, override a company’s ability to use a brand to differentiate itself from its competitors?

NICOLA ROXON: Well, I believe that it is in the public interest for us to be able to take this step. Tobacco is unlike any other product, any other legal product in the world. We know so much about the harm it causes. We know that there is not a single safe cigarette or amount of smoking that can be done in a way which may not lead to very severe health outcomes.

So in those unusual circumstances, taking steps as we have already done in Australia to severely restrict advertising, has not been able to be challenged and similarly we think this next sensible, logical step will not be successfully challenged either.

ALEXANDRA KIRK: The notice of claim that Philip Morris is lodging today triggers a period of three months for negotiation. Will you negotiate with Philip Morris?

NICOLA ROXON: Well, I’m not going to make comments on a claim that has not even been provided to me. It is in the media and I’m happy to make general comments in the media and when these materials are served on us, we will deal with them appropriately.

TONY EASTLEY: The Federal Health Minister, Nicola Roxon speaking there with Alexandra Kirk in Canberra.

http://www.unctad.org/sections/dite/iia/docs/bits/hongkong_australia.pdf

Tobacco funding: time to quit – The Drum Opinion (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)

Clear the Air says : Hong Kong SAR (sub China)  is a ratified party to the FCTC Treaty.

The FCTC Treaty  Article 5.3  Section 4.11 states ”Taking into account national law and constitutional principles, Parties should have effective measures to prohibit contributions from the tobacco industry or any entity working to further its interests to political parties, candidates or campaigns, or to require full disclosure of such contributions.”  Hong Kong remains in contravention of this International  Treaty section and has no law to prohibit such contributions nor to force political parties or front organisations to disclose their sources of contribution funding.       This needs to change.

14 June 2011

Abbott can’t shake the stink of the tobacco lobby

Michael Danby

As every smoker knows, one of the worst things about the tobacco habit is the smell – it clings to you no matter what you do. That’s the problem the Liberal Party now has. They’ve been in the pocket of the tobacco lobby for so long that they can’t shake off the stink, no matter how hard they try.

The Liberal Party’s last-minute turnaround on plain packaging of cigarettes, after much huffing and puffing, won’t help them escape from the clutches of the tobacco companies who fill their party coffers. The question for Mr Abbott is: when will he kick the habit of taking money from the tobacco companies?

The Labor Party announced in 2004 that it would not on principle take money from Big Tobacco. Since then the tobacco companies have lavished more than $1.5 million on the Coalition parties. This does not include donations to individual electorate campaigns who are under the disclosable limit of 10,000.

According to the AEC data, since 1998 the Liberal Party has received $1,618,353 from British American Tobacco (BAT) and $1,440,595 from Phillip Morris. During last year’s election the Liberal Party received $145,035 from British American Tobacco and $147,035 from Phillip Morris.

Source: Assembled from Donor Returns published in the website of the Australian Electoral Commission (Prepared: 31 May 2011)

As Health Minister Nicola Roxon stated in parliament last week, BAT makes political donations to political parties in only three countries in the world, and Australia accounts for nearly all that spending – 97% of BAT’s donations go to the Liberal Party and the National Party.

During last year’s election, the tobacco companies funded a $5.5 million anti-Labor ad blitz with the help of Liberal strategists, headed by Jason Aldsworth of the Civic Group – a former Liberal parliamentary candidate – and including former Howard government adviser Mark Domitrak (now head of corporate affairs at BAT) and former Howard adviser Chris Argent (now corporate affairs director at Phillip Morris).

Phillip Morris International and BAT spent $2.2 million each, and Imperial Tobacco Australia spent $1.1 million.

This funded campaign was coordinated under the sham organisation, The Alliance of Australian retailers, who are controlled by tobacco companies under the guise of representing retailers. It was brought into existence solely as a medium for tobacco companies to influence public opinion, and was payed $200,000 a month retainer. In emails to and from the parties involved, entitled “Your Commission”, Jason Aldsworth of the Civic Group was asked  whether he would like the commission to be transferred “to your bank, or hold it for drinks in Barbados?” Mr. Aldsworth responded “…Maybe the bank for this one – we’ll use the next one for the drinks tab in Barbados” and provided the account details for the Civic Group.

Nothing illustrates the persistent stink of tobacco that haunts the Liberal Party than the unanswered questions about the Member for Indi, Sophie Mirabella, and the secret donation that BAT made to her in 2007 via a group called “Friends of Indi.”

The Friends of Indi failed to lodge a return for two financial years (2005-07), keeping its receipts and donations a secret. It wasn’t until BAT lodged its return form that the Friends of Indi cover was blown. Two receipts were received by the AEC for 2005-06 from British Tobacco Australia Ltd to the value of $7,500 each that was donated to the Friends of Indi.

Ms Mirabella – a member of Mr Abbott’s shadow ministry – was a direct beneficiary of donations made to the Friends of Indi, including the $15,000 donation from BAT. She refused to answer questions at the time on this secret donation. This wasn’t the first time BAT donated to Ms Mirabella. In 2004-05, Friends of Indi received $5,000 from BAT. Only last year, Friends of Indi received $35,000 dollars although the AEC notes no individual receipts were declared by this associated entity.

Mr Abbott is increasingly isolated on this issue. Even the state Liberal parties are coming around to banning donations from the tobacco industry. In 2008 research published in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health shows that approximately 61.6% of smokers and 78.4% of non-smokers were against political parties accepting donations from the tobacco industry. WA Liberal Premier Colin Barnett has stated his opposition to tobacco donations.

It’s time that Mr Abbott and the Liberal party gave up their river of gold from the tobacco companies. About 20% of Australians are currently addicted to cigarettes. Of the total cost of drug abuse in 2004-05 of $55 billion, tobacco accounted for $31.5 billion. The cost of tobacco addiction is a “great big tax” on all Australians, one which Mr Abbott doesn’t seem to care about.

But it seems that Mr Abbott won’t be parting company with big tobacco any time soon. Last April he was asked directly whether he would stop taking donations from the tobacco industry. He said: “It is legal to smoke, it is not the mafia. I don’t see why if they want to make a donation we shouldn’t accept.”

So long as he takes this line, the stink of the tobacco lobby will cling to the Liberal Party.
Michael Danby is the Federal Labor member for Melbourne Ports.  http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/2756764.html

http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/33994.html

Find More Stories

10 May 2010

Tobacco funding: time to quit

Mike Daube

Tobacco companies are not philanthropic institutions. As long ago as 1967 the late Senator Robert Kennedy said, “the cigarette industry is peddling a deadly weapon. It is dealing in people’s lives for financial gain”.

The Australian tobacco industry is dominated by three big companies (or in modern political parlance, three “great big” companies), British American Tobacco, Philip Morris and Imperial Tobacco – all overseas-owned, with decisions made not in Sydney or Melbourne but in London and New York.

These are tough and ruthless multinational corporations, promoting and selling a product that kills one in two of its regular users. They have known for sixty years that their product is lethal. During this time almost one million Australians have died because they smoked – while the tobacco companies have denied and downplayed the evidence, doing their utmost to oppose and delay any action that might be effective in reducing smoking. Around the world their products cause five million deaths a year – a figure which will only increase as their drive into developing countries bears lethal fruit.

The new Chief Executive of Imperial Tobacco, Alison Cooper, was recently reported in the UK media as still refusing to accept that smoking causes cancer. Small wonder that only last week a survey of the reputations of the UK’s largest 150 companies had Imperial Tobacco at 147 and British American Tobacco at a rock bottom 150.

There is massive evidence from once-confidential industry documents now available following litigation in the US that for decades tobacco companies have acted more cynically than even tobacco campaigners might have thought – summarised by a quote from an industry executive – “We don’t smoke this shit, we just sell it. We reserve the right to smoke for the young, the poor, the black and the stupid.”

And as if all this were not enough, the industry has been found guilty of racketeering in the US.

Tobacco companies have only one aim, in London, New York or Canberra. In line with their responsibility to their shareholders, they spend money with the sole purpose of benefiting their interests.

So why would anybody want to take money from this pariah industry?

The Australian Electoral Commission website reports that in recent years both the Philip Morris company and British American Tobacco have been generous donors to the Liberal Party and the National Party. During the year 2008/9 Philip Morris contributed $158,000 to the Liberal and National parties around Australia.

No doubt in addition to direct contributions there is also much indirect funding from groups supporting and representing tobacco companies, but this is much harder to pin down.

The only reason for these contributions is to further the interests of tobacco companies. The website of the British American Tobacco company is quite explicit about political donations: “Such payments can only be made for the purpose of influencing the debate on issues affecting the company or Group…”

A review of tobacco industry political donations in the US, published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, concluded that, “tobacco industry monetary contributions are closely related to the way a legislator votes on tobacco issues”, and “The more campaign contributions received by a Congress member, the more likely he/she votes pro-tobacco on tobacco-related bills”.

Political donations are not simply about an intention to buy direct support: they are also about much less tangible benefits gained through indirect support, influence, contacts, access and credibility.

The Greens and Democrats took the lead in refusing tobacco industry funding, followed by the ALP. The other major parties understand the dangers of smoking; they know exactly why tobacco companies want to give them money; it is hard to imagine that they would knowingly take money from drug dealers – and yet they seem content to accept contributions from an industry whose products cause more than 80 per cent of Australia’s drug deaths. Surely there is something awry with the moral radar of anyone who accepts this kind of blood money.

The argument we sometimes hear that this is a “legitimate industry” is old and tired. If cigarettes were a new product they would not be allowed on the market. Our parliaments have decreed that the product is so harmful that it should not be sold to children and adolescents, should not be advertised, and that its sales should be subject to ever-increasing controls. This is no ordinary product, no ordinary industry.

The Australian government now leads the world in action to reduce smoking, complementing strong action in most jurisdictions (other than the Northern Territory, whose lack of interest in tobacco remains a mystery).

It is time for all political parties to refuse tobacco funding, or for legislation that forbids such contributions from companies that still seek to oppose the work and recommendations of governments and health authorities, and whose products cause 15,000 Australian deaths each year when used precisely as intended. Then we can be assured that all parties are making policy on this vital public health issue free of the taint of association with tobacco companies, and free of any suspicion that their policies might be influenced by these disreputable, lethal donors.

Mike Daube is Professor of Health Policy at Curtin University.

Maximum CNY 200 fine for littering cigarette butt

06/01/2011, Yancheng Evening News [Jiangsu Province] — This reporter learned on May 31 that the government has introduced the “Yangzhou Public Venue Tobacco Control Provisional Regulations”, which prohibit smoking in nine types of public venues. Littering a cigarette butt at a public venue could incur a CNY 20-200 fine. The Provisional Regulations give passive smokers the right to ask a person to stop smoking in a public venue. They are also entitled to ask operators of venues where smoking is prohibited to stop people from smoking as required by law; and they have the right to report violations to the health administration or other competent supervisory agency.

Tax rises shown to slash rate of smoking – Retailers report huge fall in cigarette sales

South China Morning Post — 29th April 2011

Fewer people are buying cigarettes and more are trying to quit since the government increased the tobacco tax by 41.5 per cent in February, while a previous rise caused a dramatic reduction in youth smoking, new statistics and university studies show.

Retailers say cigarette sales plunged by almost 40 per cent immediately after the increase was announced in this year’s budget.

This comes as lawmakers seek to revoke the order giving effect to the increase, saying it will hurt low-paid workers who cannot quit.

A 7-Eleven shop manager said tobacco sales had dropped by nearly 40 per cent since the announcement.

Before the tax rise, his outlet sold about 400 packs of cigarettes a day. This fell to 170 packs immediately after the budget, and although sales had risen since, his outlet still sold just 250 packs a day.

This was in line with the number of people who tried to give up. A total of 4,151 people have called the Department of Health’s quit line since March, which was 2.6 times more than in the same period last year.

And in February and March, some 634 people enrolled in quit-smoking programmes at the clinics of the department and the Tung Wah Group of Hospitals, 2.2 times more than in the same period last year.

“Some lawmakers always say raising tax significantly will hurt the grass roots, but in fact minor increases won’t be effective in pushing people to quit,” Council on Smoking and Health chairwoman Lisa Lau Man-man said.

In further evidence of the effectiveness of tax rises, a University of Hong Kong study found the 50 per cent increase in 2009 was the main reason the youth smoking rate fell 51 per cent from 2008 to last year.

Researchers surveyed 53,504 pupils from Form One to Form Five, and found that 3.4 per cent smoked. This was down from 4.8 per cent last year, which was itself a 43 per cent drop from 6.9 per cent in 2008.

School of public health assistant professor Daniel Ho Sai-yin, who carried out the survey, estimated that the 2009 tax rise had prevented 13,452 young people from taking up smoking, saving half of them from premature deaths.

Another study found 56 per cent of young people who called the university’s quit line were motivated by the tax rise. Of these, half had been able to kick the habit.

Ho said young people were the main target of tobacco companies’ efforts to expand their customer base, and they were the most price-sensitive. As two-thirds of the city’s smokers took up the habit in their teens, Ho said stopping young people from smoking was essential to reduce future tobacco-related deaths.

Meanwhile, a proposal by two lawmakers to repeal the public revenue protection order – which gave a provisional legal basis for the 41.5 per cent tax rise – seems likely to fall short of the votes needed to pass.

Lawmakers Albert Chan Wai-yip, of People Power, and Vincent Fang Kang, of the Liberal Party, will seek to repeal the tax increase at a Legislative Council meeting on Wednesday. But major parties, including the Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong and the Civic Party, will oppose the attempt. The Federation of Trade Unions will also vote in favour of the order, despite its opposition to the tax increase.

“Blocking the order will create administrative troubles, as the government will need to refund the tax it has already collected,” federation lawmaker Wong Kwok-kin said.

DAB lawmaker Wong Ting-kwong, an opponent of the tax rise, said he would go on urging the government to concede. “We believe that even if the order is passed, the government will make a concession if we can line up enough opposition.”

The director of Hong Kong University’s school of public health, Professor Lam Tai-hing, said that if legislators overturned the increase, it would send “a very wrong message” to young people. “They would think that even the honourable lawmakers are encouraging people to smoke.”

Some lawmakers say increasing the tax will push more people to buy illicit cigarettes, but Lam said the illicit trade had always existed regardless of the tax.

“What the lawmakers are doing is to reverse something that has already been established,” he said. “If they succeed, cigarettes would suddenly become much cheaper. When price decreases, demand will certainly shoot up. And when that happens, do you think the illicit traders will back off and step out of the game?”

China to ban smoking in enclosed public places from May 1

Xinhua News Agency

BEIJING, April 29 (Xinhua) — Smoking will be banned in all enclosed public locations including hotels, restaurants, theaters and waiting rooms at railway stations and airports starting May 1, according to a regulation issued by the Ministry of Health.

Business owners should set up conspicuous non-smoking signs, carry out promotional activities to warn people of the dangers of smoking and encourage their employees to dissuade smokers from lighting up, according to the regulation.

The new regulation also says that outdoor smoking areas should not obstruct pedestrian walkways and that cigarette vending machines should be excluded from public places.

Yang Gonghuan, director of China’s National Office of Tobacco Control, said the regulation gives business owners a clear view of their responsibilities in relation to the smoking ban.

“It is realistic to demand a bigger role for these business owners in dissuading smokers,” Yang said.

It is estimated that China has more than 300 million regular smokers, and more than 700 million people are routinely exposed to harmful second-hand smoke, according to experts.

The regulation does not specify punishments for business owners who fail to meet the smoking ban’s requirements. It also does not specify penalties for people who continue to smoke in areas affected by the smoking ban.