Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

High tobacco tax increase has led to large drop in sales of cigarettes

South China Morning Post – 5 July 2011

I refer to the letter from Markus Shaw (“A lot of puff about new cigarette tax”, June 23). Yet again Mr Shaw seeks to repeat the PR spin of big tobacco by attempting to equate tobacco smoking with junk food and alcohol use.

Passive smoking kills innocent bystanders – 1,400 people out of 7,000 total smoking deaths a year here – whereas junk food and alcohol affect the product users not bystanders. Mr Shaw says the health secretary should instead comment on air pollution.

The Hedley online index shows the deaths attributable to pollution in 2010 were 792, being 11 per cent of the deaths attributable to smoking, while smoking itself is a serious form of air pollution.

Mr Shaw states the increased tax will deny “pleasure” to the poor and present an opportunity for crime.

The people most in need of quitting are the poor who can then spend more on their families and add 10 years to their lifespan with them. In the past two years, 65 per cent of contraband cigarettes seized by the Customs and Excise Department were genuine tobacco products and, of those, 7 per cent were marked “HK Duty Not Paid”, obviously leaked from our duty free outlets. It is a fact proved worldwide that the tobacco companies deliberately fail to control their supply chains, allowing unscrupulous elements to supply the illicit market.

The government has injected an additional HK$42 million in 2011 towards increased free cessation therapy and products. Mr Shaw further states the tax increase oppresses a minority. In 2010, when there was no budget excise tax increase, the legal sales of cigarettes in Hong Kong were: March, 53.9 million; April, 114 million; May, 225.7 million. After the tax increase announced in February’s budget, the numbers were: March, 6.1 million; April, 45.2 million; May, 75.5 million. Even the blinkered can see the tax increase is a positive preventive health measure. We have probably the most efficient Customs and Excise Department in the world and statistics show that the seizures and quantities have declined dramatically since 2007.

The only oppression of this health measure is on the dwindling profits of the tobacco companies. The University of Hong Kong’s department of community medicine study (1998) shows that the cost to Hong Kong society including loss of life per year was HK$72 billion; this will now be far higher in equivalent 2011 terms.

James Middleton, chairman, Clear the Air

Plain Packaging

Summary
Tobacco packaging has become one of the tobacco industry’s leading promotional tools. In Australia,
the Government proposes to require that tobacco products be sold in plain, standardised packaging.
In the UK, the Government has committed to consulting on similar legislation. Research suggests that
plain packaging would increase the impact of health warnings, reduce false and misleading messages
that one type of cigarette is less harmful than another, and reduce the attractiveness to young people.

SummaryTobacco packaging has become one of the tobacco industry’s leading promotional tools.

In Australia,the Government proposes to require that tobacco products be sold in plain, standardised packaging.In the UK, the Government has committed to consulting on similar legislation. Research suggests thatplain packaging would increase the impact of health warnings, reduce false and misleading messagesthat one type of cigarette is less harmful than another, and reduce the attractiveness to young people.

Read more, download PDF : ASH_699

Cigarette smoke and mirrors

http://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010/indepth/2011-07/01/c_13961245.htm

BRUSSELS, July 1 (Xinhua) — No butts about it. Belgian bars become less hazy on Friday as the country becomes the 20th in Europe to widen its smoking ban.

Belgium’s new laws take effect close on the heels of China which also banned smoking in indoor public venues in May this year. So, what challenges do both countries face as they seek to control a notoriously addictive product sold by an equally powerful industry?

From July 1, people in bars and cafes in Belgium with the urge to light up will only be allowed to do so in designated smoking areas. By law, these zones need to be fitted with air vents and be no larger than 25 percent of the venue. Another rider is no sale of drinks and snacks will be permitted there.

Those caught violating the law can be fined between 143 and 1,650 euros. The onus of enforcing the ban is expected to lie on bar-owners and their employees.

For many campaigners, Belgium has been frustratingly slow in changing its smoking laws. The path to today’s smoking ban in pubs was paved by the ban of smoking in trains in 2004, in workplaces in 2006 and in restaurants in 2007.

“The anti-tobacco voice in Europe is growing louder,” tobacco control expert Luk Joossens from the Belgian chapter of the Foundation Against Cancer told Xinhua.

“Though we are extremely disappointed by the delay in getting to this stage, I’m optimistic now that the ban is in effect and I think it will work,” he said, stressing its main objective is not to reduce the consumption of cigarettes but to protect bar employees and the general public from passive smoking.

Because people will no longer be subject to passive smoking, Joossens hopes for a major drop in heart disease in Belgium. “After the smoking ban in Scotland, heart attacks in the country fell by 17 percent. If a similar thing happens in Belgium, there will be 2,500 fewer heart-attacks per year,” he said.

While tobacco control campaigners win the public health debate, tobacco lobbies often counter by mentioning government tax revenues. For example, Chinese newspapers in 2009 reported that more than 7.5 percent of Chinese government revenue, or 77.3 billion U.S. dollars, came from taxes and profits related to tobacco.

However, leading Belgian law academic and anti-tobacco campaigner Professor Roger Blanpain rubbishes the notion that revenues will be hit.

“The economic argument for tobacco is nonsensical. Governments spend three times their tax income from tobacco companies in treating the medical fallouts of tobacco-related illnesses. Not to mention, days off work due to tobacco-related illnesses or children getting sick because of their parents smoking,” Blanpain told Xinhua.

Tobacco industry can butt out over plain-packaging rules

sweetman graphic

Source: The Courier-Mail

http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/opinion/tobacco-industry-can-butt-out-over-plain-packaging-rules/story-e6frerdf-1226085088355

WHAT do you see in Imperial Tobacco’s Nanny State advertisements?

You’re supposed to see an overbearing, officious, unelected power bitch who’s going to boss you around, subject you to a full body search and whip you into submission with the lash of legislative pettifoggery.

I see the confected face of entrenched corporate arrogance trying to tell my nation what it can and can’t do.

I see a nameless woman as guardian of a boardroom door behind which sit the representatives of a vastly profitable multinational – and marvellously anachronistically named – company trying to defy the will of the Australian Government.

I imagine a room full of corporate suits who want to retain the right to use their last remaining advertising window to sell their products.

Having failed to bluff enough political friends to block legislation for plain packaging, they are now taking legal action and appealing directly to the people on the grounds that it is a misappropriation of intellectual property and descent into tyranny.

People are nodding sagely over tobacco rights and “nanny state” has become a pejorative term like “political correctness”.

Phillip Morris, flagbearer for an industry whose products are calculated to cost the Australian economy about $32 billion a year, is seeking more billions in compensation.

It would have us cry over the devaluation of its trademark while many of us are grieving the more than 15,550 tobacco-caused deaths a year.

It is waving the stick of punitive compensation when we are collectively footing the bill for a habit responsible for nearly 10 per cent of the national disease and injury burden for Australian men and nearly 6 per cent for women.

An industry that has never paid due compensation for the grief it has caused wants compensation from the same country that has largely footed the bills for its actions.

A United States company is suing our Government to bring a case through an international tribunal via the litigious gateway of an obscure investment treaty signed with Hong Kong in 1991.

That must surely be the punchline to a black historical joke that began when native Americans convinced visiting Europeans that sucking tobacco smoke into their lungs was a good thing to do.

The tobacco lobby may have been emboldened by the success of the mining industry in watering down the resource tax but it is finding it difficult to similarly tart up self-interest as national interest.

Apart from some disputed employment claims, the tobacco industry offers nothing we couldn’t well do without. Under the plain-packaging rules, it will retain the right to sell its products and its individual brand names but it will be restricted in how it markets them and attracts new users.

Sceptics scoff at the potential effectiveness of the move but changing habits since the Tobacco Advertising Prohibition Act of 1992 ended overt advertising suggest it is worth toning down the covert advertising of the cigarette packet.

The industry is undoubtedly paying a price for social and scientific progress but not an excessive price when you consider its products killed an estimated 100 million people last century (according to The Independent on Sunday).

It has been trying to shirk its responsibility since the link between tobacco and cancer was first noted in the 1930s.

“What company would stand for having its brands taken away from them?” asked one British American Tobacco spokesman. “A large brewing company or fast-food chain certainly wouldn’t and we’re no different.”

But it is different for the simple reason that its product is demonstrably unsafe at any level of consumption.

Why is the industry fighting so hard for its market in Australia, a country that has been hostile territory for nigh on 20 years?

The online resource www. tobaccoinaustralia.org.au says sales of tobacco products totalled $10.1 billion in 2006-07, representing about 5 per cent of all retail sales in Australia.

Nice, but small beer when you take into account the $41 billion profit for Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Japan Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco in 2009.

The West accounted for a decline in world consumption in 2009, in no small part due to the sorts of initiatives Australia has been pioneering. The developing world, which accounts for 76 per cent of consumption, is the promised land for an industry that will go to any lengths to protect its territory (Phillip Morris is reportedly suing Uruguay for damages over bans on smoking in public places and for putting health warnings on its cigarette packets).

Australian initiatives are being copied in addicted nations and countries such as Britain, Canada and the US are watching the plain-packaging move with much interest.

“What’s to stop this same law being applied in other parts of the world?” asked Australian National University marketing expert Andrew Hughes.

The tobacco industry is asking precisely the same question.

Australia, it seems, can make a difference.

sweetwords@ozemail.com.au

Australia’s world first plain packs legislation

Read the two bills  here (substantive bill) and  here (trademarks bill) – and all  submissions to the public consultation, June 2011

House of Reps inquiry 2011 with submissions, transcripts


Social media the new battleground in the war against Big Tobacco

http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/social-media-the-new-battleground-in-the-war-against-big-tobacco-20110629-1gqip.html

30 June 2011

Big Tobacco is taking its aggressive marketing online and those fighting to curb smoking rates need to follow suit.Photo: Craig Abraham

Sun Tzu wrote that “all warfare is based on deception”. This maxim seems to have been taken to heart by Big Tobacco as it seeks to use the fight over plain packaging, which is destined for the courts, to distract from a more important advertising realm – social media.

From the perspective of Big Tobacco, a federal government ban on plain packaging is not the greatest threat it faces. Far from it. Plain packaging is like the killing of Osama Bin Laden – an important and sweet victory for coalition forces – but not the main game. The danger to our anti-smoking heroes is that if they focus all their efforts on this battle, then the enemy may outflank them.

The real fight is quickly unfolding in social media. Evidence is emerging, including from the World Health Organization and the University of Sydney’s Becky Freeman and Simon Chapman, that Big Tobacco is moving its estimated annual marketing spend of tens of billions of dollars online – and fast.

The incredible growth of “consumer driven” online fan groups for the Marlboro Man and Joe Camel, plus viral YouTube content and slick sponsorships are evidence of the marshalling of the troops on this front. Brands are being strengthened and smoking initiated with the help of social media. The government and public health campaigners are engaged in these fights yet distraction from them could give Big Tobacco the time it needs to dig trenches, secure allies and settle in for the long term. It is in the interests of Big Tobacco to keep the campaign focused on the plain-packaging front.

Of course the fight for plain packaging must be won, as many assume it will. But anti-smoking advocates, including government, should also consider what mix of limited public resources is most effective. Policy makers often argue that the best solutions to problems are better regulation. And in many cases they are right, including on smoking.

Some efforts are made to complement regulation with public awareness campaigns and appeals to industry, however, often these are ineffective and sometimes add to the problem. Typically this returns the focus to regulations. Yet in the complex online world, regulation will take a long time to catch up as control shifts from companies and governments to users, consumers and citizens.

But there is good news for those fighting the good fight. While anti-smoking policy makers grapple with the application of conventions and regulations to social media, there is evidence that beating Big Tobacco at their own game through social marketing is effective at preventing smoking initiation, especially among young people.

Both anti-smoking advocates and Big Tobacco are fighting the plain-packaging battle because they start from the same premise – marketing works. However, an entrenched resistance to marketing among many policymakers is proving to be one of the biggest barriers to success in the war against Big Tobacco. Rather than resist marketing, anti-smoking campaigners should trust evidence that marketing can help convert consumers to healthier lifestyles. And this could hold the key to success in the difficult-to-regulate social media realm.

Success from social marketing campaigns shows us the way to beat Big Tobacco. These include the Truth (anti-smoking) program from the US which, according to George Washington University’s W. Douglas Evans, is building its brand through social media with positive images of non-smoking youth as cool and confident rebels fighting against the tobacco industry. Others include the Queensland alcohol campaign “Becky’s not drinking”, the SunSmart campaign against skin cancer “Slip! Slop! Slap! and many others. These campaigns were successful because they understood the barriers and benefits to behaviours, how influence is disseminated and they didn’t wag their fingers or treat people as stupid. These campaigns built brands that people trust.

The concepts of connection, dissemination and trust are the fundamentals of social media, where Big Tobacco is starting to assert dominance. If we concentrate our limited resources on regulation over plain packaging and not enough in social media, we risk being distracted by Big Tobacco and losing the war against smoking.

Nicholas Goodwin works in social marketing and international development and is a PhD candidate at the University of Sydney’s Department of Media and Communications in the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences. He tweets using @nickgoodwin.

Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/social-media-the-new-battleground-in-the-war-against-big-tobacco-20110629-1gqip.html#ixzz1Qhuinhkg

NZ backs Aussie in tobacco brand row

http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/5204781/NZ-backs-Aussie-in-tobacco-brand-row

29 June 2011

The Government is throwing its support behind Australia in its fight against tobacco giant Philip Morris, as unbranded cigarette packets look likely to be introduced in New Zealand.

Tobacco giant Philip Morris Asia is threatening to sue the Australian Government over its plans to severely restrict advertising on cigarette packaging, with new laws set to be introduced by the Prime Minister, Julia Gillard.

The laws would restrict tobacco industry logos and brand imagery, with only the product name in standardised text allowed on the packet. All packets would be green, a colour research has shown is unattractive to smokers.

Australia will be the first country to introduce the laws, and Associate Health Minister Tariana Turia said New Zealand was watching the situation closely to see how best to follow.

“We are very supportive of Australia’s initiative and it is our expectation that New Zealand will inevitably follow their lead and look to introduce the plain packaging of tobacco products.”

It was no surprise that tobacco companies could “see the writing on the wall”, and were feeling threatened, she said.

“Tobacco companies are very wealthy – they make a lot of money from peddling their dangerous, deathly, addictive product – and they clearly have no problem instigating legal challenges even if they have little chance of success.”

Philip Morris has filed legal action against Australia under that country’s bilateral trade agreement with Hong Kong, which means the Government has to protect Hong Kong investments in Australia.

Mrs Turia said officials would look at New Zealand trade agreements when drafting plain-packaging laws, to see how to counter legal challenges from the tobacco industry.

“Like Australia, we are probably in a position where the public health arguments for tobacco control outweigh the tobacco company interests, but … we are also mindful of doing things in a way that is not going to unnecessarily cut across our trade interests.”

But Green Party MP Russel Norman called for the removal of “perverse” investor rights given to foreign companies in free trade agreements, saying they would allow Philip Morris to sue New Zealand – possibly for billions of dollars. “That means taxpayers will be funding big tobacco’s profits. That’s not free trade, that’s global extortion.”

A report on possible alignment with Australia’s packaging laws is set to be reviewed by Cabinet.

The Government has already committed to making the country smokefree by 2025.

Tobacco lawsuit could impact enforcement

http://timestranscript.canadaeast.com/newstoday/article/1419383

29 June 2011

A newly launched $1.5-billion lawsuit against contraband tobacco manufacturers across Canada could change the way the RCMP attempts to snuff out the trade of illegal cigarettes.

Cpl. Robert Fullerton of New Brunswick’s RCMP customs and excise unit says a lawsuit by Canada’s largest tobacco company Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd. may shift greater police focus to eliminating illegal smokes at the source.

“It might change the way we do enforcement,” Fullerton said. “Right now we seem to be more concentrated on the end users than the manufactures.

“Maybe this is going to see the government force us to target the manufacturing more.”

Imperial Tobacco launched the lawsuit this month against what it labeled as contraband tobacco manufacturers and retailers on First Nations reserves.

Imperial also wants to bring smaller producers – whether operating legally or not – in as third parties to lawsuits it faces from the New Brunswick, Ontario and British Columbia governments.

The provinces are suing tobacco giants, including Imperial Tobacco, for health-care costs from tobacco-related illnesses.

The result of the lawsuits could focus the public eye on the large existence of illegal tobacco in the country, which big tobacco maintains is illegal competition to a regulated industry.

The RCMP has special units to deal with contraband tobacco and organized crime surrounding the trade. In 2010, the RCMP seized approximately 782,000 cartons and bags of illegal cigarettes nationwide.”It’s going to be very interesting to see how the government reacts,” Fullerton said.

Imperial was also critical of New Brunswick’s move in March to increase the tobacco tax in the province, saying the government had “set out the province’s welcome mat for organized crime to expand its thriving contraband business in the east.”

The Alward government’s first provincial budget, released in March, increased the tobacco tax by 45 per cent – a move that exceeds the request of the Canadian Cancer Society. The jump equates to an increase of 5.25 cents per cigarette, $1.31 per pack, $10.50 per carton and an extra $25 million in new government revenue.

Fullerton, who is based in Edmundston, said that there has yet to be an influx in illegal cigarette seizures since the tax increase, despite expectations that there in fact could be. New Brunswick RCMP spokesman Cpl. Yann Audoux said the amount of illegal tobacco seized in the last three months was not available yesterday.

More than 350,000 illegal cigarettes were seized at two traffic stops on the Trans Canada Highway in the Edmundston area on the same day last month.

In both cases, the cigarettes and the vehicles used to transport them were seized and will be forfeited.

In April, police also seized 124 cartons of illegal cigarettes at a home in Tracadie-Sheila.

Last week, the RCMP customs and excise section executed a search warrant at a residence near Sussex.

During the search, officers seized approximately 9,800 illegal cigarettes.

It also executed a search warrant at a residence in Albert Mines where more than 100 cartons of illegal cigarettes were seized.

NZ monitors Australian plain packaging bid

28 June 2011

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/breaking-news/nz-monitors-australian-plain-packaging-bid/story-e6frf7jx-1226083752647

THE New Zealand minister who wants cigarettes sold in plain packets says she won’t be deterred by threats of legal action by a tobacco company against the Australian government.

However, Associate Health Minister Tariana Turia can’t confirm the government will go ahead with the policy.

“We’re keeping an eye on Australia, we want to align our work with the work they’re doing over there,” she told One News.

“It’s something that needs to be looked into really carefully – we don’t want to get ourselves into a situation where we’re wasting a lot of taxpayer money fighting these tobacco companies because they’re incredibly wealthy.”

Philip Morris has served a notice of legal claim on the Australian government, which sets a mandatory three-month period for the two sides to negotiate an outcome.

“Failing that, we aim to go ahead with a compensation claim for the loss to our business in Australia that would result from plain packaging,” the company said.

Start of sidebar. Skip to end of sidebar.

Related Coverage

End of sidebar. Return to start of sidebar.

Plain packaging in Australia is due to start in a year’s time, which would make it the first country in the world to enforce the anti-smoking measure.

The action Philip Morris is taking is under a trade agreement between Australia and Hong Kong, and New Zealand has a similar treaty which covers intellectual property such as trademarks.

Philip Morris is arguing its trademark is protected and plain packaging will be detrimental to it.

Green Party co-leader Russel Norman says Philip Morris could use the same tactic against New Zealand.

“It shows how dangerous these investment rights treaties are when a multi-national company has more rights than a sovereign government to regulate in the interests of public health,” he said.

Should Philip Morris win, the Australian government could have to pay billions in compensation.

The Greens, and academic Jane Kelsey, are also concerned that the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) which is being negotiated could cause similar problems.

“We call on the government to release the draft text of the intellectual property section of the TPP talks with the USA,” Dr Norman said.

“We need to know what rights our government is handing over to Philip Morris in those negotiations.”

The Public Health Association (PHA) said it was “appalled” by news of the legal action.

“It is beyond immoral that a business that sells addictive killers to young people is now threatening court action,” said PHA national executive director Dr Gay Keating.

“The PHA applauds Canberra for its courage and leadership in standing up to the bully tactics and hopes the New Zealand government is watching closely.”

The Smokefree Coalition said the industry knew plain packaging would hit it hard, and that was why it was “pulling out all the stops”.

“We expect our leaders will show the same guts and backbone when those threats start over here,” said coalition executive director Dr Prudence Stone.

Cancer Society chief executive Dalton Kelly said cigarette companies could see the writing on the wall.

“Smoking is rapidly becoming a thing of the past. Australia is leading the world by introducing plain packaging and I hope New Zealand is not far behind.”

Big Tobacco v Australia: Philip Morris jumps the gun on legal challenge

It is far from clear whether Philip Morris’ tactic against plain packaging will succeed. AAP

Smoking-1309155803

In the latest salvo in the fight over plain packaging for tobacco products, Philip Morris is launching legal action under Australia’s bilateral investment treaty with Hong Kong.

The key aspect of Philip Morris’ claims against the Australian government is that the proposed plain packaging law results in unreasonable measures that impair the enjoyment of an investment.

Investment is broadly defined under treaty to include intellectual property.

Bilateral investment treaties seek to facilitate investment between two countries. They basically enhance business activities between the nations.

The treaties provide guarantees of non-discriminatory treatment between investors from the two countries; protect those investors from unreasonable measures in terms of their investment; and provide mechanisms for dispute resolution.

Disputes are a growth area in such treaties – which are themselves going through a boom period – as they allow investors to trigger dispute resolution mechanisms.

Investment disputes are normally heard by the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), which is supported by United Nations arbitration conventions.

So, the argument Philip Morris might seek to make is that the plain pack laws will unreasonably impair its ability to enjoy the intellectual property it has established with its design and properties in Australia.

But while there are mechanisms under that treaty to resolve disputes such as these, the legislation isn’t operative yet so I’m not sure the the company’s claim has any basis.

What’s more, the government says any legislation it passes will only come into effect on January 2012.

Technically, there’s no dispute until then, but Philip Morris could argue that the government has announced its intention to introduce the legislation, so it would be prudent for both parties to engage in a conversation now.

In other words, the claim is not consistent with provisions of the agreement but prudence would dictate that it would be advantageous for both sides to start to work out a solution to the impending issue.

And the government could seek to resolve the concerns that Philip Morris is raising.

One way forward for the government is to say “We’re going ahead with this and if you wish to sell your products here, you’ll have to comply with the proposed legislation”.

If the company wants to claim for its intellectual property, the government could offer a monetary settlement and this might be Philip Morris’ tactic in raising this issue and having it discussed in advance. It could be a pre-emptive move.

If there were a dispute, the agreement provides that there has to be a three-month cooling period between the time the dispute is raised and the formal commencement of proceedings.

This allows the parties to reach some kind of settlement before getting to arbitration so we’re a way off formal proceedings.

Commercially, if a settlement is reached between the government and Philip Morris, it would put an end to the matter. That is, if the company were to enter into an agreement with the government, that would affect its ability to bring future claims.

Another way to approach this from the government’s side is to phase the measure in as a way of reaching a mutually beneficial outcome.

The company can acquiesce that the government has the right to dictate how products are sold and the government would agree that the company has a right to sell and prepare for the legislative change.

The key issue then would concern the dominant commercial interest on the part of Philip Morris – whether they are concerned about the sale of their products or the intellectual property associated with the packaging of their product.

On the face of it, this move by the company is about creating a precedent for plain packaging and the knock-on effect it may have for other more lucrative markets.

If we look at intellectual property associated with a brand, clearly tobacco companies have in many instances around the world faced significant constraints on the way they can promote their brand.

Already in Australia they are prevented from running television advertisements, advertising during sporting events and they have to carry prominent warnings on their products.

This clearly diminishes tobacco companies’ ability to promote their products and the government can argue that the plain packaging initiative is consistent with previous measures.

In fact, this could end up being the what the arbitration panel decides on.

It is far from clear whether Philip Morris’ tactic against plain packaging will succeed. AAP

In the latest salvo in the fight over plain packaging for tobacco products, Philip Morris is launching legal action under Australia’s bilateral investment treaty with Hong Kong.

The key aspect of Philip Morris’ claims against the Australian government is that the proposed plain packaging law results in unreasonable measures that impair the enjoyment of an investment.

Investment is broadly defined under treaty to include intellectual property.

Bilateral investment treaties seek to facilitate investment between two countries. They basically enhance business activities between the nations.

The treaties provide guarantees of non-discriminatory treatment between investors from the two countries; protect those investors from unreasonable measures in terms of their investment; and provide mechanisms for dispute resolution.

Disputes are a growth area in such treaties – which are themselves going through a boom period – as they allow investors to trigger dispute resolution mechanisms.

Investment disputes are normally heard by the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), which is supported by United Nations arbitration conventions.

So, the argument Philip Morris might seek to make is that the plain pack laws will unreasonably impair its ability to enjoy the intellectual property it has established with its design and properties in Australia.

But while there are mechanisms under that treaty to resolve disputes such as these, the legislation isn’t operative yet so I’m not sure the the company’s claim has any basis.

What’s more, the government says any legislation it passes will only come into effect on January 2012.

Technically, there’s no dispute until then, but Philip Morris could argue that the government has announced its intention to introduce the legislation, so it would be prudent for both parties to engage in a conversation now.

In other words, the claim is not consistent with provisions of the agreement but prudence would dictate that it would be advantageous for both sides to start to work out a solution to the impending issue.

And the government could seek to resolve the concerns that Philip Morris is raising.

One way forward for the government is to say “We’re going ahead with this and if you wish to sell your products here, you’ll have to comply with the proposed legislation”.

If the company wants to claim for its intellectual property, the government could offer a monetary settlement and this might be Philip Morris’ tactic in raising this issue and having it discussed in advance. It could be a pre-emptive move.

If there were a dispute, the agreement provides that there has to be a three-month cooling period between the time the dispute is raised and the formal commencement of proceedings.

This allows the parties to reach some kind of settlement before getting to arbitration so we’re a way off formal proceedings.

Commercially, if a settlement is reached between the government and Philip Morris, it would put an end to the matter. That is, if the company were to enter into an agreement with the government, that would affect its ability to bring future claims.

Another way to approach this from the government’s side is to phase the measure in as a way of reaching a mutually beneficial outcome.

The company can acquiesce that the government has the right to dictate how products are sold and the government would agree that the company has a right to sell and prepare for the legislative change.

The key issue then would concern the dominant commercial interest on the part of Philip Morris – whether they are concerned about the sale of their products or the intellectual property associated with the packaging of their product.

On the face of it, this move by the company is about creating a precedent for plain packaging and the knock-on effect it may have for other more lucrative markets.

If we look at intellectual property associated with a brand, clearly tobacco companies have in many instances around the world faced significant constraints on the way they can promote their brand.

Already in Australia they are prevented from running television advertisements, advertising during sporting events and they have to carry prominent warnings on their products.

This clearly diminishes tobacco companies’ ability to promote their products and the government can argue that the plain packaging initiative is consistent with previous measures.

In fact, this could end up being the what the arbitration panel decides on.