Download PDF : TrademarksAmendPlainPack
Legislation
Australian Ambassador: Tobacco Packaging Legislation Does Not Violate TRIPS
http://infojustice.org/archives/4405
Australian Ambassador Kim Beasley has vowed that Australia will not change the Tobacco Plain Packaging Act, which prohibits cigarette packs from displaying brands and logos, despite accusations that the law violates international trademark law. According to Inside U.S. Trade, last week Beasley “dismissed U.S. companies’ claims that the plain packaging law… unjustifiably restricts the use of their trademarks in violation of the World Trade Organization’s Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights.”
Philip Morris has also served a notice of claim on the Australian government, announcing its intention to challenge the law as a violation of the Australia’s investment treaty with Hong Kong.
Last month, the bill was the subject of debate at the TRIPS Council, where a group of developing countries suggested the legislation would violate Article 20 of TRIPS, which states: “The use of a trademark in the course of trade shall not be unjustifiably encumbered by special requirements.”
Big Tobacco Spent $100 Million Plus on CA Politics in Past Decade
Over the past decade, “Big Tobacco” spent over US$100 million to influence elections and legislative policy in California, according to a report, Tobacco Money in California Politics. The report can be read in full at the Center For Tobacco Policy and Organizing site. A searchable database of campaign contributions on the site provides precise figures about the campaign contributions tobacco companies are making to individual California state assembly members and Senators.
US 9.3 million was spent on campaign contributions and lobbying during the 2009-2010 election cycle. 48 percent of California’s state legislators — 59 members out of 122 — have received campaign contributions from the tobacco industry (a total that was the same in previous election cycles). More than $62 million was spent to oppose Proposition 86, a 2006 ballot initiative that would have increased California’s tobacco tax by $2.60 a pack, to pay for pay for “additional hospital funding, health coverage of children, nursing education, anti-smoking education programs, and funding for nonprofit clinics.” Proposition 86 lost by a narrow margin.
Further, Philip Morris USA Inc. alone spent more than $750,000 on lobbying from April through June of 2009, the second quarter of that year: This was a “record amount for lobbying expenditures in one quarter by any tobacco interest over the last decade,” according to apress release from the American Lung Association about the report. Incidentally, it was during those very three months that the California legislature voted on two budget bills that were of more than a little interest to the tobacco industry. One bill contained atobacco tax increase, while the other bill was also about tobacco taxes (and was already moving forward in the legislative process) — tobacco companies are out to protect their interests, not to mention their profits.
Of all special interests, tobacco companies ranked “near the top” in total spending on campaign contributions and lobbying, says the report.
Nonetheless, in this same time period, smoking rates in California have kept falling and more communities passed policies meant to reduce the impact of smoking in California. The San Jose Mercury News reports that the state’s adult smoking rate is 11.9 percent, a record low. (Money doesn’t all buy results, it’s heartening to know.)
I’m originally from California and, even though I grew up in the years prior to the passing of a anti-smoking legislation, I remember a general attitude of “why would anyone deliberately endanger their health and smoke”? Much more recently, and thankfully, smoking has been banned from restaurants, indoor public places and workplaces (and in casinos) in New Jersey where we live. In New York, it’s illegal to smoke not only in restaurants but on train platforms and parks and beaches.
A recent study has shown that babies admitted to hospital with bronchiolitis from a household where a parent smokes are twice as likely to need oxygen therapy than babies whose parents do not smoke — and they’re five times as likely to need mechanical ventilation. Does it need to be said again that smoking is not good for you, or for those around you
Banning tobacco displays ‘violates Bill of Rights’
http://www.3news.co.nz/Banning-tobacco-displays-violates-Bill-of-Rights/tabid/419/articleID/219143/Default.aspx
18 July 2011
Three ACT Party MPs say the bill banning the display of tobacco products in shops, which passed in Parliament last week, violates the New Zealand Bill of Rights.
The Smoke-free Environments (Controls and Enforcement) Amendment Bill makes it against the law for shops to display tobacco products and have references to tobacco products in their trading names.
But the ban “violates the basic right to freedom of expression” according to ACT MPs Heather Roy, Sir Roger Douglas and Hilary Calvert who voted against the bill.
Ms Roy says Section 14 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act “protects the right to freedom of expression. This bill violates that right. The right to display legal products in a store is basic”.
“Smokers have rights too. We support their rights. We don’t like smoking, but we don’t believe it is for us as MPs to say whether people should smoke or not, much less whether they may display a legal product or not. That our Parliament deems it fit to interfere in people’s personal lives, as it did on Thursday, saddens us,” Ms Roy says.
Sir Roger says it is “another tedious example of nanny-statism and political correctness” and says he is worried that “activists won’t stop till they’ve achieved complete prohibition”.
But Associate Minister of Health Tariana Turia believes the bill is the complete opposite and says “it’s a great moment for New Zealand” and it “closes one of the last loopholes the tobacco industry uses to prey on our young people”.
The bill also increases fines for selling tobacco products to under-age persons, with maximum penalty becoming $10,000 compared with a previous $2000 fine.
The powers of Smokefree Enforcement Officers will also be increased, enabling them to impose instant fines of up to $1000 for sales to those under 18 years of age.
The changes come into force in July next year
Roxon introduces plain packaging bill
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/07/06/3262578.htm?section=justin
The tobacco industry is warning of several legal challenges to the plain packaging legislation
Federal Health Minister Nicola Roxon has introduced plain packaging legislation for cigarettes into Parliament, saying the Government will defend it from any legal threats.
The legislation will force cigarettes to be sold in plain packs with a large, graphic health warning, while a second bill will remove company trademarks from the packs.
Ms Roxon told Parliament the legislation will mean Australia has the toughest tobacco promotion laws in the world.
“We’re taking this action because tobacco is not like any other legal product. When used as intended it is lethal,” she said.
“Despite Australia’s success in reducing smoking rates over recent decades, tobacco remains one of the leading causes of preventable death and disease among Australians, killing over 15,000 Australians each and every year.”
The tobacco industry is warning of several legal challenges to the legislation in a move it says could cost the Government billions of dollars.
Tobacco giant Philip Morris is among the companies taking legal action over the laws.
It is accusing the Government of breaching a bilateral investment treaty with Hong Kong, where the company is based.
Ms Roxon says the Government is determined to fight any legal challenges.
“Introducing this legislation today shows that the big tobacco’s intimidation tactics have not worked,” she said.
“Our Government won’t be deterred from taking this action and we believe that we are on very strong ground, although this is a world first taking this action, and are determined to proceed with it.”
Opposition Leader Tony Abbott has said the Coalition will not oppose the legislation but may attempt to make amendments to ensure smoking rates really do drop.
Last night Liberal backbencher Alex Hawke told the Parliament he is against it because it is a nanny state response to an everyday problem.
Ms Roxon says the Government is prepared to consider amendments from the Opposition as long as they do not change the requirement that tobacco be sold in plain packs.
“I’m very confident that we have very broad support within the Parliament for this, of course it’s true that the Liberal party were dragged kicking and screaming but they have announced that they will support this legislation,” she said.
Why is Deloitte’s name on junk tobacco research?
http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/2783400.html
6 July 2011
Remember the Alliance of Australian Retailers (AAR) who brought us the first salvo of anti-plain packaging ads in 2010?
These were the doozies that featured storekeepers with advanced knowledge of effective tobacco control explaining that plain packs “won’t work, so why do it” and then later on, “It just doesn’t make sense“.
It is no secret that the AAR is funded by big tobacco, who strangely have one or two concerns of their own about a policy “that won’t work” – enough to be in blind panic mode, pouring millions into their campaign to stop it. Personally, I never bother worrying about changes to my life that won’t make any difference.
This week the AAR released a Deloitte report with lots of shocking numbers and findings in it about an Armageddon that will descend on Australia’s corner stores because of a policy that won’t work. But now we have “research” to prove it. So let’s take a look at how they conducted the research.
First, Deloitte tells us that “Roy Morgan Research was engaged by the AAR to conduct a consumer survey to verify the risk of channel shift following the introduction of plain packaging”. Channel shift is industry jargon for your customers switching to buying their tobacco from bigger outlets like supermarkets, which of course have been attracting small business customers for decades because of their cheaper prices on everything.
Note importantly that the survey was not designed to examine whether there was a risk in channel shift arising from plain tobacco packaging, but to “verify” it. It’s a foregone conclusion, apparently. Great science.
We read that those surveyed “were presented with an overview of the proposed regulation and asked whether they thought their shopping experience at a small retailer would be affected”. So they were presented with an overview that would assist in “verifying” the risk of channel shift. No chance of any push polling there, I suppose?
Catastrophically for our corner stores, independent petrol stations and newsagents, more than one of three smokers (34 per cent) and 18 per cent of non-smoking consumers told Roy Morgan after hearing the overview that they were “either somewhat likely or very likely to change where they shopped as a result of plain packaging”.
So why would they do this? Smokers thought they would be “more likely to be given the wrong tobacco product”. So presumably they think that small shopkeepers are a cut below the staff in supermarkets and specialist tobacconists, and won’t be able to read the name on the pack or the column on the pack shelving behind the counter. Why else would there be more mistakes in handing over the brand requested? They will be packaged the same wherever they are sold.
Another reason given was that small store staff “would have a harder time finding what I want” and so “queues would be longer”. Again, how could this be different in small stores compared with large stores, given that the packs will be the same? Particularly when we discover below that small shopkeepers think supermarkets will stock far more brands, which presumably makes the search more difficult in the larger outlets.
The research also reports on focus groups with small retailers who believed that channel shift may occur because of:
- The increase in time required to complete a tobacco related transaction would lead to customers becoming increasingly frustrated due to delays and longer queuing time.
- The knowledge that a larger retailer, eg. a major supermarket with a broader range of products, would always have what they require.
Come again? Small shopkeepers think that the introduction of plain packs will cause them to cut back on the range of products they offer, but that supermarkets won’t do this? How come?
And what about the greater transaction time issue? Next time you are in a shop selling tobacco, watch what happens when a smoker asks for their brand. The shopkeeper turns away from the counter to face the storage columns on the wall behind them, as they have always done. Each brand is kept in its own column, they are not all jumbled together.
The regulations may well permit the brand name in standard font and colour to be displayed on the top or base of the pack so that the shop assistant can simply read “Winfield Blue” or “Holiday”. The idea that the shop assistant won’t know which brand is which is utter nonsense. The columns will be allowed to be labelled.
We have long expected big tobacco and its acolytes in tobacco retailing to react against any policy that threatens to reduce tobacco use and to use all manner of scare tactics to argue their sordid case for wanting to keep selling as many cigarettes as possible. But the really interesting question is what is a company with Deloitte’s reputation doing putting its name to nonsense like this?
The information contained in this report can only suggest that those interviewed were not given a full account of what plain packaging would look like. It seems that many are falling for tobacco industry lies that the packs will be indistinguishable: that there will be no way of distinguishing one brand from another. But every pack will be clearly labelled with its brand name and variant (eg: Winfield Blue, Winfield Red).
The Deloitte report is prefaced with an interesting caveat “No-one else, apart from the AAR, is entitled to rely on this Report for any purpose. We do not accept or assume any responsibility to anyone other than the AAR in respect of our work or this Report.”
Fine. Now we all know.
Simon Chapman is professor of public health at the University of Sydney
Australia Brings Tobacco Legislation to Parliament
Asian Wall Street Journal – 5 July 2011
SYDNEY—Australia’s government introduced into parliament new laws banning advertisements on cigarette packets Wednesday, setting up a legal battle against the world’s biggest tobacco companies.
Under the proposed laws, Canberra wants to be the first government in the world to restrict logos, branding, colors and promotional text on tobacco packets beginning in January 2012. Product names will appear in standard colors and positions in a regular font and size on packets colored a dark olive-brown, which government research has found holds the lowest appeal to smokers.
Health warnings with graphic images of the harmful effects of smoking will have to make up 75% of the front of the packaging and 90% of the back.
“This world first initiative sends a clear message that the glamour is gone from smoking,” Health Minister Nicola Roxon said in a statement.
Philip Morris International Inc., the world’s largest tobacco company by revenue, last month warned Australia’s government it will challenge the decision in the courts and will seek billions of dollars in financial compensation.
British American Tobacco PLC—the biggest cigarette seller in Australia—has also warned it could pursue legal action, while Imperial Tobacco Group PLC is also opposed to the measures.
The new laws have the backing of the center-right opposition coalition and are expected to be passed by both the lower and upper house of parliament.
Write to Enda Curran at enda.curran@dowjones.com
What a drag … Iceland considers prescription-only cigarettes
Guardian newspaper – 5 July 2011
Tobacco bill proposes outlawing shop sales, with only doctors allowed to prescribe cigarettes to addicts unable to kick habit
Iceland is considering banning the sale of cigarettes and making them a prescription-only product.
The parliament in Reykjavik is to debate a proposal that would outlaw the sale of cigarettes in normal shops. Only pharmacies would be allowed to dispense them – initially to those aged 20 and up, and eventually only to those with a valid medical certificate.
The radical initiative is part of a 10-year plan that also aims to ban smoking in all public places, including pavements and parks, and in cars where children are present. Iceland also wants to follow Australia’s lead by forcing tobacco manufacturers to sell cigarettes in plain, brown packaging plastered with health warnings rather than branding.
Under the mooted law, doctors will be encouraged to help addicts kick the habit with treatments and education programmes. If these do not work, they may prescribe cigarettes.
The private member’s bill is sponsored by former health minister Siv Fridleifsdottir, who worked with the Icelandic Medical Association as well as a coalition of anti-tobacco groups to come up with the proposal. “The aim is to protect children and youngsters and stop them from starting to smoke,” she said on Monday. The proposal would initially result in an increase in cigarette prices, said Fridleifsdottir, of “10% per year, in line with World Health Organisation proposals – evidence shows that a 10% increase results in a 4-8% reduction in consumption”.
But by the end of the 10-year plan, prescription-only cigarettes should actually be cheaper than ever, according to Thorarinn Gudnason, president of the Icelandic Society of Cardiology, who helped draw up the proposal.
“Under our plan, smokers who are given prescriptions will be diagnosed as addicts, and we don’t think the government should tax addicts.”
Gudnason said current cigarette pricing in Iceland did not take into account the huge costs imposed on society by smokers. “A packet currently costs around 1,000 krona [£5.50], but if you factor in the cost of sick leave, reduced productivity due to smoking breaks and premature retirement on health grounds, it should really be 3,000 krona,” he said.
The tobacco proposal also says that nicotine should be classed as an addictive substance. “It’s as hard to give up nicotine as heroin, not in terms of the side effects, but in terms of the cravings and how quickly one becomes addicted,” said Gudnason.
“We also want the government to license cigarettes like a medicine, which would mean they would have to go through the same rigorous trials as any other drug. I doubt cigarettes would ever get on the market now that we know the side-effects – lung cancer, heart attacks, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.”
Gudnason said 300 out of the 1,500 deaths in Iceland each year were caused by one of those three conditions.
“That’s 20% of all deaths. We think that our proposals could lead to a significant reduction in smoking-related deaths – perhaps down to just 100 annually.”
The proposal also suggests that tobacco smoke should be treated as a carcinogenic substance, and that it should be restricted in a similar way to other known carcinogens, because of the known effects of passive smoking.
Gudnason did a study five months after Iceland introduced a smoking ban in restaurants and pubs in 2007 and found a 21% reduction in acute coronary syndrome (heart attacks and near heart attacks) among non-smoking men, compared to five months before the ban.
A spokeswoman from the Icelandic ministry of welfare said on Monday that the proposal was “very serious” but had limited chances of success.
“Siv Fridleifsdottir is a very serious politician and this is a very serious proposal,” said Anna Baldursdottir, political adviser to the minister of welfare, Gudbjartur Hannesson.
“Whether it not it eventually becomes law, I do not know. I seriously doubt it.”
The idea will be debated in the Althing, Iceland’s parliament, in the autumn, when politicians return from recess, she added.
Iceland has successfully halved smoking rates over the past 20 years. In 1991, 30% of the population smoked; today, only about 15% light up regularly, according to Baldursdottir, giving it the lowest smoking rates in Europe.
This success is attributed to huge increases in tobacco tax, which accounts for about 25% of the pack price, as well as the drop in disposable income among islanders since the financial crash of 2008.
Other countries have gone further. Bhutan has completely outlawed smoking and Finland hopes to follow suit by 2040.
Swedish surgeons now refuse to operate on smokers until they give up, because of the deleterious effect smoking has on the healing process, Gudnason added.
As an isolated island, Iceland arguably stands a greater chance of success with such draconian measures than other nations.
With no neighbouring countries and rigid customs controls at ports and airports, it will be difficult for anyone to smuggle in contraband cigarettes.