Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Tobacco ruling has a financial side

swissinfo.ch


15 August 2011

Following a Federal Court ruling, the Federal Health Office has concluded that nicotine addiction can be considered an illness.

Basic compulsory insurance, which currently does not reimburse any anti-tobacco medication, will have to pay up. The health office made its decision on August 9. Criteria have yet to be fixed.

“This ruling is historical because it gives prevention the right place,” Jean-Charles Rielle, a doctor at the Information Centre for Tobacco Addiction Prevention in Geneva (CIPRET), told public radio on August 9.

Rielle, also a parliamentarian, welcomed the “financial boost” for smokers who want to give up.

On August 4 the Federal Court underlined that alcohol and heroin addiction could be considered an illness and that “under certain conditions” so could dependence on nicotine. In this case, insurance companies would have to reimburse medicines to treat smoking addiction.

The court partially agreed with drug maker Pfizer which wanted its Champix (or Chantrix) medication included in the list of medicines reimbursed by basic insurance.

Pfizer’s demand had previously been dismissed by the health office in 2008 and then in 2010 by the Federal Administrative Court. The federal court ruling meant the health office had to reconsider its position, which it has since August 9, confirmed the health office’s spokesman Daniel Dauwalder.

“Negative message”

For their part, health insurance companies have denounced the “negative message.”

“We only cover risk of illness and not prevention, which is not a risk. Prevention is down to individual responsibility and can’t be carried by everyone. This would be putting all types of behaviour under state control,” explained Yves Seydoux, spokesman for Groupe Mutuel.

But if alcohol addiction is considered an illness, why not tobacco dependency?  Seydoux argues that tobacco addiction’s effects are not as great as those for alcohol.

Addiction to the bottle can “affect behaviour and create sometimes grave side effects, whereas it’s the consequences of tobacco addiction that are harmful to health”, he said. “It’s a question of free choice.”

Jacques de Haller, president of the Swiss Medical Association, does not quite agree. “From a medical point of view the two pathologies are different, but both are a dependency.”

“A smoker is addicted to tobacco which makes him lose his free will and can considerably shorten his life,” he said. In addition, there is “the real problem of passive tobacco addiction”.

Economic side

The health office must now decide when smoking addiction can be considered an illness through the treatment needed. Then it must pronounce on the second fundamental factor: the economic side of the treatment.

For de Haller this latter point makes the federal court’s ruling a positive one.

“The issue of non-recognised treatments by insurance companies affects those who need it the most – the lower economic classes – who are already penalised on a social level,” he said.

CIPRET says Champix can double the chances of heavy smokers giving up in three months. But Gianfranco Domenighetti, professor of health economics at Lugano University, warns that the controversial medication needs to be well tolerated.

“According to a Canadian study, this medicine increases cardiovascular risk by 73 per cent,” he said.

Tolerance and effectiveness issues have also been raised for other treatments such as nicotine substitutes or Zyban, an antidepressant used against addiction. But most of all, according to de Haller, “their effectiveness is not 100 per cent guaranteed”.

Other measures?

Seydoux hopes that the federal court’s ruling will be applied “rigorously”.

“The health office has enough room for manoeuvre to ensure that a free market does not develop and that the notion of individual responsibility over tobacco’s consequences remains in people’s minds,” he said.

Some voices, notably in parliament, have suggested that anti-smoking drugs should only be reimbursed if the treatment is successful. De Haller is sceptical about “making people pay in relation to the therapy’s success, when the effectiveness is not 100 per cent guaranteed”.

Do insurance companies intend to penalise smokers by raising premiums? “No, it’s impossible to ‘police’ people. Society has to accept deviances [from the norm] and that it can only curb the consequences of the deviances,” Seydoux said.

De Haller concludes that the solution is in any case “more political than health-based”.

“The most efficient measure is increasing the price of a packet of cigarettes. Each time, the number of smokers drops,” he said.

Isabelle Eichenberger, swissinfo.ch
(Translated from French by Isobel Leybold-Johnson)

Swiss pictures

Smoke Signals

Despite a ban on smoking in public places, tobacco is still grown in Switzerland.


Key facts

29 per cent of the Swiss population aged 14-65 smoke. The proportion of smokers is highest among those aged 20-24.

About 8,300 people die from tobacco consumption in Switzerland annually.

There are around 16,000 cases of disability attributable to smoking.

The consumption of tobacco costs the Swiss economy SFr10 billion a year (SFr1.2 billion on medical treatment, SFr3.8 billion on invalidity costs, loss of quality of life is estimated at SFr5 billion). Income from tax on tobacco amounts to just over SFr2 billion a year.

In Switzerland, 20 cigarettes currently cost SFr7.40 ($9.30).

(source: Federal Health Office’s National Programme Tobacco 2008-2012)


Second-hand smoke

There is no safe level of second-hand tobacco smoke. Smoke-free laws protect the health of non-smokers, are popular, do not harm business and encourage smokers to quit.

Second-hand smoke causes 600,000 premature deaths a year globally, of whom around 1,000 are in Switzerland.

Almost half of children – whose organs are damaged by passive smoke more than adults – regularly breathe air polluted by tobacco smoke. In 2004, children accounted for 28% of the global deaths attributable to second-hand smoke.

In adults, second-hand smoke causes serious cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, including coronary heart disease and lung cancer. In infants, it causes sudden death. In pregnant women, it causes low birth weight.

(source: WHO and Federal Health Office)


URL of this article

http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/swiss_news/Tobacco_ruling_has_a_financial_side.html?cid=30904316

Clear the Air Says

TIME TO QUIT? ASSESSING INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT CLAIMS AGAINST PLAIN TOBACCO PACKAGING IN AUSTRALIA*

Download PDF : SSRN-id1906560

Tobacco boss’s struggle with arithmetic

http://media.crikey.com.au/dm/newsletter/dailymail_709ae35410de72443e4a61ad74c80408.html

Last week, David Crow, the CEO of British American Tobacco Australia, gave evidence to the House of Representatives  Standing Committee on Health and Ageing’s hearings into the Tobacco Plain Packaging Bill 2011.

Crow continued to push the argument that the tobacco industry has ushered into the front line of its opposition to plain packaging legislation: that plain packs will cause a deluge of illicit, black-market tobacco to flood the market.

Crow referred to the tobacco industry-commissioned Deloitte report, at one point saying: “It is robust research. It is based on thousands of interviews of consumers done in a very thorough way by Roy Morgan Research, who work with Deloitte. The aim was to estimate — and you will never get a real answer — the size. That size has been consistent over the past 18 months. The last report found that about 15.6% of the industry is illicit. We say one in five; one in 5½ cigarettes smoked in this country is illicit.”

You do, eh, Dave?

There are a couple of small problems with what Crow told the committee. He presumably has read the Deloitte report, which states on page 20 “This initial sample comprised of 9206 identified people. However after allowing for natural sample attrition, 949 respondents completed the survey.”

So 949 smokers in five capital cities, not “thousands”, answered questions about whether they believed they had used illegal tobacco (loose chop-chop, counterfeit or duty not paid). When it comes to counterfeit or duty not paid packs, how would they actually know?

Then there’s the small matter of Crow’s arithmetical,  or is it his rhetorical ability … 15.6% is not one in five (that’s what 20% is Dave!) or one in 5½ cigarettes.  It is one in 6.41, which is “less than one in 6″. So what’s the difference between one in five and one in six? Not much you ask? But when you’re talking about the number of cigarettes involved, this  means a difference of 741.69 tonnes of tobacco, using the Deloitte data.

Depending on what assumptions are made about the average weight of a cigarette (0.75-1grm) this translates to  between about  a mere 750m and 900m cigarettes and roll-your-own cigarette equivalents.

Crow would have been aware that in the week before he gave evidence, the Australian Institute of Health and Welfarepublished its latest estimate how much illicit tobacco is used by smokers in Australia. Surveying 26,648 people across Australia, of whom 15.1% were daily smokers (and with 17% smoking at all — 4530 smokers — now that’s thousands!), the AIHW found about 1.5% of Australian smokers regularly smoked unbranded tobacco in 2010 — see table 3.11 p39.

Predictably, Crow did not refer to this substantially lower estimate.

Time to Quit? Assessing International Investment Claims Against Plain Tobacco Packaging in Australia

Tania S. Voon

Melbourne Law School

Andrew D. Mitchell

Melbourne Law School; Georgetown University Law Center

August 11, 2011
Abstract:
The Australian federal government recently introduced into Parliament legislation mandating the plain packaging of all tobacco products. Tobacco companies and others have raised various legal concerns with this tobacco control scheme, both at a domestic level in relation to constitutional and intellectual property law, and at an international level in relation to international economic law. Some Members of the World Trade Organization (‘WTO’) have asked questions about the scheme in the WTO Committee on Technical Barriers to Trade and the Council for Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights. In addition, Philip Morris (Asia) Limited has given notice of an investor-State dispute settlement claim against Australia regarding plain packaging pursuant to the Hong Kong – Australia Bilateral Investment Treaty. This article considers the merits of that claim as well as certain related procedural issues. It also compares Australia’s investment obligations with respect to plain packaging under the Australia – United States Free Trade Agreement, as some allegations have been made that plain packaging is inconsistent with those obligations.

IV CONCLUSION

Several impediments exist to PMA’s claim, including the possibility that it has been brought prematurely, the remaining chance (against that background) for Australia and Hong Kong to modify or re-interpret the terms of the Hong Kong – Australia BIT, and the potential difficulties of enforcing an adverse arbitral award against Australia due to concerns of public policy and sovereign immunity. More importantly, most of PMA’s substantive claims under the Hong Kong – Australia BIT appear weak, in particular as regards fair and equitable treatment, full protection and security, unreasonable impairment, and the umbrella clause. PMA may have stronger arguments in relation to Australia’s obligation not to engage in expropriation, but a number of relevant factors still weigh in favour of Australia’s plain packaging measure as a legitimate noncompensable health regulation rather than a compensable expropriation. The outcome of that claim is likely to depend on the final form of the legislation that is enacted and implemented, as well as the evidence brought to bear by both sides and the arbitrators selected to make the decision. In the meantime, the AUSFTA provides a contrasting case study demonstrating the kind of clarifications that Australia, Hong Kong and other countries may wish to consider adding to their more traditional investment protection agreements if they wish to ensure control over their sovereign regulatory frameworks for purposes such as health and the environment. The AUSFTA also offers an example of excluding ISDS, which Australia is contemplating on a broader scale and which may be desirable for a number of countries.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 35

Keywords: Investment, international law, tobacco, cigarettes, bilateral investment treaty, international dispute settlement

JEL Classifications: K33, F21, L66

Working Paper Series

Date posted: August 11, 2011

Suggested Citation

Voon, Tania S. and Mitchell, Andrew D., Time to Quit? Assessing International Investment Claims Against Plain Tobacco Packaging in Australia (August 11, 2011). Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1906560
Export to: Export Citation What’s this?

Contact Information

Tania Voon (Contact Author)

Melbourne Law School ( email )

University of Melbourne
Victoria 3010 Australia

Andrew D. Mitchell

Melbourne Law School ( email )

The University of Melbourne
Victoria 3010
Australia
+61383441098 (Phone)
+61393472392 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.law.unimelb.edu.au/staff/Andrew%20Mitchell

Georgetown University Law Center ( email )

600 New Jersey Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20001
United States

Smoking warnings to change

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2011-08/11/content_13089389.htm

BEIJING – Next year will bring a doubling in the size of the words that appear on cigarette packages to warn consumers of the dangers of smoking.

Starting in April 2012, cigarettes produced and sold in China will bear a new warning label containing letters that will be no less than 4 millimeters in height. That will be twice the size of the current minimum, which stipulates that the letters be at least 2 mm from bottom to top, according to a notice written by the China National Tobacco Corp and published on the State Tobacco Monopoly Administration’s website.

Despite the intentions, many tobacco-control experts said the step is “minor” and that it fails to deal with the chief issue.

“There is no use in making the font size even 100 times bigger if the warning is pointless,” said Wu Yiqun, deputy director of the ThinkTank Research Center for Health Development, a Beijing-based non-governmental organization that advocates for the adoption of stronger smoking-control measures.

Both Wu and Yang Gonghuan, director of the tobacco control office of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, said the warning that now appears on cigarette packs is too weak. It says: “Smoking is harmful to your health. Quitting early is good for your health.”

“The package should inform consumers of the dangers of smoking in accordance with requirements adopted by the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. (It should say that) smoking causes lung cancer, coronary disease and makes people grow old,” Yang said.

China decided in 2005 to ratify the convention, which also requires that tobacco warnings cover a third of the surface of cigarette packs.

“Even if the size of the words is doubled, it still doesn’t meet those standards,” Yang said. “The Chinese practice is to draw a line to demarcate a third of a cigarette package, where the warning should be, but the words put on it are still very small.”

Experts said graphic health warnings could be printed on cigarette packs and used as a “scientific, direct and shocking” deterrent to smoking.Throughout the world, more than 1 billion people in 19 countries live under laws that require the packaging of various types of tobacco products to bear large, graphic health warnings. They often show pictures of black lungs and festering mouth sores, according to the World Health Organization.

China, though, is excluded from those rules.

Both Wu and Yang said the fundamental barrier to better control of tobacco use in the country is the fact that the China National Tobacco Corp, the country’s largest cigarette-maker, is a subsidiary of the State Tobacco Monopoly Administration, China’s tobacco regulatory body.

Wu said the tobacco control office has conducted surveys in recent years in which 90 percent of the respondents said graphic warnings would help them come to the grips with the thought that they should quit smoking.”But the national tobacco administrator also sells cigarettes and wouldn’t do something that would harm its sales,” Wu said.

Both Wu and Yang said the Ministry of Health should take a lead in the campaign against smoking and the government should place more of a priority on protecting people’s health than on economic interests.

“On the cigarette packaging of more than 40 countries, there are government warning that say things like ’85 percent of lung cancer victims smoked’,” Wu said.

China, home to more than 300 million smokers, contains the largest population of smokers in the world. Official statistics show that 1.2 million Chinese residents die of smoking-related diseases every year.

Nepal bans smoking at public places

Kathmandu: Nepal has banned smoking at public places with the 2010 Tobacco Control and Regulatory Act coming into effect from Sunday.

As per the law, those caught smoking at public places will be fined and civil servants indulging in smoking at public places will be liable to departmental action.

The law designates government offices, corporations, educational institutions, libraries, airports, public vehicles, orphanages, childcare centres, cinema halls, homes for the elderly, cultural centres, children”s gardens, hotels, restaurants, resorts, girls” and boys” hostels, department stores, religious sites and industries as no-smoking zones.

According to Xinhua, Nepal Health Secretary Sudha Sharma said the government would carry out a mass awareness programme, highlighting the penalty for smoking in public places.

She also said that an inter- ministerial coordinating committee has also been formed to enforce the law to ensure citizens’ right to health.

The government has also made pasting of no-smoking notices mandatory at every public place.

The law also bans the sale of tobacco products and single sticks within a 100-meter radius of educational and health institutions, children”s homes, child- care centres and elders’ home, the Himalayan Times reports.

It also prohibits selling tobacco to an individual below 18 years and pregnant women.

According to the Act, advertising and sponsoring programmes in the name of tobacco-related products through media would attract a fine.

ANI

http://zeenews.india.com/news/south-asia/nepal-bans-smoking-at-public-places_724822.html

China Tobacco

Yangzhou acts on [Peasants and Workers Democratic] Party proposal, introduces public venue tobacco control regulations

07/25/2011, www.rmzxb.com.cn (CPPCC) — The Yangzhou Municipal Government recently enacted the “Yangzhou Provisional Regulations for Public Venue Tobacco Control”. The formulation and implementation of the said Regulations has much to do with the hard work and determination of the Yangzhou Municipal Committee of the Chinese Peasants and Workers Democratic Party.

[Huai’an City] The long and winding road to tobacco control

07/26/2011, www.hynews.net [Jiangsu Province] — The “Huai’an Administrative Procedures for Public Area Tobacco Control” have been in effect for more than a month now. This reporter toured the downtown area and found people smoking in public venues just as before; there’s still a long and winding road ahead for tobacco control.

[Guizhou Province] Passenger can refuse to pay fare if taxi driver smokes on the job

07/27/2011, www.china.com, 16 media hits — The campaign will run for three months, ending on September 20. The main objective is to regulate public transport services in the city of Guiyang: applying strict punitive measures to those tyrannizing over the roads, stalling or stopping at will, parking illegally, being biased in their selection of passengers, refusing service, cramming different passengers into one ride, charging extra, taking another route without permission, smoking while driving, or throwing trash out the window.

46 citations in first half for violating tobacco control regulations, with fines totaling CNY 75,800

07/27/2011, www.eastday.com [Shanghai], 3 media hits — At a press conference organized by the Shanghai Municipal Government today, Li Zhongyang, vice director of the Shanghai Health Advancement Commission and deputy inspector for the Bureau of Health, detailed the progress made since the “Shanghai Public Venue Tobacco Control Regulations” went into effect as well as the tobacco control tasks on the upcoming agenda.

This year’s agenda: Using medicine in moderation and controlling tobacco

07/28/2011, www.jfdaily.com (Jiefang Daily, Shanghai), 8 media hits — The Shanghai Bureau of Health and Shanghai Health Advancement Commission have officially released the “2011-2020 Shanghai Health Advancement Plan”, which entails carrying out ten major health advancement campaigns to gradually raise health awareness among city residents and improve the ability to maintain a healthy lifestyle. The major tasks for 2011 are using medicine in moderation and controlling tobacco.

Shanghai to legislate for expansion of smoking ban

07/28/2011, www.eastday.com [Shanghai], 8 media hits — At a press conference organized by the Shanghai Municipal Government yesterday, Li Zhongyang, vice director of the Shanghai Health Advancement Commission and deputy inspector for the Bureau of Health, explained the purpose of revisions made to the “Shanghai Public Venue Tobacco Control Regulations”.

Shanghai creates a smoke-free environment, targets restaurants and entertainment venues

07/28/2011, www.cnhuadong.net, 42 media hits — Li Zhongyang, vice director of the Shanghai Health Advancement Commission and deputy inspector for the Bureau of Health, on July 27 said that pursuant to the “Shanghai Public Venue Tobacco Control Regulations”, the city is taking measures to enforce the ban on smoking at all designated venues for the creation of a completely smoke-free environment.

Letter to The Hong Kong Standard

The Standard – letters page

August 1, 2011

Smoke signals

Johnny Phang in his letter “Ban smoking completely” (The Standard, July 19) advocates banning smoking and asks how much tax is collected on tobacco and related products. Bhutan has banned smoking and New Zealand intends to do so by 2025; Iceland is debating making tobacco available only by medical prescription.

Monday, August 01, 2011

Johnny Phang in his letter “Ban smoking completely” (The Standard, July 19) advocates banning smoking and asks how much tax is collected on tobacco and related products. Bhutan has banned smoking and New Zealand intends to do so by 2025; Iceland is debating making tobacco available only by medical prescription.

The Hong Kong government has many tools in its armory if it has the political will to use them.

The first tool was to increase tobacco tax belatedly but without an included amount for inflation in the last budget, thereby making cigarettes less affordable to replacement smokers (youth).

The tax increase, while welcome, does not go far enough given Hong Kong’s standard of living and retail elasticity/affordability.

Using one control pack of 20 cigarettes, the HK$ international retail prices inclusive of taxes are: New York 113, New Zealand 90, Ireland 90, UK 80, Singapore 72, and Hong Kong 50.

In Hong Kong’s 2010 budget we did not have an excise increase; in the following four months 661,559 million excise-paid sticks were sold, reaping excise of HK$797.83 million. After the excise increase in the 2011 budget, in the same four-month period the figures are 291,217 million sticks and HK$496.65 million.

The tax increase cut comparative sales by 370.34 million sticks over 2010 figures and excise revenue fell by HK$301 million.

James Middleton,

Actual letter

From: James Middleton – Hong Kong [mailto:dynamco@netvigator.com]

Sent: Wednesday, July 27, 2011 10:03 AM

To: ‘editor@thestandard.com.hk‘

Subject: Letter to editor HK Standard

Letters to Editor HK Standard newspaper

Johnny Phang  (July 19) ‘Ban smoking completely –  someone to show me how much taxes governments all over the world collect on tobacco and related products’  advocates banning smoking and asks how much tax is collected.. Bhutan has banned smoking and New Zealand intends to do so by 2025; Iceland is debating making tobacco available only by medical prescription. The HK Government has many available tools in its armoury if it has the political will to use them.  The first tool was to increase tobacco tax belatedly but without an included amount for inflation in the last Budget, thereby  making cigarettes less affordable to  replacement smokers (youth). The tax increase whilst welcome does not go  far enough given Hong Kong’s standard of living and retail elasticity /affordability.  Using one control pack of 20 cigarettes  the HK$ international retail prices inclusive of taxes  are : New York 113, Singapore 72, New Zealand 90 (with another i10% increase scheduled Jan 01 2012) , Ireland 90, UK 80 , Hong Kong  50. In Australia  the Government will introduce into Law plain packaging of cigarettes this month. New Zealand intends to follow their lead; this removes the packaging attractiveness  (known as the Silent Salesman) which appeals to youth and the  pink colour that appeals to girls. Big Tobacco is screaming breach of trade agreements and loss of trademarks since it realizes the move will domino. They do not have a cancerous leg legally to stand on and think huff and puff will work instead but the admirable Governments will not back down. In Hong Kong’s Budget  in 2010 we did not have an excise increase ; in the four months thereafter 661,559 million excise paid sticks were sold reaping excise HK$ 797.83 million whereas after the excise tax increase in the 2011 Budget in the same 4 month period thereafter the figures are 291,217 million sticks  and HK$ 496.65 million. The tax increase has reduced comparative sales by 370,34 million sticks over 2010 figures and excise revenue reduced by HK$ 301 million. In 1998 the HKU Department of Community Medicine study revealed the cost to HK society for loss of productivity and health care for treating smoking related diseases was HK$ 5.3 billion per year, if loss of life were included due to smoking related disease the figures would be HK$ 73 billion per year. It is clear the cost of treatment at 2011 prices will be far higher than the HK$ 5.3 billion in 1998 dollars and abundantly clear that the tax payer is subsidising the massive treatment costs inflicted on society by Big Tobacco . The Government has a duty of care to its citizens and , like the USA did and Canada is now doing, must sue Big Tobacco  to recover these costs – to do otherwise condones the 7,000 tobacco deaths each year here .

James Middleton

Chairman

Clear the Air NGO    Tel 26930136

www.cleartheair.org.hk

Report on the public consultation on the possible revision of the Tobacco Products Directive (2001/37/EC)

Executive Summary
• The public consultation generated over 85 000 contributions, which illustrates a great
interest in EU tobacco control policy. Citizen contributions accounted for 96% of the
survey response. Almost 2/3 of the contributions were from just two Member States: Italy
and Poland.
• It is difficult to draw firm conclusions from the outcome of the public consultation
procedure. In general, opinions varied significantly between and also within categories of
respondents. Arguments provided by respondents in the ‘free text’ sections of the
consultation present a variety of different justifications for policy action.
• Those who were in favour of extending the scope of the Directive to all tobacco and
nicotine products argued that these products present hazards to public health. Some
respondents suggested nicotine products should be regulated under pharmaceutical
legislation. Others arguing against the extension of the scope raised concerns about the
lack of scientific evidence and claimed that the use of many novel forms of tobacco and
nicotine products are healthier than cigarette use.
• Respondents in favour of keeping the ban on oral tobacco (snus) or banning all smokeless
tobacco argued that, although some of these products are considered ‘reduced risk’ tobacco
products, oral tobacco is harmful to health. . Those who were in favour of lifting the
current ban on oral tobacco, referred to snus as a healthier alternative to tobacco smoking
and a potentially effective way to quit smoking.
• Respondents in favour of mandatory pictorial warnings and plain or generic tobacco
packaging stressed that these measures would eliminate the advertising and marketing
effects utilized by the industry and will provide equal protection of European citizens.
According to the opponents of these measures, implementing mandatory pictorial
warnings and generic packaging would have little to no impact on the uptake of smoking,
especially among youth. Opponents also expressed legal concerns about intellectual
property and suggested that generic and plain packaging could increase illicit trade in
tobacco.
• Most of the respondents were in favour of a common compulsory reporting format,
underlining that it would facilitate the comparison and analysis of ingredients information.
• Respondents in favour of regulating ingredients said that restricting certain additives
alongside sweet, fruity, floral, and candy flavours could prevent young people from taking
up smoking. Additionally, these actions would have the added benefit of facilitating intra-
EU trade by synthesizing current ingredients regulation in Member States. Opponents, on
the contrary, said that ingredients and additives do little to influence youth uptake and that
a regulation of ingredients could discriminate against certain varieties and brands of
tobacco.
• Respondents in favour of banning the sale of tobacco products over the internet and from
vending machines indicated that these actions would reduce the advertisement of tobacco
products through these channels and better restrict young people’s access to tobacco
products. It was also argued that a tobacco display ban at the point of sale would limit
youth smoking and deter tobacco purchasing by adults. Opponents raised concerns about a
lack of scientific evidence, market difficulties for new, unadvertised products and
excessive intervention in consumers’ right to product choice.

Executive Summary• The public consultation generated over 85 000 contributions, which illustrates a greatinterest in EU tobacco control policy. Citizen contributions accounted for 96% of thesurvey response. Almost 2/3 of the contributions were from just two Member States: Italyand Poland.• It is difficult to draw firm conclusions from the outcome of the public consultationprocedure. In general, opinions varied significantly between and also within categories ofrespondents. Arguments provided by respondents in the ‘free text’ sections of theconsultation present a variety of different justifications for policy action.• Those who were in favour of extending the scope of the Directive to all tobacco andnicotine products argued that these products present hazards to public health. Somerespondents suggested nicotine products should be regulated under pharmaceuticallegislation. Others arguing against the extension of the scope raised concerns about thelack of scientific evidence and claimed that the use of many novel forms of tobacco andnicotine products are healthier than cigarette use.• Respondents in favour of keeping the ban on oral tobacco (snus) or banning all smokelesstobacco argued that, although some of these products are considered ‘reduced risk’ tobaccoproducts, oral tobacco is harmful to health. . Those who were in favour of lifting thecurrent ban on oral tobacco, referred to snus as a healthier alternative to tobacco smokingand a potentially effective way to quit smoking.• Respondents in favour of mandatory pictorial warnings and plain or generic tobaccopackaging stressed that these measures would eliminate the advertising and marketingeffects utilized by the industry and will provide equal protection of European citizens.According to the opponents of these measures, implementing mandatory pictorialwarnings and generic packaging would have little to no impact on the uptake of smoking,especially among youth. Opponents also expressed legal concerns about intellectualproperty and suggested that generic and plain packaging could increase illicit trade intobacco.• Most of the respondents were in favour of a common compulsory reporting format,underlining that it would facilitate the comparison and analysis of ingredients information.• Respondents in favour of regulating ingredients said that restricting certain additivesalongside sweet, fruity, floral, and candy flavours could prevent young people from takingup smoking. Additionally, these actions would have the added benefit of facilitating intra-EU trade by synthesizing current ingredients regulation in Member States. Opponents, onthe contrary, said that ingredients and additives do little to influence youth uptake and thata regulation of ingredients could discriminate against certain varieties and brands oftobacco.• Respondents in favour of banning the sale of tobacco products over the internet and fromvending machines indicated that these actions would reduce the advertisement of tobaccoproducts through these channels and better restrict young people’s access to tobaccoproducts. It was also argued that a tobacco display ban at the point of sale would limityouth smoking and deter tobacco purchasing by adults. Opponents raised concerns about alack of scientific evidence, market difficulties for new, unadvertised products andexcessive intervention in consumers’ right to product choice.

Download PDF : consultation_report_en